Raheja District Iii Private Limited Through Ashish S Raheja vs The State Of Maharashtra And Anr.

Court
Bombay High Court

CNR No : HCBM010422522026

2026:BHC-AS:45635
WP.4373.2026.doc
Ajay


IN IN THE THE HIGH HIGH COURT COURT OF OF JUDICATURE JUDICATURE AT AT BOMBAY BOMBAY
CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
WRIT PETITION NO. 4373 OF 2026
Raheja District – III Private Limited,
Through Ashish S. Raheja and Anr. .. Petitioners
Versus
State of Maharashtra and Anr. .. Respondents
WITH
INTERIM APPLICATION NO. 3544 OF 2026
IN
WRIT PETITION NO. 4373 OF 2026
New Era Advisor Pvt Ltd.
Applicant /
Orig. Respondent No.2
Versus
Raheja District – III Private Limited,
Through Ashish S. Raheja and Anr. .. Respondents
..
....................

Mr. Aabad Ponda, Senior Advocate a/w. Zulfiquar Memon, Mr.
Parvez Memon, Mr. Abhishek Gupta, Mr. Mahesh Ahire, Mr. Kush
Agarwal, Mr. Chinmay Bambarkar and Mr. Bharat Zaveri,
Advocates i/by MZM Legal LLP for Petitioners.

Ms. Shilpa G. Talhar, APP for Respondent – State.

Mr. Manoj Mohite, Senior Advocate a/w. Mr. Gaurav Parkar,
Advocate for Respondent No.2.

PI – Juberahmed Mujawar, Housing – I EOW, PI – Kiran Aher,
EOW, Mumbai and API – Sandip Pise, EOW, Mumbai.
......…...........
CORAM : MILIND N. JADHAV, J.
DATE : NOVEMBER 18, 2026.
JUDGEMENT:
1. Heard Mr. Ponda, learned Senior Advocate for Petitioner;
Ms. Talhar, learned APP for Respondent – State and Mr. Mohite,
learned Senior Advocate for Respondent No.2.
1 of 30

WP.4373.2026.doc

2. The Petition is filed under Article 226 of the Constitution of
India read with Section 528 of Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita,
2023 (for short “BNSS”) for quashing and setting aside of CR No.78 of
2026 dated 11.08.2026 currently under investigation by the Economic
Offences Wing (for short “EOW”) under Sections 318(1), 318(4) and
3(5) of Bharatiya Nyaya Samhita, 2023 (for short “BNS”)arising out of
FIR No.1180 of 2026 registered with Oshiwara Police Station wherein
Petitioners are arraigned as Accused Nos.5 and 6 respectively. Accused
No.1 is Unimers India Ltd., Accused No.2 is J.P. Goenka, Accused No.3
is Vardhan Goenka and Accused No.4 is Satya Prakash Gupta. Accused
Nos.2, 3, 4 are associated with Accused No.1 – Company.
3. The brief facts necessary of adjudication of the present
Petition are as under:-
3.1. Petitioner No.1 is a Private Limited Company incorporated
under the Companies Act, 1956 carrying on business of real estate
development. Petitioner No.2 is its director. Respondent No.2 is a
private limited company and through its director Mr. Brijmohan P.
Rathi has filed the FIR leading to registration of present CR on
11.08.2026.
3.2.
According to prosecution case, Accused No.1 – Unimers India
Ltd. took a loan from IFCI to set up a chemical plant and defaulted on
repayment as a result of which IFCI was in the process of selling off the
2 of 30

WP.4373.2026.doc

loan to another entity. According to First Informant it is alleged that its
Director went to IFCI’s office at Nariman Point, Mumbai to obtain
details and learned that as on 01.07.2008 its outstanding dues
aggregating to Rs.86.55 crores were secured by mortgage of the
company’s movable and immovable assets including 1,52,419 square
meters of land in District Thane along with plant, building and
machinery thereon. It is stated in the FIR that Unimers India Ltd. had
also taken loans from other institutions namely ICICI Bank, IDBI Bank,
LIC and SBI Bank but since no third party rights were created over its
mortgaged property, Respondent No.2 – First Informant agreed to
purchase IFCI’s loan for Rs.95,49,50,000 which was formalized
through a Deed of Assignment dated 01.10.2009 by virtue of which all
rights over Unimers’s outstanding dues of Rs.86.55 crores as on
01.07.2008 were transferred to Respondent No.2. This was followed
by a registered Supplementary Deed of Assignment dated 29.12.2012
reaffirming the outstanding amount of Rs.86.55 crores as stated in the
Deed of Assignment.
3.3. It is stated in the FIR that Unimers filed Civil Suit No.1656 of
2009 in the Delhi High Court challenging Respondent No.2’s purchase
of the loan followed by another Suit No.942 of 2013 in the Bombay
High Court. Both these Suits are presently pending, the former before
Saket District Court (Suit No.209825 of 2015) and City Civil Court
Mumbai (Suit No.0102727 of 2024).
3 of 30

