M P SINGH SENGAR vs GEOLOGICAL SURVEY OF INDIA

Court
Central Administrative Tribunal

1
Item 36 (C-V)
OA No.1665/2022



Central Administrative Tribunal
Principal Bench, New Delhi

O.A. No.1665/2022
M.A. No.1459/2026

Order reserved on : 13.08.2026
Order pronounced on: 26.10.2026


Hon’ble Dr. Chhabilendra Roul, Member (A)
Hon’ble Mr. Rajveer Singh Verma, Member (J)


M.P. Singh Sengar,
Son of Shri Indra Pal Singh Sengar
aged about 66 years,
R/o Plot No.17, Ramdwara Colony,
Mahavir Nagar, Tonk Road, Jaipur -302018.
He is a retired Central Government Employee (Organized
Group 'A' Services) from the post of Director (Chemistry)
MFSG,
Geological Survey of India.
...Applicant

(In person)

VERSUS


1. Union of India through the Secretary
to Government of India,
Ministry of Mines,
Sastri Bhawan, New Delhi-110001.


2. The Director General,
Geological Survey of India,
27, Jawaharlal Nehru Road,
Kolkata-700016.

3. Additional Director General,
Geological Survey of India,
Eastern Region, DK-6, Karunamai, Salt Lake,
th
4 Floor, Kolkata-700091.
Digitally signed by
RACHNA
KAPOOR
RACHNA
KAPOOR
…Respondents
(By Advocate : Shri Subhash Gosai)

2
Item 36 (C-V)
OA No.1665/2022


ORDER
By Hon’ble Mr. Rajveer Singh Verma, Member (J) :-

The applicant joined Geological Survey of India (GSI)
as Assistant Chemist (Group B Gazetted) at Mangalore, on
31.05.1983 and was later transferred from Mangalore to
Jaipur on 31.05.1986. After rendering about seven years of
service, following UPSC selection, the applicant joined as
Chemist (Junior), an Organised Group ‘A’ Junior Time
Scale post, on 09.05.1991. Between 06.02.1995 and
23.02.1998, he served on deputation as Senior Analyst in
the Ministry of Finance before being promoted to Chemist
(Senior) in Senior Time Scale on 24.02.1998. DOP&T then
issued an OM regarding formal promotions on 17.09.1998.
2. The applicant was transferred from Jaipur to
Chandigarh on 01.08.2008. On 31.12.2008, he received a
promotion order to the post of Director (Geochemistry) JAG
in PB-3 Grade Pay Rs. 7600 with a transfer to Patna, where
he joined on 12.01.2009 after availing joining time. The
DOP&T issued OM No. AB.14017/64/2008-Estt.(RR)
setting guidelines for Non-Functional Upgradation (NFU) to
Digitally signed by
RACHNA
KAPOOR
RACHNA
KAPOOR
Organised Group ‘A’ Services on 24.04.2009, followed by
OM No. AB.14017/61/2008-Estt.(RR)/Pt. on 15.12.2009

3
Item 36 (C-V)
OA No.1665/2022

revising eligibility requirements for promotion to SAG and
HAG. On 02.12.2010, the Ministry of Mines issued letter
No. 27/118/2008-M-II advising GSI to grant NFU as per
revised eligibility criteria pending service rule amendments.
The applicant was later appointed on the post of Director
(Chemistry) NFSG in PB-4 Grade Pay Rs. 8700.
3. The DOP&T issued OM No. AB.14017/47/2011-
Estt.(RR) on 01.08.2012, clarifying that officers not meeting
st
eligibility on 1 January are to be considered for NFU
st
w.e.f. 1 April of the next vacancy year. On 10.12.2012,
DOP&T issued OM No. AB.14017/30/2011-Estt.(RR) noting
that a 1993 batch IAS officer was posted to the Centre as
Joint Secretary on 19.11.2012, thereby covering 1991
batch Organised Group A officers for NFU. The crucial
eligibility date for calendar year vacancy 2013 was
01.01.2013. New Recruitment Rules for GSI Chemical
Service Group A were notified on 28.06.2013. Shortly after,
DOP&T issued an OM dated 24.07.2013 showing a 1994
batch IAS officer posted as Joint Secretary, covering 1992
and earlier batches for NFU.
4. The applicant superannuated from service as Director
Digitally signed by
RACHNA
KAPOOR
RACHNA
(Chemistry) NFSG on 31.07.2013. On 23.05.2014, GSI
KAPOOR
granted NFU in DDG grade w.e.f. 01.04.2011 to Dr. U. K.

