LAXMAN CHANDRAUBHAI VAGHAT vs All India Radio

Court
Central Administrative Tribunal

: 1: OA No.120/416/2023

CENTRAL ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL
AHMEDABAD BENCH

Original Application No.416 OF 2023


Reserved on: 07.08.2026
Ordered on: 01.10.2026


CORAM:

Hon’ble Mr. Jayesh V Bhairavia, Member (J)
Hon’ble Mr. Sanjiv Kumar, Member (A)

LAXMAN CHANDRUBHAI VAGHAT
Aged: 61 years (DoB being 01.06.1962)
Son of Shri Chandrubhai Vaghat
Retired: Senior Technician, AIR, Ahmedabad
& presently residing at Village: Pahadpara,
Post: Sarigam, Taluka: Umbergam.
District: Valsad
GUJARAT 396 155.
… Applicant
(By Advocate Shri M.S. Rao and Ms. Hemlata Sharma)


V/s.

1. UNION OF INDIA
(to be represented through its Secretary to the Govt. of India)
Ministry of Information & Broadcasting
Govt. of India, "A" Wing, Shastri Bhavan,
NEW DELHI 110001.

2. THE CHIEF CONTROLLER OF ACCOUNTS (CCA)
Ministry of Information & Broadcasting
Govt. of India,
Room No.703-703A
"A" Wing,
Shastri Bhavan,
NEW DELHI 110001.

3. PRASAR BHARATI
(to be represented through its Chief Executive Officer,
Prasar Bharati,
Broadcasting Corporation of India,
Copernicus Marg
NEW DELHI 110001).
2026.10.01
PRATIK VYAS
15:52:15+05'30'

: 2: OA No.120/416/2023

4. THE DIRECTOR GENERAL
All India Radio
Prasar Bharati,
Broadcasting Corporation of India,
O/o DG, AIR Hqrs.,
"Akashwani Bhawan"
Sansad Marg,
NEW DELHI 110001

5. THE DEPUTY DIRECTOR GENERAL,
All India Radio
Prasar Bharati,
Broadcasting Corporation of ]ndia,
Akashawani Bhavan,
Ashram Road,
Navrangpura,
AHMEDABAD 380 009

6. THE ADDITIONAL DIRECTOR GEENRAL
(ENGG)/WZ)
Akashvani & Door Darshan,
Prasar Bharati
Broadcasting Corporation of India
10th Floor, ASF Building,
Doordarshan Complex,
WORLI,
MUMBAI 400 030.

7. THE PAY AND ACCOUNTS OFFICER
Ministry of Information & Broadcasting,
All India Radio,
Prasar Bharati,
Broadcasting Corporation of India
st
1 Floor, New Broadcasting House,
Backbay Reclamation,
Church Gate,
MUMBAI 40020.
… Respondents
(By Advocate Ms. R.R. Patel)

ORDER

Per: Hon’ble Shri Jayesh V Bhairavia, Member (J)
1. The grievance of the applicant is that despite having retired from the
services of the respondents’ department on 31.05.2022, when he was
neither under suspension nor facing any departmental or criminal
2026.10.01
PRATIK VYAS
15:52:15+05'30'

