Anshu vs Nitin Kumar
- Court
- Delhi High Court
$~77
* IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
%
#
CNR No.DLHC010430322026
Date of Decision: 03.11.2026
CRL.A. 909/2026, CRL.M.A.No.28212/2026
+
ANSHU .....Appellant
Through: Mr. Siddharth Satija, Advocate
(DHCLSC) along with Mr. Sriharsh
Raj, Mr. Akash Sachan, Mr. Shashanka
Tewari, Ms. Akanksha Bisht, Ms.
Charu Sinha and Mr. Raghav Gupta,
Advocates.
versus
NITIN KUMAR .....Respondent
Through: None.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SACHIN DATTA
SACHIN DATTA, J (Oral.)
1. The appellant assails an order dated 17.03.2026 passed by the learned
Principal District & Sessions Judge, North-East District, Karkardooma Courts,
Delhi in MISC CRL No.50/2025.
2. By that order, on the application of the respondent, the learned Principal
District & Sessions Judge directed that a complaint be made against the
appellant for filing a fake medical certificate.
3. The factual conspectus is that the complaint of the appellant under the
Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act, 2005, was dismissed for
non-prosecution on 09.10.2024.
4. In an appeal against that order, the appellant filed a medical certificate
dated 09.10.2024. The same is as under:-
CRL.A. 909/2026 Page 1 of 11
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed
By:UMANG
Signing Date:18.11.2026
12:06:52
5. On the objection of the respondent, the learned Principal District &
Sessions Judge passed the following order on 18.10.2025:-
CRL.A. 909/2026 Page 2 of 11
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed
By:UMANG
Signing Date:18.11.2026
12:06:52
6. Thereafter, the SHO reported that the clinic had closed and had
functioned only in 2019-20 and that Dr. Shahin was never associated with it
and had issued no certificate. The report submitted by the SHO is as under:-
CRL.A. 909/2026 Page 3 of 11
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed
By:UMANG
Signing Date:18.11.2026
12:06:52
7. On 23.12.2025, the learned Principal District & Sessions Judge recorded
that the certificate was prima facie fake and the appellant withdrew her appeal.
8. After considering the appellant’s reply and hearing both sides, the
impugned order was thereafter passed on 17.03.2026. The same reads as
under:-
CRL.A. 909/2026 Page 4 of 11
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed
By:UMANG
Signing Date:18.11.2026
12:06:52
CRL.A. 909/2026 Page 5 of 11
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed
By:UMANG
Signing Date:18.11.2026
12:06:52
9. Learned counsel for the appellant submits as follows:
i. It is submitted that the requirement that it be expedient in the interest of
justice to make a complaint is not satisfied. It is submitted that the
appellant derived no benefit from the certificate, which was obtained
outside the Court and in good faith;
ii. It is submitted that in terms of Section 343(1) of the CrPC, the case
cannot be tried as a complaint case;
iii. It is submitted that the impugned order contains observations which
amount to conclusions on guilt such that the trial stands foreclosed; and
iv. The certificate was not in the custody of the Court when the alleged
offence was committed so that in view of Paragraph 10 of Iqbal Singh
Marwahv.MeenakshiMarwah (2005) 4 SCC 370, no complaint by the
Court was called for.
10. I have given my thoughtful consideration to the said submissions.
11. At the outset, it is noted that the certificate was filed and the application
for prosecution was made after 01.07.2024. As such, the procedure is governed
by Section 379 of the BharatiyaNagarikSurakshaSanhita, 2023
(BNSS). The
reference in the impugned order to Section 340 CrPC is a misdescription which
causes no prejudice.
