Rajendra Prasad vs State Of Goa
- Court
- Supreme Court
2026 INSC 891
NON-REPORTABLE
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
SPECIAL LEAVE PETITION (CRL.) NO. 9754 OF 2026
RAJENDRA PRASAD … PETITIONER
VS.
STATE OF GOA & ANR. … RESPONDENTS
O R D E R
DIPANKAR DATTA, J.
1
1. The High Court of Judicature at Bombay at Goa , by the impugned
th 2
order dated 08 April, 2026 , has rejected the petitioner’s second
application for bail.
th
2. In connection with investigation of FIR No. 90 of 2023 dated 28
August, 2023, registered at Old Goa Police Station, District North Goa
3
under Sections 302 and 201 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 against
unknown accused person(s), the petitioner was identified as an
th
accused and arrested on 29 August, 2023. Upon completion of
Signature Not Verified
Digitally signed by
JATINDER KAUR
Date: 2026.08.19
16:52:46 IST
Reason:
1
High Court
2
Criminal Application (Bail) No. 988 of 2025 (F)
3
IPC
Page 1 of 7
investigation, he was arraigned as Accused No. 1 in the chargesheet
rd
which came to be filed on 23 November, 2023. In due course, the
case was committed to the Sessions Court for trial. Petitioner is
presently facing trial in Sessions Case (302) No. 11 of 2023, for
offences under Sections 342, 302, and 201 read with Section 120-B,
IPC, before the District and Sessions Court, Merces, Tiswadi, North
Goa.
3. According to the prosecution, owing to a pre-existing family/property
dispute at their native village in Gorakhpur, Uttar Pradesh, the
petitioner, along with the co-accused persons, allegedly hatched a
conspiracy to eliminate the victim, Chandrika @ Gabbar Sahani. It is
rd
the case of the prosecution that on 23 August, 2023, the petitioner
deceitfully lured the victim to his rented residence in Porvorim, Goa,
under the pretext of providing painting work. Thereafter, the petitioner
4
and Ranajit Prasad wrongfully confined the victim in a room and
brutally assaulted him with a wooden stick (danda). Subsequently,
5 6
joined by Akhilesh Kumar Sahani and Rajkumar Prasad , the accused
persons tied the unconscious victim to a heavy stone using an orange-
coloured nylon rope and iron hooks, transported the body in a Maruti
Swift car, and disposed it of in the Gaundalim river.
4
Accused No. 2
5
Accused No. 3
6
Accused No. 4
Page 2 of 7
4. Ms. Menaka Guruswamy, learned senior counsel appearing on behalf
of the petitioner, has strenuously contended that the petitioner is
entitled to be enlarged on bail on the ground of parity, inasmuch as
the prosecution’s own chargesheet and counter-affidavit attribute a
similar and indistinguishable role to all four accused; not only that, the
nd th
High Court, vide orders dated 02 September, 2024 and 08 April,
2026, has already granted bail to the co-accused, namely, Accused
No. 3 and Accused No. 4, respectively. The prayer for parity is further
buttressed by the submissions that there is no prima facie material
against the petitioner; that there are inherent inconsistencies in the
prosecution’s narrative; and that the petitioner has suffered prolonged
incarceration of nearly three years without any substantial progress in
the trial.
5. Per contra , it has been submitted by Mr. Abhay Anturkar, learned
counsel appearing on behalf of the respondent-State, that the present
case involves a premeditated grave offence, and that the material
collected during the investigation prima facie discloses the petitioner’s
active role in the alleged murder. More importantly, the ground of
parity is unavailable to the petitioner as his role is demonstrably
distinct and more specific than that of the co-accused who have been
enlarged on bail. Further, since the trial is underway, he has strongly
contended that the petitioner’s release at this stage carries a risk of
prejudice to the fair conduct of the proceedings, particularly in view of
Page 3 of 7
the concerns raised regarding the testimonies of certain material
witnesses, who are known to the petitioner.