WP.4373.2026.doc

3.4. It is then stated in the FIR that in a previous Suit proceeding
namely Notice of Motion No.791 of 2002 in Suit No.771 of 2002 filed
by ICICI Bank in this Court order dated 29.03.2004 was passed
wherein it was held that any charge on Unimers’s property would
remain subject to ICICI Bank’s rights. In the FIR it is charged and
alleged that despite prevalence of this order and without obtaining
consent of IFCI or other lenders, Unimers executed Agreement For
Assignment (for short "AFA") dated 14.05.2008 (registered on
14.08.2008) agreeing to assign the mortgaged land to Petitioner No.1
for Rs.184.29 crores in lieu of which on execution of the AFA,
Unimerse received an upfront amount of Rs.29,62,50,000 from
Petitioner No.1 which was used by its promoters towards their
unsecured liabilities and to return promoter share capital. I need to
note here that Petitioner No.1 on instructions has shown its willingness
to pay the balance amount as per the AFA to fructify the Assignment.
3.5. After the aforesaid actual charge it is stated in the FIR that
Respondent No.2 – Complainant upon learning about this transaction
of 2008 personally visited the Company's site in February 2026 and
saw that there was no trace of the company called Unimers India Ltd.
thereupon and no plant or machinery existed thereon and the security
personnel could not tell him about the whereabouts of the machinery.
Hence on 02.04.2026, Respondent No.2 lodged a criminal complaint
before the EOW. Preliminary Inquiry No.115 of 2026 was registered
4 of 30

WP.4373.2026.doc

and conducted over a period of 4 months. Petitioners cooperated with
the inquiry and duly submitted all relevant documents rather many
more documents pertaining to the intervening period during which
substantial pleadings and proceedings that were filed by Respondent
No.2 – Complainant itself before the Civil Courts in the pending Suit
proceedings and before the NCLT where Insolvency proceedings filed
against Unimers were pending due to initiation of CIRP against the
company and contended that the entire dispute alleged and raised by
Respondent No.2 – Complainant was purely civil in nature and most
importantly the AFA was to the knowledge of the Respondent No.2 -
Complainant despite which on a false premise that it gained
knowledge only in February 2026, the Complaint was filed on
06.04.2024 and CR was registered on 11.08.2026.
4. Hence the Petition for quashing.
5. Mr. Ponda, learned Senior Advocate for Petitioners at the
outset would submit that Respondent No.2 – Complainant is guilty of
suppressio veri and suggestio falsi . He would submit that Respondent
No.2 filed the FIR with a selective and partial disclosure of facts
deliberately suppressing material particulars having a direct bearing on
the registration and continuation of the CR. He would submit that
Respondent No.2 suppressed material facts and evidence about
pending proceedings before the Civil Courts in Mumbai and Delhi
5 of 30

WP.4373.2026.doc

NCLT, and NCLAT which it was infact actively pursuing during the
interregnum. He would draw my attention to order dated 18.11.2022
passed by NCLT, Mumbai admitting Company Petition No.604 of 2018
copy of which is appended at page No. 439 to the Petition and contend
that this Company Petition filed by Gill International Limited was
admitted and NCLT initiated Corporate Insolvency Resolution Process
(for short “CIRP”) against Unimers India Ltd. (Accused No.1) declaring
a moratorium. He would submit that Petitioner No.1 was thereafter
duly admitted by the Interim Resolution Professional (for short “IRP”)
as a financial creditor with admitted claim of Rs.1,257 crores and the
claim of Respondent No.2 – Complainant was classified as "Other
Creditor" for Rs.218 crores. He would submit that Respondent No.2
complainant being aggrieved by this classification filed Interim
Application No.1667 of 2026 and Interim Application No.1669 of 2026
before NCLT Mumbai for setting aside Petitioner No.1’s admitted claim
and removal of the IRP. He would submit that these material facts are
suppressed by Respondent No.2 in the CR.
5.1. He would submit that Respondent No.2 pursued its remedy
before the NCLT and thereafter filed the present CR upon finding itself
dissatisfied in response to an adverse commercial classification which
cannot be attributed to the discovery of any offence committed by
Petitioner No.1 despite its statutory appeals pending before the NCLT.
He would submit that grievance of Complainant was already sub –
6 of 30

WP.4373.2026.doc

judice before the NCLT at its own instance and suppression of such
facts prima facie show the malafides of Respondent No.2 in setting
criminal law into motion for extraneous reasons. He would submit that
classification of Respondent No.2 – Complainant’s claim as “other
creditor” is on account of pendency of Suit No.0102727 of 2024 before
the City Civil Court, Mumbai which is suppressed in the CR altogether.
On this ground he would submit that suppression of material facts
particularly pendency of parallel civil or statutory proceedings
concerning the same subject matter of the CR vitiates the invocation of
the criminal process altogether.
5.2.
Next he would submit that when the aforesaid material was
placed before the Investigating Officer during preliminary inquiry, the
inquiry was conducted over a period of 4 moths for ascertaining
whether the dispute disclosed any criminality on the part of
Petitioners. He would submit that Petitioners furnished voluminous
documentary material to the Investigating Officer under their covering
letter dated 05.05.2026 including material bearing directly on the
question of Respondent No.2’s knowledge of the AFA executed in
2008, pendency of NCLT proceedings and pendency of Civil Suit
proceedings between the parties at Mumbai and New Delhi. He would
submit that the CR is filed simpliciter on the basis of the original
complaint dated 06.04.2024 without independent verification, scrutiny
or investigation of the aforesaid documentary evidence, neither the CR
7 of 30

