Ramji Lal Meena vs D/o Income Tax

Court
Central Administrative Tribunal

:: 1 :: OA No. 427/2020

CENTRAL ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL
AHMEDABAD BECH

Original Application No. OA No. 427/2020

rd
Dated this the 23 day of October, 2026.

CORAM:
Hon’ble Shri Jayesh V Bhairavia, Member (J)
Hon’ble Shri Sanjiv Kumar, Member (A)

1. Ramji Lal Meena
S/o Kalyan Sahaya Meena
Aged: 55 years (DOB being 25.09.1964)
Presently serving as Income Tax Offier,
O/o Principal Commissioner of Income Tax (ReAC)-2,
rd
Ahmedabad having address at 3 Floor, Room No. A-302,
Pratyaksh Kar Bhawan, Opp- Govt Polytechnic, Ambawadi,
Ahmedabad – 380015.
…Applicants
(By Advocate: Mr. Hardik V Vora)

V/s.

1. Union of India through
The Secretary, Ministry of Finance,
Government of India, Department of Revenue,
Room No. 46, North Block,
New Delhi – 110001

2. Pr. Commissioner of Income Tax (ReAC)-2 Ahmedabad
rd
3 Floor, Room No. A-302, Pratyaksh Kar Bhawan,
Opp- Govt Polytechnic,
Ambawadi, Ahmedabad – 380015.

3. Pr. Chief Commissioner of Income Tax, Gujarat
Room No. 206, Second Floor, Aaykar Bhavan,
Ashram Road, Ahmedabad – 380009.
… Respondents

(By Advocate: Mr. Chirayu Mehta)






2026.11.04
PRATIK VYAS
15:02:56+05'30'

:: 2 :: OA No. 427/2020

ORDER
Per: Hon’ble Shri Jayesh V Bhairavia, Member (Judicial)
The applicant has preferred this Original Application under Section 19 of the
Administrative Tribunals Act, 1985, challenging the speaking
order/communication dated 15.09.2020 passed by the Respondent No. 3
whereby his claim/representation dated 02.03.2020 seeking reallocation of
seniority in the cadre of Income Tax Officer (ITO) on the basis of the 2003
Departmental Examination has been rejected. The applicant also prays for
issuance of directions upon the respondents to reallocate his seniority
immediately after the Departmental Promotion Committee (DPC) conducted
for the 2003 batch, along with all consequential and notional benefits.
2. Brief facts of the case are as under:-
2.1 That the applicant was initially appointed as an Inspector of Income Tax
(Direct Recruit) on 03.06.1993. Under the Recruitment Rules then in force,
passing the Departmental Examination for Income Tax Officers was a
mandatory condition precedent for promotion to the post of ITO (Group ‘B’).
The applicant appeared in the departmental examination conducted in the
year 2003 but failed to qualify.
2.2 Thereafter, on 21.12.2004, the respondents notified the Income Tax
Officer, Group 'B' Posts, Recruitment Rules, 2004 , whereby the pre-condition
of passing the departmental examination was omitted, making three years of
regular service as an Inspector the sole criteria for promotion.
Consequently, no departmental examinations were conducted
during the years 2004 and 2005. During this interim phase, the department
introduced various ad-hoc promotions on multiple dates between January
2004 and October 2006.
2.3 Subsequently, realizing an administrative omission, the Ministry of
Finance issued the Income Tax Officer, Group 'B' Posts, Recruitment
(Amendment) Rules, 2005 on 24.03.2005. This amendment, which
2026.11.04
PRATIK VYAS
15:02:56+05'30'

