RAVI S/O MALLAPPA AND ORS vs THE STATE OF KARNATAKA AND ORS

Court
Karnataka High Court

- 1 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12309
WP No. 205581 of 2016


CNR: KAHC030062452016




IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA


KALABURAGI BENCH

TH
DATED THIS THE 16 DAY OF NOVEMBER, 2026

BEFORE

THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE VIJAYKUMAR A. PATIL

WRIT PETITION NO. 205581 OF 2016 (S-REG)

BETWEEN:
1. RAVI S/O MALLESHI
AGED ABOUT 37 YEARS
OCC: WORKING AS PUMP OPERATOR

2. RAJASHEKAR S/O ANNAVEERAYYA
AGED ABOUT 38 YEARS
OCC: BILL COLLECTOR

3. SHIVAKUMAR S/O BASAVARAJ
AGED ABOUT 38 YEARS
OCC: WORKING AS SANITARY INSPECTOR

ALL PETITIONERS ARE RESIDENT OF
SHAHABAD TQ: CHITTAPUR
DIST: KALABURAGI-585102
…PETITIONERS










Digitally signed by
SWETA
KULKARNI
Location: HIGH
COURT OF
KARNATAKA

(BY SRI. RAVINDRA REDDY., ADVOCATE)
AND:
1.
THE STATE OF KARNATAKA
BY ITS SECRETARY
HOUSING AND URBAN DEVELOPMENT
M.S.BUILDING, BENGALURU-560001

2.
THE DIRECTOR OF
MUNCIPAL ADMINISTRATION
AMBEDKAR VEEDHI
VISVESHWARAIAH TOWER

- 2 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12309
WP No. 205581 of 2016


CNR: KAHC030062452016


BENGALURU-560001

3.
THE DEPUTY COMMISSIONER
KALABURAGI DISTRICT
KALABURAGI-585102

4.
THE COMMISSIONER
TOWN MUNICIPAL COUNCIL
SHAHABAD, TQ: CHITTAPUR
DIST:KALABURAGI-585102
…RESPONDENTS
(BY SRI.MALLIKARJUN SAHUKAR, AGA FOR R1 TO R3;
SRI.GOURISH S KHASHAMPUR ADV., FOR R4)

THIS WRIT PETITION IS FILED UNDER ARTICLES 226
AND 227 OF THE CONSTITUTION OF INDIA, PRAYING TO
ISSUE WRIT AS FOLLOWS: A) TO ISSUE WRIT OF MANDAMUS
DIRECTING THE RESPONDENT NO.1 TO 4 TO REGULARIZE THE
SERVICES OF THE PETITIONERS IN THE POST PRESENTLY
WORKING; B) TO ISSUE WRIT OR DIRECTION OR ORDER,
DEEMED FIT TO THIS HONOURABLE COURT, IN THE
CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE IN THE INTEREST OF JUSTICE.
THIS PETITION, COMING ON FOR PRELIMINARY HEARING
'B' GROUP, THIS DAY, ORDER WAS MADE THEREIN AS UNDER:
CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE VIJAYKUMAR A. PATIL

ORAL ORDER
This petition is filed seeking the following prayers:
“a) To issue writ of Mandamus directing the
respondent No.1 to 4 to regularize the services
of the petitioners in the post presently
working.
b) To issue writ or direction or order,
deemed fit to this Hon’ble Court, in the

- 3 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12309
WP No. 205581 of 2016


CNR: KAHC030062452016


circumstances of the case in the interest of
justice.”


2. Heard Sri.Ravindra Reddy, learned counsel
appearing for the petitioner, Sri.Mallikarjun Sahukar,
learned AGA appearing for respondent Nos.1 to 3,
Sri.Gourish S. Khashampur, learned counsel appearing for
respondent No.4 and meticulously perused the material
available on record.


3. Petitioner Nos.1 and 2 were appointed on
17.04.1998 and petitioner No.3 was appointed on
31.03.2000 as Pump Operator-Bill Collectors by
respondent No.4. It is to be noticed that the services of
the petitioners were terminated without conducting any
enquiry. Hence, they filed writ petitions in WP.Nos.26513-
26515/2003. This Court, vide order dated 22.03.2005
allowed the writ petitions and set aside the impugned
order terminating services of the petitioners by respondent
No.4. Consequently, the respondents were directed to
reinstate the petitioners into service. However, it is

- 4 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12309
WP No. 205581 of 2016


CNR: KAHC030062452016


observed that the petitioners shall not be entitled for any
back wages.


4. The material on record clearly indicates that the
petitioners have been working with the respondent-Town
Municipal Council from the date of their appointment till
this day without any discontinuation of their services. It is
averred that the services rendered by the petitioners are
essential services to the respondent-Town Municipal
Council. In other words, the services are perennial in
nature. The material on record further indicates that the
petitioners have been working in the same post from 1998
and 2000 respectively, till this day and their services have
not been regularized. Hence, the petitioners submitted
representations dated 01.08.2016, 02.08.2016 and
03.08.2016, produced at Annexures-L1 to L3 respectively,
wherein the petitioners are seeking to regularize their
services as permanent employees of respondent No.4-
Town Municipal Council.