4
Item 36 (C-V)
OA No.1665/2022

Mishra based on 2010 recruitment rules. The DOP&T
issued OM No. 22011/6/2013-Estt.(D) on 28.05.2014
clarifying the 3-month gap between the crucial eligibility
st
date (1 January) and the vacancy year commencement
st
date (1 April). On 14.09.2015, the respondents issued an
office order granting NFU w.e.f. 01.04.2014 to batchmates
of the applicant while excluding the applicant as he was
retired.
5. The applicant filed OA No. 291/00647/2015 before
the CAT Jaipur Bench, which was allowed to be withdrawn
on 28.07.2016 with liberty to file a fresh Application. He
then filed OA No. 291/00675/2016 on 24.08.2016. The
Ernakulam Bench of the Tribunal passed an order in a
related service matter on 26.10.2016, and DOPT issued OM
No. I-11019/5/2017-CRD on 03.04.2017 explicitly listing
GSI Chemical Service Group A as an Organised Group A
Service. On 11.12.2018, the CAT Jaipur Bench allowed the
withdrawal of OA No. 291/00675/2016 to pursue
administrative representation. The applicant submitted a
representations to the Director General, GSI, on
27.12.2018 and on 02.07.2019, and the Ministry of Mines
advised GSI via PG Portal to consider representations of
Digitally signed by
RACHNA
KAPOOR
RACHNA
KAPOOR
retired officers as per DOP&T guidelines.

5
Item 36 (C-V)
OA No.1665/2022

6. The Applicant filed OA No. 741/2019 before CAT
Jaipur Bench on 02.12.2019 (re-numbered as OA No.
1665/2022 upon transfer to Principal Bench, New Delhi)
seeking the following relief(s) :-
“i) That the respondents may kindly be directed to grant
the benefit of Non Functional Upgradation (NFU) to the
applicant in the pay scale PB-4 and grade pay of Rs.10000/-
w.e.f. 01.01.2013 as per DOPT office memorandum dated
10.12.2012 (Annex.-A/13) with retrospective effect and may
further be directed to pay all the consequential benefits and
interest till date.

OR

That the respondents may kindly be directed to grant the
benefit of Non Functional Upgradation (NFU) in the pay
scale PB-4 and grade pay of Rs.10000/- w.e.f. 28.06.2013
st
as per DOPT office memorandum dated 1 August, 2012
th
(Annex.- A/4)& Govt. of India notification dated 28 June,
2013 with retrospective effect and may further be directed
to pay all the consequential benefits and interest till date.

ii) That the respondents may kindly be directed to modify
the pension of the applicant accordingly from the date of
superannuation after granting him the benefits of Non
Functional Upgradation (NFU) from the effective date with
retrospective effect and to pay the arrears accruing therein
with all consequential benefits and interest till date.
iii) Any other relief which this Hon'ble tribunal deem fit in the
facts and circumstances of the case may be granted to the
applicant.”

7. In addition to the pleadings in the OA, the applicant
has filed additional affidavit/reply to addition affidavit and
Digitally signed by
RACHNA
KAPOOR
RACHNA
KAPOOR
written synopsis reiterating his claim in the OA. The
applicant who appears in person submitted that that the

6
Item 36 (C-V)
OA No.1665/2022

GSI Chemical Service has continuously been an Organised
Group A Service since the DOP&T notification dated
31.07.1982. The applicant completed the qualifying service
of 4 years on the post of Director (Geochemistry) JAG w.e.f.
30.12.2012 calculating from the promotion order date i.e.
31.12.2008, rendering him eligible for NFU w.e.f.
01.01.2013. Alternately, counting 4 years residency from
his joining date of 12.01.2009, the applicant completed 4
years of service on 11.01.2013 and became eligible for NFU
w.e.f. 01.04.2013 as per para 15 of DOP&T OM dated
01.08.2012 prior to his superannuation on 31.07.2013.
Furthermore, DOP&T OM dated 10.12.2012 covered 1991
batch Organised Group A officers for NFU upon the central
posting of a 1993 batch IAS officer on 19.11.2012, and the
Ministry of Mines instructed GSI on 02.12.2010 to grant
NFU benefits pending service rules amendment. The
applicant submitted that superannuation on 31.07.2013
cannot deprive him of NFU benefits accrued during active
service as per para 5 of DOP&T OM dated 25.09.2009,
making the denial of NFU to him while extending it to
batchmates vide order dated 14.09.2015 which is
discriminatory and arbitrary.
Digitally signed by
RACHNA
KAPOOR
RACHNA
KAPOOR
8. Pursuant to notice, the respondents filed their reply
opposing the OA. In addition to the counter affidavit, the

