Smt. Parvati Bai Ghavre vs The State Of Madhya Pradesh
- Court
- Madhya Pradesh High Court
1 WP-29869-2018
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH
AT JABALPUR
BEFORE
HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE ANAND SINGH BAHRAWAT
th
ON THE 18 OF NOVEMBER, 2026
WRIT PETITION No. 9815 of 2018
CNR No.: MPHC010214352018
CHANDAR SINGH AND ANR
Versus
THE STATE OF MADHYA PRADESH AND OTHERS
Appearance:
Shri Bhaskar Upadhyay - Advocate for the petitioner.
Shri Adwitya Parashar - Panel Lawyer for the respondents/State.
WITH
WRIT PETITION No. 9108 of 2018
CNR No.: MPHC010198122018
GHANSHYAM SINGH
Versus
THE STATE OF MADHYA PRADESH AND OTHERS
Appearance:
Shri Bhaskar Upadhyay - Advocate for the petitioner.
Shri Adwitya Parashar - Panel Lawyer for the respondents/State.
WRIT PETITION No. 9601 of 2018
CNR No.: MPHC010209702018
PRATAP SINGH KEER
Versus
THE STATE OF MADHYA PRADESH AND OTHERS
Appearance:
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: DINESH VERMA
Signing time: 19-11-2026
18:19:09
2 WP-29869-2018
Shri Bhaskar Upadhyay - Advocate for the petitioner.
Shri Adwitya Parashar - Panel Lawyer for the respondents/State.
WRIT PETITION No. 9796 of 2018
CNR No.: MPHC010214292018
MAHESH PRASAD KHARE
Versus
THE STATE OF MADHYA PRADESH AND OTHERS
Appearance:
Shri Bhaskar Upadhyay - Advocate for the petitioner.
Shri Adwitya Parashar - Panel Lawyer for the respondents/State.
WRIT PETITION No. 9862 of 2018
CNR No.: MPHC010214632018
SURENDRA SINGH THAKUR AND OTHERS
Versus
THE STATE OF MADHYA PRADESH AND OTHERS
Appearance:
Shri Bhaskar Upadhyay - Advocate for the petitioner.
Shri Adwitya Parashar - Panel Lawyer for the respondents/State.
WRIT PETITION No. 9902 of 2018
CNR No.: MPHC010216322018
KISHORE SINGH BIJAWAT AND OTHERS
Versus
THE STATE OF MADHYA PRADESH AND OTHERS
Appearance:
Shri Bhaskar Upadhyay - Advocate for the petitioner.
Shri Adwitya Parashar - Panel Lawyer for the respondents/State.
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: DINESH VERMA
Signing time: 19-11-2026
18:19:09
3 WP-29869-2018
WRIT PETITION No. 10134 of 2018
CNR No.: MPHC010220882018
ASHOK MAHESHWARI AND ANR
Versus
THE STATE OF MADHYA PRADESH AND OTHERS
Appearance:
Shri Bhaskar Upadhyay - Advocate for the petitioner.
Shri Adwitya Parashar - Panel Lawyer for the respondents/State.
WRIT PETITION No. 10240 of 2018
CNR No.: MPHC010223752018
DEEP SINGH MUKATI
Versus
THE STATE OF MADHYA PRADESH AND OTHERS
Appearance:
Shri Bhaskar Upadhyay - Advocate for the petitioner.
Shri Adwitya Parashar - Panel Lawyer for the respondents/State.
WRIT PETITION No. 10485 of 2018
CNR No.: MPHC010229422018
RAFATULLA KHAN
Versus
THE STATE OF MADHYA PRADESH AND OTHERS
Appearance:
Shri Bhaskar Upadhyay - Advocate for the petitioner.
Shri Adwitya Parashar - Panel Lawyer for the respondents/State.
WRIT PETITION No. 10739 of 2018
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: DINESH VERMA
Signing time: 19-11-2026
18:19:09
4 WP-29869-2018
CNR No.: MPHC010235562018
BHAJAN LAL VAIDH AND OTHERS
Versus
THE STATE OF MADHYA PRADESH AND OTHERS
Appearance:
Shri Bhaskar Upadhyay - Advocate for the petitioner.
Shri Adwitya Parashar - Panel Lawyer for the respondents/State.
WRIT PETITION No. 11226 of 2018
CNR No.: MPHC010243422018
KAMAL SINGH SARASVAL AND OTHERS
Versus
THE STATE OF MADHYA PRADESH AND OTHERS
Appearance:
Shri Sarvesh Kumar Jaiswal - Advocate for the petitioner.
