SURESH KUMAR DUBEY vs BLOCK EDUCATION OFFICER
- Court
- Chhattisgarh High Court
1
CGHC010423542026
NAFR
Digitally signed
by INDRAJEET
SAHU
Date: 2026.11.18
10:37:36 +0530
INDRAJEET
SAHU
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
WP227 No. 1416 of 2026
1 - Suresh Kumar Dubey S/o Late Bhagwat Kumar Dubey Aged About 57
Years R/o Present Address Village Yadunandan Nagar, Tifra, District Bilaspur
(C.G.)
... Petitioner(s)
Versus
1 - Block Education Officer Bilha, District Bilaspur (C.G.)
2 - Branch Manager State Bank of India, Collectorate Branch, District
Bilaspur (C.G.)
3 - Pushpa Bharti W/o Rakesh Keshware, D/o Madan Lal Hela Aged About 53
Years
4 - Chandra Kant Hela S/o Madan Lal Hela Aged About 74 Years
5 - Shashi Bharti W/o Late Shrikant Bharti, D/o Madan Lal Hela Aged About
63 Years
6 - Ajit Kant Bharti S/o Madan Lal Hela Aged About 67 Years
7 - Ravindra Kant Bharti S/o Madan Lal Hela Aged About 61 Years
8 - Umesh Kant Bharti S/o Madan Lal Hela Aged About 59 Years
Respondents No. 3 to 8 are R/o Brihaspati Bazar, Shivaji Chowk, Beside
Bajrang Akhada, Bilaspur, Tahsil And District Bilaspur (C.G.)
... Respondent(s)
(Cause-title taken from Case Information System)
For Petitioner : Shri Punit Ruparel, Advocate.
For State : Ms. Supriya Upasne, Govt. Advocate.
For Respondent No.2 : Shri Vikas Dhritlahre on behalf of Shri P.R.
Patankar, Advocate.
Hon’ble Shri Justice Ravindra Kumar Agrawal, J
Order on Board
17.11.2026
1. The present writ petition under Article 227 of the Constitution of India
has been filed by the petitioner against the impugned order dated
2
24.09.2026 passed by the First Civil Judge, Senior Division, Bilaspur,
in Succession Case No.27/2026 whereby the application filed by the
intervenor under Order 1 Rule 10 CPC was allowed and they were
directed to be impleaded as party non applicant in the Succession
Case filed by the petitioner.
2. Learned counsel for the petitioner would submit that the petitioner is
the applicant before the trial court who is prosecuting an application for
grant of Succession Certificate in his favour. The wife of the petitioner
namely Smt. Vandana Bharti died on 02.02.2026. As per petitioner, he
married with Vandana Bharti on 05.01.2017. She was employed as a
Upper Division Teacher and posted at Govt. Middle School, Bitkuli,
District Bilaspur. After her death, the petitioner is entitled for her
departmental dues for which he made an application to the
department, but department have not paid the departmental dues of
the deceased Vandana Bharti to him and then he filed an application
under Section 372 of the Indian Succession Act, 1925 for grant of
Succession Certificate in his favour. In the succession case, the
respondents No.3 to 8 filed an application under Order 1 Rule 10 CPC
for impleading them as party non applicant in the succession case filed
by the petition. In the said application they averred that respondent
No.3 Pushpa Bharti is the nominee declared by the deceased Vandana
Bharti in her service record as she is the real sister of the deceased
Vandana Bharti whereas, the petitioner is claiming himself to be the
Husband of late Vandana Bharti. Since the respondents No.3 to 8 are
real brother and sister of late Vandana Bharti and the name of
respondent No.3 Pushpa Bharti is recorded as nominee in the service
3
record of the deceased Vandana Bharti, they are necessary and proper
party to the Succession proceeding which is required to be adjudicated
in accordance with law. He would further submit that deceased
Vandana Bharti was wife of the petitioner and Husband is the heir as
provided under Section 15 of the Hindu Succession Act. Merely by
recording the name of respondent No.3 as nominee of deceased, she
is not entitled to inherit any property of the deceased and she is only a
custodian of the property of the deceased. Therefore, they are neither
necessary nor proper party in the proceeding, yet the trial court has
allowed the application filed by them on the ground that proposed non
applicants are claiming that they are the near relative of deceased and
in view of the controversy involved in the case and relationship
between the parties, the proposed non applicants are required to
provide an opportunity to put up their case and for that they have been
directed to be made as party non applicant in the proceeding. He
would also submit that though the proposed non applicant are brother
and sisters of deceased Vandana Bharti, but they cannot be made as
party non applicant in the present proceeding as they have no right or
title over the property of deceased Vandana Bharti. Therefore, the
impugned order may be set aside and their application may be
rejected.