7
Item 36 (C-V)
OA No.1665/2022

respondents have also filed additional affidavit/reply to
additional affidavit filed by the applicant and written
synopsis maintaining their stand. Learned counsel for the
respondents submitted that the applicant was not eligible
for the grant of NFU to Senior Administrative Grade (SAG)
in Pay Band-4 Grade Pay Rs. 10000 on the crucial
eligibility date of 01.01.2013 because the requisite
residency period was not completed. NFU is governed
strictly by empanelment, residency criteria, and
promotional norms mandated under DOP&T OM dated
24.04.2009. It is submitted that as per the eligibility
criteria for promotion to the post of Deputy Director
General (Chemistry), the individual should be
superintending chemist with eight years of regular service
in the grade including NFSG i.e. Director (Chemistry) or
Officers with 17 years of regular service in Group ‘A’ posts
in the service out of which at least four years regular
service should be in the grade of Superintending Chemist
(including service rendered in the NFSG of the JAG i.e.
Director (Chemistry) and the said criterion are to be met as
on 01.01.2013, as per the DOP&T OM. The applicant has
completed 17 years of regular service in Group ‘A’ cadre as
Digitally signed by
RACHNA
KAPOOR
RACHNA
KAPOOR
on 08.05.2008, whereas he has not completed the
mandatory four years regular service in the JAG level as on

8
Item 36 (C-V)
OA No.1665/2022

01.01.2013 as his date for promotion to the post of Director
Geochemistry is 12.01.2009. He has completed the same
on 11.01.2013 and has not fulfilled the promotional norms
as on 01.01.2013 for the post of Deputy Director General
(Chemistry) and is not eligible for consideration for NFU for
the vacancy year 2013-14. The rules for formal promotion
requirements under DOPT OM dated 17.09.1998 and
promotional norms apply directly for the grant of NFU
benefits. Since the applicant superannuated on 31.07.2013
prior to fulfilling the required eligibility conditions under
the applicable service rules for financial year 2013-14, he
cannot be granted the benefit. This is reinforced by Dr. U.
K. Mishra speaking order dated 24.12.2024, which
confirms that an officer must fulfil all promotional eligibility
conditions and residency periods in the feeder grade as on
the crucial date without any relaxation.
9. In support of their contentions, the respondents have
relied upon the order of the Tribunal passed in OA
No.2159/2022 dated 30.05.2023, wherein it has been held
that no promotion can be granted with retrospective effect.
10. In rejoinder, the applicant submitted that the
Digitally signed by
RACHNA
KAPOOR
RACHNA
respondents incorrectly stated in Tribunal order dated
KAPOOR
08.01.2026 that the date of posting of the 1993 batch IAS

9
Item 36 (C-V)
OA No.1665/2022

officer was 19.11.2013 instead of the correct date of
19.11.2012. The respondents wrongly confused the criteria
for formal vacancy-based promotion under OM dated
17.09.1998 with the non-vacancy linked NFU scheme
introduced w.e.f. 01.01.2006. In terms of DOP&T OM dated
01.08.2012 and 28.05.2014, an officer completing
residency between 02.01.2012 and 31.03.2013 stands
eligible for NFU w.e.f. 01.04.2013. The applicant completed
over 22 years of Group A service and more than 4 years
and 7 months of continuous service in JAG/NFSG prior to
retirement on 31.07.2013. The speaking order dated
24.12.2024 in Dr. U. K. Mishra’s case is clearly
distinguishable because the applicant held the feeder post
in a regular capacity well within the eligibility period.
Additionally, the Ministry of Mines directive dated
02.07.2019 explicitly directed the consideration of retired
officers' claims as per DOP&T guidelines.
11. We have heard the learned counsel for the parties,
gone through the pleadings available on record as well as
perused the Written synopsis/Additional Affidavits and
replies thereto filed by the respective parties.
Digitally signed by
RACHNA
KAPOOR
RACHNA

