Abhinash Baruah vs Central Bank Of India And 2 Ors

Court
Gauhati High Court

GAHC010129662025
2026:GAU-AS:14229

THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(THE HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM & ARUNACHAL PRADESH)

Writ petition [c] no. 3344/2025


Shri Abhinash Baruah, aged about 46 years, son
of Pradip Baruah, R/O – Subachani Road, P.O. –
Tinsukia, District – Tinsukia, Assam, PIN 786125.

………………Petitioner

- VERSUS -

1. Central Bank of India, having its registered Central
Office at Chandermukhi Nirman Point, P.O. & P.S.
and Dist.- Mumbai, Maharashtra, PIN – 400001.
2. Chief Manager cum Authorized Officer, Central
Bank of India, Regional Office at Nehru Park
Road, P.O. & P.S. – Jorhat, District – Jorhat,
Assam, PIN 785001.
3. The Branch Manager, Central Bank of India,
st
Dibrugarh Branch, Bhagawan Building 1 Floor,
H.S. Road, P.O. & P.S. – Dibrugarh, District –
Dibrugarh, Assam, PIN 786001.
………………. Respondents
Page 1 of 28

BeFore
Hon’BLe Mr. JUStice MAniSH cHoUDHUrY



Advocates :

Advocate for the Petitioner : Mr. B.K. Das, Advocate

Advocate for the Respondent
Central Bank of India Authorities : Mr. M. Sharma, Advocate

Date of hearings : 25.08.2026 & 17.09.2026
Date of pronouncement of judgment : 17.09.2026
Whether the pronouncement is of the
Operative part of the judgment ? : No
Whether the full judgment has been
Pronounced ? : Yes



JUDGMent & orDer


The case of the petitioner herein for invoking the extra-ordinary and
discretionary jurisdiction of this Court under Article 226 of the Constitution of
India is that he after becoming successful in an auction sale process undertaken
by the respondent Central Bank of India authorities could not reap the benefit of
Page 2 of 28

his investment till date, as he has neither been handed over physical possession
of the purchased landed property nor he has been refunded the invested
amount. In the process, his another landed property was to be kept in mortgage
with the respondent Bank.

2. The facts leading to filing of the writ petition can be exposited, in brief, at first.
The respondent Central Bank of India [hereinafter referred to as ‘the respondent
Bank’, for easy reference] authorities through its Authorized Officer took
symbolic possession of a landed property – a plot of land measuring 0 Bigha, 02
Kathas & 15 Lessas, covered by Dag no. 19 of Patta no. 232, located at Gabhoru
Pothar Ward, Mouza – Dibrugarh, District – Dibrugarh, Assam with defined
boundaries [hereinafter referred to as the 'subject-property', for ready reference]
under Section 13[4] of the Securitization and Reconstruction of Financial Assets
and Enforcement of Security Interest Act, 2002 ['the SARFAESI Act', for short].

3. At an earlier point of time, the subject-property was mortgaged in favour of the
respondent Bank by one Sri Rajkumar Shah [‘the borrower’, for short] along with
Smti. Sapna Kumari for availing financial facilities under Cent Mortgage Loan
Scheme of the respondent Bank. After the borrower defaulted in making
repayment against the Cent Mortgage Loan Account no. 2059221892 as per the
terms and conditions of the loan agreement, the respondent Bank declared the
Loan Account as Non-Performing Asset [NPA] on 31.05.2012.

4. After taking over symbolic possession of the subject-property, the Authorized
Officer of the respondent Bank published an Auction Sale Notice dated
07.04.2014. By the Auction Sale Notice, sealed tenders were invited from
Page 3 of 28

intending tenderers for sale of five nos. of landed properties. Among the five
landed properties mentioned in the Auction Sale Notice dated 07.04.2014, one of
the landed properties belonged to Sri Rajkumar Shah, Proprietor of M/s Maa
Shanti Rice Mill; and another one of the landed properties belonged to Sri
Rajkumar Shah & Smti. Sapna Kumari. The landed property which belonged
jointly to Sri Rajkumar Shah & Smti. Sapna Kumari is the subject-property and is
the subject-matter of this writ petition.

5. As per the Auction Sale Notice dated 07.04.2014, the intending bidders were to
send their bids separately for each of the five landed properties along with the
respective Earnest Money Deposit [EMD], which was 10% of the reserved price,
by means of a demand draft drawn in favour of the respondent Bank payable at
Jorhat on or before 08.05.2014. The reserved price fixed against the subject-
property was Rs. 36.05 Lakhs. The Auction Sale Notice dated 07.04.2014 was
published in newspapers including in the English daily newspaper, ‘
The Assam
Tribune’ , in its issue dated 08.04.2014. The sealed tenders were to be opened
by the Authorized Officer in the presence of the available / attending tenderers.

6. In the course of the auction sale process, the petitioner submitted his bid at Rs.
29,50,000/- against the subject-property. The bid value offered by the petitioner
was accepted by the Competent Authority of the respondent Bank.
Acknowledging the receipt of Rs. 29,50,000/-, that is, the auction sale price in
full, from the petitioner, the Authorized Officer issued a Sale Certificate as per
Appendix – V on 27.09.2014.