WP.4373.2026.doc

indicates that Investigating Officer has examined the same before
arriving at a conclusion that a cognizable offence is even made out. He
would therefore vehemently submit that there is complete non-
application of mind since the CR does not deal with the aforesaid
documentary evidence but most importantly it does not answer the
inordinate and unexplained delay of 18 years in registration of the
complaint before setting the criminal law into motion. He would
submit that the CR has been registered without any independent fact
finding inquiry and on the ground of material suppression by
Respondent No.2 – First Informant and therefore deserves to be
quashed as against the Petitioners.
5.3. On the applicability of the provisions of Section 318(1) read
with 318(4) of BNS to Petitioners pertaining to the offence of cheating,
he would submit that in the CR there is no allegation let alone any
particulars of facts that Petitioners have made any promise,
representation, assurance or inducement to Respondent No.2 – First
Informant at any point in time, neither there is any allegation about
communication or correspondence, oral and / or written between the
parties. He would submit that when deception is neither alleged nor
discernible from the complaint, the inquiry does not even reach the
question of inducement and the offence has to fail at the threshold.
While drawing my attention to the provisions of Section 318(1) and
318(4) of BNS he would submit that, offence of cheating requires the
8 of 30

WP.4373.2026.doc

essential ingredient of deception practiced upon the person alleged to
have been cheated coupled with a dishonest or fraudulent intention
existing at the very inception of the transaction by reason thereof that
the person was induced to deliver property or to do or omit to do
something which he would not otherwise have done. In support of this
submission he would refer to and rely upon the decision of the
Supreme Court in the case of Delhi Race Club (1940) Ltd. Vs. State of
1
UP and contend that it is authoritatively settled that deception
whether by false representation, by other action or omission is the
foundation and an indispensable ingredient without which the offence
of cheating cannot be said to exist followed by a fraudulent
inducement flowing from that deception. He would submit that it is
Respondent No.2’s case is that it had carried out legal due diligence
with regard to assignment of the property belonging to Unimers and
had made its own independent assessment before purchasing the debt
from IFCI. Once it is Respondent No.2’s own case that it had acted
upon its own due diligence without any nexus or representation by
Petitioners who were not concerned with the said transaction
altogether on their own showing, there is no inducement much less
any offence of cheating. Another point argued by Mr. Ponda is that
provisions of Section 318(4) of BNS can never apply to transactions
that took place prior to coming into force of BNS but considering the
1
2024 10 SCC 690
9 of 30

WP.4373.2026.doc

substance of the provisions and the then subsisting provision of Section
420 IPC, he would argue that essential ingredients thereof namely
dishonestly, inducing delivery of property, making false representation
or any other such overt act even on the Respondent No.2’s own
complaint is not attributable to the Petitioners.
5.4. Next he would submit that there is complete absence of
privity of contract or nexus between Petitioners and Respondent No.2 –
First Informant and most importantly it is an admitted the fact that
Respondent No.2 came into the picture only after the AFA was
executed and registered by Petitioner No.1 with Unimers. He would
submit that in complete absence of any transaction, direct or indirect,
between Petitioners and Respondent No.2, the offence of cheating
cannot in law be predicated of the Petitioners at the instance of
Respondent No.2 especially if it is founded on deception and
inducement as alleged in the CR.
5.5. Finally on merits of the transactions namely the AFA, he
would submit that it is not equivalent to an assignment or transfer of
property so as to breach the injunction granted by this Court in Suit
No.771 of 2002. He would submit that a mere glance through the AFA
would show that it contains reciprocal obligations to be carried out and
fulfilled as stipulated therein and its completion is expressly based
upon Unimers settling the public debenture holder's dues and
10 of 30

WP.4373.2026.doc

procuring vacation of injunction order and withdrawing Suit No.771 of
2002. He would submit that the Deed of Assignment is not executed or
registered till date and assignment or leasehold interest in the subject
land is not made made in favour of Petitioner No.1 neither registered
nor consented to by MIDC since it is a leased property. He would
vehemently submit that Petitioner No.1 at this juncture has no title
through the AFA in the subject land. He would submit that the AFA as
it stands is an agreement to assign which when unperformed transfers
no right, title or interest in the immovable property.
5.6. He would submit that status of Petitioner No.1 is that of a
creditor of Unimers for the monies it has paid and the sums claimed
under the AFA whereas Respondent No.2 has purchased the right from
IFCI and both parties have been treated in the CIRP accordingly as
"Secured Financial Creditor and "Other Creditor". He would submit
that the real grievance for invoking criminal proceedings infact stems
from the fact that the List of Creditors dated 25.11.2025 classifies
Respondent No.2 as "Other Creditor" which is not palatable to
Respondent No.2 whereas Petitioner No.1 is classified as a “Secured
Financial Creditor” and it is this classification and resulting loss of
control over Committee of Creditors (for short “CoC”) which has
precipitated filing of the present criminal complaint.
11 of 30

