Varun Atulya Mafatlal vs Shree Vallabh Chandak
- Court
- Bombay High Court
CNR No : HCBM020197852025
COMMP.27.2024.doc
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
ORDINARY ORIGINAL CIVIL JURISDICTION
IN ITS COMMERCIAL DIVISION
COMMERCIAL MISCELLANEOUS PETITION NO.27 OF 2024
WITH
INTERIM APPLICATION NO.3462 OF 2025
IN
COMMERCIAL MISCELLANEOUS PETITION NO.27 OF 2024
Varun Atulya Mafatlal ….Petitioner/Applicant
Versus
Shree Vallabh Chandak & Anr. ....Respondents
Mr. Verendra Tulzapurkar, Sr. Adv. a/w. Ashish Kamat, Sr. Adv.,
Abhineet Sharma & Ms Riya Gokalgandhi i/b. K.R. Parekh, Adv.
For Petitioner/Applicant.
Mr. Sharan Jagtiani, Senior Advocate a/w. Mr. Amit Jajoo, Priyank
Kapadia a/w. Amit J., Vedant Chhajed & Arjun Deshmukh i/b.
Trilegal, for Respondent No.1.
Mr. Nikhil Kumar Rungta a/w. Mr. Jayesh Ramgiri, for
Respondent No.2.
CORAM: SOMASEKHAR SUNDARESAN, J.
DATE : NOVEMBER 19, 2026
Page 1 of 49
November 19, 2026
Aarti Palkar
Digitally
signed by
AARTI
GAJANAN
PALKAR
Date:
2026.11.19
15:53:11
+0530
AARTI
GAJANAN
PALKAR
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 16:12:58
COMMP.27.2024.doc
JUDGEMENT:
Context and Factual Background:
1. This is a petition under Section 57 of the Trade Marks Act, 1999 (" TM
Act ") filed by Mr. Varun Atulya Mafatlal (" Varun ") invoking the rectification
jurisdiction of this Court. Varun seeks expungement of the entries in the
Register of Trade Marks (" Register ") in favour of Respondent No. 2, Malavika
Taktawala (" Malavika ") and Respondent No. 1, Shree Vallabh Chandak
(" Chandak ") in relation to the device marks of ‘SUNGRACE MAFATLAL’,
registered in Class 24 (No. 2081790) and Class 25 (No. 2177358) (together, the
" Marks "). The Registrar of Trade Marks (" Registrar ") is Respondent No. 3.
1. Varun’s Interim Application No. 3462 of 2025 (" Condonation IA ") seeks
condonation of 557 days' delay (as computed by Varun) in filing the Petition
without prejudice to Varun's stance that there is no delay in filing the Petition.
2. The factual matrix relevant to the case may be summarised thus:
A] Ms. Madhuri Mafatlal (" Madhuri ") applied for registration of the
Marks in 2011. The Class 24 application bears the date January 7, 2011
and the Class 25 application bears the date July 19, 2011;
Page 2 of 49
November 19, 2026
Aarti Palkar
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 16:12:58
COMMP.27.2024.doc
B] The certificates of registration, in her name, were sealed on May
5, 2017 (Class 24) and August 4, 2017 (Class 25), by which time Madhuri
was no more;
C] Madhuri died on July 15, 2013 and is said to have made a will on
1
February 6, 2012 (“ Madhuri Will ”). Her offspring includes two sons
Mr. Ajay Mafatlal (“ Ajay ” – prior to gender reassignment, Ms. Aparna
Mafatlal) and Mr. Atulya Mafatlal (“ Atulya ”). Ajay is said to have died
2
on August 22, 2015 and is said to have made a will on August 5, 2013
(“ Ajay Will ”). Neither the Madhuri Will nor the Ajay Will is probated or
even sought to be probated. Atulya died in September 2022. There is no
reference by any party to any will said to have been made by Atulya;
D] Varun is Atulya’s son. Madhuri also had three daughters –
Varun’s paternal aunts, namely, Malavika, Gayatri Jhaveri (“ Gayatri ”),
Ms. Kunti Shah (“ Kunti ”);
E] Malavika contends that Madhuri bequeathed the Marks to Ajay,
3
and Ajay bequeathed them to Malavika and Gayatri . On December 11,
2015, Malavika filed two Form TM-16 applications (“ 2015
Applications ”), under the Trade Marks Rules, 2002 (“ 2002 Rules ”)
seeking to be recorded as the subsequent proprietor of the Marks. At
1
Exhibit H of the Petition, Pages 102–105
2
Exhibit M of the Petition, Pages 150–153
3
Malavika’s Reply Affidavit, Paras 7.14 and 7.17, Pages 209–211
Page 3 of 49
November 19, 2026
Aarti Palkar
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 16:12:58
COMMP.27.2024.doc
this stage, Malavika would produce the Madhuri Will, the death
certificates and an undertaking from Gayatri dated December 7, 2015
(“ Gayatri Undertaking ”). By this time, Ajay was dead (August 2015) but
the Ajay Will would not be produced by Malavika, although the Gayatri
Undertaking would contain an explicit reference to the Ajay Will with
the date being left blank;
F] Neither side is able to indicate that any order was passed on the
2015 Applications. Effectively, these applications are still pending
adjudication on the docket of the Registrar;
G] On August 13, 2015, Suit No. 685 of 2016 (“ Suit 685 ”) was filed by
Malavika and Gayatri Jhaveri as Suit (L) No. 830 of 2015. Suit 685 is
still pending on the docket of this Court in relation to Ajay’s estate;
H] As stated above, the Marks were registered only on May 5, 2017
4
(Class 24) and August 4, 2017 (Class 25) . By this time, Madhuri, the
applicant, was dead (in July 2013) to the knowledge of the Registrar (by
5
the 2015 Applications filed in December 2015 );
6
I] On May 11, 2018, Malavika filed Form TM-P under the Trade
Marks Rules, 2017 (“ 2017 Rules ”, the successor to the 2002 Rules),
seeking transfer of the Marks to her name recognising her as the owner
4
Exhibit B to the Petition, Pages 65–67
5
Exhibits I and J to the Petition, Pages 106 and 116
6
Exhibit L to the Petition, Pages 132–133
Page 4 of 49
November 19, 2026
Aarti Palkar
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 16:12:58
COMMP.27.2024.doc
(“ 2018 Application ”). This time, Malavika produced a photo copy of the
7
Ajay Will ;
J] By an order dated July 5, 2018, Respondent No.3, the Registrar of
Trade Marks, Mumbai, (“ Registrar ”) recorded Malavika as the
subsequent proprietor, in disposal of the 2018 Application. No notice
was issued to any of the relatives. On the next day i.e. on July 6, 2018,
Malavika is said to have executed deeds of assignment by which she
assigned the Marks to Chandak for a sum of Rs. 9,00,000 for each of the
two Marks (“ Deeds of Assignment ”);
K] Chandak filed a Form TM-P (form for post-registration changes)
on July 12, 2018 (“ Chandak Application ”) seeking recognition of the
assignment to him. The Registrar recorded Chandak as the proprietor
of the Marks on September 17, 2018 on the strength of the Chandak
Application, the Deeds of Assignment and no-objection letters of
Malavika dated September 6, 2018;
L] Varun claims to have first learnt of Chandak's use of the Marks
only in August 2023 to discover the entries on a search of the Register,
well after Atulya died in September 2022. Varun affirmed this petition
on December 7, 2023 and filed it on December 13, 2023. The
7
Exhibit M to the Petition, Pages 150–153
Page 5 of 49
November 19, 2026
Aarti Palkar
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 16:12:58
COMMP.27.2024.doc
Condonation IA was filed only on July 2, 2025, after Chandak raised the
issue of limitation.
