QUIDBUDEEN vs THE STATE REP BY ITS,
- Court
- Madras High Court
CRL RC.No.478 of 2019
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE OF MADRAS
Reserved on : 15.09.2026
Pronounced on : 13.11.2026
CORAM:
THE HON'BLE MR.JUSTICE M.NIRMAL KUMAR
CRL.RC.No.478 of 2019
Quidbudeen ... Petitioner / Accused No.5
Vs.
State Represented by
The Inspector of Police,
CCB, St.Thomas Mount,
Chennai. ... Respondent / Complainant
PRAYER: Criminal Revision Case filed under Sections 397 and 401 of
the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973, to call for the records
pertaining to the impugned Judgment dated 21.03.2019 in
Crl.A.No.125/2017, on the file fo the Hon’ble I Additional and
Sessions Court, Tiruvarur, confirming the conviction dated
27.03.2015 in C.C.No.233 of 2006, on the file of the Judicial
Magistrate Court, No.I, Poonamalloee and set aside hte same by
allowing the above Criminal Revision Case.
For Appellant : Mr.P.Sivamani
For Respondent : Mr.S.Udayakumar
Government Advocate (crl.side)
1
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 08:47:04 pm )
CRL RC.No.478 of 2019
O R D E R
This Criminal Revision Case has been filed by A5 in C.C.No.233
of 2006, on the file of the learned Judicial Magistrate No.I,
Poonamallee, challenging the Judgment, dated 21.03.2019, passed by
the learned I Additional District and Sessions Judge, Tiruvallur, in
Crl.A.No.125 of 2017, by which, the petitioner's appeal dismissed and
the judgment of conviction and sentence, dated 27.03.2015, passed
by the trial Court confirmed.
2. The prosecution case, in brief, is that one Raghavan
Naicker, by a registered settlement deed in Doc.No.2704 of 1925,
dated 23.10.1925, on the file of Sub-Registrar Office, Saidapet, gave
an extent of 1 acre 50 cents comprised in Survey Nos.51/2, 52/2A and
52/2B of Okkiyam Thuraipakkam Village to his daughter Kannammal
as 'Sridhana'. After her demise, the property enjoyed by her son
Ayyasamy, who died on 20.06.1993, thereafter, by the defacto
complainant Rajasekar (P.W.1) and his sister Shanthi (P.W.2). In the
year 1987, 87 cents out of the said extent acquired by the
Government for formation of a road, leaving the balance with the
family, of which 58 cents is the subject matter of this case.
2
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 08:47:04 pm )
CRL RC.No.478 of 2019
3. It is alleged that on 29.09.2005, P.W.1 came to know that
one Kathiresan (A2) approached the Village Administrative Officer
seeking patta for the said land. On obtaining Encumbrance
Certificate from the Sub-Registrar Office, Neelankarai, P.W.1 found
that Santha (A1), wife of one Senthil Velayutham, executed a
registered settlement deed in Doc.No.4719 of 2005, dated
17.08.2005, in favour of her son A2, in respect of 58 cents, who in
turn sold the same extent to one Boominathan (A3) under a
registered sale deed in Doc.No.5867 of 2005, dated 10.10.2005, for a
recited consideration of Rs.14,16,128/-. In these documents, the title
of A1 to the property was traced to a sale deed purportedly executed
in 1964 by Kannammal and Ayyasamy in favour of Senthil
Velayutham, registered as Document No. 2648 of 1964, the original
of which was stated to have been destroyed.
4. According to the prosecution, Doc.No.2648 of 1964
registered in the Sub-Registrar Office, Pallavaram, is in fact a
mortgage deed between two strangers, namely Sulthan Moidheen
and Abdul Rahim, relating to property at Jamin Pallavaram, and the
document projected by the accused as the 1964 sale deed (Ex.P9) is a
forgery, the stamp paper of which bears serial No.3238 dated
15.12.1972 and the name of one S.Mangalam as vendor, who was
licensed as a stamp vendor from the year 1990. The petitioner (A5)
3
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 08:47:04 pm )
CRL RC.No.478 of 2019
and one Nallasivam (A4) are alleged to have signed as attesting
witnesses to the settlement deed and the sale deed of the year 2005,
and all the five accused are alleged to have conspired together to
grab the property of P.W.1 and P.W.2.
