VENKATESH vs THE STATE OF KARNATAKA

Court
Karnataka High Court

- 1 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:10748-DB
WP No. 201304 of 2026

CNR: KAHC030034612026




IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA


KALABURAGI BENCH

TH
DATED THIS THE 30 DAY OF SEPTEMBER, 2026

PRESENT


THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE ASHOK S. KINAGI

AND

THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SUBRAMANYA RANGARAO



WRIT PETITION NO. 201304 OF 2026 (S-KAT)


BETWEEN:

SRI. VENKATESH
S/O SANJEEVAPPA,
AGE. 49 YEARS,
OCC. WORKING AS REVENUE INSPECTOR,
TAHASILDAR OFFICE,
HUNASAGI
DIST. YADGIRI,
R/AT NARAHAR COLONY,
NEAR BUS STAND,
TAVARAGER
TQ. KUSTAGI,
DIST. KOPPAL-583 279.
…PETITIONER

(BY SRI. AVINASH A UPLAONKAR., ADVOCATE)

AND:

1. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA







Digitally signed
by B NAGAVENI
Location: HIGH
COURT OF
KARNATAKA

REPRESENTED BY ITS PRINCIPAL SECRETARY,
REVENUE DEPARTMENT,

- 2 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:10748-DB
WP No. 201304 of 2026

CNR: KAHC030034612026



MS BUILDING,
BENGALURU-560 001.

2. THE REGIONAL COMMISSIONER
REVENUE DEPARTMENT,
KALABURAGI DIVISION,
KALABURAGI-585 102.

3. THE DEPUTY COMMISSIONER
REVENUE DEPARTMENT,
YADGIRI DISTRICT,
YADGIRI-509 209.

4. THE TAHASHILDAR
REVENUE DEPARTMENT,
HUNASAGI TALUK,
YADGIRI DISTRICT-585 215.

5. THE HON'BLE KARNATAKA LOKAYUKTA
REPRESENTED BY ITS REGISTRAR
LOKAYUKTA,
M.S. BUILDING,
DR. B.R. AMBEDKAR ROAD,
BENGALURU-560 001.
…RESPONDENTS

(BY SRI.VEERANAGOUDA MALIPATIL, AGA FOR R1 TO R4
SRI. GOURISH S. KHASHAMPUR, ADVOCATE FOR R5)

THIS WRIT PETITION IS FILED UNDER ARTICLES 226
AND 227 OF THE CONSTITUTION OF INDIA, PRAYING TO
ISSUE WRIT OR ORDER OF CERTIORARI BY SETTING
ASIDE THE IMPUGNED ORDER OF DISMISSING THE
APPLICATION FILED BY THE PETITIONER BEFORE THE
KARNATAKA ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL IN APPLICATION
NO.20956/2023 ORDER DATED 06.03.2026, VIDE
ANNEXURE-B AND QUASH THE DECISION / ORDER TAKEN

- 3 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:10748-DB
WP No. 201304 of 2026

CNR: KAHC030034612026



BY THE 1ST RESPONDENT VIDE ORDER BEARING
NO.KAME 05 BDP 2012 DATED 12.10.2023, PASSED BY
THE 1ST RESPONDENT (VIDE ANNEXURE-A-12), IN THE
INTEREST OF JUSTICE AND EQUITY.

THIS PETITION, COMING ON FOR FINAL HEARING,
THIS DAY, ORDER WAS MADE THEREIN AS UNDER:

CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE ASHOK S. KINAGI
and
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SUBRAMANYA RANGARAO

ORAL ORDER

(PER: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE ASHOK S. KINAGI)


The petitioner has filed this writ petition challenging
the order dated 06.03.2026 passed by the Karnataka
Administrative Tribunal in Application No.20956/2023.

2. The brief facts leading to the filing of this writ
petition are as follows:
Respondent No. 5 submitted a report under Section
12(3) of the Karnataka Lokayukta Act, 1984 on
27.12.2011, seeking an inquiry into the same allegations.