Contentions of the Parties:
3. Against this backdrop, I have heard at length, submissions by Dr. V.D.
Tulzapurkar and Mr. Ashish Kamat, Learned Senior Advocates on behalf of
Varun and Mr. Sharan Jagtiani, Learned Senior Advocate on behalf of
Chandak and Mr. Nikhil Rungta, Learned Advocate on behalf of Malavika.
With their assistance, I have reviewed the material on record. The Registrar
has chosen not to enter appearance or even file any pleadings.
4. Varun seeks rectification by deletion of the entries in favour of Malavika
and Chandak from the Register under Section 57 of the TM Act. He seeks that
upon rectification, Madhuri should be shown as proprietor of the Marks. He
also seeks an interim injunction against Chandak's use of the Marks. Chandak
submits that the Petition is hopelessly barred by limitation, and the reliance
on the purported weight of merits cannot cure limitation. He would submit
that limitation must be dealt with first before delving into merits.
5. In a nutshell, Varun’s key contentions are:
A] Varun is a “person aggrieved”, being Madhuri’s grandson and the
Mafatlal family name being his family legacy. Chandak was a mere
Page 6 of 49
November 19, 2026
Aarti Palkar
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 16:12:58
COMMP.27.2024.doc
licensee of the family who has usurped the Marks in a clandestine
operation. Varun contends that there was an oral family settlement by
which it was agreed that the Marks could only be used by members of
Madhuri’s family and their descendants and they could not be alienated
to anyone outside the family;
B] There is no delay. The right to apply under Section 57 of the TM
Act is distinct from a right to sue. Time under Article 137 of the
Schedule to the Limitation Act, 1963 (“ Limitation Act ”) runs only from
the date the right to apply accrues. Section 17 of the Limitation Act
would apply because fraud and concealment are writ large and only
upon discovery of the fraud can limitation start to run – that would
occur only in August 2023, when Varun learnt of the entries;
C] The transmission of title to the Marks rests on un-probated and
uncertified Wills. The pendency of Suit 685 too is suppressed from the
Registrar. No notice went to the heirs. There is no duty on any person to
keep vigil and monitor the Register;
D] Effectively, the Marks have been first registered in the name of a
dead person. Further movement of title to that registration has been
registered without following due process under the TM Rules. Rule 75
allows only the person “entitled” to the mark to apply for transmission
Page 7 of 49
November 19, 2026
Aarti Palkar
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 16:12:58
COMMP.27.2024.doc
or assignment. Respondents were never “entitled” to the subject marks.
Rule 76 of the 2017 Rules required a duly certified copy of the original
instrument, and this was clearly not even sought by the Registrar. This
has allegedly vitiated the integrity of the Register;
E] Section 213 of the Indian Succession Act, 1925 (“ Succession Act ”)
bars recognition of rights under an un-probated Will. The notarisation
of the Wills relied on in this case, is no proof. The executors did not
assent as required under Sections 211, 307, 332 and 333 of the
Succession Act. Besides, Madhuri's Will does not cover the Class 25
Mark. Rule 55 of the 2017 Rules is mandatory and was not followed,
since the Marks were registered in the name of a person who had died;
F] Integrity of the Register is a foundational principle under the TM
Act. Not only was there no compliance with due process but also there
is an evident lack of any speaking order to effect the registration or to
effect the transfer of registration by the Registrar. The Registrar acted
without notice, without a speaking order, and without inquiry into
doubts. The Registrar's conduct warrants this Court’s intervention.
6. Chandak’s core contentions may be summarised thus:
Page 8 of 49
November 19, 2026
Aarti Palkar
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 16:12:58
COMMP.27.2024.doc
A] The Condonation IA must be decided first – the purported
strength of merits is irrelevant when no sufficient cause to condone the
delay is shown;
B] Under Article 137 of the Schedule to the Limitation Act, the right
to apply accrued when the entry was made in Chandak’s name in
September 17, 2018. The registration of the assignment is constructive
notice to the world at large. In any case, Varun, as a successor of Atulya,
inherits the clock of limitation of his predecessor, who did not act
throughout his lifetime;
C] For Section 17 of the Limitation Act to apply, Varun is required to
have exercised reasonable diligence. Sufficient cause is to be read
strictly in commercial matters. Varun is actually a proxy for Mafatlal
Industries Ltd. (“ Mafatlal Industries ”), a company belonging to the
Arvind Mafatlal branch of the family, which is not even connected to the
Yogindra Mafatlal branch to which Atulya belonged. The attorneys of
Mafatlal Industries issued a legal notice to Chandak about the use of the
Marks way back on February 26m, 2015, and it is they who have
conducted the search in the Register, and have launched these
proceedings, using Varun as a proxy. Acquiescence and waiver on the
part of Mafatlal Industries, and thereby Varun, bars relief; and
Page 9 of 49
November 19, 2026
Aarti Palkar
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 16:12:58
COMMP.27.2024.doc
D] Section 213 of the Succession Act bars reliance on an un-probated
Will only before a court, which the Registrar is not. Rule 55 of the 2017
Rules is directory and not mandatory. Under Section 45 of the TM Act
and Rule 77, the Registrar may seek further proof only when reasonable
doubt has arisen. Under Section 23 of the TM Act, the effect of the
registration relates back to the date of the filing. Chandak is a bona fide
assignee for value and there is nothing untoward to warrant this Court’s
interference.
7. Malavika’s contentions may be summarised as follows:
A] Malavika held a bona fide belief of title under the Wills. There was
no concealment;
B] The Registrar knew of the deaths and there can be no claim of
concealment. Rule 55 of the 2017 Rules is fully complied with; and
C] Assent of executors of the Wills can be inferred under Sections
333 to 336 of the Succession Act. Gayatri, the executor of the Madhuri
Will had recognised Malavika’s interest; and
D] Malavika has not been and is not involved in any business and she
was guided by Chandak and one Mr. Subhash Choksi (“ Choksi ”), a
Page 10 of 49
November 19, 2026
Aarti Palkar
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 16:12:58
COMMP.27.2024.doc
broker through whom royalties had been contracted with Chandak for
use of the Marks.
Points for Determination:
8. The points that arise for determination based on submissions by the
parties may be summarised thus:
A] Whether Varun is a "person aggrieved";
B] Whether there has been a delay in filing the captioned Petition
and if so, whether such delay may be condoned; whether the right to
apply accrued on the entries being made in July 2018 (Malavika) and
September 2018 (Chandak) or on Varun's purported knowledge in
August 2023, with Varun claiming through a predecessor who did not
act throughout his lifetime; whether fraud, suppression and want of
diligence affect the computation of the period of limitation; whether the
integrity of the Register has a bearing on sufficient cause for the delay;
and whether Varun’s efforts to rectify the Register can be entertained;
C] Whether the entries of May and August 2017 (in the name of
Madhuri); the entry on July 5, 2018 (in the name of Malavika) and the
entry on September 17, 2018 (in the name of Chandak) in the Register,
were made without due process being followed; and
Page 11 of 49
November 19, 2026
Aarti Palkar
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 16:12:58
COMMP.27.2024.doc
D] Whether, a case has been made out from the material on record
for this Court to initiate a suo motu process under Section 57(4) of the
TM Act.
Analysis and Findings:
9. At the threshold, Section 57 of the TM Act bears reproduction:
"57. Power to cancel or vary registration and to rectify the register.—
(1) On application made in the prescribed manner to the High Court or to the
Registrar by any person aggrieved, the Register or the High Court, as the case may
be, may make such order as it may think fit for cancelling or varying the registration
of a trade mark on the ground of any contravention, or failure to observe a condition
entered on the register in relation thereto.
(2) Any person aggrieved by the absence or omission from the register of any
entry, or by any entry made in the register without sufficient cause, or by any entry
wrongly remaining on the register, or by any error or defect in any entry in the
register, may apply in the prescribed manner to the High Court or to the Registrar,
and the Register or the High Court, as the case may be, may make such order for
making, expunging or varying the entry as it may think fit.
