Mehboob Shah vs State Of Madhya Pradesh

Court
Supreme Court

2026 INSC 729
NON-REPORTABLE

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION


CRIMINAL APPEAL NO(S)……………………OF 2026
(Arising out of SLP(Crl.) No(s).5946-5947 of 2026)



MEHBOOB SHAH …APPELLANT(S)

Versus

STATE OF MADHYA PRADESH …RESPONDENT(S)



J U D G M E N T

SANJAY KAROL J.

1. Leave Granted.

2. The present appeals arises out of the impugned judgment and order dated
29.09.2011 passed by the High Court of Madhya Pradesh, Bench at Indore, in
Criminal Appeal No.390/1997, whereby the High Court affirmed the judgment
and order of conviction dated 07.04.1997 passed by the Court of Additional
1
Sessions Judge Garoth, District – Mandsaur, Madhya Pradesh , in Special Crl.
Signature Not Verified
Case No. 123 of 1996, whereby the appellant, Mehboob Shah, was convicted
Digitally signed by
SOURAV PAL
Date: 2026.07.21
17:26:37 IST
Reason:

1
Hereinafter referred to as the 'Trial Court.'
CRL.APP.NOS……/2026@ SLP(CRL.)NOS.5946-5947 OF 2026 1

under Sections 8 and 21 of the Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances Act
2
1985 and sentenced to undergo a rigorous imprisonment for 14 years along with
a fine of Rs.1 Lakh, and in default of payment of fine, to undergo RI for a further
period of two years.

3. The case of the prosecution, as emerging from the record, is that on
23.06.1996, ASI Indrabhan Singh Parihar (PW-9) received confidential
information that the appellant was carrying contraband ( smack ), concealed in a
water bottle, and was about to board the train, DN Frontier Mail, going towards
Delhi. Acting upon the said information, PW-9 apprehended the appellant and
allegedly recovered 100 grams of smack from the water bottle carried by him.
Thereafter, PW-9 drew two representative samples of 5 grams each at the spot,
seized the contraband and arrested the appellant. Consequently, FIR No.302/1996
was registered against him.

4. The Trial Court, upon consideration of oral and documentary evidence,
found the appellant guilty of offences punishable under Sections 8 and 21 of the
NDPS Act. It held that the prosecution had proved beyond reasonable doubt that
100 grams of smack had been recovered from the water bottle found in the
possession of the appellant. The Trial Court further observed that the procedural
requirements prescribed under the NDPS Act had been substantially complied
with. Accordingly, the appellant was convicted and sentenced as set forth in
Paragraph 2.

5. Aggrieved thereby, the appellant preferred an appeal before the High Court
which, vide the impugned order and judgment dated 29.09.2011, affirmed the
order of the Trial Court and held as under:

2
Hereinafter referred to as ‘NDPS’.
CRL.APP.NOS……/2026@ SLP(CRL.)NOS.5946-5947 OF 2026 2

“20. In the case in hand, the water bottle carried by the accused on his
shoulder was searched and the smack was found in that water bottle As
per Ex-P/2 it is crystal clear that nothing incriminating was found from
the appellant-accused when his personal search was made. The water
bottle was searched at the first instance and therefore, there was no
requirement at all to inform the appellant his right to be searched in the
presence of the Gazetted Officer or Magistrate.. In view of the
discussions made earlier, Section 50 of the Act can have no application
on the facts and circumstances of the present case as heroin was
allegedly recovered from the watter bottle which was being carried by
the accused. Therefore, the search conducted by the Investigating
Officer and the evidence collected thereby, is not illegal. Not only this,
we have found that by giving option the appellant was apprised of his
right and therefore, the provisions of Section 50 of the Act was fully
complied with.
21. Consequently, we do not find any merit in the contentions of the
learned counsel for the appellant as regards the non compliance of
Section 50 of the Act.
… … …
23. In the present case, the trial Court by applying the recognized
principle of evaluation of evidence have rightly come to the conclusion
that appellant was arrested and smack was recovered from the water
bottle for which he had no licence. We find no good reasons to differ
from that finding.
… … …
25. The other point argued by the learned counsel is that there were
discrepancies as to weight of the recovered contraband. Insofar as the
recovery of contraband smack is concerned, it has been fully established
that 100 gms. of smack was recovered and the samples thereof were
sent to the FSL along with the seals. The documents like panchnama
and seizure memos clearly bring out the position that 100 gm. of smack
was found in the plastic bag. In that backdrop, the error committed by
the witnesses. could be attributed to failure of human memory which is
inconsequential. Under these circumstances, we are unable to agree
with the contention raised before us by the learned counsel for the
appellant. In our view, there is no infirmity in the judgment impugned
nor on that ground the same can be set aside.
… … …
28. In the case in hand, there is a difference of 5 gms. in weight, in the
facts and circumstances of this case, is of not much significance. The
difference was minimal. In view of the law laid down in the case of
Dahel Singh(supra) , the said discrepancy in weight is not fatal, neither
on that ground it can be said that the prosecution has failed to prove its
case beyond all reasonable doubts nor it creates serious doubt to the
credibility of the prosecution case.
29. The learned trial Court after placing reliance on the testimony of the
PW.6 and PW.9 and considering the material evidence on record was
of the opinion that the case of the prosecution was fully established. The
view taken by the trial Court is plausible view. All the mandatory
provisions of the Act had been complied with by the prosecution. The
CRL.APP.NOS……/2026@ SLP(CRL.)NOS.5946-5947 OF 2026 3

