Mohinder Singh vs State Of Punjab And Anr.
- Court
- Punjab and Haryana High Court
1
CWP-9660-2016 (O&M) - -
102
IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA AT
CHANDIGARH
CWP-9660-2016 (O&M)
Date of Decision: 11.11.2026
MOHINDER SINGH
....Petitioner (s)
Versus
STATE OF PUNJAB AND ANOTHER
.....Respondent(s)
CORAM: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE JASGURPREET SINGH PURI
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE PRAVINDRA SINGH CHAUHAN
Present: Mr. S.S. Salar, Advocate,
for the petitioner.
Mr. Raghav Goel, AAG, Punjab.
Mr. Manbir Singh Batth, Advocate,
for respondent No.2.
JASGURPREET SINGH PURI, J. (Oral)
1. The present Civil Writ Petition has been filed under Articles
226/227 of the Constitution of India seeking issuance of a writ in the nature
of certiorari for quashing the orders dated 07.12.2015 (Annexure P-5),
31.05.2007 (Annexure P-3) and order/resolution dated 20.01.1992
(Annexure P-2), whereby plot No.11-G measuring 40 square yards situated
in 475 Acre Development Scheme (allotted under anti Sikh-Riots Quota) has
been cancelled without hearing and in a discriminatory manner and even
without issuing any notice to the petitioner.
2. The petitioner, namely, Mohinder Singh son of Sohan Singh is
admittedly a victim of the 1984 riots in Delhi.
RAKESH KUMAR
2026.11.19 16:57
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this
order/judgment.
2
CWP-9660-2016 (O&M) - -
3. Mr. S.S. Salar, learned counsel appearing on behalf of the
petitioner while giving the brief facts of the case submitted that the
petitioner and his family were residing in Delhi in the year 1984, when riots
took place in Delhi. However, the petitioner survived and subsequently
migrated to Punjab. For some time, the petitioner stayed in Punjab and
wanted to return to Delhi but he could not succeed in settling there and again
came back to Punjab. Thereafter, the State of Punjab came out with a Policy
for the welfare and rehabilitation of the Delhi riot victims. He submitted that
the petitioner has not attached the basic policy of the State of Punjab but in
pursuance of the aforesaid policy, the petitioner was allotted Plot No.11-G,
measuring 40 square yards vide allotment letter dated 12.08.1987 (Annexure
P-1) in Shaheed Bhagat Singh Nagar at the rate of Rs.88/- per square yard
under the Sikh Migrant Quota. Various terms and conditions were mentioned
in the aforesaid allotment letter, whereby the petitioner was required to
deposit an amount of Rs.3,520/- in lump sum within a period of 30 days
from the date of issuance of the allotment letter or to deposit Rs. 880/-, being
th
1/4 of the total price, within the same period of 30 days and the remaining
amount was to be paid in installments. Various other conditions regarding
the rate of interest on delayed payments were also mentioned in the
aforesaid allotment letter dated 12.08.1987 (Annexure P-1). Although the
aforesaid allotment amount was meagre but when the allotment was to be
made in the year 1987, the petitioner was suffering from extreme poverty
being a riot victim and had no means to pay even the aforesaid amount and
therefore, he defaulted in paying either the lump sum amount or the partial
th
amount of 1/4 of the total price as stipulated in the aforesaid allotment
RAKESH KUMAR
letter dated 12.08.1987 (Annexure P-1).
2026.11.19 16:57
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this
order/judgment.
3
CWP-9660-2016 (O&M) - -
4. He submitted that the petitioner tried his best to deposit the
amount but could not do so due to the aforesaid reasons. Thereafter, when
the petitioner managed to arrange some money, he requested the respondent-
Improvement Trust to accept the payment but his request was turned down
by the State Government on 31.05.2007 vide Annexure P-3 on the ground
that the allotment had already been cancelled. The allotment was cancelled
in the year 1992 by the Improvement Trust, Ludhiana vide impugned order
(Annexure P-2) on the ground of non-deposit of the amount as per the terms
and conditions stipulated in the allotment letter.
