Amay Technosystems Private Limited vs Asis Elektronik Ve Biliim Sistemleri A
- Court
- Bombay High Court
CNR No : HCBM020330862026
carbpl33085-2026-J.doc
AGK
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
ORDINARY ORIGINAL CIVIL JURISDICTION
IN ITS COMMERCIAL DIVISION
COMM ARBITRATION PETITION (L) NO.33085 OF 2026
Amay Technosystems Private Limited
… Petitioner
Vs.
1. Asis Elektronik Ve Bilisim Sistemleri A.S.
2. Hakan Ozyurek
3. Gurkan Gucbilmez
4.
Mumbai Metro Rail Corporation Limited … Respondents
ATUL
GANESH
KULKARNI
Mr. Amrut Joshi with Ms. Radhika Kulkarni, Mr.
Prashant Trivedi, and Ms. Riya Pichaya i/by Mr. Aman
Kumar Shahi for the Petitioner.
Digitally signed by
ATUL GANESH
KULKARNI
Date: 2026.11.19
11:48:12 +0530
Mr. Vishal Hegde with Ms. Kritika i/by Samudra Legal
LLP for Respondent No.1.
CORAM : AMIT BORKAR, J.
RESERVED ON : NOVEMBER 18, 2026.
PRONOUNCED ON : NOVEMBER 19, 2026
JUDGMENT:
1. By the present Petition filed under Section 9 of the
Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996, the Petitioner is seeking
urgent interim reliefs before commencement of arbitration
proceedings. The disputes arise out of the Agreement dated 14
December 2022 entered into between the Petitioner and
Respondent No.1 in relation to the Mumbai Metro Line-3
Automatic Fare Collection (AFC) Project. Under the said
1
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 11:55:40
carbpl33085-2026-J.doc
Agreement, the Petitioner carried out substantial work relating to
software development and implementation of the Project.
2. In July 2024, certain disputes arose between the parties.
Thereafter, senior representatives of both parties held meetings at
Istanbul, Türkiye. In the said meetings, Minutes of Meeting dated
9 August 2024 were executed. Under these Minutes, Respondent
No.1 agreed to take over the remaining software development
work. Respondent No.1 agreed to pay the Petitioner an amount of
USD 700,000 towards the software development work completed
by the Petitioner. In return, the Petitioner agreed to continue
providing technical support and keep its technical team at the
project site till 31 December 2024. According to the Petitioner, it
duly fulfilled this obligation. The case of the Petitioner is that
despite taking benefit of the services provided by the Petitioner
and giving repeated assurances, Respondent No.1 has failed to pay
the agreed amount of USD 700,000. The Petitioner states that it
made several requests for payment, held negotiations, sent
reminders and correspondence and issued legal notices. However,
Respondent No.1 has not made the payment. The Petitioner has
started the process under the dispute resolution mechanism and is
taking steps to commence arbitration in accordance with the
arbitration clause contained in the Agreement. According to the
Petitioner, it has a strong claim for recovery of the said amount. It
apprehends that the amounts which Respondent No.1 is likely to
receive under the Mumbai Metro Line-3 Project may be transferred
elsewhere, spent or otherwise made unavailable during the
arbitration proceedings. According to the Petitioner, if such a
2
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 11:55:40
carbpl33085-2026-J.doc
situation arises, even if an award is passed in its favour, it may
become difficult to recover the amount. The Petitioner has,
therefore, filed the present Petition seeking interim protection to
secure its claim and to ensure that the subject matter of the
proposed arbitration is protected.
3. On 14 December 2022, the Petitioner and Respondent No.1
entered into a Software Development Agreement in relation to the
Mumbai Metro Line-3 AFC Project. The said Agreement contained
an arbitration clause which provided that the parties should first
try to settle their disputes amicably and, if such settlement was not
possible, the disputes would be referred to arbitration under the
Rules of the International Chamber of Commerce (ICC). Between
December 2022 and July 2024, the Petitioner carried out software
development, implementation, and project support work under the
said Agreement. On 19 July 2024, Respondent No.1 informed the
Petitioner that it was terminating the Agreement. For this purpose,
Respondent No.1 referred to the reason of "non-sufficient work
completion" and treated its decision as final. On 22 July 2024, the
Petitioner disputed the allegations made by Respondent No.1. The
Petitioner explained the circumstances which had caused delay in
completing the work and requested Respondent No.1 to resolve
the disputes amicably. Thereafter, on 8 and 9 August 2024,
meetings were held between senior representatives of both parties
at Istanbul, Türkiye, to find an amicable solution to the disputes.
On 9 August 2024, the parties executed Minutes of Meeting. Under
the said Minutes, Respondent No.1 agreed to pay USD 700,000 to
the Petitioner. The Petitioner, in return, agreed to continue
3
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 11:55:40
carbpl33085-2026-J.doc
providing technical support till 31 December 2024. Between
August and December 2024, the Petitioner continued to provide
technical support as agreed under the Minutes of Meeting. On 12
November 2024, the Petitioner requested Respondent No.1 to
make an interim payment and suggested a planned method for
clearing the outstanding amount. On 1 January 2025, the
Petitioner informed Respondent No.1 that the agreed period for
providing technical support had been completed.
4. Between January and March 2025, the Petitioner sent several
communications to Respondent No.1 requesting payment and
suggested different commercial solutions for settling the
outstanding amount. On 19 June 2025, Respondent No.1
acknowledged that certain financial issues between the parties
were still pending and informed the Petitioner that the matter
would be examined internally. On 9 July 2025, the Petitioner once
again called upon Respondent No.1 to release the agreed amount
of USD 700,000 without any delay. On 31 July 2025, the Petitioner
gave a final opportunity to Respondent No.1 to resolve the matter
amicably. On 1 August 2025, Respondent No.1 informed the
Petitioner that its finance team had been instructed to look into the
pending financial issues. However, as the payment was still not
made, on 17 February 2026, the Petitioner issued a final legal
notice to Respondent No.1 demanding payment of USD 700,000
together with applicable interest.
5. On 6 July 2026, the Petitioner issued a Notice of Dispute by
invoking Clause 10 of the Agreement. By the said notice, the
Petitioner called upon Respondent No.1 to participate in the
4
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 11:55:40
carbpl33085-2026-J.doc
process of amicable settlement of the disputes between the parties.
Thereafter, on 15 September 2026, the Petitioner issued a Notice
of Invocation of Arbitration under Clause 10 of the Agreement
dated 14 December 2022. In these circumstances, the Petitioner
has approached this Court by filing the present Petition under
Section 9 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996.
6. Mr. Joshi, learned Advocate appearing for the Petitioner,
submitted that the Petitioner has a genuine and reasonable
apprehension that if this Court does not grant interim protection,
the arbitration proceedings may become meaningless and even if
an award is passed in favour of the Petitioner, it may not be
possible to enforce the same. He submitted that this apprehension
is not based on any guess or mere possibility, but on certain events
and documents which have taken place during the relevant period.
He submitted that Respondent No.1 is a company incorporated
under the laws of the Republic of Turkey and its business activities
in India have substantially reduced. During 2025, its metro rail
projects in India were affected. The Agra Metro Project was
terminated. In respect of the Bhopal-Indore Metro Project, a notice
was issued recording that it had become impossible to continue the
work due to circumstances arising from national security reasons.