WP.4373.2026.doc

5.7. Petitioners have also argued that Respondent No.2’s right
rests upon the Deed of Assignment executed in 2009, Supplementary
Deed of Assignment executed in 2012 and Deed of Confirmation
executed in 2013. The sequitur of this submission is that the document
effecting transfer of undivided share in right, title and interest in
immovable property is compulsory registrable under Registration Act,
1908. Petitioner No.1’s AFA is a registered document is prior in point
of time that any of the documents claimed by the Petitioner. It is seen
that the 2009 Deed of Assignment executed by Respondent No.2 was
registered in 2012 only.
5.8.
In support of his aforesaid submissions, he has referred to
and relied upon the following decisions of the Supreme Court in the
2
cases of:-(i) Anita Maurya Vs. State of UP (ii) Kishan Singh Vs.
3 4
Gurpal (iii) Nazibul Rahim Khan and Ors. Vs. State of UP (iv) Mohd.
5
Wajid Vs. State of UP (v) Bhikhubhai Govindbhai Patel & Anr. Vs. State
6
of Gujrat and Anr. (vi) Suraj Lamp & Industries (P) Ltd. Vs. State of
7 8
Haryana (vii) Ghanshayam Vs. Yogendra Rathi (viii) Rekha Jain Vs.
9 10
Karnataka (ix) Paramjeet Batra Vs. State of Uttarakhand (x) Mohd.
11
Azad Khan Vs. State of Jammu and Kashmir (xi) Mohd. Ibrahim Vs.
2 2026 SCC OnLine 1519
3 (2010) 8 SCC 775
4 2026 SCC OnLine 1557
5 (2023) 20 SCC 219
6 2026 SCC OnLine SC 915
7
(2012) 1 SCC 656
8
Civil Appeal No.7527 – 7528 of 2021 decided on 02.06.2023
9
(2022) 18 SCC 174
10
(2013) 11 SCC 673
11
2020 SCC OnLine J&K 663
12 of 30

WP.4373.2026.doc

12 13
State of Bihar (xii) Vesa Holding (P) Ltd. Vs. State of Kerala (xiii)
14
Anukul Singh Vs. State of UP
6.
PER CONTRA Mr. Mohite learned Advocate for Respondent
No.2 – First Informant vehemently opposed the present Petition and at
the outset drawn my attention to the Affidavit-in-Reply dated
22.10.2026 copy of which is appended at page no. 265 of the Petition
and contended that by order dated 29.03.2004 this Court had granted
injunction restraining Unimers India Ltd. (Accused No.1) from
disposing, alienating or creating third party rights over the mortgaged
property and movable assets despite which the AFA dated 14.05.2008
was executed by Unimers in favour of Petitioner No.1 and Unimerse
accepted/received an amount of Rs.29,62,50,000 from Petitioner No.1.
He would submit that the AFA was executed contrary to the injunction
order without obtaining leave of this Court in the first instance.
6.1. Next he would submit that against the stated consideration
therein of approximately Rs.184.29 crores and without fulfillment of
any of the conditions precedent under the AFA, the injunction was not
vacated, the secured creditors were never settled, Suit No.771 of 2002
was never withdrawn and the charges on the property belonging to
Unimers were never released from attachment, neither final Deed of
Assignment was executed in favour of Petitioner No.1 nor assignment
12
(2009) 8 SCC 751
13
(2015) 8 SCC 293
14
2025 SCC OnLine SC 2060
13 of 30

WP.4373.2026.doc

of leasehold rights was fructified. He would vehemently argue that the
upfront amount of Rs.29.62 crores received by Unimers was never
utilized to repay the banks and financial institutions and Unimers
diverted / siphoned off the same to repay its unsecured loans and to
refund the advance against the share capital of the promoters of
Unimers. He would submit that the AFA was executed between parties
not only in willful breach of the injunction order of 2004 but without
sanction of the secured creditors. He would vehemently argue that the
said transaction was not a bonafide commercial transaction but as
stated in the FIR designed to siphon of valuable secured assets of
Unimers.
6.2. He would persuade me to consider that the AFA was
designed as a camouflage to discharge Unimers’s unsecured loans
rather than apply it towards repayment of its secured creditors and
therefore was a suspicious transaction. He would fairly concede that
Unimers was admitted into CIRP by NCLT on 18.11.2026 and pursuant
to the public announcement, Respondent No.2 lodged a Financial
Secured Creditor claim of approximately Rs.3,466 crores. While
drawing my attention to the averments made in the affidavit-in-reply,
he would submit that the IRP wrongfully rejected Respondent No.2’s
Financial Secured Creditor claim of Rs.3466 crores and admitted only
Rs.218.62 crores claim under the caption of “Other Creditor” thereby
excluding Respondent No.2 from the CoC. He would argue that this
14 of 30

WP.4373.2026.doc

rejection and reclassification of Respondent No.2’s claim was not
merely an adjudication error but a result of collusion between the IRP
and the other accused persons in relegating the Respondent No.2’s
claim as “Other Creditor” and this constituted the very core of the
criminal conspiracy alleged.
7. Before I proceed further it would be apt to deal with this ground
argued by Respondent No.2 and as reflected as paragraph No.1(xii) of
its Reply Affidavit. It is seen that Respondent No.2 is aggrieved with
the IRP admitting Petitioner No.1’s claim of Rs.1256.41 crores as a
secured financial debt based on the AFA under which only Rs.29.62
crores was paid and no title ever passed onto Petitioner No.1.
Respondent No.2 is peeved with the fact that by virtue of this
Petitioner No.1, is conferred a dominant 86.41% voting share in the
CoC which enabled Petitioner No.1 to exercise effective control over all
decisions in the CIRP including the decision concerning the fate of the
assets claimed as security by Respondent No.2. It is seen that in
paragraph No.1(xii) to (xiv), Respondent No.2 has raised the above
grievance however the said grievance is not raised or pleaded or
charged in the Complaint / CR dated 11.08.2026, thus the objection of
the Respondent No.2 – Complainant comes to the fore and it is prima
facie seen that in view of the proceedings before the NCLT and the
orders passed therein, Respondent No.2 is aggrieved with the same.
On a pointed question been asked to Mr. Mohite about absence of the
15 of 30

