S. MARUTHAKUTTI(Died) vs A. JEEVARATHINAM
- Court
- Madras High Court
SA No. 259 of 2014
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT MADRAS
RESERVED ON : 30-09-2026
PRONOUNCED ON: 16.11.2026
CORAM
THE HON'BLE MR.JUSTICE P. DHANABAL
SA No. 259 of 2014 and M.P. No.1 of 2014
CNR: {HCMA011043472014}
1. S. MARUTHAKUTTI(Died)
S/o Late Subbanna Gounder
2. S. Manoharan
S/o Late Subbanna Gounder
3. K. Sivakami
W/o Late Rajendran
4. R. GOUTHAMAN(Died)
S/O LATE S.RAJENDRAN
A1 Died -Recorded vide Memo
SR.No.27185,dated 17/09/2019.
A4 Died-Recorded vide Memo
SR.No.36985,dated 24/08/2026 and court order
dated 25/08/2026 made in SA.No.259 of
2014(PDBJ)
5. Minor Prem Kumar S/o Late S. Rajendran
represented by his Mother and Natural
Guardian K.Sivakami.
..Appellant(s)
Vs
1. A. Jeevarathinam W/ Ashokan
2. Kaliammal W/o Late Nanjappan
3. Vasanthamani @ Ponnammal
W/o Soundararajan
4. Padmavathy W/o N.M. Marudhachalam.
5. Muthammal W/o P. Selvaraj
Page 1 of 16
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 17/11/2026 05:48:47 pm )
SA No. 259 of 2014
..Respondent(s)
PRAYER : The Second Appeal has been preferred under Section 100 of Civil
Procedure Code as against the decree and judgment passed in A.S No.43 of
2008 dated 22.08.2013 on the file of the IV Additional District Judge,
Coimbatore confirming and modifying the decree and judgment passed in O.S.
No.89 of 2006 dated 03.09.2007 on the file of the Subordinate Judge,
Coimbatore.
For Appellant(s): Mr. A.E.Ravichandran
For Respondent(s): M/s.M.Sriram [For R1]
R2, R3, R5 – Served – No appearance.
R4 - Dispensed With
JUDGMENT
The Second appeal has been preferred as against the decree and judgment
passed by the IV Additional District Judge, Coimbatore in A.S No.43 of 2008
st
dated 22.08.2013. The appellants are the defendants 1, 2 and 7 to 9. The 1
respondent herein, being the Plaintiff, has filed the Suit in O.S. No.89 of 2006
on the file of the Subordinate Judge, Coimbatore for the reliefs of partition,
separate possession and for costs. The said Suit was decreed by granting
partition of 9/40 shares in favour of the Plaintiff. Aggrieved by the said decree
and judgment, the defendants 1,2 and 7 to 9 have preferred an appeal in A.S.
No.43 of 2008 on the file of the IV Additional District Judge, Coimbatore. The
said appeal was partly allowed and the Plaintiff was granted 1/8 share in the
Suit property and the findings of the trial Court that the Ex.B.2 is not genuine,
Page 2 of 16
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 17/11/2026 05:48:47 pm )
SA No. 259 of 2014
valid, are set aside and the document was declared as true and valid to the extent
of 1/8 share of Subbanna Gounder. Aggrieved by the said decree and judgment,
the defendants 1,2 and 7 to 9 have preferred this second appeal.
2. The case of the Plaintiff before the trial Court is that originally the Suit
property belonged to one Maruthanna Gounder @ Maruthey Gounder. He
st
purchased the 1 item of the property through Sale Deed in the year 1904. The
nd rd
2 item of the property was purchased in the year 2012 and the 3 item was
purchased in the year 1931. The said Marutha Gounder @ Maruthanna
Gounder died in the year 1960 intestate leaving behind his only son Subbanna
Gounder as his legal heir to succeed his estate. The said Subbanna Gounder
died intestate on 28.11.1993 leaving behind the Plaintiff, defendants 1 to 6 and
one Rajendran as his legal heirs to succeed his estate. The said Rajendran died
leaving behind the defendants 7 to 9 as his legal heirs. The Plaintiff and the
defendants were all in joint and constructive possession with common
enjoyment of the Suit properties. Therefore, the Plaintiff is entitled to 1/8 share
over the Suit property.
