MAHINDER SINGH SEKHON vs THE STATE OF WEST BENGAL AND ANR
- Court
- Calcutta High Court
IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA
CRIMINAL REVISIONAL JURISDICTION
APPELLATE SIDE
Present:
The Hon’ble Justice Ajay Kumar Gupta
C.R.R. No. 2178 of 2022
Mahinder Singh Sekhon
Versus
The State of West Bengal & Anr.
For the Petitioner : Mr. Sekhar Kumar Basu, Ld. Sr. Adv.
Mr. Saubhik Mitter, Adv.
Ms. Rajnandini Das, Adv.
Mr. Karan Bapuli, Adv.
For the
Opposite Party No. 2 : Mr. Debabrata Acharyya, Adv.
Mr. Sital Samanta, Adv.
For the State : Mr. Sagar Saha, Adv.
Ms. Nayana Mukhopadhyay, Adv.
Heard on : 29.09.2026
Judgment on : 16.11.2026
Uploaded on : 16.11.2026
Ajay Kumar Gupta, J.:-
1. By filing this Criminal Revisional application under Section 482 of the
Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (In short, ‘Cr.P.C.’), the petitioner
2
sought for quashing of the FIR being Ekbalpore P.S. Case No.
365/2020 dated 25.10.2020 under Sections 498A of the Indian Penal
Code, 1860 (corresponding to C.G.R. Case No. 3450/2020) and all
proceedings in connection thereof, now pending before the Court of
th
the Learned Judicial Magistrate, 9 Court, Alipore, South 24
Parganas and the order dated 29.01.2022 passed by the Learned
Chief Judicial Magistrate, Alipore, South 24 Parganas thereby taking
cognizance of the offence as mentioned in the Charge Sheet No.
388/2021 dated 31.12.2021 under Section 498A of the IPC
submitted against the petitioner in connection with the aforesaid
case.
2. The background facts leading to the filing of the instant revisional
application are that on 19.10.2020, when the Petitioner was about 69
years old, his wife/opposite party no. 2 herein lodged a written
complaint alleging inter alia that on 03.01.1983 they got married at a
Gurudwara in Behala, Kolkata and led their conjugal life. However,
on 16.08.1987, nearly five years after their marriage, the opposite
party no. 2 came to know that the petitioner had been deceiving her
by concealing his extramarital affair with a woman named Rajinder
Kaur from Ludhiana, Punjab. She further discovered that the two had
an illegitimate son.
3
3. The opposite party no. 2 thereafter filed a suit being Title Suit No.237
of 1987 praying for declaration of her marriage null. On 29.06.1988,
the Learned Assistant District Judge, 3rd Court, Alipore, South 24
Parganas, allowed her prayer and declared that no marriage had been
solemnised between the petitioner and the opposite party no. 2 on
3.01.1983, and that there had never been any husband-wife
relationship between the parties. It was further declared that the
marriage certificate dated 03.01.1983, issued by the District Marriage
Registrar, Alipore, 24-Parganas(s) under the provisions of the Hindu
Marriage Act and subsequent amendments, is void.
4. Thereafter, the opposite party no. 2 went to Pune to pursue her
education. In the meantime, the petitioner approached her parents,
apologised several times, and also personally expressed his
repentance to her. Having fallen ill with tuberculosis, he took shelter
at her parents’ house, seeking to rekindle their love and affection for
him. The petitioner convinced the opposite party no. 2 that he had
changed and further promised that he would not pursue any illicit
relationship with anyone else. She believed him and resumed living
with him again. On 02.06.1990, a son named Mahan Singh was born
to them, and on 02.12.1992 they married once again. Subsequently,
however, she learnt that on 11.06.1990, Rajinder Kaur had given
birth to a second child on account of the Petitioner’s continuing
4
relationship with her. On being confronted, the petitioner, who had
claimed to have renounced all such relationships, denied any illicit
relationship or illegitimate child and affirmed that he was leading an
honest married life with the opposite party no. 2.
5. The parties continued to live together. On 18.01.1995, the opposite
party No. 2 gave birth to their second son, named Nishan Singh
Sekhon. In March, 1998, they purchased an apartment at Janaki
Apartment, Block A, 60, Kavi Md. Iqbal Road, Kolkata 700023. Till
2015, they lived together peacefully, with barely any friction.
6. On 13.06.2014, the petitioner executed a General Power of Attorney
in favour of the opposite party no. 2, empowering her to sell/transfer
half of his property, which is situated at Mouza Argori, Police Station
Sankrail, District Howrah. From 2015 onwards, however, his
behaviour towards her and their sons changed abruptly.