KAPOOR

10
Item 36 (C-V)
OA No.1665/2022

Issues

12. Having regard to the pleadings and the submissions,
the following questions arise for determination:

(i) whether the applicant, a member of the GSI Chemical
Service Group 'A' of the 1991 batch, was eligible for Non-
Functional Upgradation (NFU) to the Senior Administrative
Grade (SAG) in PB-4 with Grade Pay Rs. 10000/- under
DoP&T OM dated 24.04.2009 before his superannuation on
31.07.2013, and if so, from which date;
(ii) whether the four years' regular service in the Junior
Administrative Grade (JAG) is to be counted from the date
of the promotion order (31.12.2008) or from the date on
which the applicant assumed charge of the promotional
post (12.01.2009);
(iii) whether an officer who completes the residency period
st
after the crucial date of 1 January can be made to wait
st
until 1 April of the next vacancy year, and whether his
superannuation in the interregnum defeats his claim; and
(iv) the relief, if any, to which the applicant is entitled.

Undisputed position
Digitally signed by
RACHNA
KAPOOR
RACHNA
KAPOOR

13. Several facts are not in dispute. The applicant entered
the Organised Group 'A' service as Chemist (Junior) on

11
Item 36 (C-V)
OA No.1665/2022

09.05.1991 and belongs to the 1991 batch. He was
promoted to the JAG as Director by order dated
31.12.2008, which also transferred him from Chandigarh to
Patna, and he joined at Patna on 12.01.2009 after availing
joining time. He held the JAG, and later its Non-Functional
Selection Grade as Director (Chemistry) in PB-4 with Grade
Pay Rs. 8700/-, until he superannuated on 31.07.2013. He
had completed 17 years of regular service in Group 'A'
posts on 08.05.2008. The respondents themselves state, in
their reply, that he completed four years of regular service
in the JAG on 11.01.2013.

14. It is also not disputed that the GSI Chemical Service
Group 'A' is an Organised Group 'A' Service to which the
NFU scheme applies. The DoP&T OM dated 03.04.2017
lists it as such, and the respondents have not contended
otherwise. The question of the organised status of the
technical streams of the Geological Survey of India has in
any event been settled by the Hon'ble Delhi High Court in
Union of India v. Kanhaiya Singh , W.P.(C) 16769/2004
with W.P.(C) 1541/2012, decided on 28.01.2026, where it
was held:
"As noted hereinabove, since 1982, it had been recognised that
GSI is an Organized Group 'A' Service." (para 45)

Digitally signed by
RACHNA
KAPOOR
RACHNA
KAPOOR

12
Item 36 (C-V)
OA No.1665/2022

15. As to the date on which the 1991 batch became due
for consideration, DoP&T OM dated 10.12.2012 [Annexure
A/13] records that the first officer of the 1993 batch of the
IAS was posted at the Centre as Joint Secretary on
19.11.2012, so that officers of the 1991 batch and earlier of
the Organised Group 'A' Services became due for
consideration for NFU to the SAG with effect from that date.
The reference to 19.11.2013 in the submissions noted in
the order dated 08.01.2026 is an evident error and is
corrected accordingly. On 19.11.2012, however, the
applicant had not completed four years in the JAG on any
computation, and he could not have been granted NFU on
that date.

The scheme of NFU

th
16. NFU was introduced on the recommendation of the 6
CPC to secure batch-wise parity between the IAS and the
Organised Group 'A' Services. Under para 1(i) of DoP&T
OM No. AB.14017/64/2008-Estt.(RR) dated 24.04.2009,
whenever an IAS officer is posted at the Centre in a
particular grade, officers of the Organised Group 'A'
Services belonging to batches senior by two years or more
Digitally signed by
RACHNA
KAPOOR
RACHNA
KAPOOR
who have not been promoted to that grade are to be granted
that grade on a non-functional basis from the date of

13
Item 36 (C-V)
OA No.1665/2022

posting of the IAS officer. The grant is governed by the
terms and conditions in Annexure-I to the OM. Two of them
are material as reproduced by the Hon'ble Delhi High Court
in Shri Kant & Ors. v. Union of India & Ors ., W.P.(C)
13600/2019 and connected matters, decided on
01.07.2026, they read:
"All the prescribed eligibility criteria and promotional norms
including 'benchmark' for upgradation to a particular grade pay
would have to be met at the time of screening for grant of higher
pay scale under these orders." (Annexure-I, para 3)

