Sudha vs The State of Tamilnadu
- Court
- Madras High Court
CRL OP(MD) No. 26462 of 2026
BEFORE THE MADURAI BENCH OF MADRAS HIGH COURT
DATED: 20-11-2026
CORAM
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE R.VIJAYAKUMAR
CRL OP(MD) No. 26462 of 2026
CNR:{HCMD011658072026}
AND
CRL MP(MD) Nos. 24590 & 24593 of 2026
Sudha
W/o.Late Balakrishnan,
No.80/4, Alagarnayakkanpatti West Street,
Lakshma Nayakapatti Post, Thevaram,
Uthamapalayam Taluk,
Theni District 625 530.
..Petitioner(s)
Vs
1. The State of Tamilnadu
Rep by The Superintendent of Police,
Office of the Superintendent of Police,
Madurai District.
2. The Deputy Superintendent of Police
Usilampatti Subdivision,
Madurai District.
3. The Inspector Of Police,
Checkanurani Police Station,
Madurai District.
4. The Inspector Of Police,
Valandur Police Station,
Madurai District.
5. The Inspector Of Police,
Usilampatti Town Police Station
Madurai District.
__________
Page 1 of 18
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 21/11/2026 12:05:37 pm )
CRL OP(MD) No. 26462 of 2026
6. The Inspector Of Police,
Usilampatti Taluk Police Station
Madurai District.
7. The Superintendent of Police
Office of the CBCID South Zone, Madurai,
No.7 Kamaraj Nagar 2nd Street,
Chinna Chockkikulam,
Madurai 625002. ..Respondent(s)
PRAYER: This Petition filed under section Petition u/s 528 of BNSS to
direct the Respondents Nos.3 to 7 to preserve the CCTV footage (audio
and video) recorded on all CCTV cameras at the above Police Stations
for the above periods, showing the entry, detention and exit of the
petitioner's husband, Balakrishnan from each of the police stations above
referred, and provide a copy to the petitioner based on her representation
dated 15.11.2026, within a stipulated time that may be fixed by this
Court.
For Petitioner(s) :Mr.HENRI PATRICK TIPHANGE
For Respondent(s) :Mr.P.SAMUEL GUNASINGH,
ADDL.PUBLIC PROSECUTOR
ORDER
This Criminal Original Petition has been filed seeking a direction
to respondents 3 to 7 to preserve the CCTV footage (audio and video)
recorded on all the CCTV cameras at the police stations of respondents 3
to 6, for the periods mentioned in the petition, showing the entry,
detention and exit of the petitioner’s husband at each of those police
stations, and to furnish a copy of the same to the petitioner on the basis of
__________
Page 2 of 18
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 21/11/2026 12:05:37 pm )
CRL OP(MD) No. 26462 of 2026
her representation dated 15.11.2026, within a stipulated time.
(A) The averments in the petition are as follows:
2. The petitioner’s husband was a lorry driver by profession. On
03.11.2026, at about 2.30 a.m., while he was driving a lorry loaded
with sacks of cardamom from Thevaram to Madurai, the lorry
caught fire near the Valandur cremation ground on the Usilampatti–
Theni Road. The petitioner’s husband (the deceased) attempted to
put out the fire and recorded a video of the incident on his mobile
phone. Several sacks of goods were destroyed. The deceased is said
to have called the petitioner and informed her about the incident.
3. It is further averred that, on the same day, the petitioner’s
th
husband lodged a complaint before the 4 respondent police and
promptly informed the owner of the vehicle. It is stated that the
petitioner’s husband had no criminal antecedents, and that the family
is unaware of what has happened to the lorry since then or where it is
presently kept.
