SAHADEO YADAV vs STATE OF BIHAR

Court
Patna High Court

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT PATNA
CRIMINAL APPEAL (DB) No.14 of 1996
CNR No. BRHC010232071996
======================================================
SAHADEO YADAV, son of Balli Yadav, resident of village
Keilaghat, P.S. Barari, District Bhagalpur
... ... Appellant/s
Versus
The STATE OF BIHAR
... ... Respondent/s
======================================================
Appearance :
For the Appellant/s : Mr. Siddharth Harsh
For the Respondent/s : Mr. Sujit Kumar Singh
======================================================
CORAM: HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE ANIL KUMAR SINHA
and
HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE VIKASH KUMAR
JUDGMENT AND ORDER
C.A.V.
(Per: HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE ANIL KUMAR SINHA)
Date : 19-11-2026
1. The present appeal has been preferred against the
judgment of conviction, dated 15.12.1995, and order of sentence,
dated 20.12.1995, passed by the learned Additional Sessions
Judge–II, Bhagalpur, in Sessions Trial No. 236 of 1882, arising out
of Kotwali Police Station Case No. 40 of 1980, whereby the sole
appellant was convicted for the offences punishable under Section
302 read with Section 34 and Section 457 of the Indian Penal
Code. Pursuant to his conviction, the sole appellant was sentenced,
vide order, dated 20.12.1995,to undergo rigorous imprisonment for
life for offence under Section 302 read with 34 of the Indian Penal

Patna High Court CR. APP (DB) No.14 of 1996 dt.19-11-2026
2/44
Code and for the offence under Section 457 of the Indian Penal
Code, he was sentenced to undergo rigorous imprisonment for four
years. However, both the sentences were directed to run
concurrently.
2. The prosecution case, as unfolded in the fardbeyan of
the informant, Ajay Kumar Singh, on 23.12.1980, is that in the
intervening night of 22/23 December, 1980, at about 3 A.M., the
informant’s elder brother, Nirbhay Kumar Sharma @ Chunnu,
woke up to answer the call of nature and shouting, “Thief, Thief”,
upon which, the informant woke up and saw that Chunnu bhaiya
was following a person and he also followed him and saw that his
elder brother had descended from the rooftop and reached near the
water tap situated on the eastern side of the house. The informant
also saw three-four other persons near the water tap along with his
elder brother, who appeared to be of average height and build. The
informant further stated that it was a moonlit night and bulb was
also illuminated outside, due to which he claimed to have saw their
faces and would be able to identify them.
3. Thereafter, the informant, accompanied by others,
opened the door and went outside, where they found his elder
brother lying on the ground beside the water tap with stab injuries
inflicted by the thieves. A lathi (wooden stick) and a sheet, left

Patna High Court CR. APP (DB) No.14 of 1996 dt.19-11-2026
3/44
behind by the thieves, were also found at the place where his elder
brother was lying injured. The Informant took his elder brother to
the hospital, where the doctor declared him dead.
4. On the basis of the aforesaid fardbayan of the
informant, Kotwali Police Station Case No. 40 of 1980, dated
23.12.1980, was registered against the three-four unknown persons
for the offences punishable under Sections 457/302 of the Indian
Penal Code. Upon registration of the case, S.I. Vijay Kumar Sinha
was entrusted with the investigation of the case.
5. Upon completion of investigation, the police
submitted Charge-Sheet/Final Form No. 136, dated 07.05.1981,
against the sole appellant for the offences punishable under
Sections 302 and 457 of the Indian Penal Code. In this case, the
learned Chief Judicial Magistrate, without taking cognizance of
the aforesaid offences against the appellant, committed this case to
the Court of Sessions for trial, vide order, dated 26.06.1982.
th
6. On 04.02.1986, the learned 6 Additional Sessions
Judge, Bhagalpur, framed charges against the appellant Sahdeo
Yadav @ Maina Yadav under Section 302 read with Section 34
and Section 457 of the Indian Penal Code, 1980. The charges were
read over and explained to the appellant in Hindi, to which he
pleaded not guilty and claimed to be tried.

Patna High Court CR. APP (DB) No.14 of 1996 dt.19-11-2026
4/44
7. The prosecution, in order to substantiate its case, has
examined as many as eleven witnesses and also exhibited some
documents on its behalf. List of prosecution witnesses and exhibits
are being mentioned herein under in tabular form:
List of Prosecution Witnesses :
P.W.
Name of witness Description
No.
1. Vivekanand Singh Formal Witness
2. Arun Kumar Singh Tendered by the prosecution
for cross-examination
3. Sadai Kumar Shirmour Brother of the Deceased
4. Abhay Kumar Singh Elder brother of the Deceased
5. Dhananjay Kumar
Uncle of the Deceased/
Singh
Tendered by the prosecution
for cross-examination
6. Ajay Kumar Singh Informant
7. Shatrughan Singh Father of the Deceased
8. Dr. H. I. Ansari Doctor who conducted the
Post-mortem
9. Sri S. P. Gupta Judicial Magistrate who
conducted the TIP
10. Babu Lal Ram Investigating Officer
11. Bijay Kumar Sinha Police Officer who prepared
the inquest report
List of Exhibits on behalf of the prosecution :
Exhibit
Description of the Exhibit Date/proved by
No.
1 Signature of Vivekanand Singh
05.03.1986/PW 1
on the Inquest Report.
1/1 Signature of Arun Kumar Singh 05.03.1986/PW 1

Patna High Court CR. APP (DB) No.14 of 1996 dt.19-11-2026
5/44
on Injury report
2 Written Report (Fardbeyan) 19.04.1986
3 Post-mortem examination report 25.07.1986
4 T.I.P. Chart 17.05.1989
5 Formal F.I.R 17.05.1989
6 Inquest Report 17.05.1989
7 Seizure list 17.05.1989
7/1 Seizure list 17.05.1989
A Para 25, 26 & 27 of the Original
By Defence –
Case Diary
30.05.1989
A/1 Para 25, 26 & 27 of the Carbon
By Defence –
copy of Case Diary
30.05.1989
8. After closure of the prosecution evidence, the
statement of the appellant was recorded under Section 313 of the
Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 on 07.06.1989. In his
statement, under Section 313 of the Code of Criminal Procedure,
the appellant denied the incriminating circumstances appearing
against him in the prosecution evidence and stated that he has
falsely been implicated in the present case.
9. Mr. Siddharth Harsh, learned Counsel for the
appellant, argued that the judgment of conviction is against the
weight of evidence and has been rendered on mere presumption of
guilt. It is contended that the prosecution has failed to prove its
case beyond reasonable doubt inasmuch as the testimonies of the
prosecution witnesses suffer from contradictions and
inconsistencies, which the learned Trial Court failed to properly
appreciate and convicted the appellant.

