Sh. Ashok Bansal vs Kohli Tents Private Limited

Court
Delhi High Court

$~48
* IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
th
Date of decision: 24 September 2026
# CNR No. DLHC010425502026
+ CM(M) 1986/2026
SH. ASHOK BANSAL .....Petitioner
Through: Mr. Raghvendra Kishore Singh,
Mr. Abhishek Gupta Mr. Nishant
Anand Ms. Shilpa Dewan, Mr.
Mahik Singh, Mr. Udit Wadhwa &
Mr. Tarun Choudhary, Advs.

versus

KOHLI TENTS PRIVATE LIMITED .....Respondent
Through: Mr. Sunil Kapoor, Advocate

CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE ANISH DAYAL
JUDGMENT

ANISH DAYAL, J (ORAL)

1. This petition has been filed under Article 227 of the Constitution of
rd th th
India, impugning orders dated 23 April 2026, 13 July 2026 and 10
August 2026, passed by the Commercial Court, West District, Tis Hazari
Courts, Delhi [‘ Trial Court ’], in CS (COMM) 495/2024 .
2. The commercial suit was filed by plaintiff/petitioner against six
defendants, wherein defendant no.1 was ‘ Kohli Tents Private Limited ’;
defendant nos. 2 to 4 were its Directors, and defendant no.5 was the
Manager of the venue named ‘ The Florence by Kohli ’.
Signature Not Verified
CM(M) 1986/2026 Page - 1/11

Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
Signing Date:30.09.2026
16:53:24

3. The said suit was filed by plaintiff/petitioner seeking refund of
Rs.5,26,000/- i.e. the amount of Rs. 3,00,000/- , paid towards an advance
booking made by petitioner/plaintiff for booking the aforesaid venue for
st
the marriage of his daughter, scheduled for 01 May 2021, and with
interest. However, due to the onset of the first wave of the COVID-19
pandemic, the marriage event stood cancelled. Despite requesting refund
of the amount, the same was declined by the respondent/defendant no.1.
th
4. Issues in the suit were framed on 12 November 2024. The said
issues are extracted as under:
“ 1. Whether the suit is barred by limitation? OPD.
2. That the suit is bad for mis-joinder of parties?
OPD.
3. Whether the plaintiff has no cause of action to file
the present suit?
OPD.
4. Whether the plaintiff is entitled to recovery of suit
amount alongwith Interest, as prayed for? OPP.
5. Relief. ”

5. Mr. Raghavendra Singh , counsel for petitioner/plaintiff, points out
that no issue was framed by the Commercial Court regarding whether the
suit was maintainable or not, on account of it not being a commercial suit
or otherwise.
rd
6. Subsequently, on 23 April 2026, an application was moved by
respondents/defendants under Order XVIII of Code of Civil Procedure,
1908 [‘ CPC’ ], seeking permission to examine four more witnesses. This
application was however dismissed.
7. Unprovoked by any submission made by the
respondents/defendants, the Commercial Court then noted that part final
Signature Not Verified
CM(M) 1986/2026 Page - 2/11

Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
Signing Date:30.09.2026
16:53:24

arguments had been heard, but the Court was of a prima facie view that
the dispute involved in the suit was not a commercial dispute , since
petitioner/plaintiff had been a consumer while approaching the
respondents/defendants and, therefore, petitioner/plaintiff ought to have
approached the Consumer Court or the Civil Court in this regard. The
observations rendered by the Commercial Court on this aspect are
extracted as under:
“ Part final arguments heard on behalf of the plaintiff,
however, during the course of arguments, this court is
of the prima facie view that the dispute involved in the
present suit is not a commercial dispute because
plaintiff as a consumer had approached the defendant
for providing services and now plaintiff has filed the
suit for recovery of advance payment that was given to
the defendant. Prima facie this suit is not maintainable
before this court and has to be tried by Consumer
Court or Civil Court .”
(emphasis added)

