In Re: Phalodi Accident vs National Highways Authority Of India

Court
Supreme Court

2026 INSC 1243
REPORTABLE
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
CIVIL ORIGINAL JURISDICTION

SUO MOTO WRIT PETITION (CIVIL) NO(s). 9/2025

IN RE: PHALODI ACCIDENT PETITIONER(S)

VERSUS

NATIONAL HIGHWAYS AUTHORITY
OF INDIA & ORS. RESPONDENT(S)

WITH

WRIT PETITION (C) NO. 1100/2025

AND

WRIT PETITION (C) NO. 1272/2019

IA No. 308397/2026,
IA No. 296745/2026,
IA No. 316792/2025,
IA No. 270466/2026,
IA No. 270243/2026,
IA No. 269086/2026,
IA No. 308233/2026,
IA No. 270722/2026,
IA No. 242242/2026,
IA No. 288848/2026,
IA No. 293942/2026 ,
Signature Not Verified
IA No. 288807/2026,
Digitally signed by
SONIA BHASIN
Date: 2026.11.18
17:38:00 IST
Reason:
IA No. 293929/2026,
IA No. 288684/2026,
SUO MOTO WRIT PETITION (CIVIL) NO. 9/2025 ETC. 1

IA No. 293900/2026,
IA No. 293514/2026,
IA No. 293363/2026,
IA No. 289276/2026,
IA No. 288920/2026,
IA No. 288866/2026,
IA No. 305733/2026,
IA No. 242241/2026,
IA No. 289277/2026,
IA No. 288921/2026,
IA No. 288867/2026,
IA No. 288849/2026,
IA No. 293943/2026,
IA No. 288808/2026,
IA No. 293931/2026,
IA No. 288685/2026,
IA No. 293901/2026,
IA No. 269087/2026,
IA No. 293515/2026,
IA No. 293366/2026,
IA No. 294494/2025,
IA No. 269085/2026,
IA No. 288916/2026,
IA No. 308232/2026,
IA No. 259477/2026,
IA No. 288868/2026,
IA No. 305732/2026,
IA No. 335365/2025,
SUO MOTO WRIT PETITION (CIVIL) NO. 9/2025 ETC. 2

IA No. 288852/2026,
IA No. 293939/2026,
IA No. 288809/2026,
IA No. 293919/2026,
IA No. 288681/2026,
IA No. 293896/2026,
IA No. 270721/2026,
IA No. 293510/2026,
IA No. 270465/2026,
IA No. 293361/2026,
IA No. 270241/2026,
IA No. 289273/2026,
IA No. 308395/2026,
IA No. 289275/2026,
IA No. 288919/2026,
IA No. 288865/2026,
IA No. 288847/2026,
IA No. 293941/2026,
IA No. 288806/2026,
IA No. 293928/2026,
IA No. 288683/2026,
IA No. 293899/2026,
IA No. 293513/2026,
IA No. 293364/2026,
IA No. 308234/2026,
IA No. 270723/2026,
IA No. 270467/2026,
IA No. 270244/2026
SUO MOTO WRIT PETITION (CIVIL) NO. 9/2025 ETC. 3


IN SUO MOTO WRIT PETITION(CIVIL) No(s). 9/2025

IA No. 152354/2026 IN W.P.(C) NO.1100/2025

AND
IA No. 106150/2024,
IA No. 280278/2025,
IA No. 184634/2022,
IA No. 255152/2025,
IA No. 221232/2025,
IA No. 20800/2021,
IA No. 1096/2021,
IA No. 3439/2021,
IA No. 228114/2025,
IA No. 230162/2024,
IA No. 236406/2024,
IA No. 135458/2019,
IA No. 251974/2024,
IA No. 41241/2024 IN W.P.(C) No. 1272/2019

J U D G M E N T
VIKRAM NATH, J.

1. The present suo motu proceedings (Suo Moto Writ Petition
No. 9 of 2025) arise out of the concerns relating to road
safety on National Highways, following the unfortunate
road accidents at Phalodi, Rajasthan, and other places. In
the course of these proceedings, this Court has issued
various directions aimed at improving road safety and
SUO MOTO WRIT PETITION (CIVIL) NO. 9/2025 ETC. 4

ensuring the removal of unauthorised encroachments from
National Highways.
2. By order dated 13.04.2026, this Court issued various
interim directions in the larger interest of road safety. For
the purposes of the present applications, it would be
appropriate to reproduce the relevant directions contained
in paragraph 4 of the said order, which read as follows:

“b) Inspection, Survey and Citizen Grievance –
The Highway Administration, NHAI, NHIDCL, and
State PWDs shall, within 30 days, file before this
Court a consolidated report on –

(i) Composition and schedule of dedicated
inspection teams for each highway stretch;

(ii) State-wise encroachments identified, notices
issued under Section 26 of the Control of National
Highways (Land and Traffic) Act, 2002 – CNH Act
and structures demolished, and

(iii) Status of compliance with the directions issued
in Gyan Prakash vs. Union of India and others.
NHAI shall simultaneously confirm full
operationalisation of the Rajmargyatra
encroachment complaint module (with geo-tagged
uploads, grievance tracking, and appeal
mechanism), activation of toll-free number 1033 for
encroachment complaints, and dissemination of
both across highway signage, toll plazas, and
media. Drone-based aerial surveys (DRAMS Policy
Circular, 05.09.2025) shall be conducted at least
twice annually, with six-monthly reports filed
before this Court.

c) Encroachment Prohibition and Removal –
Construction/operation of any new dhaba, eatery,
or commercial structure within the Right of Way
SUO MOTO WRIT PETITION (CIVIL) NO. 9/2025 ETC. 5

(ROW) of any National Highway is prohibited with
immediate effect. District Magistrates shall enforce
demolition/removal of all new or existing
unauthorised structures within 60 days, in terms
of the CNH Act procedure and SOP dated
07.08.2025.

e) District Highway Safety Task Force – In
every district wherever the National Highway
passes through, the concerned District Magistrate
within 15 days of this order constitute a District
Highway Safety Task Force in every district across
India within 7 days of this order, comprising
officers of the District Administration, Police, NHAI
(or concerned land-owning agency), PWD, and local
bodies. The District Collector and Commissioner of
Police/Superintendent of Police shall bear joint
responsibility for timely encroachment removal.
The Task Force shall hold fortnightly review
meetings and maintain minutes. State
Governments shall further issue notifications
within 60 days prohibiting change of land use
within 40 metres (residential) and 75 metres
(commercial) from the mid-point of any National
Highway, consistent with IRC norms; MoRTH shall
facilitate uniform notifications across all States
within the same period.”

3. At this stage, we are concerned with a batch of
interlocutory applications filed by persons who are
aggrieved by the action initiated by the National Highways
Authority of India (hereinafter referred to as “NHAI”) and
other concerned authorities for removal of structures
alleged to be encroachments upon the Right of Way of
National Highways. The applicants have, inter alia, sought
interim protection against demolition or other coercive
action in respect of their properties. Since the grievances
SUO MOTO WRIT PETITION (CIVIL) NO. 9/2025 ETC. 6

raised in these applications are substantially similar, we
propose to consider them together by this common order.
4. Pursuant to the aforesaid directions, NHAI and the
concerned authorities initiated action for removal of
structures alleged to be encroachments upon the Right of
Way of National Highways. Aggrieved by such action,
several persons have approached this Court seeking
clarification of the earlier directions and interim protection
against demolition or removal of their structures. Some of
the applicants had also approached the jurisdictional High
Courts and were granted liberty to seek clarification from
this Court. During the pendency of these applications, this
Court, by orders dated 08.09.2026, 22.09.2026 and
06.10.2026, directed maintenance of status quo in certain
matters.
5. I.A. Nos. 269085 and 269086 of 2026 have been filed by
Prakashbhai Manharlal Shah and Others, seeking
impleadment and clarification of the order dated
13.04.2026. The applicants claim ownership of the
disputed property on the basis of a registered sale deed
dated 02.05.1988 and have challenged the proposed
demolition of their structures by NHAI. Having initially
approached the High Court of Gujarat, they were granted
liberty to seek clarification from this Court as to whether
their properties are covered by the directions issued on
13.04.2026.
6. Similarly, I.A. Nos. 270241, 270243 and 270244 of 2026
have been filed by Patel Nileshbhai Pravinbhai and Others,
SUO MOTO WRIT PETITION (CIVIL) NO. 9/2025 ETC. 7