st
3. The case of the 1 defendant before the trial Court is that the Suit is
not maintainable. The relationship between the parties is admitted. It is not
correct that the Subbanna Gounder died intestate on 28.11.1993. In fact, the
Page 3 of 16
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 17/11/2026 05:48:47 pm )
SA No. 259 of 2014
father of the Plaintiff and the defendants 1 to 6 namely Subbanna Gounder
executed a Registered Will dated 16.05.1986 bequeathing the properties in
favour of his three sons namely the defendants 1, 2 and one Late Rajendran.
The Plaintiff had also knowledge about the Will and by suppressing the material
facts, the Plaintiff has filed this false Suit. The Plaintiff is not in joint
possession with the defendants. After the demise of the Subbanna Gounder,
Patta was also transferred in the name of the defendants 1, 2 and 7 to 9.
Therefore, the Suit is liable to be dismissed.
4. Based on the above said pleadings and after hearing both sides, the trial
court has framed the following issues for trial:-
Issues:
1. Whether the Plaintiff is entitled to partition and other reliefs as
prayed for in the Plaint?
2. To what other reliefs, the Plaintiff is entitled?
5. Before the trial court, on the side of the plaintiff, witnesses P.W.1 and
PW2 were examined and marked exhibits, Ex.A.1 to A13. On the side of the
defendants, witness D.W.1 to DW3 were examined and Ex.B1 and Ex.B.2 have
been marked. Ex.X1 was also marked. The trial court, after evaluating the oral
Page 4 of 16
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 17/11/2026 05:48:47 pm )
SA No. 259 of 2014
and documentary evidences adduced on both sides and perusing the records,
decreed the Suit by granting 9/40 shares to the Plaintiff. Aggrieved by the said
decree and judgment, the defendants 1,2 and 7 to 9 have preferred an appeal in
A.S. No.43 of 2008 on the file of the IV Additional District Judge, Coimbatore
on various grounds.
5.1. During the pendency of the appeal before the First Appellate Court,
the appellants have filed an application to receive additional documents in I.A.
No.74 of 2013. The First Appellate Court has framed the points for
determination as follows:-
(i) Whether Ex.B.2 is true, valid and binding?
(ii) Whether the Plaintiff has any share in the Suit properties?
(iii) Whether the Plaintiff is in joint possession of the Suit properties?
(iv) Whether the judgment and decree of the trial Court are
sustainable?
(v) Whether I.A. No.74 of 2013 can be allowed?
6. After hearing both sides and perusing the records, the First Appellate
Court modified the preliminary decree and granted 1/8 share to the Plaintiff.
Further the findings of the trial Court that Ex.B.2 is not genuine, valid were set
Page 5 of 16
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 17/11/2026 05:48:47 pm )
SA No. 259 of 2014
aside and the document was declared as true and valid to the extent of 1/8 share
of Subbanna Gounder. Aggrieved by the said decree and judgment, the present
second appeal has been preferred by the appellants / defendants.
7. This Court, at the time of admitting the second appeal, formulated the
following Substantial Questions of Law .:-
(i) When the Suit properties admittedly belonged to Maruthanna
Gounder absolutely and on his death intestate the property vested on his son
Subbanna Gounder, whether the property in the hands of Subbanna Gounder
is his absolute property or a co-parcenary property?
(ii) When the property is inherited by Subbanna Gounder as a Class-I
legal heir under Section 8 of the Hindu Succession Act, was the Appellate
Court right in holding that Subbanna Gounder is a coparcener and he is
entitled to only 1/8 share in the property and he can execute a Will only to
that extent?