Page 4 of 28

7. As even after elapse of about eleven years from the issuance of the Sale
Certificate the petitioner as the auction purchaser was not handed over physical
possession of the subject-property by the respondent Bank authorities, the
petitioner has approached this Court by the present writ petition under Article
226 of the Constitution of India seeking a direction in the nature of mandamus
to the respondent Bank authorities to hand over the possession of all part and
parcel of the subject-property, and also, to pay interest @ 18% on the amount
of Rs. 29,50,000/- from the date of issuance of the Sale Certificate dated
27.09.2014 till delivery of possession of the subject-property to compensate the
loss suffered by the petitioner.

8. I have heard Mr. B.K. Das, learned counsel for the petitioner; and Mr. M.
Sharma, learned counsel for the respondent Central Bank of India authorities.

9. Mr. Das, learned counsel appearing for the petitioner has submitted that the
petitioner duly participated in the auction sale process initiated by the Auction
Sale Notice date 07.04.2014 and emerged as the successful bidder for the
subject-property when he offered the bid value of Rs. 29,50,000/-. He has
submitted that the petitioner had fulfilled all the terms and conditions of the
auction sale process. For the purpose of depositing the offered amount, the
petitioner also applied for a loan from the respondent Central Bank of India itself
and on 24.09.2014, the respondent Bank sanctioned a loan amount of Rs.
25,00,000/- under its Cent Trade Scheme with the rate of interest : @ 10.25
Base Rate + 3.0 presently [13.25% per annum]. After sanctioning of the loan
amount, the petitioner completed payment of the auction sale price and the
respondent Bank issued the Sale Certificate on 27.09.2014. But, due to litigations
Page 5 of 28

initiated by, and at the instance of, the borrower against the auction sale process
and the proceedings initiated under the SARFAESI Act, the petitioner was denied
the physical possession of the subject-property in the subsequent period. No
earnest efforts were seen from the end of the respondent Bank authorities
during all these years to take over physical possession of the subject-property in
order to hand over its physical possession to the petitioner. It was the petitioner
who had to make all efforts to secure physical possession of the subject-property
by instituting legal proceedings, when the situation permitted. He has further
contended that despite termination of all the legal proceedings in the year 2024,
there is apparent inaction and reluctance on the part of the respondent Bank
authorities to hand over physical possession of the subject-property till the time
of institution of the writ petition. He has, thus, contended that the directions, as
sought for, in the present writ petition are just and proper, which are called for
in the obtaining fact situation. Mr. Das has further submitted that in the event it
is not possible for the respondent Bank authorities to hand over physical
possession of the subject-property, as it is projected to be encumbered, the
petitioner who has been exasperated after enduring such long ordeal, shall be
refunded the amount he had deposited at the time of auction and is to be
appropriately compensated with interest. For payment of any amount towards
interest or compensation, the interest the petitioner had to pay for obtaining the
loan to deposit the auction sale amount is to be taken into consideration.

10. Mr. Sharma, learned counsel appearing for the respondent Bank authorities has
submitted that the writ petition has suffered from delay and laches. It is
submitted that possession was taken by the writ petitioner at the time of
issuance of Sale Certificate. The subject-property came under protracted
Page 6 of 28

litigation thereafter, and got encumbered also. He has submitted that the
respondent Bank can initiate action to take physical possession of the subject-
property once again as per provisions of the SARFAESI Act, provided the
petitioner is ready and willing to bear the necessary costs. Mr. Sharma has
referred to the statements and averments in the affidavit-in-opposition filed by
the respondent Bank authorities to support his submissions.

11. I have duly considered the submissions of the learned counsel for the parties
and have gone through the materials brought on record by the parties through
their pleadings. I have also gone through the decisions cited at the Bar.

12. As per the terms and conditions laid down in the Auction Sale Notice dated
07.04.2014, the successful bidder was to deposit 25% of the bid amount
[without interest and inclusive of EMD] immediately after the auction on the
same day of the sale in cheque or demand draft. The balance of the bid amount
was required to be paid within fifteen days from the date of confirmation of sale
or such extended period as agreed by the Authorized Officer. All the statutory
dues, charges, fees payable for conveyance such as stamp duty, registration
fees, etc. as applicable as per law and Income Tax laws were to be borne by the
successful bidder. It was mentioned that if the subject-property was not sold on
the date of auction scheduled in the Auction Sale Notice dated 07.04.2014, the
same would be put to auction again at the same time, the same venue and the
same date of the following three months and for that, there would be no further
publication. It was mentioned that, the Auction Sale Notice was also to be
treated as thirty days' sale notice to the borrower, guarantor and / or mortgager.

Page 7 of 28

13. It is noticed that assailing the proceedings initiated by the respondent Bank
under the SARFAESI Act and the auction sale of the subject-property below the
reserved price, the borrower as the writ petitioner approached this Court by a
writ petition, W.P.[C.] no. 6015/2014. On 24.11.2014, while issuing notice, an
interim order was passed to the effect that the borrower shall not be
dispossessed of the subject-property till the returnable date, 30.01.2015.

14. After the interim Order dated 24.11.2014, the Authorized Officer of the
respondent Bank informed the present writ petitioner by an Office Letter dated
09.12.2024 that delivery of physical possession of the subject-property was
temporarily held up till the outcome of the writ petition preferred by the
borrower.