Shri Rahul Rajpoot - Advocate for the respondent.
WRIT PETITION No. 29869 of 2018
CNR No.: MPHC010654762018
SMT. PARVATI BAI GHAVRE
Versus
THE STATE OF MADHYA PRADESH AND OTHERS
Appearance:
Shri Bhaskar Upadhyay - Advocate for the petitioner.
Shri Adwitya Parashar - Panel Lawyer for the respondents/State.
ORDER
Since the controversy involved in all the writ petitions is one and the
same, therefore, they have been heard together and are being decided by this
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: DINESH VERMA
Signing time: 19-11-2026
18:19:09
5 WP-29869-2018
common order.
2. For the sake of convenience, facts are being taken from W.P.
No.9815 of 2018. This petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India
has been filed seeking following reliefs:
i) By issuance of writ in the nature of 'certiorari' order dated
09/04/2018 (Annexure/P-60 cancelling the promotion of the
petitioner, may be quashed.
ii) by the issuance of appropriate writ, the respondents may be
directed to approve the order dated 16/01/2008 (Annexure/P-1),
and order dated 10/06/2008 (Annexure/P-2) further to restore the
promotions of the petitioners on the post of Multipurpose Health
Worker and Dai and consequential benefits thereof.
iii) Grant any other relief as deemed fit and proper in the
circumstances of this case, along with the cost of this writ petition
be also awarded."
3. Learned counsel for the petitioners submitted that initially the
petitioners were appointed on the post of Sweeper. The case of the
petitioners was considered by the DPC met on 10.01.2008, 16.05.2008
and 26.07.2002 and the petitioners were promoted from the post of Sweeper
to the post of Multipurpose Health Worker and Dai vide order dated
16.01.2008 and 10.06.2008 in the pay-scale of Rs.3050-75-80-4590.
Consequently, the petitioners joined on the promotional posts. The
petitioners were sent on training and they successfully completed the same.
Learned counsel for the petitioners further submitted that thereafter without
giving any opportunity of hearing and without issuing any show cause
notice to the petitioners meaning thereby without complying the principle of
natural justice, the aforesaid promotional orders have been cancelled by the
impugned order dated 09.04.2018 (Annexure P/6). Learned counsel for the
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: DINESH VERMA
Signing time: 19-11-2026
18:19:09
6 WP-29869-2018
petitioners submitted that the petitioners have been promoted in the year
2008 and the promotion orders have been cancelled after 10 years, the
opportunity of hearing is necessary but the respondents have not granted any
opportunity of hearing to the petitioners. As the impugned orders are having
the civil consequences, the opportunity of hearing is necessary. Learned
counsel for the petitioners has placed reliance upon the judgment of Apex
Court in the case of Shekhar Ghosh v. Union of India & Anr. (2007) 1 SCC
331, Ram Ujarey v. Union of India (1999) 1 SCC 685, Prakash Ratan Sinha
v. State of Bihar and Others,[Civil Appeal Nos. 4348–4349 of 2009] and the
judgments of this Court in Smt. Laxmi Gaud v. State of Madhya Pradesh and
Others [W.P. No. 3141 of 2015], Pradeep Sharma v. State of Madhya
Pradesh & Ors. [W.P. No. 4986 of 2016], Raju Batham & Ors. v. State of
Madhya Pradesh & Ors.[W.P. No. 693 of 2012], Vinay Kumar Savita & Ors
v. State of Madhya Pradesh & Ors [W.P. Nos. 2465 of 2016], Prakash
Kumar Dehariya & Ors v. State of Madhya Pradesh & Ors [W.P. Nos.
4836/2005]. He has further placed reliance upon a judgment delivered by
this Court in the case of Pratab Babu Sen vs. The State of M.P., and others,
W.P.No.4111 of 2006(S) decided on 02nd March, 2009 , wherein
promotions on the basis of the similar DPC were cancelled by the competent
authority.
4. Learned counsel for the petitioners further submitted that the
aforesaid promotion cancellation orders have been passed by the
respondents under the pressure of the Lokayukta and the Lokayukta is not
the competent authority and the impugned orders cannot be passed under the
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: DINESH VERMA
Signing time: 19-11-2026
18:19:09
7 WP-29869-2018
pressure of the Lokayukta. It is further submitted that the once the
petitioners have been promoted in 2008, the promotion orders can only be
cancelled after conducting the regular departmental enquiry for which
opportunity of hearing is necessary to the petitioners. It is submitted that the
aforesaid procedure has not been followed by the respondents before issuing
the impugned order dated 09.04.2018.
