SUKHVINDER vs DEPARTMENT OF POSTS
- Court
- Central Administrative Tribunal
1
O.A. No. 2944/2025
Item No. 08 (C-2)
CENTRAL ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL
PRINCIPAL BENCH, NEW DELHI
O.A. No. 2944/2025
rd
This the 23 day of October, 2026
Hon’ble Mr. R. N. Singh, Member (J)
Hon’ble Mr. Rajinder Kashyap, Member (A)
1. SHRI SUKHVINDER
S/o Jaibir Singh
R/oH. No. L7-C, Gali No. 9,
Near BD School, Azad Nagar, Panipat
Haryana-132103
2. MANDEEP
So Late Mohinder Singh
R/o V.P.O Chhattar (Sameer Patti) Tehsil Uchana, District Jind,
Haryana -126125
3. SANJAY KUMAR
S/o Mahavir Singh
R/O- Chhimpo Ka Mohalla,
VPO- Badbirana Tehsil Nohar,
District- Hanumangarh-335523
4. MANTU
So Chandi Ram,
R/o, VPO- Sandil, Tehsil- Jind, Haryana- 126102.
(All posted as Postal Assistant /Sorting Assistant
Group C Employees with Department of Posts)
… Applicants
(By Advocate: Mr. Mukesh Kumar)
Versus
1. UNION OF INDIA
Through The Secretary, Ministry of Communications,
Department of Posts, Dak Bhawan, New Delhi-110001
2. THE DIRECTOR GENERAL OF INDIA POST
Ministry of Communications,
Department of Posts,
Government of India,
Dak Bhawan, Sansad Marg, New Delhi-110001
3. THE CHIEF POSTMASTER GENERAL
Gujarat Circle, Post Office,
Makubhai Sheth Marg, Opposite Khanpur,
Ahmedabad, Gujarat 380001
AKANSHA
2026.11.09
14:06:37
+05'30'
AKANSHA
2
O.A. No. 2944/2025
Item No. 08 (C-2)
4. THE CHIEF POSTMASTER GENERAL
Opp: Kalla Hospital, Sardar Patel Marg,
Hathroi, Jaipur, Rajasthan 302001
5. SUPERINTENDENT OF POST OFFICE,
RMS AM Division, Ahmedabad, Gujarat -380004
6. SUPERINTENDENT OF POST OFFICE,
Bharuch, Gujarat-360575
7. SUPERINTENDENT OF POST OFFICE
Junagadh, Division Junagadh, Gujarat
8. SUPERINTENDENT OF POST OFFICE,
Churu, Churu Division, Gujarat-331001.
.... Respondents
(By Advocate: Mr. Subhash Gosai)
AKANSHA
2026.11.09
14:06:37
+05'30'
AKANSHA
3
O.A. No. 2944/2025
Item No. 08 (C-2)
O R D E R (ORAL)
Hon’ble Mr. R. N. Singh, Member (J)
This is the second round of litigation. Earlier, the
applicants had approached this Tribunal vide O.A. No.
2001/2022, seeking the following relief(s):-
“i) Quash and set aside the Impugned Order No. B2-
18/PA/Direct Rectt/2013 & 2014 dated 10.05.2022 vide which
the applicant's representation dated 27.09.2021 has been
rejected on the basis of CFS report vide which it has been ruled
that the applicant's signature on the OMR sheet did not match
with specimen signature and hence the offer of appointment
has been cancelled.
ii) Direct the respondents to allow the applicant to join to the
Post of Postal Assistant/Sorting Assistant with full back wages
and all consequential benefits.
iii) To kindly extend the benefit of order dated 10.03.2022
passed by the Hon'ble Central Administrative Tribunal
Principal Bench, New Delhi in O.A. 2756/2019 Sanjeev Kumar
etc.
iv) Any other relief the Hon'ble tribunal deems fit and proper
in the facts and circumstances of the case.”
