SRI BALAJI vs SMT SHAKILA PURUSHOTHAM

Court
Karnataka High Court

- 1 -
CRL.RP No. 1197 of 2024


IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU
R

DATED THIS THE 17TH DAY OF NOVEMBER, 2026


BEFORE

THE HON'BLE MRS. JUSTICE GEETHA K.B.

CRIMINAL REVISION PETITION NO. 1197 OF 2024

(397(Cr.PC)/438(BNSS))

BETWEEN:
1. SRI BALAJI
S/O SRI MOHAN G
AGED ABOUT 26 YEARS
R/AT NO.199, KRISHNA NAGAR
BYRATHI BANDE, BANGALURU-562 149
…PETITIONER





(BY SRI.T.S.VENKATESH, ADVOCATE)


AND:
1. SMT SHAKILA PURUSHOTHAM
W/O DR.KONCHADY PURUSHOTTAM
AGED ABOUT 43 YEARS
RESIDING AT NO.186/8, 2ND FLOOR
ABHISHEK COMPLEX, SHESHADRIPURAM
BENGALURU-560020
…RESPONDENT





(BY SRI. AKRAM PASHA K.,ADVOCATE)

THIS CRL.RP IS FILED U/S.397 R/W 401 CR.P.C (U/S 438
R/W 442 BNSS) BY THE ADVOCATE FOR THE PETITIONER
PRAYING THAT THIS HONOURABLE COURT MAY BE PLEASED
TO SET ASIDE THE IMPUGNED JUDGMENT/ORDER DATED
03.09.2024 IN CRIMINAL APPEAL NO.25221/2023 PASSED BY
HONBLE LXXIV ADDL. CITY CIVIL AND SESSIONS JUDGE,
MAYO HALL UNIT, BENGALURU (CCH-75) AND ALSO SET-
ASIDE THE JUDGMENT/ORDER DATED 18.07.2023 IN
C.C.NO.53235/2022 PASSED BY THE HONBLE XIV ACMM, MAYO
HALL, BENGALURU BY ALLOWING THIS CRIMINAL REVISION
PETITION.
Digitally Signed By:
K B GEETHA

- 2 -
CRL.RP No. 1197 of 2024


THIS PETITION HAVING BEEN HEARD AND RESERVED ON
17.10.2026, COMING ON FOR PRONOUNCEMENT OF ORDER
THIS DAY, THE COURT DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:

CORAM: HON'BLE MRS. JUSTICE GEETHA K.B.

CAV JUDGMENT
This is the revision petition filed under Section 397 read
with Section 401 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973
(in short, 'Cr.P.C.') by the revision petitioners/accused
challenging the judgment of conviction and order of
sentence dated 18.07.2023 in CC No.53235/2022 on the
file of XIV Addl. CMM, Mayohall, Bengaluru (in short, the
Trial Court), which is confirmed in the appeal in Criminal
Appeal No.25221/2023 dated 03.09.2024 on the file of
LXXIV Addl. City Civil and Sessions Judge, Mayohall Unit,
Bengaluru (CCH-75) (in short, the Appellate Court).

2. The parties would be referred with their ranks, as
they were before the Trial Court, for the sake of
convenience and clarity.

3. The complainant has filed the complaint under
Section 200 Cr.P.C., praying for taking cognizance of the
offence under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments
Digitally Signed By:
K B GEETHA

- 3 -
CRL.RP No. 1197 of 2024


Act, 1881 (in short, 'N.I Act') against the accused and
punish him in accordance with law and to order
compensation to the complainant and for such other
reliefs.

4. The case of the complainant before the trial
Court in nutshell is that there was a rental agreement
between the husband of the complainant and the accused
in respect of the premises bearing No.74 and 75 with
Khata number 74/74/28 and 75/75/28 situated at Sri
Krishna Nagar, Byrathi Bande, Bengaluru, and they
entered into the lease agreement dated 23.01.2020 for a
period of 10 years with a monthly rent of Rs.1,75,000/-.
The husband of the complainant, who is a doctor, has paid
Rs.35,00,000/- as an advance rental deposit to the
accused. The husband of the complainant also made
arrangements for procuring medical and other equipments
worth Rs.42,38,489/-. The accused ought to hand over the
premises on 01.03.2020, and when the husband of the
complainant had approached the accused, he was turned
away on the pretext of ongoing construction work.
Digitally Signed By:
K B GEETHA

- 4 -
CRL.RP No. 1197 of 2024


Because of continuous delay by the accused and the onset
of the COVID-19 pandemic, the plans of the husband of
the complainant to open the hospital went in vain. After
lifting of restrictions of COVID-19, the husband of the
complainant approached the accused to take possession of
the building, but the accused insisted for enhancement of
the advance amount. Accordingly, an amended rental
agreement dated 23.07.2020 came into existence and an
additional amount of Rs.10,00,000/- was paid with a
stipulation to hand over the possession in September
2020. There was continuous harassment to the husband of
the complainant by the brother of the accused- Vinod, who
was not the owner of the property. Finally, with some
changes, the rental agreement dated 04.02.2021 again
came into existence, but the brother of the accused lashed
out at him by making defamatory remarks and unilaterally
terminated the agreement after conveniently receiving an
advance amount of Rs.40,00,000/- and causing a
significant delay of over two years. Because of all these
things, the husband of the complainant has filed
Digitally Signed By:
K B GEETHA