5. Per contra, learned counsel appearing for the respondents/State
submitted that the Joint Director, Health and Family Welfare wrote a letter to
the CM & HO, Sehore regarding regularization/promotion of employees in
the department by holding a DPC. On 10.01.2008 a DPC was constituted on
the basis of which the petitioners and other employees were
regularized/promoted by the DPC dated 16.01.2008. Thereafter, the
Department received a complaint in which it was alleged that illegalities had
been deliberately made in the DPC dated 10.01.2008. On the basis of
aforesaid complaint, the Collector held an enquiry. In the said enquiry, all
the erring officers who were allegedly involved in holding the illegal DPC
were put to notice and respective replies were sought from them and two
annual increments of the erring officers with cumulative effect have been
stopped vide order dated 04.01.2017. Learned counsel for the respondents
further submitted that the promotion of the petitioners were found to have
been granted on the basis of undue favour by the DPC and thus the
promotion/regularization of the petitioner were void ab initio. On the basis
of aforesaid enquiry and the conclusion reached therein,. the impugned
orders have been issued by which the status of the petitioners have been
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: DINESH VERMA
Signing time: 19-11-2026
18:19:09
8 WP-29869-2018
reverted as the entire excise of the DPC was found to have been illegal.
Learned counsel for the respondents further place reliance on the judgment
of Apex Court in the case of Union of India v. Raghuwar Pal Singh, AIR
2018 SC 1411 and submitted that as per the aforesaid judgment there was no
necessity to afford an opportunity to the petitioners before issuing the
impugned reversion order/promotion cancellation order. The learned counsel
for the respondents has further placed reliance upon the decision of Apex
Court in the case of Munna Lal Yadav vs Dr. Hari Singh Gour (M.P. No.
3615 of 1993 decided on 20.01.2006) and submitted that merely if show
cause notice is not issued, an order cannot be automatically quashed only on
the mere technicality that an opportunity was not granted.
6. Heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the record.
7. A perusal of the record reveals that i nitially, the petitioners were
appointed to the post of Sweeper. Their cases were considered by the
Departmental Promotion Committee (DPC) in its meetings held on
10.01.2008, 16.05.2008 and 26.07.2002, pursuant to which they were
promoted from the post of Sweeper to the posts of Multipurpose Health
Worker and Dai vide orders dated 16.01.2008 and 10.06.2008, respectively,
in the pay scale of Rs.3050-75-80-4590. Accordingly, the petitioners joined
their respective promotional posts and were also deputed for training, which
they successfully completed. Thereafter, vide impugned order dated
09.04.2018 (Annexure P/6), the respondents cancelled the aforesaid
promotion orders after a lapse of nearly ten years. Before passing the
impugned order, no show-cause notice was issued to the petitioners, nor
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: DINESH VERMA
Signing time: 19-11-2026
18:19:09
9 WP-29869-2018
were they afforded any opportunity of hearing. The impugned order was
passed pursuant to the intervention of the Lokayukta. The petitioners'
promotions were cancelled without conducting any regular departmental
enquiry.
8. The decision complained against in the instant case is an
administrative decision. The decision is likely to have far reaching civil
consequences for the petitioners, as it has adversely affected his right to
continue in the promotional post. Therefore, in our view, the decision
concerning the promotion makes itself available for scrutiny by the Courts on
the touchstone of well-established principles of natural justice.
9. The decision that was questioned before the Court was an
administrative decision having civil consequences and is alleged to have
been taken without affording an opportunity of hearing to the petitioners.
