Nirmala Bai Devidas Chavhan vs The State Of Maharashtra And Ors. Etc.

Court
Supreme Court

2026 INSC 787
NON-REPORTABLE

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION


CRIMINAL APPEAL NOS.502-507 OF 2023


NIRMALA BAI DEVIDAS
CHAVHAN

… APPELLANT(S)

VERSUS

STATE OF MAHARASHTRA
AND OTHERS ETC.

… RESPONDENT(S)

WITH

CRIMINAL APPEAL NOS.508-513 OF 2023


J U D G M E N T


AUGUSTINE GEORGE MASIH, J.

1. This judgment shall decide Criminal Appeal
Nos. 502-507 of 2023, preferred by the
informant, and Criminal Appeal Nos. 508-513 of
2023, preferred by the State of Maharashtra,
both of which arise out of the common judgment
Signature Not Verified
dated 02.02.2022 (“Impugned Judgment”)
Digitally signed by
SOURAV PAL
Date: 2026.08.03
17:47:57 IST
Reason:
passed by the High Court of Judicature at
Crl.A. Nos.502-507/2023 etc. Page 1 of 38

Bombay, Nagpur Bench (“High Court”), in
Criminal Appeal Nos. 559, 560, 561, 562, 570
and 576 of 2018. By Impugned Judgment, the
High Court, upon a reappreciation of the entire
evidence, reversed the judgment of conviction
and order of sentence dated 10.08.2018 passed
by the In-charge Additional Sessions Judge,
Mangrulpir (Camp at Washim) (“trial court”), in
Sessions Trial No. 44 of 2014, whereby twenty
of the accused had been convicted and
sentenced to imprisonment for life, the High
Court allowed all six appeals and acquitted
them of the offences charged.

2. The prosecution case has its genesis in an
incident alleged to have occurred on
18.03.2014, the day of the Holi festival, at about
4:00 p.m., at Naik Nagar, Manora, District
Washim, within the jurisdiction of Police Station
Manora. On the same day, at 17:15 hours, First
Information Report No. 38 of 2014 (“FIR”) came
to be registered upon the oral report of Nirmala
Bai Devidas Chavhan, the Appellant in the first
set of appeals and the mother of the deceased
Crl.A. Nos.502-507/2023 etc. Page 2 of 38

Avinash, for offences punishable under Sections
302, 307, 147, 148 and 149 of the Indian Penal
Code, 1860 (“IPC”), read with Section 135 of the
Bombay Police Act, 1951.

3. It is the case of the prosecution that at about
1:00 p.m. on that day the deceased Avinash had
gone to Somnath Nagar to seek the blessings of
his grandmother, where the accused Janardhan
(A-1) and Milind (A-22) were playing a DJ and
Avinash asked the DJ to be stopped as his
grandmother was unwell which culminated into
a quarrel, in the course of which, according to
the prosecution witnesses, reference was made
to the Zilla Parishad election of the year 2013
and a threat to kill was held out.


4. At about 4:00 p.m. on the same day, the
deceased, along with his father Devidas (PW-
10), his brother Mukesh (PW-2) and his cousin
Ganesh (PW-13), returned to Naik Nagar, which
is around some 2 to 2.5 kilometres distant from
Somnath Nagar, in a car. As the four alighted in
front of their house, the accused persons are
alleged to have caught hold of them and dragged
Crl.A. Nos.502-507/2023 etc. Page 3 of 38

them outside the house of A-1, at a distance of
about 150 feet, where they were assaulted with
iron pipes, an iron bar and wooden planks,
some of the accused held the victims and others
exhorted. Avinash died at the spot and others
i.e. PW-2, PW-10 and PW-13 sustained injuries,
principally upon the head. The informant
Nirmalabai (PW-19), who deposed to having
witnessed the occurrence from the porch of her
house, named 21 persons in her report and
attributed to each of them the weapon carried,
the victim held and the part of the body
assaulted.

5. The investigation was thereafter carried out in
the normal course. The spot panchanama was
drawn between 17:30 and 18:15 hours upon the
spot being shown by PW-19, and blood-mixed
soil and a blood-stained stone were seized. The
inquest upon the body of the deceased was held
at 18:55 hours. The postmortem examination
was conducted on 19.03.2014 by Dr. Gote (PW-
21), who found a laceration measuring 2 x 4 cm
over the scalp upon the head of the deceased
Crl.A. Nos.502-507/2023 etc. Page 4 of 38

with a fracture of the frontal bone and opined
the cause of death to be haemorrhage due to
head injury. The three injured were treated at
the Rural Hospital, Manora, were referred to the
Government Medical College, Akola, and were
thereafter shifted to Icon Hospital, Akola. All the
accused came to be arrested in due course.
Memorandum and recovery panchanamas
under Section 27 of the Indian Evidence Act,
1872 were recorded and iron pipes and wooden
planks came to be recovered at the instance of
some of the accused.