5. Considering the hardships faced by migrants and riot victims
from Delhi and other parts of India, the Government of Punjab had
introduced various policies as welfare and beneficial measures to provide
relief and benefits to the riot victims. One such Policy of the year 2015 has
been attached vide Annexure P-4 with the present writ petition, which was
issued by the Government of Punjab, Department of Local Government on
29.01.2015, although certain earlier policies were also issued. Learned
counsel submitted that under the aforesaid policy, the State of Punjab had
made a one-time offer to all those persons who had defaulted in payment and
whose plots had been resumed or cancelled, so that they could get their
previously allotted plots regularised. The aforesaid policy was publicized
widely so that maximum number of people could avail the benefits. He
submitted that as per the aforesaid policy and keeping in view the earlier
policies, the State of Punjab had decided to give a one-time offer to those
allottees of the properties of the respondent-Improvement Trust who had not
deposited the due amount till the date of issuance of the policy, even though
RAKESH KUMAR
2026.11.19 16:57
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this
order/judgment.
4
CWP-9660-2016 (O&M) - -
the period mentioned in the allotment letter had also expired. Such allottees
were given an opportunity to deposit all outstanding charges including
interest, penalty and deemed restoration charges and get their allotments
regularised.
6. Learned counsel submitted that in pursuance of the aforesaid
policy, the petitioner again requested the State to consider his request with
regard to restoration of the aforesaid plot but the same was declined by the
State of Punjab by way of the impugned order dated 24.11.2015 (Annexure
P-5) by the Secretary, Department of Local Government, Punjab. He
submitted that in the impugned order, it is noted that the petitioner had
stated all the relevant facts, including that he had earlier requested the
respondent-Improvement Trust to accept the amount due from him. Even
after the issuance of the policy, the petitioner had again requested the
respondent-Improvement Trust to accept the entire amount but vide letter
dated 05.03.2015, the respondent-Improvement Trust informed him that
since the Government vide order dated 31.05.2007 (Annexure P-3) had
already dismissed his application in default, his case could not be considered
under the policy. He submitted that it was incumbent upon the State
Government to have considered the request of the petitioner under the
aforesaid policy (Annexure P-4) in accordance with law and he could not
have been non-suited because of the reason that since earlier in the year
2007 i.e. 8 years before, his request was declined and therefore his
request now could not be considered was totally contrary to the policy and
the law.
7. Learned counsel further referred to the last paragraph of the
RAKESH KUMAR
aforesaid order (Annexure P-5), wherein the State Government rejected the
2026.11.19 16:57
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this
order/judgment.
5
CWP-9660-2016 (O&M) - -
claim of the petitioner on two counts. Firstly, that the petitioner did not
th
deposit 1/4 of the price, which was to be deposited compulsorily and there
was no provision to give concession at that stage and therefore, his case was
not covered under the policy dated 29.01.2015 (Annexure P-4) and secondly,
the appeal was filed after a delay of 23 years. He submitted that both the
aforesaid reasons given are totally arbitrary, illegal and against the policy
itself being unconstitutional and violative of Articles 14, 21 and 300-A of
the Constitution of India. He submitted that so far as the first reason is
th
concerned, the petitioner could not deposit 1/4 of the price because he did
not have money being a riot victim but that could not have become a ground
for non-suiting him as the policy was framed by the Government as a
beneficial policy to address such kind of defaults and no proper reason has
been assigned in the impugned order (Annexure P-5) as to why and under
what circumstances the case of the petitioner was not covered under the
aforesaid policy. He submitted that by just writing that the case of the
petitioner was not covered under the policy dated 29.01.2015 (Annexure P-
4) is no reason for non-suiting the petitioner. He submitted that rather several
other persons who had committed default in payment of the amount had
been granted the benefit vide Annexure P-10, whereas the petitioner had
been victimised twice. Firstly, during the Delhi riots and secondly, at the
time when his claim was rejected by the Government itself who came out
with a Policy for the welfare and rehabilitation of the Delhi riot victims.
8. So far as the second reason of delay is concerned, the same is
also misconceived and against the law. Petitioner had been requesting the
respondents from the very beginning after cancellation of plot but all in
RAKESH KUMAR
vain. Even otherwise also delay if any cannot be fatal in such like case
2026.11.19 16:57
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this
order/judgment.