WP.4373.2026.doc

main charge in the CR, he would accept the same and contend that in
the first complaint dated 02.04.2026 filed before the EOW, the above
charge was duly stated. Though Respondent No.2 has argued in the
same breath that pendency of the civil proceedings before NCLT does
not bar criminal investigation pertaining to alleged dishonesty,
diversion, fabrication of record and conspiracy, but these are mere bald
allegations printed on paper without satisfying and justifying any role
attributed to Petitioner No.1 qua the aforesaid 4 charges. There is a
clear dichotomy in the contents of the CR and the grounds stated
therein and the defence taken by the Complainant in its affidavit in
reply which is alluded to hereinabove. Therefore I am not inclined to
accept the submissions made qua dishonesty, diversion, fabrication of
record and conspiracy without there being any factual basis or material
showing involvement of Petitioner No.1. Rather, save and except
alleging conspiracy on the part of Petitioners as a bald assertion, all
submissions made by Mr. Mohite are directed towards Unimers and its
conduct.
8. It is argued by Mr. Mohite that in February 2026,
Respondent No.2 discovered that the security guards manning the
subject property in Thane were deployed and engaged by the
Petitioners because the adjoining properties also belonged to the
Petitioners, however there is no explanation offered with regard to the
inordinate delay if 18 years in alleging that conduct of Petitioners in
16 of 30

WP.4373.2026.doc

2026 seriously jeopardized the security and interests of the secured
creditors including that of Respondent No.2. Respondent No.2’s further
argument and submission on the issue of knowledge of the AFA is that
it is a matter of mere inference that Mr. Prakash Selot then a minority
shareholder of Unimers had pleaded and annexed the AFA in Company
Petition 133/397 – 398 / MB / 2008 and he subsequently became
Director of Respondent No.2. It is seen that Respondent No.2 has
acknowledged the existence of the registered AFA with Petitioner No.1
in its Written Statement dated 12.02.2016 filed in Suit No.942 of
2013.
9.
It has also further acknowledged that IFCI and Respondent
No.2 referred to the AFA in proceedings before the Civil Court in New
Delhi filed on 07.12.2018 however in the same breath Respondent
No.2 contends that even though Respondent No.2 may have had
knowledge of the existence of AFA, the adverse classification of
Respondent No.2’s claim by RP was done in November 2025 and
disappearance of hypothecated movable assets of Unimers was
discovered in February 2026 and therefore the criminal complaint and
CR is maintainable against not only Unimers but also against
Petitioners. What is argued is that delay and laches will not hit the
claim Respondent No.2 because the moment the aforesaid two issues
occurred complaint was filed and therefore knowledge of the AFA with
Petitioner No.1 since 2008 is immaterial and irrelevant.
17 of 30

WP.4373.2026.doc

10. It is stated in the Affidavit in Reply by Respondent No.2 that
its real grievance is against Unimers and its promoters. If that be the
case then there is no reason for implicating and indicting the
Petitioners. The main thrust of the Affidavit in Reply filed by
Respondent No.2 is its grievance regarding admission of Petitioner
No.1’s claim as Financial Secured Creditor as against Respondent
No.2’s claim categorized as “Other Creditor” leaving it entirely outside
the CoC as a Secured Financial Creditor. The CR copy is appended at
page No.55 and Respondent No.2 - Complainant’s statement begins at
page No.62 and ends on page No.76 of the Petition. In the entire
statement of complainant, there is not a whisper of the grievance
raised by Respondent No.2 regarding classification of its claim as
“Other Creditor” by the IRP though in the Affidavit in Reply it is
alleged that IRP has connived with Petitioners. Thus a clear dichotomy
exists in the pleadings on the face of record.
11. Respondent No.1 – State has filed Affidavit of Juberahmed
Chansaheb Mujawar, Police Inspector of EOW, Police
Commissionerate, Mumbai dated 07.10.2026 to oppose the Petition. In
the said Affidavit in Reply, the entire factual history is narrated. In this
Affidavit in Reply in paragraph Nos.30, 31 and 32 the prosecution has
raised a question and has also answered the same with regard to
disposal of movable property of M/s. Unimers India Ltd. Which had
came to the notice of Respondent No.2 – Complainant in the month of
18 of 30

WP.4373.2026.doc

February 2026. In paragraph No.30 under reference, it is stated by the
prosecution that “ ... since M/s. Unimers had also disposed of its
movable property, this came to the notice of complainant in the month
of February 2026, and they filed a complaint regarding the same...” . In
paragraph No.31 it is stated that “... Accused No.1 (Unimers)
transferred / disposed of its movable property, when, how, and with
whose permission …” In paragraph No.32 it is stated that “.. M/s.
Unimers India Ltd. company who had disposed of its movable property
which came to the notice of the complainant only in the month of
February 2026..” . Thus there is no role attributed to the Petitioners
regarding disposal of the (movable properties) at all. What is
significant to note here is that the entire Affidavit in Reply of the
prosecution is stoically silent on the entire material placed before the
prosecution during Preliminary Enquiry and that speaks volumes of the
nature of investigation carried out by the prosecution. It is seen that
First Informant has referred to AFA (executed in 2008), alleged
disposal of movables by Unimers and classification of its claim by the
IRP as “Other Creditor” and filed the Complaint in 2026 alleging fraud
in executing the AFA only in the CR.
12. I have heard the submissions of the learned advocates at the
bar and considered the entire entire material placed before me with
their able assistance. Submissions made the learned advocates have
received due consideration of the Court.
19 of 30

