REPRESENTED BY ITS PRINCIPAL SECRETARY REVENUE DEPARTMENT VIKAS SOUDHA BENGALURU 560001 vs RAJESHWARI TIMMANNA HEGADE AGED ABOUT 38 YEARS WORKING AS SUB REGISTRAR OFFICE OF THE SUB REGISTRAR

Court
Karnataka High Court

- 1 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:17227-DB
WP No. 103324 of 2023
C/W WP No. 100328 of 2023


CNR: KAHC020068712023



IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT DHARWAD

TH
DATED THIS THE 15 DAY OF OCTOBER 2026


R

PRESENT

THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE M.NAGAPRASANNA

AND

THE HON'BLE MRS JUSTICE HEMA KULKARNI


WRIT PETITION NO.103324 OF 2023 (S-KAT)
C/W
WRIT PETITION NO.100328 OF 2023 (S-KAT)

IN WP NO.103324/2023:
BETWEEN:






THE INSPECTOR GENERAL OF REGISTRATION
AND COMMISSIONER OF STAMPS,
TH
8 FLOOR, KANDAYA BHAVAN,
BENGALUR-560016.


…PETITIONER
(BY SMT.GIRIJA S.HIREMATH, HCGP)

AND:

SMT. RAJESHWARI HEGADE
D/O. SRI. TIMMANNA,
AGED ABOUT 38 YEARS,
WORKING AS SUB-REGISTRAR,
OFFICE OF THE SUB-REGISTRAR,
MINI VIDHANA SOUDHA, SIRSI-581402,
RESIDING AT POST, KASABA HOBLI,
SIRSI TALUK, UTTAR KANNADA DISTRICT.




Digitally signed
by RAKESH S
HARIHAR
Location: High
Court of
Karnataka,
Dharwad Bench

…RESPONDENT
(BY SRI.PRITHVEESH M.K., ADVOCATE)

THIS WRIT PETITION IS FILED UNDER ARTICLES 226 AND 227
OF THE CONSTITUTION OF INDIA PRAYING TO ISSUE A WRIT,
ORDER OR DIRECTION IN THE NATURE OF CERTIORARI TO QUASH
THE ORDER DATED 30.06.2022 PASSED BY THE KARNATAKA STATE
ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL, BELAGAVI IN APPLICATION NO.11280
OF 2021 (ANNEXURE-B TO THE WRIT PETITION); AND ETC.

- 2 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:17227-DB
WP No. 103324 of 2023
C/W WP No. 100328 of 2023


CNR: KAHC020068712023


IN WP NO.100328/2023:
BETWEEN:

1. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA
REPRESENTED BY ITS PRINCIPAL SECRETARY,
REVENUE DEPARTMENT VIKASA SOUDHA,
BENGALURU-560001.

2. THE INSPECTOR GENERAL OF REGISTRATION
AND COMMISSIONER OF STAMPS,
TH
8 FLOOR, KANDAYA BHAVAN,
BENGALURU-560016.

3. THE DISTRICT REGISTRAR
DEPT. OF REGISTRATION AND STAMPS,
RD
NO. 860, 3 FLOOR, TRUMP TOWERS,
CHURCH STREET, SHIVAJINAGAR,
BENGALURU-560016.
...PETITIONERS
(BY SMT.GIRIJA S.HIREMATH, HCGP)

AND:

SMT. RAJESHWARI HEGDE
D/O. SRI. TIMMANNA,
AGED ABOUT 38 YEARS,
WORKING AS SUB-REGISTRAR,
OFFICE OF THE SUB-REGISTRAR,
MINI VIDHANA SOUDHA, SIRSI-581402,
RESIDING AT POST, HOSAKULI (BOLTATTEN),
HONNAVARA TALUK, UTTAR KANNADA DISTRICT.