These developments took place at a time when public authorities
in India had taken certain steps affecting Turkish entities in view of
the increased national security concerns. He submitted that
Respondent No.1, in its own correspondence dated 15 June 2025
addressed to the Petitioner, admitted that certain issues relating to
the Mumbai Metro Line-3 Project were under legal consideration
5
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 11:55:40
carbpl33085-2026-J.doc
with its Joint Venture partner, Texmaco. According to him, this
correspondence shows that the commercial position of Respondent
No.1 in relation to the said Project was uncertain.
7. Mr. Joshi submitted that though the Petitioner does not have
any official document to show that similar action has been taken in
respect of the Mumbai Metro Line-3 Project, the other
circumstances placed on record cannot be ignored. According to
him, if all these circumstances are considered together, they create
a reasonable apprehension that the business activities and assets of
Respondent No.1 in India have substantially reduced and may
reduce during the pendency of the arbitration proceedings. He,
therefore, submitted that there is a real possibility that the
Petitioner may face difficulty in recovering the amount even if an
award is passed in its favour. Mr. Joshi submitted that the
apprehension of the Petitioner is not based merely on the fact that
Respondent No.1 has not made payment. According to him, there
have been material changes in the business position of Respondent
No.1 in India, which are supported by official documents and the
correspondence exchanged between the parties. These
circumstances, according to him, show that there is a real and
immediate risk that any award which may ultimately be passed in
favour of the Petitioner may become difficult to enforce unless
interim protection is granted by this Court.
8. Mr. Joshi submitted that the condition relating to back-to-
back payment contained in the Agreement dated 14 December
2022 would no longer apply after termination of the said
Agreement. Inviting my attention to Exhibit-F, which is the
6
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 11:55:40
carbpl33085-2026-J.doc
Agreement dated 14 December 2022, he submitted that Clause 4
of the Agreement provided for back-to-back payment. However,
according to him, this condition came to an end when the
Agreement was terminated. He submitted that Clause 10.1, which
contains the arbitration agreement, would nevertheless continue to
operate even after termination of the Agreement. In this
connection, he invited my attention to the email dated 19 July
2024 sent by Respondent No.1 and submitted that the said email
clearly shows that Respondent No.1 had terminated the
Agreement. He then invited my attention to the Minutes of
Meeting dated 9 August 2024 and submitted that Respondent No.1
had clearly agreed under the said Minutes to pay USD 700,000 to
the Petitioner. According to him, this promise amounts to an
admission by Respondent No.1 that the said amount is payable to
the Petitioner. On the basis of this admission, he submitted that the
Petitioner is entitled to the interim reliefs sought in the present
Petition. In support of his submissions, Mr. Joshi relied upon the
judgment of the Division Bench of this Court in Tata Advanced
Materials Limited Vs. Tooltech Global Engineering Private Limited ,
2013 SCC OnLine Bom 1922, by which the judgment delivered in
Company Petition No.198 of 2012 was set aside.
9. On the other hand, Mr. Hegde, learned Advocate appearing
for Respondent No.1, invited my attention to various clauses of the
Agreement dated 14 December 2022. He submitted that the
provisions relating to payment, variation and increase in price
clearly contemplated that payment to the Petitioner would be
made on a back-to-back basis. According to him, the expression
7
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 11:55:40
carbpl33085-2026-J.doc
"back-to-back" means that Respondent No.1 would be required to
make payment to the Petitioner only after receiving the
corresponding payment from the main employer. In support of this
submission, Mr. Hegde relied upon the judgment of a learned
Single Judge of this Court in Tata Advanced Materials Limited Vs.
Tooltech Global Engineering Private Limited , Company Petition
No.198 of 2012, decided on 15 October 2013.
10. Mr. Hegde submitted that the Petitioner has taken a stand
that the Agreement dated 14 December 2022 was terminated. If
that is so, according to him, the Petitioner's claim for USD 700,000
is based only on the Minutes of Meeting dated 9 August 2024. The
said Minutes do not contain any arbitration clause. They do not
refer to or incorporate the arbitration clause contained in the
Agreement dated 14 December 2022. Therefore, according to him,
the Petitioner cannot seek any relief under Section 9 of the
Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996, on the basis of such
Minutes of Meeting. The Petitioner will have to take such other
legal proceedings as may be available to it. He submitted that
merely because Respondent No.1 issued an email dated 19 July
2024, it cannot be said that the Agreement dated 14 December
2022 stood terminated. According to him, the said email is not
sufficient to bring the Agreement to an end.
11. Mr. Hegde submitted that, it is necessary to consider whether
the claim made by the Petitioner is covered by the arbitration
agreement between the parties. According to him, the only
arbitration agreement between the parties is Clause 10 of the
Agreement dated 14 December 2022. However, the amount of USD
8
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 11:55:40
carbpl33085-2026-J.doc
700,000 claimed by the Petitioner is not claimed under the said
Agreement. The Petitioner has based its claim entirely on the
Minutes of Meeting dated 9 August 2024. The said Minutes are a
separate document. They do not contain any arbitration clause and
do not incorporate Clause 10 of the original Agreement. Therefore,
according to him, the claim made in the present Petition does not
fall within the arbitration agreement and the Petition under
Section 9 of the Act is not maintainable.
12. Mr. Hegde submitted that the Minutes of Meeting are
disputed and cannot be treated as a valid or binding document. He
submitted that Mr. Mustafa Ozicsel has denied the signature
attributed to him on the said Minutes and that Exhibit-J is a
fabricated document. In the alternative, he submitted that even if
the signature is found to be genuine, Mr. Mustafa Ozicsel had no
authority to make Respondent No.1 liable for any payment under
the said document. He submitted that the document is not
properly stamped and, therefore, cannot be relied upon.
13. Mr. Hegde submitted that even if the said Minutes are given
some legal effect, they would have to be read as part of the
original Agreement and would remain subject to the back-to-back
payment condition contained in Clause 3 thereof. He submitted, in
the alternative, that if the Petitioner's case is that the Minutes of
Meeting constitute a separate and independent settlement between
the parties, then the said Minutes do not contain any arbitration
agreement. Therefore, a claim based only on those Minutes cannot
be the basis for seeking interim relief under Section 9 of the Act.
9
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 11:55:40
carbpl33085-2026-J.doc
14. Mr. Hegde submitted that there is no dispute that the
original Agreement contains an arbitration clause under Clause 10.
The said clause provides that the parties should first attempt to
settle their disputes amicably. If such settlement is not possible, the
disputes are to be referred to arbitration under the Rules of the
International Chamber of Commerce (ICC Rules), with the place of
arbitration being India. He submitted that all disputes between the
parties, including disputes relating to the meaning of the
Agreement, performance of obligations, alleged breach of the
Agreement, effect of the Minutes of Meeting, entitlement of the
Petitioner to receive payment, adjustment of amounts and all
related issues, can be decided by the Arbitral Tribunal. He
submitted that under Section 16 of the Arbitration and
Conciliation Act, 1996, the Arbitral Tribunal has the power to
decide whether it has jurisdiction to entertain the disputes. This
principle is known as Kompetenz-Kompetenz. Therefore, according
to him, this Court should not decide in advance the issues which
are required to be examined and decided by the Arbitral Tribunal.