- 5 -
CRL.RP No. 1197 of 2024


O.S.No.425/2021 which was referred to Lok-Adalat where
the accused agreed to settle the matter amicably by
repaying the advance amount by filing a joint memo dated
29.03.2021 before the II Additional Senior Civil Judge,
Bengaluru Rural Court, wherein the accused agreed to pay
Rs.20,00,000/- on 31.05.2021 and Rs.20,00,000/- on
31.07.2021 to the husband of the complainant. However,
he miserably failed to make such payments. An email
dated 03.06.2021 was sent by the complainant's husband
seeking payment of Rs.20,00,000/-, for which the brother
of the accused responded with a reply on 03.06.2021.
Thereafter, the husband of the complainant has issued a
legal notice dated 07.06.2021 demanding payment as per
the joint memo. Thereafter, the husband of the
complainant came to know that the accused entered into a
rental agreement with one Dr.Nilufer Rehman and received
the security deposit. These facts were brought to the
notice of the Court in O.S.No.425/2021. The accused has
made payment of Rs.10,00,000/- towards the principal
amount and Rs.1,20,000/- towards the interest. Again the
Digitally Signed By:
K B GEETHA

- 6 -
CRL.RP No. 1197 of 2024


matter was referred to Lok-Adalat on 18.01.2021; both
parties agreed to settle the matter for a total amount of
Rs.47,20,000/-. After deducting the Rs.11,20,000/- paid
by the accused, the accused has agreed and issued the
subject cheque bearing No.000063 dated 17.01.2022 for a
sum of Rs.36,00,000/- in the name of the complainant,
who is the partner in the work of her husband, and
accordingly, a joint memo, entered into by both parties,
was filed before the Court. When the complainant
presented the said cheque for encashment on 17.01.2022
through her banker-Kotak Mahindra Bank, Kalyan Nagar
Branch, Bengaluru, it was returned dishonored with bank
endorsement dated 18.01.2022 that the ‘drawer's
signature differs’. When it was brought to the notice of the
accused, he has not given a proper reply. He has failed to
make payment. Then the complainant issued legal notice
dated 14.02.2022 which was returned unserved with a
postal endorsement as ‘insufficient address’. Then she has
issued another legal notice dated 09.03.2022 which was
served on the accused on 15.03.2022, and thereafter both
Digitally Signed By:
K B GEETHA

- 7 -
CRL.RP No. 1197 of 2024


the said notices are withdrawn by the complainant due to
an error in the description of the complaint and issued
another legal notice dated 26.04.2022 to the accused
which was returned with a postal shara 'unclaimed' dated
10.05.2022. Within 15 days from 10.05.2022, the accused
has not made payment. Hence, the complaint was filed on
27.05.2022. This is owing to the extension of the
limitation period by the Hon'ble Apex Court in
Miscellaneous Application No.21/2022 in suo moto Writ
Petition (C) No.3/2020.

5. After recording the sworn statement, the trial
Court has taken cognizance of the offence, and issued
summons to the accused. The accused appeared and
pleaded not guilty of the offence when the accusation
leveled against him is read over and explained to him. The
statement under Section 313 Cr.P.C., was recorded. The
complainant was cross-examined by the learned counsel
for the accused and marked some documents on behalf of
the accused in that cross-examination. However, he has
not let-in defence evidence.
Digitally Signed By:
K B GEETHA

- 8 -
CRL.RP No. 1197 of 2024



6. After hearing arguments of both sides, the trial
Court concluded that the accused has committed the
offence punishable under Section 138 of the NI Act;
convicted him and sentenced to pay a fine of
Rs.41,75,000/- for the offence punishable under Section
138 of the NI Act and also directed to pay Rs.41,70,000/-
out of the fine amount to the complainant as
compensation and the remaining Rs.5,000/- shall be
adjusted to the State.

7. Aggrieved by the said judgment of conviction
and order of sentence, the accused has preferred the
appeal.

8. After hearing arguments of both sides, the
appellate Court confirmed the judgment of the trial Court.

9. Aggrieved by the same, the accused is before
this Court.

10. Heard arguments of both sides.

11. The sum and substance of the arguments of the
learned counsel for revision petitioner Sri T.S. Venkatesh
Digitally Signed By:
K B GEETHA

- 9 -
CRL.RP No. 1197 of 2024


is that, the complainant is the wife of one doctor who is
the prospective tenant of the property of the accused. The
husband of the complainant approached the accused for
material alteration in 80% of the completed building from
residential building to hospital and in that respect, he has
given advance amount of Rs.35,00,000/- and the rental
agreement as per Ex.D.3 came into existence between the
accused and the husband of the complainant. However, as
per the terms and conditions of the said agreement, the
complainant's husband has not come forward to occupy
the building due to COVID-19 pandemic. Then two
amended draft agreements came into existence as per
Ex.D.2 and D.3. But those agreements have not become
final and not duly signed by both parties. Afterwards, the
husband of the complainant has filed the civil suit in
O.S.No.425/2021 which was finally disposed in Lok-Adalat,
as plaintiff has not pressed the suit. In that case, earlier a
joint memo was filed on 01.03.2021 but it was not
materialized. His further contention is that, one more joint
memo dated 18.12.2021 filed before the Civil Court was
Digitally Signed By:
K B GEETHA

- 10 -
CRL.RP No. 1197 of 2024


not admitted by the accused because it does not bear the
signature of the accused in the order sheet. After filing the
said joint memo, the case was called for seven hearing
dates, not for hearing on joint memo or to report
settlement, but to file objections to IA for attachment
before judgment, for filing of objections and to hear on
said IA. Ultimately, during March-2021, the plaintiff i.e.
the husband of complainant got dismissed the said suit on
the ground that the matter is settled out of Court.
However, as on the date of dismissal of said suit, the
subject cheque which was mentioned in said joint memo
dated 18.12.2021 presented and dishonoured and even
the legal notice was also issued on behalf of the husband
of the complainant in respect of dishonour of said cheque.
Furthermore, the husband of complainant has filed one
commercial suit in respect of the same transaction. When
the rental agreement came into existence initially and
draft amendments subsequently and filing of
O.S.No.425/2021 are in commercial suit, there is no
whisper about Ex.P.12- the partnership agreement. He
Digitally Signed By:
K B GEETHA

- 11 -
CRL.RP No. 1197 of 2024


would further submit that thus the complainant has no
locus-standi at all to file the present complaint. There is no
transaction whatsoever between the complainant and the
accused.

