Surjit Singh vs Sandeep Arora And Others

Court
Punjab and Haryana High Court

CR-7721-2023 (O&M) -:1:-
IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA
AT CHANDIGARH
CR-7721-2023 (O&M)
Date of Decision: 16.11.2026
Surjit Singh
… Petitioner
Versus
Sandeep Arora and Others
... Respondents
-.-
CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE VIRINDER AGGARWAL
Present:- Mr. Varun Goyal, Advocate
for the petitioner.
Mr. Rajiv Joshi, Advocate and
Ms. Ankita, Advocate
for respondent No.1.
-.-
VIRINDER AGGARWAL , J . (Oral)
1. The present revision petition has been preferred under Article
227 of the Constitution of India, invoking the supervisory jurisdiction of
this Court, assailing the order dated 16.11.2023 (Annexure P-9) passed by
the Civil Judge (Junior Division), Jalandhar, whereby the application filed
by the petitioner-plaintiff under Order VI Rule 17 CPC, seeking
amendment of the plaint in Civil Suit No. CS No.5811 of 2018, titled
Surjit Singh vs. Sandeep Arora and Others, was dismissed. The petitioner
seeks setting aside of the impugned order, permission to carry out the
proposed amendment in the plaint and a stay of further proceedings in the
aforesaid suit during the pendency of the present petition before this Court.
GAURAV SOROT
2026.11.16 16:24
I attest to the accuracy and integrity
of this document

CR-7721-2023 (O&M) -:2:-
2. Briefly stated, the petitioner claims ownership and possession
of ancestral property bearing House No. 1189, Rama Mandi, Jalandhar,
and instituted a suit for permanent injunction. During its pendency, he was
allegedly dispossessed and the property demolished by the defendants with
police assistance. Consequently, he sought amendment of the plaint under
Order VI Rule 17 CPC to incorporate these subsequent events and seek
mandatory injunction for restoration of possession, contending that the
proposed amendments neither altered the nature of the suit nor introduced
a fresh cause of action.
3. Learned counsel for the petitioner contended that the Trial
Court had adopted an unduly technical and restrictive approach in
declining the amendment sought under Order VI Rule 17 CPC, despite the
fact that the proposed amendments were necessitated by subsequent events
occurring during the pendency of the suit. It was submitted that the
petitioner had initially instituted the suit for permanent injunction while
asserting his possession over the suit property; however, his subsequent
forcible dispossession and demolition of the structure during the pendency
of the proceedings gave rise to the necessity of incorporating the
consequential relief of mandatory injunction for restoration of possession.
The proposed amendments, therefore, neither introduced an independent
cause of action nor altered the fundamental nature of the suit, but merely
sought to bring subsequent developments on record and enable the Court
to comprehensively adjudicate the real controversy between the parties.
3.1. Learned counsel further argued that the proposed amendment
was essential to avoid multiplicity of litigation, as the petitioner would
GAURAV SOROT
2026.11.16 16:24
I attest to the accuracy and integrity
of this document

CR-7721-2023 (O&M) -:3:-
otherwise be compelled to institute a separate suit founded upon the very
same subsequent events. It was contended that the defendants would suffer
no irreparable prejudice, since they would have an adequate opportunity to
file an additional written statement and contest the amended pleadings.
Reliance, in support of the aforesaid submissions, was placed upon Rajesh
Kumar Aggarwal and Others vs. K.K. Modi and Others, 2002(2) RCR
(Civil) 577; Dev Raj Dua vs. Madan Lal and Others, Law Finder Doc
ID # 1451416; Balbir Singh vs. Satnam Singh and Another, Law
Finder Doc ID # 813403; Arjun Singh and Another vs. Haryana Urban
Development Authority, Panchkula and Another, 2017(5) RCR (Civil)
249; Gurdev Singh and Others vs. Gurnam Singh and Others, Law
Finder Doc ID # 1255404; Aarti Seth and Another vs. Gopi Krishan
and Another, 2026 PHHC 73414 and Gurbir Singh Sandhu and
Another vs. Jagmohan Singh, 2016(4) Law Herald 3615 . On these
premises, learned counsel urged that the impugned order be set aside, the
proposed amendment be allowed and the petition be accepted.
4. Learned counsel for respondent No. 1, controverting the
submissions advanced on behalf of the petitioner, contended that the
proposed amendment would substantially alter the nature and character of
the suit, which was originally instituted for permanent injunction
simpliciter. It was argued that the petitioner, by seeking to incorporate a
consequential relief of mandatory injunction for restoration of possession,
was attempting to introduce an entirely new dimension to the proceedings,
involving disputed questions regarding the alleged dispossession,
demolition and identity of the property in question. Learned counsel
GAURAV SOROT
2026.11.16 16:24
I attest to the accuracy and integrity
of this document