"Grant of higher pay scale on the non-functional basis would be
from the date of posting of the 1st officer belonging to the
particular batch of IAS officer at the Centre. In case of any
delay in the issue of order, financial benefits under these orders
will be given from the due date." (Annexure-I, para 6)

17. Two features of the scheme follow from these
provisions. First, the officer must satisfy the eligibility
conditions prescribed for promotion to the grade, including
the residency period in the feeder grade; batch parity alone
does not suffice. Secondly, NFU is not a promotion. It is a
financial upgradation that carries no change of post, and
the scheme itself contemplates that it will operate from a
past date, namely the due date, with financial benefits
flowing from that date even where the order is issued later.

The eligibility condition
Digitally signed by
RACHNA
KAPOOR
RACHNA

18. The eligibility for promotion to the SAG prescribed by
KAPOOR
DoP&T OM dated 15.12.2009 is that the officer should be

14
Item 36 (C-V)
OA No.1665/2022

in the JAG with eight years' regular service in the grade
including the NFSG, or should have 17 years' regular
service in Group 'A' posts in the service out of which at
least four years' regular service is in the JAG including
service in the NFSG. The Ministry of Mines, by letter No.
27/118/2008-M-II dated 02.12.2010, advised the GSI to
grant NFU in accordance with these revised criteria pending
amendment of the service rules, and the Recruitment Rules
for the GSI Chemical Service Group 'A' notified on
28.06.2013, while the applicant was still in service, are
stated by the respondents to embody the same condition.
The respondents apply this very test in their reply. There is
therefore no dispute as to the yardstick. In Shri Kant
(supra) the Hon'ble High Court held that entitlement must
be judged by the rules in force when the officer
superannuated:
"In the absence of any such amendment, the entitlement of
Petitioners 1 and 2 to NFFU in terms of the DOPT OM dated 24
April 2009 has to be decided on the basis of the RRs as they
existed on the date when the said petitioners superannuated."
(para 57)

19. Judged by the condition in force on 31.07.2013, the
applicant satisfied the requirement of 17 years in Group 'A'
on 08.05.2008. The only question is when he completed
Digitally signed by
RACHNA
KAPOOR
RACHNA
KAPOOR
four years of regular service in the JAG.


15
Item 36 (C-V)
OA No.1665/2022

Counting of JAG service: 31.12.2008 or 12.01.2009

20. The applicant contends that the four years should be
reckoned from the date of the promotion order, 31.12.2008,
so that they were complete on 30.12.2012 and he was
eligible on the crucial date of 01.01.2013. We are unable to
accept this. Regular service in a grade commences when
the officer assumes the duties of the post. The order dated
31.12.2008 promoted the applicant and transferred him to
Patna, and he assumed charge there only on 12.01.2009.
The period of joining time before that date was not service
rendered in the JAG. The Hon'ble Supreme Court in
Government of West Bengal & Ors. v. Dr. Amal
Satpathi & Ors ., 2024 INSC 906, held, as quoted by the
Hon'ble Delhi High Court in Union of India & Ors. v.
Ramesh Chandra Shukla , W.P.(C) 16274/2024, decided
on 24.09.2025 (para 29):
"The legal precedents discussed above establish that
promotion only becomes effective upon the assumption of
duties on the promotional post and not on the date of
occurrence of the vacancy or the date of recommendation."

21. To count service from 31.12.2008 would be to
antedate the applicant's JAG promotion by twelve days,
which is impermissible. The applicant completed four years
Digitally signed by
RACHNA
KAPOOR
RACHNA
KAPOOR
of regular service in the JAG on 11.01.2013, as the
respondents themselves state, and became eligible on

16
Item 36 (C-V)
OA No.1665/2022

12.01.2013. The first limb of relief (i), seeking NFU with
effect from 01.01.2013, therefore fails.
The crucial date and the deferral to 1st April

22. The respondents' case is that eligibility for NFU is to
st
be tested on the crucial date of 1 January preceding the
vacancy year, by applying the instructions on the crucial
date for promotion contained in DoP&T OM dated
17.09.1998. Since the applicant was short of four years in
the JAG by eleven days on 01.01.2013, he was not eligible
for the vacancy year 2013-14; he could only be considered
for the vacancy year 2014-15 commencing on 01.04.2014,
by which date he had retired. This is also the basis on
which his batchmates were granted NFU with effect from
01.04.2014 by the office order dated 14.09.2015. The
respondents also rely on the clarification issued by DoP&T
on 01.08.2012, which, in substance, provides that an
officer who does not meet the eligibility requirement as on
st
1 January of the corresponding vacancy year is to be
considered in the subsequent vacancy year on completion
st
of the qualifying service, with effect from 1 April, that is,
the first day of the next vacancy year.