12. In this regard he places reliance on the judgment
of Mrs. Sujan Sawant vs. Dr. Kamlakant Shantaram
1
Desai . Further there is no whisper in the complaint that
she files the complaint as partner of the partnership firm.
Further, in that partnership agreement, the place belonged
to the accused, which was intended to be leased to the
husband of complainant, is shown as the place of business
of the partnership firm which was never leased to the
complainant. He would further submit that under Ex.D.3, it
was agreed that, in case the husband of complainant
vacates the premises within the lock-up period of 5 years,
he has to refund Rs.6,00,000/- to the husband of
complainant; in Ex.D.2 it is stated that in case the lessee
terminates the lease, the lessor (present accused) shall
withhold Rs.14,00,000/-; in case, the lessor terminates

1

AIR 2004 Bom 446
Digitally Signed By:
K B GEETHA

- 12 -
CRL.RP No. 1197 of 2024


the lease, the lessee (the husband of complainant) is
entitled to penalty of Rs.14,00,000/- with total security
deposit. Furthermore, when the subject cheque was
presented by the complainant; it was returned with an
endorsement 'drawer's signature differs' and not with an
endorsement 'funds insufficient'. Hence, the complainant
ought to establish that, the signature found on the cheque
is the signature of the accused.

13. In this regard he places reliance on
2
Ravichandra vs. Rosi Line Reena Rani . Further,
because even though Section 138 of N.I Act appears to be
quasi-civil in nature; as penal provision is attracted under
Section 138 of N.I Act, the strict interpretation of the
section is required and there shall not be any ambiguity in
it. In this regard, he places reliance on the judgments of
the Hon'ble Apex Court in H.M.Parimala Vs. M Babu

2
Crl. Appeal No.1244/2019 decided on 02.12.2021
Digitally Signed By:
K B GEETHA

- 13 -
CRL.RP No. 1197 of 2024


3
Reddy and Sham Sundar and Others v. State of
4
Haryana .

14. The learned counsel for revision petitioner would
further submit that even though the cheque was
dishonoured in the month of January-2022, first two
notices were issued on behalf of the husband of the
complainant and finally only in April-2022, the notice on
behalf of the present complainant was issued. Hence, the
legal notice was not issued within the prescribed period to
attract the offence under Section 138 of NI Act. Further,
only at the fag end of the case, the complainant recalled
herself and produced Ex.P.12-the alleged partnership
agreement which is not at all helpful for the complainant.
When the accused has raised probable defence that there
was no transaction of whatsoever nature between the
complainant and the accused and when the cheque was
not bearing the signature of the accused, the offence
under Section 138 of NI Act would not be attracted against

3
Criminal Petition No.9649/2018 decided on 01.03.2019
4
AIR 1989 Supreme Court 1982
Digitally Signed By:
K B GEETHA

- 14 -
CRL.RP No. 1197 of 2024


the revision petitioner. Hence, prayed for allowing the
revision petition.

15. The learned counsel for respondent Sri Akram
Pasha would submit that the facts admitted before the trial
Court by both sides are that there was rental agreement
between the husband of the complainant and the accused
in respect of the property belonged to the accused.
However, as per the terms and conditions of the said
agreement, the accused has not handed over the building
to the husband of complainant. Hence, two more draft
lease deeds came into existence but because of the
brother of the accused, the transaction between both went
in vain. The subject cheque was issued by the accused in
O.S.No.425/2021 along with joint memo dated 18.12.2021
to the complainant's husband by mentioning the name of
the complainant and hence when it is issued in a civil suit
towards settlement arrived between the parties, the
complainant has established that there exists legally
recoverable debt. The complainant is none other than the
wife of the prospective tenant. Moreover, she is having
Digitally Signed By:
K B GEETHA

- 15 -
CRL.RP No. 1197 of 2024


authority to file the complaint because Ex.P.12-
partnership agreement establishes that she is having
every right in the transaction between her husband and
the accused. Considering it, the subject cheque was issued
in her name. Even though the second legal notice was
received in person by the accused, he has not made any
efforts to give reply to it. There is deemed service of
notice of the third legal notice. The accused has not
stepped into witness box to prove his defence. The
accused has not elicited from the cross-examination of the
complainant, to rebut the presumption in favour of the
complainant. The accused has not challenged Exs.P.15 to
P.17. They are the joint memo dated 31.03.2021 and the
affidavit of present accused and the husband of present
complainant filed in OS No.425/2021. These documents
clearly establish that there exists legally recoverable debt
in favour of the husband of the complainant and the
cheque is drawn in the name of the complainant. There is
no inter se dispute between the complainant and her
husband. The accused cannot challenge it. He voluntarily
Digitally Signed By:
K B GEETHA

- 16 -
CRL.RP No. 1197 of 2024


issued the subject cheque in favour of the complainant.
Hence, he cannot dispute these documents. Even though
in his statement under Section 313 Cr.P.C., the accused
stated that he would examine the witnesses; he has not
made any efforts to examine himself or examine the
witness to prove his defence. Considering these aspects,
rightly the trial Court concluded that the accused has
committed the offence and convicted him which is upheld
by the appellate Court. The jurisdiction of the revision
Court is very limited. The extraneous evidence was not
considered by the trial Court or the appellate Court and no
gross erroneousness in said judgments and they are not
perverse , not capricious. Hence, this Court cannot
interfere in the aforesaid judgments. Hence, prayed for
dismissal of the revision petition.