who claim to be owners of land adjoining National Highway
48 in District Valsad, Gujarat. They are aggrieved by
notices issued by the Highway Administrator proposing
removal of structures situated on their land. I.A. Nos.
270465, 270466 and 270467 of 2026 have been filed by
Ashokbhai Nanubhai Patel and Others, who contend that
although no formal written notices have been served upon
them, announcements concerning removal of structures
have been made through Highway Patrol Vehicles, and
notices have been issued to other adjoining landowners.
Apprehending similar action against structures situated on
their privately owned land, they have approached this
Court seeking clarification of the earlier directions and
interim protection against any coercive action. I.A. Nos.
270721, 270722 and 270723 of 2026, filed by Arihant
Petroleum and Another, raise similar grievances
concerning the proposed removal of structures situated on
land claimed to be privately owned by the respective
applicants. These applications also seek clarification of the
earlier directions and interim protection against the
proposed action.
7. A further set of applications has been filed by Sabbirali
Jivabhai Sunsara, Sarabhai Virubhai Bharvad,
Jivankumar Chandanmal Jain, Mukeshbhai Keshubhai
Vora, Laljibhai Meghjibhai Vaghasiya and Tanujaben
Nalinbhai Patel, through their Advocate-on-Record, Mr. T.
Harish Kumar. These include I.A. Nos. 288681, 288809,
288852, 288868, 288916 and 289273 of 2026, together
SUO MOTO WRIT PETITION (CIVIL) NO. 9/2025 ETC. 8

with their respective connected applications for
modification and interim stay. The applicants have
challenged notices issued by the Highway Administration
proposing removal of structures situated on properties
claimed to be privately owned by them in Navsari, Gujarat.
They contend that the proposed demolition is being
undertaken without proper determination of their rights or
compliance with the applicable statutory procedure. They
have also sought protection against coercive action and, in
the alternative, acquisition of their land and payment of
compensation in accordance with law, if the same is
required for highway widening or other public purposes.
8. Similar applications have been filed by Dahyabhai
Mavjibhai Patel, Siddik Sumar Safiya, Prima Auto Cool,
National Tyre Services and M/s GD Hotel, through the
same Advocate-on-Record. These include I.A. Nos. 293361,
293510, 293896, 293919 and 293939 of 2026, along with
their respective connected applications for modification
and interim stay. The applicants claim that the structures
proposed to be removed are situated on their privately
owned properties and that the action initiated by NHAI is
contrary to the procedure prescribed by law. They have
sought clarification of the order dated 13.04.2026,
protection against demolition and, wherever applicable,
consideration of their entitlement to acquisition and
compensation in accordance with law.
9. I.A. Nos. 305732 and 305733 of 2026 have been filed by
Hatim Sirajbhai Lokhandwala, who claims to be the
SUO MOTO WRIT PETITION (CIVIL) NO. 9/2025 ETC. 9

registered owner of land situated in District Navsari,
Gujarat, upon which a hotel is being operated. The
applicant has challenged the notice dated 22.08.2026
issued by NHAI proposing removal of structures alleged to
fall within the Right of Way of National Highway 48. The
applicant disputes the demarcation undertaken by NHAI
and claims that the structures are situated on privately
owned land which has neither been acquired nor
compensated for. Having approached the High Court of
Gujarat, the applicant was permitted to seek clarification
from this Court and has also sought interim protection
against the proposed demolition.
10. I.A. Nos. 308232, 308233 and 308234 of 2026 have been
filed by Ramanbhai Dhirubhai Patel, seeking impleadment,
clarification and interim stay. The applicant is aggrieved by
notices issued for removal of structures which he claims
are situated on his privately owned land adjoining a
National Highway. He has sought clarification of the
directions dated 13.04.2026 and protection against the
proposed removal of such structures pending adjudication
of his grievance.
11. During the pendency of these applications, this Court, by
order dated 08.09.2026, directed NHAI to file its response
and ordered maintenance of status quo. By a subsequent
order dated 22.09.2026, the interim protection was
continued, and NHAI was granted an opportunity to
respond to certain additional applications raising similar
grievances. Thereafter, by order dated 06.10.2026, this
SUO MOTO WRIT PETITION (CIVIL) NO. 9/2025 ETC. 10

Court issued notice in I.A. Nos. 305732, 305733 and
308232 of 2026 and directed maintenance of status quo
therein. The Office Report dated 12.10.2026 indicates that
NHAI has filed its responses in several of the applications.
Thus, while formal notice has been expressly issued in
certain applications, NHAI has also participated in the
proceedings and filed responses in several other
applications where no express order issuing notice has
been passed.
12. We have heard learned counsel appearing for the respective
applicants, learned counsel appearing for NHAI and the
learned Amicus Curiae, and have considered the material
placed on record. The principal submission advanced on
behalf of the applicants is that the structures sought to be
removed are situated on land which they claim to be
lawfully owned or occupied by them. It is contended that
the authorities have proceeded to treat such structures as
unauthorised encroachments without properly
determining the extent of the Right of Way or affording the
applicants an adequate opportunity to establish their
respective claims. Several applicants have also disputed
the measurements and demarcation undertaken by NHAI
and have relied upon documents concerning ownership,
acquisition and permissions granted by the competent
authorities. It is further submitted that the directions
issued by this Court on 13.04.2026 cannot be construed
as authorising demolition of structures without following
the procedure prescribed by law.
SUO MOTO WRIT PETITION (CIVIL) NO. 9/2025 ETC. 11