5. On the complaint of P.W.1 (Ex.P4), the Central Crime
Branch, Chennai, registered Crime No.102 of 2005 on 23.11.2005
through P.W.8, Sub-Inspector of Police, under Sections 468, 471 and
420 IPC (Ex.P13). During investigation, the offences were altered to
Sections 465, 468 r/w 471 r/w 120(B), 109 and 34 IPC. A1 and A2
were arrested, while A3, A4 and the petitioner obtained anticipatory
bail from this Court (the petitioner in Crl.O.P.No.17703 of 2006).
P.W.9, Inspector of Police, completed the investigation and filed the
final report on 21.09.2006, which was taken on file in C.C.No.233 of
2006, by the learned Judicial Magistrate No.I, Poonamallee, on
28.09.2006.
6. During trial, the prosecution examined 9 witnesses as
P.W.1 to P.W.9, marked 16 documents as Ex.P1 to Ex.P16 and no
material object marked. The defence examined D.W.1 and marked
Ex.D1 to Ex.D10. When the incriminating circumstances were put to
the accused under Section 313(1)(b) Cr.P.C., they denied them as
false. By judgment dated 27.03.2015, the learned Judicial Magistrate
4
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 08:47:04 pm )
CRL RC.No.478 of 2019
No.I, Poonamallee, found A1 to A5 guilty and sentenced each of them
as follows:
(i) Sections 465 r/w 120(B) IPC:
rigorous imprisonment for one year and fine of
Rs.1,000/-, in default, simple imprisonment for one
month;
(ii) Sections 468 r/w 471 IPC: rigorous
imprisonment for one year and fine of Rs.1,000/-, in
default, simple imprisonment for one month; and
(iii) Sections 420 r/w 34 IPC: rigorous
imprisonment for two years and fine of Rs.3,000/-, in
default, simple imprisonment for two months.
The sentences were directed to run concurrently.
7. The trial Court, upon considering the evidence of P.W.3 (Sub-
Registrar, Pallavaram), P.W.4 (District Registrar), P.W.5 (Joint Sub-
Registrar, Saidapet) and P.W.6 (Stamp Vendor), together with Ex.P5
and Exs.P14 to P16, held that Document No.2648 of 1964 was only a
mortgage deed and the document projected by the accused as a sale
deed of the year 1964 was forged and fabricated. As regards the
petitioner, the trial Court reasoned that A1, being only one of the
legal heirs of her deceased husband, could not have settled the
property in favour of A2, particularly, when there were other legal
heirs. It further observed that A4, being the husband of A1’s sister,
would have been aware of these facts. Therefore, the trial Court
inferred that the participation of A4 and A5 as attesting witnesses to
5
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 08:47:04 pm )
CRL RC.No.478 of 2019
the settlement deed indicated their complicity in the attempt to grab
the complainant’s property. The trial Court further held that A3 was
not an innocent purchaser.
8 . Aggrieved by the findings of the trial Court, the petitioner
preferred an appeal in Crl.A. No.125 of 2017, before the learned I
Additional District and Sessions Judge, Tiruvallur. The said appeal
was dismissed by judgment dated 21.03.2019. The appellate Court,
upon noting that the defence, in effect, admitted the title of
Kannammal and Ayyasamy, concurred with the finding that Document
No.2648 of 1964 was a forged document. As regards the petitioner,
the appellate Court observed that the settlement deed, dated
17.08.2005 and the sale deed, dated 10.10.2005, produced before
the trial Court and were, therefore, materials on record. It further
noted that the petitioner signed as a witness to both documents. In
that context, the lower appellate Court observed that “there is
th
nothing culled out by the defence to show that the 5 appellant
herein did not possess the culpable mind and was not part of the
conspiracy committed.” The appellate Court further held that A4 and
A5, having attested both documents, notwithstanding the interval of
three months between them, were “more than mere witnesses to the
documents”, and the conspiracy stood established by the surrounding
circumstances. It also noticed that the trial Court omitted to frame a
6
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 08:47:04 pm )
CRL RC.No.478 of 2019
charge of criminal conspiracy, but held that such omission not
vitiated the proceedings, in view of Section 464 Cr.P.C.