- 5 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12309
WP No. 205581 of 2016


CNR: KAHC030062452016



5. It is trite law that, if the petitioners’
appointment is against the sanctioned post, if they have
worked for more than 10 years in the said post
uninterruptedly, and their services are essential to
respondent No.4, then there should not be any
impediment to regularize their services. The Hon'ble
Supreme Court in a recent decision in the case of Shripal
1
and Another v. Nagar Nigam, Ghaziabad at paragraph
Nos.3 to 10 and 14, 15 and 18 has held as under:
“3. The factual matrix leading up to the appeal
before us is as follows:
3.1. The Appellant Workmen claim to have
been engaged as Gardeners (Malis) in the
Horticulture Department of the Respondent
Employer, Ghaziabad Nagar Nigam, since the
year 1998 (in some instances, since 1999).
According to them, they continuously discharged
horticultural and maintenance duties— such as
planting trees, maintaining parks, and
beautifying public spaces—under the direct
supervision of the Respondent Employer. They
further allege that no formal appointment letters
were ever issued to them, and that they were
persistently denied minimum wages, weekly offs,
national holidays, and other statutory benefits.

1

2025 SCC OnLine SC 221

- 6 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12309
WP No. 205581 of 2016


CNR: KAHC030062452016


3.2. In 2004, the Appellant Workmen, along
with many other similarly situated employees,
raised an industrial dispute (C.B. Case No. 6 of
2004) before the Conciliation Officer at
Ghaziabad, seeking regularization of their
services and the requisite statutory benefits.
They contend that, upon learning of this
demand, the Respondent Employer began
delaying their salaries and subjected them to
adverse working conditions. Eventually, around
mid-July 2005, the services of numerous
workmen were allegedly terminated orally,
without any notice, written orders, or
retrenchment compensation.
3.3. Since the above termination took place
during the pendency of the conciliation
proceedings, the Appellant Workmen argue it
violated Section 6E of the U.P. Industrial
Disputes Act, 1947. Consequently, the State
Government referred the disputes concerning
both (i) regularization and (ii) legality of the
alleged termination, to the Labour Court,
Ghaziabad for adjudication.
3.4. The Labour Court proceeded to decide the
references vide two orders:
(i) Order dated 03.06.2011 : In numerous
adjudication cases (e.g., Adjudication Case
Nos. 448, 451, 467 of 2006, etc.), the
Labour Court passed awards holding the
terminations illegal for want of compliance
with Section 6N of the U.P. Industrial
Disputes Act, 1947, and directed
reinstatement with 30% back wages.
(ii) Order dated 11.10.2011 : However, in
about 41 other adjudication cases (e.g.,
Adjudication Case Nos. 269, 270, 272, etc.),
the Labour Court arrived at a contrary

- 7 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12309
WP No. 205581 of 2016


CNR: KAHC030062452016


conclusion, dismissing the claims on the
finding that the concerned workmen had not
been engaged directly by the Nagar Nigam
but rather through a contractor, and hence
had no enforceable right to reinstatement or
regularization against the Respondent
Employer.
3.5. Aggrieved by the adverse portion of the
awards (i.e., those granting reinstatement), the
Respondent Employer, Ghaziabad Nagar Nigam,
filed several writ petitions before the High Court
of Judicature at Allahabad, challenging the
Labour Court's findings. On the other hand, the
workmen whose claims were dismissed by the
other set of awards also approached the High
Court by filing their own writ petitions. All these
writ petitions were heard together, culminating
in the common judgment dated 01.03.2019,
which partly modified the Labour Court's
conclusions.
3.6. Through the impugned judgment, the High
Court held that while the Labour Court was
correct in exercising jurisdiction under the U.P.
Industrial Disputes Act (since municipalities
could be treated as “industry”), there remained
factual complexities as to whether the workmen
were genuinely on the rolls of the Nagar Nigam
or were provided by contractors. The High Court
also noted that the State Government had, by
notifications/orders, placed a ban on fresh
recruitments in Municipal Corporations, thereby
restricting direct appointments to any post.
Ultimately, the High Court partially modified the
relief granted, directing re-engagement of the
workmen on daily wages, with pay equivalent to
the minimum in the regular pay scale of
Gardeners, while allowing future consideration of
their regularization if permissible by law.

- 8 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12309
WP No. 205581 of 2016


CNR: KAHC030062452016


4. Both the Appellant Workmen and the
Respondent Employer have now approached this
Court by way of Special Leave Petitions. The
workmen primarily seek full reinstatement with
back wages and a direction to secure their
regularization, whereas the Respondent
Employer seeks to quash the modifications
ordered by the High Court on the ground that the
High Court exceeded its jurisdiction by granting
partial relief akin to regular employees, contrary
to constitutional provisions and the State's ban
on recruitment.
5. Learned counsel for the Appellant Workmen
made the following submissions:
I. Continuous Service & Comparable
Duties : The Appellant Workmen had
continuously discharged horticultural and
maintenance duties— like planting trees,
upkeep of public parks, and general
beautification—under the direct supervision
and control of the Respondent Employer for
periods often exceeding a decade. They
insist such longstanding, continuous work
parallels that of permanent Gardeners.
II. Direct Engagement & Wage
Disbursement : They aver that their
wages, though inadequate, were paid
directly by the Horticulture Department of
the Respondent Employer, nullifying the
Employer's claim of contractual hiring.
Muster rolls and internal notes are cited to
show direct employer-employee relations.
III. Illegal Termination : Alleging
violation of Sections 6E and 6N of the U.P.
Industrial Disputes Act, 1947, the Appellant
Workmen maintain their abrupt termination
in July 2005 (during pendency of

