SADDAM HUSSAIN vs NARAYAN B WAGH AND ANR
- Court
- Karnataka High Court
- 1 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:11493
MFA No. 200973 of 2024
CNR: KAHC030012262024
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
KALABURAGI BENCH
TH
DATED THIS THE 17 DAY OF OCTOBER, 2026
BEFORE
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE BRUNGESH M
MISCL. FIRST APPEAL NO.200973 OF 2024 (MV-I)
BETWEEN:
SADDAM HUSSAIN S/O ABDUL WALIKAR,
AGE: 29 YEARS, OCC: PVT. SERVICE,
R/O. KUDAL SANGAM,
NOW AT VENKATESH NAGAR,
VIJAYAPURA,
TQ. AND DIST. VIJAYAPURA-586 101.
…APPELLANT
(BY SRI. G.G. CHAGASHETTI, SRI. I.R. BIRADAR AND
SRI. L.T. PUJARI, ADVOCATES)
AND:
1. NARAYAN B. WAGH,
AGE: 41 YEARS, OCC: SERVICE,
R/O. ADAT BAZAR, KALADAGI,
TQ. AND DIST. BAGALKOT-587 101.
2. THE MANAGER,
NATIONAL INSURANCE CO. LTD.,
S.S. ROAD, VIJAYAPURA-586 101.
…RESPONDENTS
(BY SRI. SHARANABASAPPA M. PATIL, ADVOCATE FOR R2;
V/O DATED 22.10.2024, NOTICE TO R1 IS DISPENSED WITH)
Digitally signed by
BASALINGAPPA S
D
Location: HIGH
COURT OF
KARNATAKA
- 2 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:11493
MFA No. 200973 of 2024
CNR: KAHC030012262024
THIS MFA IS FILED U/S. 173(1) OF MV ACT, PRAYING TO
ALLOW THIS APPEAL AND TO MODIFY THE JUDGEMENT AND
AWARD DATED 19.04.2023 PASSED BY THE II ADDL. DISTRICT
AND SESSIONS JUDGE AND MEMBER MACT-III VIJAYAPUR IN
MVC NO.934/2017 BY AWARDING COMPENSATION AS
CLAIMED BY THE APPELLANT IN THE CLAIM PETITION, WITH
COST.
THIS APPEAL, COMING ON FOR FURTHER HEARING, THIS
DAY, JUDGMENT WAS DELIVERED THEREIN AS UNDER:
CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE BRUNGESH M
ORAL JUDGMENT
This appeal is filed by the appellant-Saddam Hussain,
questioning the correctness and legality of the judgment
th
dated 19 April, 2023, passed by the II Additional District
and Sessions Judge and Member, M.A.C.T. No.III,
Vijayapura, in MVC No.934 of 2017.
2. The present appellant, Saddam Hussain, was
the petitioner, whereas the present respondents, Narayan
- 3 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:11493
MFA No. 200973 of 2024
CNR: KAHC030012262024
and National Insurance Company, were respondents Nos.
1 and 2, respectively, before the Tribunal.
3. For the sake of convenience and clarity, the
parties are referred to as per their ranks before the
Tribunal.
4. The facts leading up to this appeal, in a
nutshell, are as follows:
(i) The petitioner, Saddam Hussain, filed MVC No.
934 of 2017 before the II Additional District and Sessions
Judge and Member, M.A.C.T. No.3, Vijayapura (hereinafter
referred to as the “Tribunal” for brevity), claiming
compensation of Rs.50,90,000/- for the injuries
sustained by him in the road traffic accident that occurred
th
on 16 January, 2017.
(ii) According to the petitioner, Saddam Hussain,
th
on 16 January 2017, at about 9 p.m., he was riding
pillion on a motorcycle bearing registration No.KA-29-Y-
9208. The petitioner contends that the rider was riding the
- 4 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:11493
MFA No. 200973 of 2024
CNR: KAHC030012262024
motorcycle slowly and cautiously on the extreme left side
of the Badami–Banashankari Road near Banashankari
Nagar. When they were so proceeding, a motorcycle
bearing registration No.KA-03-HN/4998 (hereinafter
referred to as the “offending vehicle”) came from the
opposite direction at high speed and was ridden in a rash
and negligent manner. Its rider lost control, came onto the
wrong side of the road and caused the accident. As a
result, the petitioner was thrown to the ground and
sustained grievous injuries.