15. Mr. Hegde submitted that merely because the Petitioner has
made a monetary claim or has expressed apprehension about
recovery of the amount, no order directing deposit of money,
furnishing of security or attachment of property can be passed. He
submitted that there is no unconditional admission by Respondent
No.1 that the amount claimed by the Petitioner is payable.
Therefore, the principle under which a Court may direct deposit of
an amount admitted to be payable has no application in the
present case. He submitted that the Petitioner has not produced
10
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 11:55:40
carbpl33085-2026-J.doc
any material to show that Respondent No.1 is selling or
transferring its assets, removing its assets from India, entering into
sham transactions or taking any other steps with the intention of
defeating any award that may be passed in the arbitration
proceedings. In the absence of such material, according to him,
there is no reason to grant the interim protection sought by the
Petitioner.
REASONS AND FINDINGS:
16. I have heard Mr. Joshi, learned Advocate appearing for the
Petitioner, and Mr. Hegde, learned Advocate appearing for
Respondent No.1. The main question before this Court is whether
the Petitioner has shown sufficient reason to direct Respondent
No.1 to deposit USD 700,000 or to give a Bank Guarantee for the
same amount. Another question is whether there is material to
stop Respondent No.1 from dealing with its properties and other
assets and to direct it to give details of its bank accounts,
properties and money received or likely to be received from
different projects.
17. At the beginning, it is necessary to remember that this
Petition is filed under Section 9 of the Arbitration and Conciliation
Act, 1996. At this stage, this Court is not required to finally decide
whether the Petitioner is entitled to recover USD 700,000 from
Respondent No.1. That question will be decided by the Arbitral
Tribunal. However, merely because a party has raised a money
claim in arbitration, it does not mean that the Court must direct
the other party to deposit the whole amount or give security for it.
11
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 11:55:40
carbpl33085-2026-J.doc
The Petitioner must show why such protection is necessary. It must
show that if such protection is not granted, there is a real chance
that even if an award is passed in its favour, it may not be possible
to recover the amount under that award.
18. The main document relied upon by the Petitioner is the
Minutes of Meeting dated 9 August 2024, produced at Exhibit-J,
page 80 of the Petition. According to the Petitioner, under these
Minutes, Respondent No.1 agreed to pay USD 700,000 for the
software development work done by the Petitioner for the Mumbai
Metro Line-3 Project. The Petitioner says that, as agreed in the
Minutes, it continued to provide technical support and kept its
technical team at the Project site till 31 December 2024.
Respondent No.1 disputes that these Minutes create any liability
upon it. It says that there is no unconditional obligation on its part
to pay the said amount.
19. There is no dispute that the Petitioner and Respondent No.1
entered into an Agreement dated 14 December 2022, produced at
Exhibit-F, pages 58 to 63 of the Petition. There is no dispute that
this Agreement was for software development work relating to the
Mumbai Metro Line-3 Automatic Fare Collection Project. Under
this Agreement, Respondent No.1 had engaged the Petitioner for
software development and implementation work. Respondent No.1
was carrying out the Mumbai Metro Line-3 Project as a member of
a consortium with Texmaco Rail. Thus, the work given to the
Petitioner was connected with the main Mumbai Metro Line-3
Project which Respondent No.1 was carrying out with its
consortium partner. It was not a separate transaction where the
12
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 11:55:40
carbpl33085-2026-J.doc
Petitioner was only required to supply some goods for a fixed
price. This background is important because the original
Agreement contains conditions about the manner and time in
which payment was to be made to the Petitioner.
20. On going through Exhibit-F, I find that Clause 3 is given the
heading "Payment Terms" and provides as follows:
"Back-to-Back as per project milestone and receipt of
payment as per agreement between Texmaco & ASIS".
21. Clause 4, which deals with changes in the work, provides
that payment would be made on a back-to-back basis as per the
agreement between ASIS and Texmaco. Clause 5, which deals with
increase in prices, contains a similar condition.
22. Thus, under the original Agreement, there was no clear
condition that Respondent No.1 must make payment immediately
after receiving an invoice or merely because the Petitioner had
completed its work. The payment was connected with the project
milestones and receipt of money under the arrangement between
Texmaco and Respondent No.1. This condition cannot be ignored
while considering the Petitioner's claim. At the same time, it will
have to be seen whether the parties later changed this condition by
entering into the Minutes of Meeting dated 9 August 2024.
23. Mr. Joshi submitted that Respondent No.1 ended the
Agreement by its email dated 19 July 2024. According to him,
once the Agreement was terminated, the earlier condition of back-
to-back payment came to an end. I am unable to accept this
submission. Exhibit-G, at page 64, contains an email dated 19 July
13
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 11:55:40
carbpl33085-2026-J.doc
2024 sent by Mr. Mustafa Ozicsel, Head of International Sales of
Respondent No.1. The said email reads as under:
"As you are aware, we have not achieved the required work
in Mumbai Line3 project and this was confirmed by the latest
testings in the field.
The Authority made it very clear to complete the project in
time using only Asis resources from Istanbul.
Due to not meeting project timelines and Authority's ultimate
warning for not using local support, we inform you that we
will carry out the project as Asis only without any support
from Amay.
Our decision is final and irrevocable."
24. From this email, it appears that Respondent No.1 decided to
take over the remaining work and complete the Project without
help from the Petitioner. Therefore, after this email, the Petitioner
was not expected to continue the remaining software development
work under the earlier arrangement. However, the email does not
say that the Petitioner would lose its right to claim payment for the
work completed by it. Merely because Respondent No.1 decided to
complete the remaining work, it cannot mean that the Petitioner
would have no right to ask for payment for its earlier work. But at
the same time, it cannot be said that the earlier payment condition
came to an end. In my view, even if the Agreement was ended by
the email dated 19 July 2024, the rights and liabilities which had
arisen between the parties will still have to be considered. Whether
the back-to-back payment condition continued even after the
Agreement came to an end, or whether the parties later agreed to
a different payment arrangement, will have to be decided by
14
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 11:55:40
carbpl33085-2026-J.doc
reading the original Agreement together with the Minutes of
Meeting dated 9 August 2024. Therefore, the submission of Mr.
Joshi that the back-to-back payment condition came to an end only
because the Agreement was terminated cannot be accepted
without examination. The Petitioner will have to show that
Respondent No.1 had agreed to change the earlier payment
arrangement.
25. In this connection, the Minutes of Meeting dated 9 August
2024, produced at Exhibit-J, page 80, become important. These
Minutes contain two separate parts. One part relates to the
Bhopal-Indore Project and the other part relates to the Mumbai
Metro Line-3 Project. Regarding the Mumbai Metro Line-3 Project,
the Minutes record as follows:
"As a strategical decision, Asis will take over the SW
development and implementation of MMRC Line3 project
which was subcontracted to Amay.
Asis will pay USD 700.000.- to Amay for their developments
so far and Amay will keep his team in the field till
31.12.2024."
