REYAZUL HAQUE vs STATE OF WEST BENGAL AND ORS.
- Court
- Calcutta High Court
Form No. J(2)
In the High Court at Calcutta
Constitutional Writ Jurisdiction
Appellate Side
Present: The Hon’ble Justice Sabyasachi Bhattacharyya
And
The Hon’ble Justice Md. Shabbar Rashidi
WPLRT No. 83 of 2026
Reyazul Haque
Vs.
State of West Bengal and others
For the petitioner : Mr. Somnath Gangopadhyay,
Mr. Rajesh Kumar Shaw, Advs.
For the State : Mr. Nilanjan Bhattacharjee, Sr. Standing Counsel,
Ms. J. D. Chakraborty, Jr. Govt. Adv.,
Mr. Arghya Chatterjee,
Mr. Bratin Kumar Dey, Advs.
For the private
respondents : Mr. Supratick Shyamal,
Mr. Sonali Sengupta,
Ms. Manisha Nath,
Ms. Paramita Barik, Advs.
Heard on : November 19, 2026.
Judgment on : November 19, 2026.
Sabyasachi Bhattacharyya, J.:-
1. The present challenge has been preferred against an order whereby
the West Bengal Land Reforms and Tenancy Tribunal (in short “the
Tribunal”) refused to interfere with an order passed by the Kolkata
Thika Tenancy Controller to the effect that the objection of the writ
petitioner that premises no. 19/A Blackman Street, Kolkata - 700 013,
which is a separate and distinct premises, was erroneously clubbed
2
with premises nos. 33/14A and 33/14B, S. N. Banerjee Road, Kolkata-
700 013 in the selfsame proceeding under Section 5(3) of the of the
West Bengal Thika Tenancy (Acquisition and Regulation) Act, 2001.
2. Learned counsel for the petitioner argues, by placing reliance on an
order dated September 19, 2024, a copy of which is handed over in
Court, that by the said order, the Thika Controller for the first time
observed that it appeared that three premises are involved in the
enquiry and that the other premises are “daughter premises” of
premises no. 19/A Blackman Street, Kolkata- 700 013.
3. Learned counsel for the petitioner argues that the Tribunal placed
reliance on a coordinate Bench judgment of this Court in the matter of
Anil Kumar Makur and others Vs. The State of West Bengal and others ,
reported at 2018 SCC OnLine Cal 3422 , whereas the said decision has
no bearing on the present matter.
4. Learned counsel appearing for the private respondents argues that the
question as to whether the three premises are daughter premises or
not has been kept open by the Thika Controller for being decided later.
5. That apart, it is submitted that since the premises are adjoining ones,
being situated next to each other, there was no error on the part of the
Thika Controller in clubbing the two proceedings in respect of the
same.
6. From the two notices annexed to the writ petition, respectively dated
November 2, 2023 and October 24, 2024, we find that the two pertain
to separate miscellaneous cases. Whereas Miscellaneous Case No.
140 of 2023, which is the subject matter of the notice dated November
3
2, 2023, encompasses premises no. 33/14A, S.N.Banerjee Road,
Kolkata- 700 013, the notice dated October 24, 2024 which is in
respect of Miscellaneous Case No. 120 of 2023, pertains to the
aforementioned premises as well as premises nos. 33/14B, S.N.
Banerjee Road, Kolkata- 70013 and 19/A, Blackman Street, Kolkata-
700 013, the latter being the subject-matter of the present dispute.
7. In any event, from the order dated September 19, 2024, it is evident
that two miscellaneous cases have been clubbed for being taken up
together by the Thika Controller.
8. We do not find that any right, title, interest and/or liability of the parties
has been decided by the Thika Controller or the Tribunal, justifying
interference at this stage by the writ court.
9. The Thika Controller, by the order impugned before the Tribunal dated
April 8, 2025, merely recorded that whether the premises no. 33/14A,
S. N. Banerjee Road, Kolkata-700 013 and 19/A, Blackman Street,
Kolkata-700 013 are totally two different premises or interconnected in
terms of the ownership and the tenancy rights is not clear and the
Controller preferred not to separate the premises from the adjudication-
in-question.
10. Thus, we do not find any patent illegality or conclusive adjudication by
dint of the said order of the Controller.
11. Although the petitioner is justified in contending that the proposition
laid down in Anil Kumar Makur (supra), relied on by the learned
Tribunal, is not apt in the circumstances since the Court was
considering there an order of the Tribunal refusing to fix up a date of
4
hearing, which was observed by this Court not to be amenable to
challenge in a writ petition, fact remains that it is open to the petitioner
as well as the private respondents in the instant case to canvass the
question as to whether the properties-in-question are interconnected or
separate for the purpose of adjudication at the time of hearing of the
proceedings under Section 5(3) of the 2001 Act pending before the
Tribunal.
12. Accordingly, WPLRT No. 83 of 2026 is disposed of without interfering
with the impugned judgment dated December 2, 2025 passed by the
Third Bench, West Bengal Land Reforms and Tenancy Tribunal in MA
1261 of 2025 [OA 1666 of 2025 (LRTT)], however, with liberty to the
petitioner to raise the question as to the identity or separateness of the
three premises-in-question before the Controller at the time of final
hearing of the miscellaneous cases, bearing Miscellaneous Case No.
120 of 2023 and Miscellaneous Case No. 140 of 2023.
13. There will be no order as to costs.
14. Urgent Photostat certified copies of this order, if applied for, be made
available to the parties upon compliance with the requisite formalities.
(Sabyasachi Bhattacharyya, J.)
I agree.
(Md. Shabbar Rashidi, J.