...RESPONDENT
(BY SRI.PRITHVEESH M.K., ADVOCATE)
THIS WRIT PETITION IS FILED UNDER ARTICLES 226 AND 227
OF THE CONSTITUTION OF INDIA, PRAYING TO ISSUE A WRIT,
ORDER OR DIRECTION IN THE NATURE OF CERTIORARI TO QUASH
THE ORDER DATED 04.08.2022 PASSED BY THE KARNATAKA STATE
ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL, BELAGAVI IN APPLICATION NO.10189
OF 2020 (ANNEXURE-B TO THE WRIT PETITION); AND ETC.

THSE WRIT PETITIONS COMING ON FOR FINAL HEARING THIS
DAY, ORDER WAS MADE THEREIN AS UNDER:

- 3 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:17227-DB
WP No. 103324 of 2023
C/W WP No. 100328 of 2023


CNR: KAHC020068712023


CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE M.NAGAPRASANNA
AND
HON'BLE MRS JUSTICE HEMA KULKARNI

ORAL ORDER

(PER: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE M.NAGAPRASANNA )


1. The State is before us in both these cases calling in
question 2 separate orders dated 30.06.2022 and 04.08.2022
passed by the Karnataka State Administrative Tribunal,
Belagavi (hereinafter referred to as the ‘Tribunal’, for short), in
Application Nos.11280/2021 and 10189/2020, respectively,
whereby the Tribunal in one of the cases sets aside the charge
sheet issued against the petitioner and in the other directs
consideration of promotion by opening the sealed cover.


2. Since the parties are the same, the two are taken
up together and considered by this common order.


3. Facts in brief, germane, are as follows:
The respondent, at the relevant point in time, was
functioning as a Sub-Registrar in the Department of Revenue.
In the discharge of her official duties, he registered three
documents, all being sale deeds, upon which stamp duty came

- 4 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:17227-DB
WP No. 103324 of 2023
C/W WP No. 100328 of 2023


CNR: KAHC020068712023


to be levied on the basis of a particular method of valuation
adopted by him. The levy of stamp duty, which was alleged to
be excessive, became the subject matter of challenge before
this Court in Writ Petition No.2591 of 2020 and several
connected matters. The learned Single Judge of this Court, by
an order dated 24.07.2020, allowed the writ petitions and
directed that the properties be subjected to fresh valuation.
Pursuant thereto, the respondent–Sub-Registrar undertook the
exercise of revaluation of the properties in terms of the
directions issued by this Court. It is this exercise that appears
to have invited the wrath of the Department, resulting in the
sword of disciplinary proceedings being unsheathed against the
respondent.
4. Articles of Charge dated 28.10.2019 came to be issued
against the respondent, alleging that, in the course of
registration of the aforesaid three sale deeds, he had
committed misconduct resulting in loss to the State Exchequer.
The respondent called the said Articles of Charge in question
before the Karnataka State Administrative Tribunal in
Application No.10189 of 2020. The Tribunal, upon a detailed

- 5 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:17227-DB
WP No. 103324 of 2023
C/W WP No. 100328 of 2023


CNR: KAHC020068712023


consideration of the matter, allowed the application and set
aside the Articles of Charge, thereby bringing the disciplinary
proceedings initiated against the respondent to a quietus. It is
this order of the Tribunal that is called in question by the State
in Writ Petition No.100328 of 2023.
5. The companion petition in Writ Petition No.103324 of
2023 is but a sequel to the aforesaid proceedings. The
respondent, having succeeded in securing obliteration of the
Articles of Charge, approached the Tribunal yet again in
Application No.11280 of 2021, seeking the consequential
service benefits that ought to flow from the order setting aside
the disciplinary proceedings. The grievance projected was that
the Departmental Promotion Committee, on account of the
pendency of the disciplinary proceedings initiated pursuant to
the Articles of Charge, had kept its recommendation concerning
the respondent's promotion in a sealed cover. The respondent,
therefore, sought a direction for opening of the sealed cover
and grant of promotion with all consequential benefits. The
Tribunal granted the relief sought, which has, in turn, driven
the State to this Court in the companion writ petition.