26. The above words of the Minutes do not only say that the
parties discussed the difficulties in carrying out the Project. They
state that Respondent No.1 would take over the remaining
software development and implementation work and would pay
USD 700,000 to the Petitioner for the development work done.
They state that the Petitioner would keep its team at the Project
site till 31 December 2024. Thus, the Minutes contain words
showing that Respondent No.1 agreed to pay USD 700,000. At the
15
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 11:55:40
carbpl33085-2026-J.doc
same time, the Petitioner was required to keep its team at the
Project site till the said date. Both these things are recorded in the
same document and have to be read together. The Minutes do
support the Petitioner's case that the parties wanted to end their
earlier working arrangement and decide the amount relating to the
work completed. However, only because USD 700,000 is written in
the Minutes, it cannot immediately be held that the amount
became an unconditional debt which had to be paid without any
condition. The original Agreement, the circumstances in which the
Minutes were prepared and the authority of the person who signed
them for Respondent No.1 will have to be considered.
27. Mr. Hegde submitted that the Minutes of Meeting are not a
genuine document and that the signature shown as that of Mr.
Mustafa Ozicsel is fabricated. He submitted that Mr. Mustafa
Ozicsel was not a member of the Board of Directors of Respondent
No.1 and had no authority to make Respondent No.1 liable to pay
USD 700,000. On the other hand, the Petitioner says that senior
representatives of both parties met at Istanbul on 8 and 9 August
2024 and that the Minutes were signed by representatives of both
sides. In support of this statement, the Petitioner has produced
flight tickets, hotel booking documents and passport entry and exit
records of its representative. These documents support the
Petitioner's case that its representative had travelled to Istanbul
and attended the meetings. It is important that Respondent No.1
has not denied that meetings between representatives of both
parties took place at Istanbul on 8 and 9 August 2024. Its dispute
is mainly about whether the Minutes were signed, whether the
16
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 11:55:40
carbpl33085-2026-J.doc
signature of Mr. Mustafa Ozicsel is genuine and what legal effect
can be given to this document.
28. I have gone through Exhibit-J. Signatures are appearing at
the bottom of the document. However, what is produced before
this Court is only a copy of the Minutes. The original document has
not been produced. Respondent No.1 has denied the signature
shown as that of Mr. Mustafa Ozicsel. It has questioned his
authority to sign such an arrangement. At the same time, I find
that the allegation of fabrication made by Respondent No.1 is not
supported by examination of the original document or by any
handwriting expert's report. No separate affidavit of Mr. Mustafa
Ozicsel denying his signature has been produced. The affidavit in
reply says that the signature is not genuine and that he had no
authority to sign the Minutes. However, merely making such a
statement in the affidavit does not finally prove that the document
is fabricated. Whether the meeting took place and whether the
Minutes were signed by an authorised representative are two
different questions. The first fact is not disputed. The second is
disputed. At this stage, I am not ready to hold that Exhibit-J is a
fabricated document. Equally, I am unable to hold that the
signature and authority of the person who signed on behalf of
Respondent No.1 are fully proved.
29. I have considered the material about the position of Mr.
Mustafa Ozicsel in Respondent No.1. The email dated 19 July
2024, Exhibit-G, shows that he was communicating with the
Petitioner about the Mumbai Metro Line-3 Project. He was
informing the Petitioner about the decision of Respondent No.1 to
17
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 11:55:40
carbpl33085-2026-J.doc
take over the remaining work. In the said email, he was described
as Head of International Sales. Further, the email dated 1 August
2025, sent by Mr. Hakan Ozyurek, General Manager and Executive
Board Member of Respondent No.1, states that he had asked
Mustafa to clarify "all financial matters between the two
companies" and that prompt action would be taken thereafter.
These documents show that Mr. Mustafa Ozicsel was involved in
commercial discussions and financial matters between the two
companies. This fact will have to be kept in mind while
considering the Petitioner's case about his role in the negotiations.
However, only because Mr. Mustafa Ozicsel was involved in
commercial discussions, it does not mean that he had authority to
make Respondent No.1 liable for USD 700,000. The Petitioner has
not produced any Board Resolution, power of attorney or written
authority showing that he was authorised to make such a financial
commitment on behalf of Respondent No.1. On the other hand,
Respondent No.1 has not produced any material clearly showing
that he was completely prevented from representing the company
in such matters. Therefore, whether Mr. Mustafa Ozicsel had actual
or apparent authority to sign the Minutes and whether Respondent
No.1 later accepted or acted upon the arrangement will have to be
examined on the basis of evidence. This issue cannot be finally
decided in the present proceedings.
30. Mr. Hegde submitted that Clause 11.3 of the Agreement says
that any change in the Agreement must be in writing and must be
signed by an authorised representative of each party. I find that
there is substance in this submission to the extent that if the
18
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 11:55:40
carbpl33085-2026-J.doc
Minutes are being relied upon as a document changing the
payment conditions of the original Agreement, they must satisfy
the requirement of Clause 11.3. Clause 11.3 says that the
Agreement cannot be changed, amended or modified unless it is
done in writing and signed by an authorised representative of both
parties. The Minutes are in writing. The Petitioner's case is that
they were signed by representatives of both parties. However, the
signature and authority of the person signing on behalf of
Respondent No.1 are disputed. If the Petitioner proves that the
Minutes were signed by an authorised representative of
Respondent No.1, it will have to be considered whether the earlier
payment conditions were changed by reading the entire Minutes
together with the original Agreement. If such authority is not
proved, the Minutes may not be treated as a valid change to the
original Agreement. Therefore, the Petitioner's submission that the
Minutes have replaced the earlier payment conditions cannot be
accepted as a final position at this stage. At the same time, the
submission of Respondent No.1 that the Minutes have no legal
effect at all cannot be accepted without examining the necessary
evidence.
31. Mr. Hegde submitted that the Minutes do not mention any
date by which the amount of USD 700,000 was required to be
paid. He submitted that there is no mention of the mode of
payment, interest or any final settlement of all the claims between
the parties. I find that there is some substance in this submission.
The Minutes record that Respondent No.1 "will pay USD 700.000"
to the Petitioner. However, no date or period for making the
19
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 11:55:40
carbpl33085-2026-J.doc
payment is mentioned. There is no statement that the amount
must be paid immediately, within a particular number of days or
within a fixed period after Respondent No.1 receives money from
Texmaco. However, only because the Minutes do not mention a
particular date for payment, it cannot be said that there was no
promise to pay at all. It may still be possible to find out when
payment was required to be made by looking at the nature of the
arrangement and the conduct of the parties. But the absence of a
payment date is an important fact while considering whether the
amount can be treated as an admitted amount which is payable for
granting interim relief.
32. Mr. Hegde submitted that the Minutes must be read along
with Clauses 3 to 5 and Clause 11.1 of the original Agreement.