- 9 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12309
WP No. 205581 of 2016


CNR: KAHC030062452016


conciliation proceedings) was devoid of due
process and statutory payments, rendering
it patently illegal.
IV. Entitlement to Reinstatement &
Regularization : Given their long service
and the principle of “equal pay for equal
work,” the Appellant Workmen submit they
deserve full reinstatement with back wages
and a legitimate pathway to regularization,
as opposed to the partial relief of mere
daily-wage re-engagement prescribed by
the High Court.
6. On the other, the learned counsel for the
Respondent Employer, Ghaziabad Nagar Nigam
made the following submissions:
I . Compliance with Constitutional
Requirements : Emphasizing the
constitutional scheme of public
employment, it is urged that there was (and
remains) a ban on fresh recruitment in
Municipal Corporations, and no proper
selection process was ever followed to
appoint the Workmen on any sanctioned
posts.
II. No Direct Employer-Employee
Relationship : The Respondent Employer
contends that all horticulture work was
carried out through independent contractors
appointed via tender processes. It claims
any partial wage documentation cited by the
Workmen fails to establish direct
engagement.
III. Inapplicability of Regularization :
Relying on Secretary, State of Karnataka v.
1
Umadevi , it is asserted that no daily wager
can claim permanent absorption without

- 10 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12309
WP No. 205581 of 2016


CNR: KAHC030062452016


adherence to constitutional requirements
and availability of duly sanctioned
vacancies.
IV. Inadequate Proof of 240 Days'
Service : The Respondent Employer points
out that the Workmen did not convincingly
demonstrate they completed 240 days of
continuous work in any calendar year, thus
undermining the assertion that their
cessation from service was illegal.
V. Challenge to Modified Relief : Finally,
it argues that the High Court's direction to
pay minimum-scale wages and to consider
the Workmen for future regularization
oversteps legal boundaries, disregards the
recruitment ban, and fosters an
impermissible avenue of public
employment. The Respondent Employer,
therefore, seeks the quashing of the
impugned judgment.
7. Having heard the arguments and
submissions of the learned counsel for the
parties and having perused the record, this Court
is of the considered opinion that the nature of
engagement of the Appellant Workmen, the
admitted shortage of Gardeners, and the
circumstances under which their services were
brought to an end, merit closer scrutiny.
8. It is undisputed that, while the Appellant
Workmen were pressing for regularization and
proper wages through pending conciliation
proceedings, the Respondent Employer
proceeded to discontinue their services, without
issuing prior notice or granting retrenchment
compensation. At this juncture, it is to have a
look at the requirements of Section 6E of the

- 11 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12309
WP No. 205581 of 2016


CNR: KAHC030062452016


U.P. Industrial Disputes Act, 1947 which has
been reproduced hereunder:—
“6E. [Conditions of service, etc. to remain
unchanged in certain circumstances during
the pendency of proceedings. [Inserted by
U.P. Act No. 1 of 1957.]
(1) During the pendency of any
conciliation proceeding before a
Conciliation Officer or a Board or of any
proceeding before a Labour Court or
Tribunal in respect of an industrial
dispute, no employer shall, -
(a) in regard to any matter
connected with the dispute, alter, to
the prejudice of the workmen
concerned in such dispute, the
conditions of service applicable to
them immediately before the
commencement of such proceeding,
or
(b) for any misconduct connected
with the dispute, discharge or
punish, whether by dismissal or
otherwise any workman concerned
in such dispute save with the
express permission in writing of the
authority before which the
proceeding is pending.
(2) During the pendency of any such
proceeding in respect of an industrial
dispute, the employer may, in
accordance with the standing orders
applicable to a workman concerned in
such dispute, -

- 12 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12309
WP No. 205581 of 2016


CNR: KAHC030062452016


(a) alter, in regard to any matter not
connected with the dispute, the
conditions of service applicable to
that workman immediately before
the commencement of such
proceeding, or
(b) for any misconduct not
connected with the dispute,
discharge or punish, whether by
dismissal or otherwise:
Provided that no such workman
shall be discharged or dismissed,
unless he has been paid wages for
one month and an application has
been made by the employer to the
authority before which the
proceeding is pending for approval
of the action taken by the
employer.
(3) Notwithstanding anything contained
in sub-section (2) no employer shall
during the pendency of any such
proceeding in respect of an industrial
dispute, take any action against any
protected workman concerned in such
dispute, -
(a) by altering, to the prejudice of
such protected workman, the
conditions of service applicable to
him immediately before the
commencement of such proceeding,
or
(b) by discharging or punishing,
whether by dismissal or otherwise,
such protected workman, such with
the express permission in writing of