- 4 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:10748-DB
WP No. 201304 of 2026

CNR: KAHC030034612026



Based on that report, respondent No. 1 entrusted the
matter to respondent No. 5 under Rule 14(a) of the
Karnataka Civil Services (Classification, Control and
Appeals) Rules, 1957 (hereinafter, “the 1957 Rules”). On
28.04.2012, pursuant to the entrustment order, the
inquiry was entrusted to the Additional Registrar of
Enquiries-04, who issued the articles of charge on the
same date. After conducting the inquiry, the Inquiry
Officer submitted a report to the Upalokayukta on
31.07.2019. Respondent No. 5, along with its
recommendations, forwarded the report to respondent No.
1 on 02.08.2019. Without considering the facts and
circumstances of the case or applying its mind to the
inquiry report and recommendations, respondent No. 1
issued a second show-cause notice on 18.11.2019, calling
upon the petitioner to respond within 15 days. The
petitioner submitted a reply to the second show-cause
notice on 06.02.2020. After considering the petitioner’s
explanation, the Government passed the impugned order

- 5 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:10748-DB
WP No. 201304 of 2026

CNR: KAHC030034612026



dated 12.10.2023, imposing the punishment of
compulsory retirement under Rule 8(vi) of the 1957 Rules,
as recommended by respondent No. 5. Aggrieved by the
order of punishment, the petitioner approached the
Karnataka State Administrative Tribunal, Kalaburagi
Bench, in Application No. 20956/2023. By order dated
06.03.2026, the Tribunal dismissed the application. Hence,
this writ petition.

3. Heard the learned counsel for the petitioner,
the learned Additional Government Advocate, and the
learned counsel appearing for the Lokayukta.

4. Learned counsel for the petitioner submits that
the petitioner was acquitted in the criminal case and has
produced a copy of the judgment dated 19.09.2018
passed in Special Case No. 38/2011. He submits that the
Inquiry Officer’s report is perverse and unsupported by
evidence. He further submits that the petitioner was

- 6 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:10748-DB
WP No. 201304 of 2026

CNR: KAHC030034612026



acquitted in the criminal case on the same set of charges
as those in the disciplinary proceedings; the charges
framed in both proceedings are identical, and the
witnesses examined in both proceedings are also the
same. He submits that the petitioner was acquitted
because the prosecution failed to prove the case beyond
reasonable doubt.

5. In support of his submissions, learned counsel
relies on the judgments of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in
M AHARANA P RATAP S INGH V . S TATE OF B IHAR , C IVIL A PPEAL
O DECIDED ON ANK V
N . 5497/2025, 23.04.2025; G.M. T .
TATE OF UJARAT REPORTED IN AND
S G , (2006) 5 SCC 446;
C APT . M. P AUL A NTHONY V . B HARAT G OLD M INES L TD . &
A NR ., REPORTED IN (1999) 3 SCC 679. H E ALSO RELIES ON
THE D IVISION B ENCH JUDGMENT OF THIS C OURT IN A EJAZ
H USSAIN V . S TATE OF K ARNATAKA & O RS ., W.P. N O .
203239/2019, DECIDED ON 29.05.2020 . On these
grounds, he prays that the writ petition be allowed.

- 7 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:10748-DB
WP No. 201304 of 2026

CNR: KAHC030034612026



6. Per contra , the learned Government Advocate
submits that the petitioner’s acquittal in the criminal case
is not, by itself, a ground for dropping the disciplinary
proceedings. She further submits that the charges are
stated to have been established in the disciplinary
proceedings on the basis of the evidence, applying the
standard of preponderance of probabilities. She contends
that the disciplinary authority rightly passed the impugned
order of punishment and, on these grounds, prays that the
writ petition be dismissed.