15. The writ petition, W.P.[C.] no. 6015/2014 was finally heard on 21.05.2018. The
Division Bench observed that in United Bank of India vs. Satyawati Tondon,
[2010] 8 SCC 110 , the Hon'ble Supreme Court had held that the High Courts
should not ignore availability of the statutory remedies under the Debts Recovery
Tribunal Act and the SARFAESI Act and passing of interim orders by the High
Courts under Article 226 would have serious adverse impact on the rights of the
Banks and other financial institutions to recover their dues. The Division Bench
having regard to the decision in Satyawati Tondon [supra], directed the
borrower to avail the remedy as provided under Section 17 of the SARFAESI Act
and further observed that if the borrower would avail the remedy within one
month from 21.05.2018, the Debts Recovery Tribunal shall decide the borrower’s
application on merit. Before the Court, the borrower-writ petitioner implored that
the interim protection granted to him earlier by the Court be allowed to continue.
Page 8 of 28

As it was agreed to on behalf of the respondent Bank, the Division Bank directed
that the parties shall maintain status-quo, as it existed on 21.05.2018, for a
period of two months.

16. The borrower, that is, the petitioner in W.P.[C.] no. 6015/2014 failed to prefer
any appeal under Section 17 of the SARFAESI Act within the time period of one
month, as allowed by the Division Bench by its Order dated 21.05.2018. He had
again approached the Division Bench by way of an interlocutory application,
I.A.[Civil] no. 3157/2018 seeking grant of further time to prefer the appeal under
Section 17 of the SARFAESI Act. In its Order dated 03.09.2018, the Division
Bench observed that despite liberty given, the borrower did not avail the remedy
under Section 17 of the SARFAESI Act within the period granted by the Order
dated 21.05.2018. The borrower was found to have made an application before
the Debts Recovery Tribunal, Guwahati seeking condonation of the delay as the
appeal under Section 17 of the SARFAESI Act was not preferred within the time
period of one month, as provided in the Order dated 21.05.2018. The said
application for condonation of delay was dismissed by the Debts Recovery
Tribunal vide its Order dated 24.07.2018. In view of such facts and
circumstances, the Division Bench did not find any merit in the interlocutory
application on two counts, firstly, the borrower was not diligent enough to avail
the remedy under Section 17 of the SARFAESI Act despite sufficient time granted
by the Court to avail the remedy vide Order dated 21.05.2018 passed in W.P.[C.]
6015/2014; and secondly, it was brought to the notice of the Division Bench that
the borrower had suppressed material facts inasmuch as a part of the mortgaged
subject-property was sold off vide a Deed no. 2738 dated 23.11.2015. The
Division Bench found that the bona fide of the borrower to pay back the
Page 9 of 28

outstanding loan amount was in question and before the Division Bench also, he
was not willing to pay 50% of the outstanding amount. As the conduct of the
borrower did not merit grant of relief sought for in the interlocutory application,
the interlocutory application, I.A.[Civil] no. 3157/2018 was dismissed on
03.09.2018.

17. Undeterred by the failure he met before the Division Bench in the manner
narrated above, the borrower proceeded to invoke the jurisdiction of the civil
court by instituting a title suit, Title Suit no. 108/2018 on 12.10.2018. The
borrower as the plaintiff and subsequently, through his legal representatives,
had alleged fraud on the part of the respondent Bank authorities in auctioning
the subject-property at a price below the reserved price. In Title Suit no.
108/2018, the writ petitioner herein being the auction purchaser, was also
impleaded as defendant no. 4, apart from the authorities in the respondent Bank
as main defendants. In Title Suit no. 108/2018, which was then pending before
the Court of learned Civil Judge [Senior Division], Dibrugarh [‘the Trial Court’, for
short], the present writ petitioner filed a petition, Petition no. 2459/2020 under
Order 7, Rule 11[d] r/w Section 151 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 [‘the
CPC’] for rejection of the plaint. The said Petition no. 2459/2020 was registered
and numbered as Misc. [J] Case no. 279/2023. It was inter-alia contended that
in view of Section 34 of the SARFAESI Act, the civil court had got no jurisdiction
to entertain any suit or proceeding in respect of any matter in which the Debt
Recovery Tribunal or the Appellate Tribunal was empowered under the
SARFAESI Act. The Trial Court had, however, found that the provisions of Order
7, Rule 11[d], CPC were found not strictly applicable with reference to the facts
of the title suit. Holding that it was not a fit case to reject the plaint, the Trial
Page 10 of 28

Court by an Order dated 18.11.2023 rejected the prayer of the present writ
petitioner for rejection of the plaint made in Misc. [J] Case no. 279/2023.

18. Taking exception to the Order dated 18.11.2023 passed by the Trial Court in
Misc. [J] Case no. 279/2023, the present writ petitioner preferred a petition
under Article 227 of the Constitution of India before this Court. The said petition
was registered and numbered as CRP [IO] no. 11/2024. The Hon’ble Court took
notice of the fact that the plaintiff-borrower, after rejection of its
application/appeal filed under Section 17 of the SARFAESI Act, did not prefer any
appeal under Section 18 of the SARFAESI Act. The Court after hearing the
parties; considering the materials on record; and examining the Order dated
18.11.2023; allowed the petition by a Judgment and Order dated 05.06.2024.
The Court reached a finding that a clear bar under Section 34 of the SARFAESI
Act was made out. Holding that the Order dated 18.11.2023 was unsustainable
in law, the same was interfered with and the petition filed by the present writ
petitioner as defendant no. 4 - petitioner under Order 7, Rule 11[d], CPC,
registered as Misc.[J] Case no. 279/2023 was allowed and consequently, the
plaint filed in Title Suit no. 108/2018 was rejected. The Court while interfering
with the Order dated 18.11.2023, had observed that as there was availability of
an appellate forum under Section 18 of the SARFAESI Act, the plaintiff-borrower
could avail the said remedy strictly in accordance with law.