(iii) The petitioner further contends that
immediately after the accident, he was shifted to
Government Hospital, Badami, and thereafter to Kerudi
Hospital, Bagalkot, where he took treatment as an
inpatient. He spent more than Rs.3,00,000/- towards
medical treatment. Prior to the accident, he was hale and
healthy, aged about 22 years, doing skilled work in a
private company and earning Rs.15,000/- per month. He
was also earning Rs.4,00,000/- per year from
- 5 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:11493
MFA No. 200973 of 2024
CNR: KAHC030012262024
agricultural work. The petitioner contends that he
sustained permanent physical impairment in the accident
and thereby lost his income. It is his specific contention
that the accident occurred solely due to the rash and
negligent riding of the offending vehicle by its rider. On
these and other formal grounds, the petitioner filed MVC
No.934 of 2017 seeking compensation.
5. After presentation of the petition, the same was
registered and notices were issued to respondents Nos.1
and 2 by the Tribunal. Respondent No.1, Narayan, entered
appearance and filed his written statement, denying all the
material allegations made in the claim petition. He denied
the age, occupation and income of the petitioner, as well
as the nature of the injuries alleged to have been
sustained in the accident. He further contended that at the
time of the alleged accident, the offending vehicle was
insured under a policy issued by respondent No.2.
Therefore, if the Tribunal found that the petitioner was
entitled to compensation, respondent No.2, National
- 6 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:11493
MFA No. 200973 of 2024
CNR: KAHC030012262024
Insurance Company, was liable to satisfy the award. On
these and other formal grounds, respondent No.1,
Narayan, prayed for dismissal of the petition.
6. Respondent No.2, National Insurance Company,
filed a separate written statement contending that the
accident did not occur due to the rash and negligent riding
of the offending motorcycle by its rider. According to
respondent No.2, the rider of the motorcycle on which the
petitioner was riding pillion was solely responsible for the
accident. On these and other formal grounds, respondent
No.2 prayed for dismissal of the petition.
7. After completion of the pleadings, the Tribunal
framed four issues for its consideration.
8. Thereafter, the learned Tribunal afforded
reasonable opportunities to the parties to adduce their
evidence. The petitioner, Saddam Hussain, examined
himself as PW1. He also examined Kiran Balaganur as PW2
and Dr. Siddagondappa as PW3. The petitioner got marked
- 7 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:11493
MFA No. 200973 of 2024
CNR: KAHC030012262024
17 documents as Exs. P1 to P17. Per contra, the
respondents, Narayana and National Insurance Company,
did not adduce any oral evidence. Nevertheless, the
insurance company got marked the insurance policy as
Ex.R1.
9. After the closure of the evidence, the Tribunal
heard the arguments and passed the impugned judgment
th
dated 19 April, 2023. The Tribunal awarded
compensation of Rs.2,30,000/- together with interest at
the rate of 7.5% per annum from the date of the petition
till realization. Further, the learned Tribunal fastened the
liability to satisfy the award on respondent No.2, National
Insurance Company. Aggrieved by the said award, the
petitioner, Saddam Hussain, filed this appeal, principally
questioning the adequacy of the compensation.
10. The learned counsel for the petitioner
contended that the judgment and award passed by the
learned Tribunal are illegal and erroneous in law, besides
- 8 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:11493
MFA No. 200973 of 2024
CNR: KAHC030012262024
being based on non-consideration of material documentary
evidence brought on record. Consequently, the judgment
and award require modification by enhancing the
compensation. In the accident, the petitioner, Saddam
Hussain, sustained five grievous injuries as reflected in the
wound certificate, Ex.P12. Nevertheless, the Tribunal
awarded inadequate compensation, which requires
enhancement.
11. The learned advocate for the petitioner further
contended that the salary certificate, Ex.P11, shows that
the petitioner was earning a salary of Rs.15,000/- per
month. However, the Tribunal assessed his income on a
notional basis, contrary to Ex.P11. Consequently,
according to the learned advocate for the petitioner, the
impugned judgment and award require interference by this
Court.
