Jahir Ussain vs U.A.Rahman Batcha

Court
Madras High Court

CMA(MD) No. 1277 of 2026
BEFORE THE MADURAI BENCH OF MADRAS HIGH COURT
DATED: 30-09-2026
CORAM
THE HON'BLE MR JUSTICE G.R.SWAMINATHAN
AND
THE HON'BLE MRS.JUSTICE M.D.SUMATHI
CMA(MD) No. 1277 of 2026
CNR:{HCMD010329182026}
and
CMP(MD)No.12251 of 2026
Jahir Ussain S/o.Kaniyar Mohamed Kasim,
Door No.260, Keezha Theru,
Chakkarappalli Village,
Papanasam Taluk,Thanjavur District.
..Petitioner(s)
Vs
1. U.A.Rahman Batcha S/o.Abdul Jameel,
Door No.9, High Road,
Mydeen Nagar, Ayyampettai,
Papanasam Taluk, Thanjavur District.
2. Mehraj Nisha W/o.Mohamed Fharuk,
Door No.88. Jinnaa Street,
Chakkarappalli Village,
Papanasam Taluk, Thanjavur District.
Mumthaj Begum (Died).
3. Imthiyaz Ahamed, S/o.Rahman Batcha,
Door No.9, High Road, Mydeen Nagar,
Ayyampettai, Papanasam Taluk,
Thanjavur District.
4. Rabiyathul Basiriya, W/o.Rahman Batcha,
Door No.9, High Road, Mydeen Nagar,
Ayyampettai, Papanasam Taluk,
Thanjavur District.
__________
Page1 of 12
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 01/10/2026 04:08:46 pm )

CMA(MD) No. 1277 of 2026
5. Sirajudeen Muneera,
W/o.Mohamed Kasim Sha,
Door No.7/8, High Road, Mydeen Nagar,
Ayyampettai, Papanasam Taluk,
Thanjavur District.
6. U.A.Hawva Kani, W/o.Ullu Mohamed Basheer,
Door No.9, High Road, Mydeen Nagar,
Ayyampettai, Papanasam Taluk,
Thanjavur District.
7. Afrin D/o.Mohamed Fharuk,
Door No.88, Jinnaa Street,
Chakkarappalli Village,
Papanasam Taluk,Thanjavur District.
Mohamed Ibrahim (Died)
8. Habeeb Ammal D/o.Mohamed Batcha,
Door No.72, Jinnaa Street,
Chakkarappalli Village, Papanasam Taluk,
Thanjavur District.
9. Rahamathunnisa, D/o.Mohamed Batcha,
Door No.72, Jinnaa Street,
Chakkarappalli Village, Papanasam Taluk,Jn
Thanjavur District.
10. Mohamed Basheer,
S/o.Kaniyar Mohamed Kasim,
Door No.260, Keezha Theru,
Chakkarappalli Village, Papanasam Taluk,
Thanjavur District.
11. Sabeer Ahamed,
S/o.Kaniyar Mohamed Kasim,
Door No.260, Keezha Theru,
Chakkarappalli Village, Papanasam Taluk,
Thanjavur District.
12. Ameerjohn, D/o.Kaniyar Mohamed Kasim,
Door No.260, Keezha Theru,
Chakkarappalli Village, Papanasam Taluk,
Thanjavur District.
__________
Page2 of 12
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 01/10/2026 04:08:46 pm )

CMA(MD) No. 1277 of 2026
13. Sobia, W/o.Kaniyar Mohamed Kasim, Door
No.260, Keezha Theru, Chakkarappalli Village,
Papanasam Taluk, Thanjavur District.
14. Fathima Yaswin, W/o.Sabeer Ahamed,
Door No.260, Keezha Theru, Chakkarappalli
Village, Papanasam Taluk, Thanjavur District.
15. The Sub Registrar, Sub Registrar Office,
Ayyampettai.
16. The Joint Sub Registrar No.I
District Registrar Office,
Sivagangai Poonga, Thanjavur.
17. The District Collector,
District Collector Office,
Thanjavur.
..Respondent(s)
Prayer : Civil Miscellaneous Appeal filed U/s 75(2) of the Provincial
Insolvency Act, 1920, to call for the records and set aside the order and
decretal order dated 18.12.2025 passed in I.P. No. 4 of 2016 on the file of II
Additional District and Sessions Court, Thanjavur and allow the present Civil
Miscellaneous Appeal with costs throughout and thus render justice.
For Petitioner(s): Ms.Janaki Devi V
for Mr.Shyllappakalyan
For Respondent(s): Mr.S.Venkatesan for R1, R4 To R6
JUDGMENT
(By G.R.Swaminathan J.)
Challenge in this appeal is to the order dated 18.12.2025 made in IP
No.4 of 2016 passed by the learned II Additional District and Sessions Judge,
Thanjavur.
__________
Page3 of 12
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 01/10/2026 04:08:46 pm )