3. On the other hand, learned counsel for the respondent No.1 opposes
the submissions made by the counsel for the petitioner and would
submit that though the name of petitioner is not recorded in the service
record of the deceased Vandana Bharti, but he is claiming that he is
the husband of deceased Vandana Bharti and the proposed non
4
applicants are claiming that they are the near relative of the deceased.
Considering the rival submissions of the parties, the trial court has
allowed the application and directed them to be impleaded as party
non applicant in the proceeding for effective adjudication of the dispute
between the parties. No prejudice would be caused if an opportunity to
put up their case before the trial court is given to the proposed non
applicants. Therefore, the impugned order does not suffer from any
perversity and the writ petition is liable to be dismissed.
4. Learned counsel for respondent No.2 Bank would support the
submissions made by the counsel for the respondent No.1 and would
submit that it is a dispute between the private parties and Bank is
willing to follow the ultimate outcome of the succession proceeding.
5. I have heard the counsel for the parties and perused the documents
annexed with the petition.
6. From perusal of documents annexed with the petition it transpires that
the petitioner is claiming to be the husband of deceased Vandana
Bharti who was a Upper Division Teacher, posted at Govt. Middle
School, Bitkuli. She died on 02.02.2026 and thereafter the petitioner,
being husband, is claiming her departmental dues. In the application
filed by the petitioner under Section 372 of the Indian Succession Act,
1925, though the petitioner has pleaded that cause of action arose on
24.02.2026 when he contacted with the non applicant No.1&2 for
payment of departmental dues of the deceased and when no action
has been taken on his application, he filed the Succession Case,
howsoever, he could not disclose about the nominee or any other
claimants of the departmental dues of deceased in his application. In
5
the application under Order 1 Rule 10 CPC filed by the proposed non
applicants, Annexure P/4, they claimed that through letter dated
27.04.2026 issued by the respondent No.1 they came to know that the
petitioner is claiming departmental dues of the deceased stating that
he is the sole legal heir of the deceased Vandana Bharti. In the
application it has also been averred that they are real brother and
sister of deceased Vandana Bharti and the name of respondent No.3-
Pushpa Bharti is recorded as nominee in the service record of the
deceased Vandana Bharti, and therefore, they would be the proper and
necessary party in the proceeding and their names may be directed to
be impleaded as non applicants in the case. The trial court after
considering the rival claims of the parties and also the nature of dispute
and further that the name of respondent No.3-Pushpa Bharti is
recorded as nominee in the service record of the deceased Vandana
Bharti, they considered them to be proper party in the proceeding and
directed for their impleadment in the succession case.
7. Perusal of the nature of dispute between the parties and subject matter
& claim of the proposed non applicants would show that no prejudice
would be caused to the petitioner even if the proposed non applicants
are given opportunity of hearing and to put up their case before the trial
court for the reason that the petitioner is claiming to be the husband
and preferential right over the property of the deceased Vandana Bharti
as per Section 15 of the Hindu Succession Act, 1956, whereas, the
proposed non applicants are claiming their rights as Class-II heir and
near relatives of deceased Vandana Bharti and also on the ground that
the name of respondent No.3 is recorded as nominee in the service
6
record of deceased Vandana Bharti. Thus, the proposed non applicants
appear to be proper and necessary party in the proceeding and they
are required to be heard before deciding the case by the trial court.
