The Director Of Income Tax, International Taxation vs M/S Star Cruises (India) P. Ltd.

Court
Supreme Court





2026 INSC 771
NON-REPORTABLE


IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION

CIVIL APPEAL NO(S). 3334-3336 OF 2012

THE DIRECTOR OF INCOME TAX,
(INTERNATIONAL TAXATION). … APPELLANT(S)


VERSUS


M/S STAR CRUISES (INDIA) P. LTD. … RESPONDENT(S)


J U D G M E N T

S.V.N. BHATTI, J.
1. The Civil Appeals arise from the Judgment and Order dated
01.07.2011, in Income Tax Appeal Nos. 485, 486 and 683 of 2010 (for short,
‘impugned Order’) of the High Court of Judicature at Bombay. The Director of
Income Tax, International Taxation (for short, ‘the Revenue’) is the Appellant.
2. M/s Star Cruises (India) Pvt. Limited is the Assessee/Respondent. The
Civil Appeals relate to the assessment years 2006-07, 2007-08, and 2008-09.
3. The Superstar Libra Ltd. (for short, ‘SLL’), a non-resident entity,
operated a cruise known as “Superstar Libra” in India. The Assessee, the
Agent of SLL, was responsible for conducting the cruise and collecting revenue
Signature Not Verified
from the sale of cruise packages and shore excursions in India.
Digitally signed by
SNEHA DAS
Date: 2026.07.30
17:57:07 IST
Reason:

4. The impugned Order has considered the claim of the Assessee under
Section 44B of the Income Tax Act, 1961 (for short, ‘the Act’) for withholding
1





tax determined under Section 195 of the Act on the remittances by the
Assessee in favour of SLL. The Assessee stated that income accruing in favour
of SLL is computed by applying Section 44B of the Act and that the estimated
income was 7.5% of the cruise fare collected by the Assessee. The Assessee
further claimed consideration for granting a certificate for TDS under Section
195 of the Act, at the rate of 7.5% of the estimated income under Section 44B
of the Act. The Assessee claimed that, as an Agent, it received receipts for
providing carriage of passengers operated by SLL, and that the estimated
income was 7.5% of the cruise fare collected by the Assessee.
5. The Assessing Officer, vide order dated 30.03.2007, held that Section
44B of the Act is applicable in cases of carriage of goods, passengers, etc.,
and, in the view of the Assessing Officer, the term “carrying” means taking or
transporting from one place to another or from one port to another. SLL
conducted cruise services originating from and terminating at Mumbai Port,
i.e., a round trip. During the round trip, SLL extended hospitality and
provided entertainment. Therefore, the activity of SLL falls under
entertainment and hospitality and does not include carriage of
passengers/goods within the meaning of section 44B of the Act. Consequent
to such view, the Assessing Officer estimated deemed income at 25% of the
cruise fare collected for and on behalf of SLL, not at 7.5% as claimed by the
Assessee.
6. The Assessee carried the matter in appeal before the Commissioner of
Income Tax (Appeals) [for short, ‘CIT(A)’], Mumbai. By Order dated
2





15.06.2007, the CIT(A) allowed the Appeal and set aside the Assessment
Order dated 30.03.2007.
7. The Appellate Authority appreciated all the circumstances of the case
under Section 44B of the Act and held that the deemed income of SLL was
estimated at 7.5% of the receipts received from the cruise fare.
8. The Revenue carried the matter in appeal before the Income Tax
Appellate Tribunal (for short, ‘ITAT’), and the Tribunal, by the Order dated
01.07.2009, dismissed the Appeal. The Tribunal’s finding of fact is
summarised as follows:-
A. While rejecting the Assessing Officer’s interpretation of the term
‘carriage’, it affirmed that a round-trip voyage constitutes two separate acts
of carriage, i.e., from station A to station B and back to station A. Further, the
Assessee also offered one-way cruises, and passengers booking round-trip
cruises are entitled to disembark at intermediate ports without being
compelled to return to Mumbai.
B. Booking slips establish that the primary fees collected from passengers
were for cabin and transport fares. Any on-board entertainment, whether
included or paid separately, was incidental to the main business of operating
ships.
C. CBDT Circulars No. 763 and 169 dated 18.02.1996 and 23.06.1975,
respectively, clarify that carriage payments include handling charges and that
Section 44B of the Act was designed to simplify the computation of taxable
profits for foreign shipping enterprises. Since SLL is a non-resident entity
3





engaged in the business of operating ships, it fulfils the essential conditions
under the said section.
D. It directed that SLL’s income be assessed at the statutory presumptive
rate of 7.5% of gross cruise fare receipts for tax deduction under Section 195
of the Act rather than 25% of income estimated by the Assessing Officer.