- 13 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12309
WP No. 205581 of 2016


CNR: KAHC030062452016


the authority before which the
proceeding is pending. Explanation.
- For the purposes of this sub-
section, a ‘protected workman’ in
relation to an establishment, means
a workman who, being an officer of
a registered trade union connected
with the establishment, is
recognized as such in accordance
with rules made in this behalf.
(4) In every establishment, the number
of workmen to be recognized as
protected workmen for the purposes of
sub-section (3) shall not exceed one per
cent of the total number of workmen
employed therein subject to a minimum
number of five protected workmen and a
maximum number of one hundred
protected workmen and for the aforesaid
purpose, the State Government may
make rules providing for the distribution
of such protected workmen among
various trade unions, if any, connected
with the establishment and the manner
in which they may be chosen and
recognized as protected workmen.
(5) Where an employer makes an
application to a Board, Labour Court or
Tribunal under the proviso to sub-section
(2) for approval of the action taken by
him, the authority concerned shall,
without delay, hear such application and
pass, as expeditiously as possible, such
order in relation thereto as it deems fit.”
9. On a plain reading of this section, we can
deduce that any unilateral alteration in service
conditions, including termination, is
impermissible during the pendency of such

- 14 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12309
WP No. 205581 of 2016


CNR: KAHC030062452016


proceedings unless prior approval is obtained
from the appropriate authority. The record in the
present case does not indicate that the
Respondent Employer ever sought or was
granted the requisite approval. Prima facie,
therefore, this conduct reflects a deliberate
attempt to circumvent the lawful claims of the
workmen, particularly when their dispute over
regularization and wages remained sub judice.
10. The Respondent Employer consistently
labelled the Appellant Workmen as casual
employees (or workers engaged through an
unnamed contractor), yet there is no material
proof of adherence to Section 6N of the U.P.
Industrial Disputes Act, 1947, which mandates a
proper notice or wages in lieu thereof as well as
retrenchment compensation. In this context,
whether an individual is classified as regular or
temporary is irrelevant as retrenchment
obligations under the Act must be met in all
cases attracting Section 6N. Any termination
thus effected without statutory safeguards
cannot be undertaken lightly.
14. The Respondent Employer places reliance
2
on Umadevi (supra) to contend that daily-wage
or temporary employees cannot claim permanent
absorption in the absence of statutory rules
providing such absorption. However, as
frequently reiterated, Uma Devi itself
distinguishes between appointments that are
“illegal” and those that are “irregular,” the latter
being eligible for regularization if they meet
certain conditions. More importantly, Uma Devi
cannot serve as a shield to justify exploitative
engagements persisting for years without the
Employer undertaking legitimate recruitment.
Given the record which shows no true
contractor-based arrangement and a consistent
need for permanent horticultural staff the alleged

- 15 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12309
WP No. 205581 of 2016


CNR: KAHC030062452016


asserted ban on fresh recruitment, though real,
cannot justify indefinite daily-wage status or
continued unfair practices.
15. It is manifest that the Appellant Workmen
continuously rendered their services over several
years, sometimes spanning more than a decade.
Even if certain muster rolls were not produced in
full, the Employer's failure to furnish such
records—despite directions to do so—allows an
adverse inference under well-established labour
jurisprudence. Indian labour law strongly
disfavors perpetual daily-wage or contractual
engagements in circumstances where the work is
permanent in nature. Morally and legally,
workers who fulfil ongoing municipal
requirements year after year cannot be
dismissed summarily as dispensable, particularly
in the absence of a genuine contractor
agreement. At this juncture, it would be
appropriate to recall the broader critique of
indefinite “temporary” employment practices as
done by a recent judgment of this court in Jaggo
3
v. Union of India in the following paragraphs:
“22. The pervasive misuse of temporary
employment contracts, as exemplified in this
case, reflects a broader systemic issue that
adversely affects workers' rights and job
security. In the private sector, the rise of the
gig economy has led to an increase in
precarious employment arrangements, often
characterized by lack of benefits, job
security, and fair treatment. Such practices
have been criticized for exploiting workers
and undermining labour standards.
Government institutions, entrusted with
upholding the principles of fairness and
justice, bear an even greater responsibility
to avoid such exploitative employment
practices. When public sector entities engage

- 16 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12309
WP No. 205581 of 2016


CNR: KAHC030062452016


in misuse of temporary contracts, it not only
mirrors the detrimental trends observed in
the gig economy but also sets a concerning
precedent that can erode public trust in
governmental operations.
………
25. It is a disconcerting reality that
temporary employees, particularly in
government institutions, often face
multifaceted forms of exploitation. While the
foundational purpose of temporary contracts
may have been to address short-term or
seasonal needs, they have increasingly
become a mechanism to evade long-term
obligations owed to employees. These
practices manifest in several ways:
• Misuse of “Temporary” Labels :
Employees engaged for work that is
essential, recurring, and integral to the
functioning of an institution are often
labelled as “temporary” or “contractual,”
even when their roles mirror those of
regular employees. Such misclassification
deprives workers of the dignity, security,
and benefits that regular employees are
entitled to, despite performing identical
tasks.
• Arbitrary Termination : Temporary
employees are frequently dismissed
without cause or notice, as seen in the
present case. This practice undermines
the principles of natural justice and
subjects workers to a state of constant
insecurity, regardless of the quality or
duration of their service.