Patna High Court CR. APP (DB) No.14 of 1996 dt.19-11-2026
6/44
10. Learned Counsel further submits that the
prosecution has failed to establish the place of occurrence as well
as the manner in which the alleged occurrence had taken place
beyond reasonable doubt. The testimonies of the prosecution
witnesses contain material inconsistencies regarding the sequence
of events and the manner in which the alleged occurrence took
place, thereby creating serious doubt over the prosecution version.
Further, the testimonies of the prosecution witnesses appear to be
stereotyped, tutored and parrot-like. Their depositions, particularly
on material aspects of the occurrence and identification of the
assailants, lack the naturalness of independent and spontaneous
narration and, therefore, require careful scrutiny.
11. Learned Counsel next submits that the appellant was
not named in the First Information Report inasmuch as the First
Information Report was registered against three to four unknown
persons. The name of the appellant surfaced during the
investigation of the case, and the prosecution has failed to
establish his identity and involvement through wholly reliable and
convincing evidence. Further, though the appellant was taken on
remand by the police, the name of other persons could not come to
light. No independent witness has been examined by the
prosecution to support its version of the alleged occurrence,

Patna High Court CR. APP (DB) No.14 of 1996 dt.19-11-2026
7/44
although, as per the prosecution evidence itself, several persons
from the neighbourhood had assembled at or near the place of
occurrence after the alarm was raised. The non-examination of
independent witnesses assumes significance and creates further
doubt over the prosecution case.
12. Lastly, it is submitted that the alleged seized articles
i.e. kurta, lathi and chadar (sheet), were not produced before the
Trial Court as material evidence during the trial. Their non-
production deprived the defence of an opportunity to examine the
alleged physical evidence and test its connection with the
occurrence.
13. In view of the aforesaid infirmities and the
cumulative effect of the deficiencies in the prosecution evidence,
the prosecution has failed to establish the guilt of the appellant
beyond reasonable doubt. As such, the appellant is entitled to be
acquitted of the charges levelled against him.
14. Per contra, Mr. Sujit Kumar Singh, learned
Additional Public Prosecutor, argued that the judgement of
conviction and the order of sentence under challenge require no
interference as the prosecution has been able to prove the case
beyond all reasonable doubts. It has been submitted that the
prosecution witnesses have remained consistent during the trial

Patna High Court CR. APP (DB) No.14 of 1996 dt.19-11-2026
8/44
and there is no lacuna in the case of the prosecution. The minor
inconsistencies in the testimony of the witnesses cannot be a
ground to reject their evidence as a whole.
15. It is further submitted that the testimony of the
witnesses stands corroborated in material particulars by the
prosecution evidence and the offences alleged against the
appellant appears to be serious in nature inasmuch as the
prosecution witnesses examined have duly supported its case.
16. Learned Additional Public Prosecutor finally argued
that guilt of the appellant has been satisfactorily proved by the
evidence adduced during the trial and there is no infirmity in the
judgment of conviction passed by the learned trial Court.
17. I have heard learned Counsel for the parties
concerned and have perused the materials available on record.
18. It would be apposite to discuss the oral/documentary
evidence as available on record to re-appreciate the evidence for
just decision of the present appeal.
19. PW 1, Vivekanand Singh, is a formal witness, who
has identified and proved his signature as well as the signature of
Arun Kumar Singh on the seizure list.
20. PW 2, Arun Kumar Singh, was tendered by the
prosecution for cross-examination. In his cross-examination, he

Patna High Court CR. APP (DB) No.14 of 1996 dt.19-11-2026
9/44
deposed that he could not tell what clothes the deceased was
wearing at the time of preparation of the inquest report.
21. PW 5, Dhananjay Kumar, is the uncle of the
deceased and he was tendered by the prosecution for cross-
examination. In his cross-examination, he has deposed that his
father and Shatrughan Prasad Singh are cousins. Devendra Prasad
Singh and Shatrughan Prasad Singh are brothers. He has further
deposed that Devendra Prasad Singh is presently posted as Deputy
Superintendent of Police at Darbhanga.
22. PW 7, Shatrughan Singh, was tendered by the
prosecution for cross-examination. In his cross-examination, he
has deposed that Devendra Singh is his brother and at the time of
occurrence, Devendra Singh was posted as Police Inspector at
Chandi. The statement of this witness was recorded by the police
on the second or third day of the occurrence. The police did not
read over the statement to him. He was also not been able to see
the case diary. The police was noting down only the points of his
statement in his presence. The police was not noting down his
statement in the case diary. This witness denied having made any
statement before the police to the effect that Sahdeo Yadav was
supplying milk to his house for a few days about three years prior
to the occurrence and Sahdeo Yadav had been told once or twice

Patna High Court CR. APP (DB) No.14 of 1996 dt.19-11-2026
10/44
not to enter into the house without permission. He has further
denied having stated to the police that Sahdeo Yadav had cut
branches from the Gular tree situated adjacent to their house for
feeding his cattle and he had been prohibited from doing so. He
has denied the suggestion that he, Devendra Babu and the
Investigating Officer had replaced a page of the case diary.
23. PW 11, Vijay Kumar Sinha, in his examination-in-
chief, has deposed that on 23.12.1980, while he was posted at
Kotwali Police Station, Bhagalpur and was on O.D. duty at
Bhagalpur Medical College Hospital, at 5:30 AM, he received a
written report from Ajay Kumar Singh and he forwarded the same
to Kotwali Police Station for its registration under Sections
302/457 of the Indian Penal Code. He further deposed that he
prepared the inquest report of the dead body of Nirbhay Kumar
Sirmaur in presence of witnesses, Arun Kumar Singh and
Vivekanand Singh. This witness sent the inquest report along with
the dead body. The Officer-in-Charge, Sri B. L. Das, also arrived
at the hospital, whereupon he handed over the charge of the case
to him. He has further stated that he prepared the seizure list at the
request of the Investigating Officer and the witnesses signed the
same in his presence.

Patna High Court CR. APP (DB) No.14 of 1996 dt.19-11-2026
11/44
24. In his cross-examination, this witness (PW 11)
deposed that there was a police camp at B.M.C.H. at the relevant
time and that police camp still exists. He has further deposed that
Ajay Kumar Singh is the son of Devendra Singh, who was Police
Inspector.
25. PW 8, Dr. H. I. Ansari, was the doctor who
conducted the post-mortem examination on the dead body of
rd
Nirbhay Kumar Sirmaur, on 23 December, 1980, at about 3:15
PM. The deceased was of healthy built and fair complexion. Rigor
mortis was present. On further examination, he found the
following ante mortem injuries:-
“Stab wound on the left side back of
th
chest, size 3/4" × 1/4", chest deep between the 6
th
and 7 intercostal spaces. On dissection, the
weapon was found to have passed through the
above intercostal space and entered the chest
cavity, pierced the lower lobe of left lung and had
come out through the lung into the chest cavity.
The chest cavity was full of blood and
blood clots. Lungs were pale. Both chambers of
Heart empty. The stomach contained black pasty
material. The liver, spleen and kidneys were found
pale. The urinary bladder was empty, and the
colon contained gas.
On opening the scalp, the area
corresponding to the vertex was found contused.

