Saroj Devi & Ors. vs Union Of India
- Court
- Delhi High Court
* IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
% Reserved on : 04.11.2026
Pronounced on : 17.11.2026
Uploaded on : 17.11.2026
+ FAO 169/2023
SAROJ DEVI & ORS. .....Appellants
Through: Mr.Rajan Sood, Ms. Ashima Sood
and Ms. Megha Sood, Advocates
versus
UNION OF INDIA .....Respondent
Through: Mr. Vivek Goyal, CGSC with Mr.
Aryan Aggarwal, Advocate
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE MANOJ KUMAR OHRI
JUDGMENT
1. The present appeal has been filed under Section 23 of the Railway
Claims Tribunal Act, 1987 against the judgment dated 03.01.2023 passed by
the Railway Claims Tribunal, Principal Bench, Delhi (hereinafter referred to
as the “Tribunal”) in Claim Application No. OA/II(u)/DLI/74/2021, whereby
the claim application filed by the appellants seeking compensation on
account of the death of one Mahipal Singh (hereinafter referred to as the
“deceased”) came to be dismissed.
2. The brief facts of the case are that on 08.01.2020, the deceased had
undertaken a train journey from Jalesar Road Railway Station towards
Signature Not Verified
FAO 169/2023 Page 1 of 7
Digitally SignedPREM
MOHAN CHOUDHARY
Signing Date:17.11.2026
23:41:57
Tundla Railway Station. It is the case of the appellants that after purchasing
a valid journey ticket, the deceased boarded the Train No. 64584 ( Delhi -
Tundla MEMU Passenger), when he accidentally fell from the train at
Jalesar Road Railway Station and sustained grievous injuries and thereafter,
he succumbed to his injuries.
3. Learned counsel for the appellants submits that the Tribunal failed to
appreciate the material evidence on record while holding that the deceased
was not a bona fide passenger. It is submitted that although the original
claim application stated that the journey ticket had been lost in the incident,
the subsequent DRM inquiry brought on record refers to the particulars of
ticket No. 33333728, issued from Jalesar Road to Allahabad . It is further
submitted that the said ticket was verified during the railway inquiry and that
AW-1/ Pikal Singh , son of the deceased, also categorically deposed that his
father had purchased the ticket in his presence. Learned counsel submits that
the Tribunal discarded this evidence merely on account of the discrepancy in
the versions put forth by the appellants. It is further contended that the
Station Master’s memo dated 08.01.2020 records that one person had fallen
from the trainwhereas the subsequent DRM report attributed the occurrence
to an attempt by the deceased to board the train from the off side. It is
submitted that even the railway records contain varying versions as to
whether the deceased was boarding or de-boarding the train.
4. On the contrary, learned counsel for the respondent submits that the
original claim application specifically mentioned the journey from Jalesar
Road to Tundla and stated that the ticket had been lost in the incident. It is
contended that the subsequent production of the ticketwas an attempt to
Signature Not Verified
FAO 169/2023 Page 2 of 7
Digitally SignedPREM
MOHAN CHOUDHARY
Signing Date:17.11.2026
23:41:57
improve the case after institution of the claim. Learned counsel also submits
that the body of the deceased was found between the loop line and the main
line after the departure of Train No. 64584, which establishes that he was
attempting to board the train from the off side. It is accordingly contended
that neither the bona fide status of the deceased nor the occurrence of an
“untoward incident” within the meaning of the Railways Act, 1989
(hereinafter referred to as the “Act”) stands established.
5. The next question which arises for consideration is whether the death
of the deceased occurred in an “untoward incident” within the meaning of
Section 123(c) of the Act. The Tribunal has principally relied upon the
statement of HC/RPF Jogendra Singh that after the departure of Train No.
64584 at about 18:47 hrs. from Platform No.1, Jalesar Road Railway
Station, he noticed one person lying between the loop line and the main line.
On this basis, it has been inferred that the deceased was attempting to board
the train from the off side.
6. Pertinently, the Station Master’s memo dated 08.01.2020, issued at
about 18:50 hrs., records that one person had “fallen” from Train No. 64584
at Jalesar Road Railway Station Yard. The injured person was thereafter
taken to Primary Health Centre with the assistance of the railway/police
personnel. The aforesaid memo is a contemporaneous railway record and
assumes significance in determining the nature of the occurrence. Further,
the RPF record, as noticed even in the impugned judgment, contains an entry
describing the occurrence as one where a person fell from the off side while
attempting to de-board Train No. 64584. Thus, while the Station Master’s
memo records that the person had fallen from the train, the subsequent
Signature Not Verified
FAO 169/2023 Page 3 of 7
Digitally SignedPREM
MOHAN CHOUDHARY
Signing Date:17.11.2026
23:41:57
entries and the DRM report attribute the occurrence to an attempt to board or
de-board the train from the off side. These varying versions, emanating from
the railway records themselves, cannot be ignored and will, in view of the
beneficial course of the legislation, benefit the appellants.