: 3: OA No.120/416/2023

proceedings, the respondents have failed to release his full and final
pensionary and other retiral dues, including regular pension,
commutation, balance gratuity and leave encashment, and have
continued to grant him only provisional pension. The respondents have
withheld his retiral benefits and insisted upon recovery of Rs.7,74,490/-
towards alleged excess payment on account of III MACP, besides
requiring him to furnish a fresh undertaking for such recovery,
notwithstanding the applicant's earlier undertaking and the judicial
orders/directions for release of full pension and gratuity.
2. By filing the present OA under Section 19 of the Administrative
Tribunals Act, 1985, the applicant is seeking the following reliefs:-
“A. Your Lordships may be graciously pleased to call upon the
official respondents herein to place before this Hon'ble Tribunal the
entire original departmental file / noting sheet, etc., which gave rise to
the issuance of the impugned documents at Annexure-A/l to Annexure-
A/6 hereto;
B. Upon the perusal of the said files/noting sheet, etc., your Lordships
may be further graciously pleased to:-
B-1 quash and set aside the impugned (i) Order bearing No.AHM/21
(2)/Provisional Pension/LCV/2022-Admn/244 dated 04.08.2022 at
Annexure-A/l hereto, (ii) Communication bearing
No.AHM/21(LCV)/2022-S/256, dated 29.08.2022 at Annexure A/2 hereto,
(iii) Communication bearing NO.PAO/AIR/MUM/PN-Pro.
Pen/1649, dated 10.10.2022, at Annexure-A/3 hereto (iv) Communication
bearing NO.PAO/AIR/MUM/Provisional Gratuity/1651, dated
10.10.2022 at Annexure-A/4 hereto (v)
Communication bearing File No.A-11019/18/2023/GRC/559,
dated 26.04.2023 at Annexure-A/5 hereto and (vi) Communication
bearing No.AHM/21 (LCV/Pension/2022-S/61, dated 27.04.2023 at
Annexure-A/6 hereto, holding and declare the aforesaid impugned
documents and the decisions conveyed therein to be ex facie
deliberately contumacious, illegal, arbitrary, unreasonable, unfair
and contrary to ratio laid down by the Hon'ble Principal Bench's
Final Order dated 05.07.2022 in OA No.2629/2021 and also the
consequent communication bearing F.No.V-11013/07/2021-BAE,
dated 06.10.2022 issued by the Ministry of Information &
Broadcasting, GoI, New Delhi to the Chief Controller of Accounts,
Ministry of I&B, New Delhi, who in turn pleased to issue an
Office Memorandum bearing No.G-11502/Pr.AO/I&B/Court
Cases/2022-23/l018, dated 07.10.2022 to all Zonal Heads in AIR to
comply with the ruling of the Hon'ble Principal Bench in the
aforesaid OA.
B-2 Issue appropriate directions to the respondents no.4, 5, 6 & 7
herein commanding them to forthwith issue (i) regular Pension Payment
Order (PPO) to the applicant herein granting him full/final pension with
2026.10.01
PRATIK VYAS
15:52:15+05'30'

: 4: OA No.120/416/2023

interest thereon @ 18% p.a., (ii) release to the applicant herein the sum
of Rs.l,84,840/- (alongwith interest thereon w.e.f. 01.06.2022 at the rate
of 18% p.a.), (iii) release all other retiral dues as admissible under the
rules, with interest thereon @ 18% p.a. and (iv) permanently restrain
themselves, their officers, representatives, agents, etc., from seeking to
recover from the applicant herein the sum of Rs7,74,490/- being the
alleged excess amount allegedly recoverable from the applicant on
account of III MACP granted to him on 28.03.2012.
B-3 Issue further directions to all the respondents herein that in the
event of the outcome of the litigation being W.P.(C) No.9890/2019,
presently pending before the Hon'ble High Court of Delhi, being against
the interests of the applicant herein, then the competent authority in the
respondent department shall grant III MACP to the applicant herein
w.e.f. 15.01.2018 and adjust the amount of arrears of salary, arising
therefrom, against the aforesaid amount of Rs.7,74,490/-.
B-3 Issue further directions to the Chief Executive Officer, Prasar
Bharati, New Delhi to inquire as to who is/are responsible for the
continued delay in the matter of release of regular pension and other
retiral dues to the applicant even after the issuance of the instructions
issued by the Chief Controller of Accounts, MIB, New Delhi on
07.10.2022 and initiate appropriate departmental disciplinary against
the said officer/s who are found to be solely responsible for the aforesaid
delay in the matter of release of regular pension and other retiral dues to
the applicant herein.
C. grant such other and further relief/s as may be deemed fit
and proper in the peculiar facts & circumstances of the present case.”
3. Pursuant to notice issued by this Tribunal, the respondents have filed
their reply to which the applicant has also filed his rejoinder.
FACTS OF THE CASE
4. Initially, the applicant had joined the services of the
Government of India as a Technician in All India Radio at Ahmedabad
on 16.01.1988. Thereafter, the applicant came to be granted promotion
to the post of Senior Technician (Group ‘B’ Non Gazetted) on
26.03.1992 and was posted in the said capacity in SPT, AIR Rajkot.
Having served at SPT, AIR, Rajkot till 30.04.1988, the applicant came
to be transferred and posted as Senior Technician in AIR, Ahmedabad
and he took over the charge of the said post at AIR, Ahmedabad on
01.05.1998. In the year 2003, the applicant was again transferred to
Rajkot and posted as Sr. Technician at SPT, AIR, Rajkot on 10.02.2003.
After serving at Rajkot for more than a year, the applicant came to be
2026.10.01
PRATIK VYAS
15:52:15+05'30'