Patna High Court CR. APP (DB) No.14 of 1996 dt.19-11-2026
12/44
The underlying brain tissue were also found
contused and had some blood clot.”
26. In the opinion of the doctor (PW 8), the injuries
were ante-mortem in nature. Injury No. 1 was caused by a sharp-
pointed weapon. Injury No. 2 was caused by a hard and blunt
substance. The cause of death was haemorrhage shock and coma
as a result of injury to vital organ, lung. He further opined that
injury No. 1, i.e., the stab wound, was sufficient to cause death.
27. In his cross-examination, PW-8 has stated that there
must have been a penetration of the left lung.
28. Nothing, in particular, was elicited by the defence to
show that the findings of the doctor and/or his opinion, with
regard to the cause of death was incorrect. This apart, I, too, do
not find anything inherently incorrect or improbable in the
evidence given by PW 8.
29. It can, therefore, be safely concluded, and I do
conclude, that the deceased died as a result of having sustained the
injuries as has been mentioned by the doctor (PW 8) and the
hemorrhage, shock and coma, which resulted from the ante
mortem injuries aforementioned, became the cause of his death
and that the injuries, which had been inflicted on, and sustained

Patna High Court CR. APP (DB) No.14 of 1996 dt.19-11-2026
13/44
by, the said deceased, was sufficient to cause death of a person in
the ordinary course of nature.
30. What also clearly follows from the discussion of the
medical evidence on record is that the death of the said deceased
was homicidal in nature. Whether the appellant was the one, who
had caused the death, of the deceased, therefore, falls for
consideration.
31. The test identification parade of the appellant was
held on 15.02.1981 by Sri S. P. Gupta, Judicial Magistrate,
Bhagalpur (PW 9). PW9, in his examination-in-chief, has deposed
that pursuant to the order of the Chief Judicial Magistrate,
Bhagalpur, he conducted a test identification parade of the suspect
in connection with Kotwali Police Station Case No. 40 of 1980, at
Central Jail, Bhagalpur, in presence of Ramakant Rai, Clerk. The
suspect was Sahdeo Yadav @ Maina Yadav and the witnesses
were Ajay Kumar Singh, Sadai Kumar Sirmaur and Abhay Kumar
Singh.
32. This witness further deposed that the suspect was
placed among nine other persons of similar appearance, age and
physique for the purpose of the identification parade. He further
deposed that witness Ajay Kumar Singh identified the suspect,
Sahdeo Yadav, stating that he had seen him scaling the boundary

Patna High Court CR. APP (DB) No.14 of 1996 dt.19-11-2026
14/44
wall of his house at the time of the occurrence. Witness Sadai
Kumar Sirmaur also identified the suspect, Sahdeo Yadav, stating
that he had seen him scaling the boundary wall of his house.
Witness Abhay Kumar Singh likewise identified the suspect,
Sahdeo Yadav, stating that he had seen him scaling the boundary
wall. He has also stated that no police officer was present at the
time of conducting the test identification parade.
33. In his cross-examination, this witness (PW 9) has
deposed that he could not recall whether the witnesses had
accompanied him to the jail or who had identified the witnesses.
He has further deposed that while one witness was participating in
the test identification parade, the other witnesses were kept
outside at a different gate. After completion of the identification
by a witness, he was sent to a secluded place within the jail
premises where he could not interact with the other witnesses. He
did not mention in the test identification parade chart that the
position of the suspect had been changed. He also did not record
the identifying marks of the suspect in the test identification
parade chart. He has deposed that the answers given by the
witnesses during the identification parade were recorded. He
denied the suggestion that the Investigating Officer and the Police

Patna High Court CR. APP (DB) No.14 of 1996 dt.19-11-2026
15/44
Inspector were present at the time of the test identification parade
and had conducted the identification of the witnesses.
34. PW 3, Sadai Kumar Sirmaur, in his examination-in-
chief, has deposed that deceased Nirbhay Kumar Sirmaur @
Chunnu was his elder brother. He deposed that on the date of
occurrence, he was sleeping in a room along with Dhananjay
Kumar Singh. His elder brother Chunnu was scheduled to leave
for Nepal the following morning. He further deposed that at about
3 AM, upon hearing the alarm of "Chor-Chor" from outside, he
woke up. His sister, Madhulika Singh, was raising an alarm from
the courtyard/verandah, shouting that Chunnu Bhaiya is chasing
the thieves and had gone to the roof. Thereafter, this witness,
along with Dhananjay Kumar Singh, proceeded towards the roof
with lathis and on reaching the roof, they saw Chunnu Bhaiya
grappling with one person, while two to three other persons were
standing nearby. He deposed that the place of occurrence was near
a water tap and his brother was calling them. Thereafter, they
came downstairs, unlocked the middle room and came outside,
where they found Chunnu Bhaiya writhing in pain and asking for
water. The miscreants jumped over the boundary wall and fled
towards the eastern direction along the road. His sister Madhulika
Singh gave water to Chunnu Bhaiya. PW-3 further deposed that

Patna High Court CR. APP (DB) No.14 of 1996 dt.19-11-2026
16/44
his brother was bleeding profusely. He first took him to K. K.
Nursing Home, where no doctor was available, and thereafter took
him to B.M.C.H., Bhagalpur, where the doctor declared him dead.
35. This witness (PW 3) deposed that it was moonlit
night on the night of occurrence and that a municipal street light
was glowing near the water tap and in that light, he had properly
seen the faces of the miscreants. He further deposed that one sheet
and a lathi belonging to the miscreants were left behind at the
place of occurrence.
36. This witness (PW 3) further deposed that he had
gone to jail for the purpose of the Test Identification Parade,
wherein he identified one of the miscreants in presence of a
Magistrate, who was also present in the Court.
37. This witness (PW 3), in his cross-examination, has
deposed that on the date of occurrence, his father was not present
at the house, whereas his mother was present. Devendra Singh is
his uncle, who had earlier served as a Police Inspector at
Bhagalpur. He further deposed that Ajay Kumar Singh was also
residing with him in the same house at that time. PW-3 further
deposed that Dhananjay had gone outside the house, but he had
come upon hearing the alarm. His mother had also come outside
upon hearing the commotion. He further stated that he had not