7. The petitioner stopped caring for the opposite party no. 2 and their
sons, spent no time with them, and became infuriated whenever they
sought an explanation for his estrangement. In 2016, the opposite
party no. 2 met with an accident, as a result of which her right hand
got fractured, for which she had to undergo two major surgeries. At
such trying times, the petitioner provided neither financial nor
emotional support and remained absent. He began visiting Ludhiana,
Punjab frequently on various pretexts.
5
8. In 2018, the opposite party no. 2 learnt that the petitioner had settled
with Rajinder Kaur in Ludhiana, Punjab. She has implored the
petitioner to come back to her, but he turned a blind eye and a deaf
ear to her requests and needs. She then filed an application under
section 9 of the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955 (being MAT Suit No. 3364
of 2018) before the Learned District Judge, Alipore, South 24
Parganas, seeking restitution of conjugal rights.
9. In the year 2019, she learnt that the petitioner had transferred all his
immovable properties, including agricultural land in Dakha, Punjab
and in Bhomaur, in favour of Rajinder Kaur, thereby depriving the
opposite party no. 2 and their sons from enjoying his properties and
cheating her over several years. The petitioner’s case is that he is
innocent and never neglected her and their sons; rather, he also
transferred various properties in her name; therefore, he filed this
application seeking relief as aforesaid. Hence, this application.
10. Mr. Basu, Sr. counsel appearing on behalf of the petitioner,
vehemently argued and submitted that the opposite party no. 2 has
falsely implicated the petitioner without disclosing the essential
ingredients as required to establish an offence under Section 498A of
the IPC; further, the allegations levelled against the present petitioner
are mainly with regard to an extra-marital affair with another woman.
It is an undisputed fact that he had an earlier wife. The marriage was
6
legal with a valid marriage certificate. Their marriage was prior to the
marriage of the opposite party no. 2; two sons were born from the
earlier marriage. The earlier marriage was performed on 09.04.1978,
and the same was a registered marriage. He has two sons from his
second wife, i.e., with the opposite No.2 herein. All were living
peacefully for a long time, but suddenly, she started pressuring him
to transfer all his properties in favour of the opposite party no. 2 and
their two sons only, depriving others, and it was not acceptable to the
petitioner.
11. It was further submitted that the opposite party is a very greedy lady
and always pressurised the petitioner in different ways; it was/is not
possible for him to accept her illegal demands and proposals. He
never neglected them. He always took care even when he was in
Africa, where he worked from 2014-2016. During that period, the
petitioner used to transfer his income digitally to fund the education
and maintenance of the sons. However, the opposite party no. 2
lodged a false and frivolous case 37 years after the initial marriage
and 28 years after the subsequent marriage, only to harass the
petitioner for illegal gain, even though both the petitioner and the
opposite party no. 2 are now septuagenarian. The petitioner is
suffering from various old age ailments, and now he cannot move
here and there freely.
7
12. It was further contended that the petitioner purchased several
properties in Kolkata and Punjab in the name of opposite party No.2,
There is a joint ownership property in Howrah in joint names and
Petitioner executed the general power of attorney in favour her to deal
with his share in the property. The property was sold, but he did not
receive any share from the proceeds of the sale of the said property.
The allegation against the petitioner is only about an extra-marital
relationship, although the said marriage was legal and valid and he
has sons from earlier wedlock. The allegation of an extra-marital
relationship with another woman is not considered to be an offence
punishable under section 498A of the Indian Penal Code. To fortify
his submission, the learned Sr. counsel has placed reliance on two
decisions in the case of Pinakin Mahipatray Rawal v. State of
Gujarat reported in (2013) 3 SCC (Cri) 801 and Wasim v. State
(NCT of Delhi) reported in (2019) 3 SCC (Cri) 69 .
13. It was further contended that during investigation, no substantial
material was collected against the present petitioner to implicate him
for an offence punishable under Section 498A of the IPC. In the
absence of such substantial material, the de-facto complainant’s
accusations appear to be concocted, fabricated and made with mala
fide intention only to harass the petitioners, though he is innocent.
Therefore, allowing such proceeding to continue in the absence of any
8
substantial material against the present petitioner would amount to
abuse of process of law and for securing the ends of justice, the
proceeding may be quashed; otherwise, the petitioner would be highly
prejudiced.