(iii) Is the Appellate Court right in holding that the sons and daughter
of Subbanna Gounder are entitled to share in the Suit property as
coparceners of the property of their grand father and is not such a finding
contrary to the judgments reported in 2012 (7) MLJ 414 and 2014 (1) CTC 73?
Page 6 of 16
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 17/11/2026 05:48:47 pm )
SA No. 259 of 2014
8. For the sake of convenience and brevity, the parties herein are referred
as plaintiff and defendants, as referred before the trial Court.
9. The learned counsel appearing for the appellants would submit that the
st
appellants are the defendants 1,2 and 7 to 9 in the main Suit. The 1 respondent
has filed the said Suit for partition and separate possession. The relationship
between the parties are admitted. Originally the Suit properties belonged to one
Maruthanna Gounder @ Maruthey Gounder. The said Maruthey Gounder had
purchased the properties through Sale Deeds in his name and thereby, the
properties are the separate properties of Maruthey Gounder. The said Maruthey
Gounder had one son namely Subbanna Gounder. The said Subbanna Gounder
died intestate on 28.11.1993 leaving behind the Plaintiff and the defendants 1 to
6 as his legal heirs. During his life time, he executed a Will dated 16.05.1986
bequeathing the properties in favour of his three sons namely the defendants
1 and 2 and one Late Rajendran. Since the properties were purchased by the
father of the Subbanna Gounder namely Maruthey Gounder, the Subbanna
Gounder became the Class-I legal heir through succession and thereby, the
properties are separate properties of Subbanna Gounder. While so, the said
Subbanna Gounder executed a Will dated 16.05.1986 and after the demise of
Subbanna Gounder, the defendants 1, 2 and 7 to 9 are in joint possession and
enjoyment of the properties. Thereby, the Plaintiff has no right over the Suit
Page 7 of 16
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 17/11/2026 05:48:47 pm )
SA No. 259 of 2014
properties. However, the Courts below failed to consider that after the death of
Maruthey Gounder, his son Subbanna Gounder is entitled to the properties as
his absolute Class-I legal heir under Section 8 of Hindu Succession Act and the
female children have no right over the properties and they are not co-parceners
and the properties are not co-parcenery properties. However, the trial Court
without considering the same, granted partition by allotting 9/40 shares to the
Plaintiff. The First Appellate Court also held that the Subbanna Gounder is a
co-parcener and he is entitled to execute Will to an extent of 1/8 share.
Therefore, the judgments and decrees passed by the Courts below are liable to
be set aside.
10. The learned counsel appearing for the respondents would submit that
st
the 1 respondent has filed a Suit for partition and separate possession as against
the other defendants. In fact, the properties belonged to Subbanna Gounder,
who is the father of the Plaintiff and the defendants 1 to 6 and one Rajendran.
The said Rajendran died and the defendants 7 to 9 are his legal heirs. Originally,
the properties were purchased by Maruthey Gounder through Sale Deeds and
after his demise, his only son Subbanna Gounder was entitled to the properties
and the said Subbanna Gounder died on 28.11.1993 intestate leaving behind the
Plaintiff, the defendants 1 to 6 and one Rajendran as his legal heirs to succeed
his estate. Therefore, the Plaintiff is entitled to 1/8 share over the Suit
Page 8 of 16
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 17/11/2026 05:48:47 pm )
SA No. 259 of 2014
properties. The Plaintiff and the defendants are in joint possession and
enjoyment of the properties. The Courts below have correctly appreciated the
facts and granted partition. Therefore, the Courts below have rendered
concurrent findings and the second appeal is liable to be dismissed.
11. This Court heard both sides and perused the entire materials available
on record.
12. In this case, there is no dispute in respect of relationship between the
parties. It is an admitted fact that originally the Suit properties belonged to one
Maruthanna Gounder @ Maruthey Gounder and he purchased the properties
through Sale Deeds, thereby the properties were the separate properties of
Maruthey Gounder and Subbanna Gounder is the only son to succeed the estate
of the said Maruthey Gounder as his Class-I Legal Heir. The Plaintiff is none
other than the daughter of Subbanna Gounder and the defendants 1 to 6 are also
the children of Subbanna Gounder and one Rajendran was also born to
Subbanna Gounder. The defendants 7 to 9 are the legal heirs of the said
Rajendran.