- 17 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12309
WP No. 205581 of 2016


CNR: KAHC030062452016


• Lack of Career Progression : Temporary
employees often find themselves excluded
from opportunities for skill development,
promotions, or incremental pay raises.
They remain stagnant in their roles,
creating a systemic disparity between
them and their regular counterparts,
despite their contributions being equally
significant.
• Using Outsourcing as a Shield :
Institutions increasingly resort to
outsourcing roles performed by temporary
employees, effectively replacing one set of
exploited workers with another. This
practice not only perpetuates exploitation
but also demonstrates a deliberate effort
to bypass the obligation to offer regular
employment.
• Denial of Basic Rights and Benefits :
Temporary employees are often denied
fundamental benefits such as pension,
provident fund, health insurance, and paid
leave, even when their tenure spans
decades. This lack of social security
subjects them and their families to undue
hardship, especially in cases of illness,
retirement, or unforeseen circumstances.”
18. The impugned order of the High Court, to
the extent they confine the Appellant Workmen
to future daily-wage engagement without
continuity or meaningful back wages, is hereby
set aside with the following directions:
I. The discontinuation of the Appellant
Workmen's services, effected without
compliance with Section 6E and Section 6N
of the U.P. Industrial Disputes Act, 1947, is
declared illegal. All orders or

- 18 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12309
WP No. 205581 of 2016


CNR: KAHC030062452016


communications terminating their services
are quashed. In consequence, the Appellant
Workmen shall be treated as continuing in
service from the date of their termination,
for all purposes, including seniority and
continuity in service.
II. The Respondent Employer shall reinstate
the Appellant Workmen in their respective
posts (or posts akin to the duties they
previously performed) within four weeks
from the date of this judgment. Their entire
period of absence (from the date of
termination until actual reinstatement) shall
be counted for continuity of service and all
consequential benefits, such as seniority and
eligibility for promotions, if any.
III. Considering the length of service, the
Appellant Workmen shall be entitled to 50%
of the back wages from the date of their
discontinuation until their actual
reinstatement. The Respondent Employer
shall clear the aforesaid dues within three
months from the date of their reinstatement.
IV. The Respondent Employer is directed to
initiate a fair and transparent process for
regularizing the Appellant Workmen within
six months from the date of reinstatement,
duly considering the fact that they have
performed perennial municipal duties akin to
permanent posts. In assessing
regularization, the Employer shall not impose
educational or procedural criteria
retroactively if such requirements were
never applied to the Appellant Workmen or
to similarly situated regular employees in the
past. To the extent that sanctioned
vacancies for such duties exist or are
required, the Respondent Employer shall

- 19 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12309
WP No. 205581 of 2016


CNR: KAHC030062452016


expedite all necessary administrative
processes to ensure these longtime
employees are not indefinitely retained on
daily wages contrary to statutory and
equitable norms.”


6. The Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of
Neelima Srivastava v. State of Uttar Pradesh and
2
Others , considered the various judgments and ordered
for regularization. The Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case
3
of Jaggo versus Union of India at paragraph Nos.7 to
9, 11, 13, 16, 17, 19 to 27 has held as under:
“7. They urged the High Court to recognize
their long and continuous service, the nature of
their work, and the lack of any backdoor or
illegal entry. They highlighted that they had
functioned without any break, performed tasks
equivalent to regular employees, and had been
assigned duties essential to the regular upkeep,
cleanliness, and maintenance of the respondent's
offices. The High Court, after examining the
Tribunal's decision and the submissions
advanced, concluded that the petitioners before
it were part-time workers who had not been
appointed against sanctioned posts, nor had they
performed a sufficient duration of full-time
service to satisfy the criteria for regularization. It
relied on the principle laid down in Secretary,
3
State of Karnataka v. Uma Devi holding that the

2

(2021) 17 SCC 693
3

2024 SCC OnLine SC 3826

- 20 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12309
WP No. 205581 of 2016


CNR: KAHC030062452016


petitioners could not claim a vested right to be
absorbed or regularized without fulfilling the
requisite conditions. The High Court further
observed that the petitioners did not possess the
minimum educational qualifications ordinarily
required for regular appointments, and
additionally noted that the employer had
subsequently outsourced the relevant
housekeeping and maintenance activities.
Concluding that there was no legal basis to grant
the reliefs sought, the High Court dismissed the
writ petition. Aggrieved by this rejection, the
appellants have approached this Court by way of
these appeals.
8. On behalf of the appellants, the following
arguments have been advanced before us:
(i). Continuous and Substantive
Engagement: The appellants emphasize
their long, uninterrupted service spanning
well over a decade—and in some instances,
exceeding two decades. They argue that their
duties were neither sporadic nor project-
based but permanent and integral to the daily
functioning of the respondent's offices.
(ii). Nature of Duties: Their
responsibilities— such as cleaning, dusting,
gardening, and other maintenance tasks—
were not casual or peripheral. Instead, they
were central to ensuring a clean, orderly, and
functional work environment, effectively
aligning with roles typically associated with
regular posts.
(iii). Absence of Performance Issues:
Throughout their tenure, the appellants were
never issued any warning or adverse
remarks. They highlight that their work was
consistently satisfactory, and there was no