(3) The Register or the High Court, as the case may be, may in any proceeding
under this section decide any question that may be necessary or expedient to decide in
connection with the rectification of the register.
(4) The Register or the High Court, as the case may be, of its own motion, may,
after giving notice in the prescribed manner to the parties concerned and after giving
them an opportunity of being heard, make any order referred to in sub-section (1) or
sub-section (2).
Page 12 of 49
November 19, 2026
Aarti Palkar
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 16:12:58
COMMP.27.2024.doc
(5) Any order of the High Court rectifying the register shall direct that notice of
the rectification shall be served upon the Registrar in the prescribed manner who
shall upon receipt of such notice rectify the register accordingly."
[Emphasis Supplied]
10. A plain reading of the foregoing would indicate that if this Court comes
to a finding that if Varun is a person aggrieved and has validly demonstrated a
contravention in the making of the entries in the Register recognising
Malavika first and Chandak subsequently, Section 57 entails the jurisdiction to
rectify such contravening entry from the Register by expunging it. That apart,
the Court has suo motu powers under Section 57(4) to make any order in the
rectification jurisdiction, of course after issuing notice and giving an
opportunity of being heard. Bearing this in mind, the points for determination
set out above need to be dealt with.
Person Aggrieved:
11. Varun is from the Mafatlal family – the grandson of Madhuri, the
original applicant for registration of the Marks. Indeed, Varun claims in the
Petition that there was a purported oral family arrangement that entailed
Madhuri applying for registration of the Marks, as also a prohibition on an
assignment of the Marks to any third party not belonging to the Mafatlal
family. While that may be a matter of evidence and would need to be tested,
Page 13 of 49
November 19, 2026
Aarti Palkar
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 16:12:58
COMMP.27.2024.doc
on the face of the record, it cannot be said that Varun is a completely
unconnected person to the original applicant for registration.
12. It is well settled that the term “person aggrieved” must be liberally
construed and if an interest in the Marks can be perceived, the Court should
lean more in favour of hearing the grievance rather than shutting out the
person contending to be aggrieved. Whether the grievance has been slept over
for too long or whether other material would indicate that the grievance need
not lead to any intervention is a matter of merits that can be considered, but
after considering whether the person claiming to be aggrieved has the ‘ locus ’
to hold a grievance.
13. The issue about whether Varun can pursue a cause of action that his
father, Atulya did not pursue during his lifetime, is not one of whether Varun
is a person aggrieved but one of limitation, delay and laches. Suffice it to say,
without prolix reproduction from a plethora of case law cited in this regard, I
would hold Varun to be a person with locus , who would be entitled to have a
8
grievance about the Marks, based on the law declared in Hardie Trading ,
8
Hardie Trading Ltd. & Anr. v. Addisons Paint & Chemicals Ltd., (2003) 11 SCC 92,
Paragraphs 30 to 34.
Page 14 of 49
November 19, 2026
Aarti Palkar
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 16:12:58
COMMP.27.2024.doc
9 10 11
Infosys , VR Holdings and Toshiba articulating principles for determination
of a “person aggrieved” in the context of Section 56 of the Trade and
Merchandise Marks Act, 1958 and Section 57 of the TM Act.
14. Considering Varun’s membership of the Mafatlal family is not in
dispute, in the facts of this case, I see no reason to hold Varun as not having
locus as a person aggrieved. Had Varun been a rank outsider or some sort of
an interloper or purported to be an informant, without nothing to indicate an
interest in the subject matter of the Petition, there would have been a need to
elaborate further on this facet. That not being the case, and considering
Varun’s membership of the Mafatlal family, and the Marks being founded on
the Mafatlal surname, in my view, it would be appropriate hold in favour of
Varun being a person aggrieved and to move on to the core issue of whether
his grievances warrant intervention by this Court.
Delay, Limitation, Acquiescence, Waiver and Bona Fides:
15. Varun’s father Atulya, who was the original applicant and Madhuri’s
son, died in September 2022. The registration of the Marks in Madhuri’s
9
Infosys Technologies Ltd. v. Jupiter Infosys Ltd. & Anr., (2011) 1 SCC 125, Paragraphs 30
and 31.
10
V.R. Holdings v. Hero Investcorp Ltd. & Anr., 2023 SCC OnLine Del 1380, Paragraphs 62,
63 and 83 to 85.
11
Kabushiki Kaisha Toshiba v. Tosiba Appliances Co. & Ors., (2008) 10 SCC 766,
Paragraph 50.
Page 15 of 49
November 19, 2026
Aarti Palkar
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 16:12:58
COMMP.27.2024.doc
name took place in May and August 2017. Thereafter, the recognition of
Malavika as the successor to the Marks and recognition of assignment of the
Marks to Chandak by Malavika, all took place in the span of July and
September 2018. The record shows that Madhuri’s offspring were engaged in
inter se litigation – Atulya and Ajay facing off, and upon Ajay requiring
intensive healthcare, Gayatri and Malavika suing Atulya and Kunti to
safeguard Ajay’s interests.
16. In parallel, the registration of the Marks was finally effected on
Madhuri’s application after she passed away without a formal substitution of
the applicant. In other words, in 2017, the Registrar granted registration to a
person who had been dead for nearly four years, despite having had notice of
Madhuri’s death in 2015. Curiously, by the time the Registrar was informed
about Madhuri being no more (in December 2015), Ajay too was dead (in
August 2015). In December 2015, Malavika would produce the Madhuri Will
before the Registrar along with the Gayatri Undertaking but not the Ajay Will,
although she contends that she found both the Wills in the papers that
Chandak and Chokshi had given her, after Ajay’s demise. The Gayatri
Undertaking refers to a Will of Ajay under which he bequeathed his properties
to Malavika and Gayatri in equal portions, but inexplicably leaves blank, the
date of that will.
Page 16 of 49
November 19, 2026
Aarti Palkar
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 16:12:58
COMMP.27.2024.doc
17. Now, the record clearly indicates that dissensions were rife in the
Mafatlal family during this period with Atulya too being in the midst of
multiple litigation proceedings with his siblings. If there had been an oral
family settlement not only to have Madhuri apply for registration of the Marks
and also that the Marks could not be alienated in favour of third parties, it
would stand to reason that litigious siblings would have been vigilant about
this property. Suit 685 makes no mention of the Marks and focuses on
moveable assets kept in the second floor of the Mafatlal Bungalow occupied by
Ajay before being moved to hospital. There is not a whisper of litigation by
Atulya about the Marks during his lifetime – he would expire only in
September 2022.
18. The material on record also shows that Mafatlal Industries issued a legal
notice dated February 26, 2015 to Chandak about the usage of the Marks by
Chandak. This was replied to on March 5, 2015 on Chandak’s behalf by the
same attorneys who filed the 2015 Applications in Form TM-16 on behalf of
Malavika. The material on record shows multiple license agreements between
entities under the control of Madhuri’s offspring and entities under Chandak’s
ownership and control between 1998 and 2020 (nearly 21 license agreements)
under which Chandak had been given the license to use the Marks for the
specific extent of manufacture of fabric length.
Page 17 of 49
November 19, 2026
Aarti Palkar
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 16:12:58
COMMP.27.2024.doc
19. Considering that Madhuri’s offspring were intensely fighting one
another and the Arvind Mafatlal branch of the family (Mafatlal Industries),
which was aggrieved by Chandak’s usage of the marks lived in the same
Mafatlal Bungalow, it would also stand to reason that Atulya could not have
been unaware of Chandak’s role and his sibling earning royalty from them. In
much the same way Varun claims to have learnt from the Arvind Mafatlal
family about the Marks being in Chandak’s name in August 2023, it is more
unbelievable than believable that Atulya would not have known all the way
until September 2022.