2. The said OA was partly allowed vide a common order
dated 13.04.2023 (Annexure A-8). Para 7 of the same reads
as under:-
“7. In view of the aforesaid, the captioned OAs are partly
allowed. The impugned orders of termination are set aside.
The respondents are directed to re-instate the applicants. The
applicants shall be entitled for consequential benefits, in
accordance with rules and instructions on the subject. The
aforesaid exercise shall be completed by the respondents as
expeditiously as possible and preferably within six weeks from
the date of receipt of a copy of this order. However, the
respondents shall be at liberty to proceed against the
applicants, if they so desire, in accordance with relevant rules
and instructions. However, in the facts and circumstances,
there shall be no order as to costs.
A copy of this order may be placed in case files of both the
OAs.”
AKANSHA
2026.11.09
14:06:37
+05'30'
AKANSHA
4
O.A. No. 2944/2025
Item No. 08 (C-2)
3. In purported compliance of directions of the Tribunal
in order dated 13.04.2023, the applicant was reinstated in
service vide order dated 07.02.2025 [Annexure A-2 (Colly)],
which reads as under:-
“In pursuance of Circle office Ahmedabad letter no.STA/11-
424/101/CAT-PB/SJS/2023/11 dated 07.02.2025 received
through email dated 07.02.2025 from the ADPS(Staff),
Ahmedabad HQ Region, Ahmedabad and approval accorded
by DG(P), New Delhi letter No.A-34018/15/2024-DE dated
06.02.2025, the undersigned is pleased to issue order of
reinstatement with immediate effect.
Shri Sukhvinder Jaibirsingh is posted as Sorting Assistant in
the pay matrix of 5200-20200 (Grade pay of Rs.2400) at
HRO Ahmedabad, RMS 'AM' Division with immediate effect.
The pay and allowances will be governed as per the prevailing
th
rates/instructions contained in 7 CPC recommedations.
1. The order of resinstatement is subject to the conditions laid
down in his original order of appointment.
2. He shall have to undergo/complete the induction training, if
not undergone earlier.
3. No TA/DA is admissible to the officials.
4. This is in compliance of order passed by the Hon'ble
Supreme court of India in the SLP Diary No.55733/2024 filed
by the Department against the judgement dated 27.08.2024
pased by the Hon'ble High Court of Delhi in Writ Petition no.
13635/2023.”
4. Alleging willful defiance of directions of the Tribunal
contained in order dated 13.04.2023, the petitioner had
approached this Tribunal by way of C.P. No. 775/2024,
wherein it has been the case of the applicant that
consequential benefits have not been granted to the
petitioner while reinstating him in service pursuant to
directions of the Tribunal. The CP was closed vide order
dated 26.05.2025 (Annexure A-13), with liberty to him to
AKANSHA
2026.11.09
14:06:37
+05'30'
AKANSHA
5
O.A. No. 2944/2025
Item No. 08 (C-2)
agitate his surviving grievances, if any, afresh in accordance
with law.
5. It is not in dispute that in view of such liberty the
present OA has been filed seeking the following relief(s):-
“a) Partly quash and set aside impugned order dated
17.04.2025 issued by the Director (GDS), Department of Posts
(Respondent No.I) to the extent of para ii and ili, wherein it is
stated:-
ii. If any material is available against the candidates,
appropriate action in accordance with law, after
providing due opportunity of hearing, may be taken.
iii. Principle of 'No Work No Pay' may be strictly
adhered to.
b) Partly quash and set aside the: -
a. Memo No. B.7/1/T/2013&14/2025 dated 07.02.2025
sent by the Senior Superintendent RMS 'AM' Division,
Ahmedabad-380004 to the Applicant No.1.
b. Memo No. B2/11/Rectt/2013&2014/2025 dated
17.04.2025 sent by the Superintendent of post offices
Junagadh Division, Junagadh-362001 to the Applicant
No.2.