16. Having heard arguments of both sides, verifying
the revision petition papers, the trial Court and the
appellate Court records, the point that arises for
consideration is:
Digitally Signed By:
K B GEETHA

- 17 -
CRL.RP No. 1197 of 2024


"Whether the revision petitioner establishes
perversity or grossly erroneousness in the judgment
of the trial court and appellate court or the judgment
of the trial court and appellate court is glaringly
unreasonable or wholly unreliable or untenable and
the judgment of the trial court and appellate court
considered immaterial or irrelevant material or no
material or non-consideration of any relevant material
or judicial discretion has been exercised arbitrarily or
capriciously ?"


17. The finding of this Court on above point is in
‘ Affirmative’ for the following :
REASONS

18. The revisional jurisdiction of this Court is very
limited. In this regard, this Court places reliance on the
Judgment of the Hon’ble Apex Court in the case of
Kuntegowda v/s Thurubaiah in Criminal Appeal
No.3654/2026, (Arising out of Special Leave Petition
(Criminal) No.2247 of 2024 dated 04.08.2026
reported in 2026 SCC OnLine SC 1485 . In the aforesaid
judgment, the Hon'ble Apex Court at paragraph Nos.7.1.
to 7.3 has discussed the revisional jurisdiction of this
Court, which reads as follows:
Digitally Signed By:
K B GEETHA

- 18 -
CRL.RP No. 1197 of 2024


"7.1 This Court, in the State of Maharashtra
vs. Jagmohan Singh Kuldip Singh Anand, (2004) 7
SCC 659 observed that the High Court, in exercise
of its revisional jurisdiction, cannot embark upon an
in-depth roving re-examination of the oral evidence
and medical evidence and come to a conclusion
contrary to the consistent one reached by two
courts below. In the facts of the present case, in the
impugned judgment, the High Court gravely erred in
upsetting the concurrent findings of conviction of
the trial court and the Appellate Court by
substituting its own conclusions and reasoning on
the merits of the case and thereby erred in setting
aside the well-reasoned and correct judgement and
orders of the trial and appellate courts.

7.2 Upon perusal of the impugned judgment
and order dated 06.10.2023, it is apparent that the
High Court went into great detail into each of the
testimonies, documents and merits of the case
which could have been avoided especially when the
subject matter had come under its revisional
jurisdiction. Instead, acting as an appellate Court,
the High Court deemed it fit to go into the merits of
the case, something which is generally
impermissible unless a glaring contradiction is
apparent on the face of record. In State of Kerala
vs. Puttumana Illath Jathavedan Namboodiri, (1999)
2 SCC 452, while considering the scope of the
Digitally Signed By:
K B GEETHA

- 19 -
CRL.RP No. 1197 of 2024


revisional jurisdiction of the High Court this Court
has laid down the following:

"5.... In its revisional jurisdiction, the
High Court can call for and examine the
record of any proceedings for the purpose
of satisfying itself as to the correctness,
legality or propriety of any finding,
sentence or order. In other words, the
jurisdiction is one of supervisory
jurisdiction exercised by the High Court for
correcting miscarriage of justice. But the
said revisional power cannot be equated
with the power of an appellate court nor
can it be treated even as a second
appellate jurisdiction. Ordinarily, therefore,
it would not be appropriate for the High
Court to reappreciate the evidence and
come to its own conclusion on the same
when the evidence has already been
appreciated by the Magistrate as well as
the Sessions Judge in appeal, unless any
glaring feature is brought to the notice of
the High Court which would otherwise
tantamount to gross miscarriage of justice.
On scrutinizing the impugned judgment of
the High Court from the aforesaid
standpoint, we have no hesitation to come
to the conclusion that the High Court
exceeded its jurisdiction in interfering with
the conviction of the Respondent by
reappreciating the oral evidence...."

7.3. The contours for exercise of revisional
jurisdiction has been well settled by the judicial
Digitally Signed By:
K B GEETHA

- 20 -
CRL.RP No. 1197 of 2024


dicta of this Court wherein time and again it has
been observed that the High Court shall not
interfere with the orders of the lower court unless:

i. The order or finding of the lower court is
perverse, grossly erroneous, glaringly unreasonable
or wholly unreliable or untenable in law.
ii. The lower court has passed the impugned
order after considering an immaterial or irrelevant
material or no material at all.
iii. There is a non-consideration of any
relevant material or the judicial discretion has been
exercised arbitrarily or capriciously."


19. Thus, only if the judgment of the trial Court
confirmed by appellate Court is perverse or grossly
erroneous, or grossly unreasonable, or wholly unreliable,
or wholly untenable, or the trial Court considered an
immaterial or irrelevant, material or no material or not at
all relevant material or judicial discretion has been
exercised arbitrarily and capriciously, the revisional Court
can interfere with such judgment.

20. The alleged offence in this case is the offence
under Section 138 of NI Act; to attract the offence under
Digitally Signed By:
K B GEETHA

- 21 -
CRL.RP No. 1197 of 2024


Section 138 of NI Act, the complainant has to satisfy the
following ingredients:
(i) that there exists legally enforceable debt;
(ii) that the cheque was drawn from the
account of bank of the accused for the discharge in
whole or in part of any debt or other liability;
(iii) that the cheque has been presented to the
bank within a period of six months from the date on
which it is drawn or within the period of its validity,
whichever is earlier;
(iv) that cheque so issued has been returned
due to insufficiency of funds;
(v) the payee or the holder in due course of
the cheque makes a demand for the payment of the
said amount of money by giving a notice in writing
to the drawer of the cheque, within 30 days of the
receipt of information by him from the bank
regarding the return of the cheque as unpaid;
(vi) the drawer of such cheque fails to make
payment of the said amount of money to the payee
or the holder in due course of the cheque within 15
days of the receipt of the said notice;
(vii) Filing of the complaint within a month
from the date of expiry of the grace period of fifteen
Digitally Signed By:
K B GEETHA

- 22 -
CRL.RP No. 1197 of 2024


days before a Metropolitan Magistrate or a Judicial
Magistrate not below first class.