: 5: OA No.120/416/2023

transferred back to Ahmedabad and posted as Sr. Technician in AIR,
Ahmedabad on 01.12.2004.
4.1 While serving in AIR, Ahmedabad, the applicant came
nd
to be granted 2 Financial Up-gradation under the Modified Assured
Career Progression Scheme (in short ‘MACP Scheme’) retrospectively
w.e.f 01.09.2008 with the grant of higher Grade Pay of
Rs.4600/-, vide Office Order dated 23.04.2010 issued by AIR,
Ahmedabad ( Annexure-A/7 refer). Thereafter, the applicant came to be
transferred and posted as Senior Technician at LPT, AIR, Dhandhuka
on 01.09.2010.
4.2 In the year 2012, while serving in Dhandhuka, the applicant
rd
came to be granted 3 Financial Up-gradation under the MACP
Scheme retrospectively w.e.f. 28.03.2012 vide Order dated 08.10.2012
issued by the Office of the Addl. DG, (ENGG)/(WZ), Mumbai
( Annexure-A/8 refer) and the consequential Pay Fixation Order dated
16/ 17.09.2013 issued by the erstwhile DDMC, AIR, Bhavnagar
( Annexure-A/9 refer).
4.3 In the year 2015, when the applicant was drawing the
rd
grade pay of Rs.4800/- by virtue of the grant of 3 MACP
retrospectively w.e.f. 28.03.2012, the Prasar Bharati Hqrs., New Delhi,
vide Circular/Letter dated 12.01.2015 ( Annexure A/10 refer) addressed
to all Zonal Heads of Prasar Bharati, had advised that in view of the
DOP&T's ID Note ( Annexure A/11 refer) clarifying & interpreting the
illustrations (i), (ii) & (iii) of the MACP Scheme, the authorities were
called upon to ensure strict compliance of the aforesaid clarification &
interpretation of the DOP&T Note and that the financial up-gradations,
if any, wrongly granted, may be rectified respectively.
4.4 On coming to know of the aforesaid Circular/Letter as also the
directives given therein by the Prasar Bharati Hqrs., the Association of
Radio & Television Employees' Association had approached the
Principal Bench of this Tribunal by filing Original Application being
2026.10.01
PRATIK VYAS
15:52:15+05'30'

: 6: OA No.120/416/2023

OA No.3035 of 2015 challenging the aforesaid Circular/Letter dated
12.01.2015. In the said OA proceedings, the Principal Bench of this
Tribunal vide its Notice and Interim Order dated 14.08.2015
( Annexure-A/12 refer) was pleased to grant interim relief in favour of
the aforesaid Association (meaning thereby its members) by directing
that no recovery shall be made from the applicant till next date. In
pursuance of the aforesaid Interim Order dated 14.08.2015, the DG,
AIR, New Delhi, vide its Communication dated 19.08.2015 ( Annexure-
A/13 refer) had circulated the aforesaid interim order of the Principal
Bench of this Tribunal to all the Zonal Heads.
4.5 In the year 2016, pending the filing of the written
statement in the aforesaid OA proceedings, DG, AIR, New Delhi,
vide its communication dated 05.01.2016 ( Annexure-A/14 refer), had
advised the lower formations to ensure the compliance of the DG AIR's
letter dated 12.01.2015. In pursuance of the aforesaid directive from the
DG AIR Hqrs., the Prasar Bharati, West Zone, Mumbai, vide its
Revised III MACP Order for Senior Technicians dated 17.11.2016
( Annexure-A/15 refer) had withdrawn the III MACP granted to the
applicant earlier. It is stated that even going by the interpretation of the
MACP Scheme by the DoP&T and consequently adopted/followed by
the Ministry of Information & Broadcasting, the applicant ought to have
been granted III MACP on his completion of 30 years of regular service
in the month of January 2018. Nevertheless, the same was not granted to
the applicant. There was no occasion for the applicant to raise any
grievance in this behalf in the year 2018 or ever thereafter inasmuch as
the local authorities in AIR, Ahmedabad, did not implement the
aforesaid Revised Order dated 17.11.2016 and consequently the III
MACP granted to the applicant in 2012 was not being withdrawn till his
retirement on 31.05.2022 and in the aforesaid background the applicant
was also not aware of the issuance of the aforesaid Revised Order dated
17.11.2016.
2026.10.01
PRATIK VYAS
15:52:15+05'30'

