V.SHANTHA KUMARI(died) vs E.BALARAMAN(Died)
- Court
- Madras High Court
SA Nos.1153 and 1154 of 2008
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT MADRAS
DATED: 19-11-2026
CORAM
THE HON'BLE MR.JUSTICE P. DHANABAL
SA No. 1153 of 2008 and M.P. No.1 of 2008 }
[CNR:{HCMA010089462008 ]
and SA No. 1154 of 2008
SA No. 1153 of 2008
1. V.Shantha Kumari (died) W/o.Balasubramanian
2. Balasubramani S/o.Murugesan
3. Jayaprakash Mohan S/o.Balasubramani
4. Subashini W/o.Thirumal
5. Sasikala D/o.Balasubramani
[Sole Appellant died, A2 to 5 brought on record
as legal representatives of the deceased sole
appellant vide order dated 29/07/2022 made in
C.M.P. Nos.9823 and 9824 of 2022)
..Appellant(s)
Vs
1. E. Balaraman (Died) S/o.Ethiraj Mudali,
2. Malar D/o.Late Balaraman, W/o.Aranganathan
3. Panneer Selvam S/o.Late Balaraman
4. Pandian S/o.Late Balaraman.
5. Asha D/o.Late Balaraman, W/o.Kishore
[The respondents 2 to 5 were brought on record
as legal representatives of the deceased sold
respondent vide order dated 29-08-2022 made
in CMP Nos.14103, 14108 and 14111/2022)
..Respondent(s)
SA No. 1154 of 2008 and M.P. No.1 of 2008
CNR:{HCMA010089482008}
1. V.Shantha Kumari (died)
W/o.Balasubramanian
2. Balasubramani S/o.Murugesan
__________
Page 1 of 17
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 03:15:22 pm )
SA Nos.1153 and 1154 of 2008
3. Jayaprakash Mohan S/o.Balasubramani
4. Subashini W/o.Thirumal
5. Sasikala D/o.Balasubramani
[Sole Appellant died, A2 to 5 brought on
record as legal representatives of the
deceased sole appellant vide order dated
29/07/2022 made in C.M.P. Nos.9823 and
9824 of 2022)
..Appellant(s)
Vs
1. E. Balaraman (Died) S/o.Ethiraj Mudali,
2. Malar D/o.Late Balaraman, W/o.Aranganathan
3. Panneer Selvam S/o.Late Balaraman
4. Pandian S/o.Late Balaraman.
5. Asha D/o.Late Balaraman, W/o.Kishore
[The respondents 2 to 5 were brought on record
as legal representatives of the deceased sold
respondent vide order dated 29-08-2022 made
in CMP.14104,14107 and14110/2022)
..Respondent(s)
PRAYER in S.A. No.1153 of 2008: The Second Appeal has been filed under
Section 100 of Civil Procedure Code as against the judgment and decree dated
11.04.2008 made in A.S. No.1 of 2005 on the file of the Sub Judge, Tiruvallur
reversing the judgment and decree dated 29.09.2004 made in O.S. No.81 of
2001 on the file of the District Munsif, Pallipattu.
PRAYER in S.A. No.1154 of 2008: The Second Appeal has been filed under
Section 100 of Civil Procedure Code as against the judgment and decree dated
11.04.2008 made in A.S. No.3 of 2005 on the file of the Sub Judge, Tiruvallur
reversing the judgment and decree dated 29.09.2004 made in O.S. No.538 of
2001 on the file of the District Munsif, Pallipattu.
__________
Page 2 of 17
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 03:15:22 pm )
SA Nos.1153 and 1154 of 2008
Both appeals:
For Appellant(s): Mr. N. Manoharan for Mr. P. Krishnan
For Respondent(s): R1 - Died
M/s.P.Dinesh Kumar [For R2 To 5]
COMMON JUDGMENT
These Second Appeals have been preferred as against the common
judgment and decrees dated 11.04.2008 passed by the First Appellate Court in
A.S. Nos.1 of 2005 and 3 of 2005 on the file of the Subordinate Judge,
st
Tiruvallur. The deceased 1 appellant in S. A. No.1153 of 2008 has filed a Suit
in O.S. No.81 of 2001 on the file of the District Munsif, Pallipattu for the reliefs
st
of declaration and permanent injunction. The deceased 1 respondent in S.A.