21. If the aforementioned ingredients are satisfied,
then there shall be a presumption under section 139 of the
NI Act. Always, the cheque is a bill of exchange and thus
there shall be a presumption under Section 118 of the NI
Act. there is also statutory presumption under Section 139
of NI Act that there exists legally recoverable debt and the
cheque is issued for recovery of legally recoverable debt
either wholly or in part. But the presumptions available
under Section 118 and 139 of the NI Act are rebuttable
presumptions.

22. With this background, the facts of the present
case are to be analysed and to verify whether the trial
Court and the appellate Court have not examined the
records produced by either party or erroneously
appreciated the evidence.

23. The cheque as per Ex.P.1 is dated 17.01.2022
drawn for a sum of Rs.36,00,000/-; when it was presented
Digitally Signed By:
K B GEETHA

- 23 -
CRL.RP No. 1197 of 2024


for encashment, the same was dishonoured with an
endorsement dated 18.01.2022 that 'drawer's signature
differs'. Afterwards, the first notice dated 14.02.2022 was
issued on behalf of the husband of complainant to the
accused which was not served with endorsement
'insufficient address'; subsequently, on 09.03.2022 the
second notice as per Ex.P.4 was issued on behalf of the
husband of complainant to the accused which was served
on him; but no reply is given; then on 26.04.2022, third
notice was issued on behalf of the complainant to the
accused which was returned unserved as 'unclaimed'.
Hence there is deemed service of legal notice dated
26.04.2022. Then on 27.05.2022, the complaint was
presented before the trial Court.

24. The trial Court has taken cognizance of the
offence only based on the notice dated 14.02.2022 and
not on the notice dated 26.04.2022. The accused has not
disputed that the cheque was from his bank account. But
he disputed his signature on the cheque.
Digitally Signed By:
K B GEETHA

- 24 -
CRL.RP No. 1197 of 2024



25. Only if foundational facts i.e., clause number (iii)
to (vii) of ingredients of Section 138 are fulfilled; the Court
shall presume that there exists legally recoverable debt
and the cheque is issued for discharge of part or whole of
it as per Section 139 of NI Act.

26. In the instant case, as stated above, the
endorsement 'the drawer's signature differs' and the
endorsement is not 'insufficient funds' or 'exceeds
arrangements' or 'account closed' or 'payment stopped' or
'referred to the drawer'.

27. The learned counsel for the respondent places
5
reliance on M/s.Laxmi Dyechem vs. State of Gujarat
case and would submit that even in case of mismatch of
signature, the offence under Section 138 can be made out.
In the aforesaid judgment at paragraph No.15 has held as
follows:
"15. The above line of decisions leaves no room for
holding that the two contingencies envisaged under
Section 138 of the Act must be interpreted strictly or
literally. We find ourselves in respectful agreement

5
(2012) 13 SCC 375
Digitally Signed By:
K B GEETHA

- 25 -
CRL.RP No. 1197 of 2024


with the decision in NEPC Micon Ltd. (supra) that the
expression "amount of money...... is insufficient"
appearing in Section 138 of the Act is a genus and
dishonour for reasons such "as account closed",
"payment stopped", "referred to the drawer" are
only species of that genus. Just as dishonour of a
cheque on the ground that the account has been
closed is a dishonour falling in the first contingency
referred to in Section 138, so also dishonour on the
ground that the "signatures do not match" or that
the "image is not found", which too implies that the
specimen signatures do not match the signatures on
the cheque would constitute a dishonour within the
meaning of Section 138 of the Act. This Court has in
the decisions referred to above taken note of
situations and contingencies arising out of deliberate
acts of omission or commission on the part of the
drawers of the cheques which would inevitably result
in the dishonour of the cheque issued by them. For
instance this Court has held that if after issue of the
cheque the drawer closes the account it must be
presumed that the amount in the account was nil
hence insufficient to meet the demand of the
cheque. A similar result can be brought about by the
drawer changing his specimen signature given to the
bank or in the case of a company by the company
changing the mandate of those authorised to sign
the cheques on its behalf. Such changes or alteration
in the mandate may be dishonest or fraudulent and
that would inevitably result in dishonour of all
cheques signed by the previously authorised
signatories. There is in our view no qualitative
difference between a situation where the dishonour
takes place on account of the substitution by a new
set of authorised signatories resulting in the
dishonour of the cheques already issued and another
situation in which the drawer of the cheque changes
his own signatures or closes the account or issues
Digitally Signed By:
K B GEETHA

- 26 -
CRL.RP No. 1197 of 2024


instructions to the bank not to make the payment.
So long as the change is brought about with a view
to preventing the cheque being honoured the
dishonour would become an offence under Section
138 subject to other conditions prescribed being
satisfied. There may indeed be situations where a
mismatch between the signatories on the cheque
drawn by the drawer and the specimen available
with the bank may result in dishonour of the cheque
even when the drawer never intended to invite such
a dishonour. We are also conscious of the fact that
an authorised signatory may in the ordinary course
of business be replaced by a new signatory ending
the earlier mandate to the bank. Dishonour on
account of such changes that may occur in the
course of ordinary business of a company,
partnership or an individual may not constitute an
offence by itself because such a dishonour in order
to qualify for prosecution under Section 138 shall
have to be preceded by a statutory notice where the
drawer is called upon and has the opportunity to
arrange the payment of the amount covered by the
cheque. It is only when the drawer despite receipt of
such a notice and despite the opportunity to make
the payment within the time stipulated under the
statute does not pay the amount that the dishonour
would be considered a dishonour constituting an
offence, hence punishable. Even in such cases, the
question whether or not there was a lawfully
recoverable debt or liability for discharge whereof
the cheque was issued would be a matter that the
trial Court will examine having regard to the
evidence adduced before it and keeping in view the
statutory presumption that unless rebutted the
cheque is presumed to have been issued for a valid
consideration."