The argument of the learned Counsel for the petitioners, basically is that, the
administrative decision taken by the respondents is unfair, unreasonable and
in breach of principles of natural justice. The administrative decision taken
by the respondents is within the realm of public law and therefore, the
decision ought to have been taken in a fair and reasonable manner. This was
more necessary because the action cancelling the promotion of the appellant
had civil consequences in the sense that it not only puts an end to the right of
the appellant and also his further career prospectus. Therefore, the
respondents are under an obligation to take all decisions in a fair and lawful
manner by adhering to the rules of natural justice. The law in this regard has
been settled by several decisions of this Court. The principle that emerge
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: DINESH VERMA
Signing time: 19-11-2026
18:19:09
10 WP-29869-2018
from the decisions of this Court is that, if there is a power to decide and
decide detrimentally to the prejudice of a person, duty to act judicially is
implicit in exercise of such a power and that the rule of natural justice
operates in areas not covered by any law validly made. Corollary principles
emanating from these cases are as to what particular rule of natural justice
should apply to a given case must depend to an extent on the facts and
circumstances of that case and that it is only where there is nothing in the
statute to actually prohibit, the giving of an opportunity of being heard and
on the other hand, the nature of the statutory duty imposed on the decision
maker itself implies an obligation to hear before deciding. These cases have
also observed, whenever an action of public body results in civil
consequences for the person against whom the action is directed, the duty to
act fairly can be presumed and in such a case, the administrative authority
must give a proper opportunity of hearing to the affected person. The Apex
Court in Canara Bank and Others Vs. Debasis Das and Others reported in
(2003) 4 SCC 557 has stated that "the adherence to principles of natural
justice as recognized by all civilized states is of supreme importance or when
a quasi judicial body embarks on determining dispute between the parties, or
any administrative action involving civil consequences is an issue. Even an
administrative order, which involves civil consequence must be consisted
with the rules of natural justice.
10. Once the petitioners had been promoted to the promotional post,
they could not have been reverted to a lower post without issuance of a
proper show-cause notice and without affording an opportunity of hearing.
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: DINESH VERMA
Signing time: 19-11-2026
18:19:09
11 WP-29869-2018
Since the impugned order has civil consequences, an opportunity of hearing
was necessary. The relevant portion of order dated (pls check) 2.3.2009
passed in the case of Pratab Babu Sen (supra) is quoted below for ready
reference and convinience:
"In the present case it is not in dispute that the petitioner was
promoted in the year 2004 and the impugned order was passed on
19-06-06 revered the petitioner from the post of Assistant Grade-
III. On 08-08-2006, this Court has granted an interim order in the
matter. The enquiry report which is enclosed along with return as
Annexure R/6 at page 17 clearly reflects that no irregularities of
any kind was noticed in the case of promotion of Shri Pratap Babu
Sen petitioner in W.P. No. 4111/2006(S) and Shri Ram Kumar
Trivedi, petitioner petitioner in W.P. No. 4101/2006(S). Thus the
contention of the learned counsel for the petitioner is that in the
enquiry itself there was no allegations against the petitioner and
therefore, by no stretch of imagination, the appointment of the
petitioner could not have been put to an end. Learned counsel for
the petitioner has relied upon a judgment delivered in the case of
Suresh Babu Kaurav Vs. State of M.P. and others in W.P. No.
4215/2006(S) dated 11-09-2008, wherein this Court while
considering the same DPC and reversion order of identically
placed persons has held as under:-
"The Apex Court in the case of Gajanan L.Pernekar vs. State of
Goa and another, (1999) 8 SCC 378 has held that in case an order
is passed recalling another administrative order, an opportunity of
show cause to adversely affected person has to be given in the
matter. The Apex Court was dealing with a case of recall of
absorption and it was held that opportunity of hearing should have
been provided to the employees before recalling the order of
absorption.
Similarly, the Apex Court in the case of S hekhar Ghosh vs. Union
of India and another, (2007) 1 SCC 331 has held that an
opportunity of hearing has to be granted to an employee in those
cases where civil consequences are involved. The Apex Court has
held in paragraphs 18, 19, 20, 21 and 22 as under:
"Curiously, the respondents in their counter-affidavits filed before
theTribunal and the High Court did not raise any plea of
rectification of any mistake. It was also not stated in the show-
cause notice issued to the appellant. Only a plea of mistake was
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: DINESH VERMA
Signing time: 19-11-2026
18:19:09
12 WP-29869-2018
taken for the first time before the Tribunal, but no plea was taken
that it was entitled to rectify the same or the order impugned
before it was capable of being rectified. Thus, it was not a case
where an opportunity of hearing was given to the appellant on the
premise that a mistake had been committed by the authorities of
the first respondent and the same was required to be rectified.
If a mistake is to be rectified the same should be done as
expeditiously as possible. (See Board of Secondary Education of
Assam v. Mohd. Sarifuz Zaman, 2003 (12) SCC 408.
We are not oblivious that in Ram Chandra Tripathi v. U.P. Public
Services Tribunal IV 1994 (5) SCC 180, an order passed by way
of a mistake was permitted to be corrected as the same was done
in violation of the order of injunction. In such a situation only, this
Court held that an opportunity of being heard for correcting such
mistake would not arise because there would not have been any
occasion to take one view of the other in the matter on the basis of
representation to be made by the affected employee.