No.1154 of 2008 has filed a Suit in O.S. No.538 of 2001 on the file of the
District Munsif, Pallipattu for the relief of permanent injunction. Both the Suits
were tried jointly together along with another Suit in O.S. No.262 of 2001 and a
common judgment has been passed by the trial Court and the trial Court decreed
the Suit in O.S. No.81 of 2001 and dismissed the Suit in O.S. No.538 of 2001.
Aggrieved by the said decrees and common judgment, the defendant in O.S.
No.81 of 2001 and the Plaintiff in O.S. No.538 of 2001 have preferred appeals
in A.S. Nos.1 of 2005 and 3 of 2005 respectively. The First Appellate Court
partly allowed the appeal in A.S. No.1 of 2005 by declaring that the Plaintiff is
entitled to declaration for 11 cents and also granted permanent injunction. The
__________
Page 3 of 17
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 03:15:22 pm )
SA Nos.1153 and 1154 of 2008
appeal in A.S. No.3 of 2005 was also partly allowed in respect of permanent
injunction to an extent of 56 cents of land. Aggrieved by the said common
judgment and decrees, these Second appeals have been preferred by the
respective appellants.
2. The case of the Plaintiff s in O.S. No. 81 of 2001 is as follows:
The Suit property, originally belonged to one V.P. Venkatachala Mudali
and he had two wives namely Kannammal alias Lakshmiammal and
Sakkubaiammal. The said Venkatachala Mudali had two sons and two
daughters namely Muniganapathy, Manoharan, Perundevi and Saraswathy
st
through his 1 wife. Through his second wife, he had one daughter namely
nd nd
Santhakumari. The 2 wife and the daughter born through 2 wife are the
Plaintiffs 1 and 2. While so, Perundeviammal had filed a Suit in O.S. No.92 of
1960 as against the Plaintiff for partition and separate possession on the file of
the Subordinate Court, Vellore. The Plaintiffs were allotted with the Suit
property and the possession was also granted through E.P. No.125 of 1968. The
Plaintiffs took possession on 06.05.1968 along with other properties, thereby
the Plaintiffs are in possession and enjoyment of the property. Patta was also
granted in favour of the Plaintiffs and the Plaintiffs are in continuous possession
and enjoyment of the Suit property. The defendant is a stranger and he has no
connection whatsoever over the Suit property. While so, on 10.04.1995, the
defendant attempted to trespass into the Suit property, thereby, the Plaintiffs
__________
Page 4 of 17
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 03:15:22 pm )
SA Nos.1153 and 1154 of 2008
issued a notice on 17.04.1995. After receipt of the notice, the defendant failed
to reply the notice. Therefore, the Plaintiffs filed the Suit.
2.1. The defendant in O.S. No.81 of 2001 has filed a Written statement
as follows:-
The Suit is not maintainable. The relationship between the parties is
admitted. The filing of a Partition Suit in O.S. No.92 of 1960 on the file of the
Subordinate Court, Vellore is true, but it is not true that the Plaintiffs were put
in possession of the Suit property through execution proceedings vide E.P.
No.125 of 1968. The Plaintiff was never in possession and enjoyment of the
Suit property at any point of time. The defendant is the real owner of the Suit
property and he is in possession and enjoyment of the same and he purchased
the property through two Sale Deeds dated 17.05.1968. Even since the date of
sale deeds, the defendant is in possession and enjoyment of the property in
S. No.1/6 measuring to an extent of 0.68 cents. The vendors of the defendant
are the owners of the property by virtue of preliminary decree in O.S. No.92 of
1960 and final decree dated 14.03.1966. They also took possession of the
property in E.P. No.126 of 1966 on the file of the District Munsif, Tiruttani on
20.07.1966. The Plaintiffs have no right over the property and they were never
in possession of the Suit property at any point of time. Therefore, the Suit is
liable to be dismissed.