12. The learned advocate for the appellant also
contended that the Tribunal awarded inadequate
- 9 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:11493
MFA No. 200973 of 2024
CNR: KAHC030012262024
compensation towards pain and suffering, loss of future
income and other heads. Therefore, the impugned
judgment requires modification. The learned counsel
further contended that the amounts awarded under other
heads are also on the lower side and require interference
by this Court. On these and other formal grounds, the
learned advocate for the petitioner prayed for suitable
enhancement of compensation.
13. Per contra, Sri Sharanabasappa M. Patil,
learned advocate for the insurance company, sought to
justify the award passed by the learned Tribunal.
14. Heard the arguments advanced by the learned
advocates. The trial court record has been secured and the
entire record has been perused.
15. In view of the rival contentions and the
materials available on record, the points that arise for
consideration of this Court are as follows:
- 10 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:11493
MFA No. 200973 of 2024
CNR: KAHC030012262024
1. Whether interference by this
Court is necessary?
2. Whether the petitioner is entitled
to enhanced compensation?
3. What order?
16. Firstly, this Court proceeds to discuss the
medical evidence available on record. The reason for the
same is as follows.
17. The learned advocate for the petitioner
contended that the doctor, PW3, assessed the permanent
physical impairment of the petitioner at 22% to 24%.
However, without assigning any reason, the Tribunal
reassessed his whole-body disability at 4%. According to
the learned advocate for the petitioner, this resulted in the
award of inadequate compensation. The learned counsel
further contended that the petitioner, Saddam Hussain,
sustained five fracture injuries and, therefore, the learned
Tribunal ought to have assessed his whole-body disability
- 11 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:11493
MFA No. 200973 of 2024
CNR: KAHC030012262024
at 20%. Consequently, the impugned judgment requires
interference by this Court.
18. Per contra, Sri Sharanabasappa M. Patil,
learned advocate for the insurance company, contended
that although the petitioner sustained five fracture
injuries, all the fractures have united and the petitioner
has completely recovered. Therefore, the Tribunal
correctly assessed his whole-body disability at 4%, and
the impugned judgment does not require interference by
this Court. In view of these rival contentions, this Court
proceeds to discuss the medical evidence available on
record.
19. The record shows that the petitioner examined
Dr. Siddagondappa Havinal as PW3. PW3 filed his affidavit
in lieu of examination-in-chief, supporting the case of the
petitioner. In paragraph No.1 of his affidavit, the doctor
narrated, in chronological order, the events that led the
petitioner to undergo treatment. Since the occurrence of
- 12 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:11493
MFA No. 200973 of 2024
CNR: KAHC030012262024
the accident, the involvement of the offending vehicle and
the injuries sustained by the petitioner are not in dispute,
there is no necessity to discuss those facts narrated by the
doctor. The insurance company has not filed any separate
appeal or cross-objections questioning the correctness of
the judgment of the learned Tribunal. Therefore, the
aforesaid facts narrated by the doctor do not require
further discussion.
st
20. Further, PW3 stated that on 21 February,
2019, the petitioner appeared before him for assessment
of disability. Under the caption “Examination of affected
part—left lower limb”, the doctor recorded the following:
“1. Old healed operated scar mark over
the left distal part of the thigh,
measuring about 1.5 cm on either
side.
2. Old healed scar mark over the left
proximal part of the thigh, measuring
about 5 cm.
3. On palpation, local tenderness at the
operated site, with restricted range of
movements and pain at the terminal
- 13 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:11493
MFA No. 200973 of 2024
CNR: KAHC030012262024
movements of the left hip and knee
joint.”
21. Further, under the caption “Stability
component”, PW3 has specifically recorded that the
petitioner experiences difficulty in squatting, sitting cross-
legged, kneeling, standing on the affected limb for a
longer duration and walking on a sloping surface. Each
component constitutes 3% permanent disability. According
to the doctor, these functional limitations adversely affect
the petitioner’s ability to perform several ordinary
activities of daily living.