Clause 11.1 says that the Agreement and its annexures form the
entire Agreement between the parties. According to him, the
Minutes do not clearly say that the earlier condition of back-to-
back payment is removed. On this aspect, I find that the Minutes
do not state that Clause 3 of the original Agreement will no longer
apply. They do not say that the payment of USD 700,000 will be
independent of the amount received by Respondent No.1 from
Texmaco. On the other hand, the words used in the Minutes are
that Respondent No.1 "will pay" USD 700,000 towards the
development work done by the Petitioner. The Petitioner may
therefore argue before the Arbitral Tribunal that the Minutes
amounted to a fresh settlement of the amount payable and that the
earlier payment condition no longer applied. At this stage, both
views are possible. What the parties intended will have to be
20
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 11:55:40
carbpl33085-2026-J.doc
understood from the words used in the Minutes, the original
Agreement and the conduct of the parties after the Minutes were
signed. This Court cannot finally decide between these two views
in proceedings under Section 9. The Arbitral Tribunal will have to
decide whether the Minutes changed or settled the earlier payment
arrangement.
33. Mr. Joshi and Mr. Hegde both relied upon the judgment in
Tata Advanced Materials Limited . I have gone through both the
judgments referred to by the learned Advocates. The learned
Single Judge, in paragraph 14 of the judgment reported in 2012
SCC OnLine Bom 1566, had observed that the question was not
only about liability to make payment but that payment was subject
to reconciliation and receipt of payment from HAL. However, the
said judgment was challenged before the Division Bench of this
Court. The Division Bench, in its judgment reported in 2013 SCC
OnLine Bom 1922, set aside the order passed by the learned Single
Judge. In paragraph 17, the Division Bench expressly observed
"Accordingly, the impugned judgment and order dated 17
October 2012 passed by the learned Company Judge,
dismissing Company Petition No. 198 of 2012 is set aside."
34. Therefore, the view taken by the learned Single Judge in that
matter cannot be treated as the final view of this Court. The
judgment of the Division Bench will have to be considered. In
paragraph 9 of the judgment of the Division Bench, the Court
found that the dispute raised by the respondent company was
neither bona fide nor substantial. This finding was based upon an
undertaking given by the respondent company on 29 July 2009
21
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 11:55:40
carbpl33085-2026-J.doc
and balance confirmation letters dated 25 March 2010 and 7
March 2011. The respondent company had clearly accepted the
amount payable. It had made payments against the invoices raised
by the appellant without raising any dispute. The Division Bench,
therefore, observed that the dispute regarding the debt payable to
the appellant was "neither bona fide, nor substantial".
35. However, the facts of the present case are different. Here,
Respondent No.1 has disputed the Minutes of Meeting. It has
questioned the authority of the person who is said to have signed
them. There is no similar written undertaking given by an
authorised officer whose authority is not disputed. There is no
balance confirmation letter in which Respondent No.1 has clearly
accepted, without any condition, that USD 700,000 is immediately
payable. Therefore, the finding recorded in paragraph 9 of the
Division Bench judgment cannot be applied to the present case in
the same way. The documents and circumstances of the present
matter will have to be examined. Paragraph 12 of the Division
Bench judgment is important because the Court considered what is
meant by a back-to-back payment condition. The Division Bench
interpreted Clause 5.2 of the purchase order and observed as
follows:
"The use of the word “however” makes it clear that though
the respondent company was bound to effect the payments
within 3 to 5 working days upon receipt of payments from
HAL, nevertheless if such payments were not forthcoming
from HAL, the respondent company would do the best
possible to release payments within 45 days from the date of
receipt of certified bills from the appellant. The payments of
22
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 11:55:40
carbpl33085-2026-J.doc
amounts to the appellant was therefore not dependant upon
the respondent company receiving payments from HAL."
36. Thus, the Division Bench did not accept the argument that
the respondent company could avoid payment only because it had
not received money from HAL. This was because the contract
contained another condition. Under that condition, the respondent
company was required to make its best possible efforts to release
payment within 45 days from the date of receipt of certified bills
from the appellant. The important difference in the present case is
that Clause 3 of Exhibit-F does not contain any similar condition
requiring payment within 45 days or any other fixed period, even
if money is not received from Texmaco. It connects payment with
the project milestones and receipt of payment under the
agreement between Texmaco and ASIS. Therefore, the judgment of
the Division Bench does not support the Petitioner's submission
that the back-to-back payment condition in the present Agreement
can simply be ignored. At the same time, it cannot be said that the
words "back-to-back" will always mean that payment can be
delayed for unlimited time. The exact conditions of the Agreement
and the later arrangement between the parties will have to be
considered.
37. The Division Bench judgment noticed that there was no
privity of contract between the appellant and HAL. In the present
matter also, the Petitioner is not a party to the main arrangement
between Texmaco and Respondent No.1. However, there is one
important difference. In the present case, the parties have referred
to the agreement between Texmaco and ASIS in Clause 3 of
23
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 11:55:40
carbpl33085-2026-J.doc
Exhibit-F. Therefore, the Petitioner cannot completely avoid the
effect of the payment condition which it had accepted under the
original Agreement. Whether the Minutes dated 9 August 2024
changed this condition is a separate question. That question will
have to be decided.
38. I now come to the question whether the Petitioner carried
out its obligations under the Minutes. Respondent No.1 has denied
that the Petitioner properly completed its obligations till 31
December 2024. In this connection, I have considered the email
correspondence at Exhibit-K, pages 81 and 82. By its email dated 1
January 2025, the Petitioner informed Respondent No.1 that its
support for the Mumbai Metro Line-3 Project had ended on 31
December 2024 and that its team would be withdrawn from 1
January 2025. In reply, Mr. Muharrem Saygi asked whether the
Petitioner could continue giving support for one more month. The
Petitioner, by its email dated 5 January 2025, informed
Respondent No.1 that its engineers had been engaged in another
project and that it was not possible for them to continue the
support period. This correspondence supports the Petitioner's case
that it continued to give support till 31 December 2024.
Respondent No.1 has not pointed out any particular technical work
or support which the Petitioner was required to provide during this
period but failed to provide. A general denial about the Petitioner's
work is not enough to completely reject its case at this
stage.Therefore, for the limited purpose of deciding the present
application, I am inclined to accept that the Petitioner has shown
that it continued to provide technical support till 31 December
24
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 11:55:40
carbpl33085-2026-J.doc
2024, as recorded in the Minutes. However, this finding will not
prevent the Arbitral Tribunal from examining the complete work
done by both parties and the quality of the work carried out by the
Petitioner.
39. I have considered the email dated 12 November 2024 at
page 83 of the Petition. By this email, the Petitioner requested
Respondent No.1 to make an interim payment of USD 200,000. It
suggested that the remaining amount could be paid in five equal
monthly instalments beginning from December 2024. This email
shows that after the Minutes were prepared, the Petitioner was
asking Respondent No.1 to make payment. It shows that the
Petitioner was ready to discuss how the amount could be paid in
instalments. However, there is nothing in this email to show that
Respondent No.1 accepted the suggested payment arrangement. It
does not prove that the entire amount of USD 700,000 had
become payable on any particular date.
40. I have considered the email dated 8 January 2025 at page 85
of the Petition. In this email, the Petitioner described as a "back-to-
back partner" and requested Respondent No.1 to release the
payment received by it from SBI in relation to the Agra Project.