WP.4373.2026.doc

13. The present case can be decided on the basis of the following
4 propositions which are argued before the Court:-
(i) On the aspect of delay and laches for registering the FIR
qua the AFA executed in 2008 after 18 years;
(ii) Purpose of the AFA dated 14.05.2008;
(iii) Applicability of the provisions of 318(1) and 318(4) of
BNS, 2023 to the facts of the present case; and
(iv) nature of the dispute between the various parties.
14.
Before I address the aforesaid 4 issues to adjudicate the
present Writ Petition, it needs to be noted that admittedly the main
offence pertained to disposal of movable assets of Unimers and
classification of Respondent No.2’s Claim by IRP as “Other Creditor” in
CIRP proceedings in the NCLT alleging conspiracy and fraud by
Petitioners is not disclosed in the FIR which becomes the starting point
of criminal prosecution. This is an admitted fact and Mr Mohite in his
usual fair mindedness would however attempt to make up the lost
ground by arguing that the principal offence is disclosed in the EOW
Complaint dated 02.04.2026; Secondly, record shows that there is
absolutely no nexus / privity of contract between Petitioners and
Respondent No.2; Thirdly the AFA is a registered document as against
the Deed of Assignment of 2009 which was registered in 2012
20 of 30

WP.4373.2026.doc

subsequently; Fourthly and admittedly Respondent No.2 accepts and
acknowledges having knowledge about the AFA as averred in its
Affidavit in Reply notwithstanding which it is really aggrieved with
classification of its claim in the category of “Other Creditor” in and
hence CIRP proceedings the present complaint is filed. What is
significant is that Respondent No.2 has filed two Interim Applications
before the NCLT seeking to set aside Petitioner No.1’s admitted claim
and removal of the IRP which are pending hearing despite which on
the same cause of action, the present criminal complaint is filed
invoking only the AFA as a fraudulent document.
15.
In the above background, it is seen that Unimers entered into
the AFA with Petitioners subject to specific terms and conditions stated
therein to assign its leasehold interest in the said land for consideration
of Rs.184.29 crores payable in 4 stages. Copy of AFA dated 14.08.2008
which is a registered document is appended Annexure “D” page 85 of
the Petition. Clause Nos.4, 5, 6 and 7 of the said AFA are directly
relevant with regard to the agreement to assign obligations of the
parties. Clause No.4 of the AFA stipulates that the AFA is subject to the
assignor first fulfilling the obligations stated under Clause Nos. 6 and 7
and the assignor must get the injunction in the 2002 Suit vacated and
have that Suit withdrawn. The AFA states that only after those steps
are completed the Assignee must purchase the property free from all
encumbrances for a total consideration of Rs.184.29 crores. Next, as
21 of 30

WP.4373.2026.doc

per Clause No.5 consideration is not paid at one time directly to the
Assignor instead an escrow account is opened with HDFC Bank and
the consideration is deposited by the Assignee in the escrow account
on the conditions set out on compliance of Stage 1 and Stage 2
compliances and only when documentary proof of compliances is
shown to the Assignee, the payment made upfront of Rs.
Rs.29,62,50,000/- would be referred by HDFC Bank in stages. Further
Clause No.6 stipulates payments and vacation of the injunction order
of 2002 as conditions precedent before the AFA could transcend into
an actual Deed of Assignment. It is seen that Clause 6(a)(i) of the AFA
required Unimers, within four months, to settle the dues of the Public
Debenture Holders, to have the injunction vacated and to withdraw
2002 Suit; and Clause 6(a)(ix) provided that if Unimers failed to do so,
the Petitioner No.1 was at liberty to pay the Debenture Holders or the
Trustee directly, or to deposit the amount in Court, so as to secure the
withdrawal of the suit and the vacation of the injunction.
16.
It is therefore clearly deduced that the AFA thus expressly
contemplated the subsisting injunction and structured completion
around its removal. Completion of the transaction was based on
fulfillment and compliance of reciprocal obligations recorded in the
Agreement which was a registered instrument, disclosed in the public
record on 14.08.2008.
22 of 30

WP.4373.2026.doc

17. It is seen that Stage 1 installment of INR.18,50,00,000/- and
stage 2 installment of Rs.9,12,50,000/ was paid by the Petitioner No.1
into an Escrow Account maintained with HDFC Bank, thus payment
was made through a scheduled bank under an escrow mechanism, and
not by any direct or informal transfer. It is further seen that application
of the funds after their receipt by Unimers was a matter entirely within
the control of Unimers and its directors and is the subject of the
allegations made in the said CR against accused Nos. 1 to 4, hence
indictment of the Petitioners is not understood at all .
18. Further it is seen that the conditions stipulated in Clause
6(a) of the AFA were never fulfilled. No Deed of Assignment has ever
been executed in favour of the Petitioner No.1. No assignment has
been made or registered with, or consented to by, MIDC, the lessor.
The Petitioner No.1 holds, and has at all material times held, no title to
the Said Land.
19. From the above it is prima facie seen that only Stage 1 and
Stage 2 installments of Rs. 18.50 crores and Rs.9,12,50,000 as paid by
Petitioner No.1 into the escrow account maintained with HDFC Bank
whereas the Stage 3 installment pertaining to the Stage 3 obligations
which involved dismantling and removal of the factory, its equipment,
inventory and structures is not yet paid. The AFA is not the same as the
Deed of Assignment and it does not amount to transfer and creation of
23 of 30