6. The statements of the eye-witnesses PW-9 and
PW-14 were recorded on 20.03.2014, those of
the injured PW-2 and PW-13 on 24.03.2014 and
that of PW-10 on 28.03.2014, also recorded
after a certification of fitness was given by the
treating doctor. The case property was
despatched to the Chemical Analyser, Amravati
on 20.05.2014, which was declined on that day
for the reason that the lac seals were broken,
and was accepted on 22.05.2014 after resealing
by doctors and by police officers, of which no
Crl.A. Nos.502-507/2023 etc. Page 5 of 38

record was made.

7. After completion of the investigation,
chargesheet came to be filed before the Judicial
Magistrate, First Class, Manora, against 23
accused for offences punishable under Sections
147, 148, 149, 307, 302 and 120-B of IPC read
with Section 135 of the Bombay Police Act,
1951. The case was committed to the Court of
Session and registered as Sessions Trial No. 44
of 2014 upon the file of the trial court.

8. The trial court framed the charge under
Sections 147, 148, 149, 302 read with Section
149, 307 read with Section 149 and 120-B of
IPC and under Section 135 of the Bombay Police
Act, 1951. The accused pleaded not guilty. A-19
had died during the pendency of the trial. The
prosecution examined 29 witnesses, among
them were the three injured, PW-2, PW-10 and
PW-13, the three eye-witnesses, PW-9, PW-14
and PW-19, the medical witnesses PW-20, PW-
21, PW-24, PW-25 and PW-26, and the two
investigating officers, PW-23 and PW-28. The
accused denied their involvement and stated the
Crl.A. Nos.502-507/2023 etc. Page 6 of 38

case to be one of false implication. The accused
asserted in their statements recorded under
Section 313 of Code of Criminal Procedure,
1973 (“CrPC”) that it was the complainant party
which had come to the house of the accused,
and that the injuries were caused in the scuffle
by residents of the locality who had come to
their rescue. Three medical witnesses were
examined in defence, and documents were
brought on record to show that four of the
accused had taken treatment for their own
injuries on 21.03.2014.

9. Vide judgment dated 10.08.2018, the trial court
held the death of the deceased to be homicidal
and the testimony of the injured witnesses and
of the eye-witnesses to be cogent and
trustworthy. It disbelieved and discarded the
evidence relating to the dragging of the victims
from before the house of PW-10 to the house of
A-1, no panchanama of that place or of the car
having been prepared, and it excluded the
reports of the Chemical Analyser for the reason
that the case property not having been kept
Crl.A. Nos.502-507/2023 etc. Page 7 of 38

sealed. The trial court acquitted all the accused
of the charge under Section 120-B IPC and
under Section 135 of the Bombay Police Act,
1951 and acquitted A-16 and A-17 of all the
charges.
9A. However, upon the available evidence it
convicted 20 accused i.e., A-1 to A-15, A-18, A-
20, A-21, A-22 and A-23, under Section 302
read with Section 149 of IPC and sentenced
them to imprisonment for life; under Section
307 read with Section 149 IPC upon three
counts and sentenced them to rigorous
imprisonment for seven years upon each count;
under Section 147 IPC and sentenced them to
rigorous imprisonment for one year; and under
Section 148 IPC and sentenced them to rigorous
imprisonment for two years, all the sentences to
run concurrently, together with fine and default
stipulations.

10. The convicted accused challenged the judgment
of trial court before the High Court by filing the
six appeals as aforementioned. The High Court
vide Impugned Judgment allowed the appeals
Crl.A. Nos.502-507/2023 etc. Page 8 of 38

and held that the prosecution had failed to
prove its case beyond reasonable doubt and that
the accused were entitled to the benefit of doubt,
and directed them to be set at liberty forthwith.
The grounds upon which the High Court
proceeded with acquittal are taken up in the
course of the discussion which follows.

11. The informant, who was not arrayed as a party
before the High Court, obtained permission to
prefer special leave petition. The State of
Maharashtra preferred separate special leave
petition. Leave having been granted in both, the
appeals were registered as aforesaid and have
been heard together.

12. Learned senior counsel appearing on behalf of
the Appellant-informant assails the Impugned
Judgment by contending that the High Court
has failed to appreciate the facts and
circumstances of the case in their proper legal
perspective, and that its findings run contrary
to the material on record. He submits that the
judgment of the trial court was a well-reasoned
one, rendered upon a consideration of the whole
Crl.A. Nos.502-507/2023 etc. Page 9 of 38

of the evidence, and that nothing was shown
which called for interference with it. The High
Court became oblivious of the fact that the case
was one of murder and of grievous hurt, that the
death of the deceased was neither accidental
nor natural but homicidal, and that the
Impugned Judgment reads as though the case
pertained to a fight or to simple hurt.