7. Per contra , learned counsel appearing for the
Lokayukta supports the impugned order. In support of his
submissions, he relies on the judgment of the Hon’ble
Supreme Court in S TATE B ANK OF I NDIA & ORS V . P.
Z ADENGA , C IVIL A PPEAL N O . 2518/2012, DECIDED ON
03.10.2023; D Y . I NSPECTOR G ENERAL OF P OLICE & A NR . V .
S. S AMUTHIRAM , C IVIL A PPEAL N O . 8513/2012, DECIDED
ON AND THE JUDGMENT IN HE NION OF
30.11.2012; T U

- 8 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:10748-DB
WP No. 201304 of 2026

CNR: KAHC030034612026



I NDIA & ORS V . J AYASHANKAR K.T., W.A. N O .5731/2012
DATED 18.12.2019 . On these grounds, he prays that the
writ petition be dismissed.

8. Perused the records and considered the
submissions of learned counsel for the parties.

9. It is undisputed that respondent No. 5
submitted a report under Section 12(3) of the Karnataka
Lokayukta Act, 1984 seeking an inquiry into the
allegations against the petitioner. Respondent No. 1
entrusted the matter to respondent No. 5 under Rule
14(a) of the 1957 Rules. The articles of charge were
issued, and, after conducting an inquiry, the Inquiry
Officer submitted a report finding that the charges against
the petitioner were proved. The disciplinary authority
issued a second show-cause notice along with the inquiry
report, calling upon the petitioner to submit an
explanation. The petitioner submitted a reply. Thereafter,

- 9 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:10748-DB
WP No. 201304 of 2026

CNR: KAHC030034612026



respondent No. 1 imposed the punishment of compulsory
retirement by order dated 12.10.2023. A criminal case had
also been registered against the petitioner in Crime No.
1/2009 on 12.02.2009. The case was tried by the Sessions
Court as S.C. No. 38/2011. The charges leveled against
the petitioner in the criminal proceedings and the
departmental proceedings are set out below:
CHARGE IN CRIMINAL
CASE
CHARGE IN
DEPARTMENTAL ENQUIRY
Points for
Consideration on the
charge in Spl. Case No.
38/2011 (Para No. 6
and P.No.115)
Page No. 44 (Annexure-
A-5)

That, you DGO-1 Sri
Venkatesh son of
Sanjeevappa and you DGO-2
Gopal son of Hanumappa
Guragunti while working as
Revenue Inspector of
Surapura taluk and Village
Assistant in the office of the
Tahasildar, respectively, the
complainant namely Sri
Ramaiah s/o Kariyappa
resident of Mavinamatti in
Surpur taluk of Yadgir district
filed application to enter the
Whether prosecution
proves that accused No.1
being the public servant
along with accused No.2
who is reported dead,
demanded an amount of
Rs. 1,500/- for the
purpose of set-righting
the pahani records of Sy.
No. 33 of Mavinamatti
village and on 12.02.2009
at about 1:45 p.m.
received the illegal
gratification of Rs. 1,500/-

- 10 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:10748-DB
WP No. 201304 of 2026

CNR: KAHC030034612026



correct extent of land as 29
acres 26 guntas instead of 39
acre 4 guntas in his name in
Sy.no.33 of his village
Mavinamatti and you DGO-1
demanded bribe of Rs.1,500/-
from the complainant to enter
correct extent of land to his
name and on 12-02-2009,
you DGO-1 received the said
bribe of Rs.1,500/- through
you DGO-2 from the
complainant to show official
favour failing to maintain
absolute integrity, devotion to
duty and thereby committed
mis-conduct as enumerated
U/R Q. duty 3(1)(i) to (iii) of
Karnataka Civil Service
(Conduct) Rules 1966.
from the complainant
their private office at
Surpur and voluntarily
accepted the bribe
amount by demanding the
same punishable u/sec.7,
13(1) (d) R/w Section 13
(2) of the Prevention of
Corruption Act, 1988.