20. Against that backdrop, when one examines Varun’s claims being
founded on his being Atulya’s son, the fact that Atulya did not think it fit to
perceive a cause of action to litigate about the Marks during his lifetime cannot
be wished away lightly. Atulya would pass away four years after the transfer of
the Marks to Chandak, without initiating any litigation. This begs the question
as to whether Varun, who essentially claims through Atulya and thereby
through Madhuri can now contend that he has a right to seek rectification
upon purportedly obtaining knowledge that his father interests have suffered.
That Madhuri and Atulya were estranged as a matter of public record, which is
brought to bear into the material on record, is a separate matter altogether.
Page 18 of 49
November 19, 2026
Aarti Palkar
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 16:12:58
COMMP.27.2024.doc
21. Whether Varun can purport that there is no delay because he only got to
know in August 2023 (at a family event from the Arvind Mafatlal family) that
the Marks, bearing the Mafatlal family name is actually standing in the name
of Chandak, and that he promptly filed this Petition, is the point to consider.
Chandak has produced the public record of the inspection in 2023 conducted
by Mafatlal Industries by the same attorneys. If Varun’s stance is to be
accepted, every successive generation can claim to have obtained knowledge
for the first time about what transpired during the lifetime of the earlier
generation through which a claim is made, and yet contend that there is no
delay in pursuit of the cause of action not pursued by that earlier generation.
22. On first principles, this is difficult to accept. Atulya is not alive today for
his state of mind to be tested. Suit 685 having been filed by Malavika and
Gayatri against Atulya (it is pending on the docket of this Court even today);
Atulya and Ajay having been embroiled in litigation; Atulya and Madhuri too
having had serious disputes, it would only be reasonable to conclude that
developments in the publicly accessible and searchable Register ought to have
been to Atulya’s knowledge. At the least, it would be reasonable to hold him to
have had constructive notice of developments in a public register. No action
having been taken for that long, it is not easy to accept Varun’s simplistic
Page 19 of 49
November 19, 2026
Aarti Palkar
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 16:12:58
COMMP.27.2024.doc
contention that he got to know in 2023 and the period of delay should only be
counted from his purported knowledge.
23. The provisions of the Limitation Act, 1963 (“ Limitation Act ”), addressed
by each of the parties, bears analysis. Section 2 of the Limitation Act defines
an “applicant” and an “application”, and the “period of limitation”. It provides
as follows:
"2. Definitions.—
In this Act, unless the context otherwise requires,—
(a) “applicant” includes—
(i) a petitioner;
(ii) any person from or through whom an applicant derives his right to
apply;
(iii) any person whose estate is represented by the applicant as executor,
administrator or other representative;
(b) “application” includes a petition;
(j) “period of limitation” means the period of limitation prescribed for any suit,
appeal or application by the Schedule, and “prescribed period” means the period of
limitation computed in accordance with the provisions of this Act;"
[Emphasis Supplied]
24. On the face of the aforesaid provisions, a rectification application in the
form of this Petition would be an “application” while the Petitioner would be
an “applicant” for purposes of the Limitation Act. The period of limitation
Page 20 of 49
November 19, 2026
Aarti Palkar
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 16:12:58
COMMP.27.2024.doc
stipulated in the Limitation Act and the prescribed period would prima facie
apply.
25. Section 3 of the Limitation Act bars an application made after the
prescribed period. Section 5 of the Limitation Act permits admission of an
application after the prescribed period on sufficient cause. Section 9 of the
Limitation Act deals with continuous running of time while Section 16 deals
with the death of a person before the right to apply accrues. Section 17 of the
Limitation Act deals with the effect of fraud or mistake in computing the
period of limitation. These provisions are extracted below:
"3. Bar of limitation.—
(1) Subject to the provisions contained in sections 4 to 24 (inclusive), every suit
instituted, appeal preferred, and application made after the prescribed period shall be
dismissed, although limitation has not been set up as a defence.
(2) For the purposes of this Act,—
(a) a suit is instituted,—
(i) in an ordinary case, when the plaint is presented to the proper
officer;
(ii) in the case of a pauper, when his application for leave to sue as
a pauper is made; and
(iii) in the case of a claim against a company which is being wound
up by the court, when the claimant first sends in his claim to the
official liquidator;
Page 21 of 49
November 19, 2026
Aarti Palkar
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 16:12:58
COMMP.27.2024.doc
(b) any claim by way of a set off or a counter claim, shall be treated as a
separate suit and shall be deemed to have been instituted—
(i) in the case of a set off, on the same date as the suit in which the
set off is pleaded;
(ii) in the case of a counter claim, on the date on which the counter
claim is made in court;
(c) an application by notice of motion in a High Court is made when the
application is presented to the proper officer of that court."
[Emphasis Supplied]
"5. Extension of prescribed period in certain cases.—
Any appeal or any application, other than an application under any of the provisions
of Order XXI of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (5 of 1908), may be admitted after
the prescribed period if the appellant or the applicant satisfies the court that he had
sufficient cause for not preferring the appeal or making the application within such
period.
Explanation.—The fact that the appellant or the applicant was missed by any order,
practice or judgment of the High Court in ascertaining or computing the prescribed
period may be sufficient cause within the meaning of this section."
[Emphasis Supplied]
"9. Continuous running of time.—
Where once time has begun to run, no subsequent disability or inability to institute a
suit or make an application stops it:
Provided that, where letters of administration to the estate of a creditor have been
granted to his debtor, the running of the period of limitation for a suit to recover the
debt shall be suspended while the administration continues."
[Emphasis Supplied]
Page 22 of 49
November 19, 2026
Aarti Palkar
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 16:12:58
COMMP.27.2024.doc
"16. Effect of death on or before the accrual of the right to sue.—
(1) Where a person who would, if he were living, have a right to institute a suit or
make an application dies before the right accrues, or where a right to institute a suit
or make an application accrues only on the death of a person, the period of limitation
shall be computed from the time when there is a legal representative of the deceased
capable of instituting such suit or making such application.
(2) Where a person against whom, if he were living, a right to institute a suit or
make an application would have accrued dies before the right accrues, or where a
right to institute a suit or make an application against any person accrues on the
death of such person, the period of limitation shall be computed from the time when
there is a legal representative of the deceased against whom the plaintiff may institute
such suit or make such application.
(3) Nothing in sub-section (1) or sub-section (2) applies to suits to enforce rights
of pre-emption or to suits for the possession of immovable property or of a hereditary
office."
[Emphasis Supplied]
"17. Effect of fraud or mistake.—
(1) Where, in the case of any suit or application for which a period of limitation is
prescribed by this Act,—
(a) the suit or application is based upon the fraud of the defendant or
respondent or his agent; or
(b) the knowledge of the right or title on which a suit or application is
founded is concealed by the fraud of any such person as aforesaid; or
(c) the suit or application is for relief from the consequences of a mistake;
or
Page 23 of 49
November 19, 2026
Aarti Palkar
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 16:12:58
COMMP.27.2024.doc
(d) where any document necessary to establish the right of the plaintiff or
applicant has been fraudulently concealed from him,
the period of limitation shall not begin to run until the plaintiff or applicant has
discovered the fraud or the mistake or could, with reasonable diligence, have
discovered it; or in the case of a concealed document, until the plaintiff or the
applicant first had the means of producing the concealed document or compelling its
production:
Provided that nothing in this section shall enable any suit to be instituted or
application to be made to recover or enforce any charge against, or set aside any
transaction affecting, any property which—
(i) in the case of fraud, has been purchased for valuable consideration by a
person who was not a party to the fraud and did not at the time of the purchase know,
or have reason to believe, that any fraud had been committed, or
(ii) in the case of mistake, has been purchased for valuable consideration
subsequently to the transaction in which the mistake was made, by a person who did
not know, or have reason to believe, that the mistake had been made, or
(iii) in the case of a concealed document, has been purchased for valuable
consideration by a person who was not a party to the concealment and, did not at the
time of purchase know, or have reason to believe, that the document had been
concealed.