This email shows that the Petitioner understood that payments
between the parties were connected with the receipt of money
from the main project. However, this email relates to the Agra
Project. Therefore, only on the basis of this email, it cannot be
concluded that payment of USD 700,000 relating to the Mumbai
Metro Line-3 Project was subject to the same condition. This is
particularly so because the Petitioner relies upon the later Minutes
25
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 11:55:40
carbpl33085-2026-J.doc
of Meeting dated 9 August 2024 for its claim relating to Line-3.
Thus, this email is one of the facts which will have to be
considered. However, it cannot give a complete answer to the
Petitioner's claim.
41. The most important correspondence for understanding the
financial dealings between the parties is the email exchange dated
21 January 2025, produced at pages 101 to 103 of the Petition. By
its email dated 21 January 2025, the Petitioner placed before
Respondent No.1 a combined statement showing the amounts
payable by both parties in relation to different projects. In the said
statement, the Petitioner showed Rs.1,88,55,000 as payable by it
to Respondent No.1 in relation to the Kolkata Project. It showed
Rs.5,87,93,000 as payable by Respondent No.1 to the Petitioner in
relation to the Mumbai Metro Line-3 Project. The said amount was
described as 700K USD on the date of settlement, i.e. 9 August
2024. The Petitioner showed Rs.2,50,20,536 as payable by
Respondent No.1 to it in relation to the Agra Project. After
adjusting the amounts shown as payable by both parties, the
Petitioner arrived at a net amount of Rs.6,49,58,536 payable by
Respondent No.1 to the Petitioner. The Petitioner showed interest,
GST and other financial items amounting to Rs.47,44,075 as
payable by it to Respondent No.1. Thus, from the Petitioner's own
statement, it appears that the financial dealings between the
parties were not only about the Mumbai Metro Line-3 Project. Both
parties had raised claims relating to the Kolkata, Agra and other
projects. The Petitioner suggested that the accounts of different
projects should be considered together and the amounts should be
26
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 11:55:40
carbpl33085-2026-J.doc
adjusted. The above email and the statement prepared by the
Petitioner are important for one more reason. Though the
Petitioner relies upon USD 700,000 as an amount agreed under the
Minutes of Meeting, its later correspondence shows that it was
treating this amount as part of the total financial dealings between
the parties.
42. The Petitioner described USD 700,000 as payable on the date
of settlement, namely 9 August 2024. This supports its case that it
understood the Minutes as a settlement of its financial claim
relating to Line-3. However, the figures in the statement were
prepared by the Petitioner. There is no clear acceptance of the
entire statement by Respondent No.1. In the same email exchange,
the Chief Financial Officer of Respondent No.1, Mr. Gurkan
Gucbilmez, thanked the Petitioner for giving the explanation and
asked for a meeting to discuss all aspects of the matter in greater
detail. He did not clearly accept the figures mentioned in the
statement. He did not confirm that USD 700,000 was immediately
payable without any adjustment or condition. Therefore, this
correspondence shows that there were financial disputes between
the parties. However, it cannot be treated as an unconditional
admission by Respondent No.1 that the entire amount of USD
700,000 was payable immediately.
43. Mr. Hegde has relied upon the email correspondence dated
15 June 2025 to 9 July 2025, which forms part of Exhibit-Q. I find
that all these emails will have to be read together. On 15 June
2025, the Petitioner informed Respondent No.1 that the amount of
USD 700,000 relating to the Mumbai Line-3 Project had remained
27
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 11:55:40
carbpl33085-2026-J.doc
unpaid for more than ten months. It requested the management of
Respondent No.1 to look into the matter and give a clear plan for
payment. Respondent No.1, by its reply dated 8 July 2025, stated
that it was taking help of its lawyers to clarify the matter with
Texmaco and required some more time. The Petitioner, by its email
dated 9 July 2025, did not accept this explanation. It stated that its
payment had no connection with the pending dispute between
ASIS and Texmaco and again demanded immediate payment of
USD 700,000. Thus, these emails show that both parties had
different views about the connection between the Mumbai Line-3
payment and the financial arrangement between ASIS and
Texmaco. Respondent No.1 was saying that the matter required
clarification with Texmaco. The Petitioner, on the other hand, was
saying that its payment was separate from that dispute. This is an
important dispute between the parties. The email of Respondent
No.1 shows that it was considering the question of payment.
However, it does not contain any unconditional admission that
USD 700,000 was immediately payable irrespective of the
arrangement with Texmaco.
44. I have considered the email dated 1 August 2025, Exhibit-M,
at page 114 of the Petition. The said email was sent by Mr. Hakan
Ozyurek, General Manager and Executive Board Member of
Respondent No.1. In the said email, he stated that he had asked
Mr. Mustafa Ozicsel to clarify "all financial matters between the
two companies" and that prompt action would be taken after such
clarification. This email shows that Respondent No.1 knew that
financial matters between the two companies were pending and
28
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 11:55:40
carbpl33085-2026-J.doc
that its senior management had asked Mr. Mustafa Ozicsel to
examine them. However, the email does not mention USD
700,000. It does not say that Respondent No.1 had accepted that
the said amount was payable without any examination or
adjustment. Therefore, this email cannot be treated as a clear and
unconditional admission of liability for USD 700,000. It only shows
that the financial matters between the parties were still being
looked into by Respondent No.1.
45. The Petitioner has relied upon the legal notice dated 17
February 2026, marked as Exhibit-N, at pages 119 to 121. In this
notice, the Petitioner demanded USD 700,000 along with interest.
It alleged that Respondent No.1 had transferred approximately
USD 1,000,000 from its Bhopal Project Office without making any
arrangement for payment of the Petitioner's dues. The notice
alleged that Respondent No.1 was in the process of closing down
its business activities in India. These are serious allegations.
However, the legal notice was issued by the Petitioner. It contains
the allegations made by the Petitioner. It does not contain any
independent bank statement or other document showing that USD
1,000,000 was transferred. It does not show from which bank
account the amount was transferred, to whom it was transferred or
why the transfer was made. Therefore, only because the allegation
about transfer of USD 1,000,000 is mentioned in the legal notice,
it cannot be treated as a fact which has been proved.
46. I now come to the main submission of Mr. Joshi regarding
the financial position and business activities of Respondent No.1 in
India. He submitted that Respondent No.1 is a company
29
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 11:55:40
carbpl33085-2026-J.doc
incorporated in Türkiye and that its business activities in India
have reduced considerably. According to him, the Agra Metro
Project was terminated and the Bhopal-Indore Metro Project came
to an end due to national security reasons. He therefore
apprehends that Respondent No.1 may transfer its money from
India and make it difficult for the Petitioner to recover the amount
under any future award. In support of this submission, he relied
upon the termination notice dated 7 August 2025 relating to the
Agra Metro Project and the notice dated 18 August 2025 relating
to the Bhopal-Indore Metro Project. Both these documents form
part of Exhibit-Q.