22. Taking into consideration the aforesaid
difficulties and the resulting functional restrictions, the
disability attributable to the stability component works out
to 15%. It is true that the doctor has not expressly stated
that the petitioner has sustained 15% disability under the
stability component. However, what assumes significance
is that, under this caption, the doctor has identified
- 14 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:11493
MFA No. 200973 of 2024
CNR: KAHC030012262024
difficulties in performing five different activities of daily
living involving the lower limb. Further, the doctor has
stated that each component constitutes 3% disability.
Therefore, the disability attributable to these five
functional limitations works out to 15%.
23. Furthermore, under the caption “Mobility
component”, PW3 has recorded that the impairment of
muscle power, with moderate wasting of the thigh muscles
on the right side compared to the left side, constitutes
about 6% disability.
24. Before proceeding to appreciate and analyse
the evidence of the doctor, it would be apposite to advert
to and examine the relevant Guidelines and the Gazette
Notification issued by the Ministry of Social Justice and
Empowerment, Government of India, framed pursuant to
the recommendations of the Committee constituted under
the Chairmanship of the Director General of Health
Services (DGHS), Government of India, bearing
- 15 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:11493
MFA No. 200973 of 2024
CNR: KAHC030012262024
Registration No.DL33004/99 (Extraordinary) Part II,
Sec.1, June 13, 2001, Bon-Hooghly, Kolkata .
25. It is significant to note that the aforesaid
guidelines make it clear that a person, whether male or
female, is required to perform nine different activities,
referred to as coordinated activities, by using the lower
limb . The said nine coordinated activities are as follows:
i. Ability to walk on a plain surface;
ii. Ability to walk on a slope;
iii. Ability to climb steps;
iv. Ability to stand on both legs;
v. Ability to stand on the affected leg;
vi. Ability to squat;
vii. Ability to sit cross-legged;
viii. Ability to sit on the knees; and
ix. Ability to turn.
26. Likewise, the aforesaid guidelines make it clear
that a person, whether male or female, is required to
perform ten different activities, referred to as coordinated
- 16 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:11493
MFA No. 200973 of 2024
CNR: KAHC030012262024
activities, by using the upper limb . The said ten activities
are as follows:
i. Lifting an object over the head and placing it at the
same place;
ii. Touching the nose with the end of the extremity;
iii. Eating in the Indian style;
iv. Combing and plaiting;
v. Putting on a shirt/kurta;
vi. Holding a glass of water;
vii. Drinking a glass of water;
viii. Buttoning;
ix. Tying the nara of a dhoti; and
x. Writing.
27. The reason why these activities are described
as “coordinated activities” requires to be understood. As
stated above, both the upper and lower limbs of a human
being consist of three joints. The upper limb comprises the
shoulder, elbow and wrist joints, whereas, the lower limb
comprises the hip, knee and ankle-foot joints. It is only
when there is proper coordination or cooperation among
- 17 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:11493
MFA No. 200973 of 2024
CNR: KAHC030012262024
these three joints that person is able to perform the
aforesaid activities. Hence, such activities are
appropriately referred to as “coordinated activities” OR
activities of daily living.
28. Further, the said parameters/guidelines make it
clear that only when a person is totally unable to perform
any of the aforesaid coordinated activities, the disability
attributable to that activity work out to 10%. However, the
percentage of disability may vary, being 5%, 6%, 4% or
3%, as the case may be, depending upon the severity of
the difficulty or inability. In this context, it is relevant to
recall that the doctor has assessed the permanent
disability attributable to each activity under the stability
component at 3%. This means that the petitioner, Saddam
Hussain, is not totally unable to perform those activities
but experiences difficulty while performing them.
Therefore, the doctor has assessed the disability at 3% for
each activity. These facts are sufficient to conclude that,
out of the aforesaid nine coordinated activities, the
- 18 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:11493
MFA No. 200973 of 2024
CNR: KAHC030012262024
petitioner experiences difficulty in performing five
activities and cannot perform them as comfortably as he
could before the accident.