9. The petitioner thereafter filed the present Revision in the
year 2019. According to the status report filed by the respondent,
this Court, by order dated 04.06.2019, directed the petitioner to
surrender before the trial Court and posted the case to 14.06.2019.
As the petitioner not surrendered, the Revision dismissed as
withdrawn on 14.06.2019. The petitioner thereafter approached the
Hon'ble Supreme Court in SLP (Crl.) No.45379 of 2019 and, by order
dated 27.01.2020, was granted three weeks' time to surrender. The
petitioner surrendered before the learned Judicial Magistrate No.I,
Poonamallee, on 13.02.2020 and remanded to Puzhal Central Prison.
By order dated 20.03.2020, this Court suspended the sentence on the
condition that the petitioner shall appear before the trial Court on
the first working day of every month at 10.30 a.m. The Revision has
thus come up for final disposal.
10.As regards the co-accused, the status report and the order
of this Court dated 07.04.2022 in Crl.R.C.No.1064 of 2017 disclose
that A1 (Santha) unsuccessfully challenged her conviction right up to
this Court; A4 (Nallasivam) died; A2 (Kathiresan) absconded; and A3
(Boominathan), whose appeal in C.A.No.35 of 2015 had been
dismissed by the learned Principal Sessions Judge, Tiruvallur, on
7
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 08:47:04 pm )
CRL RC.No.478 of 2019
05.07.2017, was acquitted of all the charges by this Court in
Crl.R.C.No.1064 of 2017, by order dated 07.04.2022.
11. Mr.P.Sivamani, the learned counsel for the revision
petitioner would submit that the petitioner /A5 convicted only for the
reason he signed as an attesting witness to the settlement deed
between A1 and A2 and the consequential sale deed between A2 and
A3, on the presumption that, as the two documents executed within
about three months, he was “more than an attesting witness”,
although there is no statutory presumption against him. Criminal
conspiracy under Section 120-B IPC is an independent offence which
prosecution must prove by the same standard as any other offence.
There is no material that the petitioner participated in any conspiracy
or even had knowledge of it. There is no material to implicate the
petitioner in the offences under Sections 465, 468, 471 and 420 IPC.
Doc.No.4719 of 2005 and Doc.No.5867 of 2005 not marked as
exhibits, and the original of Doc.No.2648 of 1964 not produced
before the trial Court to show that it was what the prosecution
claimed it to be a forged document, based on which, the settlement
deed and sale deed executed.
12. The learned counsel further submitted that there is no
evidence that the petitioner was a party to the preparation or use of
the forged document, he received any benefit, or that he had any
8
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 08:47:04 pm )
CRL RC.No.478 of 2019
knowledge of the alleged forgery and the Courts below, instead of
finding a link in evidence, shifted the burden on the petitioner to
show that he was not part of the conspiracy. The learned counsel also
placed reliance on the order of this Court dated 07.04.2022 in
Crl.R.C.No.1064 of 2017, by which the third accused, the purchaser
and beneficiary of the very same transaction, acquitted on the same
evidence, and submitted that the petitioner, a mere attesting witness,
stands on a far better footing.
13.Per contra, Mr.S.Udayakumar, learned Government
Advocate (Crl.side) submitted that the prosecution proved the case
beyond reasonable doubt through the prosecution witnesses and the
material evidence. Prosecution had examined 9 witnesses and
marked 16 documents. The defence has examined one witness as
DW1 and marked 10 documents. In this case, Kannamal’s father
Ragava Naicker had given 1 acre 50 cents to his daughter in Survey
Nos.51/2, 52/2A, 52/2B to her daughter Kannammal, who is the
grandmother of PW1 and PW2 and this has been registered in
Document No.2704 of 1925 in SRO, Saidapet.. After Kannammal, the
property devolved upon her son, Ayyaasamy. In the year 1983, for the
expansion of the road, the Government acquired 69 cents in survey
number 51/2 and 9 cents in survey number 54/2A and paid
compensation. Finding it inadequate, Ayyaasamy had filed an LAOP
case in 60/2002, which is still pending before the Sub-Court,
9
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 08:47:04 pm )
CRL RC.No.478 of 2019
Poonamallee. A1 to A5 in this case had encroached upon and
grabbed this property. This fact has been spoken to by PW1 and PW2.