47. I have gone through both the notices. The notice dated 7
August 2025 was issued by State Bank of India in relation to the
Agra Metro Project. It records that the competent authority had
decided to use its right to terminate the contract under Clause
16.2. The contract was to stand terminated on 5 November 2025.
However, the said notice does not state that the contract was
terminated for any national security reason. It does not state that
Respondent No.1 had become insolvent or was unable to meet its
financial liabilities. The second notice dated 18 August 2025 was
issued by the Madhya Pradesh Metro Rail Corporation Limited in
relation to the Bhopal and Indore Metro Rail Projects. It refers to
Sub-Clause 18.6 of the contract and states that carrying out the
work had become impossible due to circumstances arising from
national security reasons. It states that both the contractor and the
employer would be released from performance of the contract.
These documents show that the Agra and Bhopal-Indore Projects
30
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 11:55:40
carbpl33085-2026-J.doc
were affected and that Respondent No.1 could not continue those
projects in the earlier manner. However, only because two project
contracts came to an end, it cannot be said that Respondent No.1
has become unable to pay its liabilities or that it is transferring its
assets to defeat the Petitioner's claim. It is important to notice that
neither of these notices relates to the Mumbai Metro Line-3
Project. The Petitioner has stated that it does not have any official
document showing that similar action was taken in relation to the
Mumbai Metro Line-3 Project. The fact that the Agra and Bhopal-
Indore Projects were affected may have some effect on the future
business activities of Respondent No.1 in India. However, there is
no material to show that Respondent No.1 has closed all its offices
in India, stopped all its business activities, sold its properties or
transferred all its assets outside India. A company may lose a
project or may be required to stop work on a project for reasons
which are beyond its control. Only because such an event has
taken place, it cannot be said that the company intends to avoid
paying the money claimed by another party. Similarly, the fact that
Respondent No.1 is incorporated in Türkiye cannot be a reason to
direct it to give security. It cannot be presumed that a foreign
company will not honour an arbitral award only because it is
incorporated outside India. There must be some material about the
conduct of that particular company which creates a real fear that
the award may not be possible to enforce.
48. I find that the correspondence with Texmaco does not prove
that Respondent No.1 has started transferring its assets or closing
its business in India. The correspondence shows that there were
31
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 11:55:40
carbpl33085-2026-J.doc
financial issues or disputes between Respondent No.1 and its
consortium partner. This may create some uncertainty about the
amount which Respondent No.1 expects to receive in relation to
the Mumbai Metro Line-3 Project. However, there is a difference
between uncertainty about receiving money from a business
partner and an intention to remove assets or defeat an arbitral
award. The Petitioner has not produced any material to show that
Respondent No.1 has deliberately transferred any identified
property or money to another person with the intention of
avoiding payment of the Petitioner's claim.
49. Mr. Joshi submitted that the amount which may be received
by Respondent No.1 from Mumbai Metro Rail Corporation Limited
may be transferred or removed before the arbitral award is passed.
He therefore asked for a direction against Respondent No.4,
namely Mumbai Metro Rail Corporation Limited, to disclose all
running bills, final bills, retention money, security deposits and
other amounts which may be payable to Respondent No.1. I have
considered this submission. The documents show that the main
Mumbai Metro Line-3 contract was awarded to the Kalindee-ASIS
Joint Venture. Respondent No.1 was carrying out the work as a
member of the said consortium with Texmaco. The Petitioner was
engaged by Respondent No.1 for software development work
under the Agreement dated 14 December 2022. Therefore, the
contract between Mumbai Metro Rail Corporation Limited and the
Kalindee-ASIS Joint Venture is different from the contract between
the Petitioner and Respondent No.1. The Petitioner has not
produced any clear material to show that Respondent No.4 is
32
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 11:55:40
carbpl33085-2026-J.doc
directly liable to pay a separate amount of USD 700,000 or any
other identified amount to Respondent No.1. Only because the
Mumbai Metro Line-3 Project is situated in Mumbai and
Respondent No.1 is a member of the consortium, it cannot be said
that every amount payable by Respondent No.4 to the consortium
belongs only to Respondent No.1. The interests of Texmaco and
other members of the consortium may be involved. Therefore,
when there is no material showing that Respondent No.4 is
holding money which belongs to Respondent No.1 and which
needs to be secured for the Petitioner's claim, I am not inclined to
grant the disclosure direction sought against Respondent No.4.
50. Mr. Hegde submitted that the Petitioner is trying to secure an
ordinary money claim by asking for very wide orders against all
the assets and bank accounts of Respondent No.1. According to
him, the Petitioner has not identified any particular property or
bank account which Respondent No.1 is trying to dispose of. I find
substance in this submission. On page 31 of the Petition, the
Petitioner has asked for a direction to Respondent No.1 to deposit
the entire amount of USD 700,000 with the Prothonotary and
Senior Master of this Court. In the alternative, it has asked for a
direction to furnish an unconditional and irrevocable Bank
Guarantee for USD 700,000 along with interest and arbitration
costs. The prayers on pages 32 to 34 are very wide. The Petitioner
wants to stop Respondent No.1 and its officers from dealing with
movable and immovable properties, bank balances, amounts
receivable and other financial interests in India. It has asked for
details of all movable and immovable properties in India and
33
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 11:55:40
carbpl33085-2026-J.doc
Türkiye, all bank accounts, bank statements from 9 August 2024,
details of money sent outside India and preservation of all
financial and electronic records. These directions would cover
almost all the assets and bank accounts of Respondent No.1. This
would include even those assets which may have no connection
with the Mumbai Metro Line-3 Project or the amount claimed by
the Petitioner. The Petitioner has not shown any particular transfer
or transaction which would justify such wide directions.
51. A direction to deposit the entire amount claimed or to give a
Bank Guarantee for the same amount will have serious financial
effect. A Bank Guarantee for USD 700,000 may affect the banking
limits and working capital of Respondent No.1. Such a direction
cannot be passed only because the Petitioner has made a claim and
fears that the amount may not be paid in future. It is true that the
powers of this Court under Section 9 are wide. The Court is not
required to follow every technical requirement relating to
attachment before judgment under the Code of Civil Procedure in
exactly the same way as in an ordinary civil suit. However, when a
party asks for an order which will have the effect of freezing the
assets of another party or securing the entire money claim even
before the dispute is decided, the Court must be satisfied that such
an order is really needed. The Court will have to see whether the
applicant has shown a proper case, whether the proposed order is
necessary for protecting the subject matter of arbitration, whether
the balance of convenience is in favour of granting such relief and
whether refusal of the relief is likely to cause serious loss which
cannot be properly compensated later. A Petition under Section 9
34
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 11:55:40
carbpl33085-2026-J.doc
cannot be used only to convert an ordinary disputed money claim
into a secured claim. There must be some material showing why
such security is required in the facts of that particular case.
52. In the present matter, I find that the Petitioner has shown
that there is a genuine commercial dispute between the parties
regarding USD 700,000. The Minutes of Meeting dated 9 August
2024 mention this amount. The Petitioner has shown that it
continued providing technical support till 31 December 2024. The
later emails show that the question of payment remained under
discussion between the parties for a considerable time. Therefore, I
am not ready to say that the Petitioner's claim is imaginary or has
no basis. The Petitioner has shown that it has a claim which
deserves to be examined by the Arbitral Tribunal. However, having
a claim which can be argued is one thing. Whether that claim
requires immediate protection by directing deposit of the entire
amount or giving a Bank Guarantee is another thing. For getting
such protection, the Petitioner must show that there is a real
possibility that Respondent No.1 may take steps to make the
arbitral award ineffective by disposing of or transferring its assets.