c. Memo No.B2-9/17-18 dated 19.04.2025 sent by the
Superintendent of post offices 'Churu Division', Churu-
331001 to the Applicant No.3.
d. Memo No. B2/11/Rectt/2013&2014/2025 dated
17.04.2025 sent by the Superintendent of post offices
Junagadh Division', Junagadh-362001 to the Applicant
No.4.
c) Direct the Respondents to grant the consequential benefits
including seniority/ notional seniority, full pay & back wages
with arrears and interest & counting of service for all
purposes, which are denied to the applicant and further direct
the Respondents to assign seniority to the Applicant from the
date of their initial appointment; and/or
d) Any other relief the Hon'ble tribunal deems fit and proper
in the facts and circumstances of the case.”
6. Learned counsel for the applicants submits that it is
the case of the applicants that the relief sought by them is
AKANSHA
2026.11.09
14:06:37
+05'30'
AKANSHA
6
O.A. No. 2944/2025
Item No. 08 (C-2)
squarely covered by a common order/judgment dated
12.03.2026 in O.A. No. 1758/2025 with O.A. No. 1987/2025
and O.A. NO. 1993/2025, which was disposed of by a co-
ordinate Bench of this Tribunal vide order dated
12.03.2026. He submits that order/judgment dated
12.03.2026 of the Tribunal has been challenged before the
Hon’ble High Court of Delhi by way of separate writ
petitions including one being W.P.(C) No. 11512/2026 titled
Union of India v/s Satish Kumar & Ors. , and the
Hon’ble High Court has passed an interim order dated
14.08.2026. He submits that the respondents herein
(petitioners before the Hon’ble High Court) have filed
Review Petition before the Hon’ble High Court of Delhi vide
diary no. 392700/2026 on 16.09.2026, seeking review and
recall of the order/judgment dated 14.08.2026 of the
Hon’ble High Court in W.P.(C) No. 11512/2026 (supra).
7. Learned counsel for the applicants, under
instructions, submits that the present Original Application
may be disposed of in light of order dated 14.08.2026 of the
Hon’ble High Court in W.P.(C) No. 11512/2026 titled
Union of India v/s Satish Kumar & Ors. , of course,
subject to the final decision of the Hon’ble High Court
and/or subsequent proceedings arising out of the said writ
petition.
AKANSHA
2026.11.09
14:06:37
+05'30'
AKANSHA
7
O.A. No. 2944/2025
Item No. 08 (C-2)
8. We are of the considered view that if such request on
behalf of the applicant, in the facts and circumstances,
precisely recorded hereinabove is acceded to no prejudice is
likely to be caused to the respondents rather the same would
be, in the interest of both the parties, to avoid any further
litigation in the matter. For sake of clarity, the order dated
14.08.2026 of the Hon’ble High Court in W.P.(C) No.
11512/2026 is reproduced as under:-
“ CAV 381/2026
1. As the respondents have entered appearance, the caveat
stands discharged.
CM APPL. 53315/2026 & CM APPL. 53316/2026
2. Exemptions allowed, subject to all just exceptions.
3. The applications stand disposed of.
W.P.(C) 11512/2026
4. This writ petition assails order dated 12 March 2026 passed
by the Central Administrative Tribunal' in OA 1987/2025.
5. The respondents in this writ petition were applicants before
the Tribunal in the aforenoted OA. They were candidates who
had participated in an examination for Postal Assistants and
were duly appointed as such. Later, their services were
terminated on the ground that there was a mismatch of
signatures, purportedly based on an expert opinion. The
respondents challenged their termination before the
Ahmedabad Bench of the Tribunal in a batch of original
Applications. By order dated 18 March 2016, the Ahmedabad
Bench of the Tribunal set aside the termination order and
directed a fair investigation into the alleged misdemeanours.