23. The applicant reads the same clarification differently.
Digitally signed by
RACHNA
KAPOOR
RACHNA
KAPOOR
According to him, the vacancy year corresponding to the

17
Item 36 (C-V)
OA No.1665/2022

coverage of his batch on 19.11.2012 was 2012-13; he
completed the qualifying service within that year, on
11.01.2013, and the clarification therefore entitles him to
NFU from the first day of the next vacancy year,
01.04.2013, which falls within his service.

24. It is not necessary for us to choose between these two
readings of the clarification, for the question is now
governed by the decision of the jurisdictional High Court in
Shri Kant (supra). In that case the respondents had
st
granted NFU to officers of the CRPF only from 1 April of
the year following the year in which they completed the
residency period in the feeder grade. The Hon'ble Delhi
High Court held:
"That said, however, we see no justification for the respondents
granting NFFU to Petitioner 1 and Petitioner 2 only from the first
day of April of the year following the year in which they
satisfied the requirement of two years' residency in the SAG.
There is nothing in the DOPT OM dated 24 April 2009 which
justifies postponement of the date from which NFFU would be
granted to the first day of April of the year following the year in
which the officer was entitled thereto." (para 60)

"Clause 3 of Annexure-I of the OM required the officers to fulfill
the prescribed eligibility criteria and promotional norms for
promotion to the grade in which NFFU was sought. That
requirement was satisfied in the case of Petitioner 1 on 10 July
2010 and in the case of Petitioner 2 on 8 July 2008. The said
petitioners, therefore, became ipso facto entitled to NFFU in the
HAG scale from those dates." (para 61)


25. The Hon'ble High Court accordingly advanced the
Digitally signed by
RACHNA
KAPOOR
RACHNA
KAPOOR
st
dates of NFU of those officers from 1 April of the following
year to the very dates on which they completed the

18
Item 36 (C-V)
OA No.1665/2022

residency period. The ratio is that, once the batch of an
officer has been covered by the posting of the corresponding
IAS batch at the Centre, the officer becomes entitled to NFU
on the date on which he satisfies the eligibility condition of
Annexure-I, para 3, and the parent OM dated 24.04.2009
does not permit that date to be postponed to the
commencement of the next vacancy year. That decision
binds this Tribunal.

26. We have considered whether the instructions relied
upon by the respondents take the case out of the ratio in
Shri Kant . In our view they do not. The OM dated
17.09.1998 regulates the crucial date for determining
eligibility for promotion against vacancies of a vacancy year,
to be filled through a Departmental Promotion Committee.
NFU is not vacancy based. It is triggered by an external
event, namely the posting of an IAS batch at the Centre,
and the date from which it operates is fixed by para 1(i) and
Annexure-I, para 6 of the OM dated 24.04.2009. The
clarification dated 01.08.2012, which is an executive
clarification of that OM, cannot be read so as to postpone
an entitlement that the parent OM confers from the date of
Digitally signed by
RACHNA
KAPOOR
RACHNA
KAPOOR
eligibility. Indeed, DoP&T itself, in OM No. 22011/6/2013-
Estt(D) dated 28.05.2014, acknowledged the anomaly

19
Item 36 (C-V)
OA No.1665/2022

st
produced by the three month gap between a 1 January
st
crucial date and a vacancy year commencing on 1 April:
"Due to this gap, for any such vacancy year, even if the
Departmental Promotion Committee (DPC) meeting is held in
time as per the Model Calendar, there is always a possibility
of few officers not fulfilling the eligibility criteria as on the
crucial date of eligibility, though they are fulfilling the same as
on the date of commencement of the vacancy year." (para 2)


27. We are conscious that the OM dated 28.05.2014
operates only from the vacancy year 2015-16 onwards
(para 3 thereof), and we do not rest the applicant's
entitlement on it. We refer to it only because it shows that
the result for which the respondents contend, under which
an officer who completes the residency period on
11.01.2013 and is in service when the vacancy year begins
on 01.04.2013 is nonetheless shut out altogether, is one
that the nodal Department itself regarded as anomalous.