19. Subsequent to the Judgment and Order dated 05.06.2024 passed in CRP[IO] no.
11/2024, the Trial Court by a consequential Order dated 18.09.2024 passed in
Title Suit no. 108/2018 disposed of the title suit as the plaint had already been
rejected. Nothing has been brought on record by the respondent Bank that the
Page 11 of 28

borrower had availed the appellate remedy under Section 18 of the SARFAESI
Act.

20. Thereafter, on 24.08.2025, the present writ petitioner submitted a
Representation before the Authorized Officer of the respondent Bank,
highlighting the sequence of events till 18.09.2024, to request the Authorized
Officer to hand over physical possession of the subject-property at the earliest.
In the Representation, the present writ petitioner had represented that he
arranged the auction money of Rs. 29,50,000/- by taking loan and he made the
investment in order to earn income by constructing commercial spaces on the
subject-property. It was stated that while he was awaiting for handing over of
physical possession of the subject-property in all these years, he continued to
repay the loan amount and therefore, he would be entitled to be compensated
for the loss he had suffered. He staked a claim for interest @ 18% on the
amount of Rs. 29,50,000/- from the date of issuance of the Sale Certificate dated
27.09.2014 till delivery of possession of the subject-property.

21. In the affidavit-in-opposition filed on behalf of all the respondents, it is
contended that the writ petition would suffer from delay in that Sale Certificate
was issued on 27.09.2014 and the writ petitioner choose to wait more than
eleven years before approaching the Court by a writ petition. It is contended that
the Sale Certificate was accepted with possession and when the writ petitioner
preferred CRP [IO] no. 11/2024, he made no whisper about lack of possession.
There is no statutory obligation on the respondent Bank to pay interest, as
claimed by the writ petitioner. It has, however, been admitted by the respondent
Bank authorities that the cases filed by the borrower were dismissed. But, the
Page 12 of 28

borrower had alienated a part of the mortgaged subject-property vide a Deed
dated 23.11.2015 and in view of such alienation and also, for continued
obstruction by third parties claiming derivative rights, the subject-property could
not be peacefully taken possession by the respondent Bank. It is mentioned that
delivery of possession under the SARFAESI Act can only be effected after the
Bank itself obtains physical possession, either through measures under Section
13[4] of the SARFAESI Act, or with the assistance of the District Magistrate
under Section 14 of the SARFAESI Act.

22. The facts that the Auction Sale Notice was published on 08.04.2014; that the
writ petitioner participated in it and was declared the highest bidder for the
subject-property; and the Sale Certificate dated 27.09.2014 was issued to the
writ petitioner after receipt of full consideration; are found admitted by the
respondent Bank authorities.

23. A plea has been taken by the respondent Bank authorities that the Sale
Certificate was issued with possession and the subject-property was vacant at
that particular point of time of handing over the possession. It is mentioned that
the respondent Bank would extend all possible help in regaining of possession of
the subject-property by the writ petitioner and in that connection, an Application
under Section 14 of the SARFAESI Act was submitted on 04.09.2019. The
respondent Bank authorities have mentioned that though a hearing for
demarcation of the subject-property was held before the Circle Officer, Dibrugarh
East Revenue Circle on 12.09.2019, the order passed in the demarcation
proceeding was not traceable. The respondent Bank authorities have sought to
contend that the writ petitioner was handed over possession of the subject-
Page 13 of 28

property by the respondent Bank but the writ petitioner was not able to retain
the possession. Thereafter, orders restraining dispossession were passed in
favour of the borrower and those orders prevented the respondent Bank
authorities from proceeding to take over physical possession of the subject-
property. It has been admitted by the respondent Bank authorities that an
interim order of stay remained operative till 2018 and thereafter, there was
institution of Title Suit no. 108/2018 which proceeding finally culminated on
05.06.2024. But, in the meantime, the borrower had created third party
alienation on the subject-property, thereby frustrating the objects and purposes
of the SARFAESI Act. It is admitted that after rejection of the plaint and disposal
of Title Suit no. 108/2018 on 18.09.2024, no civil proceeding remained pending
challenging the Sale Certificate. But due to litigation till 2024, handing over of
physical possession of the subject-property could not be taken and presently,
encumbrances created over the subject-property by construction and induction
of tenant have hindered the respondent Bank to move forward to hand over
possession of the subject-property. It is stated that as presently the subject-
property is subject to encumbrances, the procedure delineated in Rule 9[7] to
Rule 9[9] of the Security Interest [Enforcement] Rules, 2002 are to be followed
for the purpose of handing over physical possession of the subject-property to
the writ petitioner. It is reiterated that the initial restrain order continued to
prevent the respondent Bank from taking over possession of the subject-
property and as a consequence, there was no executable possession order in
favour of the respondent Bank. The respondent Bank have taken a stand that
possession can be delivered to the present writ petitioner only after it takes
possession by following the measures laid down in Section 14 of the SARFAESI
Act.
Page 14 of 28