8. Mr. Singh , therefore, contends that having taken a prima facie view
at the stage of final arguments, despite no issue having been framed in
this regard, and without being provoked by any submission made by
respondents/defendants, the said order be set aside and the parties be
relegated back to the Commercial Court for addressing final arguments on
the merits of the matter.
9. The submissions of Mr. Singh , counsel for petitioner/plaintiff, can
therefore, be summarised as under:

i) firstly , no issue had been framed previously and therefore, the
parties did not have an opportunity to address the Court on this
issue;
Signature Not Verified
CM(M) 1986/2026 Page - 3/11

Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
Signing Date:30.09.2026
16:53:24

ii) secondly , the issue of maintainability could not have been raised at
the stage of final arguments and;
iii) thirdly , there is no reason why this suit could not be considered as a
commercial suit in light of Section 2(1)(c)(xviii) of the Commercial
Courts Act, 2015 [‘ CCA ’], which allows suits filed in respect of
‘ provision of services ’ to be considered as commercial suits .

10. Mr. Singh , counsel for petitioner/plaintiff has further drawn the
attention of this Court to a judgment passed in another suit, being CS
(Comm) 146/2021 , titled ‘ Sh. Surinder Kumar Anand v. Kohli Tent
House (Partnerships) ’, wherein the same defendant was yet again
arrayed as a defendant, and the Commercial Court proceeded to decide
the matter in the favour of the plaintiff therein.
11. Mr. Sunil Kapoor , counsel, appears for the respondent and
essentially submits that the Trial Court has already listed the matter for
arguments on maintainability and therefore, said issue may be considered
by the Trial Court.
12. However, in the process of examining whether this suit could be
treated as a ‘ commercial suit ’ or not, various decisions have been placed
before this Court, which prompts the Court to give its opinion in this
matter.

Analysis and findings
13. The suit had been filed under Section 6 read with Section 12A(i) of
the CCA for recovery of Rs.5,26,000/- . The crux of the matter was based
on refund of the amount, which had been paid towards an advance
booking made by petitioner/plaintiff for booking the venue for marriage
of his daughter.
Signature Not Verified
CM(M) 1986/2026 Page - 4/11

Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
Signing Date:30.09.2026
16:53:24

14. What needs be considered therefore is whether the aforesaid
transaction would fall within the purview of Section 2(1)(xviii) of the
CCA.
15. The recent judgment of the Division Bench of this Court, in Chand
Mehra v. British Airways PLC , 2025 SCC OnLine Del. 6207, is
instructive in this regard, wherein, a suit had been filed seeking refund of
the money paid towards booking business class air tickets in the
respondent airlines. An application under Order VII Rule 10 and 11 of the
Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 [‘ CPC’ ] was moved by the defendant,
before the Commercial Court, contending that the dispute does not fall
within the ambit of a ‘ commercial dispute ’. The Commercial Court
allowed the application and held that the suit was not maintainable as a
‘ commercial suit ’. The same was then appealed against, in FAO (COMM)
No.245/2024 , which came up for consideration before the Division Bench
of this Court. The question to be considered was whether the said
transaction would qualify as a ‘ commercial dispute ’ or not. The Court
analysed the relevant judgments presented by the respective parties, and
thereafter held as under:
“ 27. The aforequoted provision of Section 2(1)(c)(xviii)
provides that any dispute arising out of agreement for
sale of goods or arising out of agreement for provision
of services will constitute commercial dispute. In the
instant case there is no agreement for sale of goods; it
is only a contract for providing services, however
dispute arising out of such a contract for providing
services can be construed to be a commercial dispute
only in case it involves some or the other kind of trade
or business or financing etc.
Signature Not Verified
CM(M) 1986/2026 Page - 5/11

Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
Signing Date:30.09.2026
16:53:24

28. An agreement containing a provision for providing
mere services on payment of certain charges cannot, in
every case, be termed to be an agreement, dispute in
respect of which can be said to be a commercial
dispute. To constitute a dispute to be a commercial
dispute arising out of an agreement which contains a
provision of services, the agreement or transaction is
to necessarily contain an element of commerce or trade
or business. ”
(emphasis added)