1. Witnesses Examined

DEPARTMENTAL
ENQUIRY
WITNESSES

Pw’s name Witnesses
examined in Trial
Court
PW-1
Complainant-
Annexure- A-7
P.NO.74
Sri Ramiah PW-1
Kariyappa Poojar
PW-2
Shadow
Annexure-A-8
P.No.80

Sri Hanamanthu PW-2

- 11 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:10748-DB
WP No. 201304 of 2026

CNR: KAHC030034612026



Pw-3
I.O.
Annexure-A-10
Sri Chinnappa
Ambaji Rao
Balamakar

Pw-8
P.NO.116

10. After recording the evidence, the learned
Sessions Judge found that the prosecution had failed to
prove that accused No. 1, the petitioner herein, a
government servant, along with accused No. 2 (who was
reported dead), had demanded Rs. 1,500 to correct the
pahani records for Sy. No. 33 of Mavinamatti village and
had received illegal gratification of Rs. 1,500 from the
complainant at their private office in Surpur at about 1:45
p.m. on 12.02.2009. The petitioner was accordingly
acquitted of the offences punishable under Sections 7 and
13(1)(d), read with Section 13(2), of the Prevention of
Corruption Act, 1988. The same witnesses were examined
in the departmental and criminal proceedings. The
complainant was examined as PW-1 in the criminal case;
Sri Hanumanthu, the shadow witness, was examined in
the departmental inquiry and as PW-2 in the criminal case;

- 12 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:10748-DB
WP No. 201304 of 2026

CNR: KAHC030034612026



and Sri Chinnappa Ambaji Rao Balamakar, the
Investigating Officer, was examined in the departmental
inquiry and as PW-8 before the trial court. Thus, the
departmental and criminal proceedings were based on
identical or substantially similar facts and charges,
including the alleged raid at the petitioner’s office and the
recovery of articles.

AHARANA
11. The Hon’ble Supreme Court, in M
P RATAP S INGH V . S TATE OF B IHAR , C IVIL A PPEAL N O . 5497
OF 2025 [ ARISING OUT OF SLP (C) N O . 9818/2017], held
as follows:
"25. …Issue No.2 - Whether, in light of the
facts, evidence, witnesses, and circumstances of
the case, the charges in the criminal proceedings
are substantially identical to those in the
departmental proceedings, such that an acquittal
in the criminal case would render the findings in
the disciplinary proceedings vulnerable?

- 13 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:10748-DB
WP No. 201304 of 2026

CNR: KAHC030034612026



46. The aforesaid discussion on the first
issue seals the fate of the respondents. However,
since arguments were advanced in respect of this
issue too, we propose to briefly answer the
same.
47. While an acquittal in a criminal case does
not automatically entitle the accused to have
an order of setting aside of his dismissal from
public service following disciplinary
proceedings, it is well-established that when
the charges, evidence, witnesses, and
circumstances in both the departmental inquiry
and the criminal proceedings are identical or
substantially similar, the situation assumes a
different context. In such cases, upholding the
findings in the disciplinary proceedings would
be unjust, unfair, and oppressive."


12. The Hon’ble Supreme Court, in M AHARANA
P RATAP S INGH V . S TATE OF B IHAR AND O THERS (C IVIL
A PPEAL N O . 5497 OF 2025) , reiterated and restated the
settled principles from G.M. T ANK ( SUPRA ) AND R AMLAL V .
TATE OF AJASTHAN SCC
S R (2024) 1 175 , observing in
paragraphs 48 and 50 as follows:
"48. To assess the degree of similarity
between the charges, evidence, witnesses,
and circumstances in the disciplinary and
criminal proceedings, it is indeed crucial to
review the materials placed before (R AM LAL
VS S TATE OF R AJASTHAN (2024) 1 SCC 175)

- 14 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:10748-DB
WP No. 201304 of 2026

CNR: KAHC030034612026



the Court where such an issue arises.
However, we regret, absence of the
departmental file has disabled us from
looking into the same.

50. The judgment acquitting the appellant
reveals that the prosecution "miserably
failed to prove its case beyond reasonable
doubt" as both the informant and PW-2
refused to identify the appellant in court.
This discussion confirms that the appellant's
acquittal was based not on mere
technicalities. In Ram Lal (supra), this
Court held that terms like "benefit of doubt"
or "honourably acquitted" should not be
treated as formalities. The Court's duty is to
focus on the substance of the judgment,
rather than the terminology used.”