PW3 has spoken about Exs. P5, P14, P15, and P16, and confirmed
that Ex. P9 is a forged document. PW5 is a stamp vendor, who sold
the stamp papers marked as Exs. D1 to D6. In this case, the property
in Okiyam Thoraipakkam initially was under the jurisdiction of the
Saidapet Joint Office, thereafter with the Adyar SRO Office, and lastly
with the Neelankarai SRO Office. This being so, document number
2648 of 1964 had been created to show that the property pertaining
to this document was purchased by A1’s husband, Senthil
Velayutham / father of A2, from Ayyaasamy. The said document is
said to have been destroyed in a fire. In the year 1972, a certified
copy was obtained, and thereafter, the property was settled by A1 in
favor of her son, A2, despite having other legal heirs. Following this,
A2 executed a sale deed in favor of A3. A settlement deed in
Document No.4719 of 2005 was executed by A1 in favour of A2 in
August 2005. Thereafter, a sale deed in Document No.4719 of 2005
has been executed by A2 in favour of A3 in October 2005. Within a
period of two months, a settlement deed and, following it, a sale deed
had been executed. In both these documents, A4, brother-in-law of A1
and A5 / the petitioner herein signed as witnesses. From the
evidence of the witnesses and documents, it is clear that these two
documents are sham documents created without any right. There are
civil suits pending before the civil courts with regard to this property.
The petitioner thus conspired along with the other accused, knowing
10
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 08:47:04 pm )
CRL RC.No.478 of 2019
that these documents were forged, and stood as a witness. Hence,
the prosecution has established its case. The trial Court and the
lower appellate Court rightly convicted the petitioner. There is no
valid point to be argued and the revision is liable to be dismissed.
14. The Court heard the submission of Mr.P.Sivamani, learned
counsel for the petitioner and Mr.S.Udayakumar, learned Government
Advocate (Crl.side) for the respondent and perused the materials
available on record.
15.The point that arises for consideration is whether the
conviction and sentence imposed on the petitioner by the trial Court,
as confirmed in appeal, suffer from any infirmity in law or in the
appreciation of evidence as would warrant interference in exercise of
the revisional jurisdiction.
16. This Court is conscious that the revisional jurisdiction
under Sections 397 and 401 Cr.P.C. is limited in scope and that
concurrent findings of fact are not to be lightly interfered with. The
revisional power is to be exercised only to correct a jurisdictional
error, a material illegality, or a perversity resulting in a miscarriage
of justice, as held in State of Kerala v. Puttumana Illath
Jathavedan Namboodiri, (1999) 2 SCC 452 and Amit Kapoor v.
Ramesh Chander, (2012) 9 SCC 460 . Where a finding of guilt is
based on no legally admissible evidence or is arrived at by
impermissibly shifting the burden of proof, such finding suffers from
11
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 08:47:04 pm )
CRL RC.No.478 of 2019
a material illegality warranting interference in the exercise of
revisional jurisdiction.
17. For the purpose of deciding the present Revision, the
concurrent finding that the document set up by A1 and A2 as the sale
deed of 1964 (Doc. No. 2648 of 1964) is not genuine may be accepted
as it stands. The question that arises for consideration is whether
there is any legally admissible evidence connecting the petitioner
with the alleged forgery, or establishing his participation in any
agreement to commit the forgery or to use the forged document.
18. A reading of the judgments of both the Courts below, as
well as the respondent's summary of the deposition of the witnesses
show that the prosecution case against the petitioner rests on a
single circumstance, namely, he signed as an attesting witness to the
settlement deed dated 17.08.2005, executed by A1 in favour of A2,
and the sale deed dated 10.10.2005, executed by A2 in favour of A3.