trial Court has assigned statutory reasons for convicting the appellant
under Section 8/21 of the N.D.P.S. Act. We found that no case for
reducing the sentence and fine as alternatively prayed by the appellant
is made out.
30. For the above mentioned reasons, the appeal filed by the appellant
has no merit and is, accordingly, dismissed . Appellant is on bail. He
shall be taken into custody immediately for serving out rest of the
sentence. His bail bonds are cancelled.”

6. Assailing the aforesaid orders of conviction and sentence, the appellant has
preferred the present appeal. The main ground of challenge is that the prosecution
failed to comply with the requirements of Sections 50 and 52A of the NDPS Act.
It is contended that the appellant was not effectively informed of his right under
Section 50 of the NDPS Act to be searched before a Gazetted Officer or a
Magistrate; representative samples were drawn by PW-9 himself, at the time of
seizure and not in the presence of a Magistrate, contrary to Section 52A of the
NDPS Act; and that the independent witnesses to the seizure turned hostile and
did not support the prosecution, thereby rendering the prosecution’s case
doubtful. Without prejudice to the aforesaid submissions, it is further prayed that,
if the conviction is sustained, the appellant should be extended the benefit of
amended Section 21, as substituted by the Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic
3
Substances Amendment Act 2001 , which introduced a quantity-based sentencing
regime. Alternatively, if the unamended Section 21 is held to be applicable, the
appellant be awarded the minimum sentence of 10 years prescribed thereunder,
as no aggravating circumstances exist to justify the imposition of a higher
sentence.

7. We have heard Mr. Sushil Kumar Jain, learned Senior Counsel for the
appellant and Mr. Pashupathi Nath Razdan, learned Advocate on Record for the

3
Hereinafter referred to as the ‘2001 Amendment Act’.
CRL.APP.NOS……/2026@ SLP(CRL.)NOS.5946-5947 OF 2026 4

respondent State, as also Mr. Sidharth Luthra, learned amicus curiae appointed
by us and perused the material placed on record.

8. At the outset, it is pertinent to reiterate that although the power of this Court
under Article 136 of the Constitution of India is wide and can be exercised even
in cases where the Courts below have returned concurrent findings of fact, such
power should be exercised only in exceptional circumstances. It is trite law that
this Court will not readily interfere with the concurrent findings of fact unless
they are shown to be perverse, erroneous or unsustainable in law. In Ganga
4
Kumar Srivastava v. State of Bihar this Court discussed the circumstances in
which such interference may be warranted and laid down the following
principles:
“ 10. From the aforesaid series of decisions of this Court on the exercise
of power of the Supreme Court under Article 136 of the Constitution
following principles emerge:
( i ) The powers of this Court under Article 136 of the Constitution are
very wide but in criminal appeals this Court does not interfere with the
concurrent findings of fact save in exceptional circumstances .
( ii ) It is open to this Court to interfere with the findings of fact given by
the High Court, if the High Court has acted perversely or otherwise
improperly .
( iii ) It is open to this Court to invoke the power under Article 136 only
in very exceptional circumstances as and when a question of law of
general public importance arises or a decision shocks the conscience of
the Court .
( iv ) When the evidence adduced by the prosecution fell short of the test
of reliability and acceptability and as such it is highly unsafe to act upon
it.
( v ) Where the appreciation of evidence and finding is vitiated by any
error of law of procedure or found contrary to the principles of natural
justice, errors of record and misreading of the evidence, or where the
conclusions of the High Court are manifestly perverse and
unsupportable from the evidence on record .”