13. Admittedly, in the present case, the charges,
evidence, witnesses, and circumstances in the
departmental inquiry and criminal proceedings are
identical. Without considering the judgment in the criminal
proceedings, the disciplinary authority passed the
impugned order of punishment, namely, withholding 60%
of the pension. The impugned order is unjust, unfair, and
oppressive, and is contrary to the law laid down by the
ANK V TATE OF UJARAT
Hon’ble Supreme Court in G.M. T . S G

- 15 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:10748-DB
WP No. 201304 of 2026

CNR: KAHC030034612026



AND O THERS , S. B HASKAR R EDDY & ANR VS
S UPERINTENDENT OF P OLICE AND A NOTHER (2015) 2 SCC
365, AND R AMLAL V . S TATE OF R AJASTHAN (supra).
14. Learned counsel for the Lokayukta relies on the
judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in S TATE B ANK OF
I NDIA V . P. Z ADENGA , C IVIL A PPEAL N O . 2518/2012,
DECIDED ON 03.10.2023 , which refers to the judgment in
M AHARANA P RATAP S INGH (supra). The judgment in
Maharana Pratap Singh is subsequent. Further, R AMLAL
(supra) was decided on 04.12.2023, relying on G.M. T ANK
(supra). There is no dispute regarding the legal
propositions laid down in the judgments relied upon by
learned counsel for the Lokayukta. However, in view of the
subsequent judgments of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in
M AHARANA P RATAP S INGH (supra) and the subsequent
judgments of this Court in writ petitions, the matter must
be considered accordingly.

- 16 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:10748-DB
WP No. 201304 of 2026

CNR: KAHC030034612026



15. There is no dispute that the rules of criminal
procedure and the evidentiary standards applicable to
criminal proceedings do not apply to departmental
proceedings in the same manner. The standard of proof
required for a criminal conviction differs from the standard
required to establish misconduct in a departmental
inquiry; the rules governing the appreciation of evidence
in the two proceedings are also different.

16. In criminal proceedings, the prosecution must
prove the accused’s guilt beyond reasonable doubt;
otherwise, the accused cannot be convicted by a court of
law. In a departmental inquiry, however, a penalty may be
imposed on a delinquent officer on the basis of the
preponderance of probabilities. An acquittal by the learned
Sessions Judge does not, by itself, absolve the petitioner
of liability under the State’s disciplinary jurisdiction where
the charges, evidence, witnesses, and circumstances are
not similar. However, where the departmental inquiry and

- 17 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:10748-DB
WP No. 201304 of 2026

CNR: KAHC030034612026



criminal proceedings are identical or substantially similar,
an acquittal in one proceeding followed by punishment in
the other may be unjust. This Court is in full agreement
with the principles laid down by the Hon’ble Supreme
Court in G.M. T ANK (supra), R AMLAL (supra), and
AHARANA RATAP INGH
M P S (supra). Those judgments apply
squarely to the present case.

17. The disciplinary authority passed the impugned
order without considering this aspect. The order is
contrary to the principles laid down by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court in the judgments referred to above and is
liable to be set aside. The Tribunal also failed to consider
this aspect and erred in dismissing the application.

18. In view of the above discussion, we pass the
following order:
ORDER

allowed
i. The writ petition is .

- 18 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:10748-DB
WP No. 201304 of 2026

CNR: KAHC030034612026





ii. The order dated 06.03.2026 passed by the
Karnataka Administrative Tribunal in
Application No.20956/2023 is hereby set
aside.


iii. Consequently, the order dated 12.10.2023
passed by Respondent No. 1 (Annexure-A-
12) is also quashed and set aside.




Sd/-
(ASHOK S. KINAGI)
JUDGE


Sd/-
(SUBRAMANYA RANGARAO)
JUDGE





SSB