13. According to the Plaintiff, the said Subbanna Gounder died intestate
and thereby, she is entitled to 1/8 share over the Suit properties. According to
Page 9 of 16
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 17/11/2026 05:48:47 pm )
SA No. 259 of 2014
the defendants 1 and 2, the said Subbanna Gounder, during his life time,
executed a registered Will dated 16.05.1986 in favour of his sons, i.e., the
defendants 1 and 2 and the deceased Rajendran. The said Subbanna Gounder
died on 28.11.1993. After the demise of Subbanna Gounder, the Will came into
effect. Once the defendants 1 and 2 pleaded about the Will, it is for them to
prove the Will in the manner known to law. In order to prove the Will, on the
side of the defendants, they examined DW2, the attesting witness of the Will
and he deposed about the execution and attestation of the Will. Another
attesting witness namely Narayanasamy died. DW2 has categorically stated
st
that the father the 1 defendant executed a Will in favour of his three sons and
he attested in the Will as a first witness and he witnessed the signature of the
Testator as well as the another attesting witness. The Plaintiff has also not
pleaded anything about the surrounding suspicious circumstances over the Will.
st
The Will has been marked as ‘Ex.B.2’. Therefore, the 1 defendant has proved
the execution of the Will in accordance with law.
14. As per the Will, the defendants 1 and 2 and the deceased Rajendran,
who is the another son of Subbanna Gounder, are equally entitled to the Suit
properties. Since the properties are separate properties of Maruthey Gounder,
after his demise, the Subbanna Gounder, as Class-I legal heir, was entitled to the
properties through succession, thereby, the properties are the separate properties
Page 10 of 16
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 17/11/2026 05:48:47 pm )
SA No. 259 of 2014
of the Subbanna Gounder. Once the properties are separate properties of
Subbanna Gounder, he is entitled to alienate his properties as per his wish. The
defendants 1, 2 and 7 to 9 have relied upon the Will dated 16.05.1986 executed
by the said Subbanna Gounder and the same has been proved in accordance
with law, thereby, the defendants 1, 2 and 7 to 9 are entitled to the properties
and other legal heirs, who are the daughters of Subbanna Gounder, are not
entitled to any share over the properties. However, the trial Court has
disbelieved the evidence of DW2 and rendered findings that ‘since the scribe of
the Will has not been examined and the daughters were also excluded from the
Will, the Will was surrounded by suspicious circumstances’. Merely because
the female heirs were excluded from the Will, that itself is not the sole ground
to suspect the Will and that alone is not the suspicious circumstance. Whereas
the trial Court failed to consider the cogency and the natural evidence of DW2,
attesting witness of the Will. Further the trial Court has treated the properties as
co-parcenary properties and rendered erroneous findings that the properties are
co-parcenary properties and the daughters and sons are equally entitled to share
over the properties as co-parceners.
15. The First Appellate Court in the judgment stated that ‘since the
Subbanna Gounder inherited the properties from his father Maruthey Gounder,
the defendants 1, 2 and the deceased Rajendran are entitled to get equal share by
Page 11 of 16
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 17/11/2026 05:48:47 pm )
SA No. 259 of 2014
birth right, because the properties in the hands of Subbanna Gounder can be
considered to be the ancestral properties in the hands of the defendants 1, 2 and
the deceased Rajendran’. The above said findings of the First Appellate Court
are erroneous and the First Appellate Court failed to consider the settled
position of law that the Subbanna Gounder inherited the separate properties of
his father Maruthey Gounder as Class-I legal heir under Section 8 of the Hindu
Succession Act and rendered erroneous findings that the properties of Subbanna
Gounder can be treated to be ancestral properties. Therefore, the judgments and
decrees passed by the Courts below are not in accordance with law.