- 6 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:17227-DB
WP No. 103324 of 2023
C/W WP No. 100328 of 2023


CNR: KAHC020068712023


6. Thus, the two writ petitions, though arising from
distinct orders of the Tribunal, are inextricably
intertwined. The first concerns the very foundation of
the disciplinary proceedings, while the second concerns
the consequences that must necessarily follow upon the
disappearance of that foundation. The legality of the
Articles of Charge, therefore, becomes the fulcrum upon
which the fate of both petitions must turn.
7. The learned High Court Government Pleader Smt. Girija
Hiremath would vehemently contend that the Tribunal ought
not to have obliterated the charge sheet without permitting
inquiry against the respondent, as the act of the respondent
had caused loss to the State Exchequer, as the value of the
property was undervalued and not appropriately valued. The
learned HCGP would submit that even if the Court had set aside
the earlier valuation, it would not mean that the respondent
acting as a Sub-Registrar would undervalue the property. The
learned HCGP submits that the order of the Tribunal be set
aside and the inquiry be permitted to be continued against the
Sub-Registrar.

- 7 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:17227-DB
WP No. 103324 of 2023
C/W WP No. 100328 of 2023


CNR: KAHC020068712023



8. Insofar as the other petition is concerned, the learned
HCGP would submit that it is a consequence of what is
submitted in Writ Petition No.100328/2023 as if the State
would succeed in W.P. No.100328/2023, the other petition
would become infructuous.
9. Per contra, the learned counsel M. K. Prithveesh
appearing for the respondent would vehemently refute the
submission in contending that the respondent acting as a Sub-
Registrar in terms of Section 86 of the Registration Act had
only performed her duty and had not committed any
misconduct that would cause any loss to the exchequer. It was
in fact valued at a higher price which was challenged before the
learned Single Judge in the afore quoted writ petition. The
learned Single Judge allowed the petition and directed
recalculation of the stamp duty upon the property which the
respondent had valued. This resulted in a particular valuation
done and that has now become the subject matter of the
charge sheet. The learned counsel submits that performing
official duties for which an appeal remedy is also available

- 8 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:17227-DB
WP No. 103324 of 2023
C/W WP No. 100328 of 2023


CNR: KAHC020068712023


would not amount to misconduct and would submit that the
Tribunal has not committed any error and has passed an order
which is in consonance with law. The learned counsel would
seek dismissal of the petition and would submit that if Writ
Petition No.100328/2023 would stand dismissed, the connected
matter would also have to follow suit.
10. We have given our anxious consideration to the
submissions made by the respective learned counsel and have
perused the material on record.
11. The afore-narrated facts, dates, link in the chain of
events are all a matter of record. They would not require any
iteration except skeletal reference at the periphery.
12. The fact that the respondent, at the relevant point in
time, was functioning as an in-charge Sub-Registrar in terms of
Rule 68 of the Karnataka Civil Services Rules (‘KCSR’ for short)
is not in dispute. While discharging the duties of the said office,
the respondent registered three sale deeds on 12.09.2018,
15.09.2018 and 29.09.2018, adopting a particular method of
valuation for the purpose of determination of stamp duty. The

- 9 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:17227-DB
WP No. 103324 of 2023
C/W WP No. 100328 of 2023


CNR: KAHC020068712023


said valuation became the subject matter of challenge before
the learned Single Judge of this Court in Writ Petition No.2591
of 2020 and connected matters. The learned Single Judge,
upon consideration of the controversy, allowed the writ
petitions and directed that the apartments be treated as
constituting a single block for the purpose of valuation,
notwithstanding the fact that the property extended over the
territorial limits of two villages. In obedience to the said
direction, the respondent undertook a fresh exercise of
valuation of the properties. What was thus an exercise
undertaken in the discharge of statutory duties, and
subsequently in furtherance of a judicial direction,
became the very foundation for the initiation of
disciplinary proceedings against the respondent. The
Department, alleging that the registration of the three sale
deeds and the valuation adopted had occasioned loss to the
State Exchequer, issued the impugned Articles of Charge. The
respondent, aggrieved by the initiation of disciplinary
proceedings on the aforesaid premise, approached the Tribunal
calling in question the very charge memorandum. Thus, the

