UNION OF INDIA AND OTHERS vs RAM PAL

Court
High Court of Himachal Pradesh

1
2026:HHC:49521

IN THE HIGH COURT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH, SHIMLA
High Court of H.P.
CWP No. 38 of 2019
Date of decision: 17.11.2026
Union of India and others ..Petitioners
Versus
Ram Pal …..Respondent
Coram
The Hon’ble Mr. Justice Ajay Mohan Goel, Judge.
The Hon’ble Mr. Justice Yogesh Jaswal, Judge.
1
Whether approved for reporting? Yes.
For the Petitioners : Mr. Shashi Kumar Shirshoo, Central
Government Standing Counsel.
For the Respondent : Mr. Nishant Khidta and Mr. Ashok
Kumar, Advocates.
Ajay Mohan Goel, Judge (Oral)
By way of this writ petition, the petitioners have assailed
order dated 23.10.2028, passed by learned Central Administrative
Tribunal, Chandigarh Bench (Circuit Bench at Shimla) in Original
Application No.063/00534/2017, titled Ram Pal versus Union of
India and others, in terms whereof, the Original Application filed by
the respondent herein was disposed of by the learned Central
Administrative Tribunal in the following terms:-
1
Whether the reporters of the local papers may be allowed to see the Judgment?Yes
::: Downloaded on - 20/11/2026 17:00:35 :::CIS

2
2026:HHC:49521
“6. It is not in dispute that the applicant has been working
with the respondents since his initial engagement in 2002.
When orders for considering his claim for regularization
were issued, the respondents proceeded to reject his claim
vide Annexure A-11 and simultaneously dispensed with his
services. In the rejoinder, the applicant claims that even if
post of Chowkidar is not available, he has been working
against clerical posts and work is available. This plea has
not even been denied by the respondents by filing a counter.
In these circumstances, the inescapable conclusion is that
the respondents indeed have work against which the
applicant has been working. In so far as non existence of
post of Chowkidar is concerned, even if that is accepted on
its face value and decision of this Bench of the Tribunal in
the case of Gopal Singh (supra) rendered by Principal
Bench, New Delhi, is applied to this, one thing is sure that
even if benefit of regularization is denied to him on the
ground of non availability of a post, there is no denial of fact
that the work exists against which the applicant is working
and he can be continued against the same, till a post
become available for considering his claim for regularization
and till then he can be continued on existing terms and
conditions.
High Court of H.P.
7. In view of the above, while upholding order, Annexure
A-11, we quash the order, Annexure A-15, terminating the
services of the applicant with the observation that the
applicant shall continue in service, in terms of above
observations. No costs.”
2. Learned Central Government Standing Counsel
submitted that the order passed by the learned Central
Administrative Tribunal was bad in law, for the reason that the
learned Central Administrative Tribunal erred in not appreciating that
the original application was bad for non-joinder of necessary parties
as the State of Himachal Pradesh, which was a necessary party,
was not impleaded as a party in the proceedings.
::: Downloaded on - 20/11/2026 17:00:35 :::CIS

3
2026:HHC:49521
3. Learned counsel further submitted that the learned
High Court of H.P.
Central Administrative Tribunal erred in not appreciating that in light
of the fact that the Youth Hostel in issue has to generate its own
resources and as it was extremely difficult for the Youth Hostel
where the respondent was serving to generate funds, and thus, pay
the salary to the respondent, the order as was passed by the
learned Central Administrative Tribunal should not have been
passed.
4. Learned counsel further submitted that the Youth
Hostel in issue was unsafe and was in an abandoned condition and
actually no gainful activity is possible there and there is no
requirement of a Chowkidar in the said Youth Hostel and this aspect
of the matter also needs attention.
5. No other point was urged.
6. On the other hand, learned counsel for the respondent
submitted that in light of the fact that the respondent was serving in
the Youth Hostel as a Chowkidar since 2002, the order that has
been passed by the learned Central Administrative Tribunal cannot
be faulted with. He also argued that the respondent was
continuously serving since the year 2002 and it was only when he
raised the demand of regularization that the petitioners terminated
his service and now, they were assailing an order passed by the
::: Downloaded on - 20/11/2026 17:00:35 :::CIS