P.W.1 speaks to the fact that A4 and A5 attested the settlement deed.
The evidence of P.Ws.3 to 6, comprising the Registration officials and
the stamp vendor, relates to the nature of Doc.No. 2648 of 1964 and
the stamp paper used therein and not implicate the petitioner in any
manner. P.Ws.7 to 9 speak to the arrest of A1 and A2, their disclosure
statements, the consequential recovery of documents, and the course
of investigation. The admissible portions of the statements of A1 and
A2, marked as Exs.P10 and P11, relate only to the recovery of
documents. There is no evidence to show that any document or
12
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 08:47:04 pm )
CRL RC.No.478 of 2019
property recovered from the petitioner. No witness attributes to the
petitioner any role in the preparation of Ex. P9, the procurement or
selection of the stamp paper, negotiation or execution of settlement
or sale transactions, or receipt of any part of consideration.
19. In law, an attesting witness is one who seen the executant
sign the instrument, or received from the executant a personal
acknowledgment of his signature, and himself signed the instrument
in the presence of the executant, as contemplated under Section 3 of
the Transfer of Property Act, 1882. Attestation is confined to
certifying the fact of execution of the instrument. An attesting
witness does not thereby vouch for the title of the executant or the
truth of the recitals contained in the instrument, nor is he ordinarily
required to investigate the title to the property. Both the documents
in the present case registered documents. It is pertinent that, as
noticed by this Court in Crl.R.C. No. 1064 of 2017, the registration
authorities found the sale deed to be proper in all respects, including
valuation, and proceeded to register the same. The mere fact that the
petitioner attested the registered documents, in the absence of any
other incriminating circumstance, may at best give rise to suspicion;
it cannot, by itself, establish that the petitioner had knowledge that
the recited root of title was forged, much less establish his
agreement with the executants to commit an offence.
20. The offence of criminal conspiracy, as defined under Section
120-A IPC, consists in an agreement between two or more persons to
13
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 08:47:04 pm )
CRL RC.No.478 of 2019
do, or cause to be done, an illegal act, or an act which is not illegal by
illegal means. The essence of the offence is the agreement between
the parties. As observed by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in K ehar
Singh v. State (Delhi Administration), (1988) 3 SCC 609 , direct
evidence of conspiracy is seldom available, and the existence of an
agreement may be inferred from the proved circumstances. However,
the circumstances relied upon must form a complete chain leading to
the conclusion that the accused persons entered into such an
agreement, consistent with the principles governing circumstantial
evidence laid down in Sharad Birdhichand Sarda v. State of
Maharashtra, (1984) 4 SCC 116 . The circumstances must be
inconsistent with any reasonable hypothesis other than the existence
of the alleged agreement. Mere suspicion, association, or presence
cannot substitute for legal proof.
21.Tested on this principle, the inference drawn by the Courts
below cannot be sustained. The appellate Court held that, because
the petitioner signed as a witness both in the settlement deed and in
the sale deed executed three months later, he was “more than mere
witnesses”. The two documents are consecutive links in a single
chain of title, the second having been executed by the donee under
the first. That the same persons attested both is a circumstance that
is equally consistent with an innocent explanation, namely they were
persons known to the parties who requested to attest the registered
transactions. Neither Court found any other circumstance, such as
14
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 08:47:04 pm )
CRL RC.No.478 of 2019
prior acquaintance with A1 or A2, participation in any meeting or
negotiation, knowledge of the family of Senthil Velayutham and of his
other legal heirs, receipt of any consideration, or any act of using the
forged document. The reasoning of the trial Court, that A1 alone
could not have settled the property in view of the other legal heirs,
and A4 being the husband of A1’s sister would have known this,
applies, if at all, to A4 and has no application to the petitioner, as
there is no finding or evidence that he was related to A1’s family or
had any means of knowing who the legal heirs of Senthil Velayutham
were.