- 10 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:17227-DB
WP No. 103324 of 2023
C/W WP No. 100328 of 2023


CNR: KAHC020068712023


issue that falls for consideration is whether an exercise
of valuation undertaken by an officer in the discharge of
the duties of an in-charge Sub-Registrar, and
subsequently revisited pursuant to an order of this
Court, could, in the facts obtaining, furnish a legally
sustainable foundation for disciplinary proceedings
alleging misconduct. The Tribunal by the following order
allowed the application:
“ 6. It is not in dispute that the applicant has been
issued Articles of Charges on 28.10.2019 for having
registered three documents without taking into
consideration the market value of the said property which
resulted in loss of revenue and further, she was charged
that she had not taken into consideration the guidelines
framed under Government Notification dated 27.10.2014.
The defense taken by the applicant is that she was only
an in-charge Sub-Registrar and she had registered the
document based on the valuation that was adopted while
registering 131 documents pertaining to the same
property by the earlier Sub-Registrar. Further, it was the
stand of the applicant that she had taken into
consideration the guidelines mentioned in the Government
Notification dated 27.10.2014 by treating the properties
as a part of Amanakere Village and she had followed the
mandatory rules under Karnataka Registration Act, 1908
and the prescribed procedure while adopting the above
valuation. The applicant cited a number of judgments as
mentioned supra and emphasized that she has acted in a
bona-fide manner and the action taken by her cannot be
subject to disciplinary action. Apart from these
arguments, learned Counsel for the applicant also brought
to our notice that the allegations made against the
applicant regarding under-valuation of the properties was
made good by charging higher valuation but when the

- 11 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:17227-DB
WP No. 103324 of 2023
C/W WP No. 100328 of 2023


CNR: KAHC020068712023


same was questioned by the affected parties before the
Hon’ble High Court of Karnataka in W.P.No.2591/2020
(GM-ST/RN) and other connected cases, the Hon. High
Court by order dated 24.07.2020 has upheld the valuation
made by the Sub-Registrar and set-aside the higher
valuation made by the District Registrar and ordered for it
refund. Since, the Hon’ble High Court has already decided
the case regarding valuation and has upheld the valuation
made by the Sub-Registrar with regard to the properties,
the applicant cannot be subject to disciplinary action and
therefore, the Counsel vehemently contended that the
Articles of Charges issued to the applicant should be set-
aside.

7. We have carefully examined the judgment passed by
the Hon’ble High Court of Karnataka in W.P.No.2591/2020
(GMST/RN) and connected cases, decided on 24.07.2020,
wherein the Hon’ble High Court has held that “Apartments
in the buildings of Prestige Tech Park-III, developed in
Sy.Nos.110/1, 110/2 and 110/3 of Amande Bellandur
Khane Village, Varthur Hobli, Bangalore East, forms one
single block irrespective of whether it falls under Amane
Bellandur Khane Village or Kaadubeesanahalli. The
relevant extract of the judgment is reproduced here
under:

“……8. As to invokability of the Guide Line Values
prescribed for Kaadubeesanahalli to the structures in
other village:

(i) In all these cases, regardless of the years of
registration of the conveyances in question, one
fact which stares at the State is that all these
registered instruments comprise the Apartments in
the buildings of Prestige Tech Park - III, developed
in Sy.Nos.110/1, 110/2 & 110/3 of Amane
Bellandur Khane village, Varthur Hobli, Bangalore
East; the contention that Prestige Tech Parks – I, II
& III constitute one single Block which is developed
on two different but contiguous villages namely
Amane Bellandur Khane and Kaadubeesanahalli,
does not make difference to the case of the
petitioners as long as their buildings are erected in
the former, as is forthcoming from the specific texts

- 12 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:17227-DB
WP No. 103324 of 2023
C/W WP No. 100328 of 2023


CNR: KAHC020068712023


of the subject sale deeds; much milk cannot be
derived by the State by banking upon the
Notification dated 27.10.2014 at Annexure-R4
which at its internal Page No.208 i.e., at Item
No.412 mentions "Prestige Tech Park (Commercial)"
when it is under the heading “XXIII
Kaadubeesanahalli”; by the very text & context of
the said Notification, the structures erected in other
villages logically stand excluded in ascertaining the
market value for the purpose of levying stamp duty,
as rightly contended by Mr.Phanindra.