CMA(MD) No. 1277 of 2026
2.The learned counsel appearing for the appellant made a very short
point. She argued that unless the debtor commits any one or more acts of
insolvency catalogued in Section 6 of the Provincial Insolvency Act, 1920, no
petition by a creditor under Section 9 of the Act would lie.
3.The respondents 1 to 9 herein filed I.P No.4 of 2016 before the Court
below to declare the appellant and respondents 10 to 14 herein as insolvent
persons. The first and second petitioner in the I.P examined themselves as
PW.1 and PW.2. Exs.A1 to A23 were marked. The appellant examined
himself as RW.1. After hearing both the parties, the court below vide order
dated 18.12.2025 allowed the petition and declared the respondents 1 to 6 in
the I.P as insolvents. The properties mentioned in the petition were directed
to be sold in public auction. Repayment was to be made from out of the sale
proceeds. Assailing the said order, this appeal has been filed.
4.Law provides for remedies through legal proceedings. To enforce
one’s civil rights, one can institute suits. Section 9 of the CPC states that the
courts shall have jurisdiction to try all suits of a civil nature excepting suits of
which their cognisance is expressly or impliedly barred. Section 26 states
that every suit shall be instituted by the presentation of a plaint. Any suit
seeking a civil remedy can be straightaway instituted before the court of
competent jurisdiction. Of course, subject to the provisions laid down in CPC.
But remedy sought through a petition would be on a different footing. It has to
__________
Page4 of 12
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 01/10/2026 04:08:46 pm )

CMA(MD) No. 1277 of 2026
be statute-specific. It has to trace the particular provision under which it is
filed. It has to conform to the parameters and criteria set out in the Section
concerned. If the conditions prescribed in the Section are not present, the
petition will not be maintainable.
5.The Provincial Insolvency Act, 1920 contemplates filing of petitions
both by the creditor as well as the debtor. A debtor’s petition to declare
himself insolvent is filed under Section 10 of the said Act. A creditor’s
petition is filed under Section 9. The case on hand arises out of a creditor’s
petition. But the petition has been filed under Section 10. The Registry of the
court below ought to have returned the petition straightaway and called upon
the counsel to make the necessary correction. Every petition should be filed
under the correct provision of law. But wrong quoting or misquoting cannot
render the petition as not maintainable. The principle that we invoke in
administrative law can as well be applied to the case on hand. We can take it
that the petition filed by the creditors/contesting respondents herein was filed
under Section 9(1) of the Provincial Insolvency Act, 1920.
6.The said provision is as follows :
“ 9. Conditions on which creditor may petition
(1) A creditor shall not be entitled to present an insolvency petition
against a debtor unless
(a) the debt owing by the debtor to the creditor, or, if two or more
__________
Page5 of 12
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 01/10/2026 04:08:46 pm )

CMA(MD) No. 1277 of 2026
creditors join in the petition, the aggregate amount of debts owing
to such creditors, amounts to five hundred rupees, and
(b) the debt is a liquidated sum payable either immediately or at
some certain future time, and
(c) the act of insolvency on which the petition is grounded has
occurred within three months before the presentation of the
petition:
[Provided that where the said period of three months referred to in
clause (c)expires on a day when the Court is closed, the
insolvency petition may be presented on the day on which the
Court re-opens.] [Added by Act 3 of 1950, Section 6 (w.e.f.
18.2.1950).]”

The expression employed in the above provision is “and”. It is conjunctive. It
means that all the three conditions set out in (a), (b) and (c) must be present.
The term “act of insolvency” is defined in Section 6(1) of the Act. It reads as
follows :
“6. Acts of insolvency
(1)A debtor commits an act of insolvency in each of the following
cases, namely:
(a) if, in India or elsewhere, he makes a transfer of all or
substantially all his property to a third person for the benefit of his
creditors generally;
(b) if, in India or elsewhere, he makes a transfer of his property or of
any part thereof with intent to defeat or delay his creditors;
(c)if, in India or elsewhere, he makes any transfer of his property, or
__________
Page6 of 12
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 01/10/2026 04:08:46 pm )

CMA(MD) No. 1277 of 2026
of any part thereof, which would, under this or any other enactment
for the time being in force, be void as fraudulent preference if he
were adjudged an insolvent;
(d) if, with intent to defeat or delay his creditors,
(i) he departs or remains out of the territories to which this Act
extends;
(ii) he departs from his dwelling-house or usual place of business or
otherwise absents himself,
(iii) he secludes himself so as to deprive his creditors of the means of
communicating with him;
(e) if any of his property has been sold in execution of the decree of
any Court for the payment of money;
(f) if he petitions to be adjudged an insolvent under the provisions of
this Act;
(g) if he gives notice to any of his creditors that he has suspended, or
that he is about to suspend, payment of his debts; or
(h) if he is imprisoned in execution of the decree of any Court for the
payment of money.”
Unless the debtor had committed an act of insolvency as defined above, a
creditor’s petition under Section 9(1) will not lie. The phrase “a creditor shall
not be entitled to present” and the word “unless” are highly significant. The
conditions set out in Section 9(1) of the Act are mandatory. If they are not
present, no petition can be filed.
7.We called upon the learned counsel for the contesting respondents to
clarify as to which act of insolvency is being attributed to the debtor. The
__________
Page7 of 12
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 01/10/2026 04:08:46 pm )