Patna High Court CR. APP (DB) No.14 of 1996 dt.19-11-2026
17/44
heard the deceased Chunnu raising any alarm. He stated that he
and Dhananjay first went to the courtyard and thereafter
proceeded to the roof. He further stated that he, Dhananjay, Ajay,
his mother, Madhulika and Abhay Kumar went to the roof. Near
the water tap, one person was engaged in a scuffle. At that time,
he saw four persons from a distance. The boundary wall was
situated at a distance of approximately 10–12 yards from the side
of the house. He saw all four miscreants jumping over the
boundary wall and fleeing. At that time, the accused was wearing
a lungi and kurta, whereas he had not noticed what the other three
miscreants were wearing. PW 3 further deposed that he did not
chase the miscreants. He stated that the accused fled towards the
northern direction, whereas all four miscreants jumped over the
boundary wall and fled towards the eastern direction. He had
never seen the accused selling milk on a bicycle nor had the
accused ever supplied milk at his house. He further stated that
while giving his statement before the Investigating Officer, he
remembered what clothes the accused was wearing at the time of
occurrence, but he could not remember whether he had
specifically disclosed the same to the Investigating Officer. He
also stated that a cow was present at his house and was tied in the
courtyard. PW 3 further stated that after the date of occurrence, he

Patna High Court CR. APP (DB) No.14 of 1996 dt.19-11-2026
18/44
again saw the accused during the Test Identification Parade. At the
Test Identification Parade, approximately 10–12 persons were
standing along with the accused, but he identified only the
accused. He further deposed that upon hearing the alarm, several
people from the neighbourhood had assembled, but he
remembered the names of Rajiv Ranjan Singh, Vibhuti
Chaudhary, Putun Dada and Raj Narayan Pandey. He denied the
suggestion that the accused used to supply milk at his house and
he was familiar to him prior to the alleged occurrence and there
was a dispute over payment of money.
38. PW 4, Abhay Kumar Singh, in his examination-in-
chief, has deposed that Nirbhay Kumar Singh was his younger
brother, who was also known as Chunnu in the family. The
occurrence took place in December, 1980, about four to five years
prior to his deposition. Approximately at about 3 AM, on the date
of occurrence, he was sleeping in the eastern room of his house
and upon hearing the alarm “Chor-Chor”, he woke up and came
out of his room. In the courtyard, his sister, Madhulika, told him
that Chunnu Bhaiya is chasing the thieves and had gone to the
roof. He also rushed to the roof, from where he saw Chunnu
Bhaiya grappling with one of the thieves near the water tap. He
then hurried downstairs, where his younger brothers were opening

Patna High Court CR. APP (DB) No.14 of 1996 dt.19-11-2026
19/44
the lock of the door. When they came outside, he saw Chunnu
lying on the ground and the thief was fleeing by scaling the
boundary wall. Blood was oozing from Chunnu’s body, and he
was asking for water. Madhulika gave him water to drink.
Thereafter, they took Chunnu to K. K. Nursing Home, but no
doctor was available there. They then took him to Sadar Hospital,
B.M.C.H., where the doctor declared him dead. He has deposed
that the test identification parade was held in jail, where he had
identified the said person. He has also deposed that Madhulika is
presently in Canada and is not likely to come here at present. He
identified the same person in the test identification parade.
39. PW 4, in his cross-examination, has deposed that
Madhulika went to Canada in February, 1985, and her address is
known to his family. Madhulika had not participated in the test
identification parade. His mother is alive and resides at home, but
she had also not participated in the test identification parade.
There are houses on both the eastern and western sides of his
house. Upon hearing the alarm “Chor-Chor”, people gathered
from the houses situated on both sides. He could not disclose their
names, as he was trying to save his brother’s life. At that time, he
did not talk to anyone. His house is surrounded by a boundary
wall on all sides. The staircase leading to the roof is situated inside

Patna High Court CR. APP (DB) No.14 of 1996 dt.19-11-2026
20/44
the house and is accessible through the verandah. He did not see
any of the miscreants climbing the staircase to reach the roof. He
also did not see Chunnu or the miscreant on the roof, nor did he
see any miscreant jumping down from the roof. He has further
stated that the distance between the place where Chunnu Bhaiya
had fallen and the point from where the miscreant was escaping
by scaling the boundary wall was approximately 4 feet. He saw
the miscreant escaping by scaling the boundary wall. He stated
that there were three to four persons escaping by scaling the
boundary wall. On further clarification, he stated that he had seen
two or three persons fleeing, and they were running almost
together. He did not chase them in order to apprehend them. He
could not remember whether he had raised an alarm of “Pakro-
Pakro”. He stated that his statement had not been recorded by the
Sub-Inspector during three days and that his statement was
recorded by the police after his return from Gaya after about 25
days. He has further stated that he did not know whether the
accused had a house at Gawar Toli, kept cows and buffaloes, or
carried the business of selling milk. He had not seen the accused
selling milk. He denied the suggestion that he had falsely
implicated the accused or he knew the accused prior to the
occurrence.

Patna High Court CR. APP (DB) No.14 of 1996 dt.19-11-2026
21/44
40. PW 6, Ajay Kumar Singh is the informant of this
case and the cousin brother of the deceased. He, in his
nd
examination-in-chief, deposed that in the intervening night of 22
rd
and 23 December, 1980, he was sleeping with deceased Nirbhay
Kumar Singh in the same room and at about 3 AM, upon hearing
the alarm “Chor-Chor”, he woke up. Nirbhay Ji was raising the
alarm “Chor-Chor”. When he came out, he saw Nirbhay Ji chasing
a thief and proceeding towards the staircase leading to the roof.
He also went to the roof. On reaching there, he saw that near the
water tap, towards the eastern side of the house, Nirbhay Ji was
engaged in a scuffle with three or four persons. He had caught
hold of one of the thieves. He witnessed the occurrence from the
roof. The street light was illuminated and it was a moonlit night;
therefore, he could clearly see the faces of all the persons. He saw
the persons scaling the boundary wall and fleeing towards the
east. Even at that time, he could identify those persons. When he
went near Chunnu @ Nirbhay Ji, he found that Chunnu had
sustained a knife injury on his back and was bleeding. He was
asking for water. A lathi and a chadar, belonging to the miscreants,
were lying at the place of occurrence. He took Chunnu Bhaiya to
K. K. Nursing Home, but no doctor was available there. He