(ii) There is yet other reason which Mr.Phanindra
points out for discounting the version of the learned
AAG Mr.Subramanya that the aforesaid Notification
of 27.10.2014 at Annexure-R4 applies to structures
in Prestige Tech Park – III too; a land developer
may take up construction in one single project
comprising multiple villages and of calling it with
one single nomenclature; that per se does not
disentitle the duty payer from invoking the
beneficial Guideline Values that may be otherwise
applicable to each of the constituent villages
independently; this view is strengthened by another
Notification dated 27.10.2014 which specifically
stipulates in it’s Appendix that where there is no
Guideline Value prescribed for the commercial flats,
their market value shall be determined with the
addition of 30% to the Guideline Value prescribed
for residential flats; the same is reiterated in clause
7 of the Notification dated 28.03.2016 as well; the
fact that the petitioners apparently have valued
their properties with this addition, cannot be
disputed.
9. Lastly, Mr.Phanindra submits and this Court
agrees that whatever excess amount that is paid or
deposited pursuant to the impugned orders, needs to
be refunded should the petitioners succeed in their
legal battle; ordinarily, the usufructs of victory in a
court case cannot be denied to a successful litigant;
no exception such as one of unjust enrichment or the
like is made out by the State to this general
proposition; even otherwise, there is no authority or

- 13 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:17227-DB
WP No. 103324 of 2023
C/W WP No. 100328 of 2023


CNR: KAHC020068712023


justification for the State to retain the money of the
citizens, which they were made to pay coercively
sans legal duty; an argument to the contrary
amounts to acquisition of property of a private citizen
without authority of law and thus, violates Article
300-A of the Constitution of India.”
From the above observations made by the Hon’ble
High Court of Karnataka, it is crystal clear that even the
higher valuation carried out by resorting to action under
section Sec.45A (3) and 46A of the Karnataka Stamp Act,
1957 has also been ordered to be held as illegal and the
Hon’ble High Court has directed the State to refund the
said amount. In view of this, no useful purpose will be
served by continuing the disciplinary action against the
applicant who has been charged on the same issue, in the
present case. There is sufficient force in the contention of
the learned counsel for the applicant that action against
the applicant cannot be pursued any further in so far as
the registration of the properties pertaining to Prestige
Tech Park-III are concerned. However, it is up to the
respondents to act against the applicant, in case it is
considered that she is at fault for certain other misconduct
which has nothing to do with the registration of the
properties relating to Prestige Tech Park III.
8. In the result, we proceed to pass the following:
O R D E R
(i) The application is hereby allowed.

(ii) The impugned order bearing No. EV (1)-13/
19-20 dated 28.10.2019 (Annexure-A1)
nd
passed by the 2 respondent, in so far as
the applicant is concerned, is hereby
quashed.

(iii) However, the respondents are at liberty to
act against the applicant in accordance with
law, if she is at fault for any other
misconduct which is not in any way
connected to the registration of the
properties relating to Prestige Tech Park
III.”

- 14 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:17227-DB
WP No. 103324 of 2023
C/W WP No. 100328 of 2023


CNR: KAHC020068712023


The Tribunal, upon a detailed examination of the material
on record, found that the respondent, while functioning as an
in-charge Sub-Registrar, had adopted the very method of
valuation followed by the predecessor in registering as many as
131 documents pertaining to the same property. More
importantly, the allegation of undervaluation resulting in loss to
the State Exchequer, which formed the very foundation of the
Articles of Charge, had already been examined by this Court in
Writ Petition No.2591 of 2020 and connected matters, wherein
the higher valuation adopted by the Department was held to be
unsustainable and refund of excess stamp duty was directed.
Thus, what the Department branded as misconduct stood
judicially vindicated as a lawful exercise of statutory
duty.