6
CWP-9660-2016 (O&M) - -
where policy is a beneficial policy in these extraordinary circumstances to
grant benefit to riot victims.
9. He further submitted that the petitioner is ready and willing to
pay the necessary charges along with reasonable interest so that the aforesaid
plot can be allotted to him in accordance with law. The aforesaid plot
measuring 40 square yards, which was allotted to the petitioner vide
Annexure P-1, is still lying vacant and has not been allotted to anybody else
till date.
10. Learned counsel for the petitioner also referred to a judgment
passed by a Co-ordinate Bench of this Court in CWP No.1599 of 1994 ,
decided on 24.04.2014, wherein in somewhat similar circumstances, relief
was granted to the persons who were victims of the Delhi riots, although
relying upon a different policy. He submitted that in the said case also, the
claim had been rejected by the State Government but the Co-ordinate Bench
granted relief to the petitioners therein.
11. On the other hand, Mr. Raghav Goel, learned Assistant
Advocate General, Punjab submitted that on the request made by the
petitioner to the State Government, the impugned order dated 24.11.2015
(Annexure P-5) had been passed and since the case of the petitioner was
not covered by the aforesaid policy of the year 2015 (Annexure P-4), the
State Government has rightly rejected his claim because his claim
was earlier rejected in the year 2007 and the petitioner was not able to show
any provision under which such a concession could have been granted to
him.
12. Learned counsel appearing on behalf of the respondent-
RAKESH KUMAR
Improvement Trust submitted that the impugned order has been passed by
2026.11.19 16:57
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this
order/judgment.
7
CWP-9660-2016 (O&M) - -
the State Government and it was for the State Government to take a decision
in the matter, as any decision taken by the State Government would be
binding upon the respondent-Improvement Trust. He also submitted that
the plot which was allotted to the petitioner was cancelled in the year 1992,
which was communicated to the petitioner and there is a considerable delay
in filing of the present writ petition and since he has agitated his claim post
the cancellation after a considerable lapse of time, he is not entitled for the
grant of plot on the ground of delay.
13. We have heard the learned counsel for the parties at length.
14. It is an admitted position by all the learned counsel for the
parties that the petitioner is a victim of the 1984 Delhi riots. The State of
Punjab had issued various policies in the nature of welfare and beneficial
policies for helping the riot victims throughout India for the purpose of their
rehabilitation and well-being. In pursuance of the broad policies issued by
the State of Punjab, the petitioner was allotted the plot in the year 1987 vide
Annexure P-1 dated 12.08.1987. The aforesaid letter dated 12.08.1987
(Annexure P-1) is reproduced as under:-
“Annexure P-1
Office of Improvement Trust Ludhiana
Sh. Mohinder Singh s/o Sohan Singh
#706, LIG, Dugri, Housing Board Colony
Ludhiana
Memo No. LIT/SB/86/3714 Dt. 12-08-1987
Regarding Allotment of plot in 475 acre Sh. Bhagat Singh
Nagar Scheme in pursuance of the draw of lots held on
02.07.1986 out of Sikh migrant quota.
RAKESH KUMAR
2026.11.19 16:57
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this
order/judgment.
8
CWP-9660-2016 (O&M) - -
You are informed that on the captioned subject plot no. 11
measuring 40 square yards is allotted to you at the rate of
88 per square yard on the following terms and conditions.
The total cost of plot is Rs. 3520 to be deposited within 30
days from issuance of this letter. In case you wish to pay the
amount in installments. Then you should deposit Rs. 880
being ¼ price within thirty days failing which the allotment
can be cancelled. Rest 75% is payable in 7, 6 monthly
installments with 12 % interest as per schedule attached.
Corner plot would be charged 10% extra.
The total price of the plot is 3520. As per the instructions of
the Govt. you are being allotted this plot 20% less than the
reserve price.
In case you fail to deposit the installments as per scheduled
dates then the due installments shall be charged with 13%,
st nd rd th
14%, 15%, 16%, 17 and 18% interest for the 1 , 2 , 3 , 4 ,
th th
5 , 6 month respectively. After 6 months the deposited
amount shall be treated as forfeited and the plot can be
restored by charging 20% penalty and upto date interest.