Digitally Signed By:
K B GEETHA

- 27 -
CRL.RP No. 1197 of 2024



28. The learned counsel for revision petitioner has
placed reliance on Ravichandra’s case cited supra of the
Co-ordinate Bench of this Court. Laxmi Dyechem's case
is not examined in Ravichandra's case. In the aforesaid
judgment at paragraph No.13 held as follows:
"13. In the case on hand, the accused has taken a
specific defence that the signature found on the
cheque in question does not belong to her and she
has not at all received a sum of ' 7 lakhs from the
complainant. The cheque was also dishonoured for
the reason that 'drawers signature differ' and the
complainant has not made any effort to establish
that the signature found on the cheque was that of
the accused. The trial Court after considering the
entire evidence on record has acquitted the
accused holding that the complainant has failed to
prove that the accused to discharge her legally
enforceable debt had issued Ex. P1-cheque in his
favour. I do not find any illegality in the order
passed by the trial Court."


29. In Laxmi Dyechem's case, the High Court has
quashed 40 complaints against the same accused on the
ground of mismatch of signature. The said fact was in the
initial stage i.e., before trial. Further, in Laxmi
Dyechem's case, the Hon'ble Apex Court has discussed
the various judgments of Hon'ble Apex Court regarding
Digitally Signed By:
K B GEETHA

- 28 -
CRL.RP No. 1197 of 2024


'stop payment', 'account closed' endorsements and in that
context, the paragraph No.15 as discussed above came
into existence. In that case, the directors of the company
were changed. In that case the Hon'ble Apex Court held
that, there is no qualitative difference between a situation
where the dishonour takes place on account of the
substitution by a new set of authorized signatories
resulting in the dishonour of cheques already issued and
where the drawer of the cheque changes his own
signatures or closes the account or issues instructions to
the bank not to make payment.

30. In the instant case, the facts are entirely
different. Of course, the accused has not given any reply
to the legal notice but he has cross-examined the
complainant and has taken the specific defence at the time
of cross-examination that the signature found on the
cheque is not the signature of the accused. The same was
substantiated by the endorsement given by the bank that,
'drawer's signature differs'.
Digitally Signed By:
K B GEETHA

- 29 -
CRL.RP No. 1197 of 2024



31. The complainant has not stated either in her
complaint or in her legal notice that, accused intentionally,
only to deceive the complainant, has changed his own
signature and issued the same to her.

32. As stated earlier, even though the endorsement
of the bank mentioning dishonour of the cheque on
18.01.2022; the complainant has issued notice only on
26.04.2022. Earlier two notices as per Exs.P.3 and P.4 are
of no consequence because they were issued on behalf of
the husband of complainant and not on behalf of the
complainant. The complainant and her husband are not
one and the same person. They are two distinct
individuals. The accused has not taken the plea of closure
notification because of COVID-19 pandemic.

33. If there was no COVID-19 pandemic during that
period, there was no chance for the complainant to issue
the legal notice belatedly. However, as discussed above,
because there is COVID-19 pandemic and closure
notification and the Hon'ble Apex Court in the suo moto
petition has held that the period up to 28.02.2022 and
Digitally Signed By:
K B GEETHA

- 30 -
CRL.RP No. 1197 of 2024


then for a period of 90 days, the limitation is exempted. It
includes even to the issuance of legal notice as required
under Section 138 of NI Act. Hence, only because of that,
it can be said that the legal notice issued on behalf of the
complainant in respect of dishonour of cheque is well
within limitation.

34. The learned trial Court and the appellate Court
have not at all considered the legal notice issued on behalf
of complainant to the accused but they have considered
the first notice issued on behalf of the husband of the
complainant to the accused and not discussed these facts
which are not proper.

35. As discussed above, the cheque was returned
dishonoured not as 'funds insufficient' but 'the signature of
drawer differs'. In this regard, in K. Damodaran vs. M.
6
Shivarama Reddy at paragraph No.19 it is held as
follows:
"19. The complainant has also not taken any steps
to secure the opinion of expert regarding the
signature of the accused on disputed cheque Ex.P1.

6

AIR OnLine 2023 KAR 2299
Digitally Signed By:
K B GEETHA

- 31 -
CRL.RP No. 1197 of 2024


No such attempt has been made by the complainant
and he tried to rely on the evidence of PW3 asserting
that the accused signed Ex.P1 in his presence, but
complainant himself admitted that no one was
present during the said transaction. In view of the
these facts and circumstances, it is evident that the
complainant has failed to establish the fact that
Ex.P1 bears the signature of the accused and it was
issued towards legally enforceable debt. When the
complainant has failed to prove the guilt of the
accused beyond all reasonable doubt, question of
convicting him in this regard does not arise at all
only on the ground that he has failed to prove his
defence. Unless the complainant initially discharges
his burden, the defence of accused does not have
any much relevance."


36. Legal notices - Ex.P.3 dated 14.02.2022, Ex.P.4
dated 09.03.2022 are issued on behalf of husband of the
complainant and not on behalf of the accused; on
26.04.2022, the notice issued on behalf of the present
complainant, is returned unserved as 'unclaimed'. The
cheque is dated 17.01.2022; it is presented to the bank
and returned as 'signature of drawer' differs on
18.01.2022. As per the order of Hon'ble Apex Court in
Miscellaneous Application No.21/2022 in suo moto Writ
Petition No.3/2020, the period from 15.02.2020 till
28.02.2022 shall be excluded to compute the period of
limitation. This exclusion applies even to issuance of legal
Digitally Signed By:
K B GEETHA

- 32 -
CRL.RP No. 1197 of 2024


notice as required under Section 138 Proviso sub clause
(b) which is specifically excluded by clause No.4 of
paragraph No.5 in the order of Hon'ble Apex Court.
However, it is to be noted here that immediately after
dishonour of the cheque on 14.02.2022 and 09.03.2022,
notices were issued to the accused on behalf of the
husband of the complainant and then notice on behalf of
the complainant was issued on 26.04.2022. There is no
mention about earlier two notices in this notice dated
26.04.2022. There is no mention that they were defective
in nature and they were withdrawn and the present notice
was issued.