16. The learned counsel appearing for the appellants has relied upon the
following judgments:
(i) Govindan and another v. Revathi and others reported in 2019 SCC OnLine Mad
39757.
(ii) Arunagiri v. Ayyar Muthuraja and others reported in 2014 (1) CTC 73.
(iii) M. Premkumar and others v. P. Murugan and others in A.S. (MD) No.177 of
2018.
(iv) S. Dakshina v. Chinnaponnu and others reported in (2012) 7 MLJ 414.
Page 12 of 16
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 17/11/2026 05:48:47 pm )
SA No. 259 of 2014
On a careful perusal of the above said judgments, it is clear that a
property that is inherited by an Hindu on the death of his father as Class-I legal
heir under Section 8 of the Hindu Succession Act will not partake the character
of co-parcenary property qua his children and he will be absolute owner of the
property and he has absolute power of alienation over the property. In the case
on hand also, the Marthanna Gounder @ Maruthey Gounder purchased the
properties in his name and thereafter his son Subbanna Gounder inherited the
properties as Class-I legal heir and thereby, the said properties are separate
properties of Subbanna Gounder and during his life time, the Subbanna
Gounder executed a registered Will in favour of his sons and thereby, the other
legal heirs are not entitled to share over the Suit properties.
17. As far as the substantial questions of law are concerned, it is an
admitted fact that the Suit properties belonged to Maruthey Gounder absolutely
and after his demise, the properties were devolved on his son Subbanna
Gounder and thereby, they are the absolute properties of Subbanna Gounder and
therefore the said properties cannot be treated as co-parcenary properties. When
the properties were inherited by Subbanna Gounder as Class-I legal heir under
Section 8 of the Hindu Succession Act, the findings of the First Appellate Court
that ‘Subbanna Gounder is a co-parcener and he is entitled to only 1/8 share and
thereby he can executed the Will only to that extent’ are erroneous. Since the
Page 13 of 16
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 17/11/2026 05:48:47 pm )
SA No. 259 of 2014
properties are separate properties of Subbanna Gounder, neither the sons nor the
daughters of Subbanna Gounder are entitled to share in the Suit properties as
co-parceners. Thereby, the findings of the First Appellate Court that the sons
and daughters of the Subbanna Gounder are entitled to Suit properties as co-
parcenery properties of their grand father, are contrary to the settled proposition
of law. Therefore, the substantial questions of law are answered in favour of the
appellants and as against the respondents.
18. In view of the above said discussions and answers to the substantial
questions of law, the judgment and decree passed by the Courts below are liable
to be set aside and the Plaintiff, who is the daughter of Subbanna Gounder is not
entitled to any share as the said Subbanna Gounder has himself executed a
registered Will dated 16.05.1986 in favour of his sons. Therefore, the decree
and judgment passed by the Courts below are liable to be set aside.
19. In the result, the Second Appeal stands allowed. The judgment and
decree passed by the trial Court in O.S. No.89 of 2006 dated 03.09.2007 on the
file of the Subordinate Judge, Coimbatore and the First Appellate Court vide
a judgment and decree passed in A.S No.43 of 2008 dated 22.08.2013 on the
file of the IV Additional District Judge, Coimbatore are set aside . The Suit in
O.S. No.89 of 2006 is dismissed.
Page 14 of 16
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 17/11/2026 05:48:47 pm )
SA No. 259 of 2014
There shall be no order as to costs. Consequently, the connected
miscellaneous petition is closed.
16-11-2026
Index: Yes/No
Speaking/Non-speaking order
Neutral Citation: Yes/No
MJS
To
1. The IV Additional District Judge, Coimbatore .
2. The Subordinate Judge, Coimbatore.
Page 15 of 16
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 17/11/2026 05:48:47 pm )
SA No. 259 of 2014
P.DHANABAL, J.
MJS
PRE-DELIVERY JUDGMENT IN
SA No. 259 of 2014
16-11-2026
Page 16 of 16
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 17/11/2026 05:48:47 pm )