The construction on the plot is to be carried out within three
years from the date of allotment to be carried out after
getting the building plan sanctioned and getting
demarcation.
This plot cannot be sold for 10 years from the date of
allotment. You shall submit this undertaking on stamp paper
of Rs. 3 attested by first class magistrate.
Rest of the contents are not translated being not relevant for
the decision of this writ.
In case the above conditions are acceptable then comply
with the formalities within the given period otherwise it
RAKESH KUMAR
2026.11.19 16:57
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this
order/judgment.
9
CWP-9660-2016 (O&M) - -
shall be presumed that you have not interest to purchase this
plot and the trust shall take further action as per rules.
Enclsd: 1. Schedule
2. Proforma Affidavit Sd/- Chairman”
15. As per the aforesaid letter, the petitioner was to deposit either
th
the entire amount of Rs. 3520/- or 1/4 of the total price and remaining
amount in installments but in both the cases, the amount was to be deposited
within a period of 30 days. The petitioner has specifically pleaded in the
petition that he was in a poor financial condition being a riot victim and
therefore, he could not deposit the amount. The State Government was very
well aware of the financial position of not only the petitioner but also of all
those riot victims and therefore, from time to time the State Government had
granted various benefits for the purpose of either paying of the installments
or for the restoration of the resumed/cancelled plots. It was in this backdrop
that one of the policies was issued in the year 2015 vide Annexure P-4. The
aforesaid policy dated 29.01.2015 (Annexure P-4) is reproduced as under:-
“Annexure P-4
Government of Punjab
Department of Local Government (LG-2 Branch)
To
1. Director Local Government Punjab, Chandigarh
2. All regional Deputy Directors Local Government
3. All Chairman/Executive Officers of All Town Improvement
Trusts of Punjab
Memo No. 11/5/2015(29)-2LG2/403010/1
Dated Chandigarh 29th January 2015
RAKESH KUMAR
2026.11.19 16:57
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this
order/judgment.
10
CWP-9660-2016 (O&M) - -
Subject: One time relaxation in the Instructions issued vide
memo no. 5/150/2013 (9)-4LG2/12452/1 dated 25.11.2013 to
ensure timely payment of installments of allotted properties
by the improvement trusts, in case of default its cancellation
and regarding appeals of such like resumed properties.
The government of Punjab vide letter 5/150/2013 (9)-
4LG2/12452/1 dated 25.11.2013 had issued consolidated
instructions in which the Improvement trusts were bound
down that the trust/executive officer shall be entitled to
receive the defaulted installments given in the schedule
attached to allotment letters only upto the time given in that
schedule, which was normally 3 years.
After that by issuing notice the improvement trust was to
resume the plot by completing the resumption proceedings
within 6 months, if even during that time the allottee does not
pay the entire money. To some extent these instructions were
complied with by the trusts. For this reason restoration
appeals were increased with the government. However even
now some cases are pending in which proceedings have not
been completed. In the meanwhile the government is
receiving representations from different quarters that the
public has made itself acquaintance of earlier policy and a
lot of allottees are ready to deposit the entire dues (along
with interest, penalty, restoration charges etc.)
Keeping in view the above circumstances, the government
has decided that the allottee of the properties of impartment
trust who have not deposited the due amount till today and
even the time given in the allotment letter has also expired,
one time offer be given to such allottees who have not
deposited all such charges including interest, penalty and
deemed restoration charges and get their allotment
regularized. It is made clear that the persons who do not
RAKESH KUMAR avail the one time opportunity, the concerned improvement
2026.11.19 16:57
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this
order/judgment.
11
CWP-9660-2016 (O&M) - -
trust shall be at liberty to take all proceedings against them
in accordance with law/rules/instructions.
The above said decisions of the government be published by
affixing it on the notice board of the trusts, public places and
through other communication methods. It be published in the
local newspapers also, so that maximum number of people
may avail this benefit. The chairman/executive officers of
different town improvement trust are further directed to set up
special counters in their offices so that the persons who wish
to avail the benefit, he may be informed in writing the due
amount on the same day or at the most on next working day.