__________
Page 5 of 17
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 03:15:22 pm )
SA Nos.1153 and 1154 of 2008
3. The case of the Plaintiff in O.S. No.538 of 2001 is as follows:-
Originally the Suit property belonged to the vendor of the Plaintiff
through two Sale deeds dated 17.05.1968 and the Plaintiff’s vendor was entitled
to the property through preliminary decree passed in O.S. No.92 of 1960 and
final decree dated 14.03.1966 and he took possession of the property through
execution proceedings in E.P. No.126/66 dated 20.07.1966. Pursuant to the
same, the Plaintiff has been under the possession and enjoyment of the property.
The defendants have no right to question or interfere with the Plaintiff’s right
over the property. The defendants, without any manner of right or title over the
property, are making attempts to dispossess the Plaintiff’s lawful possession and
enjoyment of the property since 01.11.1999. Therefore, the Plaintiff filed the
Suit.
3.1. The case of the defendants in O.S. No.538 of 2001 is as follows:-
The Suit is not maintainable. The averment that the property belongs to
the vendors of the Plaintiff through O.S. No.92 of 1960 is false. In fact, the Suit
schedule property was allotted to the defendants in final decree proceedings in
I.A. No.158 of 1963 in O.S. No.92 of 1960 on the file of the Subordinate Court,
Vellore. Through the said proceedings, item 7 in ‘A’ Schedule property was
st
allotted to the 1 defendant and the item 8 in ‘A’ Schedule property was allotted
nd st
to the 2 defendant. Out of 68 cents in Old S. No.56/2 in New S. No.1/6, the 1
nd
defendant herein was allotted to ¼ share among other properties while the 2
__________
Page 6 of 17
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 03:15:22 pm )
SA Nos.1153 and 1154 of 2008
defendant was allotted with ¾ share among other properties. Thus the entire 68
cents was allotted to the defendants herein under Item Nos.7 and 8 in the above
Suit in O.S. No.90 of 1962. These defendants were described as defendants 4
and 5 in the said Suit. Therefore, the Plaint averments that the Suit item was
allotted to the share of the Plaintiff’s vendor is not correct. Therefore, the sale
in favour of the Plaintiff is not valid. The Plaintiff is not in possession and
enjoyment of the property. The patta for the Suit property stands in the name of
the defendants. The defendants alone are in possession and enjoyment of the
property. Therefore, the Suit is liable to be dismissed.
4. Based on the above pleadings and after hearing both sides, the trial
Court has framed the following issues:
O.S. No.81 of 2001
(i) Whether the Plaintiffs are the absolute owners of the Suit property
and are in continuous possession after delivery in E.P. No.125 of 1968 on
06.05.1968?
(ii) Whether the Plaintiffs perfected their right and title to the Suit
property by adverse possession?
(iii) Whether the Plaintiffs are entitled to a decree as prayed for?
(iv) To what reliefs, the Plaintiffs are entitled?
__________
Page 7 of 17
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 03:15:22 pm )
SA Nos.1153 and 1154 of 2008
O.S. No.538 of 2001
(i) Whether the Plaintiffs are in possession and enjoyment over the Suit
property?
(ii) Whether the Plaintiffs are entitled to the relief of permanent
injunction?
(iii) To what other reliefs, the parties are entitled?
5. Before the trial court, on the side of the Plaintiff, PW1 and PW2 were
examined and the documents Ex.A1 to Ex.A.43 were marked. On the side of
the defendants, DW1 to DW4 were examined and Ex.B.1 to Ex.B.15 were
marked. The trial court, after evaluating the oral and documentary evidences
adduced on both sides and perusing the records, passed a common judgment
dated 29.09.2004 by decreeing the Suit in O.S. No.81 of 2001 and by dismissing
the Suit in O.S. No.538 of 2001. Aggrieved by the said common judgment and
decrees, the defendant in O.S. No.81 of 2001 has preferred an appeal in A.S.