13. On the other hand, NHAI has sought to justify the action
initiated by it on the ground that the removal of
unauthorised encroachments is being undertaken in
compliance with the directions issued by this Court on
13.04.2026, particularly directions 4(b), 4(c) and 4(e). It is
submitted that the concerned authorities are under an
obligation to ensure removal of encroachments from the
Right of Way of National Highways in the interest of road
safety. NHAI has further maintained, in its responses to
certain applications, that notices have been issued under
the provisions of the Control of National Highways (Land
and Traffic) Act, 2002 (hereinafter referred to as “the 2002
Act”) and that the measurements undertaken by the
authorities establish that the disputed structures fall
within the Right of Way. It has also been contended that
disputes concerning ownership, boundaries and the extent
of the Right of Way involve questions of fact which ought
to be adjudicated before the competent court.
14. Having considered the rival submissions, we find it
necessary to clarify the scope and effect of the directions
issued by this Court on 13.04.2026. There can be no
dispute that the removal of unauthorised encroachments
from National Highways is a matter of considerable public
importance, particularly having regard to the serious
consequences which such encroachments may have upon
road safety. It was precisely in this context that the
aforesaid directions were issued. However, those directions
were intended to address the larger issue of highway safety
SUO MOTO WRIT PETITION (CIVIL) NO. 9/2025 ETC. 12

and the removal of unlawful encroachments. They did not
involve an examination or determination of the individual
rights of persons whose properties may subsequently be
subjected to action by the concerned authorities. The
question whether a particular structure constitutes an
unauthorised encroachment was neither examined nor
adjudicated upon by this Court.
15. It is in this context that the submission advanced on behalf
of NHAI, that the proposed demolition is being undertaken
pursuant to the directions of this Court, must be
considered. The directions dated 13.04.2026 undoubtedly
cast an obligation upon the concerned authorities to
identify and remove unauthorised encroachments.
However, such an obligation cannot be understood as
dispensing with the requirement of determining whether
the structure sought to be removed is, in fact, an
unauthorised encroachment upon highway land. The
distinction between a general direction to remove
encroachments and the determination of whether a
particular property constitutes an encroachment is of
considerable significance. The former cannot, by itself, be
treated as a conclusive adjudication of the latter. Indeed,
direction 4(c) expressly requires that removal be
undertaken in accordance with the procedure prescribed
under the 2002 Act and the Standard Operating Procedure
dated 07.08.2025. The earlier directions, therefore, cannot
be construed as conferring upon the authorities any power
SUO MOTO WRIT PETITION (CIVIL) NO. 9/2025 ETC. 13

beyond that contemplated by the applicable statutory
framework.
16. Section 26 of the 2002 Act provides the statutory
mechanism for removal of unauthorised occupation of
highway land. Subsections (2) to (6) contemplate issuance
of notice identifying the highway land concerned, an
opportunity to make a representation, and consideration of
the cause shown by the person against whom action is
proposed. The importance of adherence to this procedure
has also been recognised by this Court in Gyan Prakash
v. Union of India and Others, 2025 SCC OnLine SC
1189 , wherein it was emphasised that the procedure
prescribed under Section 26 is essential for compliance
with the principles of natural justice. It is true that
subsections (7) and (8) of Section 26 also contemplate
removal of unauthorised occupation without prior notice in
the circumstances specified therein. However, the
availability of such powers must necessarily be examined
with reference to the statutory conditions governing their
exercise. The directions issued by this Court cannot be
invoked as an independent justification for dispensing with
the requirements of the statute.
17. In the present applications, several applicants have raised
disputes concerning ownership of the land, the extent of
the Right of Way, the correctness of the demarcation
undertaken by NHAI and the acquisition of the land in
question. These are matters which may require
examination of revenue records, acquisition proceedings,
SUO MOTO WRIT PETITION (CIVIL) NO. 9/2025 ETC. 14