- 21 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12309
WP No. 205581 of 2016


CNR: KAHC030062452016


indication from the respondents that their
performance was not satisfactory or required
improvement.
(iv). Compliance with ‘Uma Devi’
Guidelines: The appellants assert that their
appointments were not “illegal” but at most
“irregular.” Drawing on the principles laid
down in Secretary, State of Karnataka v. Uma
4
Devi , they submit that long-serving
employees in irregular appointments—who
fulfil essential, sanctioned functions—are
entitled to consideration for regularization.
(v). Discrimination in Regularization: The
appellants point out that individuals with
fewer years of service or similar engagements
have been regularized. They contend that
denying them the same benefit, despite their
longer service and crucial role, constitutes
arbitrary and discriminatory treatment.
(vi). Irrelevance of Educational
Qualifications: The appellants reject the
respondents' reliance on formal educational
requirements, noting that such criteria were
never enforced earlier and that the nature of
their work does not inherently demand formal
schooling. They argue that retrospectively
imposing such qualifications is unjustified
given their proven capability over many
years.
(vii). Equity and Fairness: Ultimately, the
appellants submit that the High Court erred
by focusing too rigidly on their initial terms of
engagement and ignoring the substantive
reality of their long, integral service. They
maintain that fairness, equity, and
established judicial principles call for their
regularization rather than abrupt termination

- 22 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12309
WP No. 205581 of 2016


CNR: KAHC030062452016


9. On the other hand, the following primary
arguments have been advanced before us on
behalf of the Respondents:
(i). Nature of Engagement: The
respondents maintain that the appellants
were engaged purely on a part-time,
contractual basis, limited to a few hours a
day, and that their work was never intended
to be permanent or full-time.
(ii). Absence of Sanctioned Posts: They
assert that the appellants were not appointed
against any sanctioned posts. According to
the respondents, without sanctioned
vacancies, there can be no question of
regularization or absorption into the
permanent workforce.
(iii). Non-Compliance with ‘Uma Devi’
Criteria: Relying heavily on Secretary, State
of Karnataka v. Uma Devi (supra), the
respondents argue that the appellants do not
meet the conditions necessary for
regularization. They emphasize that merely
serving a long period on a part-time or ad-
hoc basis does not create a right to be
regularized.
(iv). Educational Qualifications: The
respondents contend that even if the
appellants were to be considered for regular
appointments, they do not possess the
minimum educational qualifications mandated
for regular recruitment. This, in their view,
disqualifies the appellants from being
absorbed into regular service.
(v). Outsourcing as a Legitimate Policy
Decision: The respondents point out that
they have chosen to outsource the relevant

- 23 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12309
WP No. 205581 of 2016


CNR: KAHC030062452016


housekeeping and maintenance work to a
private agency. This, they argue, is a
legitimate administrative policy decision
aimed at improving efficiency and cannot be
interfered with by the courts.
(vi). No Fundamental Right to
Regularization: Finally, the respondents
underscore that no employee, merely by
virtue of long-standing temporary or part-
time engagement, acquires a vested right to
be regularized. They maintain that the
appellants' claims are devoid of any legal
entitlement and that the High Court was
correct in dismissing their petition.
11. The appellants, throughout their tenure,
were engaged in performing essential duties that
were indispensable to the day-to-day functioning
of the offices of the Central Water Commission
(CWC). Applicant Nos. 1, 2, and 3, as Safaiwalis,
were responsible for maintaining hygiene,
cleanliness, and a conducive working
environment within the office premises. Their
duties involved sweeping, dusting, and cleaning
of floors, workstations, and common areas—a set
of responsibilities that directly contributed to the
basic operational functionality of the CWC.
Applicant No. 5, in the role of a Khallasi (with
additional functions akin to those of a Mali), was
entrusted with critical maintenance tasks,
including gardening, upkeep of outdoor
premises, and ensuring orderly surroundings.
13. The claim by the respondents that these
were not regular posts lacks merit, as the nature
of the work performed by the appellants was
perennial and fundamental to the functioning of
the offices. The recurring nature of these duties
necessitates their classification as regular posts,
irrespective of how their initial engagements

- 24 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12309
WP No. 205581 of 2016


CNR: KAHC030062452016


were labelled. It is also noteworthy that
subsequent outsourcing of these same tasks to
private agencies after the appellants' termination
demonstrates the inherent need for these
services. This act of outsourcing, which
effectively replaced one set of workers with
another, further underscores that the work in
question was neither temporary nor occasional.
16. The appellants' consistent performance
over their long tenures further solidifies their
claim for regularization. At no point during their
engagement did the respondents raise any issues
regarding their competence or performance. On
the contrary, their services were extended
repeatedly over the years, and their
remuneration, though minimal, was
incrementally increased which was an implicit
acknowledgment of their satisfactory
performance. The respondents' belated plea of
alleged unsatisfactory service appears to be an
afterthought and lacks credibility.
17. As for the argument relating to
educational qualifications, we find it untenable in
the present context. The nature of duties the
appellants performed—cleaning, sweeping,
dusting, and gardening—does not inherently
mandate formal educational prerequisites. It
would be unjust to rely on educational criteria
that were never central to their engagement or
the performance of their duties for decades.
Moreover, the respondents themselves have, by
their conduct, shown that such criteria were not
strictly enforced in other cases of regularization.
The appellants' long-standing satisfactory
performance itself attests to their capability to
discharge these functions, making rigid
insistence on formal educational requirements an
unreasonable hurdle.