7. The Tribunal has proceeded on the assumption that a bona fide
passenger would not attempt to board a train from the off side and, therefore,
the deceased must have been trespassing. There is no material on record to
establish that the deceased had entered the railway track for any purpose
unconnected with the train journey. Rather, the earliest railway record points
towards a fall from Train No. 64584. The subsequent conclusion in the
DRM report regarding the deceased having attempted to board the train from
the off side is itself based upon the circumstances in which he was found and
does not conclusively establish the precise manner of occurrence.In this
regard, the decision of the Supreme Court in “ Rina Devi ” ( supra ) assumes
significance. The Supreme Court has specifically held that an accidental fall
while boarding or de-boarding a train, even from the off side, would
constitute an untoward incident within the meaning of Section 123(c)(2) of
the Act. It has further been held that the concept of self-inflicted injury
requires an intentional act and cannot be equated with negligence,
irrespective of its degree. Thus, even if the version of the Railways that the
deceased was attempting to board the train from the off side is accepted, the
same would not, by itself, take the occurrence outside the ambit of an
“untoward incident”.
8. The next question which arises for consideration is whether the
deceased was a bona fide passenger, the issue is required to be considered in
Signature Not Verified
FAO 169/2023 Page 4 of 7
Digitally SignedPREM
MOHAN CHOUDHARY
Signing Date:17.11.2026
23:41:57
the light of the principles laid down by the Supreme Court in “ Union of
1
India v. Rina Devi ” . The Supreme Court has held that mere absence or non-
recovery of a journey ticket from the injured or deceased passenger does not,
by itself, negative the claim of bona fide passenger. The initial burden upon
the claimant can be discharged by placing the relevant facts and
circumstances on record, whereafter the burden shifts upon the Railways to
rebut the same. The said principle has also been reiterated in “ Lata v. Union
2 3
of India ” and “ Sukhabhai Nanjibhai Makwana &Anr. v. Union of India ”
wherein the Supreme Court has emphasised that the issue is to be examined
on the touchstone of preponderance of probabilities.
Applying the aforesaid principles to the facts of the present case, it is
noticed that the original claim application was founded on the assertion that
the deceased was travelling from Jalesar Road to Tundla and that the
journey ticket, along with his bag and other belongings, was lost in the
incident. Subsequently, during the course of the DRM inquiry, particulars of
ticket No. 33333728, issued from Jalesar Road to Allahabad , came on
record. Significantly, the respondent/Railways itself, in its written statement,
acknowledged that a copy of the aforesaid ticket had been furnished to the
inquiry officer, though it disputed its genuineness by alleging that the same
had been arranged subsequently. The DRM report also records the
verification of the said ticket. Further, AW-1/ Pikal Singh , son of the
deceased, appeared before the Tribunal and deposed that he had
accompanied his father to Jalesar Road Railway Station and had witnessed
1
(2019) 3 SCC 572
2
2026 INSC 715
3
2026 INSC 1056
Signature Not Verified
FAO 169/2023 Page 5 of 7
Digitally SignedPREM
MOHAN CHOUDHARY
Signing Date:17.11.2026
23:41:57
him purchasing the journey ticket.
9. Further, the testimony of AW-1 could not have been discarded merely
by describing him as an interested witness, without examining it alongside
the other material on record. Even if the subsequent version regarding the
ticket is viewed with some reservation, the original assertion regarding
purchase of a journey ticket and its loss in the incident, read with the
testimony of AW-1 and the material emerging from the DRM inquiry, was
sufficient to discharge the initial burden cast upon the appellants. The
Railways, on the other hand, have not placed any cogent material to dispute
the aforesaid. The benefit of the discrepancy, in the facts and circumstances
of the present case, ought to have gone to the appellants rather than resulting
in rejection of their claim.
10. Lastly, it is well settled that claims under the Act are to be examined
keeping in view the beneficial nature of the legislation. An accidental fall
from a train would ordinarily occur without the presence of an independent
eyewitness. The Court is, therefore, required to examine the
contemporaneous railway and police records along with the attending
circumstances rather than insist upon proof of the precise mechanics of the
occurrence.
11. In view of the above, the impugned judgment is set aside and the
matter is remanded back to the Tribunal, which is requested to assess the
amount of compensation payable to the appellant in accordance with law and
direct the authorities concerned to disburse the same within two months
from the receipt of a copy of this order. For this purpose, the matter be listed
before the Tribunal at the first instance on 03.12.2026.
Signature Not Verified
FAO 169/2023 Page 6 of 7
Digitally SignedPREM
MOHAN CHOUDHARY
Signing Date:17.11.2026
23:41:57
12. The appeal is allowed and disposed of in the above terms.
13. A copy of this judgment be communicated to the learned Tribunal.
(MANOJ KUMAR OHRI)
JUDGE
NOVEMBER 17, 2026
na
Signature Not Verified
FAO 169/2023 Page 7 of 7
Digitally SignedPREM
MOHAN CHOUDHARY
Signing Date:17.11.2026
23:41:57