13. The Tribunal, therefore, rightly concluded that
continuation of disciplinary proceedings on an allegation whose
very foundation had been eroded by a judicial pronouncement
would serve no purpose. An act performed bona fide in
discharge of official duties cannot, merely because it

- 15 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:17227-DB
WP No. 103324 of 2023
C/W WP No. 100328 of 2023


CNR: KAHC020068712023


does not find favour with the Department, be
transformed into misconduct. The Tribunal accordingly
quashed the Articles of Charge, while preserving liberty to
proceed against the respondent for any independent
misconduct unconnected with the subject registrations. The
order of the Tribunal, therefore, warrants no interference.
14. The learned counsel appearing for the respondent
would submit that the order of the learned Single Judge in Writ
Petition No.2591 of 2020 and connected matters has received
the imprimatur of the Division Bench, the writ appeal preferred
against the said order having been dismissed. The
determination of the learned Single Judge, therefore, stands
affirmed by the Division Bench. The consequence of such
affirmation, according to the learned counsel, is unmistakable.
The valuation adopted by the respondent in the capacity of an
in-charge Sub-Registrar, which the Department had sought to
discredit as resulting in loss to the State Exchequer, has stood
judicially vindicated. The higher valuation subsequently
adopted by the Department was found to be unsustainable by
the learned Single Judge, a finding which has now attained

- 16 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:17227-DB
WP No. 103324 of 2023
C/W WP No. 100328 of 2023


CNR: KAHC020068712023


further judicial affirmation. It is, therefore, rather
paradoxical that an act of valuation which has received
the seal of judicial approval should become the very
foundation for fastening an allegation of misconduct
upon the officer who undertook the exercise. The
Department cannot approbate and reprobate, treating the
valuation as legally sustainable for one purpose and as
misconduct for another. The respondent, it is submitted, cannot
be made to suffer disciplinary consequences for an act which
has been found to be in consonance with law.
15. The jurisprudence on the subject is neither nascent
nor nebulous. The Apex Court, in plethora of judgments, has
delineated the circumstances in which an act performed by an
officer in the discharge of quasi-judicial functions could
legitimately become the subject matter of disciplinary
proceedings. The principle that emerges is that a mere error
in the exercise of quasi-judicial discretion, an
interpretation of law which does not find favour with a
superior authority, or an order subsequently reversed in
appeal, cannot, by itself, constitute misconduct. The

- 17 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:17227-DB
WP No. 103324 of 2023
C/W WP No. 100328 of 2023


CNR: KAHC020068712023


position would undoubtedly be different where the exercise of
such power is demonstrably tainted by mala fides,
recklessness, corrupt motive, extraneous consideration or a
deliberate disregard of statutory obligations.
16. The distinction between an erroneous decision
and a culpable act of misconduct must remain firmly
etched in the exercise of disciplinary jurisdiction. To hold
otherwise would be to place every quasi-judicial
authority under the perpetual shadow of disciplinary
proceedings for every decision that may not commend
itself to the superior authority. Such a course would
strike at the very independence of quasi-judicial
decision-making. The law on the subject is so well settled
that multiplying precedents would only add to the bulk of this
order without advancing the determination of the controversy.
Where the statute provides a remedy of appeal, revision or
judicial scrutiny against an order passed by a quasi-judicial
authority, the correctness of that order must ordinarily be
tested through the remedies so provided and not converted,
without independent material indicative of misconduct, into a

- 18 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:17227-DB
WP No. 103324 of 2023
C/W WP No. 100328 of 2023


