THE ORIENTAL INSURANCE CO LTD vs SMT FAIROZA
- Court
- Karnataka High Court
- 1 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63078
MFA No. 5936 of 2022
CNR: KAHC010382662022
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU
TH
DATED THIS THE 16 DAY OF NOVEMBER, 2026
BEFORE
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE S RACHAIAH
MISCELLANEOUS FIRST APPEAL NO. 5936 OF 2022
(MV-D)
BETWEEN:
1. THE ORIENTAL INSURANCE CO. LTD.,
SAGAR.
THROUGH ITS
BENGALURU REGIONAL OFFICE
NO.44/45, LEO SHOPPING COMPLEX,
TH
4 FLOOR, RESIDENCY ROAD CROSS,
BENGALURU – 560 025.
REPRESENTED BY ITS MANAGER.
…APPELLANT
(BY SRI. S. V. HEGDE MULKHAND., ADVOCATE)
Digitally
signed by
SUSHMA
LAKSHMI B
S
Location:
High Court
of Karnataka
AND:
1. SMT. FAIROZA,
W/O LATE NAZEER SAB,
AGED ABOUT 56 YEARS,
ANKARAVALLI VILLAGE,
SORABA TALUK,
SHIVAMOGGA DISTRICT – 577 429.
2. SRI. MANGALAMOORTHY,
S/O RAMACHANDRA,
AGED ABOUT 50 YEARS,
R/O KEREKOPPA VILLAGE,
- 2 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63078
MFA No. 5936 of 2022
CNR: KAHC010382662022
SORABA TALUK,
SHIVAMOGGA DISTRICT – 577 429.
3. SRI. S. G. VINAYA,
S/O GOPALAPPA,
AGED ABOUT 43 YEARS,
S/O SAMPEKATTE,
HOSANAGARA TALUK,
SHIVAMOGGA DISTRICT – 577 418.
4. B. K. RAGHAVENDRA,
S/O KASHI MANJAPPA,
AGED ABOUT 60 YEARS,
SECRETARY OF
VIDYA ABHIVRUDDI SANGHA
PRIMARY SCHOOL,
NISRANI, SORABA TALUK,
R/O BANADAKOPPA VILLAGE,
ULAVI HOBLI, SORABA TALUK,
SHIVAMOGGA DISTRICT – 577 429.
…RESPONDENTS
(BY SMT. VINUTHA P. KALE., ADVOCATE FOR R1;
R2 – R4 ARE SERVED)
----
THIS MFA IS FILED U/S 173(1) OF MV ACT AGAINST THE
JUDGMENT AND AWARD DATED 01.01.2022, PASSED IN
MVC.NO.81/2017, ON THE FILE OF THE SENIOR CIVIL JUDGE
AND MEMBER, ADDITIONAL M.A.C.T.-XIII, SORABA, PARTLY
ALLOWING THE CLAIM PETITION FOR COMPENSATION.
THIS APPEAL, COMING ON FOR ORDERS, THIS DAY,
JUDGMENT WAS DELIVERED THEREIN AS UNDER:
- 3 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63078
MFA No. 5936 of 2022
CNR: KAHC010382662022
CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE S RACHAIAH
ORAL JUDGMENT
1. This appeal is filed by the Insurance Company
st
being aggrieved by the judgment and award dated 01
January 2022 passed in MVC.No.81/2017 on the file of
Senior Civil Judge and Member, Additional MACT, XIII,
Soraba.
Factual matrix of the case:
2. The case of the prosecution is that on
15/09/2015 at about 8:30 a.m., the son of the petitioner
was coming from Ankarvalli to Sagar on his motorbike
bearing registration number KA-15-J-8816. While he was
coming near the house of Chandrappa of Bandige village
on Sagar Road, a Ambika bus bearing registration No.KA-
20-C-6197 came from opposite direction and hit the
motorbike of the deceased. As a result, the rider of the
motorbike sustained grievous injuries and succumbed to
the said injuries.
- 4 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63078
MFA No. 5936 of 2022
CNR: KAHC010382662022
3. It is further submitted that the deceased was
completed diploma in civil engineering and he was working
in a private construction company and he was earning
salary of Rs.18,000/- per month. The deceased was aged
22 years at the time of the accident. A claim petition was
filed by the father of the deceased. The tribunal awarded
compensation for a sum of Rs.29,86,000/- along with
interest at the rate of 6% per annum. Being aggrieved by
the same, the appellant is before this Court seeking
enhancement of the compensation.