29. Further, the aforesaid parameters indicate that
the normal muscle strength of a healthy person is Grade
5. If it is reduced to Grade 4, the corresponding disability
of the particular joint would be 20%. Anatomically, the
upper limb has three principal joints, namely, the
shoulder, elbow and wrist joints. Likewise, the lower limb
has three principal joints, namely, the hip, knee and
ankle-foot joints. Having regard to this anatomical
structure, the guidelines provide that when the muscle
strength of an injured person is reduced from the normal
Grade 5 to Grade 4, the disability attributable to the
particular joint would be 20%. Since each limb comprises
three principal joints, the said 20% is to be multiplied by
0.30, which works out to 6%. This represents the
percentage of disability attributable to the loss of muscle
strength. The PW3 has followed the same procedure while
- 19 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:11493
MFA No. 200973 of 2024
CNR: KAHC030012262024
assessing the muscle power or muscle strength of the
petitioner, Saddam Hussain.
30. Further, the aforesaid guidelines indicate that,
to assess permanent physical impairment, the doctor has
to take the healthy limb of the injured person as the
benchmark and then assess the disability of the affected
limb. In the present case, the petitioner has sustained
impairment of his left lower limb. The doctor has taken the
petitioner’s right lower limb as the benchmark and
proceeded to assess the disability of the left lower limb.
Therefore, the procedure followed by PW3 is in conformity
with the guidelines.
31. PW3, the doctor, has stated that the
movements of the petitioner’s left hip and knee joints are
painful and restricted. To substantiate this observation,
the doctor has furnished comparative measurements
indicating the normal range of movement of the
- 20 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:11493
MFA No. 200973 of 2024
CNR: KAHC030012262024
petitioner’s right hip joint and the corresponding range of
movement of his left hip joint.
32. In this regard, PW3 has stated that the normal
range of flexion of the petitioner’s right hip joint is
approximately 125 degrees, whereas the flexion of his left
hip joint is restricted to 100 degrees. Similarly, the normal
range of extension of the petitioner’s right hip joint is
approximately 15 degrees, whereas the extension of his
left hip joint is restricted to 10 degrees.
33. PW3 has further stated that the normal range of
abduction of the petitioner’s right hip joint is
approximately 30 degrees, whereas the abduction of his
left hip joint is restricted to 25 degrees.
34. Likewise, the doctor has stated that the
adduction of the petitioner’s right hip joint is
approximately 45 degrees, whereas the adduction of his
left hip joint is restricted to 20 degrees. Further, PW3 has
stated that the internal and external rotation of the
- 21 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:11493
MFA No. 200973 of 2024
CNR: KAHC030012262024
petitioner’s right hip joint measure 40 degrees each,
whereas the corresponding movements of his left hip joint
are restricted to 30 degrees each.
35. As regards the petitioner’s left knee joint, PW3
has stated that the normal range of flexion is
approximately 135 degrees, whereas the flexion of the
petitioner’s left knee joint is restricted to 120 degrees.
36. At this juncture, for a proper appreciation of the
aforesaid medical evidence, it is necessary to understand
the meaning of the expressions “flexion”, “extension”,
“abduction” and “adduction”, which have been employed
by PW3 while describing the movements of the petitioner’s
affected hip and knee joints.
37. In medical terminology, flexion refers to a
bending movement at a joint whereby the angle between
the adjoining parts of the body is generally reduced. In the
context of the hip joint, flexion refers to the forward
movement of the thigh towards the abdomen. In the
- 22 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:11493
MFA No. 200973 of 2024
CNR: KAHC030012262024
context of the knee joint, it refers to bending the knee so
that the lower leg moves towards the back of the thigh.
38. Extension, on the other hand, refers to a
straightening movement at a joint whereby the angle
between the adjoining parts of the body is generally
increased. In relation to the hip joint , extension refers
to the backward movement of the thigh from its neutral
position.
39. Abduction refers to the movement of a limb
away from the midline of the body. In the context of the
hip joint, it means moving the thigh sideways away from
the opposite lower limb.
40. Adduction refers to the movement of a limb
towards the midline of the body. In relation to the hip
joint, it means bringing the thigh inward towards the
opposite lower limb.
41. Thus, the aforesaid medical expressions denote
different directions of movement of a joint. The degree of
- 23 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:11493
MFA No. 200973 of 2024
CNR: KAHC030012262024
restriction in such movements provides relevant clinical
information regarding the functional condition of the
affected limb.