Patna High Court CR. APP (DB) No.14 of 1996 dt.19-11-2026
22/44
thereafter took him to B.M.C.H., where the doctor declared him
dead.
41. This witness (PW 6) deposed that he gave a written
report to the Sub-Inspector of the police station. The said written
report was written by him and bears his signature. The Sub-
Inspector subsequently recorded his statement and he also showed
him the place of occurrence. He participated as a witness in the
test identification parade, where he identified one of the
miscreants, who is present in the dock in the Court.
42. PW 6, in his cross-examination, deposed that at the
time of occurrence, his father was posted as Police Inspector at
Chandi. Prior to that, his father had also been posted as Police
Inspector at Bhagalpur. Apart from himself and Chunnu Ji, no
other person was sleeping in that room. He could not ascertain the
direction from which the alarm was coming, but he had heard it.
After coming out of the room, he reached the verandah, where he
did not find anyone at that time. He did not notice whether anyone
was present in the courtyard or not. When he came to the
verandah, he saw a thief is going upstairs by the staircase. He
could see only one thief. The said person was of normal height
and was neither particularly stout nor fat. He has further stated
that it might have taken him about one or two minutes to reach the

Patna High Court CR. APP (DB) No.14 of 1996 dt.19-11-2026
23/44
roof. By the time he reached the roof, the said person had already
fled. He could not remember how long he remained on the roof,
but stated that he might have remained there for about one and a
half to two minutes. While he was on the roof, Sadai, Dhananjay
and Abhay had also arrived there. He could not remember whether
any other persons had come to the roof. He did not have any
conversation with them there. Thereafter, he saw Chunnu near the
water tap, where he noticed that three or four persons were
engaged in the grappling with him. When he was witnessing the
scuffle from the roof, Sadaiv, Dhananjay and Abhay were also
there. After coming down from the roof, he went towards the
middle room. Sadai and Dhananjay Ji had been sleeping in that
room. The door on the northern side of the middle room, which
provided an exit, was locked. After coming down from the roof,
Sadai Bhaiya was opening the lock of the room, and he did not
remember anyone else coming there. He went directly towards the
water tap after the lock was opened. Chunnu was lying near the
water tap. Sadai, Dhananjay and Abhay, all three, also reached that
spot. By the time he reached the place of occurrence, the
miscreants had already fled away. He had seen two or three
persons scaling the boundary wall and escaping. During the
occurrence and immediately thereafter, some persons from the

Patna High Court CR. APP (DB) No.14 of 1996 dt.19-11-2026
24/44
neighbourhood had assembled there. Vibhuti Chaudhary and Rajiv
Ranjan were also among those present. He did not have any
conversation with them at that time. He denied the suggestion that
the accused used to supply milk at his house and a dispute had
taken place with him a few days prior to the occurrence over
payment for the milk. He also denied the suggestion that he
already knew the accused before the occurrence.
43. PW 10, Babu Lal Ram, the Investigating Officer of
this case, in his examination-in-chief, has deposed that he took
over the charge of the case from Assistant Sub-Inspector Vijay
Kumar Sinha, recorded the statement of the informant, Ajay
Kumar Singh, and also recorded the statements of Arun Kumar
Singh and Vivekanand Singh on 23.12.1980. He inspected the
place of occurrence, which is the brick-built house of the
informant, having a concrete roof. The main entrance of the house
faced north. At a distance of about ten yards to the north of the
house, there was a brick boundary wall, approximately four feet in
height. Fresh marks indicating that bricks had fallen from the top
of the wall were noticed. The informant pointed out the place of
occurrence to him. He has further deposed that on the eastern side
of the house, there was a cattle shed having a roof covered with
clay tiles, some of which were found freshly broken. Towards the

Patna High Court CR. APP (DB) No.14 of 1996 dt.19-11-2026
25/44
east of the cattle shed, a potato plant was found trampled, and
signs of trampling were also noticed on a plant situated to its
north. Bloodstains were found on the ground in the area between
the potato plant and the boundary wall. A lathi and a chadar were
found at a distance of about two yards to the west of the place
where blood had fallen. The blood-stained soil, the chadar and the
lathi were seized in presence of witnesses and a seizure list was
prepared. Assistant Sub-Inspector Vijay Kumar Sinha prepared the
seizure list on his dictation, and the same bears his signature.
Witnesses Vibhuti Bhushan Chaudhary and Rajiv Ranjan Singh
signed the seizure list in his presence. He identified their
signatures. He has further deposed that he recorded the statements
of Sadai Kumar Singh, Dhananjay Kumar Singh and Kumari
Madhulika. During the investigation, a police dog was brought to
the place of occurrence and after sniffing chadar and lathi, the dog
led the police to the house of Sahdeo Yadav @ Maina Yadav,
situated at Adampur Koyla Ghat. Sahdeo Yadav was not found at
his house. A kurta bearing bloodstains was seized from the
premises in the presence of witnesses Gopeshwar Jha and Mahesh
Prasad. He prepared and signed the seizure list, which was also
signed by the witnesses. The same has been marked as Exhibit-
7/1. He has stated that when the seized kurta was placed along

Patna High Court CR. APP (DB) No.14 of 1996 dt.19-11-2026
26/44
with other kurtas before the police dog, the dog choose the seized
kurta. Similarly, when the chadar was mixed with other articles,
the dog choose the seized chadar. An objection was raised by the
defence counsel in respect of the said question.
44. This witness (PW 10) deposed that he recorded the
statement of other persons also, including the deceased's father,
Dr. Shatrudhan Prasad Singh, Abhay Kumar Singh and Sanjay
Brahmachari. He requested for the test identification parade,
which was conducted by a Magistrate. Neither he nor any other
police officer was present during the test identification parade. He
obtained the test identification parade chart. He further deposed
that the blood-stained soil and chadar, seized from the place of
occurrence, along with the kurta seized from the house of the
accused, were sent to the Forensic Science Laboratory, Patna,
Bihar, for chemical examination. After completion of the
investigation, he submitted the charge-sheet.
45. PW 10, in his cross-examination, has stated that a
written report had been received before he visited the hospital and
the said written report had been received prior to registration of
the formal First Information Report. The receipt of the written
report was entered in the station diary of Kotwali Police Station.
His departure from Kotwali Police Station was also recorded in

Patna High Court CR. APP (DB) No.14 of 1996 dt.19-11-2026
27/44
the station diary. The station diary would disclose which police
officers were present at Kotwali at that time. He was not
accompanied by any other police officer when he left Kotwali.
However, the Assistant Superintendent of Police was present at the
hospital. He voluntarily stated that he had recorded the statements
of Vibhuti Bhushan Chaudhary and Rajiv Ranjan Singh, who
resided in the same lane and were witnesses in the case. The case
diary does not mention that there were numerous houses on both
sides of Satish Sarkar Lane. He has stated that he did not seize any
bricks which had fallen from the boundary wall, nor did he find
any fingerprints on the wall. Satish Sarkar Lane connects with
Radha Rani Road. He has further described the layout of the
informant's house. The case diary does not specify the area over
which blood was found at the place of occurrence, nor does it
mention whether the blood was found in the form of droplets or a
patch. He has further stated that no bloodstains were found on the
lathi seized from near the place of occurrence. Regarding the
police dog, he has stated that its name was not mentioned in the
case diary. The dog had been brought from the Police Lines and he
was trained to handle it. The case diary does not record whether
any witnesses were present when the dog was made to smell the
lathi and the chadar. No trainer had accompanied the dog. The