22. The approach adopted by the Courts below discloses an
impermissible shifting of the burden of proof. The finding that there
th
was “nothing culled out by the defence to show that the 5 appellant
did not possess the culpable mind and was not part of the
conspiracy” places upon the accused the burden of disproving guilty
knowledge and the alleged agreement, both of which are ingredients
that the prosecution required to establish. The burden of proving
every ingredient of the offence rests upon the prosecution
throughout. The accused is presumed innocent, and no statutory
presumption of guilt arises merely because a person attested a
registered document. The trial Court likewise observed that, once the
prosecution established the forgery, it is for the defence to show that
Doc.No.2648 of 1964 was genuine. While such an observation may
15
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 08:47:04 pm )
CRL RC.No.478 of 2019
have had relevance in relation to those who relied upon or set up the
document, it could not absolve the prosecution of its obligation to
establish, by legally admissible evidence, the petitioner's connection
with the alleged forgery. It is the absence of evidence establishing
such connection, and not any failure on the part of the petitioner to
offer an explanation, that is material.
23. It is also significant that the lower appellate Court
proceeded on the basis of the settlement deed and the sale deed,
while expressly recording that it was “not clear” whether those
documents had been exhibited. The petitioner's alleged signatures on
these two documents constitute the basis to connect the petitioner in
the prosecution case. Where the allegation of conspiracy against an
accused rests entirely upon his alleged signatures on two documents,
the failure to formally prove and mark those documents, and to
establish through competent evidence that the petitioner signed
them as an attesting witness, is not proved. Admittedly, in this case,
A1, A2, and A4 are from the same family. The claim of A1 is that her
husband had purchased the property from Ayyaasamy, t father of
PW1 and PW2, in the year 1964. Thereafter, after the demise of A1's
husband, Senthilnathan, she settled the property in favour of A2, her
son, who subsequently executed the sale deed, by receiving
Rs.14,16,128/- as sale consideration. The entire registration
procedure was duly followed. In this case, the overt act attributed
16
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 08:47:04 pm )
CRL RC.No.478 of 2019
against the petitioner is that he signed as a witness to the settlement
deed and the sale deed of 2005. These two documents are created
pursuant to the 1964 sale deed. As regards the petitioner, his role is
limited to 2005 documents, whereas the prosecution's own case is
that the underlying 1964 document is forged one. Admittedly, the
petitioner has no role in the 1964 document. It is also to be seen that
in this case, the subsequent documents of the year 2005, admittedly
not produced or marked as exhibits. In view of the same, holding the
petitioner for conspiracy, creation of forged documents, using them
as genuine, cheating the de facto complainant, and committing the
offense does not arise. This Court, however, does not rest its
conclusion on that ground. Even assuming that the petitioner signed
both documents as an attesting witness, as found by the Courts
below, such attestation, by itself, does not establish any of the
offences alleged against him for the reasons already stated.
24. As regards the substantive offences, there is no legally
admissible evidence to establish that the petitioner made or executed
Doc.No.2648 of 1964 or Ex. P9, so as to attract Sections 463, 464 and
465 IPC, or he made any false document with the intention that it be
used for the purpose of cheating, so as to attract Section 468 IPC.
The settlement deed dated 17.08.2005 executed by A1 in her own
name, and the sale deed dated 10.10.2005 executed by A2 in his own
name, neither document purports to have been made by a person
17
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 08:47:04 pm )
CRL RC.No.478 of 2019
other than its executant. In M ohammed Ibrahim v. State of Bihar,
(2009) 8 SCC 751 , the Hon'ble Supreme Court held that where a
person executes a document in his own name, the document does not
become a “false document” within the meaning of Section 464 IPC
merely because the title asserted by the executant is untrue, though
other offences may, in appropriate cases, be attracted. Likewise, an
offence under Section 471 IPC requires proof that the accused
fraudulently or dishonestly used as genuine a document which he
knew or had reason to believe to be forged. There is no evidence
attributing such use of the alleged forged document to the petitioner,
whether for the registration of the deeds or in the civil proceedings.
As regards Section 420 IPC, there is no evidence that the petitioner
made any representation or induced any person to deliver property
or part with money. Nor is there any evidence establishing the
existence of a common intention on the part of the petitioner so as to
attract Section 34 IPC.