13. He further submits that the evidence of an
injured witness stands upon a higher pedestal
and that cogent reasons are required before it is
discarded, relying upon Ramlagan Singh and
1
Others v. State of Bihar , Balraje v. State of
2
Maharashtra and Jarnail Singh and Others
3
v. State of Punjab . Learned senior counsel
urge that the principle relating to a parrot-like
version has no application to an injured
witness, whose presence at the place of
occurrence cannot be doubted, and that the
portions of the depositions which the High
Court characterised as identical were in fact

1
(1973) 3 SCC 881
2
(2010) 6 SCC 673
3
(2009) 9 SCC 719
Crl.A. Nos.502-507/2023 etc. Page 10 of 38

elicited in cross-examination by the defence,
when the witnesses had no opportunity of
concerting a common story. It is pointed out
that all three injured witnesses were subjected
to searching and extensive cross-examination,
that the suggestions of tutoring put to them
were denied, and that their evidence was not
shattered but was corroborated by the medical
evidence, so that they could not be termed
tutored witnesses.

14. It is submitted that the case is not one resting
upon ocular evidence alone, the medical
witnesses proved that the death was homicidal
and that the injuries were caused by hard and
blunt objects. A weapon was discovered and
seized upon the statement of each of several
accused and the recoveries were duly proved
and that mere exaggeration as to an episode
cannot lead to the discarding of the whole of the
corroborated evidence on record.

15. It is urged that the accused admitted their
presence at the spot and, have failed to explain
that presence either in cross-examination or in
Crl.A. Nos.502-507/2023 etc. Page 11 of 38

their statements under Section 313 of CrPC, the
burden lay upon them, and a statement under
Section 313 of CrPC, not being substantive
evidence, could not discharge it, reliance being
4
placed upon Manu Sao v. State of Bihar .
Reliance was also placed upon Takhaji Hiraji
v. Thakore Kubersing Chamansing and
5
Others to contend that where overwhelming
evidence is available, the non-examination of
further witnesses is not material. Relying
further upon Rammi alias Rameshwar v.
6
State of M.P. , it is contended that post-event
conduct differs from person to person and that
no particular manner of behaviour can be
expected of the informant. Reliance is also
placed upon Gangadhar Behera and Others
7
v. State of Orissa to contend that the
mechanical rejection of the evidence of a related
witness may lead to a failure of justice and that
normal discrepancy does not affect credibility.

16. He finally submits that even assuming there

4
(2010) 12 SCC 310
5
(2001) 6 SCC 145
6
(1999) 8 SCC 649
7
(2002) 8 SCC 381
Crl.A. Nos.502-507/2023 etc. Page 12 of 38

were lapses in the investigation as to the sealing
of the case property, the delay in sending it for
chemical analysis and the failure to prepare a
panchanama of the place in front of the house
of PW-10, those lapses could not render the
ocular evidence doubtful, and that the acquittal
is perverse and was recorded without
application of mind to the evidence.

17. Learned counsel appearing for the State of
Maharashtra adopts the submissions of
informant and contends that the testimonies of
the injured and of the eye-witnesses could not
be discarded as identical when they stood
corroborated by the medical evidence. That the
High Court could not overlook the basic
principles of criminal jurisprudence and acquit
the accused of the offences under Sections 307,
147 and 148 IPC merely upon a finding of
benefit of doubt in relation to the charge of
murder. The doctrine of last seen ought to have
been applied and that the High Court could not
have ignored the reasoning of the trial court
upon an appreciation of the evidence.
Crl.A. Nos.502-507/2023 etc. Page 13 of 38

18. On the other hand, learned senior counsel
appearing for the Respondent-accused supports
the Impugned Judgment and submits that it is
humanly impossible for 6 witnesses, four of
whom were themselves under simultaneous
assault, to reproduce the same minute detail as
to the name of each of 23 accused, the weapon
carried by each, the victim held by each and the
part of the body assaulted. That such an
identity of narration is the mark of tutoring and
not of truth and the High Court committed no
error in so holding. Reliance is placed upon
Lakshmi Singh and Others v. State of
8
Bihar , Rambilas and Others v. State of
9
M.P. , State (Delhi Administration) v.
10
Laxman Kumar and Others , Himmat
Sukhadeo Wahurwagh and Others v. State
11
of Maharashtra , and State of Punjab v.
12
Mohri Ram and Others .