28. Applying Shri Kant , the applicant, whose batch stood
covered from 19.11.2012, became entitled to NFU to the
SAG on 12.01.2013, the date on which he completed four
years of regular service in the JAG. That date fell more than
six months before his superannuation on 31.07.2013.

Effect of superannuation
Digitally signed by
RACHNA
KAPOOR

29. The respondents' further objection is that the
RACHNA
KAPOOR
applicant had retired before the office order dated

20
Item 36 (C-V)
OA No.1665/2022

14.09.2015 was issued. That is no answer to a claim whose
due date falls during service. Annexure-I, para 6 of the OM
dated 24.04.2009 expressly provides that where there is
delay in issuing orders, financial benefits are to be given
from the due date. The DoP&T clarifications of 01.08.2012
relied on by the respondents themselves also state, in
substance, that retired officers who were otherwise eligible
on the due date are to be considered for the upgradation. In
Kanhaiya Singh (supra), an officer of the Geological
Survey of India who had superannuated on 31.08.2007 was
held entitled to NFU, and the Hon'ble High Court directed:
"The petitioner no. 1 is held entitled to grant of the NFU in
terms of the O.M. dated 24.04.2009 read with the O.M. dated
25.09.2007 of the DoP&T. The consequential benefits of the
same shall be released by the respondents to the petitioner
within a period of eight weeks from today, along with interest
at the rate of 6% per annum." (para 49)

30. In Shri Kant (supra) itself, the officers who were
denied NFU on account of retirement were those who had
superannuated before completing the residency period in
the feeder grade (paras 80 and 81). The applicant is not in
that position. He completed the residency period on
11.01.2013 and remained in service till 31.07.2013.

The decisions relied upon by the respondents
Digitally signed by
RACHNA
KAPOOR

31. The respondents rely on the order of this Tribunal in
RACHNA
KAPOOR
OA No. 2159/2022 dated 30.05.2023 for the proposition

21
Item 36 (C-V)
OA No.1665/2022

that promotion cannot be granted with retrospective effect.
The proposition is well settled and has been reiterated by
the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Amal Satpathi (supra) and
applied by the Hon'ble Delhi High Court in Ramesh
Chandra Shukla (supra), where it was held:
"Merely because vacancies exist, or that the name of the officer
has been recommended by the DPC for promotion, the same
will not create a right in such officer to claim promotion till it is
actually granted." (para 29)

32. We have applied that principle in rejecting the
applicant's plea that his JAG service should be counted
from 31.12.2008. It does not, however, assist the
respondents on the main question. In Ramesh Chandra
Shukla , an officer of the GSI sought retrospective regular
promotion to the post of Deputy Director General in order
to create the residency period he needed for NFU to the
next grade, and the Hon’ble High Court declined because
promotion takes effect only from the date it is granted. The
applicant before us seeks no antedating of any promotion.
He relies only on service actually rendered in the JAG from
12.01.2009 to 31.07.2013, and he claims NFU from a date
that the scheme itself fixes. NFU, as noted above, is not a
promotion, and its retrospective operation from the due
Digitally signed by
RACHNA
KAPOOR
RACHNA
date is a feature of the scheme, not a departure from it.
KAPOOR

22
Item 36 (C-V)
OA No.1665/2022

33. The speaking order dated 24.12.2024 in the case of
Dr. U.K. Mishra is relied upon for the proposition that all
promotional eligibility conditions must be met in the feeder
grade as on the crucial date, without relaxation. We have
held that the eligibility conditions must be met, and the
applicant is being granted NFU only from the date on which
he met them. To the extent that the speaking order treats
st
the crucial date of 1 January and the commencement of
the next vacancy year as postponing an entitlement already
accrued under the OM dated 24.04.2009, it cannot prevail
over the law declared in Shri Kant (supra), which it does
not consider.