Patna High Court CR. APP (DB) No.14 of 1996 dt.19-11-2026
28/44
house of Bali Yadav was situated at Koyla Ghat, Gawal Toli. The
dog entered his house, although it was not previously familiar
with that house. The number of rooms in the house was not
mentioned in the case diary. The witnesses to the seizure list were
present when the dog emerged from a room carrying a kurta in its
mouth. No separate statement of Balli Yadav was recorded. He
voluntarily stated that Balli Yadav told him that the said kurta
belonged to his son. He has further stated that blood-like stain was
found on the kurta seized from the house of Balli Yadav, the kurta
was sent for examination on 26.02.1981, however he did not
receive the chemical examination report. He has stated that no
injuries were found on the arms or knees of Sahdeo Yadav. He
subsequently clarified that no injuries were found on his elbows or
knees either. Sahdeo Yadav was not sent for medical examination.
Paragraphs 25, 26 and 27 in both the original and carbon copies of
the case diary were in his handwriting. In the original case diary,
paragraphs 25, 26 and 27 were marked as Exhibit-A; whereas in
the carbon copy, they were marked as Exhibit-A/1. He has further
stated that, on the particular page of the case diary containing
paragraph 26, both in the original and carbon copy, the digit
following '276' in the page number had been torn off. The pages of
the case diary were numbered sequentially. He denied the

Patna High Court CR. APP (DB) No.14 of 1996 dt.19-11-2026
29/44
suggestion that the statement of Dr. Shatrughan Prasad Singh,
recorded in paragraph 26, had been altered at the instance of his
brother, Police Inspector Devendra Prasad Singh. He also denied
the suggestion that Shatrughan Babu had told him that Sahdeo
Yadav used to supply milk to his house for a few days about three
years prior to the occurrence. He further denied the suggestion
that he had altered the said statement. Lastly, he has stated that the
informant, Ajay Kumar Singh, had stated that he had seen the
thieves fleeing from the place of occurrence.
46. Having carefully re-appreciated the entire evidence
on record, this Court proceeds to examine whether the prosecution
has succeeded in proving the guilt of the appellant beyond
reasonable doubt.
47. It is settled law that in criminal cases, since life and
liberty of the accused is involved, a strict standard of proof is
required so as to prove the guilt of the accused. It is not the
preponderance of the probabilities that establishes the guilt of the
accused. It is necessary that the evidence on record must prove it
beyond reasonable doubt. A conviction cannot be based on the
consideration that the prosecution story may be true. The accused
can be convicted only if the court reaches the conclusion that the
prosecution version has been proved beyond the shadow of all

Patna High Court CR. APP (DB) No.14 of 1996 dt.19-11-2026
30/44
reasonable doubts. The burden of proving the guilt of the accused
is upon the prosecution.
48. The principal evidence relied upon by the
prosecution for establishing the identity of the appellant consists
of the testimonies of PW 3, PW 4 and PW 6, who are members of
the deceased's family.
49. This Court is conscious of the well-settled principle
that just because the witnesses are related/interested/partisan
witnesses, their testimonies cannot be disregarded, however, it is
also true that when the witnesses are related/interested, their
testimonies have to be scrutinized with greater care and
circumspection.
50. On an examination of the testimonies of PW 3, PW
4 and PW 6, we find material discrepancies concerning the
manner in which the occurrence was witnessed.
51. PW 6, the informant, has deposed that upon hearing
the alarm of "Chor-Chor" by the deceased, he woke up and saw
the deceased chasing a thief towards the staircase leading to the
rooftop. He thereafter proceeded to the rooftop and allegedly saw
three or four persons grappling with the deceased near the water
tap. However, in his cross-examination, PW 6 has deposed that
when he came out of the room and reached the verandah, he saw

Patna High Court CR. APP (DB) No.14 of 1996 dt.19-11-2026
31/44
only one thief proceeding upstairs through the staircase. PW 3 has
given a materially different account of the occurrence. According
to him, he woke up upon hearing an alarm raised by his sister,
Madhulika Singh, from the courtyard, informing the family that
the deceased was chasing the thieves and gone to the rooftop. He
has further deposed that he, along with Dhananjay Kumar Singh,
proceeded towards the rooftop carrying lathis, where they saw the
deceased grappling with one person, while two or three other
persons were standing nearby. PW 3 has deposed that he had not
heard the deceased raising any alarm. He also stated that he and
Dhananjay first went to the courtyard and thereafter proceeded to
the rooftop. He further stated that he saw four persons from a
distance and that all of them jumped over the boundary wall and
fled towards the eastern direction. PW 4, on the other hand, has
deposed that upon hearing the alarm, he came out of his room and
was informed by his sister, Madhulika, that the deceased was
chasing the thieves and gone to the rooftop. He further stated that
from the rooftop, he saw the deceased grappling with one of the
thieves near the water tap. PW 4 categorically deposed further that
he did not see the deceased or any miscreant on the rooftop. He
also stated that he did not see any miscreant climbing the staircase

Patna High Court CR. APP (DB) No.14 of 1996 dt.19-11-2026
32/44
or jumping down from the rooftop. According to him, he only saw
the miscreants escaping by scaling the boundary wall.
52. The aforesaid statements reveal substantial
differences in the manner in which the witnesses claim to have
witnessed the occurrence. While PW 6 claims to have seen three
or four persons grappling with the deceased from the rooftop, PW
3 claims to have seen one person grappling with the deceased and
two or three others standing nearby. PW 4 has denied seeing the
actual occurrence on the rooftop and has confined his observation
to the alleged escape of the miscreants. These discrepancies
cannot be treated as insignificant variations concerning peripheral
details.
53. Another material circumstance is the contradictory
account regarding the number and movement of the alleged
miscreants. The prosecution case initially speaks of three to four
unknown persons. However, the witnesses have given differing
accounts regarding the number of persons seen at the rooftop, near
the water tap and while escaping over the boundary wall.
54. PW 6 has stated that by the time he reached the
place where the deceased was lying, the miscreants had already
fled. PW 4 has also stated that he saw two or three persons