19. He further submits that the medical evidence is
irreconcilable with the ocular version, in that

8
(1976) 4 SCC 394
9
AIR 1997 SC 3954
10
(1985) 4 SCC 476
11
(2009) 6 SCC 712
12
1994 Supp (1) SCC 632
Crl.A. Nos.502-507/2023 etc. Page 14 of 38

four accused are deposed to have beaten the
deceased continuously upon the head with iron
pipes while the postmortem discloses a single
laceration, and that PW-21, the doctor,
admitted in cross-examination that a single
injury is possible only if all the blows fall upon
the same place, and that had four persons so
beaten the head continuously, the head may
have been crushed. Learned senior counsel also
draws attention to the deposition of PW-2 and
PW-10 that an eyeball of PW-10 had come out
of its socket and his teeth had been dislodged,
whereas the medical record shows the eyeball
movement to be normal and a spot
panchanama
records no teeth at the place of the assault.

20. Learned senior counsel further submits that the
conduct of PW-19 was unnatural and her
presence at the scene of occurrence is doubtful
and no independent witness was examined
although the occurrence took place in a
residential locality and a crowd had gathered
when the police arrived, and that even the panch
witnesses are relatives. The statements of the
witnesses were recorded belatedly and without
Crl.A. Nos.502-507/2023 etc. Page 15 of 38

explanation and the carbon copy of the FIR sent
to the Magistrate did not tally with the original,
a discrepancy which PW-23, the Investigating
Officer, was unable to explain, further the case
property was not kept sealed and the reports of
the Chemical Analyser are therefore worthless.
That the injuries sustained by the accused were
suppressed and remain unexplained, reliance
being placed upon Lakshmi Singh (supra) and
upon Kailash Gour and Others v. State of
13
Assam to contend that the benefit of a
defective investigation must go to the accused.

21. Lastly, he submits that this Court does not
interfere under Article 136 of the Constitution of
India with an order of acquittal unless it is
shown to be clearly unreasonable, perverse,
manifestly illegal or grossly unjust, and that the
mere circumstance that a different view of the
evidence is possible affords no ground for
reversal is made, reliance being placed upon
State of Karnataka v. Amajappa and
14
Others , State of Rajasthan v. Bhanwar

13
(2012) 2 SCC 34
14
(2003) 9 SCC 468
Crl.A. Nos.502-507/2023 etc. Page 16 of 38

15
Singh and Others and State of Punjab v.
16
Kewal Krishan .

22. We have given our thoughtful consideration to
the submissions of the parties and have
carefully gone through the evidence on record
as well as the judgments rendered by the courts
below.

23. At the threshold, it is necessary to identify the
nature of the exercise which these appeals call
for. These are not appeals against concurrent
findings. The trial court convicted and the High
Court, in the exercise of its appellate power to
reappreciate the whole of the evidence, reversed
the finding of trial court. The question which
arises for our consideration is, therefore,
whether the view taken by the High Court in
acquitting the accused is a reasonable and
possible view upon the material on record, such
that it does not call for interference in the
exercise of the discretionary jurisdiction of this
Court under Article 136 of the Constitution of

15
(2004) 10 SCC 709
16
(2023) 13 SCC 695
Crl.A. Nos.502-507/2023 etc. Page 17 of 38

India, and not whether this Court, sitting as a
court of first appeal, might have taken a
different view. We propose to examine the
principal grounds upon which the High Court
proceeded and to test them, for ourselves,
against the record.

24. The first of those grounds is the identical
character of the ocular testimony. The
occurrence, as per the prosecution case itself,
was a sudden and violent assault by a large
number of persons upon four victims at one and
the same time, lasting, according to the injured
witnesses, for 2 to 3 minutes. Six witnesses
were examined as having seen the occurrence,
namely the 3 injured, PW-2, PW-10 and PW-13,
and the 3 eye-witnesses, PW-9, PW-14 and PW-
19. Their statements correspond, one with
another, in the name of every assailant, in the
weapon carried by each, in the victim held by
each and in the part of the body upon which
each blow is said to have fallen. The following
passage from the deposition of PW-2 Mukesh is
illustrative:
Crl.A. Nos.502-507/2023 etc. Page 18 of 38

“…..As soon as we alighted from our car, all
the accused caught hold of us and dragged us
in front of house of accused Janardhan
Rathod. Accused Vinod Haridhan Rathod and
Ravi Tulshiram Rathod had held me. Accused
Gowardhan Rathod and Arun Ramlal Pawar
had held my father. Accused Ashok Ramlal
Pawar, Kuldeep Ramlal Pawar had held my
brother Avinash. Manohar Tulshiram Rathod,
Dilip Dalsing Rathod and Pradip @ Dhotya
Babusing Rathod had held my Cousin
Ganesh…..”