37. It is a fact that there was transaction between
the complainant's husband and the accused in respect of
lease of the building belonged to the accused. Ex.D.3 is
the rental agreement dated 23.01.2020 between the
husband of the complainant and the accused. It is a fact
that under the said document, the accused has received
Rs.30,00,000/- as an advance amount from the husband
of complainant; because he was constructing the
Digitally Signed By:
K B GEETHA

- 33 -
CRL.RP No. 1197 of 2024


residential apartment; when the husband of complainant
approached the accused for lease of the building for his
hospital purpose, 80% of the construction work was
completed and as per request of accused, major
alterations were to be made in the building and thus, the
husband of complainant advanced Rs.30,00,000/- to the
accused even though the rate of rent per month was only
Rs.1,75,000/- which would be about 17 months rent.
Generally, in the trade usage 5 months to 10 months
rentals would be taken as advance but because of major
alterations proposed by the husband of complainant, he
has given advance amount of Rs.30,00,000 and this fact is
admitted by the complainant in her cross examination.

38. The facts established before the trial court are
that the transaction of lease was only between the
accused and the husband of complainant. Complainant
was not in picture. Because of misunderstanding between
the parties, the husband of complainant has filed OS
No.425/2021 for mandatory injunction to enforce the
rental agreement between the parties. In that suit, a joint
Digitally Signed By:
K B GEETHA

- 34 -
CRL.RP No. 1197 of 2024


memo was filed on 31.03.2021 wherein the accused
agreed to pay Rs.30,00,000/- to the accused but he paid
Rs.10,00,000/- through bank transaction and
Rs.1,20,000/- through cash.

39. One more joint memo was filed before the Civil
Court in OS No.425/2021 dated 18.12.2021, which is
seriously disputed by the accused. Under said Joint memo,
the subject cheque was handed over to the husband of
complainant for a sum of Rs.36,00,000/-. The complainant
was not in picture even in that joint memo. After filing the
joint memo, seven hearing dates were lapsed; during that
period, there is no mention directly that accused disputes
the said Joint memo, but the case was posted for not on
hearing the Joint memo but for filing objections to
application under Order XXXVIII Rule 5 CPC; after filing
objections; to hear on said application. When the case was
posted for hearing on said application, immediately the
case was posted before Lok-Adalath in the month of
March-2022 and the husband of complainant got dismissed
the suit stating that the matter is settled out of the court;
Digitally Signed By:
K B GEETHA

- 35 -
CRL.RP No. 1197 of 2024


but long prior to it, on 18.01.2022 itself the subject
cheque was dishonoured.

40. The complainant contended that there is a
partnership agreement between the complainant and her
husband as per Ex.P.12. Based on said partnership
agreement, she has filed the present complaint and the
cheque was issued into her name. However, this said
partnership agreement came into existence on
27.01.2020. Subsequent to said partnership agreement,
the alleged filing of suit in O.S No.425/2021, filing of joint
memo etc., were by the husband of complainant and not
by the complainant. The complainant was not at all in
picture in any of these transactions.

41. In this regard, in Mrs. Sujan Sawant's case
cited supra wherein at paragraph Nos.29 and 40, it is held
as follows :
"29. In Sunil Siddhart v. Commissioner of Income-
tax, Ahmedabad, Gujarat, AIR 1986 SC 368 while
considering the expression “Transfer of Property”
the Supreme Court has observed as follows:
Digitally Signed By:
K B GEETHA

- 36 -
CRL.RP No. 1197 of 2024


“In its general sense, the expression “Transfer of
Property” connotes the passing of rights in the
property from one person to another. In one case
there may be a passing of the entire bundle of
rights from the transferor to the transferee. In
another case, the transfer may consist of one of the
estates only out of all the estates comprising the
totality of rights in the property. In a third case,
there may be a reduction of the exclusive interest
in the totality of rights of the original owner into a
joint or shared interest with other persons. An
exclusive interest in the property is a larger interest
than a share in that property. To the extent to
which the exclusive interest is reduced to a shared
interest it would seem that there is a transfer of
interest. Therefore, when a partner brings in his
personal assets into the capital of the partnership
firm as his contribution to its capital he reduces his
exclusive rights in the asset to shared rights in it
with the other partners of the firm. While he does
not lose his rights in the asset altogether what he
enjoys now is an abridged right which cannot be
identified with the fullness of the right which he
enjoyed in the asset before it entered the
partnership capital. It becomes apparent that when
a partner brings in his personal asset into
partnership firm as his contribution to the capital,
an asset which originally was subject to the entire
ownership of the partner, becomes now subject to
Digitally Signed By:
K B GEETHA

- 37 -
CRL.RP No. 1197 of 2024


the rights of other partners in it. In other words,
the partner who brings in the asset reduces his
exclusive right in the asset to the shared rights in it
with other partners of the firm."

42. In the alleged partnership agreement between
the complainant's husband and the complainant, there is
no whisper that the lease advance amount paid by the
complainant shall be part of the partnership agreement; or
the property to be taken on lease by the husband of the
complainant shall be the property of the partnership firm.
In the absence of these things, the wife/complainant
cannot get any authority to claim the amount due to her
husband under the agreement.