WP.4373.2026.doc

any right in the immovable property, much less the movable
properties. The record shows that the very same AFA was infact
challenged before the Company Law Board by Mr. Prakash Selot in
Company Petition alleging oppression and mismanagement of Unimers
India Ltd. Copy of this Company Petition is appended at page No.141
of this Writ Petition. This was in the year 2008 itself. What is crucial is
that in 2009, Respondent No. 2 stepped into the shoes of IFCI by
executing the Deed of Assignment which was registered subsequently
in 2012 and Clause No.6 of the said Deed of Assignment is extremely
crucial and goes to the root of the matter to dislodge the entire
argument of Respondent No.2. Clause 6 is reproduced below for
immediate reference so that there is no ambiguity in interpreting it. It
reads thus:-
"6) That the Purchaser hereby confirms that it hly acquired all the Sellers
rights, title and interest in the Security on as "AS IS WHERE IS' and 'AS IS
WHAT IS basis pursuant to its own due diligence, legal, financial or
otherwise, in respect of the abovementioned Financial Documents, Debts and
Security and has taken steps to know and assess all facts and circumstances
in relation to the Financial Documents, Debt and Security. The Purchaser has
satisfied itself about its decision of carrying out transactions under this
Agreement and the Seller shall not ix: held liable by the Purchaser
recoverability of Debt, The Purchaser is also aware that it may not get the
rights, benefits, privileges and powers of the Seller Statutory or otherwise,
which are available to the Seiler exclusively by virtue of being 'Financial
Institutions. The Purchaser hereby further agrees and confirms that it shall
not have any recourse against the Seller in respect of the Transactions
contemplated herein, on account of any reason whatsoever including but not
limited to:-"
20. Perusal of the above clause leaves no doubt in the mind that
Respondent No.2 took over IFCI’s debt and all right, title and interest
on “AS IS WHERE IS” and “AS IS WHAT IS” basis ( emphasis supplied )
24 of 30

WP.4373.2026.doc

and more specifically after carrying out its own due diligence regarding
all financial documents, debt and security. What is crucial to note is
the next sentence where Respondent No.2 states that it has satisfied
itself about its decisions to carry out transaction under this agreement
and “ ..the seller shall not be held liable by the purchaser.. ”. This is the
critical point of time i.e. in 2009 when Respondent No.2 not only
became aware but ought to have been reasonably become aware of the
AFA which was executed on 14.05.2008 and which was infact to the
knowledge of Mr. Prakash Selot who became a Director of Respondent
No.2 on 15.09.2011 subsequently. It is also seen that Respondent No.2
through the same Mr. Prakash Selot filed Written Statement dated
12.02.2016 in the Suit filed in this Court copy of which is appended at
Annexure “G” on page No.160 of the Petition wherein in paragraph
No.16 of the said Written Statement, there is a clear acknowledgment
of the AFA dated 14.05.2008 as stated therein. This Written Statement
is verified by Mr. Prakash Selot as Director of Defendant No.2.
21.
Next it is seen that in the order dated 07.12.2018 passed by
the Additional District Judge – 04 South East Saket Court, New Delhi
in Civil Suit No.208 of 2016 in paragraph No.3 on internal page No.15
of 33 between Unimers India Ltd. Vs. IFCI Ltd., there is a categoric
reference to the AFA as disclosed and pleaded by Respondent No.2 in
its written statement thereby showing that it had knowledge of the
same. From the aforesaid timeline it is thus prima facie seen that there
25 of 30

WP.4373.2026.doc

is a delay of 18 years on the face of record in registering the FIR.
Therefore the real reason for registering the criminal case is not on
account of the AFA but the subsequent classification of Respondent
No.2’s claim in the category of other creditors. Respondent No.2
cannot approbate and reprobate at the same time by merely alleging
dishonesty and fabrication, fraud, cheating and conspiracy without
substantiating it.
22. It is plainly seen that the present criminal complaint
indicting the Petitioners is nothing but a counterblast to the creditor
classification order of 25.11.2025 passed by NCLT. When the First
Information Report contents are seen the main offence is not even
disclosed therein, thus it is seen that present criminal case is filed only
upon Respondent No.2 being dissatisfied with the creditor
classification order and not due to discovery of any offence qua the
Petitioners before me. On the face of record and the above timeline
which is discussed, the delay is completely fatal to the case of
Respondent No.2. It is settled law that unexplained delay in filing FIR
is fatal and equally it is settled law that an agreement to sale does not
create interest in immovable property. The allegations in the CR that it
is founded qua the Petitioners on the basis of facts which arose
between October 2025 and February 2026 have no nexus whatsoever
to the Petitioners or for that matter the AFA and most importantly
neither is an offence alleged in the CR. Hence merely to contend that
26 of 30