- 25 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12309
WP No. 205581 of 2016


CNR: KAHC030062452016


19. It is evident from the foregoing that the
appellants' roles were not only essential but also
indistinguishable from those of regular
employees. Their sustained contributions over
extended periods, coupled with absence of any
adverse record, warrant equitable treatment and
regularization of their services. Denial of this
benefit, followed by their arbitrary termination,
amounts to manifest injustice and must be
rectified.
20. It is well established that the decision in
Uma Devi (supra) does not intend to penalize
employees who have rendered long years of
service fulfilling ongoing and necessary functions
of the State or its instrumentalities. The said
judgment sought to prevent backdoor entries
and illegal appointments that circumvent
constitutional requirements. However, where
appointments were not illegal but possibly
“irregular,” and where employees had served
continuously against the backdrop of sanctioned
functions for a considerable period, the need for
a fair and humane resolution becomes
paramount. Prolonged, continuous, and
unblemished service performing tasks inherently
required on a regular basis can, over the time,
transform what was initially ad-hoc or temporary
into a scenario demanding fair regularization. In
a recent judgment of this Court in Vinod Kumar
5
v. Union of India , it was held that held that
procedural formalities cannot be used to deny
regularization of service to an employee whose
appointment was termed “temporary” but has
performed the same duties as performed by the
regular employee over a considerable period in
the capacity of the regular employee. The
relevant paras of this judgment have been
reproduced below:

- 26 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12309
WP No. 205581 of 2016


CNR: KAHC030062452016


“6. The application of the judgment in Uma
Devi (supra) by the High Court does not fit
squarely with the facts at hand, given the
specific circumstances under which the
appellants were employed and have
continued their service. The reliance on
procedural formalities at the outset cannot be
used to perpetually deny substantive rights
that have accrued over a considerable period
through continuous service. Their promotion
was based on a specific notification for
vacancies and a subsequent circular, followed
by a selection process involving written tests
and interviews, which distinguishes their case
from the appointments through back door
entry as discussed in the case of Uma Devi
(supra).
7. The judgment in the case Uma Devi
(supra) also distinguished between “irregular”
and “illegal” appointments underscoring the
importance of considering certain
appointments even if were not made strictly
in accordance with the prescribed Rules and
Procedure, cannot be said to have been made
illegally if they had followed the procedures of
regular appointments such as conduct of
written examinations or interviews as in the
present case…”
21. The High Court placed undue emphasis on
the initial label of the appellants' engagements
and the outsourcing decision taken after their
dismissal. Courts must look beyond the surface
labels and consider the realities of employment :
continuous, long-term service, indispensable
duties, and absence of any mala fide or
illegalities in their appointments. In that light,
refusing regularization simply because their
original terms did not explicitly state so, or
because an outsourcing policy was belatedly

- 27 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12309
WP No. 205581 of 2016


CNR: KAHC030062452016


introduced, would be contrary to principles of
fairness and equity.
22. The pervasive misuse of temporary
employment contracts, as exemplified in this
case, reflects a broader systemic issue that
adversely affects workers' rights and job
security. In the private sector, the rise of the gig
economy has led to an increase in precarious
employment arrangements, often characterized
by lack of benefits, job security, and fair
treatment. Such practices have been criticized
for exploiting workers and undermining labour
standards. Government institutions, entrusted
with upholding the principles of fairness and
justice, bear an even greater responsibility to
avoid such exploitative employment practices.
When public sector entities engage in misuse of
temporary contracts, it not only mirrors the
detrimental trends observed in the gig economy
but also sets a concerning precedent that can
erode public trust in governmental operations.
23. The International Labour Organization
(ILO), of which India is a founding member, has
consistently advocated for employment stability
and the fair treatment of workers. The ILO's
6
Multinational Enterprises Declaration
encourages companies to provide stable
employment and to observe obligations
concerning employment stability and social
security. It emphasizes that enterprises should
assume a leading role in promoting employment
security, particularly in contexts where job
discontinuation could exacerbate long-term
unemployment.
24. The landmark judgment of the United
State in the case of Vizcaino v. Microsoft
7
Corporation serves as a pertinent example from
the private sector, illustrating the consequences

- 28 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12309
WP No. 205581 of 2016