CR-7721-2023 (O&M) -:4:-
further submitted that the proposed amendments would necessitate
additional pleadings and evidence, thereby widening the scope of the trial
and causing prejudice to the respondents. It was also contended that the
petitioner had failed to satisfactorily explain the delay in seeking the
amendment or establish that the same was bona fide and necessary for
effective adjudication of the existing dispute. Accordingly, it was urged
that the Trial Court had rightly declined the amendment and that the
impugned order warranted no interference.
5. Having heard learned counsel for the parties and, with their
able assistance, having meticulously scrutinised the paper-book, this Court
finds that the Civil Judge dismissed the application for amendment
primarily on the ground that the petitioner-applicant failed to establish
that, despite due diligence, the proposed amendments could not have been
sought before commencement of the trial. It was further observed that the
petitioner had not specified any date or period when the alleged forcible
dispossession by the defendants had taken place.
5.1. The proposed amendment also sought to introduce a material
alteration in the description and nature of the suit property by pleading the
existence of structures on its first and second floors and placing on record
a fresh site plan. Significantly, the original site plan depicted only a
ground-floor structure having a room in a dilapidated condition, whereas
the proposed site plan portrayed a three-storeyed building, without any
reference to the dilapidated room. Thus, the petitioner-applicant sought to
substitute the original description of the property and materially alter the
plea regarding its nature and possession. The suit has been pending since
GAURAV SOROT
2026.11.16 16:24
I attest to the accuracy and integrity
of this document

CR-7721-2023 (O&M) -:5:-
2018, and the application for amendment was moved at a highly belated
stage.
6. As regards the contention advanced by learned counsel for the
petitioner and reliance placed upon the judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme
Court in Rajesh Kumar Aggarwal’s case (supra), there can be no quarrel
with the settled proposition that amendments necessary for determining
the real questions in controversy ought to be permitted. However, such
discretion cannot be exercised mechanically, particularly where the
conduct of the applicant lacks bona fides. A party seeking equitable
indulgence must approach the Court with clean hands, and any attempt to
introduce amendments founded upon suppression, dishonesty or mala
fides disentitles such party to the Court’s indulgence. In the present case,
the written statement filed on behalf of defendant No. 3 is already on
record, wherein preliminary objection No. 2 specifically reads as under:-
xxxx
An ejectment petition was allowed by the court of Ms. Manjinder Kaur,
the then Rent Controller, Jalandhar vide order dated 26.8.2009 and
thereafter the revision was also filed before Punjab & Haryana High
Court, Chandigarh and ultimately the possession was handed over to
defendant no. 3 in execution proceedings by the court of Sh. Bhupinder
Mittal, CJJD, Jalandhar, copies of all the relevant documents are attached
herewith. Another case was filed by Vinod Passi son of Sh. Rajesh
Kumar for permanent injunction as portion of the property in question
was in his possession. The suit was filed by Vinod Passi against Sandeep
Singh son of defendant no. 3 and now Vinod Passi has also handed over
the vacant and peaceful possession of the said portion to the defendant
no. 3. So, in this manner it is very clear that the plaintiff is nothing to do
GAURAV SOROT
2026.11.16 16:24
I attest to the accuracy and integrity
of this document

CR-7721-2023 (O&M) -:6:-
with the property in question as he is neither owner nor in possession
over the suit property.
xxxx
6.1. A perusal of the aforesaid pleading in the written statement
filed by defendant No. 3 makes it evident that, from the inception, the
specific stand of the defendant was that the plaintiff was not in possession
of the suit property and that possession had already been taken over by the
defendants. By way of the present application, the petitioner-plaintiff has
sought to transform a suit for permanent injunction into one for mandatory
injunction at a belated stage, by introducing a vague plea of forcible
dispossession during the pendency of the suit. As rightly observed by the
Trial Court, the proposed amendment does not disclose the specific date,
month or year of the alleged dispossession of the plaintiff and his family
members. Furthermore, the petitioner seeks to materially enlarge the
description of the suit property by replacing the original plea of a ground-
floor structure comprising one dilapidated room with that of a three-
storeyed building, without depicting the said room in the revised site plan.
The proposed amendments, therefore, seek to introduce substantial and
unexplained alterations in the original pleadings, without furnishing any
cogent justification for the delay or the belated plea of dispossession. In
these circumstances, the Trial Court rightly declined the application.
Finding no illegality or material infirmity warranting interference in
exercise of the supervisory jurisdiction of this Court, the present revision
petition, being devoid of merit, is dismissed .
7. It is clarified that the observations made herein are confined to
the adjudication of the present proceedings and shall not be construed as
GAURAV SOROT
2026.11.16 16:24
I attest to the accuracy and integrity
of this document

CR-7721-2023 (O&M) -:7:-
an expression of opinion on the merits of the underlying dispute or
prejudice the rights and contentions of either party therein.
8. In view of the final disposal of the principal matter, all
pending miscellaneous applications, if any, also stand disposed of
accordingly.
( VIRINDER AGGARWAL )
16.11.2026 JUDGE
Gaurav Sorot
Whether reasoned / speaking? Yes / No
Whether reportable? Yes / No
GAURAV SOROT
2026.11.16 16:24
I attest to the accuracy and integrity
of this document