6. We have heard learned counsel for the parties.
7. Trial is in progress. Evidence of only one of the sixty-two witnesses
whom the prosecution proposes to examine to drive home the charges
against the petitioner and the co-accused has been recorded.
8. Having carefully perused the materials on record, we are unable to
accept the submissions advanced on behalf of the petitioner.
9. It is trite that grant of bail to one accused does not, ipso facto ,
constitute a ground for granting bail to another accused. Parity is not
a mechanical mathematical formula; it must be assessed based on the
specific role attributed to each accused in the factual matrix.
10. Considering the dicta in Ramesh Bhavan Rathod v. Vishanbhai
7 8
Hirabhai Makwana , Sagar v. State of U.P. and Rekha Sengar v.
9
State of M.P. , in the light of the facts and circumstances of this case,
we are unable to hold that the petitioner can claim an order for grant
of bail on the ground of parity.
11. Prima facie , the material on record reveals the prosecution case that
the petitioner, with requisite intention, was the principal architect of
the plan to eliminate the victim, and with the help of the other accused
(two currently on bail and one still in custody) acted as facilitators in
7
(2021) 6 SCC 230
8
2025 SCC OnLine SC 2584
9
(2021) 3 SCC 729
Page 4 of 7
giving effect to that design. Petitioner’s specific role stands out and
cannot be ignored. Lest the case of either party is prejudiced, we
refrain from delving deep into the matter and making further
observations at this stage. The specific submission based on parity is,
therefore, considered and rejected.
12. Further, the contention raised by Ms. Guruswamy (that the petitioner
has suffered prolonged incarceration of nearly three years without any
substantial progress in the trial) has not impressed us. The
investigation in this case was completed within three months of the
FIR's registration. It has, indeed, been less than three years since the
petitioner’s liberty has been curtailed, but one cannot lose sight of the
fact that the trial has commenced. The mere fact of the petitioner
having been incarcerated for nearly three years or the likelihood of the
trial not concluding within a reasonable period would not by itself
entitle him to be released on bail, given the gravity of the offence
alleged and the possibility of the witnesses being influenced and the
evidence being tampered with.
13. Nevertheless, we are not oblivious of the petitioner’s right to a speedy
trial. Having taken note of the concerns expressed by the respondent-
State that since the prosecution case rests on circumstantial evidence
and having regard to the fact that testimonies of the vulnerable
employee-witnesses and associates are highly sensitive and crucial,
which need to be recorded without any taint, we encourage the
Page 5 of 7
relevant Sessions Court to make sincere endeavour to have the
testimony of the following eight sensitive witnesses recorded, out of
turn, i.e., PW-25 Sonu Sahani, PW-26 Biju Sahani, PW-29 Amarnath
Maurya, PW-30 Shriram Tharu, PW-33 Santu Singh, PW-34 Ganesh
Tharu, PW-36 Sahil Shinde and PW-38 Mahabaleshwar Gouda, within
a year from the date of communication of this order. This observation
need not, however, be understood as requiring the Sessions Court not
to record the testimony of any other witness in the meantime. It shall
be open to the Sessions Court to regulate its own business as it deems
fit and proper in the circumstances.
14. Should recording of the aforesaid eight witnesses be complete even
before the stipulated period of a year ends or be not completed within
such period, the petitioner shall be at liberty to approach the
appropriate forum afresh for consideration of his prayer for grant of
bail. Liberty granted hereby to the petitioner will, however, be subject
to the condition that he cooperates with the Sessions Court and any
delay in recording of the evidence of the aforesaid witnesses is not due
to cause(s) attributable to him.
15. We clarify that any observation on facts has been made solely for the
purpose of deciding the present special leave petition. The same shall
not be construed as findings on the merits of the case before the
Sessions Court.
Page 6 of 7
16. The special leave petition stands disposed of on the above terms.
Pending application(s), if any, shall also stand disposed of.
…………………………….J.
DIPANKAR DATTA
…………………………….J.
SHEEL NAGU
NEW DELHI;
AUGUST 18, 2026.
Page 7 of 7