No.1 of 2005 and the Plaintiff in O.S. No.538 of 2001 has preferred an appeal in
A.S. No.3 of 2005 on the file of the Subordinate Judge, Tiruvallur on various
grounds.
6. The First Appellate Court has framed the points for determination in
all the three appeals as to whether the three appeals have to be allowed or
not?
__________
Page 8 of 17
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 03:15:22 pm )
SA Nos.1153 and 1154 of 2008
7. Thereafter, the First Appellate Court through its common judgment
dated 11.04.2008, modified the common judgment of the trial Court and partly
allowed the appeal in A.S. No.1 of 2005 and decreed the Suit in O.S. No.81 of
2001 in respect of 11 cents and the Suit in O.S. No.538 of 2001 was also
modified and partly allowed the Suit in O.S. No.538 of 2001 in respect 56 cents.
Aggrieved by the said common judgment and decrees, the Plaintiff in O.S.
No.81 of 2001 and the defendant in O.S. No.538 of 2001 have preferred these
second appeals respectively.
8. This Court admitted the second appeals on the following substantial
questions of law:
(i) Whether the conclusion of the Lower Appellate Court relying on
Ex.B.16 is unsustainable in law more particularly when Ex.B.16 does not
establish possession of the properties by the parties.
(ii) Whether the Lower Appellate Court has failed to assign sufficient
and cogent reasons while reversing the findings of the trial Court and the
judgment is vitiated.
(iii) Whether the Lower Appellate court has failed to appreciate the oral
and documentary evidence in proper perspective and the judgment is vitiated.
9. The learned counsel appearing for the appellant in both the appeals
would submit that the appellant in S.A. No.1153 of 2008 has filed a Suit in O.S.
__________
Page 9 of 17
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 03:15:22 pm )
SA Nos.1153 and 1154 of 2008
No.81 of 2001 for the reliefs of declaration and permanent injunction in respect
of the Suit property. The respondent in S.A. No.1154 of 2008 has filed a Suit in
O.S. No.538 of 2001 for the relief of permanent injunction. Both the Suits were
tried along with another Suit in O.S. No.262 of 2001. The trial Court has
correctly decreed the Suit filed by the appellant and dismissed the Suit filed by
the respondent. However, the First Appellate Court modified the decree and
judgment and granted decree in respect of 11 cents and also granted decree in
the another Suit filed by the respondent to an extent of 56 cents. Originally the
Suit property was allotted to the share of the appellant and her mother through
final decree proceedings in O.S. No.92 of 1960 and possession was also granted
through proceedings in E.P. No.125 of 1968. As per the final decree, the Suit
property was allotted to the Plaintiff and her mother. While so, the respondent
attempted to interfere with the Plaintiff’s possession and enjoyment of the
property and thereby, she filed the Suit. The respondent herein filed the Suit in
O.S. No..538 of 2001 for the relief of permanent injunction claiming that he is
in possession and enjoyment of the property.
9.1. The learned counsel would further submit that in fact, both the
parties admitted that the Suit property was allotted by partition in O.S. No.92 of
1960 and delivery of possession was also granted through proceedings in E.P.