42. For the sake of clarity, the comparative
measurements furnished by PW3 may be set out as
follows:
Percentage
loss of
movement
Normal range
stated by
PW3
Range in the
affected left
lower limb
Joint and
movement
Hip—flexion 125° 100° 20%
Hip— 15° 10° 33.33%
extension
Hip— 30° 25° 16.67%
abduction
Hip— 45° 20° 55.56%
adduction
Hip—internal 45° 30° 25%
rotation
Hip—external 40° 30° 25%
rotation
Knee—flexion 135° 120° 11.11%
43. A careful examination of the aforesaid
comparative measurements makes it evident that the
- 24 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:11493
MFA No. 200973 of 2024
CNR: KAHC030012262024
petitioner has suffered a noticeable reduction in the range
of several movements of his left hip joint, besides
restriction in the flexion of his left knee joint.
44. In particular, the flexion of the left hip joint has
been reduced from 125° to 100°, while the flexion of the
left knee joint has been reduced from 135° to 120°. The
other movements of the left hip joint, namely, extension,
abduction, adduction, internal rotation and external
rotation, have also been found to be restricted to varying
degrees. These findings indicate that the petitioner is
unable to perform the aforesaid joint movements to the
extent ordinarily expected of an unaffected lower limb.
45. These restrictions assume further significance
when considered along with the pain experienced during
movement, the tenderness noticed over the hip and knee
joints, and the difficulties reported in squatting, kneeling,
sitting cross-legged, standing for prolonged periods and
walking on a sloping surface.
- 25 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:11493
MFA No. 200973 of 2024
CNR: KAHC030012262024
46. Further, PW3 has ultimately assessed the
disability attributable to the restriction in the range of
movement of the left hip and knee joints at 24%.
47. Apart from the aforesaid restrictions involving
the left hip joint of the petitioner-Saddam Hussain, PW3-
doctor has also noticed that the flexion of the petitioner’s
left knee joint has been reduced from 135° to 120°.
48. Flexion of the knee joint refers to the bending
movement by which the lower leg is brought towards the
back of the thigh. Restriction of this movement may cause
difficulty in squatting, kneeling, sitting cross-legged,
climbing stairs, sitting on the floor and rising from that
position. Therefore, when the restricted movements of the
left hip joint are considered together with the restricted
flexion of the left knee joint, it becomes apparent that the
petitioner, Saddam Hussain, may experience considerable
difficulty in performing activities requiring coordinated
movements of both joints.
- 26 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:11493
MFA No. 200973 of 2024
CNR: KAHC030012262024
49. It is particularly significant to note that PW3 has
not merely furnished the measurements of the restricted
joint movements. The doctor has also specifically recorded
that the petitioner experiences difficulty in squatting,
kneeling, sitting cross-legged, standing on the affected
lower limb for a prolonged period and walking on a sloping
surface. Thus, the functional difficulties described by PW3
are broadly consistent with the clinical findings relating to
the restricted movements of the petitioner’s left hip and
knee joints. These difficulties are described in the
disability certificate marked as Ex.P16.
50. Further, PW3 has recorded the presence of mild
muscular wasting of the petitioner’s left lower limb when
compared with his right lower limb. Such wasting may
indicate a reduction in muscle bulk and may be associated
with diminished muscle strength or prolonged reduced use
of the affected limb.
- 27 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:11493
MFA No. 200973 of 2024
CNR: KAHC030012262024
51. These findings assume significance. Therefore,
the medical evidence regarding restricted joint
movements, muscular wasting, pain and tenderness
requires cumulative consideration while assessing the
functional consequences of the injuries sustained by the
petitioner, Saddam Hussain.
52. It may be argued that the difficulties described
by the doctor might not, in fact, have been experienced by
the petitioner. In this regard, this Court has carefully
perused the entire cross-examination of PW3. During
cross-examination, the learned advocate for the insurance
company has put only general suggestions to the doctor.
Significantly, although PW3 has described the various
problems experienced by the petitioner-Saddam Hussain,
no suggestion has been put to him denying that the
petitioner experiences those problems. Therefore, there is
nothing on record to disbelieve the sworn testimony of
PW3 on these aspects, and his assertions remain
unchallenged. Accordingly, this Court concludes that the
- 28 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:11493
MFA No. 200973 of 2024
CNR: KAHC030012262024
medical evidence available on record is sufficient to
establish that the petitioner experiences several difficulties
affecting his day-to-day activities.