(emphasis in original)


4
(2005) 6 SCC 211.
CRL.APP.NOS……/2026@ SLP(CRL.)NOS.5946-5947 OF 2026 5

9. Keeping in view the exposition of law, we shall now proceed to examine
the material placed on record and determine whether the conviction recorded by
the Courts below warrants any interference.

10. The first submission advanced on behalf of the appellant is that the case of
the prosecution is doubtful since the independent witnesses to the seizure have
turned hostile; therefore, the conviction could not have been based solely on the
testimony of the police officials. It is well settled that the testimony of official
witnesses cannot be disregarded or distrusted merely on account of their official
status or for want of corroboration by independent witnesses. Examination of
independent witnesses is not an indispensable requirement and their non-support
or absence is not necessarily fatal to the prosecution’s case. A conviction may be
based on the testimony of official witnesses, provided such testimony is found to
5
be reliable and trustworthy. [See: Rizwan Khan v. State of Chhattisgarh ]

11. In the present case, we find that the prosecution has successfully proved its
case against the appellant by examining PW-3 (Ashok Singh), PW-6 (Subhas),
PW-9 (Indrabhan Singh Parihar) and PW-10 (CL Verma). It is true that all the
aforesaid witnesses are police officials and the two independent witnesses to the
seizure memo, namely PW-1 (Shantilal) and PW-2 (Babulal), turned hostile.
However, the testimony of the official witnesses inspires confidence. They have
uniformly deposed about the search, seizure and recovery of the contraband from
the appellant. Moreover, they were thoroughly cross-examined by the defence but
nothing has been brought on record to discredit their version or cast any doubt on
their credibility. We find their evidence reliable and trustworthy and see no reason
to disbelieve or discard it. Therefore, we are of the considered view that the
Courts below committed no error in relying upon the said witnesses.

5
(2020) 9 SCC 627.
CRL.APP.NOS……/2026@ SLP(CRL.)NOS.5946-5947 OF 2026 6

12. The next contention of the appellant pertains to the alleged non-compliance
of Section 50 of the NDPS Act. We find the same to be devoid of merit. Section
50 of the NDPS Act confers upon an accused a valuable right to have his personal
search conducted before a Gazetted Officer or a Magistrate, if he so requires.
Such right is sacrosanct and indefeasible which cannot be disregarded by the
6
prosecution except at its own peril. [See: State of Punjab v. Baldev Singh ] The
protection under Section 50 is confined to cases where the recovery is sought to
be effected through the personal search of the accused. It has no application where
the search is of an article, such as a bag, container, suitcase or any other object,
7
which the accused may be carrying. [See: State of H.P. v. Pawan Kuma r and
8
Ranjan Kumar Chadha v. State of H.P. ]

13. In the instant case, given that the contraband was recovered from a water
bottle which the appellant was carrying and not from his person, Section 50 of
the NDPS Act has no application. Even otherwise, the evidence on record clearly
shows that the appellant was apprised of his right to be searched before a
Magistrate or a Gazetted Officer. The Report for Grant of Consent (Exhibit P-1)
records that PW-9 informed the appellant that he had the option to be searched
before a Magistrate or Gazetted Officer. The relevant extract thereof is
reproduced hereunder for ready reference:
“Particulars of Consent
In the presence of above named witnesses, I, the ASI Indrabhan Singh
Parihar have informed above named Mahboob Muslim standing under
the Overbridge at Platform No.2 of Railway Station Shamgarh that we
have received an input that you have kept hidden narcotic substance
called smack in your water bottle. I have to search your water bottle. If
you wish you can give your search to any Magistrate or Gazetted
Officer or I in their presence, on which above Mahboob is ready to give

6
(1999) 6 SCC 172.
7
(2005) 4 SCC 350.
8
2023 SCC OnLine SC 1262.
CRL.APP.NOS……/2026@ SLP(CRL.)NOS.5946-5947 OF 2026 7

his search to I, he ASI Parihar. Report for grant of consent was prepared
and read over, which being acknowledged to be true was signed by the
witnesses in my presence.”