25. PW-10 Devidas deposed thus:
“.....As soon as we alighted from the Car, all
accused surrounded us. Each one of us was
caught hold by two persons. All accused
dragged us to the house of Janardhan.
Avinash was caught hold by Kuldeep Pawar
and Ashok Pawar. Mukesh was caught hold
by Vinod Rathod and Ravi Rathod. Ganesh
was caught hold by Manohar Tulshiram
Rathod, Dilip Dalsing Rathod and Pradip @
Dhotya Jadho…..”


26. PW-9, PW-13, PW-14 and PW-19 have deposed
in the same fashion. The High Court found that
the witnesses had spoken in almost identical
fashion without moving an inch away from each
other, and that the absence of any role in the
carrying of a weapon attributed to those who are
said to have held the victims appeared to have
been done thoughtfully so as to create a show of
truthfulness.
Crl.A. Nos.502-507/2023 etc. Page 19 of 38

27. In a normal course, where a single occurrence
involving a large number of persons is witnessed
by several persons who are differently placed,
and some of them themselves are under assault,
it is expected and natural that the accounts
which they give will ordinarily bear the marks of
individual perception. Differences of detail in
such a narration are the natural product of the
circumstances in which the observation was
made, and their presence lends assurance
rather than detracting from it. A
correspondence as complete as the present one,
extending to the description of the acts of 23
persons and even when it is given not
immediately but some days after the
occurrence, is of the opposite character. The
High Court was entitled to regard it as a
circumstance raising a serious doubt as to
whether these witnesses were speaking to what
they had seen or to what they had been tutored
to say. It is a settled principle that an identical
and stereotyped version bears the imprint of
tutoring rather than of truthful recollection,
which is a caution long administered by this
Crl.A. Nos.502-507/2023 etc. Page 20 of 38

Court, and it was administered in
circumstances not dissimilar in Lakshmi
Singh (supra) , in Laxman Kumar (supra) and
in Himmat Sukhadeo Wahurwagh (supra) .

28. The answer pressed on behalf of the Appellants
must be met squarely. It is urged that the
principle of the parrot-like witness has no
application to an injured witness, whose
presence at the scene carries its own guarantee
and whose evidence stands upon a higher
footing. The proposition, so far as it goes, is
unexceptionable, but the presence of a witness
at the place of the occurrence and the
truthfulness of the detail which he or she
attributes to each member of a large assembly
are distinct matters. An injured witness is a
reliable witness as to the assault upon himself,
however, his evidence does not, for that reason
alone, become a reliable inventory of the precise
part played by each of 23 persons, whom he
recounted identically some days later.


29. The High Court did not disbelieve that PW-2,
PW-10 and PW-13 were assaulted, nor did it
Crl.A. Nos.502-507/2023 etc. Page 21 of 38

doubt that they had suffered the injuries proved
by the medical evidence. What it declined to
accept as safe and correct was the minute and
uniform attribution of roles of all 23 persons
which was described by the witnesses. That
distinction is a legitimate one. At this juncture,
it must be taken into account that, this
distinction is not displaced by the submission
that the identical passages were elicited in
cross-examination, the attribution of a specific
role to each accused appears in the
examination-in-chief of each of these witnesses
and, indeed, in the oral report lodged on the very
day of the occurrence.

30. We now turn to the conflict between the ocular
account and the medical evidence, which we
regard as the weightier of the two grounds
carrying the acquittal. Upon the evidence of all
6 witnesses, 4 persons, namely A-1, A-2, A-18
and A-22, each armed with an iron pipe, beat
the deceased continuously upon the head. The
postmortem report disclosed only a single
laceration measuring 2 x 4 cm over the scalp
Crl.A. Nos.502-507/2023 etc. Page 22 of 38

with a fracture of the frontal bone beneath it.
PW-21, Dr. Gote, who conducted the
postmortem examination, stated in his cross-
examination as follows:
“If a person is beaten continuously for 2 to 3
minutes by 4 persons by 4 different pipes
there is possibility that there would be several
injuries on the head and it is also possible
that there would be one injury. It is correct
that a single injury is possible if all the blows
by the pipe falls on the same place. If the
blows falls on different place on the head
several injuries would be there. According to
me, if a person is beaten continuously for 2 to
3 minutes by 4 persons by 4 iron pipes and
the blows falls on the same place then the
head may be crushed, depending upon the
force of the blows.”

The High Court held it to be impossible that four
persons, continuously giving repeated blows
upon the head with different weapons, would
land every blow upon the same site, and that
upon this aspect the testimony of the eye-
witnesses could not be believed. This conclusion
drawn by the High Court is not the product of
conjecture but it is an inference drawn from the
medical evidence, flowing from the mouth of the
prosecution’s own witness, who deposed that
had four persons so beaten the head, it may,
Crl.A. Nos.502-507/2023 etc. Page 23 of 38

depending upon the force of the blows, have
been crushed. It was not in the present case.