:: 3 :: OA No. 427/2020

reintroduced the mandatory requirement of qualifying the departmental
examination for promotion to the cadre of ITO, was expressly made effective
with retrospective operation from 21.12.2004 (the date of publication of the
principal rules).
2.4 The respondents thereafter conducted the departmental examination in
October 2006. The applicant appeared in the said examination and qualified.
The results were officially declared on 17.04.2007, and the applicant was
subsequently promoted to the cadre of ITO on an ad-hoc basis vide
promotion orders in May 2007 and accordingly, his seniority as Income Tax
Officer was fixed at the bottom of the seniority list after considering all the
DPCs declared earlier in accordance with his actual date of regular
promotion/induction in 2007.
2.5 Being aggrieved the applicant submitted a detailed representation dated
02.03.2020 whereby he has requested to reallocate his seniority for
promotion after the DPC was made on the basis of 2003 exams. However,
the same remained pending. Therefore, the applicant has approached this
Tribunal by way of filing O.A. No. 198/2020 and this Tribunal vide order
dated 24.07.2020 disposed of the said OA with direction upon the
respondents to consider the representation of the applicant and intimate the
decision thereon to the applicant. This Tribunal also observed that it has not
expressed any opinion on the merits of the case.
2.6 Thereafter, the respondents in compliance of the direction issued by this
Tribunal in O.A. No. 198/2020 considered the representation of the applicant
and rejected the same by passing speaking order/communication dated
15.09.2020 by assigning the reason that he had appeared in departmental
examination for the post of ITO in 2003 but could not qualify. Further,
Departmental examination could not be held in 2004 and 2005. You appeared
in examination in 2006 and qualified it based on result declared in April 2007
and thereafter promoted to ITO in May 2007. It is stated in this regard that
DPC for V.Y 2003-04 was convened on 02.03.2005. The consequent
2026.11.04
PRATIK VYAS
15:02:56+05'30'

:: 4 :: OA No. 427/2020

promotion Order No. 59 of 2004-05 was passed on 02.03.2005. Although, the
DPC was conducted on 02.03.2005 when Notification dated 21.04.2004 was
effective wherein passing of ITO promotion examination was not a pre-
requisite for promotion to the cadre of ITO but it may be appreciated that this
DPC was meant for the V.Y 2003-04 and the crucial date of determining
eligibility for the DPC was 01.01.2003. The crucial date for determining
eligibility in case of financial year-based vacancy year falls on January 1,
immediately preceding such vacancy year. Therefore, it was mandatory to
qualify ITO promotion examination as on crucial date of eligibility i.e on
01.01.2003 (for V.Y 2003-04) for the promotion of ITO. It may also be noted
that all the Income Tax Inspectors (feeder cadre to ITO) who were
considered for the promotion to ITO by DPC dated 02.03.2005 had qualified
the departmental examination as on crucial date of eligibility i.e. 01.01.2003.
2.7 Hence, the applicant has no other efficacious remedy but to approach this
Tribunal; this OA.
3. In support of the prayer sought in this OA, Mr. Hardik V Vora learned
counsel for the applicant mainly submitted as under:-
3.1 That the respondents failed to conduct the mandatory departmental
examination during the years 2004 and 2005, therefore, for no fault on the
part of the applicant, he was unjustly deprived of an opportunity to qualify
and secure regular promotion earlier. It is stated that the Rule 1 of the Rules
for the Departmental Examination for Income Tax Officers explicitly
mandates that the promotional examination shall be held "every year in the
first quarter of the financial year" . The total failure of the respondents to
conduct any promotional examinations during the financial/vacancy years
2004–05 and 2005–06 constitutes a direct breach of statutory rules. The
applicant was entirely willing and eligible to appear, but was completely
deprived of his right to be considered for regular promotion due to this
administrative omission. Therefore, default on the part of the respondents to
2026.11.04
PRATIK VYAS
15:02:56+05'30'