The contents of the aforesaid document are duly corroborated by the testimonies
of PW-6 (Constable Subhas) and PW-9 (ASI Indrabhan Singh Parihar), both of
whom have consistently deposed that before conducting the search, the appellant
was given the option of being in the presence of a Gazetted Officer or a
Magistrate. Thus, even though Section 50 had no application, the appellant was
nevertheless informed of the safeguard prescribed thereunder.

14. The appellant has further contended that there has been non-compliance
with Section 52A of the NDPS Act, inasmuch as the representative samples were
not drawn in the presence of a Magistrate. We are unable to accept the said
submission. It is well settled that mere delayed compliance or non-compliance of
the procedure envisaged under Section 52A does not, by itself, entitle the accused
to claim acquittal in the trial, when sufficient material is collected by the
Investigating Officer to establish that the search and seizure of the contraband
was conducted in accordance with the mandatory provisions of the NDPS Act.
Where non-compliance of Section 52A of the NDPS Act is alleged, the
prosecution must prove either substantial compliance with the mandate of Section
52A of the NDPS Act or satisfy the Court that such non-compliance has not
affected its case against the accused. [See: Bharat Aambale v. State of
9
Chhattisgarh ] The ambit and scope of the aforesaid section has been discussed
in detail by a co-ordinate Bench of this Court in Narcotics Control Bureau v.
10
Kashif , wherein it was held as under:
“ 42. Significantly, the authorised officer can make the application
under sub-section (2) of Section 52-A for three purposes — ( a ) for
certifying the correctness of the inventory prepared by him; or ( b )
taking in presence of such Magistrate, photographs of the seized drugs,

9
(2025) 8 SCC 452.
10
(2024) 11 SCC 372.
CRL.APP.NOS……/2026@ SLP(CRL.)NOS.5946-5947 OF 2026 8

substances and conveyances and certifying such photographs as true; or
( c ) allowing to draw representative samples of such drugs or substances,
in the presence of such Magistrate, and certifying the correctness of any
list of samples so drawn. The use of the conjunction “OR” made in
between the three purposes mentioned therein, itself makes it explicitly
clear that the purposes for which the application could be made under
sub-section (2) are alternative and not cumulative in nature. Such
provision specifying multiple alternative purposes could not be
construed as a mandatory provision much less its non-compliance fatal
to the case of prosecution.
43. Though it is true that the inventory certified, photographs taken and
the list of samples drawn under sub-section (2) has to be treated by the
court as primary evidence in view of sub-section (3), nonetheless the
documents like panchnama, seizure memo, arrest memo, etc. prepared
by the investigating officer on the spot or during the course of
investigation are also primary evidence within the meaning of Section
62 of the Evidence Act, carrying the same evidentiary value as any other
primary evidence. Such primary evidence with regard to search and
seizure of the contraband substance could not be overlooked merely
because some lapse or non-compliance is found of Section 52-A of the
Act.
… … …
45. None of the provisions in the Act prohibits sample to be taken on
the spot at the time of seizure, much less Section 52-A of the said Act.
On the contrary, as per the procedure laid down in the Standing Orders
and notifications issued by the NCB and the Central Government before
and after the insertion of Section 52-A till the 2022 Rules were framed,
the officer concerned was required to take samples of the seized
contraband substances on the spot of recovery in duplicate in the
presence of the panch witnesses and the person in whose possession the
drug or substance recovered, by drawing a panchnama. It was only with
regard to the remnant substance, the procedure for disposal of the said
substance was required to be followed as prescribed in Section 52-A.
… … …
50. The upshot of the above discussion may be summarised as under:
… … …
50.3. The purpose of insertion of Section 52-A laying down the
procedure for disposal of seized narcotic drugs and psychotropic
substances, was to ensure the early disposal of the seized contraband
drugs and substances. It was inserted in 1989 as one of the measures to
implement and to give effect to the International Conventions on the
narcotic drugs and psychotropic substances.
50.4. Sub-section (2) of Section 52-A lays down the procedure as
contemplated in sub-section (1) thereof, and any lapse or delayed
compliance thereof would be merely a procedural irregularity which
would neither entitle the accused to be released on bail nor would vitiate
the trial on that ground alone.
CRL.APP.NOS……/2026@ SLP(CRL.)NOS.5946-5947 OF 2026 9

50.5. Any procedural irregularity or illegality found to have been
committed in conducting the search and seizure during the course of
investigation or thereafter, would by itself not make the entire evidence
collected during the course of investigation, inadmissible. The court
would have to consider all the circumstances and find out whether any
serious prejudice has been caused to the accused.
50.6. Any lapse or delay in compliance with Section 52-A by itself
would neither vitiate the trial nor would entitle the accused to be
released on bail. The court will have to consider other circumstances
and the other primary evidence collected during the course of
investigation, as also the statutory presumption permissible under
Section 54 of the NDPS Act.”