4
2026:HHC:49521
learned Tribunal, ordering the continuation of service of the
High Court of H.P.
petitioners.
7. Learned counsel for the respondent further submitted
that the petition was not bad for non-joinder of necessary parties,
because the Youth Hostel in issue was under the control of the
present petitioners only and the State of Himachal Pradesh was not
having any control over it. He submitted that the State of Himachal
Pradesh was neither necessary nor a proper party.
8. Having heard learned Central Government Standing
Counsel as also learned counsel for the respondent and having
perused the order under challenge as well as other documents
appended with the petition, we are of the considered view that the
impugned order does not call for any interference.
9. It could not be disputed before us that the respondent
has been serving as a Chowkidar/Watchman at the Youth Hostel in
issue since the year 2002. The Order under challenge was passed
by learned Tribunal in the year 2018 and we stand informed that
pursuant to that order, the respondent is continuing to perform his
duties. The above thus demonstrates that there indeed is work
available, against which the respondent stands engaged, otherwise,
nothing prevented the petitioners herein from praying for an order
during the pendency of this petition that the operation of the order
::: Downloaded on - 20/11/2026 17:00:35 :::CIS

5
2026:HHC:49521
passed by the learned Central Administrative Tribunal be stayed, as
High Court of H.P.
there was no work available for the engagement of the respondent.
10. Learned counsel for the respondent has also informed
us that daily wages were being paid to the respondent for the work
being performed by him pursuant to the order passed by the learned
Central Administrative Tribunal and this aspect should also not be
disputed by the learned Central Government Standing Counsel.
11. The relevant portion of the order passed by the learned
Central Administrative Tribunal has already been quoted by us
hereinabove. A perusal thereof demonstrates that the same is an
innocuous order and all that the learned Central Administrative
Tribunal has been pleased to observe in the said order is that if
benefit of regularization is denied to the respondent herein on the
ground of non-availability of post and as there was no denial of the
fact that the work exists, against which the applicant is working, he
can be continued against the same till a post becomes available for
considering his claim for regularization and till then, he can be
continued on existing terms and conditions.
12. It could not be demonstrated before us on behalf of the
petitioners that these findings returned by the learned Central
Administrative Tribunal were perverse and contrary to the record.
::: Downloaded on - 20/11/2026 17:00:35 :::CIS

6
2026:HHC:49521
13. In light of facts as observed by us hereinabove also, as
High Court of H.P.
the order is innocuous and it is only ensuring that the respondent is
able to make his two ends meet by performing the duties which are
being performed by him since the year 2002, same calls for no
interference.
14. We do not find any merit in the contention raised by the
learned Central Government Standing Counsel that the Original
Application was bad for non-joinder of necessary parties. It could not
be demonstrated before us during the hearing of this petition that the
Youth Hostel where the respondent was serving, was under the
control or ownership of the State of Himachal Pradesh. In light of the
fact that the request for regularization of service of the respondent
has been rejected by the present petitioners and his services were
also terminated by the present petitioners, this demonstrates that the
relationship of employer and employee, if any, is between the
petitioners and the respondent and not between the respondent and
the State of Himachal Pradesh. The contention of the learned
Central Government Standing Counsel that the Youth Hostel is in a
dilapidated condition and no income etc. is being generated from the
same, also does not impresses us for the reason that it is not for the
respondent to maintain the Youth Hostel and if it is in a dilapidated
condition or an abandoned condition, it is for the petitioners to
::: Downloaded on - 20/11/2026 17:00:35 :::CIS

7
2026:HHC:49521
ensure that if they so desire, they can undertake repair work etc.
High Court of H.P.
and use the said premises, may be to run a hostel or for some other
purpose. Accordingly, as we find no reason to interfere with the
order passed by the learned Central Administrative Tribunal, the
petition being devoid of any merit is dismissed. Pending
miscellaneous application(s), if any, also stand disposed of
accordingly.
(Ajay Mohan Goel)
Judge
(Yogesh Jaswal)
Judge
th
17 November, 2026.
( yogesh )
::: Downloaded on - 20/11/2026 17:00:35 :::CIS