No.125 of 1968 and 126 of 1966. The old Survey number of the property is
S. No.56/2 in New survey number is S. No.1/6. The Plaintiff’s property is
situated in old Survey No.56/2 to an extent of 68 cents and the defendant’s
__________
Page 10 of 17
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 03:15:22 pm )
SA Nos.1153 and 1154 of 2008
property is situated in Old Survey No.37 to an extent of 68 cents. Therefore, the
properties situated in two different survey numbers were allotted to each
Plaintiff and the defendant’s vendors. While so, the First Appellate Court has
merely relied the Survey Register, which was filed as an additional document
before the First Appellate Court and wrongly came to a conclusion that the
Plaintiff is entitled only to 11 cents. After receipt of additional document,
Ex.B.16, Land Survey Register and while dealing the same, nothing has been
discussed in the judgment that an extent of 68 cents of Suit property is not
situated in Old Survey No.56/2 and New Survey No.1/6. Thereby, reversing the
judgment of the trial Court is without any acceptable and valid reasons based on
the evidences. The Lower Appellate Court has not given clear findings while
setting aside the well considered judgment of the trial Court. Ex.A.2, Ex.A.4
and Ex.A.8 have clearly established that in Item Nos.7 and 8 of the said Suit
property, to an extent of 68 cents in Old S. No.56/2, New S. No.1/6, the Plaintiff
had taken possession of the property. While so, the First Appellate court
without even framing proper points for determination, based on the additional
document and without giving any opportunity to the parties to adduce evidence,
allowed the appeal and modified the judgment of the trial Court and granted
relief in respect of 11 cents to the Plaintiff in O.S. No.81 of 2001 and also
granted decree in respect of 56 cents to the Plaintiff in O.S. No.538 of 2001.
Therefore, the common judgment and decrees passed by the First Appellate
Court are liable to be set aside.
__________
Page 11 of 17
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 03:15:22 pm )
SA Nos.1153 and 1154 of 2008
10. The learned counsel appearing for the respondents in both the
appeals would submit that the respondent has filed a Suit in O.S. No.538 of
2001 for the relief of permanent injunction and the appellant herein has filed a
Suit in O.S. No.81 of 2001 for the reliefs of declaration and permanent
injunction. In fact, the respondent in these second appeals and the Plaintiff in
O.S. No.538 of 2001, has purchased the properties through two Sale Deeds
dated 17.05.1968 and the vendor of the respondent got the property through
Preliminary decree in O.S. No.92 of 1960 and final decree through execution
proceedings in E.P. No.126 of 1966 dated 20.07.1966. Therefore, the Plaintiff’s
predecessor had been in possession and enjoyment of the property, thereby, the
Plaintiff obtained the property and from the date of purchase, he has been under
possession and enjoyment of the property. The trial Court without considering
the evidences in a proper and perspective manner, erroneously dismissed the
Suit filed by the respondent and decreed the Suit filed by the appellant.
However, the First Appellate Court after considering the evidences in a proper
and perspective manner, partly decreed the Suits to an extent of 11 cents to the
appellant and 56 cents to the respondent. Therefore, the common judgment and
the decrees passed by the First Appellate Court are based on the available
records and therefore, these second appeals are liable to be dismissed.
11. This Court heard both sides and perused the records.
__________
Page 12 of 17
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 03:15:22 pm )
SA Nos.1153 and 1154 of 2008
12. For the sake of convenience and brevity, the ‘appellant’ in both the
appeals will be referred to as ‘Plaintiff’ and the ‘respondent’ will be referred to
as ‘defendant’.
13. In this case, there is no dispute that both the parties are entitled to the
properties through final decree proceedings in O.S. No.92 of 1960. According
to the Plaintiff, she is entitled to the property by way of final decree passed in
O.S. No.92 of 1960 and the possession was also delivered through Court order
dated 06.05.1968 passed in E.P. No.125 of 1968. Thereby, she is entitled to the
property. According to the defendant, he purchased the property from his
vendor through Sale Deeds dated 17.05.1968. The vendor of the defendant was
also entitled to the property through final decree proceedings in O.S. No.92 of
1960. Therefore, both the parties are claiming the property through final
decree.
14. As per the final decree proceedings, the Suit property was allotted to
the Plaintiff. In order to prove the case of the Plaintiff, on the side of the
Plaintiff, PW1 and PW2 were examined and the documents Ex.A1 to Ex.A.43
were marked. On the side of the defendants, DW1 to DW4 were examined and
Ex.B.1 to Ex.B.15 were marked. The trial Court decreed the Suit filed by the
Plaintiff and dismissed the Suit filed by the defendant. The First Appellate
Court partly allowed the appeals and granted decree in favour of the Plaintiff in
__________
Page 13 of 17
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 03:15:22 pm )
SA Nos.1153 and 1154 of 2008
respect of 11 cents and granted decree in favour of the defendant in respect of
56 cents.