4. It is further averred that, on the morning of 12.11.2026, the
owner of the vehicle called her husband over the phone and asked
rd
him to go and meet the 3 respondent police. Her husband was not
aware that the FIR had not been registered until the night of
13.11.2026. Accompanied by the petitioner, her husband went to the
__________
Page 3 of 18
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 21/11/2026 12:05:37 pm )
CRL OP(MD) No. 26462 of 2026
Checkanurani Police Station on 12.11.2026 and was questioned from
11.00 a.m. till close to midnight, after which he returned home along
with the petitioner. During the preliminary enquiry, the police are
said to have examined the mobile phone of the deceased and
returned it to him. It is further averred that the petitioner came to
know that his employer had lodged a complaint with the
Superintendent of Police, but no FIR has been registered on the said
complaint. It is further averred that the questioning by the
respondent police resumed on 13.11.2026. Her husband called her
from Usilampatti, stating that he had gone to the police station there
and had been asked to proceed to the Checkanurani Police Station.
The petitioner alleges that her husband was taken successively to the
Valandur, Usilampatti and Checkanurani Police Stations.
5. It is further averred that, on 13.11.2026, her husband was
detained at the Checkanurani Police Station beyond midnight and
was never furnished with a copy of the FIR in Crime No.113 of 2026
of the Valandur Police Station. Over the phone, he informed the
petitioner that he was being made to wait because the Investigating
Officer had not yet arrived. On the morning of 14.11.2026, the
petitioner received a call from the police station informing her that
__________
Page 4 of 18
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 21/11/2026 12:05:37 pm )
CRL OP(MD) No. 26462 of 2026
her husband had committed suicide and had been rushed to the
Government Rajaji Hospital.
6. It is further averred that her husband appears to have died
inside the police station while under the control and supervision of
rd
the 3 respondent police, and that he died in police custody solely on
rd
account of torture and ill-treatment at the hands of the 3 respondent
police, which caused him severe physical and mental suffering. The
post-mortem was completed at 11.00 p.m. on 14.11.2026, and the
post-mortem report was handed over to her. A careful perusal of the
report reveals certain injuries on the body of the deceased: there are
multiple contusions on the back of the chest and abdomen and over
the right shoulder, and there are also three puncture marks on the
right side of the neck. Therefore, according to the petitioner, there is
sufficient material to show that her husband was subjected to
physical torture at the hands of the police prior to his death,
notwithstanding the ligature mark described in the report as leaving a
gap of 16 cm.
7. It is stated that the petitioner subsequently came to know that
the investigation has been transferred to the CBCID. On the above
allegations, the present petition has been filed along with two
petitions seeking interim directions.
__________
Page 5 of 18
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 21/11/2026 12:05:37 pm )
CRL OP(MD) No. 26462 of 2026
8. Crl.MP(MD) No.24590 of 2026 has been filed seeking an
interim direction to respondents 1 and 2 to take immediate steps to
preserve the photographs and videos of the petitioner’s husband in
the toilet, taken before his body was removed from there.
9. When the matter came up for hearing on 17.11.2026, the
learned Additional Public Prosecutor submitted, with regard to the
above interim prayer, that the police are not in possession of any
photographs of the deceased in the toilet. Hence, the said interim
direction was not granted.
10. The petitioner has also filed Crl.MP(MD) No.24593 of 2026
seeking an interim direction to respondents 1 and 2 to take
immediate steps to preserve the CCTV footage (audio and video)
recorded on all the CCTV cameras at the four police stations during
the timings mentioned in the said petition. By order dated
17.11.2026, this Court allowed the said petition and directed the
respondent police to produce two copies of the footage, along with
the certificate under Section 63 of the BSA, in a sealed cover.
However, this Court did not pass any order on the question whether
a copy of the entire footage is to be furnished to the petitioner.
11. In compliance with the order of this Court dated 17.11.2026,
two copies of the raw footage, along with the certificate required
__________
Page 6 of 18
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 21/11/2026 12:05:37 pm )
CRL OP(MD) No. 26462 of 2026
under Section 63 of the BSA, 2023, have been placed before this
Court in a sealed cover. By a separate order, this Court has directed
the Registrar (Judicial) to preserve the CCTV footage, recorded on a
hard disk, until further orders.