24. The respondent Bank is seen to have taken contradictory stance in that, at one
point, it has said that the Sale Certificate dated 27.09.2014 was accepted by the
present writ petitioner with possession, and, at another point, it has said that the
delivery of possession under the SARFAESI Act can only be effected after the
Bank obtains physical possession, either through measures under Section 13[4]
of the SARFAESI Act or with the assistance of the District Magistrate under
Section 14 of the SARFAESI Act. It is evident from the Auction Sale Notice dated
07.04.2014 itself that till that point of time, the respondent Bank had only
symbolic possession of the subject-property under Section 13[4] of the
SARFAESI Act. Symbolic possession under the SARFAESI Act means that the
secured creditor has taken legal control of a mortgaged property of the borrower
on paper, without taking physical possession of the mortgaged property. The
physical possession of the mortgaged property may remain with the borrower or
an occupant. Under Section 13[4] of the SARFAESI Act, if a borrower fails to
clear the outstanding dues, the secured creditor like a Bank has the right to take
symbolic possession of the secured asset after delivery of possession notice to
the borrower and by affixing a copy of it on the mortgaged property and other
formalities laid down in Rule 8 of the Security Interest [Enforcement] Rules,
2002. That the respondent Bank did not have the physical possession of the
subject-property is also evident from the fact that after passing of the interim
Order dated 24.11.2014 in the writ petition, W.P.[C.] no. 6015/2014, the
Authorized Officer had himself informed the writ petitioner – auction purchaser
by an Office Letter dated 09.12.2014 that the delivery of physical possession of
the subject-property sold to him was temporarily held up till the outcome of the
writ petition filed by the borrower. When the respondent Bank did not have the
Page 15 of 28

physical possession of the subject-property, it could not have handed over
physical possession of the subject-property to the writ petitioner – auction
purchaser at the time of issuance of the Sale Certificate dated 27.09.2014 or in
the period thereafter, as discussed above. In such view of the matter, the
contention of the respondent Bank that it had handed over physical possession
of the subject-property to the present writ petitioner after the Sale Certificate
and the writ petitioner was not able to remain in possession thereafter is clearly
a misstatement, and not borne out the records.

25. The respondent Bank authorities appear to have not taken any effective and
discernible steps during the period despite having remedy available under the
SARFAESI Act. It has, thus, emerged that the writ petitioner as the auction
purchaser inspite of depositing the full consideration, has been left in the lurch to
make endeavour from his end to get the subject-property release from the
control of the borrower which he did by filing Petition no. 2459/2020, that is,
Misc.[J] Case no. 279/2023 in Title Suit no. 108/2018. The said proceeding was
pursued by the present writ petitioner till its culmination by the Judgment and
Order dated 05.06.2024 passed in CRP [IO] no. 11/2024, whereby the plaint
filed by the borrower in Title Suit no. 108/2018 came to be rejected.

26. Another contention has been raised by the respondent Bank that the writ
petitioner has an alternative remedy and as there is an alternative remedy, the
present writ petition is not maintainable. From the sequence of events narrated
above, there emerges no dispute in so far as the facts are concerned. It is
settled proposition that existence of an alternative remedy does not bar the High
Court from exercising its jurisdiction under Article 226 of the Constitution. An
Page 16 of 28

alternative remedy by itself does not divest the High Court of its powers under
Article 226 of the Constitution in an appropriate case. When there is no dispute
on the facts even after exchange of the pleadings between the parties, and
when the writ petitioner is also laying emphasis on the refund of the amount he
had deposited as consideration against the subject-property along with interest
in view of creation of encumbrances on the subject-property in the interregnum,
there appears to be no reason for the writ petitioner to be relegated to avail
alternative remedy at this stage. The facts narrated above go to show that the
present writ petitioner was not lying inactive as he was seen to have pursued the
legal remedy for having physical possession of the subject-property. Therefore,
there is no substance in the contention that there is delay and laches in filing the
writ petition.

27. It has been admitted by the respondent Bank authorities that subsequent to
issuance of the Sale Certificate, it came to their knowledge that encumbrances
were created on the subject-property by way of third party occupation and
alienation of a part of the subject-property. Though the respondent Bank
authorities have stated that it initiated measures to take over physical possession
of the subject-property by filing an application under Section 14 of the SARFAESI
Act on 04.09.2019, the process was not brought to its finality by way of an order
under Section 14 of the SARFAESI Act from the District Magistrate, followed by
taking over physical possession of the subject-property at any point thereafter,
so as to hand over physical possession of the subject-property to the auction
purchaser. It is further admitted by the respondent Bank authorities that
presently, encumbrances on the subject-property by construction and induction
of tenants, have hindered the respondent Bank to hand over the physical
Page 17 of 28

possession of the subject-property and as the subject-property is presently
encumbered, the only way forward is to proceed under Rule 9 [7] to Rule 9 [9]
of the Security Interest [Enforcement] Rules, 2002. In the considered view of
this Court, the provisions of Rule 9 [7] to Rule 9 [9] of the Security Interest
[Enforcement] Rules, 2002 are applicable where the immovable property sold is
subject to any encumbrances.

