G. Sathyanarayana Bothra vs M.D. Lokeswari

Court
Supreme Court


IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
2026 INSC 912
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION

CIVIL APPEAL NO.10045 OF 2026

G. SATHYANARAYANA BOTHRA & OTHERS APPELLANTS

VERSUS
M.D. LOKESWARI & ANOTHER RESPONDENTS

J U D G M E N T

ATUL S. CHANDURKAR, J.
1. The appellants and the first respondent are residents of a
building known as ‘Indira Arcade’. While the appellants have
purchased portion of area on the ground floor to the third floor as
well as a portion on the fourth floor, pursuant to a Memorandum
of Understanding with M/s Indira Foundations Private Limited,
the first respondent being the daughter of the owner of the plot on
which the building was erected occupies a portion on the second
floor of the said building. The grievance of the first respondent is
with regard to excess construction/unauthorised construction/
deviations effected at the instance of the appellants on the portions
owned by them and also in the building. A direction having been
Signature Not Verified
Digitally signed by
ABHINAV KUMAR
Date: 2026.08.22
18:34:57 IST
Reason:
Page 1 of 10

1
issued by the Division Bench of the Madras High Court to the
2
Chennai Metropolitan Development Authority , the second
respondent, to remove the unauthorised constructions/deviations
by the order dated 28.04.2025 in the writ petition preferred by the
first respondent, the appellants, being aggrieved have challenged
the said order.
2. It is not necessary to refer to various factual aspects. Suffice
it to state that initially, the father of the first respondent had filed
Writ Petition No.21661/2017 before the High Court with a prayer
for issuance of a direction to the CMDA to consider his
representation dated 07.07.2017 in the matter of unauthorised
construction undertaken by the appellants. By the order dated
28.03.2018, the appellants were directed to rectify the defects in
respect of violated portions of the building by 08.06.2018. The writ
petition was disposed of but for the purposes of reporting
compliance, it was directed to be listed on 22.06.2018. The
appellants on 06.06.2018 moved an application for regularisation
of the deviations in question. The regularisation was sought under
Section 113-C of the Tamil Nadu Town and Country Planning Act,

1
For short, ‘the High Court’.
2
For short, ‘CMDA’.
Page 2 of 10

3 4
1971 read with Government Order Nos.110 and 111 dated
22.06.2017.
3. When the aforesaid writ petition was considered for reporting
compliance, an undertaking was filed on behalf of the appellants
indicating the action taken by them pursuant to the earlier order.
The relevant portion of the order of the High Court dated
28.06.2018 reads as under:
“Today when the petition is taken up for hearing, the 6th respondent has
filed an affidavit on behalf of the respondents 4 to 7 stating as follows:

"3. I submit that as per the undertaking given by me before this
th
Hon'ble Court, 1 have removed the 5 floor and as well as the basement
internal partitions. Made it usable for parking of vehicles. In so as far as the
4th floor of concerned I have already applied for regularisation under Sec.
113C of the Tamil Nadu Town and Country Planning Act to CMDA and the
same is pending. In fact after the rectification of 08.06.2018 by enclosing
the photographs.

Taking note of the fact that the basement portion has been fully
demolished and that an application is pending under the Town and Country
Planning Act, this Court, by recording the undertaking and submissions is
of the considered view that no further orders are required”.

The application for regularisation in the meanwhile was
pending with the CMDA. The first respondent thereafter on
21.04.2023 issued another communication to the CMDA calling
upon it to take appropriate action with regard to the
deviations/unauthorised construction that continued to exist at

3
For short, ‘the Act of 1971’.
4
For short, ‘G.O.’.
Page 3 of 10

the building. The first respondent then preferred Writ Petition No.
17682/2023 with a prayer to direct the CMDA to decide her
representation dated 21.04.2023. The High Court by its order
dated 15.06.2023, directed the CMDA to consider the
representation dated 21.04.2023 made by the first respondent and
pass an order thereon after hearing the appellants as well as the
first respondent. Pursuant thereto, the CMDA prepared a
report/order dated 09.08.2023 indicating deviations/
unauthorised constructions undertaken by the appellants that
continued to exist.
4. The appellants were aggrieved by the report/order dated
09.08.2023 issued by the CMDA and, hence, they challenged the
aforesaid report/order in Writ Petition No.25737/2023. The High
Court on 27.09.2023 allowed the writ petition, since the larger
issue with regard to the scope of regularisation of unauthorised
constructions under the G.O.s as well as the prayer for
regularisation were pending. The relevant portion of the order
dated 27.09.2023 reads as under:
“5. It is submitted by the learned counsel for the petitioners that the
petitioners filed application for regularisation through online u/s.113-C of
the Tamil Nadu Town and Country Planning Act, before the Chennai
st
Metropolitan Development Authority / 1 respondent and the same is
pending consideration.