9. The Revenue carried the matter in appeal before the High Court, as
noted above, and through the impugned Order, the Appeal(s) have been
dismissed. Hence, the Civil Appeals.
10. Leave has been granted in the matter(s) on the following two questions,
namely:-
“(i) Whether on the facts and circumstances of the case
and in law, the Hon’ble High Court was justified in upholding
the Hon’ble ITAT’S decision that assessee is engaged in the
business of operation of Ships and is entitled to be assessed
under Section 44B of the Income Tax Act?
(ii) Whether on the facts and circumstances of the case
and in law, the Hon’ble High Court was justified in upholding
the Hon’ble ITAT’S decision without appreciating that the fact
of the case that business activity of assessee was primarily
that of providing hospitality and entertainment on board the
cruise ship and not that of mere transportation of
passengers?”

11. We have heard Mr. Raghavendra P Shankar, learned Additional
Solicitor General, assisted by Advocate Pallavi Mishra, for the Appellant and
Advocate Anand Varma, for the Respondent.
12. The Revenue argues that the impugned Order has failed to give the
meaning available to the word ‘carriage’ under Section 44B of the Act. It is
argued that a round trip with amenities is not a simple carriage of passengers
or goods for the purpose of estimated income under Section 44B of the Act.
4





The dominant purpose of SLL’s activity is more in the nature of conducting
packages/excursions with tourists, rather than the carriage of passengers
from one port to another, and the transaction is an excursion, not the carriage
of passengers/goods. Even if the Assessee satisfies the twin conditions of
Section 44B, the final estimation at 7.5% depends on the activity being the
carriage of passengers/goods. The findings of fact are untenable and warrant
interference. Therefore, the estimated income must be assessed at 25% of the
Assessee's receipts, not at 7.5%.
13. For the Assessee, it is argued that the applicability of Section 44B of
the Act depends on the twin test laid down in that Section. As per the
concurrent findings of fact recorded in the three Orders, both requirements
are satisfied by the Assessee. The inference drawn by the Revenue on the
application of the word ‘carriage’ in the circumstances of the case is untenable
and ex facie illegal. The Assessing Officer has restricted the meaning of the
word ‘carriage’ by observing that, to come within the meaning of carriage, the
carriage must necessarily be from Port A to Port B. The CIT(A) has rejected
this limited interpretation of the word ‘carriage’. The Assessee has established
that the primary grounds for attracting Section 44B of the Act are complied
with, and that making an ancillary purpose the dominant purpose,
particularly with a restricted meaning of the word ‘carriage’, is erroneous.
There is no gainsaying that a round trip of passengers would go beyond the
normal meaning of carriage of passengers and goods. The findings of fact are
lawful and not perverse, and only available findings have been recorded. The
5





scope of the Civil Appeals does not permit interference with concurrent
findings of fact on the accepted nature of SLL’s activity.
14. We have taken note of the arguments and perused the record. In the
Civil Appeals, we are not defining the meaning of the word ‘carriage’, but we
are examining its application to the facts of the case. To sum up, we may note
with disapproval the construction placed by the Assessing Officer on SLL’s
activity. The Assessing Officer insists that, to attract the meaning of the word
‘carriage’, the movement should be from place ‘A’ to place ‘B’.
15. We find it difficult to confine the meaning of the word ‘carriage’ as
attributed by the Assessing Officer. The Appellate Authority and the Tribunal,
being competent authorities to examine the facts in issue, as noted supra,
have held that the activity established by SLL does not fall outside the
expression of ‘carriage’ as per Section 44B of the Act. In the facts and
circumstances of this case, SLL, being a foreign entity, was providing cruise
services in India through the Assessee. The finding recorded is that the
possibility of passengers de-boarding at intermediate ports was not taken into
account by the Assessing Officer. On a voyage, the providing of ancillary
services does not take away from the meaning of ‘carriage’ as per Section 44B
of the Act. The meaning adopted by the Assessing Officer is restrictive in the
facts and circumstances of this case. The illegality was factually corrected by
the impugned Orders.
16. We do not wish to reiterate the same reasoning, but are satisfied that,
in the facts and circumstances of the case, the view taken in respect of the
6





subject assessment years, namely that Section 44B of the Act is attracted to
the estimated income of SLL, does not warrant interference.
17. The Civil Appeals fail and are accordingly dismissed.
18. Pending application(s), if any, shall stand disposed of.


..……….…………………J.
[S.V.N. BHATTI]







..…………………………J.
[N.V. ANJARIA]

New Delhi;
July 30, 2026.

7





NON-REPORTABLE

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION

CIVIL APPEAL NO. OF 2026
@ SPECIAL LEAVE PETITION (C) NO. 1440 OF 2016

THE DIRECTOR OF INCOME TAX (IT)-I …APPELLANT(S)


VERSUS


SUPERSTAR LIBRA LIMITED … RESPONDENT(S)

J U D G M E N T

S.V.N. BHATTI, J.
1. Leave Granted.
2. The present Civil Appeal is a companion appeal to Civil Appeal Nos.
3334-3336 of 2012 between the same parties but for a different assessment
year.
3. The issue is substantially similar to that of companion Civil Appeals,
and, by adopting the same view, the present Civil Appeal is dismissed.
4. Pending application(s), if any, shall stand disposed of.

..……….…………………J.
[S.V.N. BHATTI]




..…………………………J.
[N.V. ANJARIA]

New Delhi;
July 30, 2026.
1