14. Learned counsel appearing on behalf of the opposite party no. 2
vehemently opposed the prayer for quashing of the proceeding and
further submitted that the petitioner was torturing the opposite party
no. 2 in different ways by suppressing his extra-marital relationship
with another woman. The petitioner tortured her in different ways
and neglected the opposite party no. 2 and their sons. She refrained
from lodging any F.I.R. initially, in the hope that the situation would
improve with the passage of time. Instead, it worsened when she
raised the issue of his extramarital relationship, and she was
compelled to lodge the complaint against the petitioner. Therefore,
this case is required to be tried by the Learned Trial Court for proper
adjudication and to punish him. Even after investigation, a prima
facie case has been established against the present petitioner under
Section 498A of the IPC, and when the evidence was collected during
the investigation, this Court may not embark upon the materials
without a full-fledged trial. Therefore, the Revisional application is
liable to be dismissed.
9
15. Learned counsel appearing on behalf of the State produced the case
diary and further concurred with the submission of the learned
counsel appearing on behalf of the opposite party no. 2 and further
submitted that the FIR disclosed the cognizable offence punishable
under Section 498A of the IPC. Accordingly, an FIR was lodged and,
subsequently, after investigation, statements of the witnesses were
recorded under Section 161 of the Cr.P.C., and those statements
establish a prima facie case under Section 498A of the IPC.
Accordingly, the Revisional application is liable to be dismissed.
16. Having considered the arguments and submissions advanced by the
learned counsels for the respective parties and having gone through
the materials available in the case diary and documents annexed
with the Revisional application, this Court finds that the principal
allegation in the complaint is that the petitioner carried on an extra-
marital relationship with another woman from the very inception of
the marriage.
17. It further appears from the record that the petitioner was married to
Rajinder Kaur prior to his second marriage and that he had 2 sons
from that marriage. They reside in Punjab. The opposite party no. 2
herself admits that the petitioner resides in Punjab most of the time.
18. The marriage certificate available on record reveals that the date of
the earlier marriage recorded is 09.04.1978, long before the first
10
marriage of the opposite party no. 2 with the petitioner. She married
the petitioner again in 1992, despite knowing about his relationship
with Rajinder Kaur.
19. It is an undisputed fact that the opposite party no. 2 obtained a
decree from the civil court declaring her previous marriage with the
petitioner void. Even with the knowledge of his previous marriage and
relationship, the opposite party no. 2 married him a second time. She
had filed another similar complaint before the Punjab police on
similar facts, but the same could not be initiated after preliminary
inquiry. She has restricted the allegations against the petitioner to
the effect that he suppressed his illicit relationship with another
woman and his properties have been transferred in her favour, albeit
the previous marriage appears prima facie registered and has two
sons. There is no specific allegation in the FIR regarding physical and
mental torture but in statement recorded under section 161 of sons
disclosed petitioner used to abuse and assault time to time. However,
neither does the FIR disclose any cognizable offence nor a single
instance of abuse or assault upon the opposite party no. 2, nor has
the investigation yielded any material to corroborate such allegations.
20. From the perusal of the FIR and the statements recorded under
Section 161 during investigation, it is revealed that the allegations
are general, omnibus and lacking in particulars. No specific details
11
have been given with regard to the mode and manner of either mental
or physical torture by the Petitioner. In such a situation, a person
cannot be allowed to face the trial. The Hon’ble Supreme Court, time
and again, reiterated that the proceedings against any accused
should not be allowed to continue unless and until there is a specific
allegation and/or ingredient of the offence fulfilled against the
accused.
21. This Court is conscious of the settled legal position that the FIR is not
expected to be an encyclopaedia which indicates every minute detail.
However, during investigation, allegations should be corroborated by
substantive materials. Upon perusal of the FIR, no specific role is
attributed to the petitioner with regard to the allegations or incident
of physical and mental cruelty. No date, time or manner of inflicting
such torture has been mentioned. Mere lodging a criminal case
against any person without particular allegation after 28 years of
marriage does not constitute an offence punishable under Section
498A of the Indian Penal Code. So, it indicates that whatever
allegations made in the FIR appear to be vague and omnibus, only to
harass the petitioner for her illegal purpose or intention, which led to
this Court the proceeding initiated against the present petitioner, who
is now septuagenarian, is only for harassing him with an ulterior
motive. Therefore, this Court holds that the continuation of the
12
criminal proceeding against the present petitioner would result in
sheer abuse of process of law.
22. Upon perusal of the statements recorded under Section 161 of
Cr.P.C., this Court finds that no specific allegations or role are
mentioned by the witnesses against the petitioner. Both sons only
made statements that their father sometimes abused their mother
and assaulted time to time, but upon careful perusal of the written
complaint, there is no such allegation levelled by the opposite party
no.2 in a single word. The first information report or the complaint,
even if they are taken at their face value and accepted in their
entirety do not prima facie constitute any offence or make out a case
against the accused/petitioner.