16. The Division Bench of this Court is, therefore, categorical, in that
an agreement for provision of services must contain an element of
commerce or trade of business in order to fall within the purview of
Section 2 (1)(xviii) of the CCA.
17. To flesh out as to what would amount to a ‘ commercial purpose ’,
reference has been made to the decision of the Supreme Court in Lilavati
Kirtilal Mehta Medical Trust v. Unique Shanti Developers , (2020) 2
SCC 265, whereby the Court analysed whether Section 2(1)(d)(ii) of the
Consumer Protection Act, 1986, which states that the term ‘ consumer ’
would not include a person who avails any services for commercial
purposes, would apply to the nature of the transaction involved in the said
case. In this regard, the Supreme Court held as under:
“ 19. To summarise from the above discussion, though
a strait jacket formula cannot be adopted in every case,
the following broad principles can be culled out for
determining whether an activity or transaction is “for
a commercial purpose”:
19.1. The question of whether a transaction is for a
commercial purpose would depend upon the facts and
circumstances of each case. However, ordinarily,
“commercial purpose” is understood to include
Signature Not Verified
CM(M) 1986/2026 Page - 6/11

Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
Signing Date:30.09.2026
16:53:24

manufacturing/industrial activity or business-to-
business transactions between commercial entities.
19.2. The purchase of the good or service should have
a close and direct nexus with a profit-generating
activity
19.3. The identity of the person making the purchase or
the value of the transaction is not conclusive to the
question of whether it is for a commercial purpose. It
has to be seen whether the dominant intention or
dominant purpose for the transaction was to facilitate
some kind of profit generation for the purchaser and/or
their beneficiary.
19.4. If it is found that the dominant purpose behind
purchasing the good or service was for the personal
use and consumption of the purchaser and/or their
beneficiary, or is otherwise not linked to any
commercial activity, the question of whether such a
purchase was for the purpose of “generating livelihood
by means of self-employment” need not be looked
into. ”
(emphasis added)
18. This Court, in other decisions, has held that where the Court is
dealing with matters which purely involve a non-commercial transaction,
such as a friendly or personal loan, the same would not qualify as a
‘ commercial dispute ’ under the CCA. This opinion has been taken by the
Single Bench of this Court in Meena Vohra v. Master Hosts (P) Ltd. ,
2025 SCC OnLine Del 1758. For ease of reference, the relevant
paragraphs from Meena Vohra ( supra ) are extracted hereunder:
“ 50. In light of the foregoing discussion, this Court
finds that the claim for recovery in the present suit
does not qualify as a “commercial dispute” under
Section 2(1)(c) of the Act of 2015, as the transaction in
question pertains to a personal loan. The lender was
not a merchant, trader, banker or financier. The
deceased had advanced a personal loan to defendant
Signature Not Verified
CM(M) 1986/2026 Page - 7/11

Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
Signing Date:30.09.2026
16:53:24

no. 1 on certain terms and conditions, but such a loan,
even if ultimately used for business purposes, does not
inherently constitute a “commercial dispute” within
the meaning of the Act of 2015 as it does not pertain to
ordinary transactions involving merchants, bankers,
financiers, and traders such as those relating to
mercantile documents. Moreover, the loan was not
advanced in the ordinary course of business and has
no relation to the trade, commerce, or business of the
plaintiff's deceased brother. ”
(emphasis added)


19. In view of the aforesaid decisions, it is quite obvious that the
service sought towards booking a marriage venue would be for a
‘ personal purpose ’ and not a ‘ business purpose ’. Clearly, the transactions
to be slotted as ‘ commercial transactions ’ would involve a mercantile or
what would commonly be called as a ‘ B2B ’ or ‘ business to business ’
transaction between commercial entities. However, in this case, while the
service provider would mostly and naturally be and is a commercial
entity, purchaser of the services is not a commercial entity but had booked
the venue for personal purpose.
20. The Court, therefore needs to consider what are the options
available to it at this stage. Having arrived at this point where the suit
cannot be considered as ‘ commercial’ , leaving the matter to be yet again
considered by the Trial Court may not be necessary. Moreover,
considering that the suit is at final stage and final arguments are being
addressed, it would be not in the interest of justice to revert the matter
back to its initial stage.
21. Some light upon the aforesaid issue has been thrown by a Co-
ordinate Bench of this Court in the decision of Namita Gupta v. Suraj
Holdings Ltd. , 2024 SCC OnLine Del 143, wherein the Court was
Signature Not Verified
CM(M) 1986/2026 Page - 8/11

Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
Signing Date:30.09.2026
16:53:24

dealing with an application under Order VII Rule 11 of the CPC, which
had been filed before the Trial Court, contending that the suit involved a
‘ commercial dispute ’ but had been filed without resorting to the pre-
institution mediation as mandated under Section 12-A of the CCA and
was, therefore, liable to be rejected. The Court considered the
submissions of the parties and noted that the CCA does not exclude the
application of Section 24 of the CPC and that power under Section 24 of
the CPC to transfer the suit, is not available to a District and Sessions
Judge. Therefore, the course adopted, was for this Court itself to transfer
the suit to a Court of Competent Jurisdiction under Section 24 of the
CPC.
22. For ready reference, Section 24 of the CPC has been reproduced
hereinbelow:
“24. General power of transfer and withdrawal.— (1)
On the application of any of the parties and after
notice to the parties and after hearing such of them as
desired to be heard, or of its own motion without such
notice, the High Court or the District Court may at any
stage—
(a) transfer any suit, appeal or other proceeding
pending before it for trial or disposal to any Court
subordinate to it and competent to try or dispose of the
same, or
(b) withdraw any suit, appeal or other
proceeding pending in any Court subordinate to it,
and—
(i) try or dispose of the same; or
(ii) transfer the same for trial or disposal to
any Court subordinate to it and competent to try or
dispose of the same; or
(iii) retransfer the same for trial or disposal to
the Court from which it was withdrawn.
(2) Where any suit or proceeding has been transferred
Signature Not Verified
CM(M) 1986/2026 Page - 9/11

Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
Signing Date:30.09.2026
16:53:24

or withdrawn under sub-section (1), the Court which
1[is thereafter to try or dispose of such suit or
proceeding] may, subject to any special directions in
the case of an order of transfer, either retry it or
proceed from the point at which it was transferred or
withdrawn.
(3) For the purposes of this section,—
(a) Courts of Additional and Assistant Judges
shall be deemed to be subordinate to the District
Court;
(b) “proceeding” includes a proceeding for
the execution of a decree or order.
(4) The Court trying any suit transferred or withdrawn
under this section from a Court of Small Causes shall,
for the purposes of such suit, be deemed to be a Court
of Small Causes.
(5) A suit or proceeding may be transferred
under this section from a Court which has no
jurisdiction to try it. ”
23. Thus, it is quite evident from a bare perusal of the aforesaid
provision, particularly sub-section (1) clause (b) sub-clause (ii) read with
sub-section (5), that in the facts and circumstances of the present petition
as well, this Court has the power to transfer the suit to a Court of
competent jurisdiction, which in this case would be the Civil Court.
24. Accordingly, it is directed that the said suit be finally heard by a
Civil Court, upon transfer from the Commercial Court to a Civil Court.
The suit shall be transferred from the Court of the District Judge,
Commercial Court 04, West District, Tis Hazari Courts to the Court of
competent jurisdiction.
25. For this purpose, the matter is listed before the Principal District
th
and Sessions Judge, Tis Hazari Courts, on 07 October 2026, for
designating a Court to hear the matter afresh from the stage at which it
Signature Not Verified
CM(M) 1986/2026 Page - 10/11

Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
Signing Date:30.09.2026
16:53:24

presently stands and to proceed from the point at which it has been
transferred.
26. After having deliberated upon legal aspects involved, counsel for
the parties also consent to the said recourse, in that, suit be head from the
present stage itself by the Civil Court.
27. This petition stands disposed in terms of above directions.
28. Pending applications, if any, are rendered infructuous
29. Order be uploaded on the website of this Court.

(ANISH DAYAL)
JUDGE
SEPTEMBER 24, 2026/sm/ ya


Signature Not Verified
CM(M) 1986/2026 Page - 11/11

Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
Signing Date:30.09.2026
16:53:24