6. The matter was carried to the High Court of Gujarat, which,
by order dated 16 August 2016, quashed the decision of the
Ahmedabad Bench of the Tribunal. The decision of the High
Court was further carried to the Supreme Court by way of
Civil Appeal 10513/2016. The Supreme Court disposed of the
matter with the following directions:
“That the entire examination was not necessarily vitiated since
persons who are suspected of having used malpractices in the
examination of Postal Assistant/Sorting Assistant in five
circles, Viz. Uttarakhand, Rajasthan, Chhattisgarh, Haryana
AKANSHA
2026.11.09
14:06:37
+05'30'
AKANSHA
8
O.A. No. 2944/2025
Item No. 08 (C-2)
and Gujarat have actually been identified. It was further
directed that the respondents will proceed against the persons
so identified in accordance with law but since they are quite
few in number, a formal show cause notice is dispensed with.
However, they may be personally called and explained the
allegations against them and given some reasonable time of
about a week or ten days to give their reply to the allegations
and then a final decision may be taken. It was further ordered
that those persons who are not suspected of having committed
any malpractices and who have undergone the prescribed
courses may be reinstated with consequential benefits and
50% back wages with liberty to the respondents to take action
against them in case subsequently it is found in the
investigation that they have also Indulged in some
malpractices.”
7. It is clear from the afore-extracted directions of the
Supreme Court that the candidates have been divided by the
Supreme Court into two categories. The first category is those
who were suspected of having used malpractices and who
have been actually identified. In their case, the Supreme Court
directed that the persons identified could be proceeded against
in accordance with law without requiring a formal show
cause notice to be issued. They were, however, called upon to
submit their explanation against the allegations against them
and given time to file a reply thereto before a final decision
was taken. The second category of candidates identified by the
Supreme Court were those who were not suspected of having
committed malpractices and who have undergone the
prescribed courses. The Supreme Court directed that they be
reinstated with consequential benefits with 50% back wages
with liberty to the petitioner to take action against them in
case it was subsequently found in investigation that they had
indulged in malpractices. The petitioners have reinstated the
respondents but denied them back wages.
8. Aggrieved thereby, the respondents approached the
Tribunal by way of the OA in which the presently impugned
order has been passed. The Tribunal, relying on FR 54-A, has
held that the respondents were entitled to back wages in terms
of the said provision.
9. Aggrieved by the decision of the Tribunal, the UOI is before
us in this writ petition.
10. We have heard Mr. Haseeb, learned CGSC for the
petitioner and Mr. Ankur Chhibber, learned Senior Counsel
for the respondents.
11. Mr. Haseeb has drawn our attention to a communication
dated 17 April 2025 issued by the Director (GDS) with the
approval of the Secretary (Posts) to the Chief Postmaster
General, in various circles. We deem it appropriate to
reproduce the said communication, in extenso, thus:
“F. No. A-34018/03/2025-DE
Government of India
AKANSHA
2026.11.09
14:06:37
+05'30'
AKANSHA
9
O.A. No. 2944/2025
Item No. 08 (C-2)
Ministry of Communications
Department of Posts
DE Section
Dak Bhawan, Sansad Marg
New Delhi- 110001
Dated: 17.04.2025
To,
The Chief Postmaster General
Chhattisgarh, Gujarat, Haryana, Rajasthan
and Uttarakhand Circles
Subject: Postal Assistant/Sorting Assistant (PA/SA)
Direct Recruitment examination for the years 2013-2014-
“Administrative Decision”-regarding
Madam/Sir,
I am directed to refer to the subject mentioned
above and to say that Postal Directorate, in consultation with
Department of Legal Affairs (DOLA), Ministry of Law &
Justice. New Delhi, has examined all the cases, which are
arisen out on the basis of negative report of CFSL and pending
before various forum of law i.e. CAT/High Court/ Supreme
Court.