Patna High Court CR. APP (DB) No.14 of 1996 dt.19-11-2026
33/44
escaping. PW-3, however, has stated that he saw four persons
jumping over the boundary wall.
55. The witnesses have also differed regarding the
direction in which the miscreants allegedly escaped. PW 3 has
stated that all four persons jumped over the boundary wall towards
the eastern direction, while he has also made a statement that the
accused fled towards the northern direction. Such inconsistency
becomes relevant when the prosecution seeks to establish the
identity of an unknown accused on the basis of a brief observation
during a night time occurrence i.e. in moonlit night and street
light.
56. When witnesses are examined in the court after a
considerable lapse of time, it is neither unnatural nor unexpected
that there can be some minor variations in the statements of the
prosecution witnesses. However, where the discrepancies relate to
the opportunity of identification, the actual presence of a witness
at the relevant place and the manner in which the accused was
allegedly seen, such discrepancies assume considerable
significance.
57. In Pankaj v. State of Rajasthan, reported in (2016)
16 SCC 192 , the Hon'ble Supreme Court held that when the
genesis and manner of the incident itself are doubtful, conviction

Patna High Court CR. APP (DB) No.14 of 1996 dt.19-11-2026
34/44
cannot be sustained. The Hon'ble Supreme Court in paragraph no.
25 of the aforesaid judgement has held as under:
"25. It is well-settled principle of law
that when the genesis and the manner of the
incident is doubtful, the accused can not be
convicted. Inasmuch as the prosecution the has
failed to establish the circumstances in which the
appellant was alleged to have fired at the
deceased, the entire story deserves to be rejected.
When the evidence produced by the prosecution
has neither quality nor credibility, it would be
unsafe rest conviction upon such evidence. After
having considered the matter thoughtfully, we find
that the evidence on record in the case is not
sufficient to bring home the guilt of the appellant.
In such circumstances, the appellant is entitled to
the benefit of doubt."
58. The next important aspect requiring consideration is
the identification of the appellant. Admittedly, the appellant was
not named in the fardbeyan. The First Information Report was
registered against three to four unknown persons. The informant
an other witnesses have specifically stated that he had never seen
the appellant prior to the occurrence and had seen him for the first
time during the test identification parade conducted in jail.
59. Thus, the prosecution was required to establish that
the witnesses had an adequate and reliable opportunity to observe

Patna High Court CR. APP (DB) No.14 of 1996 dt.19-11-2026
35/44
the appellant during the occurrence and their subsequent
identification was free from any possibility of mistake or
influence.
60. PW 9, the Judicial Magistrate who conducted the
test identification parade, has deposed that the parade was held on
15.02.1981 at Central Jail, Bhagalpur. The appellant was placed
among nine other persons of similar appearance, age and
physique, who was identified by the witnesses, namely, Ajay
Kumar Singh, Sadai Kumar Sirmaur and Abhay Kumar Singh,
saying that they had seen him scaling the boundary wall of his
house at the time of the occurrence.
61. The occurrence took place at about 3 AM. during the
nd rd
intervening night of 22 and 23 December, 1980. The appellant
was not previously known to the informant or the other identifying
witnesses. Further, the description of the accused given by the
informant was vague and general, referring only to differences in
height, complexion and built. Such broad descriptions are
insufficient to inspire confidence regarding the correct
identification of unknown persons. The identification of the
appellant, therefore, assumes significance and requires careful
scrutiny, particularly in view of the circumstances in which the
occurrence took place.

Patna High Court CR. APP (DB) No.14 of 1996 dt.19-11-2026
36/44
62. The name or involvement of the appellant transpired
in this case for the first time on 23.12.1980, when the sniffer dog
entered into his house and came out with a kurta having small
marks of blood like stain and the Test Identification Parade was
conducted on 15.02.1981, i.e. about more than 55 days. Further,
the appellant surrendered before the Court on 10.02.1981.
63. The delay caused in conducting the Test
Identification Parade adversely affects the sanctity of the same and
benefit of doubt with regard to the same would lie in favour of the
appellant, on the basis of the proposition laid laid down by the
Hon’ble Supreme Court, in the case of State of U.P. v. Wasif
Haider , reported in 2019 (2) SCC 303 , wherein it has been
indicated that in a case where out of seven witnesses, the T.I.P.
was held after an inordinate delay of 55 days and although the
involvement of the accused was brought to light on an earlier day
itself, the prosecution did not take any effort to arrest or
interrogate him for a substantial period of time for which no
reasonable explanation was provided, such T.I.P would be
susceptible to doubt. The defence had pleaded in the said case that
an inordinate delay was caused by the prosecution witnesses to
mark their identification.

Patna High Court CR. APP (DB) No.14 of 1996 dt.19-11-2026
37/44
64. In such circumstances, the inordinate delay in
conducting the Test Identification Parade; particularly in absence
of any satisfactory explanation from the prosecution, undermines
the reliability of the identification evidence and diminishes the
evidentiary value of the entire exercise.
65. Further, although the witnesses have referred to
moonlit night and street light as the sources of illumination at the
time of occurrence, the prosecution has not adduced any
convincing objective evidence regarding the precise location,
intensity or adequacy of such illumination. The Investigating
Officer has also admitted that no site plan of the house or the place
of occurrence was prepared. More importantly, the opportunity of
observation claimed by the witnesses is itself rendered doubtful in
view of the material contradictions and inconsistencies in their
testimonies, as discussed herein above. PW 4, in particular, has
admitted that he did not witness the actual occurrence on the
rooftop and had merely seen certain persons allegedly escaping
over the boundary wall.
66. The identification evidence of PW 4, therefore, has
to be appreciated in the light of the limited opportunity of
observation available to him. Similarly, the identification made by
PW 3 and PW 6 cannot be examined in isolation from the material

Patna High Court CR. APP (DB) No.14 of 1996 dt.19-11-2026
38/44
inconsistencies in their respective accounts. It is also significant
that PW 6 has categorically admitted that he had never seen the
appellant prior to the occurrence and had first seen him during the
Test Identification Parade. Thus, having regard to the fact that the
appellant was previously unknown to the witnesses, the
unexplained delay in conducting the Test Identification Parade,
coupled with the doubtful circumstances of identification and the
deficiencies in the investigation, creates a serious doubt regarding
the reliability of the identification evidence.
67. Further, it is an unnatural corollary that the
witnesses will identify the appellant from behind when they were
not familiar to each other inasmuch as all the three witnesses have
identified the appellant in the Test Identification Parade saying
that they had seen him scaling the boundary wall of his house at
the time of the occurrence. Nobody can identify a person in the
night of a winter season while fleeing away, i.e. from behind. It is
not the case of the prosecution that the witnesses have claimed to
be identifying the appellant in the Test Identification Parade
saying that they had seen their faces while scuffle was going on in
between the appellant and the deceased.
68. Another circumstance which requires consideration
is the non-examination of any independent witnesses. PW 3 and