15. It is undisputed that the samples were drawn by PW-9 himself at the time
of seizure and not in the presence of a Magistrate. However, the appellant has
failed to demonstrate that such non-compliance has caused him any serious
prejudice. It is pertinent to note that the NDPS Act, as it then stood, did not
prohibit drawing of samples at the spot of seizure. As noticed above, the
requirement under Section 52A is procedural in nature. The documents like
panchnama , seizure memo, arrest memo, etc., prepared by the Investigating
Officer on the spot or during the course of investigation constitute primary
evidence, with regard to search and seizure of the contraband, which cannot be
overlooked merely because of some lapse or non-compliance is found with
Section 52A of the Act. [See: Kashif (supra)]

16. In the facts of the present case, the prosecution has adduced cogent oral
and documentary evidence to establish the recovery of the contraband including
seizure memo and panchnama . The record further reveals that the samples were
duly sealed in the presence of the appellant and were thereafter sent to the
Forensic Science Laboratory, Indore, for chemical examination, which confirmed
the seized substance to be diacetylmorphine (smack/heroin). It is nobody’s case
that the chain of custody was broken or that the samples were tampered with. In
these circumstances, the fact that the samples were not drawn in the presence of
CRL.APP.NOS……/2026@ SLP(CRL.)NOS.5946-5947 OF 2026 10

a Magistrate is merely a procedural irregularity and cannot be ground for
acquittal.

17. In view of the foregoing discussion, we find that the Trial Court and the
High Court have meticulously appreciated the entire evidence. On such close
scrutiny, both the Courts below have rightly concluded that the prosecution has
proved its case beyond reasonable doubt. We find no perversity or legal infirmity
in the findings recorded by the Courts below so as to warrant interference under
Article 136 of the Constitution.

18. Alternatively, the appellant has prayed that he be extended the benefit of
Section 21 of the amended NDPS Act, which introduced a quantity based
sentencing regime. It was submitted that the quantity of contraband allegedly
recovered from the appellant falls much below the commercial quantity specified
under the amended provision. In our considered opinion, such relief cannot be
granted. Section 41 of the Act 9 of 2001, i.e., the 2001 Amendment Act, expressly
provides that the amended provisions would only apply to cases which were
pending before the Trial Courts or under investigation as on 02.10.2001, the date
on which the 2001 Amendment Act came into force. The proviso thereto
specifically excludes cases where the trial had concluded, and the matter was
11
pending in appeal. [See: Basheer v. State of Kerala ] As the appellant had
already been convicted by the Trial Court on 07.04.1997 and his appeal was
pending before the High Court when the Amendment Act came into force, the
benefit of the amended Section 21 cannot be extended to him.

19. However, considering that the unamended Section 21 prescribed a
minimum sentence of 10 years and there are no aggravating circumstances
warranting the imposition of a higher sentence, we are of the view that the ends

11
(2004) 3 SCC 609.
CRL.APP.NOS……/2026@ SLP(CRL.)NOS.5946-5947 OF 2026 11

of justice would be adequately met if the sentence awarded to the appellant is
reduced to the minimum prescribed thereunder.

20. For the reasons stated above, the appeals are partly allowed. The conviction
of the appellant under Sections 8 and 21 of the NDPS Act is affirmed. The
impugned judgments of the Trial Court and the High Court are modified only to
the extent of the sentence awarded to the appellant, which is reduced from 14
years to 10 years of rigorous imprisonment. The punishment of a fine of Rs.1
Lakh is maintained. If the fine has not already been deposited, the appellant shall
deposit the same within a period of three months, failing which he shall undergo
rigorous imprisonment for a further period of one year.

21. We appreciate the efforts put in by the learned amicus curiae Mr. Sidharth
Luthra.

Pending application(s), if any, shall stand disposed of.



………………………………………….…J.
(SANJAY KAROL)




……………………………………….…….J.
(NONGMEIKAPAM KOTISWAR SINGH)



NEW DELHI;
st
21 July 2026

CRL.APP.NOS……/2026@ SLP(CRL.)NOS.5946-5947 OF 2026 12