53. Nevertheless, during the cross-examination of
PW3, it was suggested that he had not treated the
petitioner-Saddam Hussain. PW3 accepted this suggestion.
The learned advocate for the insurance company has
highlighted this admission. In the considered opinion of
this Court, had the doctor’s evidence been inconsistent
with the medical aspects discussed above and the residual
consequences of the injuries, his admission that he had
not treated the petitioner could have assumed significance
while appreciating his evidence.
54. Further, the petitioner has produced the X-
ray film marked as Ex.P13 . A perusal of the said X-ray
film reveals that the petitioner sustained a fracture of the
femur, which was treated by inserting implants, and that
the implants are still in situ. These facts lend support to
- 29 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:11493
MFA No. 200973 of 2024
CNR: KAHC030012262024
the evidence given by the doctor. The petitioner has also
produced another X-ray film, marked as Ex.P17, which
supports the doctor’s evidence. Therefore, this Court finds
no reason to disbelieve the evidence of PW3 and accepts
his assessment of the petitioner’s permanent physical
disability of the affected limb at 22% to 24%.
55. The record shows that the Tribunal has not
assigned any reason for declining to accept the medical
evidence. However, at pages 16 and 17 of the impugned
judgment, the Tribunal has merely stated that the
petitioner has sustained 4% disability to the whole body.
In the considered opinion of this Court, this conclusion
cannot be accepted and requires interference.
56. In the preceding paragraphs of this judgment,
this Court has discussed the various difficulties
experienced by the petitioner and their residual
consequences. Having regard to the nature of the injuries
and the difficulties experienced by the petitioner, this
- 30 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:11493
MFA No. 200973 of 2024
CNR: KAHC030012262024
Court is of the considered opinion that reassessing his
permanent physical disability to the whole body at 10%
would meet the ends of justice.
57. The learned advocate for the petitioner requests
this Court to award future prospects.
58. Per contra , the learned advocate for the
insurance company has strongly opposed the request. He
contends that it is the consistent practice of the Tribunals
and Courts to award future prospects only when the
injured claimant sustains at least 30% disability to the
whole body.
59. While considering this issue on earlier
occasions, this Court had undertaken a thorough search
but did not come across any judgment of the Hon’ble
Supreme Court or any High Court, or any statutory
provision, prescribing such a threshold. The aforesaid
guidelines also do not prescribe a threshold of 30%
disability. In other words, this Court has not come across
- 31 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:11493
MFA No. 200973 of 2024
CNR: KAHC030012262024
any authority holding that 30% disability to the whole
body is a prerequisite for awarding future prospects.
Therefore, this Court is of the opinion that the petitioner,
Saddam Hussain, is entitled to an addition towards future
prospects. However, two Division Bench judgments of this
Court specifically hold that an injured claimant is not
entitled to interest on the amount awarded towards future
prospects.
60. Further, the Tribunal has correctly assessed the
petitioner’s notional income at Rs.10,250/- per month,
having regard to the date of the accident namely
16.01.2017. The record shows that the petitioner was
aged about 22 years on the date of the accident.
According to the petitioner, before the accident, he was
doing skilled work in a private company and earning
Rs.15,000/- per month, besides earning Rs.4,00,000/- per
annum from agricultural work. However, he has not
produced any material to establish his income. Therefore,
- 32 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:11493
MFA No. 200973 of 2024
CNR: KAHC030012262024
the Tribunal has rightly assessed his income on a notional
basis.
61. Since the petitioner was self-employed and
below 40 years of age on the date of the accident, he is
entitled to an addition of 40% of the assessed income
towards future prospects, in terms of the law declared in
National Insurance Co. Ltd., vs. Pranay Sethi reported
in 2017 (16) SCC 680 . 40% of Rs.10,250/- works out to
Rs.4,100/- on adding this amount, the monthly income
works out to Rs.14,350/-. Accordingly, the annual income
works out to Rs.14,350/- × 12 = Rs.1,72,200/-. Having
regard to the petitioner’s age, the applicable multiplier is
18.
62. As discussed above, his permanent physical
disability to the whole body is assessed at 10%.