(2) Where a judgment-debtor has, by fraud or force, prevented the execution of a
decree or order within the period of limitation, the court may, on the application of
the judgment-creditor made after the expiry of the said period extend the period for
execution of the decree or order:
Provided that such application is made within one year from the date of the discovery
of the fraud or the cessation of force, as the case may be."
[Emphasis Supplied]
Page 24 of 49
November 19, 2026
Aarti Palkar
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 16:12:58
COMMP.27.2024.doc
26. It will be seen that Section 3 prohibits entertaining any application after
the prescribed period regardless of whether limitation is taken up as a defence.
On the other hand, Section 5 (to which Section 3 is subject) permits
entertaining an application after the prescribed period if the applicant satisfies
the Court that there was sufficient cause for not preferring the application
within such prescribed period. Under Section 9, when the period of limitation
starts to run, a subsequent disability or inability to institute an application
would not stop the march of limitation.
27. Section 16 deals with the effect of death of a person who would have
earned a right to sue had he been alive – the period of limitation would be
computed only when there is a legal representative of the deceased who is
capable of making the application. In other words, if the person who would
have had a right to apply dies, the limitation period would be counted only
from the time the legal representative becomes available. Likewise, when a
person who could be sued pursuant to a cause of action dies, the period would
be counted only after the legal representative is available to be sued.
28. Finally, where an application is based upon fraud by the respondent, or
the knowledge of the right or title on which the application is founded is
concealed by fraud, or any document necessary to establish such right is
Page 25 of 49
November 19, 2026
Aarti Palkar
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 16:12:58
COMMP.27.2024.doc
fraudulently concealed, the period of limitation would begin to run only after
the fraud is discovered or could have been discovered with reasonable
diligence. In the case of a fraudulently concealed document, the time would
run from the time the applicant had the means of producing the concealed
document or compelling its production. Section 17 also protects a third party
from any proceedings to set aside any transaction affecting any property
purchased for valuable consideration without knowledge or reason to believe
that fraud was committed. Similarly, a person who did not have knowledge of
concealment of a document or was not party to the concealment is protected.
29. Varun’s rectification application is founded on the purported oral family
arrangement being violated by a transfer to a third party. What is noteworthy
is that Varun has pleaded that the Mafatlal Group’s original founder Mafatlal
Gagalbhai died in 1964 and the group split into three in 1979 – each headed by
one grandson. The matter in hand concerns the group under Mr. Yogindra
Mafatlal, also called the Sungrace Mafatlal Group. Mr. Yogindra Mafatlal died
in 2005 and his spouse Madhuri and her offspring are said to have run the
businesses of that group. Yet, the application to register the Marks would only
be made in 2011 by Madhuri, six years after the demise of Mr. Yogindra
Mafatlal. By this time, Varun would have been about 22 years of age, but he
Page 26 of 49
November 19, 2026
Aarti Palkar
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 16:12:58
COMMP.27.2024.doc
has not pleaded that he was party to the family settlement but certainly he has
pleaded that Atulya was a party to it.
30. What this means is that Varun’s right to apply for rectification is derived
from his being Atulya’s son. His right cannot be higher than what Atulya
enjoyed during his lifetime. As stated above, Atulya and his siblings were
embroiled in litigation about succession to the assets of the Yogindra Mafatlal
Group and they would have been expected to have been vigilant about their
interests. The registration in Madhuri’s favour came about during Atulya’s
lifetime even if after Madhuri’s death. The Madhuri Will purports to have
bequeathed the Class 24 Mark to Ajay and is silent about the Class 25 Mark.
The Ajay Will purports to have bequeathed Ajay’s properties to Gayatri and
Malavika. Gayatri is said to have relinquished her interest, and on the
strength of these instruments, Malavika came to be recorded as the registrant
in July 2018 and her assignment of the Marks to Chandak led to his being the
registrant in September 2018. These are the two registrations that Varun
assails, seeking to reinstate the registration to Madhuri’s name.
31. Varun claims through Atulya and all the aforesaid events occurred
during Atulya’s lifetime without Atulya having taken any action to assert any
right over the Marks. In my opinion, the cause of action inherited by Varun
Page 27 of 49
November 19, 2026
Aarti Palkar
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 16:12:58
COMMP.27.2024.doc
would bring with it the attendant shortcomings and erosions it has already
suffered during Atulya’s lifetime. Every time the next generation purports to
have inherited a cause of action, it would not be open and permissible to start
from scratch on the premise that the generation that has decided to litigate
was personally unaware of certain facts and that the clock would be reset for
that generation.
32. Varun’s contention today is that the Madhuri Will and the Ajay Will are
inherently fraudulent since neither is mentioned in Suit 685 and on the basis
of the infirmities pointed out in reliance placed upon these Wills in Malavika’s
engagement with the Registrar. The cause of action pursued today is therefore
purported to be founded on the fraud alleged on her part along with Chandak.
Against this backdrop, one has to also be mindful that Atulya is not around
today to explain his silence during his lifetime. One can neither presume that
he consciously chose to remain quiet nor that he was unaware. What one can
reasonably infer is that men of commerce, purporting to defend a family legacy
by preservation of the Marks, were engaged in litigation against one another
over claims to that very legacy.
33. It is in context that Atulya would necessarily be expected to have
exercised diligence to keep himself abreast with developments over the Marks,
Page 28 of 49
November 19, 2026
Aarti Palkar
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 16:12:58
COMMP.27.2024.doc
their registration in Madhuri’s name, recognition of Malavika’s ownership and
thereafter to Chandak. At the least, in his capacity as a party to the purported
oral family settlement, Atulya would have been expected to have exercised
reasonable diligence over the Register of Trade Marks. When Madhuri died,
the family members were actively litigating against one another. Therefore,
taking the contentions about the Madhuri Will and the Ajay Will and the Deed
of Assignment at the highest i.e. that they were all instrumentalities of fraud,
in my opinion, one of the core elements of Section 17 of the Limitation Act,
namely, that Atulya, with reasonable diligence, could have discovered it, would
have to be given weightage. Atulya passed away in September 2022 and Varun
has filed this Petition in December 2023, contending that he got to know
about these instruments in August 2023. This contention cannot be lightly
accepted to wipe out the limitation period already undergone in Atulya’s
hands, through whom Varun claims. One cannot place Varun on a higher
pedestal than Atulya and permit ever-greening of limitation with every
succeeding generation.
34. Indeed, the record also shows that Mafatlal Industries issued a legal
notice to Chandak in 2015, aggrieved as a member of the wider Mafatlal
Family, by his usage of the Marks which was said to injure their interests.
Having been told by Chandak that he has legitimate licenses granted by
Page 29 of 49
November 19, 2026
Aarti Palkar
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 16:12:58
COMMP.27.2024.doc
Yogindra Mafatlal family, one would have expected Mafatlal Industries too to
have kept vigil over the movement of record of title in the Register of Trade
Marks. It would only be reasonable to expect that a branch that separated way
back in the 1970s and is aggrieved by use of the Mafatlal name by Chandak,
would have exercised reasonable diligence and alerted Atulya. It would be
more reasonable than not, to expect members of the Arvind Mafatlal Group to
have cautioned the warring members of the Yogindra Mafatlal Group that they
were losing value to outsiders in the course of their disputes. This is precisely
what Varun claims they did but in August 2023, as neighbours living in the
same bungalow. Taking a holistic view of the matter, I am not satisfied that
Varun can be held to have overcome the limitation already suffered by Atulya
before his demise.