Sd/- Special Secretary Local Government
Endorsement No. 11/5/2015(29)-2LG2/403010/1
Dated Chandigarh 29th January 2015”
16. A perusal of the aforesaid policy would show that reference has
been made to the earlier policies as well and thereafter, a conscious decision
was taken by the State Government that the allottees of the properties of the
Improvement Trust who had not deposited the due amount till the time of
the issuance of the policy and even though the period given in the allotment
letter has also expired, would be given a one-time offer to deposit all such
charges including interest, penalty and deemed restoration charges and get
their allotments regularized. A further perusal of the aforesaid policy would
show that in fact the Government took a conscious decision to publicise the
aforesaid policy so that maximum number of people could avail the benefits.
It was thereafter that a request was made by the petitioner to the State
Government to consider his claim under the aforesaid policy, wherein no
time frame was prescribed for making any such request, presumably because
RAKESH KUMAR
2026.11.19 16:57
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this
order/judgment.
12
CWP-9660-2016 (O&M) - -
the policy was in the nature of a welfare and beneficial policy. The
respondent-State of Punjab vide impugned order (Annexure P-5) rejected the
claim of the petitioner on two accounts, firstly, that the petitioner did not
th
deposit 1/4 of the price, which was to be deposited compulsorily and there
was no provision to give concession at that stage and therefore, his case was
not covered under the policy dated 29.01.2015 (Annexure P-4) and secondly,
on the ground of delay . A perusal of the last paragraph, which appears to be
the operative part of the order would show that the aforesaid are the two
reasons which have been assigned for rejecting the claim of the petitioner.
We are rather surprised to see as to how such a reason could become a
ground for rejection of the claim of the petitioner who is a riot victim who
faced displacement and financial hardships. Such beneficial policies were
introduced by the State of Punjab to address the very hardships faced by the
riot victims. However, the Secretary to the Government of Punjab,
Department of Local Government has non-suited the petitioner on the
ground that he had initially failed to deposit the amount within 30 days in
the year 1987. Such reasoning given by the Secretary, Department of Local
Government deserves to be rejected and rather deprecated by this Court. The
State Government by way of the impugned order has also noted that there
was no provision to give concession at that stage, whereas the concession
ought to have been considered against the policy of 2015. Therefore, such an
order is totally cryptic, besides being arbitrary and violative of the
provisions of the Constitution of India.
17. The first reason assigned in the impugned order is in our
considered view, wholly misconceived. The policy dated 29.01.2015
RAKESH KUMAR
(Annexure P-4) is addressed in terms to those allottees who had not
2026.11.19 16:57
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this
order/judgment.
13
CWP-9660-2016 (O&M) - -
deposited the due amount and in whose cases the period stipulated in the
allotment letter had also expired. Default was thus the very condition on
which the policy came to be operated and not a disqualification
thereunder and to reject a claim on the ground of default is to render the
policy nugatory. The petitioner who is a riot victim in extreme poverty
without the means to pay by reason of the very hardship for which the
State had undertaken rehabilitation should not be visited with the
consequence of non payment so as to be denied the benefit of a scheme
framed for persons so placed. Infact, the policy was widely publicised by the
State itself and such a representation to a class of persons give rise to a
legitimate expectation that their claims shall be considered fairly and on
merit by the State.
18. That impugned order also suffers because of arbitrariness and
non-application of mind by the Secretary to the Government of Punjab,
Department of Local Bodies. Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of
Association for Democratic Reforms v. Union of India, (2024) 5 SCC 1
while reaffirming law laid down in E.P. Royappa v. State of Tamil Nadu,
(1974) 4 SCC 3 observed that equality is antithetic to Arbitrariness. In fact
equality and arbitrariness are sworn enemies where one belongs to the rule
of law in a republic while the other, to the whim and caprice of an absolute
monarch and where an act is arbitrary it is implicit in it that it is unequal
both according to political logic and Constitutional Law and is therefore
violative of Article 14 of the Constitution of India and that the standard of
manifest arbitrariness applies to test any State action for lack of an adequate
determining principle, disproportionality or irrationality under Article 14 of
RAKESH KUMAR
the Constitution.