Therefore, the compensation payable under the
head of loss of future income on account of permanent
- 33 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:11493
MFA No. 200973 of 2024
CNR: KAHC030012262024
disability works out to Rs.14,350 × 12 × 18 × 10% =
Rs.3,09,960/-.
63. Therefore, the petitioner is entitled to
Rs.3,09,960/- towards loss of future income on account of
permanent physical impairment. Out of this amount,
Rs.88,560/- (Rs.4,100/- x 12x 18x 10%) represents the
addition towards future prospects. The petitioner is not
entitled to interest on the said amount of Rs.88,560/-.
64. The Tribunal has awarded Rs.20,000/- towards
pain and suffering and the same is maintained.
65. The Tribunal after considering the medical bills
and other incidental expenses has awarded Rs.91,000/-.
The petitioner-Saddam Hussain has not produced any
further material to establish that he incurred expenses
exceeding the amount awarded by the Tribunal. Therefore,
no enhancement is warranted under this head and the
award of Rs.91,000/- is maintained.
- 34 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:11493
MFA No. 200973 of 2024
CNR: KAHC030012262024
66. The Tribunal has awarded Rs.10,250/- towards
loss of income during the laid-up period. The petitioner
underwent inpatient treatment for 8 days. Having regard
to the nature of the injuries, he could not have resumed
his normal activities immediately after discharge and
would have required rest for two months. Accordingly,
compensation under this head is enhanced to Rs.20,500/-.
67. The Tribunal has awarded Rs.10,000/- towards
conveyance, attendant charges, food and nourishment and
Rs.10,000/- towards loss of amenities and comforts. Since
the petitioner underwent inpatient treatment for 8 days,
his family members would have travelled to the hospital
and attended to him, incurring conveyance expenses. The
petitioner would also have required assistance and a
nutritious diet. Having regard to these circumstances and
the continuing difficulties arising from the injuries,
compensation towards conveyance, attendant charges,
food and nourishment is enhanced to Rs.25,000/- and
- 35 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:11493
MFA No. 200973 of 2024
CNR: KAHC030012262024
compensation towards loss of amenities and comforts is
enhanced to Rs.25,000/-.
68. Accordingly, the compensation is reassessed as
follows:
Compensation
awarded by
this Court
Sl.
Heads Compensation
awarded by
the Tribunal
No
1. Loss of future income
on account of
permanent physical
impairment, including
future prospects
Rs.88,560/- Rs.3,09,960/-
2. Pain and suffering Rs.20,000/- Rs.20,000/-
3. Medical and other Rs.91,000/- Rs.91,000/-
incidental expenses
4. Loss of income during Rs.10,250/- Rs.20,500/-
the laid-up period
5. Loss of amenities and Rs.10,000/- Rs.25,000/-
comforts
6. Conveyance, attendant
charges and
nourishment
Rs.10,000/- Rs.25,000/-
Total Rs.2,29,810 Rs.4,91,460/-
Rounded off to Rs.2,30,000/- Rs.4,91,500/-
Difference amount Rs.2,61,500/-
- 36 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:11493
MFA No. 200973 of 2024
CNR: KAHC030012262024
69. With these observations, point Nos.1 and 2 are
answered accordingly and this Court proceeds to pass the
following:
ORDER
i. The appeal is allowed in part.
ii. The judgment and award passed by
Tribunal in MVC No.934/2017 is modified
to the aforesaid extent.
iii. The appellant/petitioner shall be entitled
to total compensation of Rs.4,91,500/-
as against Rs.2,30,000/-, awarded by
the Tribunal with interest at the rate of
6% per annum from the date of claim
petition till its realization.
iv. The petitioner is not entitled to interest
on Rs.88,560/- awarded towards future
prospects.
- 37 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:11493
MFA No. 200973 of 2024
CNR: KAHC030012262024
v. The petitioner is also not entitled to
interest on the enhanced compensation
for the period of 204 days’ delay in
filing the appeal.
vi. The respondent No.2 - Insurance
Company is directed to deposit the
enhanced compensation within six
weeks from receipt of certified copy of
this judgment.
vii. The deposit and release of the enhanced
compensation shall be as per the order
of the Tribunal.
Sd/-
(BRUNGESH M)
JUDGE
BL,SMP
List No.: 1 Sl No.: 20
CT: AK