31. The trial court sought to meet this difficulty by
treating the account as an instance of the
exaggeration to which witnesses speaking of
their own suffering are prone. As a general
proposition that could be so, and the High Court
said as much. However, exaggeration explains
an overstatement of the force or the ferocity of
an assault. It does not explain how an assault
deposed to as having been delivered by four
named assailants with four separate weapons
registered upon the body of the deceased as a
single point of impact. The trial court did not
give due weight to that distinction, which, in a
case where the conviction of twenty persons
rested upon the attribution of separate acts to
separate accused, required to be addressed.

32. The same discord runs through the evidence
relating to the injured PW-10 Devidas. PW-2
and PW-10 both deposed that an eyeball of
Devidas had come out of its socket and that his
teeth had been dislodged. The medical record
Crl.A. Nos.502-507/2023 etc. Page 24 of 38

dated 19.03.2014 showed his eyeball movement
to be normal, and the spot panchanama
recorded no teeth at the place of the assault.
PW-21 admitted that he had found no lacerated
wound upon the chin, no injury upon the lower
lip and no lacerated wound upon the right
eyebrow of Devidas, and that his notings were
not consistent with a claim that the eyeball had
come out of the socket. The High Court treated
these as vital discrepancies which could not be
lightly brushed aside, and in a case resting
wholly upon ocular testimony we are unable to
say that it was in error in doing so.

33. The approach of the High Court is in accord with
the recent decision of this Court in Sanjay
17
Kumar v. State of Bihar and Another of
which one of us was a member (Sanjay Karol,
J.), where an acquittal was sustained in the face
of a like mismatch, the Court observed as
follows:
“44. This assumes significance because the
present case is not one where there is a single
eyewitness speaking to a single injury. The
prosecution has built its case on a detailed

17
2026 INSC 735
Crl.A. Nos.502-507/2023 etc. Page 25 of 38

attribution of separate shots by separate
assailants. Where such detailed attribution is
not fully supported by medical evidence, and
where independent witnesses do not support
the prosecution, the court must be slow in
overturning an acquittal.
45. The High Court, therefore, cannot be said
to have acted perversely in treating the
mismatch between the FIR/ocular version
and the post-mortem report as a relevant
circumstance. It is not necessary for the
accused to demonstrate that the prosecution
case is false in every respect. It is sufficient if
the evidence creates a reasonable doubt as to
whether the prosecution has proved the
charge beyond reasonable doubt.”

It was further held that a criminal court cannot
select one apparently corroborated portion of
the evidence while ignoring other material
inconsistencies, and that the question is
whether the evidence as a whole crosses the
threshold of proof beyond reasonable doubt.
The submission that the injuries proved by the
medical witnesses corroborate the ocular
account is answered by that principle; the
injuries establish that the four victims were
assaulted, which was never in doubt, but do not
establish the manner of the assault as deposed
to.


34. The infirmities noticed by the High Court do not
Crl.A. Nos.502-507/2023 etc. Page 26 of 38

end there, and it is necessary to notice the
remaining ones, each of which we have
examined against the record. The genesis of the
entire episode was a quarrel over the playing of
a DJ between two persons, some hours earlier
and around 2.5 kilometres away from the place
of the assault. From that slender beginning, the
prosecution arrayed 23 persons from four
related families, most of whom were not
residents of Naik Nagar and had no connection
with that quarrel and assigned to each of them
a specific role. To nine of the twenty persons
convicted, no weapon at all was attributed, the
case against them being confined to the holding
of a victim or the shouting of exhortation.

35. It is to be noted here that a group and factional
rivalries carry with them a tendency to rope in
the innocent along with the guilty, this Court
has on several occasions administered caution
while deciding such matters, one such case is
Eknath Ganpat Aher and Others v. State of
18
Maharashtra and Others , upon which the

18
(2010) 6 SCC 519
Crl.A. Nos.502-507/2023 etc. Page 27 of 38

High Court relied. In a case which rests upon
constructive liability under Section 149 of IPC,
the safe identification of the membership of the
assembly is the very foundation of the
conviction and where that foundation is laid
exclusively by interested testimony of a
stereotyped character, an appellate court is
entitled to regard it as unsafe. It may also be
noticed, though we do not rest our conclusion
upon it, that the only overt act attributed to any
person upon the injured Ganesh (PW-13) with
an iron bar was attributed to a juvenile who was
not tried with the accused, and the blows with a
wooden plank to a person who was never
arrested or chargesheeted.