(B) Submissions of the counsel on either side:
12. Today, the learned counsel on either side made their
submissions on the question whether the petitioner is entitled to a
copy of the CCTV footage secured and preserved by the respondent
police.
13. The learned counsel for the petitioner submitted that, though
a complaint was lodged by the petitioner’s husband (the deceased)
on 04.11.2026, an FIR was registered only on 13.11.2026. The
deceased was present in the police station as a complainant and not
as an accused, and no complaint has been lodged by anyone against
the petitioner’s husband. The learned counsel further submitted that
the deceased, though only a complainant, was needlessly detained in
the police station throughout the night, and that he died in police
custody solely on account of torture and ill-treatment at the hands of
the respondent police.
14. The learned counsel for the petitioner further submitted that
the petitioner, as the widow of the deceased, wishes to know the
__________
Page 7 of 18
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 21/11/2026 12:05:37 pm )
CRL OP(MD) No. 26462 of 2026
manner in which her husband was treated inside the police station
and the circumstances that led to his death. He further submitted
that, apart from pursuing their remedy before the Criminal Court, the
family also intends to proceed against the officials concerned before
the Human Rights Commission and other fora. In such
circumstances, unless a copy of the relevant CCTV footage is
furnished to the petitioner, they would not be in a position either to
guide the course of the investigation in the criminal case or to initiate
appropriate proceedings before the said statutory fora.
15. Per contra, the learned Additional Public Prosecutor
appearing for the respondent police, relying upon Section 106(3) of
the BNSS, contended that the seized CCTV footage is required to be
produced only before the jurisdictional Magistrate. He also relied
upon Section 8(1)(h) of the Right to Information Act, 2005, which
exempts from disclosure any information that would impede the
process of investigation or the apprehension or prosecution of
offenders. According to him, permitting a copy of the CCTV footage
to be handed over to the petitioner while the investigation is
pending, particularly in a sensitive case such as this, would clearly
impede the investigation.
__________
Page 8 of 18
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 21/11/2026 12:05:37 pm )
CRL OP(MD) No. 26462 of 2026
16. The learned Additional Public Prosecutor further contended
that the video footage is likely to be tampered with or doctored and
circulated on social media, so as to create unrest and a law and order
problem in the State. Similar incidents have already occurred in the
State of Tamil Nadu. The petitioner would be entitled to a copy of
the CCTV footage as and when the trial commences. Furnishing the
footage to the petitioner before that stage would only impede the
investigation and may help the real accused escape from the clutches
of law, particularly if it is used as a political tool.
17. The learned Additional Public Prosecutor further submitted
that, instead of being used for any legal purpose, the CCTV footage
is likely to be published on social media platforms, followed by
press meets, in order to divert the course of the investigation, which
would ultimately benefit only the real accused. He further contended
that this would set a precedent whereby, in every case, the accused
or the complainant would seek a copy of the CCTV footage during
the pendency of the investigation, which would not only disrupt the
investigation but also enable the real accused to escape. He further
submitted that the respondents do not object to furnishing a copy of
the CCTV footage as such, but only to the stage at which such a
copy may be handed over to the petitioner. In fact, the petitioner
__________
Page 9 of 18
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 21/11/2026 12:05:37 pm )
CRL OP(MD) No. 26462 of 2026
would always be entitled to a copy of the said footage after the final
report is filed. What the investigating agency opposes is only the
handing over of the CCTV footage to anyone connected with the
case while the investigation is in progress.
18. Heard the learned counsel on either side and perused the
materials on record.
(C) Discussion:
19. In the present case, the deceased, a lorry driver, is said to
have been subjected to an enquiry in Crime No.113 of 2026, which
th
was registered by the 4 respondent police on 13.11.2026 as a “Non-
Act (Accidental Fire)” case. After the death of the petitioner’s
husband, an FIR was registered in Crime No.541 of 2026 on
14.11.2026 under Section 196(2)(a) of the BNSS, 2023, with the
accused column left blank.