It is also not a case where a mistake was apparent on the face of
the record and,thus, compliance with the principles of natural
justice would not have made any difference as was in Ratna Sen
Nee Raoy v. State of W.B. 1995 (1) Cal LT 462.
Requirements to comply with the principles of natural justice
would, therefore, vary from case to case. If upon giving an
opportunity of hearing to an affected employee, it is possible to
arrive at a different finding, the principles of natural justice must
be complied with. We may notice that recently in Union of India
v. Bikash Kuanar 2006 (8) SCC 192, a Division Bench of this
Court opined:
"It is now trite that if a mistake is committed in passing an
administrative order, the same may be rectified. Rectification of
an mistake, however, may in a given situation require compliance
with the principles of natural justice. It is only in a case where the
mistake is apparent on the fact of the record, a rectification thereof
is permissible without giving any hearing to the aggrieved party."
In the present case as is reflected from the enquiry report, it is
evident that the petitioner was qualified for promotion to the post
of Accountant, and therefore, this Court is of the considered view,
that in all fairness, opportunity should have been granted to the
petitioner. As the respondents have violated the principles of
natural justice and fair play in actionand in a mechanical manner
have passed the order, Annexure P/1 dated 19th June, 2006, the
same is hereby quashed.
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: DINESH VERMA
Signing time: 19-11-2026
18:19:09
13 WP-29869-2018
Resultantly, the petition is allowed. The petitioner is entitled to
continue on the promoted post and also entitled for salary for the
promoted post Accountant. The petitioner shall also be entitled for
all consequential benefits flowing from the promotion order dated
04th October, 2004 (Annexure P/6).
Petition stands allowed disposed of." and
Keeping in view the aforesaid judgment delivered by this Court in
the case of Suresh Babu Kaurav (supra) and also in other identical
cases i.e. W.P. No. 4190/2006(S) and also keeping in view that
there is nothing against the petitioner in the enquiry report and
also keeping in view that they were promoted by a duly
constituted departmental promotional committee as provided
under the Recruitment Rules, the impugned order dated 19-06-
2006 deserves to be quashed and is hereby quashed. Resultantly,
the present writ petition is allowed, the petitioner in both the writ
petition are entitled to continue on the promotional post i.e. post of
Assistant Grade-III. The petitioner shall also be entitled to all
consequential benefits including salary and arrears of salary from
the date of promotion i.e. 04-10-2004.
With the aforesaid observation, the present writ petition stands
allowed and disposed of. No order as to costs.
11. In the present case, it is evident that no opportunity of hearing
was granted to the petitioners while setting aside the promotion granted to
the next higher post. Keeping in view the judgment delivered by this Court in
the case of Pratap Babu Sen (supra) and the judgment of Apex Court in the
case of Shekhar Ghosh (supra), Ram Ujarey (supra), Prakash Ratan Sinha
(supra) and also the judgments of this Court in Smt. Laxmi Gaud (supra),
Pradeep Sharma (supra), Raju Batham (supra), Vinay Kumar Savita (supra),
Prakash Kumar Dehariya (supra), as the civil consequences are involved in
the matter and as no opportunity of hearing was granted to the petitioners, it
is fit case for interference in the matter.
1 2 . Taking into consideration, the submission putforth by learned
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: DINESH VERMA
Signing time: 19-11-2026
18:19:09
14 WP-29869-2018
counsel for rival parties, couple with the facts and circumstances of the case, this
Court is of the considered opinion that the present petition deserves to be and is
hereby allowed and disposed of in the the following manner:
(i) impugned order dated 09.04.2018 is hereby quashed;
(ii) The respondents are directed to grant all consequential benefits to
the petitioners, which have already been granted to similarly situated
persons, within a period of three months from the date of receipt of a
certified copy of this order.
(iii) The liberty is granted to the respondents to take a fresh action in
accordance with law, if so advised.
(iv) The respondents shall also consider that since 2008, the
petitioners are still working on the promotion post. The respondents shall
also consider that interim order has also been granted by this court at the
time of issuance of notice . Only the liberty has been granted to the
respondents to take a fresh action and the said liberty cannot be treated as a
direction to take a fresh action.
13. Consequently, all the writ petitions stand allowed and disposed
of in above terms.
(ANAND SINGH BAHRAWAT)
JUDGE
DV
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: DINESH VERMA
Signing time: 19-11-2026
18:19:09