36. Next, the assault took place in a residential
locality. PW-1 admitted in his cross-
examination that forty to fifty persons had
gathered at the spot; the oral report recited that
the residents had witnessed the incident, an
assertion from which PW-19 resiled in the
witness box and PW-19 admitted that there
were six houses nearby and that she was upon
Crl.A. Nos.502-507/2023 etc. Page 28 of 38

good terms with her neighbours.
Notwithstanding this, not a single independent
witness was examined, and even the panch
witnesses are admittedly relatives. The High
Court held that in these circumstances the trial
court ought to have drawn an adverse inference
against the prosecution. The principle governing
the matter was restated in Sanjay Kumar
(supra) in the following terms:
“49. In the present matter, the independent
witnesses were not peripheral witnesses. The
prosecution itself considered them material
enough to cite them in the chargesheet. When
the two independent witnesses examined did
not support the prosecution, and the
remaining independent witnesses were
withheld without satisfactory explanation, the
courts below were entitled to treat this as a
circumstance creating doubt on the
prosecution case.
50. The argument that hostile witnesses do
not completely efface the prosecution case is
again correct as a proposition of law. But
where the prosecution case is otherwise
attended by contradictions between ocular
and medical evidence, doubtful presence of
interested witnesses, and lack of independent
corroboration, the hostility of independent
witnesses assumes greater significance.”

37. The reliance placed upon Takhaji Hiraji
(supra) does not carry the matter further, the
rule there stated presupposes that the evidence
Crl.A. Nos.502-507/2023 etc. Page 29 of 38

which has been led is itself overwhelming, that
premise is absent here.

38. Another aspect which requires consideration is
that there is the delay in the recording of the
statements. PW-9 and PW-14 were admittedly
present when the police reached the spot, yet
their statements were not recorded until
20.03.2014, and PW-23 admitted in his cross-
examination that the statements of the eye-
witnesses could have been recorded through
PW-16 without delay. The statements of the
injured were recorded from 24.03.2014, though
the hospital records exhibited before the trial
court showed them to be conscious and
oriented. The trial court accepted the
explanation offered through the treating
doctors, and the explanation was not without
force so far as the injured were concerned but
no explanation at all was forthcoming for the
delay in the case of PW-9 and PW-14, and the
trial court did not advert to it. The High Court
held that the unexplained delay, in the setting
of a body of witnesses all of whom are related
Crl.A. Nos.502-507/2023 etc. Page 30 of 38

and interested, left room for the construction of
a version. That inference was open to it upon the
material.

39. Finally, there are infirmities in the FIR and in
the investigation. The carbon copy of the FIR
sent to the Magistrate does not tally with the
original, the columns as to the time of
registration and the station diary entry being
blank in the one and written in ink in the other.
PW-23 was unable to offer any explanation and
the attempt of PW-28 to explain the discrepancy
by reference to a practice of keeping two original
copies did not survive his admission that he
knew of no rule requiring it and had no personal
knowledge of the writing of this report. To these
must be added the concededly serious lapses in
the handling of the case property, which the
Chemical Analyser declined to receive because
the lac seals were broken and which was
thereafter resealed without any record, upon
which both the courts below were agreed in
excluding the reports of the Chemical Analyser.
It is not necessary for us to decide finally upon
Crl.A. Nos.502-507/2023 etc. Page 31 of 38

whether the FIR was ante-timed, nor did the
High Court rest its conclusion upon that finding
alone. A defect in investigation does not by itself
entitle an accused to an acquittal where the
substantive evidence is found to be reliable, but
where the substantive evidence is itself infirm,
the lapses assume significance and their benefit
enures to the accused.

40. At last, there remains the matter of the injuries
upon the accused. It was brought on record
through the medical witnesses examined in
defence, and by the documents exhibited that
four of the accused had taken treatment for
their injuries on 21.03.2014 and PW-21
admitted that he had examined certain of the
accused and had issued medico-legal reports in
respect of them, which did not form part of the
chargesheet. The trial court treated the non-
production of those reports as a lapse of the
Investigating Officer occasioning no prejudice.

41. The High Court took the view that the injuries
upon the accused had been withheld and
remained unexplained, and that this reinforced
Crl.A. Nos.502-507/2023 etc. Page 32 of 38

the doubt as to whether the true genesis of the
occurrence had been placed before the court.
The consequences of such a non-explanation
were considered by this Court in Parshuram v.
19
State of Madhya Pradesh , where, after
setting out the three inferences enumerated in
Lakshmi Singh (supra) , namely that the
prosecution has suppressed the genesis and
origin of the occurrence and has not presented
the true version, that the witnesses who have
denied the presence of the injuries are lying
upon a most material point, and that a defence
version which explains those injuries is
rendered probable, it was held as follows:
“22. Undisputedly, in the present case also,
the witnesses are interested witnesses. The
injuries sustained by three accused persons
are not at all explained. The trial court and the
High Court have not considered this aspect of
the matter.
23. Non-explanation of injuries on the
persons of the accused would create a doubt,
as to, whether, the prosecution has brought
on record the real genesis of the incident or
not.”