12. As to the first submission of the learned counsel for the appellant, it is
trite that the Court is not bound to make a complaint merely because an offence
appears to have been committed. It must form an opinion that it is expedient in
the interest of justice to do so. In this regard, it is apposite to refer to the
following observations in Iqbal Singh Marwah (supra):
23. In view of the language used in Section 340 CrPC the court
is not bound to make a complaint regarding commission of an
offence referred to in Section 195(1)(b), as the section is
conditioned by the words “court is of opinion that it is expedient
CRL.A. 909/2026 Page 6 of 11
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed
By:UMANG
Signing Date:18.11.2026
12:06:52
in the interests of justice”. This shows that such a course will be
adopted only if the interest of justice requires and not in every
case. Before filing of the complaint, the court may hold a
preliminary enquiry and record a finding to the effect that it is
expedient in the interests of justice that enquiry should be made
into any of the offences referred to in Section 195(1)(b)
. This
expediency will normally be judged by the court by weighing not
the magnitude of injury suffered by the person affected by such
forgery or forged document, but having regard to the effect or
impact, such commission of offence has upon administration of
justice. It is possible that such forged document or forgery may
cause a very serious or substantial injury to a person in the sense
that it may deprive him of a very valuable property or status or
the like, but such document may be just a piece of evidence
produced or given in evidence in court, where voluminous
evidence may have been adduced and the effect of such piece of
evidence on the broad concept of administration of justice may
be minimal. In such circumstances, the court may not consider it
expedient in the interest of justice to make a complaint. The
broad view of clause (b)(ii), as canvassed by learned counsel for
the appellants, would render the victim of such forgery or forged
document remediless. Any interpretation which leads to a
situation where a victim of a crime is rendered remediless, has to
be discarded .
13. The expediency is to be judged having regard to the effect or impact
which the commission of such offence has upon the administration of justice
rather than the magnitude of injury to an individual. In the present case, the
opinion is well found because the appellant herself filed the certificate in her
own appeal as the only explanation for her absence. Moreover, its genuineness
was tested by verification directed by the Court and not on the plea of the
respondent alone.
14. Further, the verification shows that the concerned clinic from which the
certificate is alleged to have been obtained was not functioning at the relevant
time and the doctor did not issue the certificate.
CRL.A. 909/2026 Page 7 of 11
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed
By:UMANG
Signing Date:18.11.2026
12:06:52
15. These facts have not been controverted.
16. The appellant was duly heard before the order was passed.
17. In the opinion of this Court, a document of this kind filed in Court
proceedings to explain a default and to obtain restoration bears directly on the
administration of justice. This is precisely the class of case in which the interest
of justice calls for a complaint.
18. The plea that the appellant did not benefit from the production of such a
document does not help the appellant. The certificate was filed to obtain
restoration of her complaint, and the appeal was withdrawn only after the
certificate was found to be prima facie fake.
19. As to the submissions regarding Section 343(1) of the CrPC (now
Section 382 (1) of the BNSS), it is trite that a Magistrate to whom a complaint
is made by a Court under these provisions is to deal with the case as far as may
be as if it were instituted on a police report notwithstanding the provisions
applicable to complaint case.
20. The submission is correct as to the statement of procedure but it goes
only to the manner in which the case is to be tried by the learned Magistrate.
The same furnishes no ground to interfere with the decision to make the
complaint. The learned Magistrate shall necessarily proceed in terms of section
382 (1) BNSS, in accordance with law.
21. As to the third submission, at the stage of deciding whether to make a
complaint, the Court only forms a prima facie opinion. It does not and cannot
decide guilt.
22. It is clarified that every observation in the impugned order is only a
prima facie view recorded for the limited purpose of deciding whether a
complaint should be made. It shall not be construed as a finding that the
certificate is forged or that the appellant knew it to be false or used it
CRL.A. 909/2026 Page 8 of 11
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed
By:UMANG
Signing Date:18.11.2026
12:06:52
dishonestly.
23. The learned Magistrate shall decide every question including the
genuineness of the certificate and the knowledge and intention of the appellant
only on the basis of the evidence led in the trial, uninfluenced by the
observations made in the impugned order.