survey reports and other relevant documents. We are
conscious that a mere assertion of ownership or lawful
occupation cannot, by itself, prevent the authorities from
exercising their statutory powers to remove unauthorised
encroachments. Equally, the mere assertion by the
authorities that a particular structure falls within the Right
of Way cannot be treated as a substitute for the
determination required under law, where the very basis of
such assertion is disputed. The competing claims must be
examined in accordance with the applicable statutory
framework, and the persons affected must be afforded such
opportunity of hearing and adjudication as the law
requires.
18. We are, therefore, of the considered view that the individual
grievances raised in these applications ought to be
examined by the respective jurisdictional High Courts. The
present suo motu proceedings are concerned with the
larger and systemic issues relating to highway safety, and
it would neither be appropriate nor practicable for this
Court to undertake a factual examination of the ownership,
boundaries and legal status of each disputed property. The
jurisdictional High Courts would be better placed to
consider the relevant records, examine the legality of the
action initiated by the authorities and determine whether
the procedure prescribed by law has been duly followed.
They would also be at liberty to consider whether any
disputed question requires determination by the
competent statutory authority or other appropriate forum.
SUO MOTO WRIT PETITION (CIVIL) NO. 9/2025 ETC. 15

Such an approach would ensure that the directions issued
by this Court for removal of unauthorised encroachments
are implemented in accordance with law, without depriving
the affected persons of an opportunity to establish their
respective claims.
19. We accordingly consider it appropriate to relegate the
applicants to the respective jurisdictional High Courts for
adjudication of their grievances. We make it clear that we
have not expressed any opinion on the merits of the claims
advanced by the applicants or upon the correctness of the
action initiated by NHAI and the other concerned
authorities. Those questions shall remain open for
independent consideration in accordance with law. At the
same time, the directions issued by this Court on
13.04.2026 shall continue to operate in their entirety,
subject to the clarification that their implementation must
remain consistent with the applicable statutory provisions
and the rights of affected persons to seek appropriate
remedies in accordance with law.
20. Accordingly, we dispose of the present interlocutory
applications by granting liberty to the respective applicants
to approach the jurisdictional High Courts for adjudication
of their grievances concerning the proposed demolition or
removal of structures alleged to be encroachments upon
the Right of Way of National Highways. Those who have
already instituted proceedings before the High Courts shall
be at liberty to pursue the same in accordance with law.
SUO MOTO WRIT PETITION (CIVIL) NO. 9/2025 ETC. 16

21. The interim protection already granted by this Court shall
continue until disposal of the respective proceedings before
the jurisdictional High Courts. In cases where no such
protection has previously been granted, we direct that
NHAI and the concerned authorities shall not undertake
demolition, removal of the disputed structures or any other
coercive action pursuant to the impugned notices until
such disposal.
22. The jurisdictional High Courts shall adjudicate upon the
respective grievances independently, after affording due
opportunity of hearing to the parties and in accordance
with law. All questions concerning ownership, demarcation
of the Right of Way, acquisition of land and compliance
with the statutory procedure shall remain open for
consideration. The directions dated 13.04.2026 shall not
be treated as having conclusively determined the rights of
the parties or the legality of the disputed structures. We
request the High Courts to dispose of such proceedings as
expeditiously as possible.
23. It is made clear that the interim protection shall remain
confined to the structures forming the subject matter of
these applications and shall not create any equity in favour
of the applicants or authorise any fresh construction or
encroachment. The directions dated 13.04.2026 shall
otherwise remain unaffected.
24. Accordingly, I.A. Nos. 269085, 269086, 270241, 270243,
270244, 270465, 270466, 270467, 270721, 270722,
270723, 288681, 288683, 288684, 288806, 288807,
SUO MOTO WRIT PETITION (CIVIL) NO. 9/2025 ETC. 17

288809, 288847, 288848, 288852, 288865, 288866,
288868, 288916, 288919, 288920, 289273, 289275,
289276, 293361, 293363, 293364, 293510, 293513,
293514, 293896, 293899, 293900, 293919, 293928,
293929, 293939, 293941, 293942, 305732, 305733,
308232, 308233 and 308234 of 2026 stand disposed of in
the aforesaid terms.
25. The remaining interlocutory applications shall remain
pending. List the main matter with the connected matters
in due course.


…………………………………………..J.
[VIKRAM NATH]




…………………………………………..J.
[APARESH KUMAR SINGH]
NEW DELHI;
NOVEMBER 18, 2026

SUO MOTO WRIT PETITION (CIVIL) NO. 9/2025 ETC. 18