2026.11.19 16:57
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this
order/judgment.
14
CWP-9660-2016 (O&M) - -
19. So far as the second reason assigned by the Secretary to the
Government of Punjab, Department of Local Bodies is concerned, the same
is that the petitioner filed the representation after a lapse of 23 years.
However, it was the case of the petitioner that right from the beginning he
had been requesting and representing to the Improvement Trust as well as
the State of Punjab in this regard. The plot was cancelled in the year 1992
and thereafter, the policy was framed in the year 2015 in continuation of the
earlier policies. In such circumstances, the delay could not have become a
ground for non-suiting the petitioner. The reply which was filed by the
respondent-Improvement Trust also annexes some of the requests made by
the petitioner. Once the petitioner is admittedly a riot victim, the petitioner
could not have been non-suited on the ground of delay. Rather it was
incumbent upon the State Government to have called the petitioner and
considered his claim once it was within the knowledge of the State
Government that the petitioner is a riot victim, which is clear from the
allotment letter issued in the year 1987. This becomes clearer from the
policy itself (Annexure P-4), wherein it has been so stated that wide
publicity should be given to the policy so that people can avail benefits. We
are therefore of the considered view that it was obligatory upon the State
Government to have itself considered the claim of the petitioner in
accordance with law and that the petitioner could not have been non-suited
on the ground of delay as the same would run contrary to the very spirit of
the policies, which were framed as beneficial and welfare measures for the
riot victims.
20. It will also be important to note here that the State Government
RAKESH KUMAR
had rejected the claim of the petitioner on the basis of aforestated two
2026.11.19 16:57
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this
order/judgment.
15
CWP-9660-2016 (O&M) - -
reasons and not because the plot allotted to the petitioner had already been
cancelled. Even the policy issued by the State Government in 2015 does not
prohibit the restoration of a cancelled plot but the scope of the policy is very
broad to encompass all kinds of eventualities to help and benefit the riot
victims. No cogent reason was assigned in the impugned order as to how the
case of the petitioner was not covered under the policy.
21. The respondent-Improvement Trust, which allotted the plot and
subsequently cancelled the same, is no less than the State Government. A
perusal of para No.2 of the reply filed by the respondent-Improvement Trust
would show that a preliminary objection has been taken by the respondent-
Improvement Trust that the petitioner is estopped from creating a story
about his economic condition as he has not uttered a word of his bad
economic condition in the representation given to the respondent-
Improvement Trust. This Court believes that once the petitioner is
admittedly victim of the Delhi riot, it was not necessary for him to have
proved his bad economic condition and it would have rather been presumed
that being a riot victim he was not in a position to pay the amount for the
allotment of the plot. Even otherwise also, it is quite unnatural that a
person who is a riot victim and has been allotted a plot at a meagre rate
of Rs.3,520/- would not pay the amount and rather relinquish his rights over
the plot if his economic condition was good. The plea taken by the
respondent-Improvement Trust is not only illegal and irrational but
also unnatural. We also deprecate the respondent-Improvement Trust,
which is an instrumentality of the State to have taken such a preliminary
objection.
RAKESH KUMAR
2026.11.19 16:57
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this
order/judgment.
16
CWP-9660-2016 (O&M) - -
22. The respondent-Improvement Trust is a statutory body
discharging the public function of urban development and allotment of land
and it is an authority within the meaning of Article 12 of the Constitution of
India which is bound by the constitutional norms of fairness and non-
arbitrariness. The State and its instrumentalities cannot act arbitrarily and
every action must be informed by reason and public interest. The Right to
life and personal liberty guaranteed under Article 21 of the Constitution of
India also includes Right to shelter and the allotment of a plot to a riot victim
under the rehabilitation scheme is infact a measure intended to give effect to
this very right. The objection raised by the respondent-Improvement Trust
that the petitioner did not inform about his economic condition in his
representation is therefore untenable, since the fact of his being a riot victim
was admitted and law raises no demand for proof of what is evident from the
admitted facts.