Plea of discrimination

34. The applicant has also contended that his exclusion
from the office order dated 14.09.2015, while his
batchmates were granted NFU, is discriminatory. On the
respondents' own approach, the batchmates were granted
NFU from 01.04.2014, a date on which the applicant was
no longer in service, so his exclusion from that order did
not by itself amount to differential treatment of persons
similarly situated. The applicant's grievance is better
Digitally signed by
RACHNA
KAPOOR
RACHNA
KAPOOR
founded on the correct date of his own entitlement, which
we have determined above. In view of that conclusion, it is

23
Item 36 (C-V)
OA No.1665/2022

unnecessary to decide the plea under Article 14
independently.

Moulding of relief

35. The applicant has prayed for NFU with effect from
01.01.2013 or, in the alternative, with effect from
28.06.2013. In his written submissions he has also pressed
for 01.04.2013. The date to which he is found entitled,
12.01.2013, lies between these dates and flows from the
same cause of action and the same instruments on which
the OA is founded. The respondents have had full notice of
the claim and have met it on merits. We, therefore, mould
the relief under prayer (iii), which seeks any other relief
that the Tribunal deems fit in the facts and circumstances
of the case.

Delay and arrears

36. Although the respondents have opposed the claim on
merits, we have also considered the question of delay. The
cause of action arose with the office order dated
14.09.2015. The applicant approached the Jaipur Bench of
this Tribunal in 2015 itself. That OA was withdrawn on
Digitally signed by
RACHNA
KAPOOR
RACHNA
KAPOOR
28.07.2016 with liberty to file a fresh Application, which he
filed on 24.08.2016. That OA was withdrawn on

24
Item 36 (C-V)
OA No.1665/2022

11.12.2018 to enable him to pursue his representation,
which he submitted on 27.12.2018 and followed up on
02.07.2019, and the Ministry of Mines advised the GSI to
consider representations of retired officers in accordance
with DoP&T guidelines. The present OA was filed on
02.12.2019. The applicant has thus pursued his claim
continuously since the cause of action arose. Further, the
claim concerns pay fixation and the consequential revision
of pension, which give rise to a recurring cause of action.
The principle in Union of India v. Tarsem Singh, (2008) 8
SCC 648, under which arrears in belated claims are
ordinarily restricted to three years before the filing of the
proceedings, is intended to deal with claimants who sit over
their rights. It has no application to an applicant who has
been before this Tribunal or the authorities without break.
We therefore see no reason to restrict the arrears.

Conclusion and directions

37. In view of the foregoing discussion, the OA is partly
allowed in the following terms:

(a) The office order dated 14.09.2015 is set aside insofar as
it excludes the applicant from the grant of NFU to the SAG.
Digitally signed by
RACHNA
KAPOOR
RACHNA
KAPOOR
(b) The prayer for grant of NFU with effect from 01.01.2013
is rejected.

25
Item 36 (C-V)
OA No.1665/2022

(c) The respondents shall grant the applicant NFU to the
Senior Administrative Grade in PB-4 with Grade Pay Rs.
10000 with effect from 12.01.2013, in terms of DoP&T OM
dated 24.04.2009, subject only to his fulfilling the other
conditions in Annexure-I thereto, including the benchmark,
as on that date. For this purpose the respondents shall
hold a review screening for the applicant within the time
stipulated below.
(d) Upon such grant, the respondents shall fix the
applicant's pay notionally in the upgraded scale with effect
from 12.01.2013 in accordance with the CCS (Revised Pay)
Rules, 2008, and shall pay him the arrears of pay and
allowances for the period from 12.01.2013 to 31.07.2013.
(e) The respondents shall thereafter revise the applicant's
pension, gratuity, leave encashment, commuted value of
pension and all other retiral benefits on the basis of the pay
so fixed, with effect from 01.08.2013, issue a revised
Pension Payment Order, and pay the resulting arrears.
(f) The above exercise shall be completed within three
months from the date of receipt of a certified copy of this
order. If the arrears under directions (d) and (e) are not paid
within that period, they shall carry simple interest at the
Digitally signed by
RACHNA
KAPOOR
RACHNA
KAPOOR
rate of 6% per annum from the date of expiry of the three
months until the date of actual payment.

26
Item 36 (C-V)
OA No.1665/2022

(g) The respondents shall pass a reasoned order in
compliance with these directions and communicate it to the
applicant.

38. All pending MAs, if any, shall stand disposed of. There
shall be no order as to costs.


(Rajveer Singh Verma) (Dr.Chhabilendra Roul)
Member (J) Member (A)

‘rk’

Digitally signed by
RACHNA
KAPOOR
RACHNA
KAPOOR