CNR: KAHC020068712023


disciplinary charge against its author. The disciplinary
authority cannot be permitted to sit in judgment over the
bona fide exercise of quasi-judicial discretion merely
because it entertains a different view of the matter. In
the case at hand, the very valuation which became the genesis
of the charge has stood vindicated by judicial pronouncements.
In the absence of any independent foundation establishing
culpable misconduct, the Tribunal was justified in setting at
naught the Articles of Charge. The order of the Tribunal,
therefore, suffers from neither perversity nor illegality
warranting interference at the hands of this Court in exercise of
its jurisdiction under Articles 226 and 227 of the Constitution of
India.
17. Therefore, finding no merit in W.P.No.100328/2023
filed by the State, the petition must fail and thus, dismissed.
IN WRIT PETITION No. 103324 of 2023 :
18. In the case at hand, the State calls in question the
order of the Tribunal directing opening of the sealed cover and
grant of promotion to the respondent to the cadre of Sub-
Registrar, with retrospective effect from 18.11.2021, the date

- 19 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:17227-DB
WP No. 103324 of 2023
C/W WP No. 100328 of 2023


CNR: KAHC020068712023


on which the respondent's juniors came to be promoted to the
said cadre. The solitary impediment that stood between the
respondent and consideration for promotion was the pendency
of disciplinary proceedings pursuant to the Articles of Charge,
on the strength of which the Departmental Promotion
Committee had placed its recommendation in a sealed cover.
That impediment has now ceased to exist. The Tribunal has
obliterated the Articles of Charge, and the said obliteration has
received the imprimatur of this Court in the companion writ
petition. Once the very foundation for adopting the sealed
cover procedure stands effaced, the consequence flowing
therefrom cannot be permitted to survive independently.
The sealed cover cannot remain sealed when the reason
for sealing it has itself disappeared. The respondent cannot
be made to suffer the deprivation of a legitimate service benefit
on the strength of disciplinary proceedings which have been
judicially set at naught. To hold otherwise would be to
perpetuate the consequences of an action that has ceased to
have any existence in the eye of law.

- 20 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:17227-DB
WP No. 103324 of 2023
C/W WP No. 100328 of 2023


CNR: KAHC020068712023


19. As a necessary corollary, Writ Petition No.103324 of
2023, which calls in question the consequential direction of the
Tribunal to open the sealed cover and grant promotion, must
also meet the same fate as the companion petition. The
Tribunal had granted two months' time for implementation of
its directions. However, during the pendency of the proceedings
before this Court, an interim order of stay was operating, owing
to which the State has not given effect to the directions of the
Tribunal. In these circumstances, we deem it appropriate to
grant the State a further period of two months from today to
implement the order of the Tribunal impugned in Writ Petition
No.103324 of 2023. It is needless to observe that the
respondent shall be entitled to all consequential service benefits
flowing from the implementation of the said order, including the
benefit of retrospective promotion from 18.11.2021, in terms of
the directions of the Tribunal. The respondent, having been
relieved of the cloud of disciplinary proceedings, cannot
be left to endure their shadow upon the respondent's
service career. What was withheld solely on account of a
charge that no longer survives must now receive its

- 21 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:17227-DB
WP No. 103324 of 2023
C/W WP No. 100328 of 2023


CNR: KAHC020068712023


lawful consideration. The order of the Tribunal, therefore,
warrants affirmation, and the challenge laid by the State
deserves rejection. The writ petition is accordingly, dismissed.
20. An application seeking impleadment is preferred by
one Sri Mahadeva R., who was a co-delinquent along with the
respondent in the disciplinary proceedings that form the subject
matter of the present petitions. In the light of the findings
recorded hereinabove and the orders passed by us affirming
the orders of the Tribunal, consideration of the impleading
application would be wholly unnecessary. The application,
therefore, does not warrant any further adjudication and
stands disposed of as having become unnecessary.
Ordered accordingly.

Sd/-
(M.NAGAPRASANNA)
JUDGE


Sd/-
(HEMA KULKARNI)
JUDGE


kmv

CT:VH