Patna High Court CR. APP (DB) No.14 of 1996 dt.19-11-2026
39/44
PW 6 have admitted that several persons from the neighbourhood
assembled at the place of occurrence after the alarm was raised.
They have specifically referred to the presence of Vibhuti
Bhushan Chaudhary and Rajiv Ranjan Singh, among others. The
Investigating Officer, too, has deposed that he recorded the
statements of Vibhuti Bhushan Chaudhary and Rajiv Ranjan
Singh, who were residents of the same lane and had signed the
seizure list. However, none of these witnesses have been
examined during trial to corroborate the prosecution version.
69. It is true that the prosecution is not required to
examine any particular number of witnesses, nor can the
testimony of related witnesses be discarded merely on account of
non-examination of independent witnesses. However, in the
present case, when the presence of several independent persons in
the immediate vicinity of the place of occurrence stands
established, their non-examination assumes significance,
particularly in view of the material contradictions and
inconsistencies in the testimonies of the family members.
70. The prosecution has also relied on the alleged
recovery of a kurta from the house of the appellant and the
evidence relating to the police dog. PW 10, the Investigating
Officer, has stated that after smelling the lathi and chadar

Patna High Court CR. APP (DB) No.14 of 1996 dt.19-11-2026
40/44
allegedly left at the place of occurrence, the police dog proceeded
to the house of Sahdeo Yadav at Adampur Koyla Ghat. A kurta
allegedly having blood like stains was seized from the appellant’s
premises. The Investigating Officer further stated that the dog
subsequently identified the seized kurta when it was placed
alongside other kurtas and similarly identified the chadar when
mixed with other articles. However, in his cross-examination, PW-
10 admitted that the name of the dog was not mentioned in the
case diary, no trainer had accompanied it, and there was no record
of the presence of any independent witness or the procedure
adopted during the tracking exercise.
71. It would be relevant to note that in the case of
Abdul Rajak Murtaza Dafadar v. State of Maharashtra (AIR
1970 SC 283) , a three-Judge Bench of the Hon’ble Supreme Court
declined to express any concluded opinion or to lay down any
general rule concerning tracker dog’s evidence or its admissibility
against the accused.
72. In the case of Abdul Rajak Murtaza Dafadar
(supra), the Hon’ble Supreme Court has observed as under:
“… It was argued in that case that the
tracker dog's evidence could be likened to the type
of evidence accepted from scientific experts
describing chemical reactions, blood tests and the

Patna High Court CR. APP (DB) No.14 of 1996 dt.19-11-2026
41/44
actions of bacilli. The comparison does not,
however, appear to be sound because the
behaviour of chemicals, blood corpuscles and
bacilli contains no element of conscious volition
or deliberate choice . But dogs are intelligent
animals with many thought processes similar to
the thought processes of human beings and
wherever you have thought processes there is
always the risk of error, deception and even self-
deception. For these reasons we are of the
opinion that in the present state of scientific
knowledge evidence of dog tracking, even if
admissible, is not ordinarily of much weight.
(emphasis supplied)
73. In the case of Dinesh Borthakur v. State of Assam,
reported in (2008) 5 SCC 697 , the Hon’ble Supreme Court has
held that the in this behalf, therefore, is settled that while the
services of a sniffer dog may be taken for the purpose of
investigation, its faculties cannot be taken as evidence for the
purpose of establishing the guilt of an accused.
74. In the present case, it further appears from the
evidence of PW-10 that the house from which the kurta was
allegedly recovered belonged to Balli Yadav. The Investigating
Officer admitted that no separate statement of Balli Yadav was
recorded. The assertion of PW 10 that Balli Yadav had informed

Patna High Court CR. APP (DB) No.14 of 1996 dt.19-11-2026
42/44
him that the kurta belonged to his son, therefore, remains
uncorroborated.
75. More importantly, PW 10 has admitted that the
chemical examination report was not received by him. Although
the bloodstained soil, chadar and kurta were allegedly sent to the
Forensic Science Laboratory, Patna, the prosecution has not
produced any forensic report establishing that the stains on the
kurta allegedly recovered from the house of the appellant were
human blood or just red marks and that it was the blood of the
deceased. The prosecution has also failed in bringing on record
any report with regards to the finger print on the danda. The
prosecution has also not able to seize knife, the alleged weapon of
murder and it also failed to brought on record the report of the
chemical examiner with regard to the blood collected from the
spot.
76. In such circumstances, the alleged recovery of the
kurta from the house of the appellant, coupled with the evidence
relating to the police sniffer dog, cannot be treated as reliable
evidence sufficient to establish the guilt of the appellant.
77. In the present case, the non-production of the seized
articles deprived the defence of a fair opportunity to test the
prosecution's claim regarding those articles and their alleged

Patna High Court CR. APP (DB) No.14 of 1996 dt.19-11-2026
43/44
incriminating character. This omission assumes greater
significance because the prosecution has not otherwise brought on
record any convincing scientific or forensic evidence connecting
the alleged seized articles with the crime.
78. In the case of Pradeep Kumar v. State of
Chhattisgarh , reported in (2023) 5 SCC 350, the Honble Supreme
Court has held, in paragraph 27, as under:-
“27. It is important to note that the
cardinal principles in the administration of
criminal justice in cases where heavy reliance is
placed on circumstantial evidence, is that where
two views are possible, one pointing to the guilt of
the accused and the other towards his innocence,
the one which is favourable to the accused must be
adopted.”
79. In the facts and attending circumstances of the
present case, the appellant ought to have been accorded benefit of
reasonable doubt inasmuch as the prosecution has failed, in the
light of the discussion of the evidence on record, to bring home
the charges against the appellant beyond all reasonable doubt.
80. In the result and for the foregoing reasons, this
appeal is allowed. The impugned conviction of the appellant and
the sentences passed against him by the judgment and order, under
appeal, are hereby set aside. The appellant is held not guilty of the

Patna High Court CR. APP (DB) No.14 of 1996 dt.19-11-2026
44/44
offences, which he stand convicted of, and he is hereby acquitted
of the same under benefit of doubt.
81. Since the appellant is on bail, he is discharged from
the liabilities of the bail bonds.
82. Registry shall, forthwith, send a copy of this
judgment and order to the learned trial Court along with the
Lower Court Records.
(Anil Kumar Sinha, J.)
Vikash Kumar, J.:-
I agree.
(Vikash Kumar, J.)
Prabhakar Anand/-
AFR/NAFR AFR
CAV DATE 01.10.2026
Uploading Date 19.11.2026
Transmission Date 19.11.2026