15. Before going into the merits of the case, this Court noticed that the
First Appellate court has not framed proper points for determination. In all the
appeals, the First Appellate Court has framed the only point as to whether the
three appeals are liable to be allowed or not. Apart from that, there is no any
other point framed by the First Appellate Court and the same is not in
consonance with Order XLI Rule 31 of Code of Civil Procedure. Further the
First Appellate Court has received an additional document Ex.B.16. The First
Appellate Court, without discussing about the above said document and without
affording opportunity to the opposite party to dispute the document, allowed the
appeals based on the above said document.
16. As per Order XLI Rule 31 of Code of Civil Procedure, the judgment
of the Appellate Court shall be in writing and shall state— (a) the points for
determination; (b) the decision thereon; (c) the reasons for the decision. In this
case on hand, no point for determination has been properly framed and the First
Appellate Court has not given reasons for reversal of the judgment of the trial
Court. As per Order XLI Rule 27 of the Code of Civil Procedure, the Appellate
Court has power to receive additional documents. As per Order XLI Rule 28 of
the Code of Civil Procedure, after receipt of a document, the First Appellate
__________
Page 14 of 17
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 03:15:22 pm )
SA Nos.1153 and 1154 of 2008
Court has to take evidence or direct the Court from whose decree, the appeal is
preferred or any other subordinate Court, to take such evidence and to send it
when taken to the Appellate Court. But in the case on hand, the First Appellate
Court failed to follow the procedure under Order XLI Rule 28 of the Code of
Civil Procedure. Without framing proper points for determination and without
proper discussions, the First Appellate Court has reversed the common
judgment passed by the trial Court and thereby, the common judgment of the
First Appellate Court is not in consonance with provisions of the Code of Civil
Procedure. Therefore, the judgment of the First Appellate Court is against the
provisions of Order XLI Rule 28 and 31 of Code of Civil Procedure. Therefore,
the common judgment and decrees passed by the First Appellate Court are
liable to be set aside and the matter is to be remanded back to the First
Appellate Court for framing proper points for determination and to record
evidence in respect of the document, Ex.B.16, received as an additional
document by affording opportunity to both the parties in respect of the same and
to dispose the appeal in the manner known to law. If necessary call for the
original record of Ex.B.16 and peruse the said document.
17. Accordingly, these second appeals are allowed. The decrees and
the common judgment dated 11.04.2008 passed by the First Appellate Court
in A.S. Nos.1 of 2005 and 3 of 2005 on the file of the Subordinate Judge,
Tiruvallur are set aside and the matter is remanded back to the First
__________
Page 15 of 17
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 03:15:22 pm )
SA Nos.1153 and 1154 of 2008
Appellate Court for fresh consideration by framing proper points for
determination and to provide opportunity to both the parties in respect of the
additional document, Ex.B.16, and to dispose the same in accordance with
law. Since the appeals are pending for a long time, the First Appellate Court
is hereby directed to dispose the appeals within four (4) months from the date
of receipt of a copy of this judgment. T here shall be no order as to costs.
Consequently, the connected miscellaneous petitions are closed.
19-11-2026
Index: Yes/No
Speaking/Non-speaking order
Neutral Citation: Yes/No
MJS
To
1. The Subordinate Judge, Tiruvallur.
2. The District Munsif, Pallipattu.
__________
Page 16 of 17
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 03:15:22 pm )
SA Nos.1153 and 1154 of 2008
P.DHANABAL J.
MJS
SA No. 1153 of 2008
AND
SA NO. 1154 OF 2008
19-11-2026
__________
Page 17 of 17
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 03:15:22 pm )