20. It is not known why a complainant was made to wait
rd
throughout the night at the 3 respondent police station. A
complainant, as a reasonable person, would have no occasion
whatsoever to commit suicide inside a police station. Though it is
alleged that certain complaints were lodged by the employer of the
deceased, no FIR has been registered on those complaints. In such
circumstances, whether the death of the deceased was a suicide or
__________
Page 10 of 18
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 21/11/2026 12:05:37 pm )
CRL OP(MD) No. 26462 of 2026
was the result of the alleged torture or ill-treatment at the hands of
rd
the 3 respondent police is a matter requiring further investigation.
21. This Court cannot lose sight of the fact that the post-mortem
report reveals certain injuries on the body of the deceased. In such
circumstances, the CCTV footage already secured and preserved by
the respondent police alone could throw light on the direction of the
investigation, particularly for the family members of the deceased.
22. Under the statutory provisions, any property seized during
an investigation is required to be reported to the jurisdictional
Magistrate in Form 91, along with the seized property.
23. The learned Additional Public Prosecutor relied upon
Section 8(1)(h) of the RTI Act, 2005, and contended that no
information which would impede the process of investigation can be
disclosed. This Court is exercising its powers under Section 528 of
the BNSS, and is not acting as a Public Information Officer under
the RTI Act; hence, it is not bound by the exemptions provided
under that Act. Therefore, such an argument is noted only to be
rejected.
24. The learned Additional Public Prosecutor further contended
that if a copy of the CCTV footage is handed over, instead of serving
to guide and inform the family members about the investigation, it is
__________
Page 11 of 18
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 21/11/2026 12:05:37 pm )
CRL OP(MD) No. 26462 of 2026
likely to fall into the hands of undesirable persons who may tamper
with or doctor the footage, causing unrest and affecting public order.
He further contended that none of the judgments cited by the learned
counsel for the petitioner provides for furnishing a copy of CCTV
footage; all of them speak only of securing and preserving CCTV
footage during the investigation, ultimately to be handed over to the
trial Court.
25. This Court cannot brush aside the argument of the learned
Additional Public Prosecutor that, if a copy of the CCTV footage is
furnished to the family of the victim, it may be tampered with,
circulated or used for political purposes by undesirable elements.
However, the right of the victim’s family to keep track of the
progress of the investigation by viewing the CCTV footage, without
recording it, cannot be faulted.
26. CCTV footage from cameras installed and maintained in a
police station stands on a footing distinct from CCTV footage
collected from external sources during an investigation, for the
following reasons:
a) Police station CCTV footage is a contemporaneous
institutional record intended, inter alia, to ensure transparency and
accountability in the exercise of police powers. In cases involving
__________
Page 12 of 18
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 21/11/2026 12:05:37 pm )
CRL OP(MD) No. 26462 of 2026
custodial death, such footage may constitute material evidence
regarding the circumstances of the detention and the conduct of the
police personnel.
b) In such cases, the police themselves are the suspects or the
subjects of the inquiry, which creates an inherent conflict of interest.
c) Police station CCTV records the conduct of the police
themselves; its purpose is to secure accountability under Article 21
of the Constitution of India. In a case of custodial death, where the
police are the suspects, such footage is governed by special
considerations. By contrast, CCTV footage seized during an
ordinary investigation is merely evidence collected by the police
against an accused.
d) In a custodial death case, police station CCTV footage is not
merely “another seized document”. It is a record created by the very
authority whose conduct is in question, covering the entry, detention,
interrogation, movement, medical attention and final moments of the
deceased.
e) The directions issued by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in
Paramvir Singh Saini v. Baljit Singh, (2021) 1 SCC 184 , at
paragraphs 18 to 22, recognise the necessity of securing such footage
in cases involving violations of human rights. Consequently, the
__________
Page 13 of 18
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 21/11/2026 12:05:37 pm )
CRL OP(MD) No. 26462 of 2026
request of the victim’s family cannot be rejected merely by treating
the footage as an ordinary document collected during an
investigation.