4. Heard learned counsel for the respective
parties.
5. Learned counsel for the appellant submits that
the income taken by the tribunal is contrary to the settled
principle of law. Mere production of the document is not
sufficient to hold that he was working and drawing the said
salary unless the employer of the said company is
examined to that extent. It is further submitted that the
- 5 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63078
MFA No. 5936 of 2022
CNR: KAHC010382662022
tribunal has committed error in taking 50% of future
prospects instead of taking 40%. In addition to that, the
tribunal has committed error in appreciating the evidence
even though the deceased was not having the driving
license to drive the motor bike. As the tribunal has
committed grievous error in all these aspects it is
appropriate to allow the appeal in accordance with law.
Having said this, learned counsel for the appellant prays to
allow the appeal.
Per Contra
6. , learned counsel for the respondent
No.1 vehemently justified the judgment and award passed
by the tribunal and further submitted that after
considering the oral and documentary evidence on record
the tribunal has passed the award. In fact, the appellant
has completed diploma in civil engineering and he was
working as a consultant and drawing the salary as stated
in the salary certificate which is marked as Ex-P21.
Merely, because the father of the deceased has not
produced the driving license of the deceased, that itself is
- 6 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63078
MFA No. 5936 of 2022
CNR: KAHC010382662022
not the ground to deny the relief as granted by the
tribunal. Therefore, learned counsel for the respondent
prays to dismiss the appeal.
7. Having heard learned counsel for the respective
parties and also on perusal of the findings of the tribunal,
it appears that the tribunal while considering the income of
the deceased has relied on the document produced by the
petitioner which is marked as Ex-P.21 which indicates that
the deceased was working as Consultant after completing
his diploma in civil engineering and was drawing a salary
of Rs.18,000/- per month. However, the employer of the
deceased has not been examined to substantiate the
same. Having considered the same, it is appropriate to
take the income of the deceased as
Rs.15,000/- per month by taking into consideration that
he has completed his diploma in civil engineering. In
addition to that, the tribunal while fixing the liability on the
insurance company has failed to take note of the fact that
the deceased was not having driving license to drive the
- 7 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63078
MFA No. 5936 of 2022
CNR: KAHC010382662022
said vehicle. These aspects are crucial to the tribunal to
fasten the liability. Having failed to consider the same, it is
appropriate to reconsider the same in the following
manner.
8. Since the deceased was not having a driving
license it is not appropriate to fix the entire liability on the
Insurance Company alone. Accordingly, it is appropriate to
fix 30% of contributory negligence towards the deceased.
In addition to that, since the deceased was not working in
a recognized sector, in view of the judgment of the
Honorable Supreme Court in the case of Pranay Sethi , it
is appropriate to take 40% of the future prospectus.
15,000 x 12 + 40% - 50% x 18 = 22,68,000/-
9. On considering all these aspects, the
compensation has been re-determined as follows:
- 8 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63078
MFA No. 5936 of 2022
CNR: KAHC010382662022
Sl. This
Heads Tribunal
No. Court
01. Towards loss of
dependency
29,16,000 22,68,000
02. Towards loss of
estate
15,000 15,000
03. Towards loss of
consortium
40,000 40,000
04. Towards funeral
expenditure
15,000 15,000
TOTAL 29,86,000 23,38,000
10. In the light of the observations made above, I
proceed to pass the following:
ORDER
allowed in part.
i) Miscellaneous First Appeal is
st
ii) The judgment and award dated
01 January 2022
passed in MVC.No.81/2017 on the file of Senior Civil
Judge and Member, Additional MACT, XIII, Soraba , is
modified, granting compensation of Rs.23,38,000/-
(Rupees Twenty Three Lakhs Thirty Eight Thousand only)
as against Rs.29,86,000/- awarded by the Tribunal.
iii) The 70% of the compensation amount shall be deposited
by the Insurance Company within a period of eight weeks
- 9 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63078
MFA No. 5936 of 2022
CNR: KAHC010382662022
from the date of receipt of the certified copy of this
judgment.
iv) The Registry is directed to communicate the order to the
Tribunal and send the records to the Trial Court forthwith.
v) The excess amount, if any, deposited by the appellant
shall be refunded to the appellant – Insurance Company.
Sd/-
(S RACHAIAH)
JUDGE
NM/-
List No.: 1 Sl No.: 7