2. The Competent Authority, after perusal of 'Legal opinion'
of DOLA, Contempt Petitions filed by the applicants and other
connected & relevant records to the case, has taken a
considered decision to reinstate all the applicants of the
identical CAT/Court cases and ordered the following:
(i) All the candidates, whose candidature were terminated
based on negative report of CFSL or the authorship were not
established by the CFSL and cases are pending before Hon'ble
CAT/High Court/ Supreme Court, may be reinstated.
(ii) If any material is available against the candidates,
appropriate action in accordance with law, after providing
due opportunity of hearing, may be taken.
(iii) Principle of 'No Work No Pay' may be strictly adhered to.
3. Circles are requested to issue the reinstatement order and
dispatch today itself to all the candidates covered in this
approval. Their training may be arranged after joining on
reinstatement as soon as possible.
4. This issues with the approval of Secretary (Posts).
Yours faithfully,
Sd/-
AKANSHA
2026.11.09
14:06:37
+05'30'
AKANSHA
10
O.A. No. 2944/2025
Item No. 08 (C-2)
(Ravi Pahwa)
Director (GDS)
LO to Director (DE)”
(Emphasis supplied)
12. To our mind, the Secretary (Posts) could not have invoked
the principle of no work no pay, which appears to have been
the basis for not paying any back wages to the respondents.
The Supreme Court has, while disposing of the appeals before
it, clearly held that persons who were reinstated were entitled
to 50% back wages. Even while retaining liberty with the
petitioner, in case any malpractices were found to have been
committed by such persons, to proceed against them in
accordance with law. There is, therefore, no category of
persons who could be reinstated with no back wages. In
creating such a category of persons by invoking the principle
of no work no pay, we are prima facie of the view that the
Secretary (Posts) has travelled beyond and has, in fact,
rewritten the judgment of the Supreme Court in Monu
Tomar .
13. At the same time, we are also prima facie of the view that
the Tribunal would not have proceeded on the basis of FR 54-
A, as the entire issue has to abide by the judgment of the
Supreme Court in Monu Tomar .
14. In that view of the matter, we are of the opinion that, for
the present, subject to the outcome of this writ petition, the
petitioner would be obligated to pay 50% of the back wages to
the respondents, as directed by the Supreme Court.
15. In the circumstances, issue notice to show cause as to why
rule nisi be not issued.
16. Notice is accepted on behalf of the respondents by Mr.
Mukesh Kumar.
17. Counter-affidavit, if any, be filed within four weeks with
advance copy to learned Counsel for the petitioner who may
file rejoinder thereto within four weeks thereof.
18. List before the Joint Registrar for completion of pleadings
on 16 October 2026.
CM APPL. 53314/2026
19. Issue notice.
20. Notice is accepted on behalf of the respondents by Mr.
Mukesh Kumar.
21. Reply, if any, be filed within four weeks with advance copy
to learned Counsel for the petitioner who may file rejoinder
thereto within four weeks thereof.
22. For the present, we direct the respondents to disburse 50%
of the back wages, in terms of the directions issued by the
AKANSHA
2026.11.09
14:06:37
+05'30'
AKANSHA
11
O.A. No. 2944/2025
Item No. 08 (C-2)
Supreme Court in Monu Tomar , to the petitioners, within a
period of twelve weeks from today. The payment shall,
however, abide by further orders to be passed in these
proceedings.
23. List before the Joint Registrar for completion of pleadings
on 16 October 2026.”
9. In the light of the aforesaid, the present OA is partly
allowed with following order(s):-
(i) Subject to the final decision of the Hon’ble High Court of
Delhi in W.P.(C) No. 11512/2026 (supra), the respondents
are directed to pay 50% of the back wages to the applicants.
(ii) The aforesaid direction shall be complied with by the
respondents as expeditiously as possible and preferably
within eight weeks from the date of receipt of a certified
copy of this order.
10. There shall be no order as to costs.
(Rajinder Kashyap) (R. N. Singh)
Member (A) Member (J)
/ aks/
AKANSHA
2026.11.09
14:06:37
+05'30'
AKANSHA