Page 4 of 10

6. The learned Standing Counsel appearing for the respondent relied on the
judgment of this Court dated 27.07.2023 in W.P. No.9725 of 2017 and
prayed this Court to take a similar view in this matter.

7. The Hon'ble First Bench of this Court in W.P. No.9725 of 2017 [K. Perumal
Vs. The State of Tamil Nadu, Rep. by the Secretary to Government and
others], by order dated 27.07.2023, while dealing with the writ petitions
seeking directions to enforce the locking and sealing and demolition notice,
held as under:-
"3. We have disposed of other writ petitions, with an observation
that, "if subsequently after the orders are passed by the Apex
Court and the petitioners have any remedy open, they are
entitled to agitate the same afresh. In that event, all contentions
are kept open”. We have observed that the parties may take
steps pursuant to the judgment of the Apex Court.
4. In case, after the judgment of the Apex Court, if it is found
that the fifth respondent is not entitled for regularisation, then
the petitioner may agitate afresh, "

8. In view of the fact that the matter regarding regularisation is seized of by
the Hon'ble Supreme Court, the respondent has to await the orders of the
Hon'ble Supreme Court. The petitioner is entitled, to agitate the issue afresh,
after the orders are passed by the Hon'ble Supreme Court, on the subject
matter. Till then, the respondent is directed not to take any coercive step
against the petitioners.

9. Accordingly, the writ petition is allowed. No costs. Consequently
connected miscellaneous petitions are closed.”

5. At this stage, it would be necessary to state that under
Section 113-C of the Act of 1971, a provision for seeking
regularisation of unauthorised construction has been made,
subject to complying with necessary requirements. The State
Government has issued various Government Orders in
consonance with Section 113-C of the Act of 1971. The Division
Bench of the High Court in C. Prabhakaran vs. Dharmendra
Page 5 of 10

5
Pratap Yadav & Ors. by its order dated 06.02.2019 held G.O.
Nos.110 and 111 dated 22.06.2017 to be invalid. As a result, it
was not permissible to seek regularisation under the said G.O.s.
It may be stated that the aforesaid order is the subject matter of
the challenge before this Court in M/s Billroth Hospital Ltd. vs.
6
The State of Tamil Nadu at the behest of the CMDA. Various
other civil appeals raising a similar challenge are pending.
6. The High Court taking note of the pendency of the aforesaid
litigation disposed of various writ petitions wherein the issue of
regularisation of unauthorised construction under the said G.O.s
was the subject matter. The High Court directed that since the
issue was pending before this Court, the parties would be bound
by the orders that would be passed in the pending proceedings
before this Court. The order dated 27.09.2023 referred to
hereinabove as passed by the Division Bench is also on similar
lines. As a result of this order, to which the appellants and the
CMDA were parties, it was restrained from taking any coercive
steps against the appellants till the aforesaid pending issues were
decided.

5
Contempt Petition No. 1087 of 2017
6
Civil Appeal Nos. 6839-6841/2022
Page 6 of 10

7. Be that as it may, the first respondent continued her pursuit
of seeking removal of unauthorised constructions/deviations
undertaken at the instance of the appellants. She, therefore, on
31.01.2024, made a fresh representation to the CMDA calling
upon it to take necessary action on the notice dated 10.11.2023
issued by it under Form IV to the appellants. The representation
not having been considered, the first respondent filed Writ Petition
No.12779/2024 with a prayer for a direction to the CMDA to
consider her representation and take further steps in the matter.
Paragraphs 15 to 17 of her affidavit indicate knowledge as regards
pendency of the application for regularisation. The said
paragraphs read as under:
st
“ 15. I state that, on 10.11.2023 the 1 respondent had issued a notice
in Notice No. EC/C-II/12765/2017 referring item No.17 in the reference to
the notice as the Regularisation Application No. 113C/672/2018 dated
13.10.2023 received under Section 113C of TNT&CP Act, 1971. It is contrary
st
to the statements made in the status report filed by the 1 respondent in
Contempt Petition No.2671 of 2023 that, respondents 2 to 5, M/s.
Sathyanarayana Bothra and his family members have filed a Regularisation
Application in No. Reg. /113C/399/2018 dated 06.06.2018 for
regularisation of Basement, GF+4F Commercial building in the disputed
above said property.