On this point, the Petitioner has not produced sufficient material.
The termination of two other project contracts and the
correspondence with Texmaco do not prove that Respondent No.1
is removing its assets from India or deliberately taking steps to
defeat the Petitioner's claim.
53. Mr. Hegde has pointed out that the Petitioner did not
approach this Court without delay. According to him, the Minutes
of Meeting were made on 9 August 2024 and the period for
35
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 11:55:40
carbpl33085-2026-J.doc
providing technical support ended on 31 December 2024. Even
then, the Petitioner issued its first final legal notice only on 17
February 2026 and filed the present Petition in September 2026. I
have considered this submission. The Petitioner has explained that
correspondence and discussions between the parties were
continuing and that it was trying to settle the dispute without
approaching the Court. The email dated 15 June 2025, the reply
dated 8 July 2025, the email dated 9 July 2025 and the email
dated 1 August 2025 show that the parties were still discussing
their pending financial matters. Therefore, the delay cannot be
treated as a reason to reject the Petitioner's entire claim. A party
may make genuine efforts to settle a dispute before starting legal
proceedings. However, when a party asks for urgent interim
protection on the ground that the other party may remove its
assets, the time taken in approaching the Court becomes an
important matter. The Petitioner relies upon events which took
place in August 2025 to show that the business position of
Respondent No.1 in India was reducing. The legal notice dated 17
February 2026 made the allegation that Respondent No.1 was
closing down its business activities. Even after these circumstances,
the Petitioner approached this Court only in September 2026. The
Petitioner has not given any convincing explanation as to why it
could not approach the Court earlier, even though it knew about
these circumstances. The delay does not take away its right to
pursue the arbitration claim. However, it makes the argument of
immediate danger less convincing. If there was such an immediate
danger that the assets of Respondent No.1 required urgent
36
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 11:55:40
carbpl33085-2026-J.doc
protection, the Petitioner could have approached the Court earlier.
54. Now, after considering all the material placed before this
Court, I find that the Petitioner has shown that there is a genuine
dispute regarding payment of USD 700,000. The Minutes of
Meeting dated 9 August 2024 state that Respondent No.1 would
pay this amount for the software development work done. The
Petitioner has shown that it continued providing technical support
till 31 December 2024. The later emails show that the question of
payment remained pending and was discussed between the parties
on different occasions. However, whether USD 700,000 was an
unconditional amount which had become payable immediately is
disputed. The original Agreement contains a back-to-back payment
condition. The Minutes do not say that this condition has been
removed. The signature and authority of the person who signed
the Minutes on behalf of Respondent No.1 are disputed. The later
correspondence shows that the parties were considering amounts
payable in relation to different projects and were trying to settle
their total financial dealings. Therefore, on the material available, I
am unable to treat USD 700,000 as an admitted and undisputed
liability for which the entire amount can immediately be secured
by directing Respondent No.1 to deposit it in Court. More
importantly, the Petitioner has not produced sufficient material to
show that Respondent No.1 is selling or disposing of its assets or
transferring money outside India with the intention of defeating
the Petitioner's claim. The termination of the Agra and Bhopal-
Indore Project contracts shows that the business activities of
Respondent No.1 in those projects were affected. However, this
37
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 11:55:40
carbpl33085-2026-J.doc
fact alone does not prove that Respondent No.1 is closing down its
business in India or removing its assets to avoid payment of the
Petitioner's claim. The allegation that approximately USD
1,000,000 was transferred from the Bhopal Project Office is not
supported by any bank statement or other independent document.
There is no material to show that the assets of Respondent No.1
have been sold, transferred, charged or removed from India with
the intention of making the arbitral award ineffective. The
Petitioner's fear about future recovery may be genuine from its
point of view. However, the Court cannot pass an order for deposit
or attachment only because a party has such a fear. There must be
some material showing that this fear is supported by actual
conduct or circumstances which create a real possibility that
enforcement of the award may become difficult.
55. I find that the balance of convenience is not in favour of
granting the reliefs sought by the Petitioner. The Petitioner has
raised a money claim which can be examined by the Arbitral
Tribunal. If the Petitioner succeeds, the Tribunal may pass an
award for the amount found payable, along with interest and
costs, as permitted by law. On the other hand, if Respondent No.1
is directed to deposit USD 700,000 or give a Bank Guarantee for
the same amount, it may affect its working capital and banking
facilities. A restriction against dealing with all its assets and a
direction to disclose all bank accounts and money sent outside
India would affect its normal business activities. Such directions
cannot be given unless there is material to show that they are
necessary for protecting the Petitioner's claim. The Petitioner has
38
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 11:55:40
carbpl33085-2026-J.doc
not shown such necessity. The reliefs asked for are much wider
than what is required for protecting the subject matter of the
present arbitration. If granted, they would practically secure the
entire money claim even before the Arbitral Tribunal decides
whether the amount is payable and under what conditions it is
payable.
56. I am therefore of the opinion that the Petitioner has shown
that it has a claim which can be pursued before the Arbitral
Tribunal. However, it has not shown sufficient grounds for granting
the interim measures asked for in the present Petition. The
Petitioner's claim cannot be rejected only because Respondent No.1
disputes the Minutes or the back-to-back payment condition. These
are matters which can be decided by the Arbitral Tribunal after
considering the evidence produced by both parties. However, only
because there is a genuine dispute between the parties, it does not
mean that the Petitioner becomes entitled to an order for deposit,
security or attachment of assets. The Petitioner was required to
show that such protection was necessary to prevent the arbitral
award from becoming ineffective. On the material available, this
requirement has not been satisfied.
57. It is made clear that the findings recorded above are only for
deciding the present Petition under Section 9 of the Arbitration
and Conciliation Act, 1996. They shall not be treated as final
findings about whether Exhibit-J is genuine, whether Mr. Mustafa
Ozicsel had authority to sign the Minutes, what is the effect of
Clause 3 of Exhibit-F, whether the Agreement was validly
terminated or whether the Petitioner is finally entitled to receive
39
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 11:55:40
carbpl33085-2026-J.doc
USD 700,000. The Arbitral Tribunal will be free to decide all these
questions independently after considering the pleadings,
documents and evidence produced by both parties. Nothing stated
in this judgment will prevent either party from raising its claims or
defences before the Arbitral Tribunal.
58. In view of the above discussion and findings, I am not
inclined to grant the prayers asking for deposit of USD 700,000,
furnishing of a Bank Guarantee, restriction against dealing with
assets, disclosure of bank accounts and money sent outside India
or attachment of the assets of Respondent No.1. The prayer asking
Respondent No.4 to disclose information is not made out on the
material available.
59. The Commercial Arbitration Petition is accordingly
dismissed. There shall be no order as to costs.
60. It is made clear that dismissal of the present Petition will not
prevent the Petitioner from pursuing its money claim in
accordance with the arbitration agreement.
61. All contentions on the merits of the disputes are kept open
for consideration by the Arbitral Tribunal.
(AMIT BORKAR, J.)
40
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 11:55:40
Powered by TCPDF (www.tcpdf.org)