27. This Court has to balance the fairness of the investigation
against the rights of the victim’s family, particularly when the
alleged occurrence took place inside a police station during the
investigation of a criminal case. Ordinarily, a request for a copy of
CCTV footage connected with the investigation of a criminal case
would not be permissible until the stage of filing of the final report is
reached. However, in cases where the investigating agency itself is
accused of the crime and the entire incident is said to have taken
place inside the police station, the family of the victim can be
permitted at least to view the footage from the CCTV cameras which
are installed in the police station pursuant to the directions of the
Hon’ble Supreme Court. Otherwise, the very purpose of installing
CCTV cameras inside police stations would be rendered futile.
28. The learned Additional Public Prosecutor further submitted
that, in case this Court is inclined to permit the petitioner to view the
CCTV footage, an Advocate should not be permitted to accompany
her. This Court is not inclined to accept the said objection. The
allegations relate to custodial torture resulting in custodial death, and
__________
Page 14 of 18
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 21/11/2026 12:05:37 pm )
CRL OP(MD) No. 26462 of 2026
the petitioner is likely to approach the Human Rights Commission as
well. In such circumstances, violations of human rights, if any, could
be identified only by a legally trained person accompanying the
family members of the victim. Therefore, the said contention is
liable to be rejected.
(D) Conclusion:
29. In view of the foregoing discussion, this Court is inclined to
pass the following directions:
a) The petitioner, along with her sister, Jeya, and the brother of
the deceased, Manikandan, shall be permitted to view the CCTV
footage of the four police stations, recorded for the periods
mentioned in the petition, at 10.00 a.m. on 23.11.2026 at the office
th
of the 7 respondent police.
b) One Advocate representing the petitioner shall be permitted
to accompany her. The petitioner, her family members and the
Advocate accompanying them shall leave their electronic devices
outside the room in which they view the CCTV footage. It is made
clear that no form of recording is permitted.
th
c) A technical staff member from the office of the 7
respondent shall be made available in the hall to assist the petitioner.
__________
Page 15 of 18
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 21/11/2026 12:05:37 pm )
CRL OP(MD) No. 26462 of 2026
d) The permission granted to the petitioner and others is solely
for the purpose of satisfying themselves as to the line and direction
of the investigation. What they view may be used only for
approaching a statutory forum. No press meet or public debate shall
follow the viewing of the CCTV footage.
e) It is made clear that this order is passed only in view of the
fact that the case relates to alleged custodial torture/custodial death,
and the same shall not be cited as a precedent in other cases.
30. With the above observations, this Criminal Original Petition
stands disposed of. Consequently, the connected miscellaneous
petitions are closed.
20-11-2026
Index: Yes/No
Speaking/Non-speaking order
Neutral Citation: Yes/No
msa
To
1. The Superintendent of Police
Office of the Superintendent of Police
Madurai District
2. The Deputy Superintendent of Police
Usilampatti Subdivision
Madurai District
3. The Inspector Of Police,
__________
Page 16 of 18
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 21/11/2026 12:05:37 pm )
CRL OP(MD) No. 26462 of 2026
Checkanurani Police Station
Madurai District
4. The Inspector Of Police,
Valandur Police Station
Madurai District
5. The Inspector Of Police,
Usilampatti Town Police Station
Madurai District
6. The Inspector Of Police,
Usilampatti Taluk Police Station
Madurai District
7. The Superintendent of Police
Office of the CBCID South Zone, Madurai
No.7 Kamaraj Nagar 2nd Street
Chinna Chockkikulam
Madurai 625002
8. The Additional Public Prosecutor
Madurai Bench of Madras High Court
Madurai
__________
Page 17 of 18
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 21/11/2026 12:05:37 pm )
CRL OP(MD) No. 26462 of 2026
R.VIJAYAKUMAR, J.
msa
CRL OP(MD) No. 26462 of 2026
and
CRL MP(MD) Nos. 24590 & 24593 of 2026
20-11-2026
__________
Page 18 of 18
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 21/11/2026 12:05:37 pm )