28. But in the case in hand, there was apparently no encumbrance on the subject-
property at the time when it was put to auction sale by the Auction Sale Notice
dated 07.04.2014 or it was sold to the writ petitioner as the auction purchaser
followed by the Sale Certificate dated 27.09.2014. It is discernible that at that
point of time, only the borrower was in possession of the subject-property after
the symbolic possession. The encumbrances, indicated by the respondent Bank,
were created in the subsequent period on 23.11.2015.

29. The reason for delineating the sequence of events is to find out the reasons,
which have prevented the respondent Bank authorities to hand over physical
possession of the subject-property to the auction purchaser in these years, and
also, whether there is any fault attributable to the auction purchaser. On analysis
of the sequence of events, as delineated above, no fault is seen attributable to
the auction purchaser for the delay of more than one decade for him for being
handed over physical possession of the subject-property.

30. In so far as the contention raised by the respondent Bank with regard to the
requirement that the petitioner has to follow the provisions of Rule 9 [7] to Rule
9 [9] of the Security Interest [Enforcement] Rules, 2002 [‘the 2002 Rules’] is
Page 18 of 28

concerned, such contention, from the facts emerging from the records, cannot
be countenanced. Sub-rule [7] of Rule 9 of the 2002 Rules has prescribed that
where the immovable property sold is subject to any encumbrances, the
Authorized Officer may, if he thinks fit, allow the purchaser to deposit with him
the money required to discharge the encumbrances and any interest due thereon
with such additional amount that may be sufficient to meet the contingencies or
further cost, expenses and interest, as may be determined by him. As per the
proviso to sub-rule [7] of Rule 9, if after meeting the cost of removing
encumbrances and contingencies there is any surplus available out of the money
deposited by the purchaser such surplus shall be paid to the purchased within
fifteen days from the date of finalization of the sale. Sub-rule [8] of Rule 9 has
mentioned that on such deposit of money for discharge of the encumbrances,
the Authorized Officer may issue or cause the purchaser to issue notices to the
persons interested in or entitled to the money deposited with him and take steps
to make the payment accordingly.

31. It is not the case of the respondent Bank that on the date of publication of the
Auction Sale Notice on 08.04.2014 or on the date of issuance of the Sale
Certificate to the present writ petitioner as auction purchaser on 27.09.2014, the
subject-property was made subject to any encumbrances. It is an admission on
the part of the respondent Bank itself that the borrower had alienated a part of
the subject-property, which was mortgaged by him to the respondent Bank, vide
a Deed dated 23.11.2015. It is, thus, clear that the subject-property was subject
to encumbrance only from 23.11.2015 and the said encumbrance has since
continued till date. As the subject-property was made subject to such
encumbrance after the publication of the Auction Sale Notice and issuance of the
Page 19 of 28

Sale Certificate to the present writ petitioner as auction purchaser, the provisions
contained in Rule 9 [7] and Rule 9 [8] of the 2002 Rules are not found applicable
in the case in hand. In other words, when the subject-property was put to
auction sale by the Auction Sale Notice dated 08.04.2014 and when the Sale
Certificate was issued to the petitioner after he emerged successful as the
auction purchaser on 27.09.2014, the subject-property was not subject to any
encumbrance. It is under sub-rule [9] of Rule 9 of the 2002 Rules, the
Authorized Officer of the respondent Bank had issued the Sale Certificate on
27.09.2014 and therefore, he has obligation to deliver the subject-property to
the petitioner as the auction purchaser. As per sub-rule [10] of Rule 9 of the
2002 Rules, the Sale Certificate issued under sub-rule [6] shall specifically
mention that whether the purchaser has purchased immovable secured asset
free from any encumbrance known to the secured creditor or not. The Sale
Certificate dated 27.09.2014 has specifically mentioned that the sale of the
subject-property was made free from encumbrances known to the secured
creditor, on deposit of money by the present writ petitioner as the auction
purchaser.

32. It is the case of the present writ petitioner that due to the proceedings initiated
at the instance of the borrower right from the first writ petition, W.P.[C] no.
6015/2014 in the year 2014, and thereafter, in the form of title suit, Title Suit no.
108/2018 after the writ proceedings and other ancillary proceedings instituted
therein had reached a culmination on 03.09.2018; the encumbrances created by
the borrower on the subject-property on 23.11.2015 in the interregnum and
during the continuance of the proceedings; and the recalcitrant attitude exhibited
by the respondent Bank authorities from taking recourse to the provisions of the
Page 20 of 28

SARFAESI Act, more particularly, Section 14 at appropriate times in order to take
physical possession of the subject-property till the institution of the present writ
petition; the petitioner is no longer interested for the subject-property in the
event the petitioner is appropriately compensated for investing the amount of Rs.
29.50 lakh as well as for spending the time period of more than a decade
without any fruitful results; and also, for paying interest to the respondent Bank
while repaying the loan amount of Rs. 25,00,000/- which was obtained by
keeping another landed property of his in mortgage.

33. At this juncture, it is apposite to refer to the decisions – Govind Kumar Sharma
and another vs. Bank of Baroda and others, [2024] 4 SCR 633; Delhi
Development Authority vs. Corporation Bank and others, [2025] 9 SCR
1559; and M.S. Sanjay vs. India Bank and others, [2025] 1 SCR 1588 cited at
the Bar.