23. The State in such like cases should not stand as an
ordinary litigant but should rather act while keeping in mind the principles
of the doctrine of parens patriae that the State is under an obligation to
act as the guardian of those citizens who by reason of extraordinary
calamity, displacement and deprivation are unable to protect their own
interests. Hon’ble Supreme Court in Charan Lal Sahu versus Union of
India (1990) 1 SCC 613 recognized the aforesaid doctrine as the obligation
of the State to protect and take into custody the rights and privileges of its
citizens for discharging its obligations. Moreover, our Constitution makes it
imperative for the State to secure to all its citizens the rights guaranteed by
the Constitution and where the citizens are not in a position to assert and
RAKESH KUMAR
secure their rights, the State must come into picture and protect and fight for
2026.11.19 16:57
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this
order/judgment.
17
CWP-9660-2016 (O&M) - -
the rights of the citizens. This obligation is reinforced by a latin maxim,
“ salus populi suprema lex esto ”, which means that the welfare of the people
shall be the supreme law. In another judgment of Hon’ble Supreme Court in
Chief Executive Officer and Vice Chairman Gujarat Maritime Board v.
Asiatic Steel Industries Ltd., 2022 (19) SCC 765 , while relying on its
earlier judgment in Dilbagh Rai Jarry v. Union of India, (1974) 3 SCC
554, held that the State is no ordinary party trying to win a case against one
of its own citizens by hook or by crook as the State's interest is to meet
honest claims, vindicate a substantial defence and never to score a technical
point or overreach a weaker party to avoid a just liability or secure an unfair
advantage, simply because legal devices provide such an opportunity.
24. The policies framed by the State of Punjab for the rehabilitation
of the 1984 riot victims are an expression of this very aforesaid obligation
and should therefore be construed liberally and in favour of the beneficiaries
and not in a narrow and hyper technical sense. This same obligation also
flows from the Directive Principles of State Policy, particularly Articles 38
and 39 which require the State to secure a social order that promotes the
welfare of the people and to ensure that the operation of the economic
system does not result in the concentration of hardship upon the weaker
sections.
25. Learned counsel for the petitioner has referred to a judgment
passed by a Co-ordinate Bench of this Court in CWP No.1599 of 1994,
decided on 24.04.2014 and we are of the considered view that barring a
distinction in the brief facts, the principles laid down in the aforesaid
judgment would apply to the present case as well. The relevant portion of
RAKESH KUMAR
the aforesaid judgment is reproduced as under:-
2026.11.19 16:57
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this
order/judgment.
18
CWP-9660-2016 (O&M) - -
“(16) The above-stated facts would speak in volume that the
petitioners cannot be blamed for dis-honouring the terms and
conditions of offer made to them. Once the State Government took
a policy decision to grant another opportunity to the riot victims
and the petitioners immediately availed such opportunity, they
shall be taken to have complied with the terms and conditions of
the allotment.
(17) The other factor, which has to be kept in view is that the
allotment was cancelled almost after two years of deposit of the
requisite amount by the petitioners. Similarly, the reason assigned
by the Additional Housing Commissioner in her D.O. dated
26.10.1993 (Annexure R-1) that the request of the petitioners for
extension of time was rejected, has indeed no bearing on the issue.
We say so for the reason that firstly the rejection of the requests
made by the petitioners was never conveyed. Secondly, even if it
was conveyed by the subordinate authorities, they were entitled to
yet another opportunity in terms of the government policy decision
taken in December, 1989. Thirdly, the petitioners were never given
such additional opportunity after the Government policy issued in
December 1989 nor they failed to avail the same.
(18) For the reasons afore-stated, we allow this writ petition and
quash the impugned orders dated 29.10.1993 (Annexures P-9 and
P-10 respectively). Resultantly, the petitioners (including legal
representatives of petitioner No. 2) shall be entitled to allotment of
shop-cum-flat sites and if the original sites bearing No. 29 and 45
have been meanwhile allotted to someone else, in that event they
shall be allotted the alternative sites. The petitioners shall be
liable to deposit the allotment price as was prevailing in the year
1987, however, alongwith interest at the rate 10% per annum. The
aforesaid order shall be subject to one more condition. If the
petitioners (including the legal representatives of petitioner No. 2)
have been meanwhile allotted any other commercial site at
concessional rate in the reserve category of 1984-riots affected
victims, in that event, they shall not be entitled to the benefit of
RAKESH KUMAR
this order. The respondents are directed to do the needful within a
2026.11.19 16:57
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this
order/judgment.