43. As discussed above, the complainant is a
separate individual and her husband is a separate
individual. Admittedly there is no transaction between the
complainant and the accused at any point of time. The
alleged partnership deed will not give authority to the
complainant to claim that the cheque was issued for
legally recoverable debt or liability. Further, the
complainant has not filed the complaint in the capacity of
Digitally Signed By:
K B GEETHA

- 38 -
CRL.RP No. 1197 of 2024


partner of the firm. It is to be noted here that Ex.P.12 is
dated 27.01.2020 i.e., after Ex.D.3-the lease deed came
into existence between the husband of complainant and
the accused. However, it is to be noted here that the
address of the partnership firm is shown as the address of
the building belonged to the accused. The said building
was not at all let out to the complainant or her husband as
on the alleged date of this partnership deed. Thus, it
appears that this is only a document created for the
purpose of this case and it was never acted upon.

44. In the cross-examination, the complainant
admitted that there were totally 3 agreements of rents
which came into existence. The first one is Ex.D.3 dated
23.01.2020 between the husband of the complainant and
the accused and it is duly signed by both the parties.
According to this document, the accused has to hand over
the property to the husband of complainant on 01.03.2020
but because of COVID-19 pandemic, it could not have
been done. Subsequently, during July-2020 as per Ex.D.1
and during February-2021 as per Ex.D.2, the two draft
Digitally Signed By:
K B GEETHA

- 39 -
CRL.RP No. 1197 of 2024


lease deeds were prepared but they were not signed by
both parties and finally the agreement was not at all come
into existence. Even in these two documents, there is no
mention about the complainant. Furthermore, after
disposal of OS 425/2021, the husband of the complainant
has filed Commercial OS 133/2022 and the complainant is
not party even in that case. She is not at all in picture in
both the agreements as per Exs.D.1, D.2 and in both the
suits. However, the subject cheque stands in her name.

45. The cross-examination of the complainant
reveals that the complainant does not know anything
about the transaction between her husband and the
accused and everything was being looked after by her
husband but only for this subject cheque, she has filed the
present complaint.
7

46. In Bir Singh vs. Mukesh Kumar Hon'ble Apex
Court at paragraph No.37 held as follows:
37. A meaningful reading of the provisions of the
Negotiable Instruments Act including, in particular,
Sections 20, 87 and 139, makes it amply clear that a

7
AIR 2019 SC 2446
Digitally Signed By:
K B GEETHA

- 40 -
CRL.RP No. 1197 of 2024


person who signs a cheque and makes it over to the
payee remains liable unless he adduces evidence to
rebut the presumption that the cheque had been
issued for payment of a debt or in discharge of a
liability. It is immaterial that the cheque may have
been filled in by any person other than the drawer, if
the cheque is duly signed by the drawer. If the
cheque is otherwise valid, the penal provisions of
Section 138 would be attracted.


47. The judgment of Hon'ble Apex Court in Ajitsinh
8
Chehuji Rathod vs. The State of Gujarat is regarding
applicability of statutory presumptions; the judgment of
Hon'ble Apex Court in M/S . Kalamani Tex vs.
9
P. Balasubramanian is also on the same point.

48. In the aforesaid Bir singh's case cited supra,
there is an observation regarding Sections 20, 87 and 139
of the NI Act and they made it clear that, a person who
signs a cheque and delivers it to the payee remains liable
unless he adduces evidence to rebut the statutory
presumption. In the instant case, as discussed above, the
signature of the accused on the cheque and its delivery by

8
2024 INSC 63
9

AIR OnLine 2021 SC 82
Digitally Signed By:
K B GEETHA

- 41 -
CRL.RP No. 1197 of 2024


the accused either to the complainant or to her husband is
not at all established. Hence, the said principle is not
helpful to this case.

49. Admittedly the accused has not stepped into the
witness box. It is not in dispute that presumptions are
always in favour of the complainant but they are
rebuttable presumptions. However, when the complainant
failed to establish the signature of the accused on the
subject cheque, the initial presumptions in favour of the
complainant are not available to him.

50. The above discussion reveals that there is no
transaction between the complainant and the accused at
any point of time. It is only between the accused and the
husband of complainant. However, the complainant came
into picture only in this case. The accused has disputed his
signature even on the alleged cheque; as discussed above,
the subject cheque mentioned in the joint memo filed by
the husband of complainant before the Civil Court was
dishonoured;, after dishonour of the said cheque and after
issuance of the notices on behalf of the husband of
Digitally Signed By:
K B GEETHA

- 42 -
CRL.RP No. 1197 of 2024


complainant, the complainant has withdrawn said suit as
settled out of Court. If it was not intended that subject
cheque is to be encashed and the husband of complainant
is entitled for the amount due under subject cheque, there
was no need for him to withdraw the said suit. He filed one
more commercial suit and withdrawn said suit also. The
complainant was not in picture even at that time.

51. The above discussion reveals that there is no
transaction of what so ever between the complainant and
the accused at any point of time; the subject cheque was
not issued in favour of the complainant; and she is not
competent to depose about the transaction that has taken
place between her husband and the accused and she failed
to establish that the subject cheque is signed by the
accused.

52. These aspects were not at all examined by the
trial Court and the appellate Court. The trial Court and the
appellate Court have wrongly inferred that the
presumptions in favour of the complainant were not
rebutted by the accused. Thus, the judgment of the trial
Digitally Signed By:
K B GEETHA

- 43 -
CRL.RP No. 1197 of 2024


Court and the appellate Court is grossly erroneous and not
appreciated the evidence in the way it should be
appreciated. Hence, this Court holds that the judgment of
trial Court and appellate Court requires interference.

53. Hence, this Court passes the following :
ORDER

I. The revision petition is allowed ;

II. The revision petitioner/accused is acquitted
of the offence punishable under Section 138
of NI Act.

III. The amount in deposit be refunded to the
accused on proper identification.

Digitally Signed By:
K B GEETHA

(GEETHA K.B.)
JUDGE

rs