34. In Delhi Development Authority vs. Corporation Bank and others [supra],
the DDA allotted a plot of land to the respondent no. 2 [a club] and a perpetual
lease deed was executed. There was a condition that the club could mortgage or
charge the plot only after consent in writing from the Lieutenant Governor of
Delhi. The respondent no. 2 mortgaged the plot with the Bank by depositing the
registered perpetual lease deed in order to obtain loan. The respondent no. 2
defaulted in payment of the loan. Thereupon, the Bank filed an original
application before the Debt Recovery Tribunal [DRT] for recovery of a sum and
the same was allowed. The Recovery Officer, DRT issued an e-auction sale
notice. The respondent no. 6 [the auction purchaser] was declared the highest
bidder in respect of the plot. The auction purchaser deposited the bid price in
favour of the Recovery Officer, DRT and the Recovery officer, DRT confirming
Page 21 of 28

the sale, issued a sale certificate in favour of the auction purchaser and the
possession of the subject-plot was handed over to the auction purchaser. The
DDA filed a writ petition seeking setting aside of the e-auction on the ground
that there was no previous sanction of the Lieutenant Governor of Delhi prior to
creation of the mortgage. The writ petition was dismissed by the High Court.
Then, the DDA preferred the appeal before the Hon’ble Supreme Court. Finding
that the e-auction was held in violation of terms of the lease deed, the e-auction
sale notice and the proclamation of sale as well as the sale certificate were held
to be bad and illegal.

34.1. On the issues of the position of the auction purchaser and deposit of auction
amount, and on its retention, the Hon’ble Supreme Court has observed as under
:-
30. [.…] In Fibrosa Spolka Akcyjna vs. Fairbairn Lawson Combe
Barbour Ltd. 1943 AC 32 : [1942] 2 All ER 122 [HL], it was held that
any civilized system of law is bound to provide remedies for cases of
what has been called unjust enrichment or unjust benefit, that is, to
prevent a man from retaining the money of or some benefit derived
from another which it is against conscience that he should keep. Such
remedies in English law are generally different from remedies in
contract or in tort, and are now recognized to fall within a third
category of the common law which has been called quasi-contract or
restitution. The aforesaid legal proposition was referred to with
approval by a Two Judge Bench of this Court in Nagpur Golden
Transport Company v. Nath Traders & Ors ., [2012] 1 SCC 555 ,
Page 22 of 28

The restitution therefore becomes not merely a legal device but a
moral imperative. The principle of restitution flows from the very heart
of justice that no one shall unjustly enrich himself at the instance of
another and that those who suffered without fault should, so far as
money can achieve, be restored to the position they once occupied .
The jurisdiction to make restitution is inherent in every court and will
be exercised wherever the justice of the case demands.
31. In the facts of the present case, the Auction Purchaser has been
caught in the undertow of circumstances, not of its making. Among all
the actors in this legal drama, it alone stands innocent. The Auction
Purchaser entered the auction in good faith, placed its bid and
deposited its hard- earned money in the belief that the law clothed the
auction with legitimacy. The Auction Purchaser neither breached the
covenant nor failed in diligence and did not seek to profit from the
illegality. The restitution therefore becomes not merely a legal device
but a moral imperative. It is this principle which in the facts of the case
must guide the relief to the Auction Purchaser. The Bank having
advanced the money of an illegal mortgage and having chosen to
auction what it never lawfully possessed, bears the responsibility for
the consequences.
35. In Govind Kumar Sharma and another vs. Bank of Baroda and others
[supra], the respondent no. 3 had taken a loan from the respondent no. 1 –
Bank. As the respondent no. 3 defaulted, the Bank initiated proceedings under
the SARFAESI Act. The Recovery Officer conducted an open auction and the
Page 23 of 28

appellants emerged as the highest bidder. On acceptance of their bid, a Sale
Certificate was issued in their favour on 30.03.2009. The appellants were tenants
of the borrower [the respondent no. 3] in the premises which was put to
auction. After the Sale Certificate, the status of the appellants changed from that
of tenants to that of owners. The borrower filed a securitization application
under Section 17 of the SARFAESI Act alleging violation of statutory procedure.
The DRT set aside the sale and directed the Bank to refund the auction money
with interest as applicable to fixed deposits after receiving possession of the
property from the auction purchaser. The appellants preferred an appeal before
the DRAT. On dismissal of the appeal by the DRAT, the appellants preferred a
writ petition. On dismissal of the writ petition, the appellants preferred the
appeal before the Hon’ble Supreme Court.
35.1. The appellants contended that they were bona fide purchasers for value and
after the sale certificate was issued, the appellants had developed the property
investing a substantial amount and in case the sale was to be set aside, the
appellants should be suitably compensated not only by refund of the auction
money along with interest but also for the improvements made by them in
developing the property and investment made therein. The Bank had admitted
there was non-compliance of the statutory provisions in conducting the sale and
sought for liberty to proceed afresh. In the above backdrop, the Hon’ble
Supreme Court had inter alia proceeded to observe as under :-
12. Considering the above facts and circumstances and the arguments
advanced, we proceed to deal with the same :
*
Page 24 of 28