:: 5 :: OA No. 427/2020

conduct examination annually cannot operate to the prejudice of the

employee.
3.2 Further, he placed reliance on the settled law established by the Hon'ble
Supreme Court in State of Maharashtra v. Jagannath Achyut Karandikar
(1989 Supp (1) SCC 393). The Apex Court held that when a scheme of
promotion links seniority to passing an exam, but the Government fails to
hold the examination annually as required by the rules, it is unjust,
unreasonable, and arbitrary to penalise a person for the default of the
Government. Therefore, the applicant’s seniority should be restored to
protect him from the department's failure to host the exams.
3.3 It is argued that he action of the respondents in convening continuous ad-
hoc DPCs (between 2004 and March 2007) and moving forward with
promotional assignments while completely bypassing the examination
process is fundamentally de hors the recruitment rules. Under the 2005
Amendment Rules, passing the exam was a non-negotiable prerequisite.
Therefore, making promotions without confirming that candidates qualified
in a corresponding exam cycle is legally unsustainable.
3.4 It is argued that even after the department recognized its mistake and
conducted the departmental examination in October 2006, the respondents
acted with arbitrary haste. Instead of waiting for the marks to be tabulated
and declared, the respondents rushed to execute final ad-hoc DPCs on
01.11.2006, 05.12.2006, 03.01.2007, and 01.03.2007. This effectively
blocked vacancies and pushed the applicant to the bottom of the list when his
results were finalized just weeks later on 17.04.2007.
3.5 Learned counsel submitted that the identical issue was litigated before the
Allahabad Bench of this Tribunal in Ashwani Kumar Singh v. Union of India
(O.A. No. 936/2005), wherein the Court explicitly restrained the department
from holding any DPC for the post of ITO without first conducting the
mandatory departmental examination and considering all who pass it.
2026.11.04
PRATIK VYAS
15:02:56+05'30'

:: 6 :: OA No. 427/2020

Similarly, the Principal Bench in Sanjeev Kumar Meena v. Ministry
of Finance (O.A. No. 3434/2016) held that conducting regular DPCs and
granting promotions in utter disregard of the examination cycle, while
ignoring the inter-se seniority of seniors in the feeder category, is wholly
unjustified and unsustainable. The department's Review Application (R.A.
No. 158/2019) against this decision was also flatly rejected. Therefore, it is
contended that his seniority should be reallocated with a deemed date from
2003, placing him directly below the batch that qualified in the 2003
examination.
4. Per Contra, on receipt of the notice issued by this Tribunal respondents
have filed the reply and denied the claim of the applicant. Mr. Chirayu Mehta
learned counsel for the respondents by referring the reply mainly submitted
as under:-
4.1 It is stated that OA is filed after a lapse of delay, in this regard, it is stated
that the applicant's name figured at Seniority No. 1220 in the All India Inter-
se Seniority List of ITOs firmed up as on 01.01.2012 (circulated on
01.09.2015), and subsequently at Seniority No. 4416 in the updated Seniority
List firmed up on 05.02.2018 following the implementation of the N.R.
Parmar judgment. The applicant accepted his placement for years without
any timely legal challenge, and the present O.A., filed in the year 2020,
suffers from gross delay and laches. Therefore, granting retrospective
seniority at this late stage would critically unsettle established seniority
positions across the entire cadre.
4.2 Further, it is argued that the regular DPC for the Vacancy Year 2003-04
was convened on 02.03.2005. Pursuant to DoPT guidelines and O.M. dated
17.09.1998, the crucial date for determining the eligibility of officials for the
financial year-based Vacancy Year 2003-04 was 01.01.2003. On that crucial
date, passing the departmental examination was a strict statutory
requirement. Since the applicant had admittedly failed to qualify the 2003
2026.11.04
PRATIK VYAS
15:02:56+05'30'