CNR: KAHC030062452016


of misclassifying employees to circumvent
providing benefits. In this case, Microsoft
classified certain workers as independent
contractors, thereby denying them employee
benefits. The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth
Circuit determined that these workers were, in
fact, common-law employees and were entitled
to the same benefits as regular employees. The
Court noted that large Corporations have
increasingly adopted the practice of hiring
temporary employees or independent contractors
as a means of avoiding payment of employee
benefits, thereby increasing their profits. This
judgment underscores the principle that the
nature of the work performed, rather than the
label assigned to the worker, should determine
employment status and the corresponding rights
and benefits. It highlights the judiciary's role in
rectifying such misclassifications and ensuring
that workers receive fair treatment.
25. It is a disconcerting reality that temporary
employees, particularly in government
institutions, often face multifaceted forms of
exploitation. While the foundational purpose of
temporary contracts may have been to address
short-term or seasonal needs, they have
increasingly become a mechanism to evade long-
term obligations owed to employees. These
practices manifest in several ways:
• Misuse of “Temporary” Labels:
Employees engaged for work that is essential,
recurring, and integral to the functioning of
an institution are often labeled as
“temporary” or “contractual,” even when their
roles mirror those of regular employees. Such
misclassification deprives workers of the
dignity, security, and benefits that regular
employees are entitled to, despite performing
identical tasks.

- 29 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12309
WP No. 205581 of 2016


CNR: KAHC030062452016


• Arbitrary Termination: Temporary
employees are frequently dismissed without
cause or notice, as seen in the present case.
This practice undermines the principles of
natural justice and subjects workers to a
state of constant insecurity, regardless of the
quality or duration of their service.
• Lack of Career Progression: Temporary
employees often find themselves excluded
from opportunities for skill development,
promotions, or incremental pay raises. They
remain stagnant in their roles, creating a
systemic disparity between them and their
regular counterparts, despite their
contributions being equally significant.
• Using Outsourcing as a Shield:
Institutions increasingly resort to outsourcing
roles performed by temporary employees,
effectively replacing one set of exploited
workers with another. This practice not only
perpetuates exploitation but also
demonstrates a deliberate effort to bypass
the obligation to offer regular employment.
• Denial of Basic Rights and Benefits:
Temporary employees are often denied
fundamental benefits such as pension,
provident fund, health insurance, and paid
leave, even when their tenure spans decades.
This lack of social security subjects them and
their families to undue hardship, especially in
cases of illness, retirement, or unforeseen
circumstances.
26. While the judgment in Uma Devi (supra)
sought to curtail the practice of backdoor entries
and ensure appointments adhered to
constitutional principles, it is regrettable that its
principles are often misinterpreted or misapplied

- 30 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12309
WP No. 205581 of 2016


CNR: KAHC030062452016


to deny legitimate claims of long-serving
employees. This judgment aimed to distinguish
between “illegal” and “irregular” appointments. It
categorically held that employees in irregular
appointments, who were engaged in duly
sanctioned posts and had served continuously for
more than ten years, should be considered for
regularization as a one-time measure. However,
the laudable intent of the judgment is being
subverted when institutions rely on its dicta to
indiscriminately reject the claims of employees,
even in cases where their appointments are not
illegal, but merely lack adherence to procedural
formalities. Government departments often cite
the judgment in Uma Devi (supra) to argue that
no vested right to regularization exists for
temporary employees, overlooking the
judgment's explicit acknowledgment of cases
where regularization is appropriate. This
selective application distorts the judgment's
spirit and purpose, effectively weaponizing it
against employees who have rendered
indispensable services over decades.
27. In light of these considerations, in our
opinion, it is imperative for government
departments to lead by example in providing fair
and stable employment. Engaging workers on a
temporary basis for extended periods, especially
when their roles are integral to the organization's
functioning, not only contravenes international
labour standards but also exposes the
organization to legal challenges and undermines
employee morale. By ensuring fair employment
practices, government institutions can reduce the
burden of unnecessary litigation, promote job
security, and uphold the principles of justice and
fairness that they are meant to embody. This
approach aligns with international standards and
sets a positive precedent for the private sector to

- 31 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12309
WP No. 205581 of 2016


CNR: KAHC030062452016


follow, thereby contributing to the overall
betterment of labour practices in the country.”


7. Considering the aforesaid enunciation of the law
laid down by the Hon'ble Supreme Court, I am of the
considered view that respondents are required to consider
the petitioners’ prayer for regularization of their services,
keeping in mind the enunciation of law laid down by the
Hon'ble Supreme Court referred supra . Hence, I proceed
to pass the following:
ORDER
i. The writ petition is allowed .
ii. The respondent No.4 is directed to
consider the petitioners’ representations at
Annexures-L1 to L3 and if found eligible,
shall send a proposal immediately to
respondent Nos.2 and 3 for regularization
of their sevices and if such proposal is
forwarded by respondent No.4, respondent
Nos.2 and 3 shall consider the same and

- 32 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12309
WP No. 205581 of 2016


CNR: KAHC030062452016


take appropriate decision in accordance
with law.
iii. The consideration by respondent
No.4 shall be within a period of 3 months
from the date of receipt of a copy of this
order. If respondent No.4 forwards the
proposal for regularization to respondent
Nos.2 and 3, they shall take decision
within a period of 3 months from the date
of such proposal.
No order as to costs.



Sd/-
(VIJAYKUMAR A. PATIL)
JUDGE


ABK
List No.: 1 Sl No.: 38