25. The above conclusion is further supported by the order of
this Court in Crl.R.C.No.1064 of 2017, dated 07.04.2022, which arose
out of the same Crime No.102 of 2005 and the same judgment in C.C.
No.233 of 2006. In that case, this Court found that none of the
witnesses had spoken to the third accused being privy to the forgery
or having actively participated with the other accused in the
execution of the alleged forged documents, no document recovered
18
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 08:47:04 pm )
CRL RC.No.478 of 2019
from him, even where certain acts were established, it must be
shown that they were committed in pursuance of an agreement
between the accused. This Court further held that an inference of
guilt from proved circumstances could be drawn only when those
circumstances were incapable of any other reasonable explanation,
since mere suspicion cannot take the place of legal proof, and
concluded that the conviction rested on surmise. The third accused
was the purchaser under the sale deed and instituted a civil suit
based on the documents, yet he was acquitted. The petitioner is
alleged to have attested the same two documents. On the same body
of evidence, there is no basis for placing the petitioner in a less
favourable position. Consistency in the appreciation of the same
evidence in respect of co-accused in the same case is a relevant
consideration, and no distinguishing circumstance has been brought
to the notice of this Court warranting a different conclusion.
26. A copy of a statement alleged to have recorded from the
petitioner on 24.02.2017 by an Inspector of Police, Central Crime
Branch, in connection with another case, namely Crime No. 216 of
2016, is among the papers placed before this Court. That statement
does not form part of the record in C.C.No.233 of 2006. It was
recorded long after the conviction in the present case, in connection
with a different crime, by a police officer while the petitioner was in
custody. A confession made to a police officer cannot be proved
against the person making it, subject to the limited exception
19
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 08:47:04 pm )
CRL RC.No.478 of 2019
contained in Section 27 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872. No
discovery of any fact pursuant to the said statement shown so as to
attract that exception. The statement cannot, therefore, be relied
upon to supply any deficiency in the prosecution evidence in C.C.No.
233 of 2006, and this Court not taken it into consideration.
27. For the foregoing reasons, this Court holds that the
prosecution has failed to establish, by legally admissible evidence,
the petitioner was a party to any criminal conspiracy or he committed
any of the offences alleged under Sections 465, 468, 471 and 420
IPC. The conviction recorded by the trial Court and affirmed by the
lower appellate Court, insofar as it concerns the petitioner, rests on
suspicion and surmise and is founded upon an impermissible shifting
of the burden of proof. The findings, to that extent, suffer from
perversity and errors of law warranting interference in the exercise
of the revisional jurisdiction.
28.In the result:
(i) This Criminal Revision Case is allowed.
(ii) The judgment dated 21.03.2019 passed by the learned I
Additional District and Sessions Judge, Tiruvallur, in
Crl.A.No.125 of 2017, confirming the judgment of
conviction and sentence dated 27.03.2015 passed by the
learned Judicial Magistrate No.I, Poonamallee, in
C.C.No.233 of 2006, is set aside insofar as the petitioner /
A5 is concerned, and the petitioner is acquitted of the
charges under Sections 465 r/w 120(B), 468 r/w 471 and
420 r/w 34 IPC.
20
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 08:47:04 pm )
CRL RC.No.478 of 2019
(iii) The fine amount, if any, paid by the petitioner shall be
refunded to him. The bail bonds, if any, executed by the
petitioner shall stand discharged, and the condition
imposed in the order dated 20.03.2020 shall stand
vacated.
13.11.2026
Index : Yes/No
Internet : Yes/No
Neutral Citation : Yes/No
To
1. The I Additional District and Sessions Judge,
Tiruvallur.
2. The Judicial Magistrate No.I,
Poonamallee.
3. The Inspector of Police,
CCB, St.Thomas Mount,
Chennai.
4. The Public Prosecutor,
High Court, Madras.
21
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 08:47:04 pm )
CRL RC.No.478 of 2019
M.NIRMAL KUMAR, J.
mpk
Pre-Delivery order made in
CRL.RC.No.478 of 2019
13.11.2026
22
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 08:47:04 pm )