35. There is one other factual development that makes Atulya’s diligence
relevant – the Registrar advertised Madhuri’s applications on December 12,
2016 and March 13, 2017. This was yet another trigger for Atulya to examine
the matter and even object to the registration by asserting his own interest in
the Marks and by asserting that the original instruments that form the basis of
the registration ought to be examined. Every objection that is now sought to
be raised could have been raised then because to his knowledge, Madhuri died
in 2013. Yet, he did nothing then. He could have conducted a search on the
Page 30 of 49
November 19, 2026
Aarti Palkar
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 16:12:58
COMMP.27.2024.doc
Register. It does not appeal to me to permit Varun to overcome this silence
and complete lack of diligence on Atulya’s part, when Varun’s interest and
claim is through Atulya. Separately, Malavika claims to have shared the
royalties earned from the Marks with Atulya until she learnt about the
Madhuri Will and the Ajay Will in 2015. Malavika pleads that, during the
negotiations, Atulya insisted on a division of the royalties received after Ajay’s
demise. Even if one were discount this contention fully, Atulya had adequate
opportunities t0 be diligent and claim an interest in the Marks, and that too
when Varun claims that Atulya was party to the oral family arrangement to
have the Marks registered in Madhuri’s name.
36. The Marks also were scheduled to expire in 2021 and were renewed, this
time in Chandak’s name with an advertisement of the renewal, for another ten
years. The advertisement of the renewal proposals was effected in 2020 and
Atulya did not initiate any opposition then too. To permit Varun to now
contend that all this means nothing would run counter to the very import of
Section 17 of the Limitation Act.
37. The Petition is therefore hit by extraordinary delay in asserting Atulya’s
rights, which were already barred by limitation. The allegation of fraud
against the Madhuri Will, the Ajay Will and the Deed of Assignment do not, in
Page 31 of 49
November 19, 2026
Aarti Palkar
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 16:12:58
COMMP.27.2024.doc
my judgement, turn the needle in Varun’s favour. Atulya could reasonably be
said to have acquiesced or waived by continuing to suffer the erosion in his
interests. I am not convinced that Varun can reset the clock on the basis of his
personal discoveries in 2023 even while the very foundation of his claim is
based on his father Atulya’s purported oral family settlement.
38. As regards Article 137 in the Schedule to the Limitation Act, the
prescribed period of limitation is three years from when the right to apply
accrues. The right to apply sought to be pursued by Varun is the right that
Atulya had, to apply for rectification. If that right had expired with time
during Atulya’s lifetime, merely on the basis that Varun personally got to know
later, the limitation clock would not stand reset.
39. Before parting with this facet of the judgement, a word about Chandak’s
engagement with the Yogindra Mafatlal family in the use of the Marks would
be in order. Chandak has contended that he was licensee for manufacture from
Sungrace Mafatlal Group between 1998 and 2018, placing reliance on a list of
21 agreements. These agreements are for manufacture of designated metre
length of fabric by Chandak for royalty paid to members of the Yogindra
Mafatlal family, and are brokered by Choksi.
Page 32 of 49
November 19, 2026
Aarti Palkar
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 16:12:58
COMMP.27.2024.doc
40. Licenses from Ajay to Rahul Syntex (Chandak) are seen from the record
(for example, an agreement in 2012). Malavika, who pleads that she was never
in business, too issued licenses and collected funds from Chandak (for
example, a license agreement of January 24, 2016, which purports to record
that Malavika inherited the Marks pursuant to the Ajay Will and that Gayatri
had relinquished her interest in the Marks on December 7, 2015). If such
earnings by Ajay and Malavika were encumbrances over the family silver, it
would have been for Atulya to sue for it – more so when Suit 685 had been
instituted by Malavika and Gayatri to protect Ajay’s interests from Atulya.
Due Process by the Registrar:
41. When it is held that Varun’s grievance is not worthy of consideration by
this Court, arguably, the matter should end there and then. However, the facts
discernible from the record necessitate examining the conduct of the
Registrar. It must be mentioned at the threshold in this segment of the
judgement that the jurisdiction involved is not simply one of a civil court that
adjudicates bilateral disputes as pleaded. Section 57(4) of the TM Act
empowers the Registrar and this Court to also exercise suo motu powers to
effect rectification. The very basis of such a power is to ensure that integrity of
the Register is preserved. Integrity of the Register of Trade Marks can only be
ensured by the integrity of due process followed by the Registrar.
Page 33 of 49
November 19, 2026
Aarti Palkar
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 16:12:58
COMMP.27.2024.doc
42. Therefore, I think it necessary to examine how the Registrar has
conducted itself in the matter, particularly bearing in mind that an application
for registration made in 2011 translated into registration in 2017 after the
death of the applicant in 2013, of which the Registrar had notice in 2015. The
2015 Applications continue on the docket of the Registrar without any orders,
even while applications made in 2018 have been processed and approved
without any order being discernible from the record and without any
indication of disposal of the 2015 Applications as having been overtaken or
rendered infructuous. This necessitates a closer examination of what
transpired without simply closing the file completely upon finding that Varun
cannot pursue the captioned Petition.
43. What stands out in this case is the fact that an applicant for registration
of the Marks was dead when the Registrar granted the registration, with the
knowledge that the applicant is dead. Neither side has any explanation for this
and indeed the Registrar has chosen to stay away from these proceedings. It is
not as if the eventuality of an applicant dying before grant of registration is not
contemplated in the law – Rule 55 of the 2017 Rules provides as follows:
"55. Death of applicant before registration.—
In case of death of any applicant for the registration of a trademark after the date of
his application and before the trademark has been entered in the register, the
Page 34 of 49
November 19, 2026
Aarti Palkar
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 16:12:58
COMMP.27.2024.doc
Registrar may, on request on form TM-M and on proof of the applicant's death and on
proof of the transmission of the interest of the deceased person, substitute in the
application, the name of successor in interest in place of the name of such deceased
applicant, and the application may proceed thereafter as so amended."
[Emphasis Supplied]
44. What is noteworthy is that when the 2015 Applications were filed to
intimate the Registrar about the death of Madhuri, the 2002 Rules held the
field – Rule 61 of the 2002 Rules read thus:
"Death of Applicant before Registration
61. In case of death of any applicant for the registration of a trade mark after the date
of his application and before the trade mark has been entered in the register, the
Registrar may, on proof of the applicant’s death and on proof of the transmission of
the interest of the deceased person, substitute in the application his successor in
interest in place of the name of such deceased applicant and the application may
proceed thereafter as so amended."
[Emphasis Supplied]
45. It will be seen that the position in law was identical except for the
insertion of a requirement to file an application in Form TM-M
(miscellaneous) to bring on record the name of the successor in interest. When
the 2015 Applications were filed, the Registrar had to be satisfied with proof of
the death and proof of the transmission of interest, and substitute the name of
the successor in interest in the application. It is only thereafter that the
application may proceed after being so amended. When the Marks were
Page 35 of 49
November 19, 2026
Aarti Palkar
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 16:12:58
COMMP.27.2024.doc
registered in 2017, Madhuri was long dead but the registration certificates
were clearly issued “ in the name of ” Madhuri. Chandak claims that these
provisions are only enabling empowering provisions that the Registrar is not
required to follow – this does not sound logical at all. Indeed the Registrar
may substitute the applicant’s name but only on receipt of proof. If there is no
proof, he may not effect such substitution. The provision if read as one
conferring a power, it is a provision that entails a power coupled with duty to
be satisfied with proof to process the application of a dead person any further.
46. There was not even a substitution of the name of the successor in
interest in the application. In other words, the very original registration that
Varun seeks to retain is a registration that was effected in the name of a dead
person, despite proof of death having been on the Registrar’s record and
without anything to evidence examination of proof of succession in interest
and substitution of the name of the successor in interest upon examination of
proof of the successor in interest. Worse, without any substitution, the
registration in Madhuri’s name was granted in 2017 and soon thereafter, the
transfers to Malavika and from Malavika to Chandak took place in 2018 in
rapid succession.