WP.4373.2026.doc

in the EOW complaint all details are given cannot suffice. If this stance
is accepted then it would amount to prosecution having accepted the
Petitioner’s case since it has conducted a detailed enquiry for 4
months.
23.
The aforesaid observations and findings do not entitle the
Respondent No.2 to maintain the CR for any criminality as against the
Petitioners. The action on part of Respondent No.2 in filing the CR
without the main offence being disclosed in the FIR / CR amounts to a
vexatious and malicious attempt made with an ulterior motive for
pressurizing and intimidating not only Petitioners but directors of
Petitioner No.1 and the Resolution Professionals.
24. On the applicability of Sections 318(1) and 318(4) of BNS, it
is unfathomable to believe how Respondent No.2 has been cheated by
any false representation made to it. When the AFA was executed and
registered Respondent No.2 was never in the picture. There is no nexus
between Petitioner and Respondent No.2 when Respondent No.2
executed its Deed of Assignment with IFCI in 2009 (which was
registered in 2013) and it categorically averred that it was on “AS IS
WHERE IS” and “AS IS WHAT IS BASIS” after carrying out due
diligence. Therefore there is no dishonest intention seen to exist at the
inception. In paragraph No.20(xiv) and (xvi) Respondent No.2 itself
concedes the fact that there is absence of direct representation and
27 of 30

WP.4373.2026.doc

inducement while alleging that deception is of secured creditors and
CIRP process including the AFA. Thus it is seen that case of
Respondent No.2 seems to have improved at every successive stage
namely at the stage of EOW complaint dated 02.04.2026, the
preliminary inquiry for four months thereafter, the FIR / CR dated
11.08.2026 and the Affidavit-in-Reply.
25.
From the above discussion, it is unequivocally clear that
Respondent No.2 – Complainant withheld the pending NCLT
proceeding and the conditional nature of its own claim. Record shows
that there is no effective consideration of the AFA dated 14.05.2008,
pendency of Insolvency proceedings and two pending Suits in the Civil
Court in Mumbai and New Delhi and the preliminary enquiry being
nothing but an eyewash. In such a situation when Section 35(3)
inquiry was required to be made, Section 179 BNSS witness summons
is issued by the prosecution. It is an admitted position that there is no
allegation of promise, representation or correspondence between
Petitioner and Respondent No.2 – Complainant, there is no
individualised role attributed to Petitioner, Respondent No.2 –
Complainant with its eyes wide open entered into Deed of Assignment
with Unimers upon its own due diligence on “AS IS WHERE IS BAIS”
and “AS IS WHAT IS BASIS”. Thus there is complete absence of
inducement of any nature by Petitioners. Further the fact that AFA
was executed and registered in the year 2008, it is admittedly prior in
28 of 30

WP.4373.2026.doc

point of time, registration of which is a notice to the world at large and
Respondent No.2 – Complainant’s, Deed of Assignment is executed in
the year 2009 and registered in the year 2013. Respondent No.2 –
Complainant was not even on the horizon when the AFA was executed
and registered. Hence its charge rather alleged charge of cheating
against the Petitioners when it had entered into the picture later
cannot be countenanced or sustained. Simply put a party entering
subsequently cannot claim to have been induced into a transaction
which preceded its very entry. Most importantly the AFA dated
14.05.2008 was conditional, it never fructified, its conditions never
fulfilled after Stage 2 compliances, no Deed of Assignment is executed
in favour of Petitioners by Unimers, MIDC never granted its consent to
transfer the subject land in favour of Petitioners, Petitioner No.1
therefore stands to be a Creditor for Rs.29.62 Crores and not a title
holder and as such the dispute is fundamentally an inter-creditor /
civil-commercial dispute and by no stretch of imagination can qualify
as a criminal offence. Knowledge of the AFA is admittedly accepted by
Respondent No.2 during the past 18 years therefore filing of criminal
Complaint is followed immediately after the “Other Creditor”
classification by IRP on 25.11.2025. In such aforesaid strong
circumstances filing of the present Complaint / CR is nothing but a
sheer abuse of the criminal process by Respondent No.2 against the
Petitioners before the Court. In so far as Respondent No.2 –
29 of 30

WP.4373.2026.doc

Complainant's grievance against Unimers and Accused Nos.1 to 4 in
the present CR is concerned, the same is not before the Court.
26. On overall consideration of the aforesaid material which is
examined by the Court, the characterization of the AFA dated
14.05.2008 as an act of cheating being the only allegation levied
against the Petitioners, the Complaint against the Petitioners cannot be
allowed to be sustained through the present CR in question which is
founded upon an alleged breach of the order dated 29.03.2004 but
which stands squarely answered as alluded to hereinabove and
therefore the complaint is without any jurisdictional foundation and is
liable to be quashed and set aside as against the Petitioners in the
present Petition.
27. In view of the above observations and findings, the Petition
stands allowed in terms of pray clause (A) of the Petition which reads
thus:-
"A. issue a Writ of Certiorari or a writ, order or direction in the nature of
Certiorari, or any other appropriate writ, order or direction, under
Article 226 of the Constitution of India and u/s. Section 528 of the
BNSS and/or direction and/or order to quash and set aside EOW CR
No. 78 of 2026 dated 11.08.2026 registered by Economic Offence
Wing, Housing Unit, Unit-1 arising out of Oshiwara Police Station
bearing FIR No. 1180 of 2026, Mumbai u/s 318(4) r/w. 3(5) of the
Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 and all consequent proceedings
emanating therefrom, qua the Petitioners."
28.
Writ Petition is allowed and disposed. In view of disposal of
Writ Petition, pending Interim Application is also disposed.
[ MILIND N. JADHAV, J. ]
Ajay
Digitally signed
by HARSHADA
HANUMANT
SAWANT
Date:
2026.11.18
14:14:42 +0530
HARSHADA
HANUMANT
SAWANT
30 of 30