:: 7 :: OA No. 427/2020

examination, he was legally ineligible to be considered against the 2003-04
vacancy panel.
4.3 Further, learned counsel for the respondents placed reliance on Rule 14 of
the Rules for the Departmental Examination for Income Tax Officers, 2004,
which explicitly addresses administrative delays and provides that that delay
in conducting examinations or declaring results can occur due to various
valid administrative factors and explicitly provides that such delays shall not
give rise to any rightful claim for promotion or a deemed date of eligibility.
4.4 It is stated that the DPC for ITO, for Vacancy Year 2003-04 was
convened on 02.03.2005. As per DoPT O.M. dated 10.04.1989 which laid
down consolidated instructions on Departmental Promotion Committees and
related matters, a vacancy shall be filled in accordance with the Recruitment
Rules in force on the date of vacancy, unless rules made subsequently have
been expressly given retrospective effect (Annexure R/4). It further states
that since amendments to recruitment rules normally have only prospective
application, the existing vacancies should be filled as per the recruitment
rules in force. Thus, it is stated that even though the DPC was convened on
02.03.2005, the vacancy year against which panel list was recommended was
2003-04. Thus, the recruitment rules applicable for vacancy year 2003-04
would be those which were in force on the date of vacancy 1.e. 01.04.2003.
At that time, one of the requisite conditions of eligibility for promotion of
ITO was passing Departmental examination for Income Tax Officers.
Further, the crucial date as defined in OM dated 17.09.1998 for determining
eligibility in case of vacancy year 2003-04 based vacancy was 01.01.2003
and on that day applicant had not cleared the departmental examination for
ITO. In other words for promotion to the post of ITO against vacancy year
2003-04, eligibility condition prevalent on 01.01.2003 was to be fulfilled. On
01.01.2003, passing of departmental examination for ITO was mandatory and
admittedly applicant had not cleared the same. Therefore the applicant was
rightly denied the seniority from the year 2003 and there is no illegality as
alleged.
2026.11.04
PRATIK VYAS
15:02:56+05'30'

:: 8 :: OA No. 427/2020

4.5 In view of the aforesaid submissions, learned counsel for the respondents
submits that the OA lacks merit and accordingly, the same is required to be
dismissed.
5. In rejoinder, the applicant submits that the O.A. is fully within the
statutory limitation period under Section 21 of the Act. The applicant was
made aware of the drastic impact on his seniority position only around 2018
when the N.R. Parmar restructuring list was fully circulated and executed.
Furthermore, because seniority and pay fixation errors create a recurring
financial disadvantage month after month, it constitutes a continuous cause
of action. Since the applicant immediately filed representations and
approached this Tribunal within weeks of the final rejection order dated
15.09.2020, there is no delay or laches on his part.
6. We have carefully evaluated the competitive submissions of both the
learned counsels, examined the detailed text documents on record, and
analyzed the statutory provisions governing the cadre.
7. It can be seen that the applicant has completely failed to establish a viable
claim. For the Vacancy Year 2003-04, the statutory cutoff date for
determining the parameters of eligibility was 01.01.2003. On that day, the
applicant did not possess the mandatory prerequisite qualification of having
cleared the departmental examination. An official who fails to clear a
mandatory qualifying examination cannot claim parity with qualified peers or
demand entry into a selection pool for which he lacked the benchmark
criteria.
7. 1 The controversy, therefore, is not whether the applicant had sufficient
service in the feeder cadre. The principal question is whether,
notwithstanding his failure to qualify the departmental examination in 2003,
he can claim seniority in the promotional cadre with reference to vacancies
against which he did not fulfil the prescribed eligibility conditions on the
relevant crucial dates.
2026.11.04
PRATIK VYAS
15:02:56+05'30'