16. I state that, respondents 2 to 5, M/s. Sathyanarayana Bothra and
his family members have filed the Regularisation Application No. Reg./113
C/399/2018 dated 06.06.2018 and Regularisation Application No.
113C/672/2018 dated 13.10.2023 received by the respondent under
Section 113C of TNT&CP Act, 1971 for regularisation of Basement GF+4F
Commercial building in the disputed above said property without my
st
knowledge. I have sent a representation dated 31.01.2024 to the 1
respondent objecting for the regularisation of Basement, GF+4F Commercial
building in the disputed above said property without my knowledge. I had
st th
also requested the 1 respondent to refrain from regularising the 4 floor
Page 7 of 10

which is open to sky as per the approved plan and as I am also one of the
th
co-owner of the building and the 4 floor together with the undivided share.

17. I state that, vide my representation dated 31.01.2024 I had also
st
requested the 1 respondent to take action on the Form IV dated 10.11.2023
issued by the 1st respondent in Notice No. EC/C-II/12765/2017 to
respondents 2 to 5, M/s. Sathyanarayana Bothra and his family members
st
and restore the setback as per Planning Permission issued by the 1
respondent and as per Planning Permission accorded in No.
B/Spl.Bldg./468/2003 dated 16.10.2003 in Letter No. B2/15128/2003
st
dated 16.01.2003. The 1 respondent has received my representation and
has taken any action on my representation.”

8. The Division Bench by its order dated 28.04.2025 observed
that it was not permissible to regularise any unauthorised
construction nor would pendency of an application for
regularisation give a ground for not taking any action against such
unauthorised construction. It observed that notwithstanding the
pendency of the regularisation application, action ought to be
taken to remove the unauthorised portions, as the application for
regularisation itself was not maintainable. It is this order that is
impugned in the present appeal.
9. We have heard Mr. Balaji Srinivasan, learned counsel for the
appellants, Mr. G. Anto Prince, learned counsel for the first
respondent and Ms. Jayasree Narasimhan, learned counsel for
the second respondent. We have also perused the written
submissions placed on record.
10. In our view, the CMDA was governed by the order dated
Page 8 of 10

27.09.2023 passed by the High Court in Writ Petition
No.25737/2023 preferred by the appellants inasmuch as it was
directed not to take any coercive steps against the appellants in
view of pendency of the issues pertaining to regularisation before
this Court. The said issue arising out of the subject G.O.s and
Section 113-C of the Act of 1971 is still pending. In such a
situation, the High Court while deciding the present proceedings
ought to have taken into consideration its earlier order dated
27.09.2023 passed in the writ petition preferred by the appellants.
Without considering the same and despite pendency of the
appellants’ regularisation application, a direction to take coercive
steps and remove the unauthorised construction has been issued.
This has resulted in passing of inconsistent orders with regard to
the same subject matter qua the appellants and CMDA. The issue
pertaining to regularisation of unauthorised constructions not
having been finally resolved and the parties having been directed
to await decision in the pending proceedings, in our view, the High
Court was not justified in issuing a direction to the CMDA to
demolish the unauthorised constructions/deviations within a
period of eight weeks from the date of its order. We, therefore, find
that the impugned order is unsustainable in law being contrary
Page 9 of 10

to its earlier order dated 27.09.2023 passed in Writ Petition
No.25737/2023.
11. In the light of this position on record, the impugned order
dated 28.04.2025 passed in Writ Petition No.12779/2024 is set
aside. It is directed that the appellants, the CMDA and the second
respondent would be governed by the order dated 27.09.2023
passed in Writ Petition No.25737/2023. The appellants and the
respondents would be at liberty to take further steps after the
issue of regularisation is decided in the pending civil appeals
before this Court. In the circumstances of the case, status quo
shall be maintained by the parties with regard to the
constructions undertaken at the building till the pending issues
are decided. The Civil Appeal is allowed in the aforesaid terms,
leaving the parties to bear their own costs. Pending Interlocutory
Application shall stand disposed of.

…...………………………..J.
[ UJJAL BHUYAN ]


.…..………………………..J.
[ATUL S. CHANDURKAR]

NEW DELHI,
AUGUST 22, 2026.

Page 10 of 10