8. In Mumbai International Airport Private Limited Vs. Regency
Convention Centra & Hotels Private Limited & Others, 2010(7)SCC
417 , the Hon’ble Supreme Court dealing with the issue of impleadment
of party in a suit have considered the proper and necessary party to be
incorporated. In paragraphs 13,15 &16 it was observed as under:
“13. The general rule in regard to impleadment of parties is that
the plaintiff in a suit, being dominus litis, may choose the persons
against whom he wishes to litigate and cannot be compelled to
sue a person against whom he does not seek any relief.
Consequently, a person who is not a party has no right to be
impleaded against the wishes of the plaintiff. But this general rule
is subject to the provisions of Order I Rule 10(2) of Code of Civil
Procedure (`Code' for short), which provides for impleadment of
proper or necessary parties. The said sub-rule is extracted
below:
“10(2) "Court may strike out or add parties. -The Court
may at any stage of the proceedings, either upon or
without the application of either party, and on such terms
as may appear to the Court to be just, order that the name
of any party improperly joined, whether as plaintiff or
defendant, be struck out, and that the name of any person
who ought to have been joined, whether as plaintiff or
defendant, or whose presence before the Court may be
necessary in order to enable the Court effectually and
completely to adjudicate upon and settle all the questions
involved in the suit, be added."
15. A `necessary party' is a person who ought to have been
joined as a party and in whose absence no effective decree
could be passed at all by the Court. If a `necessary party' is not
impleaded, the suit itself is liable to be dismissed. A `proper
party' is a party who, though not a necessary party, is a person
whose presence would enable the court to completely, effectively
and adequately adjudicate upon all matters in disputes in the
suit, though he need not be a person in favour of or against
whom the decree is to be made. If a person is not found to be a
proper or necessary party, the court has no jurisdiction to
implead him, against the wishes of the plaintiff. The fact that a
person is likely to secure a right/interest in a suit property, after
the suit is decided against the plaintiff, will not make such person
a necessary party or a proper party to the suit for specific
performance.
7
16. The learned counsel for the appellants relied upon the
following observations of a two-Judge Bench of this Court in
Sumtibai v. Paras Finance Co. [2007 (10) SCC 82] to contend
that a person need not have any subsisting right or interest in the
suit property for being impleaded as a defendant, and that even
a person who is likely to acquire an interest therein in future, in
appropriate cases, is entitled to be impleaded as a party:
"9. Learned counsel for the respondent relied on a three-
Judge Bench decision of this Court in Kasturi v.
Iyyamperuma [2005(6) SCC 733]. He has submitted that in
this case it has been held that in a suit for specific
performance of a contract for sale of property a stranger or
a third party to the contract cannot be added as defendant
in the suit. In our opinion, the aforesaid decision is clearly
distinguishable. In our opinion, the aforesaid decision can
only be understood to mean that a third party cannot be
impleaded in a suit for specific performance if he has no
semblance of title in the property in dispute. Obviously, a
busybody or interloper with no semblance of title cannot be
impleaded in such a suit. That would unnecessarily
protract or obstruct the proceedings in the suit. However,
the aforesaid decision will have no application where a
third party shows some semblance of title or interest in the
property in dispute.
14........It cannot be laid down as an absolute proposition
that whenever a suit for specific performance is filed by A
against B, a third party C can never be impleaded in that
suit. If C can show a fair semblance of title or interest he
can certainly file an application for impleadment."
9. Considering the documents available in the writ petition and the
impugned order passed by the trial court, this court is of the considered
opinion that the trial court has rightly allowed the application and
directed the petitioner to implead the proposed non applicants in the
succession case and to provide them opportunity of hearing so that
dispute between the parties could be effectively adjudicated. This court
does not find any jurisdictional error in allowing the application filed by
the proposed non applicants under Order 1 Rule 10 of CPC.
10. Accordingly, the writ petition fails and is hereby dismissed. No order
asto costs.
Sd/-
(Ravindra Kumar Agrawal)
Judge
inder