Page 36 of 49
November 19, 2026
Aarti Palkar
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 16:12:58
COMMP.27.2024.doc
47. Indeed, it is contended on behalf of Chandak that this should not matter
since registration of a mark always relates back to the date of application. This
contention is disingenuous since it would then mean that any registration can
be effected in the name of a dead person, on the ground that the dead
applicant was alive when the application was made. This makes a mockery of
the need for an existing live person to be a “proprietor” of a mark proposed to
be registered. It is not anybody’s case that any letters of administration were
issued or that any executor of the Madhuri Will or the Ajay Will sought
registration in the name of Madhuri’s estate. Madhuri’s application of 2011
was simply granted in 2017 well after her demise, with the registration being
effected in her name.
48. By the approach of giving Rule 55 of the 2017 Rules (or Rule 61 of the
2002 Rules) a go-by and by leapfrogging to the operation of Rule 75 read with
Rule 76 of the 2017 Rules, the Registrar has simply side-stepped the issue of
whether a dead applicant can be granted registration. Even under Rule 76 of
the 2017 Rules, the person applying must file a duly certified copy of the
original document purporting to transfer title to the applicant in the registered
mark. The shortcomings in the 2015 Applications come later but with notice
of the death of Mathuri, the applicant, the import of Rule 55 has been
sidestepped to grant registration to a dead person.
Page 37 of 49
November 19, 2026
Aarti Palkar
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 16:12:58
COMMP.27.2024.doc
49. Chandak contends that Rule 55 is enabling provision and can be safely
ignored. I am not able to accept this suggestion – clearly, in the run up to
registration, the law-writer has envisaged the situation of the potential death
of the applicant before registration and has provided a framework to deal with
it. That framework cannot be wished away as a discretionary power that need
not be exercised at the whim of the Registrar – as indicated above it is a power
coupled with a duty.
50. This led to the position that invoking Section 45 of the TM Act and Rule
77 of the 2017 Rules, the Registrar could simply state that there was no serious
doubt arising from the documents before him to demand any additional proof.
This has been possible because without a live person backing the applications
made in 2011 by Madhuri, despite the pendency of the 2015 Applications, the
current situation has come about. This, to my mind, raises reasonable doubt
about the integrity of the Register. In a succession dispute that is fraught with
deep fissures and internecine disputes, registration of the Marks came to be
granted to a dead person.
51. A dead person cannot sustain an application. In fact, the 2015
Applications were filed in Form TM-16 under the 2002 Rules, which is
essentially a form to correct clerical mistakes before grant of registration.
Page 38 of 49
November 19, 2026
Aarti Palkar
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 16:12:58
COMMP.27.2024.doc
There is no specific form stipulated for an application under Rule 61 of the
2002 Rules. There is not a whisper of how the 2015 Applications were
handled. It is after Madhuri’s name being entered into the Register in 2017
well after her demise in 2013 that another application by Malavika filed in May
2018 was granted in July 2018 to bring Malavika’s name as the successor of
the registered mark. Soon after that, based on the Deed of Assignment,
Chandak’s application was allowed to make him the registered owner of the
Marks.
52. Rule 61 of the 2002 Rules and Rule 55 of the 2017 Rules clearly require
the Registrar to be satisfied with the proof of the death and the proof the
succession in interest of the substitute applicant. There is nothing to show
that this process was at all followed. Instead, the application was processed
without any substitution – clearly in violation of the scheme of the law, leading
to the absurdity of grant of registration to a person known to be dead. The
recognition of Malavika would come later as a successor in interest to the
registered Marks and of Chandak as an assignee from Malavika. This is
precisely what is wrong with due process and integrity of the Register.
53. Indeed, I have held that it does not lie in Varun’s hands to pursue
rectification proceedings. Equally, what Varun desires is to sustain the
Page 39 of 49
November 19, 2026
Aarti Palkar
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 16:12:58
COMMP.27.2024.doc
registration in Madhuri’s name and only rectify the entries in Malavika’s and
Chandak’s names. On the other hand, when I examine the record and the
conduct of how the Register has been handled, I am afraid that the very
foundational registration in Madhuri’s name appears infirm. While this
matter could have been closed with the rejection of Varun’s Petition, it cannot
lose sight of the fact that the integrity of the Register being sacrosanct, and the
legislature having given the power of a suo motu rectification by the Court, it is
the integrity of the Register that is the intended beneficial objective.
54. Section 45 of the TM Act deals with grant of registration to a person who
becomes entitled to the registered mark pursuant to an assignment or
transmission. Section 45 of the TM Act read with Rule 77 of the 2017 Rules
empowers the Registrar to seek evidence or further evidence where there is
any doubt as to the veracity of the documents or information provided.
Arguably there was considerable doubt that would have emerged from the
documents presented in the 2015 Applications – the absence of the Ajay Will
although referred to in the Gayatri Undertaking and that too with the date
being blank. This is more so because Gayatri is one of the named executors in
the Madhuri Will. The other executor is her husband Priyam Jhaveri. The
Ajay Will names two executors Shanay Jhaveri and one Mr. Bhavesh Parmar.
Without even getting into whether the Registrar is a “Court” for purposes of
Page 40 of 49
November 19, 2026
Aarti Palkar
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 16:12:58
COMMP.27.2024.doc
the Succession Act (on which copious competing submissions have been
made), the least the Registrar ought to have done is to satisfy himself about
the succession in interest by calling upon the executors to confirm the
position.
55. Strangely, while this should have been done in response to the 2015
Applications, the Registrar proceeded to register the Marks in the name of a
dead person two years later, with nothing to indicate an adjudication of the
2015 Applications. By simply not dealing with it, the key round of validation
was not even dealt with and the problematic position was leapfrogged over to
give registration to the late Madhuri and to then process the new Form TM-P
from each of Malavika and Chandak in 2018 as if the Registrar was simply
dealing with the validly existing Marks.
56. What is also noteworthy is that the Madhuri Will lists only one of the
Marks as being bequeathed to Ajay – the “ Trade Mark of Sungrace Mafatlal
bearing No. 2081790 validly registered in my name ” in Paragraph 6(e) as a
moveable asset of Madhuri. Registration of that Mark had still been pending
and it had not been registered. That apart the other Mark does not seem to be
part of the Madhuri Will and therefore one wonders how the Ajay Will could
Page 41 of 49
November 19, 2026
Aarti Palkar
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 16:12:58
COMMP.27.2024.doc
have been the basis of contending that it was available for Malavika to assign
to Chandak.
57. Malavika admits to having received royalties from Chandak as a licensee
and consideration of Rs. 9 lakh per Mark for the assignment to Chandak even
while contending that she knows nothing about business operations and
needed funds for her medical expenses. The Madhuri Will and the Ajay Will
are admittedly not probated and no testamentary proceedings have been taken
up or are pending in relation to either Will.
58. Mr. Jagtiani has made submissions, among others, to the effect that the
power to suo motu rectify a registration being available only to deal with
situations where the registration is per se illegal. Prima facie , granting
registration of a trade mark to a dead person falls in that category. That apart,
all contentions on merits will be available when the parties deal with the notice
under the suo motu rectification proceedings.
Summary of Conclusions:
59. To summarise, my conclusions on the points for determination are:
A] Varun must indeed be regarded as a "person aggrieved". Whether
his contentions in the Petition are tenable and whether the Court ought
to make any intervention at his request is a matter of merits or delay,
Page 42 of 49
November 19, 2026
Aarti Palkar
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 16:12:58
COMMP.27.2024.doc
acquiescence, waiver and limitation. On the core issue of whether
Varun has skin in the game from the limited perspective of being
regarded as a person capable of being aggrieved by the registration of
the Marks, my finding is that Varun is to be regarded as a person
aggrieved;
B] On the facet of delay and limitation, in my view, Varun can only
claim through Atulya, who would in turn have had the capacity to claim
through Madhuri. It is Varun’s own contention that the purported oral
family settlement (also involving Atulya) necessitated Madhuri applying
for registration and indeed Madhuri had applied for it. Varun’s own
pleadings indicate that he lives in the same ‘Mafatlal Bungalow’ where
the Arvind Mafatlal family branch also lives and that he got to know
about the registrations in Chandak’s name from them, in August 2023.