19
CWP-9660-2016 (O&M) - -
period of three months from the date of receipt of certified copy of
this order. “
26. We are therefore of the considered view that the impugned
order (Annexure P-5) is totally illegal, arbitrary as it fails on the touchstones
of reasonableness, natural justice and non-arbitrariness and violative of
Articles 14, 21 and 300-A of the Constitution of India. Consequently, the
present writ petition is allowed . The order of cancellation dated 20.01.1992
(Annexure P-2) and the order dated 24.11.2015 (Annexure P-5) are hereby
set aside.
27. We have been apprised by the learned counsel for the parties
that the plot allotted to the petitioner vide Annexure P-1, bearing Plot No.
11-G measuring 40 square yards , is still lying vacant and has not been
allotted to anybody else.
28. The fact that the aforesaid plot has been kept reserved despite
there being no interim order passed by this Court would itself indicate that
no other riot victim is seeking allotment of the said plot, particularly when
the plot has not been allotted to anybody else.
29. We therefore direct the respondent-Improvement Trust to
restore the aforesaid plot to the petitioner forthwith alongwith delivery of
possession thereof. The petitioner shall deposit the allotment price at the rate
prevailing in the year 1987, along with interest @ 10% per annum (simple),
within a period of 30 days from the date of the order passed by the
respondent-Improvement Trust regarding resumption of the plot. The
present order shall also be subject to one condition i.e. if the petitioner or his
legal representatives have been allotted any other plot/property at a
RAKESH KUMAR
2026.11.19 16:57
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this
order/judgment.
20
CWP-9660-2016 (O&M) - -
concessional rate under the reserved category of 1984 riot victim, then in
that event, he will not be entitled to the benefit of this order.
30. The respondent-Improvement Trust and the State Government
are directed to do the needful within a period of two months from today by
passing an order.
31. Considering the aforesaid facts and circumstances, we are also
of the view that the petitioner is also entitled to costs. The petitioner is
admittedly a victim of the 1984 riots, which took place almost 42 years ago
and was to be allotted a plot measuring merely 40 square yards. Therefore,
the petitioner shall be entitled to exemplary costs of Rs. 50,000/- (Rupees
Fifty Thousand only), out of which costs of Rs. 25,000/- (Rupees Twenty
Five Thousand only) shall be paid by the State of Punjab, Department of
Local Bodies and costs of Rs. 25,000/- (Rupees Twenty Five Thousand only)
shall be paid by the respondent-Improvement Trust, within a period of
two months from today by way of demand drafts in the name of the
petitioner.
32. Before parting with the judgment, we would also like to observe
that the State of Punjab as well as all the Improvement Trusts and other local
bodies, being instrumentalities of the State form part of a welfare State.
While passing orders, particularly in extraordinary cases involving persons
who have suffered under extraordinary circumstances, especially victims of
riots, the authorities are expected to exercise due care and diligence in
dealing with such cases and should not reject the claims of such riot victims
in a casual or routine manner. These persons who are riot victims deserve
not only sympathy and empathy but their rights under Article 21 of the
RAKESH KUMAR
Constitution of India also get severely impaired if caution and prudence is
2026.11.19 16:57
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this
order/judgment.
21
CWP-9660-2016 (O&M) - -
not adhered to and therefore, the State should be extremely careful in dealing
with such kind of cases.
33. A copy of this order be sent to the Chief Secretary of the
State of Punjab so that in future such cases are considered in a proper and
careful manner and not in a casual manner as has been done in the present
case.
34. Miscellaneous applications, if any, shall also stand disposed of
since the main case has been decided.
(JASGURPREET SINGH PURI)
JUDGE
(PRAVINDRA SINGH CHAUHAN)
JUDGE
11.11.2026
rakesh
Whether speaking : Yes/No
Whether reportable : Yes/No
RAKESH KUMAR
2026.11.19 16:57
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this
order/judgment.