23. The Hon’ble Supreme Court has repeatedly held that proceedings
against an accused should not continue in the absence of specific
allegations against him. Where no specific role is attributed and no
particulars are furnished, the proceeding deserves to be nipped in the
bud, as its continuation would subject the accused to oppression and
prejudice.
24. It would be apposite to refer to the decisions of the Hon’ble Supreme
Court relied upon by the petitioner as aforesaid.
25. In Pinakin Mahipatray Rawal v. State of Gujarat (Supra) , the
husband had been convicted under Sections 498A and 306 of the IPC
13
after his wife committed suicide. The prosecution case rested entirely
on his alleged extra-marital relationship with a colleague; there was
no evidence of dowry demand or of physical or mental harassment on
that account. In the said case, the Hon’ble Supreme Court noted that
the term “extra-marital relationship” is not defined in the IPC. It held
that merely the fact that a husband develops some intimacy with
another person during the subsistence of the marriage, and fails to
discharge his marital obligations, does not by itself amount to
“cruelty”. To fall within the Explanation to Section 498A, the conduct
must be of such a nature as is likely to drive the spouse to commit
suicide. The Court added that mental harassment, and not only
physical assault, can constitute cruelty, and that mental cruelty
varies from person to person according to the intensity and degree of
endurance. On the facts, it found the relationship was not of such a
nature, and that the prosecution had not discharged its burden of
showing otherwise. The conviction was set aside.
26. In Wasim v. State (NCT of Delhi) (Supra) , the husband was
convicted under Section 498A of the IPC by the trial court for mental
cruelty arising from an extra-marital relationship and threats to leave
his wife. The trial court had found that the dowry demand was not
proved, and the High Court acquitted him under Section 306 on the
ground that neither mental nor physical cruelty was proved. The High
14
Court nevertheless sustained the Section 498A conviction on the
basis of dowry demand, without examining the evidence or the trial
court’s findings on it. The Hon’ble Supreme Court held that cruelty
under Section 498A is of two kinds: wilful conduct likely to drive the
woman to suicide or to cause grave injury or danger to life, limb or
health, or harassment connected with an unlawful demand for
property. Since the High Court had categorically found that neither
mental nor physical cruelty was proved, the conviction could not
stand on the first limb. It also could not be sustained on dowry
demand without a reasoned discussion of the evidence. The
conviction was set aside.
27. The principle that emerges from these decisions is that an extra-
marital relationship, without more, does not constitute cruelty under
Section 498A of the IPC. The prosecution must establish, by evidence,
wilful conduct falling within clause (a) or harassment falling within
clause (b) of the Explanation. In the present case, the allegations in
the FIR are confined to the petitioner’s relationship with another
woman and the transfer of properties to her. The allegations therefore
do not bring the case within either limb of the explanation.
28. After careful scrutiny of the materials available in the case diary, this
Court does not find any sufficient or cogent materials against the
present petitioner. Even if, for the sake of argument, these
15
proceedings were to be continued, the conviction of petitioner appears
bleak and remote. To secure the ends of justice, the proceedings are
deserved to be quashed under the inherent power granted under
Section 482 of the Cr.P.C. insofar as the petitioner is concerned.
29. In the light of the above facts and discussions of this Court and in
view of observations made by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the
above cited judgment, this Court is fully satisfied that this case falls
within Categories 1, 3, and 7 of the guidelines in State of Haryana
v. Bhajan Lal , reported in 1992 Supp (1) SCC 33.
30. Accordingly, CRR No. 2178 of 2022 is, thus, allowed . Pending
applications, if any, are also, thus, disposed of.
31. Consequently, FIR being Ekbalpore P.S. Case No. 365/2020 dated
25.10.2020 under Sections 498A of the Indian Penal Code, 1860
(corresponding to C.G.R. Case No. 3450/2020) and all proceedings in
connection thereof, now pending before the Court of the Learned
Judicial Magistrate, 9th Court, Alipore, South 24 Parganas and the
order dated 29.01.2022 passed by the Learned Chief Judicial
Magistrate, Alipore, South 24 Parganas thereby taking cognizance of
the offence as mentioned in the Charge Sheet No. 388/2021 dated
31.12.2021 under Section 498A of the IPC are hereby quashed and
set aside insofar as the present petitioner is concerned.
16
32. Let a copy of this Judgment be sent to the Learned Court below for
information.
33. Interim order, if any, stands vacated.
34. Case diary be returned to the learned counsel for the state.
35. All parties will act on the server copies of this Judgment duly
downloaded from the official website of this Hon’ble High Court.
36. Urgent photostat certified copy of this Judgment, if applied for, is to
be given as expeditiously to the parties on compliance of all legal and
necessary formalities.
(Ajay Kumar Gupta, J.)
(P.A.)