If Atulya chose not to seek rectification, with him died the cause of
action in furtherance of rectification. If Varun inherited the right to sue,
he inherited it with all the drawbacks and erosion of the cause of action
that took place under Atulya’s watch. Atulya having passed away, there
is no positive evidence possible about the quality of the cause of action
in his hands, for the strength of Varun’s purported cause of action to be
inferred. The cause of action to seek rectification cannot spring back to
Page 43 of 49
November 19, 2026
Aarti Palkar
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 16:12:58
COMMP.27.2024.doc
life from scratch for every successive generation, claiming to have
discovered the cause of action;
C] Under Section 2(a)(ii) of the Limitation Act, an applicant includes
a person from or through whom the applicant derives the right to apply.
Varun derives his right through Atulya. The period for an application
under Section 57 of the TM Act is three years under Article 137 of the
Schedule to the Limitation Act. Time began to run when the entries in
favour of Malavika (July 5, 2018) and Chandak (September 17, 2018)
were made in a Register open to public search. It expired in July and
September 2021. Atulya was alive and took no step. Section 9 of the
Limitation Act provides that, once time has begun to run, no subsequent
disability stops it. Section 16 does not assist Varun, since time had
begun to run and ran its course before Atulya died in September 2022.
Varun cannot restart the clock on the footing of his own discovery in
August 2023. Section 17 of the Limitation Act does not postpone the
start of limitation. The family members were embroiled in litigation
with one another. The Registrar advertised Madhuri’s applications on
December 12, 2016 and March 13, 2017, and the renewals in 2020.
Atulya, with reasonable diligence, could have discovered the entries. His
silence is also acquiescence and waiver. Varun, as his successor, cannot
Page 44 of 49
November 19, 2026
Aarti Palkar
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 16:12:58
COMMP.27.2024.doc
undo it. Sufficient cause under Section 5 of the Limitation Act is not
made out. The Condonation IA fails and the Petition is barred by
limitation – that is without the need for any finding on the title to the
Marks or on the validity of the Madhuri Will and the Ajay Will;
D] The integrity of the Register of Trade Marks is suspect on the face
of the record. The entire history of registration of the Marks is replete
with inexplicable events. The original applicant, Madhuri died well
before registration was granted. Information about her death was
officially recorded in the systems of the Registrar by December 2015,
when Malavika filed the Madhuri Will. Any reasonable officer in the
Registry would have desired to know and appreciate the precise status
of the legacy. Despite all the wherewithal provided for in the 2002
Rules and in the 2017 Rules, there is nothing to show that the Registrar
satisfied himself about the successor in interest to the application for
registration of the Marks. Regardless of Varun’s claims and attempt to
displace the registration in favour of Chandak and Malavika, in my view,
Madhuri’s own registration is suspect, having been effected well after
her death, despite knowledge of her death, and it being a matter of
public record that Madhuri’s offspring were fighting tooth and nail on
various fronts; and
Page 45 of 49
November 19, 2026
Aarti Palkar
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 16:12:58
COMMP.27.2024.doc
E] The least expected of the Registrar is that he ought to have
discharged the duty of ascertaining the precise status. The provisions of
Rule 55 of the 2017 Rules and Rule 61 of the 2002 Rules entail a power
coupled with duty to use such power to ascertain the position. After all,
the record of title to intellectual property maintained by the Registrar is
meant to give public confidence in the record of ownership of
intellectual property in India. Therefore, I am inclined to initiate suo
motu rectification proceedings in exercise of powers under Section 57(4)
of the TM Act to consider rectification of the registration from scratch
and delete even Madhuri’s name from the Register, since evidently, it
has been registered after her death, with scant enquiry into whether it
was being pursued by genuine legal heirs.
Directions:
60. Therefore, I am of the view that this case is prima facie a fit case for
issuance of notice by the Court on its own motion asking the current registrant
i.e. Chandak, the immediately preceding registrant i.e. Malavika and the estate
of Madhuri (the two named executors in the Madhuri Will) – collectively, “ the
Noticees ” – as to why the registration originally granted to a dead person
(Madhuri) in 2017 should not be cancelled. The Noticees shall also explain
Page 46 of 49
November 19, 2026
Aarti Palkar
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 16:12:58
COMMP.27.2024.doc
how the Class 25 Mark, which is not even alluded to in the Madhuri Will could
be treated as having vested in Ajay and then to Malavika, for the assignment to
Chandak to be valid.
61. Pending such proceedings, prima facie , it appears appropriate to
consider a stay on the operation of the statutory protection available pursuant
to the registration. However, I think it appropriate to enable the Noticees to
also show cause as to why such interim injunction should not be issued. The
Noticees’ reply showing cause shall also set out in a separate segment why the
effect of registration should not be stayed pending hearing and disposal of the
rectification proceedings.
62. The Noticees shall also justify their reliance on the Madhuri Will and the
Ajay Will in defence of their registrations, particularly in view of the
infirmities pointed out in this judgement. Having rejected Varun’s Petition, I
am not ruling on the questions of law raised under the Succession Act in
relation to the Wills. However, depending on the replies from the Noticees,
questions of law under the Succession Act shall be considered.
63. The Noticees’ replies shall be filed by way of an affidavit along with any
evidence to substantiate the replies, no later than January 15, 2027 . This High
Court does not have rules governing the procedure to be followed and it is only
Page 47 of 49
November 19, 2026
Aarti Palkar
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 16:12:58
COMMP.27.2024.doc
appropriate that the minimum standards in subordinate law under the TM Act
is followed. Rule 100 of the 2017 Rules provide for a minimum of one month’s
notice period and I have provided for nearly two months’ notice period,
considering the intervening holiday season.
64. Inexplicably, when all the contentions of the parties in the dispute are
about the conduct of the Registrar, there is not even a whisper of participation
by the Registrar in these proceedings. My view has usually been to let orders
of the Registrar speak for themselves but in this case, there is no reasoned
order on the file. This calls for issuance of certain directions in relation to the
Registrar. This judgement shall be sent by the Registry of this Court to the
Office of Controller General of Patents, Designs and Trade Marks, with a
direction to call for the files and records in this matter right from the first
application made on behalf of Madhuri in 2011 till date. The Controller
General shall cause the files to be independently studied by a senior
responsible officer who has not handled any facet of this case until now, and
such officer shall file an affidavit to explain how the course of conduct adopted
by the Registry has come about.
65. Such affidavit shall set out particulars of how the Registry handles cases
where an applicant being a natural person has died before grant of registration
Page 48 of 49
November 19, 2026
Aarti Palkar
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 16:12:58
COMMP.27.2024.doc
and whether the Registry has any internal manual or standard operating
procedure to deal with such situations. Statistics indicating in how many
cases, registration has been granted to the knowledge of the Registrar, in the
name of a dead person in the past ten years, shall also be compiled and
presented. Such affidavit too shall be filed no later than January 15, 2027 .
66. With the aforesaid directions, the captioned Petition is finally disposed
of .
67. The Registry of this Court shall register a new suo motu Commercial
Miscellaneous Petition pursuant to this judgement as a suo motu initiation of
rectification proceedings under Section 57(4) of the TM Act, and update the
file with the replies from the Noticees and from the Officer of the Controller
General. List such Suo Motu Petition under the caption “ For Directions ” on
January 20, 2027 .
68. All actions required to be taken pursuant to this order shall be taken
upon receipt of a downloaded copy as available on this Court’s website.
[SOMASEKHAR SUNDARESAN J.]
Page 49 of 49
November 19, 2026
Aarti Palkar
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 16:12:58
Powered by TCPDF (www.tcpdf.org)