The witnesses in the present case are, without
exception, related to the deceased and to the

19
2023 INSC 973 : (2024) 12 SCC 322
Crl.A. Nos.502-507/2023 etc. Page 33 of 38

injured and the injuries upon the accused are
unexplained; and a defence version which
would account for them was set up from the
stage of the statements under Section 313 of
CrPC. The view which the High Court took upon
this material is in keeping with the principle so
stated.

42. It is upon the cumulative effect of these several
strands that the High Court proceeded, and it is
against that background that the threshold of
interference must now be applied. The
principles governing the reversal of an acquittal
are no longer res integra . They were restated by
this Court, after a survey of the earlier
decisions, in Babu Sahebagouda
Rudragoudar and Others v. State of
20
Karnataka that an appellate court will
interfere with an order of acquittal only where
the acquittal suffers from patent perversity, or
is founded upon a misreading of or an omission
to consider material evidence on record, or
where no two reasonable views upon the

20
(2024) 8 SCC 149
Crl.A. Nos.502-507/2023 etc. Page 34 of 38

evidence are possible and the only view which
can be taken is that consistent with the guilt of
the accused.

43. The above restraint operates with added force
when this Court is invited to interfere under
Article 136 of the Constitution of India, for an
order of acquittal reinforces the presumption of
innocence with which an accused sets out, and
this Court, in the exercise of its discretionary
jurisdiction, will not disturb such an order
unless it is shown to be perverse, manifestly
illegal or productive of a gross miscarriage of
justice.

44. Tested upon that touchstone of decisions
rendered by this Court, the view taken by the
High Court cannot be displaced. It is not a view
arrived at by ignoring the evidence, the High
Court reproduced the material portions of the
depositions and dealt with each of the reasons
which had weighed with the trial court. It is not
a view based upon a misreading, the medical
evidence upon which it principally turns is the
evidence of the prosecution's own expert, in the
Crl.A. Nos.502-507/2023 etc. Page 35 of 38

very words in which he gave it. It is not a case
in which the only view possible upon the record
was the view consistent with guilt, on the
contrary, upon the conflict between the ocular
and the medical evidence and upon the unsafe
character of the identification of a large
assembly, the conclusion reached by the High
Court is one which is well justified on the basis
of the record. The submission that the acquittal
is perverse and was recorded without an
application of mind is, in these circumstances,
not one which commends itself to us.

45. We are conscious that the reasoning of the High
Court is not free from imperfection. The
characterisation of the recoveries effected under
Section 27 of the Evidence Act, and of the
explanation offered for the discrepancy in the
FIR through PW-28, might have received
detailed notice, the trial court having recorded
findings upon both. As to the former, it may be
observed that the mere exhibiting of a
memorandum does not by itself establish a
recovery, which must be proved in accordance
Crl.A. Nos.502-507/2023 etc. Page 36 of 38

with law and as to the latter, the trial court’s
reasoning was entitled to be addressed rather
than passed over. An error in the reasoning at
the margin does not, however, vitiate a
conclusion which is otherwise sustainable upon
the record. The two findings which carry the
acquittal, namely the medical improbability of
the fatal assault as deposed to and the unsafe
character of the identification of a large
assembly upon interested and stereotyped
testimony, remain untouched by any such
correction.

46. Therefore, in our considered view, the acquittal
recorded by the High Court is not the product of
a perverse or capricious appreciation of the
evidence but a reasoned conclusion resting
upon the material on record. It is, at the least, a
reasonable and possible view and once it is such
a view, it is not liable to be interfered under
Article 136 of the Constitution of India by this
Court. The threshold for interference is not
crossed in the present case.

Crl.A. Nos.502-507/2023 etc. Page 37 of 38

47. In view of the foregoing discussion, we find no
ground to interfere with the Impugned
Judgment dated 02.02.2022 passed by the High
Court in Criminal Appeal Nos. 559, 560, 561,
562, 570 and 576 of 2018. The prayer of the
Appellant-informant and the State for the
setting aside of that judgment and for the
restoration of the conviction and sentence
recorded by the trial court is declined.

48. Criminal Appeal Nos. 502-507 of 2023 and
Criminal Appeal Nos. 508-513 of 2023 are
accordingly dismissed.


49. Pending application(s), if any, shall stand
disposed of.


…..……..………..………………..J.
[ SANJAY KAROL ]


…….……..………..………………..J.
[ AUGUSTINE GEORGE MASIH ]

NEW DELHI;
AUGUST 03, 2026.
Crl.A. Nos.502-507/2023 etc. Page 38 of 38