*
[iii]. The entire controversy has arisen because of the Bank not following
the prescribed mandatory procedure for conducting the auction sale
and, therefore, the Bank must suffer and should be put to terms for
unnecessarily creating litigation. As of date the dues of the Bank have
been fully discharged and an additional amount of the auction money is
lying with the Bank since 2009. This amount is to be returned to the
appellants. In such facts and circumstances of the case, we are of the
view that the award of interest on the auction money at the rate
applicable to fixed deposits is not a correct view. The rate of interest
deserves to be enhanced.
[iv]. We could have considered awarding 24 per cent per annum
compound interest on the auction money to be refunded to the
appellants in view of serious illegality committed by the Bank in
conducting the auction and driving the parties to litigation. Considering
the fact that the money of the Bank is also public money, we feel that
interest of justice would be best served if the auction money with 12 per
cent per annum compound interest is returned to the appellants. Such
interest be calculated from the date of deposit till the date it is actually
paid.
*

36. The writ petition in M.S. Sanjay [supra] was with regard to proceeding under the
SARFAESI Act. It is observed therein that Article 226 of the Constitution of India
Page 25 of 28

grants an extra-ordinary remedy, which is essentially discretionary, although
founded on legal injury. The legal formulations cannot be enforced divorced from
the realities of the fact situation of the case. While administering law it is to be
tempered with equity and if the equitable situation demands after setting right
the legal formulations not to take it to the logical end, the High Court would be
failing in its duty if it does not notice equitable consideration and mould the final
order in exercise of its extra-ordinary jurisdiction. Any other approach would
render the High Court a normal Court of Appeal, which it is not. It is a settled
principle of law that the remedy under Article 226 of the Constitution is
discretionary in nature. The High Court while exercising its extra-ordinary
jurisdiction can mould the relief to do the substantial justice between the parties.

37. In view of the fact situation obtaining in the case in hand, as narrated above,
this Court is of the considered view that the petitioner has made out a case for
the direction to the respondent Bank to refund the amount of Rs. 29.50 lakh
which he had deposited after emerging as the successful auction purchaser in
the auction sale process initiated by the Auction Sale Notice in the dated
08.04.2014. In this writ petition, apart from the prayers for a direction to the
respondent Bank authorities to hand over physical possession of all part and
parcel of the subject-property, the petitioner has also made an alternative prayer
for refund of the amount of Rs. 29.50 lakh along with interest.

38. It is settled that a person deprived of the use of money to which he is
legitimately entitled has a right to be compensated for the deprivation. Interest is
paid for deprivation of the use of money. Interest in general terms has been
interpreted to be the return or compensation for the use or retention by one
Page 26 of 28

person of an amount of money belong to another person. It is, thus, a
consideration paid for the use of money or forbearance of money.

39. In the case in hand, the petitioner intended to purchase the subject-property for
putting it to commercial use to develop his business and to earn income, as far
back as in the year 2014. The petitioner as the auction purchaser has neither
been handed over physical possession of the subject-property nor he has been
refunded the amount of Rs. 29.50 lakh till date. In the process, the respondent
Bank has kept the auctioned money of Rs. 29.50 lakh in retention and the
petitioner has been deprived of using the said amount to put it for any other
gainful use. The petitioner is found to have waited all these years with a
legitimate expectation. It was only when he formed the belief that the chances of
getting physical delivery of possession of the subject-property encumbrance free
is almost nil despite institution of the legal proceedings by him also in the
interregnum, this Court is of the clear view that the respondent Bank is liable to
refund the amount of Rs. 29.50 lakh as well as interest on it for keeping the said
amount in retention all these years.

40. It has been brought on record that in order to deposit the auction sale amount of
Rs. 29.50 lakh, the petitioner applied for a loan before the respondent Bank. The
respondent Bank after processing his application, sanctioned a loan amount of
Rs. 25 lakhs under its Cent Trade Scheme on 24.09.2014, that is, three days
prior to issuance of the Sale Certificate dated 27.09.2014. While extending the
loan, the petitioner was made to provide security in the form of equitable
mortgage of a landed property at Tinsukia having market value of Rs.
58,96,000/-. The respondent Bank had extended the loan at a rate of interest :
Page 27 of 28

10.25 Base Rate + 3.0 at that time [13.25 per annum]. It is in May, 2026, the
petitioner had repaid the loan amount of Rs. 25 lakh, with interest, which was
sanctioned to him on 24.09.2014. The respondent Bank has also issued a No
Dues Certificate to the petitioner on 22.06.2026, which is kept with case record
by marking it as Document – ‘A’.

41. In the above obtaining fact and circumstances, the writ petition is disposed of
with the following directions :-

[i] The respondent Bank authorities shall return the entire auction amount of
Rs. 29,50,000/- to the petitioner by recalling the Sale Certificate dated
27.09.2014;

[ii] The respondent Bank shall pay an amount with compound interest @ 12
per cent per annum to be calculated from the date of receipt of the auction
amount till the date of payment;

[iii] The entire exercise is to be completed as expeditiously as possible,
preferably within a period of forty-five days from the date of submission of
a certified copy of this order to the respondent no. 3 by the petitioner.

42. The writ petition stands allowed to the extent indicated above. No cost.

JUDGE
Digitally signed by
Rupam Basumatary
Date: 2026.09.25
10:05:48 +05'30'
Comparing Assistant

Page 28 of 28