CMA(MD) No. 1277 of 2026
learned counsel responded that the debtor was attempting to alienate his
properties.
8.Section 6(a) to (c) employ the expression “makes a transfer”. It
means that the debtor must have transferred his property. Section 6 is not
about attempts to transfer of property. It is not even about agreement to
transfer the property. The High Court of Andhra Pradesh in Vadamala
Sanjeevi Reddy v. K.Ellappa Reddy and anr (1966 SCC OnLine AP 9) held
that Section 6(b) applies only when a debtor transfers his property with the
view to defeat or delay all the creditors. A learned Judge of this Court in
Chellathurai Nadar v. Ramaswami Pillai, 1995 SCC OnLine Mad 260 held
that execution of an agreement for sale cannot be held to be sufficient to
attract the provisions of Section 6 of the Provincial Insolvency Act, 1920. It is
only if the debtor conveys a right which he had in the property, in favour of
another, that too with the intention of defeating the interests of his creditors,
Section 6 of the Provincial Insolvency Act can be attracted.
9.Attempting to transfer one’s property to defeat the interest of the
creditors can be a good ground for attaching the property before judgment
under Order 38 of CPC. However, it is not an act of insolvency within the
meaning of Section 6 of the Provincial Insolvency Act, 1920.
__________
Page8 of 12
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 01/10/2026 04:08:46 pm )

CMA(MD) No. 1277 of 2026
10.The contesting respondents herein have portrayed the appellant and
others as flight-risk. The appellant herein had been present before the court
below throughout and conducted the proceedings. When we sought his
appearance, he readily complied with our direction.
11.The appellant and the respondents 10 to 14 have not committed any
act of insolvency. Hence, no petition under Section 9 of the Act could have
been filed against them. But the court below went by the fact that there were
financial transaction between the parties and that the appellant on his behalf
and on behalf of R10 to R14 herein having received amounts from the
petitioning-creditors failed to repay the same. Failure to repay by itself will
not constitute an act of insolvency. It can be a cause of action for instituting a
money suit. Cause of action is existence of those facts which give a party a
right to judicial remedy (P.Ramanatha Aiyar’s Advanced Law Lexicon). Cause
of action is the ground based on which the superstructure of legal action is
erected. What can be a cause of action for maintaining a money suit may not
be a cause of action for initiating insolvency proceedings. The trial Judge
failed to keep in view this fundamental point. The learned Judge ought to
have verified if the petition filed under Section 9 of the Provincial Insolvency
Act, 1920 fulfilled the conditions precedent set out therein. Even a cursory
perusal would have revealed that they are absent. On this sole ground, we
set aside the impugned order and allow this appeal.
__________
Page9 of 12
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 01/10/2026 04:08:46 pm )

CMA(MD) No. 1277 of 2026
12.The learned counsel for the contesting respondents suggested that
the impugned order could be set aside only in respect of the appellant. We
disagree. When the petition itself is incompetent, it has to go lock, stock and
barrel. It cannot be allowed to survive against the respondents 10 to 14 also.
We cannot permit the enforcement of the impugned order selectively. Once
an order is found to be without jurisdiction, it goes to the root of the matter and
it has to go as a whole and against everyone.
13.We wanted to explore the possibilities of settlement. We summoned
Sri U.A.Rahman Batcha as well as Jahir Ussain. The appellant admitted
before us that he had borrowed a sum of Rs.15,00,000/- from the petitioning
creditors. Rahman Batcha on the other hand claimed that what was received
was multiple times higher. We are not in a position to go into the factual
controversy. The parties are Muslims. Quran forbids collection or levy of
interest. The parties have therefore crafted the contracts between them in a
peculiar manner. A simple loan is styled as an investment. The parties are
probably labouring under the fond impression that they can thus pull the wool
over the eyes of the Almighty. Subterfuges apart, we have no doubt in our
minds that the appellant owes substantial amounts to the contesting
respondents herein. He has technically succeeded before us. But we hope
better sense prevails. Needless to say, the petitioning-creditors herein are at
liberty to pursue any remedy open to them in law.
__________
Page10 of 12
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 01/10/2026 04:08:46 pm )

CMA(MD) No. 1277 of 2026
14.For the foregoing reasons, this civil miscellaneous appeal is allowed.
No costs. Connected miscellaneous petition is closed.
(G.R.S.,J.) (M.D.S.,J.)
30-09-2026
Index: Yes/No
Speaking/Non-speaking order
Neutral Citation: Yes/No
SKM
To
1. The Sub Registrar,
Sub Registrar Office,
Ayyampettai.
2. The Joint Sub Registrar No.I
District Registrar Office,
Sivagangai Poonga,
Thanjavur.
3. The District Collector,
District Collector Office,
Thanjavur.
__________
Page11 of 12
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 01/10/2026 04:08:46 pm )

CMA(MD) No. 1277 of 2026
G.R.SWAMINATHAN, J.
AND
M.D.SUMATHI, J.
SKM
CMA(MD) No. 1277 of 2026
30-09-2026
__________
Page12 of 12
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 01/10/2026 04:08:46 pm )