:: 9 :: OA No. 427/2020

7.2 In service jurisprudence, the determination of eligibility for promotion
must be undertaken with reference to the applicable Recruitment Rules and
the instructions governing the relevant selection or promotion process.
Length of service in the feeder cadre, by itself, does not necessarily confer a
right to promotion or to seniority in the promotional cadre from an earlier
date. The employee must also satisfy the other conditions prescribed under
the applicable rules.
7.3 In the present case, the Recruitment Rules dated 21.12.2004 were
amended by the Recruitment (Amendment) Rules, 2005, with retrospective
effect from 21.12.2004. Under the amended provision, qualifying the
departmental examination was prescribed as a condition for promotion to the
post of Income Tax Officer, in addition to the requisite regular service in the
feeder grade. The respondents have explained that, for the vacancy year
2003-04, the DPC was convened on 02.03.2005 and that the eligibility of
officials was required to be determined with reference to the applicable rules
and the prescribed crucial date. Their specific case is that the crucial date was
01.01.2003 and that, on that date, the applicant had not qualified the
departmental examination, we are in agreement with the said submission of
the respondents.
7.4 The applicant has not disputed the fact that he did not qualify the
examination conducted in 2003. Nor has he established that he had acquired
the prescribed examination qualification on the crucial date applicable to the
vacancy year 2003-04. In these circumstances, his claim to be treated as
eligible for promotion against that vacancy year cannot be accepted merely
because he subsequently qualified the examination in 2006.
8. The applicant also contended that the department failed to conduct
examinations in 2004 and 2005 and that the resulting loss of opportunity
should not operate to his disadvantage. We appreciate the basis of this
grievance.
2026.11.04
PRATIK VYAS
15:02:56+05'30'

:: 10 :: OA No. 427/2020

However, the question before us is whether such non-conduct of
examinations, by itself, entitles the applicant to be treated as having qualified
an examination which he had not in fact passed, or to be assigned seniority
from a date preceding his acquisition of the prescribed qualification.
8.1 In this regard, we find merit in the respondents' reliance upon Rule 14 of
the Rules for Departmental Examination for Income Tax Officers, 2004. The
said Rule expressly addresses delay in conducting examinations or declaring
results and provides that such delay does not create a rightful claim to be
deemed eligible for promotion as on 1 January of the relevant vacancy year,
irrespective of when the examination is conducted or its result declared.
8.2 Therefore, in the face of this specific provision, the applicant cannot
claim automatic retrospective eligibility merely because examinations were
not held during 2004 and 2005. It is also material that the applicant acquired
the prescribed examination qualification only in April 2007 and was
promoted thereafter. The respondents have assigned his seniority with
reference to his promotion in May 2007. The applicant has not demonstrated
from the material placed before us that the applicable rules require his
seniority to be antedated to the vacancy years claimed by him.
8.3 We, therefore, find that the applicant has failed to establish an
enforceable right to retrospective seniority from the year 2003 or to
automatic consideration for promotion against the vacancy years 2004-05
and 2005-06.
9. The applicant’s reliance on the decision of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in
Jagannath Achyut Karandikar (supra) is structurally misplaced. In that case,
the relevant rules provided that an official would lose his existing seniority if
he failed to pass the examination within a defined time bound structure,
provided the state regularized the exam cycle annually. The Apex Court
stepped in to prevent a punitive loss of seniority where the state defaulted on
its exam cycle.
2026.11.04
PRATIK VYAS
15:02:56+05'30'

:: 11 :: OA No. 427/2020

In the present case, the applicant is not facing a punitive reduction of
existing seniority; rather, he is seeking an affirmative, retrospective
advancement to a higher regular post from a backdate when he did not hold
the statutory qualifications.
9.1 Further, the applicants reliance on order of co-ordinate Benches of this
Tribunal in Sanjeev Kumar Meena (supra) and Ashwani Kumar Singh (supra)
is also misplaced as the said orders were passed under distinct, localized
factual environments involving different regional dynamics, and they cannot
dilute the express operation of Rule 14 of the Departmental Examination
Rules and the retrospective regularizations implemented across the Gujarat.
Therefore, we are of the considered opinion that the impugned speaking
order dated 15.09.2020 passed by the Respondent No. 3 is a well-reasoned
order that is fully aligned with the applicable recruitment rules and DoPT
instructions. The applicant has failed to establish any violation of his legal or
fundamental rights.
10. In view of the discussions made herein above, the present Original
Application is devoid of merit and accordingly, the same is dismissed.
Pending MAs, if any, shall also stand dispose of. No costs.

Sanjiv Kumar Jayesh V Bhairavia
Member (A) Member(J)



/pratik/

2026.11.04
PRATIK VYAS
15:02:56+05'30'