24. As regards the fourth submission, it is noticed that Iqbal Singh Marwah
(supra) is concerned with Clause b(ii) of Section 195(1) of CrPC which relates
to offence of forgery and use of forged document under Sections 463, 471, 475
and 476 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 “in respect of a document produced or
given in evidence in a proceeding in any Court”. It was held that the bar under
that clause applies only where such an offence is committed after the document
is produced in Court i.e., while it is in custodia legis . In doing so, the Supreme
Court contrasted Clause b(ii) with Clause b(i) observing that the offences in
Clause b(i) clearly relate to giving or fabricating false evidence in judicial
proceedings and having a direct co-relation with the proceedings in the Court
of justice. In this regard, reference may be made to Paragraph 10 of Iqbal
Singh Marwah (supra) as under:
“ 10. The scheme of the statutory provision may now be
examined. Broadly, Section 195 CrPC deals with three distinct
categories of offences which have been described in clauses (a),
(b)(i) and (b)(ii) and they relate to (1) contempt of lawful
authority of public servants, (2) offences against public justice,
and (3) offences relating to documents given in evidence. Clause
(a) deals with offences punishable under Sections 172 to 188 IPC
which occur in Chapter X IPC and the heading of the Chapter is
— “Of Contempts of the Lawful Authority of Public Servants”.
These are offences which directly affect the functioning of or
discharge of lawful duties of a public servant. Clause (b)(i)
refers to offences in Chapter XI IPC which is headed as — “Of
False Evidence and Offences Against Public Justice”. The
CRL.A. 909/2026 Page 9 of 11
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed
By:UMANG
Signing Date:18.11.2026
12:06:52
offences mentioned in this clause clearly relate to giving or
fabricating false evidence or making a false declaration in any
judicial proceeding or before a court of justice or before a public
servant who is bound or authorised by law to receive such
declaration, and also to some other offences which have a direct
correlation with the proceedings in a court of justice (Sections
205 and 211 IPC). This being the scheme of two provisions or
clauses of Section 195 viz. that the offence should be such which
has direct bearing or affects the functioning or discharge of
lawful duties of a public servant or has a direct correlation with
the proceedings in a court of justice, the expression “when such
offence is alleged to have been committed in respect of a
document produced or given in evidence in a proceeding in any
court” occurring in clause (b)(ii) should normally mean
commission of such an offence after the document has actually
been produced or given in evidence in the court. The situation or
contingency where an offence as enumerated in this clause has
already been committed earlier and later on the document is
produced or is given in evidence in court, does not appear to be
in tune with clauses (a)(i) and (b)(i) and consequently with the
scheme of Section 195 CrPC.
This indicates that clause (b)(ii)
contemplates a situation where the offences enumerated therein
are committed with respect to a document subsequent to its
production or giving in evidence in a proceeding in any court.”
25. The complaint directed here is for the offence of fabricating false
evidence under Section 192 read with Section 193 of the Indian Penal Code
(corresponding to sections 228 and 229 of the BNS), which fall in Clause b(i)
[now Clause b(i) of section 215 (1) of the BNSS] and not for forgery under
Clause b(ii).
26. The essence of the allegation is that the appellant used the certificate as
evidence in CA No. 61/2025 to explain a default. The alleged offence is thus
committed in, or in relation to, a proceeding in Court and directly affects the
administration of justice. The custodialegis limitation laid down in Iqbal Singh
Marwah (supra) applies to forgery under Clause (b)(ii) and does not, therefore,
CRL.A. 909/2026 Page 10 of 11
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed
By:UMANG
Signing Date:18.11.2026
12:06:52
avail the appellant.
27. In the circumstances, the appeal is dismissed.
28. Let a copy of this order be sent to the learned Principal District &
Sessions Judge, North-East District, Karkardooma Courts, Delhi for
information.
SACHIN DATTA, J
NOVEMBER 3, 2026/r
CRL.A. 909/2026 Page 11 of 11
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed
By:UMANG
Signing Date:18.11.2026
12:06:52