: 7: OA No.120/416/2023

4.6 As a matter of fact, the aforesaid OA came to be
allowed by the Principal Bench, vide its Final Order dated 08.08.2018
In OA No.3035/2015 (Annexure-A/16 refer). However, in the writ
proceedings initiated by DO, AIR, New Delhi, before the Hon'ble High
Court of Delhi, the aforesaid final order dated 08.08.2018 was set aside
by the Hon'ble High Court of Delhi and case was remanded back to the
Principal Bench of this Tribunal vide Hon'ble High Court's Order dated
01.02.2023 in Writ Petition (C) No.1272/2023 (Annexure-A/17 refer).
The aforesaid remanded OA No.3035/2023 was pending before the
Principal Bench of this Tribunal and the same was scheduled for hearing
on 10.01.2014 at the behest of the Prasar Bharati, as is evident from the
interim order dated 22.11.2023 in OA No.3035/2018 ( Annexure-A/18
refer).
4.7 In so far as the case of the applicant is concerned, as already pointed
out hereinabove, no recovery was made from the applicant till his
retirement on 31.05.2022, in pursuance of the directives issued by the
Prasar Bharati in its Circular/Letter dated 12.01.2015, referred to
hereinabove, in view of the stay granted by the Principal Bench of this
Tribunal vide Interim Order dated 14.08.2015 passed in OA
No.3035/2015, as also the consequent communication dated 19.08.2015
issued by DG, AIR, New Delhi, referred to hereinabove.
4.8 In the year 2020, in pursuance of the order dated 11.03.2014 issued by
the DG, AIR, New Delhi, extending the benefit of notional pay fixation
to the post of Technicians and Senior Technicians enhancing their pay
scale at par with Lighting Assistants w.e.f. 01.07.1983 in the wake of
the ruling of the Hon'ble Supreme Court dated 10.01.2013 in SLP
(Civil) No.33048, the applicant was issued a pay fixation order dated
03.07.2020 ( Annexure-A/19 refer). It is stated that the aforesaid pay
fixation, done in the wake of the Supreme Court's ruling, had nothing to
do with the withdrawal of the III MACP. This is not all. While
calculating and fixing the pay of the applicant in July 2020, the
respondents’ authorities did not give effect to the aforesaid Revised
2026.10.01
PRATIK VYAS
15:52:15+05'30'

: 8: OA No.120/416/2023

Order dated 17.l1.2016 whereby the III MACP granted to the applicant
was withdrawn. If the respondents at that point of time in 2020 had
withdrawn the III MACP in pursuance of the aforesaid Revised Order
dated 17.11.2016, the applicant would have come to know of the
aforesaid Revised Order dated 17.11.2016 and he could have taken
appropriate steps demanding the grant of III MACP to him from January
2018 inasmuch as by that time in January 2018, the applicant had duly
completed 30 years of regular service in Prasar Bharati. That was also
not done by the respondents.
4.9 Be that as it may, as the applicant was due to retire from the services of
the Prasar Bharati on and from 31.05.2022 on his attaining the age of
superannuation, the applicant was called upon orally on 19.01.2022 by
his officer dealing with pension cases to give in writing to the effect that
his pension papers might be prepared after giving effect to the
withdrawal of his III MACP and that from his salary on instalments
basis. Thus, it was for the first time that the applicant was made aware
of the issuance of the aforesaid Revised Order dated 17.11.2016 by the
Addl. DG (WZ), AIR, Mumbai whereby the applicant's III MACP was
withdrawn. Accordingly, the applicant has submitted a formal letter
dated 19.01.2022 ( Annexure-A/20 refer) in this behalf to the competent
authority viz. DDG(E), AIR, Ahmedabad, with a genuine hope and
expectation that upon his retirement, he would be released regular
pension, commutation, Gratuity, Leave Encashment and other retiral
dues. As a matter of fact, at that relevant point of time on 19.01.2022,
none of the authorities in Prasar Bharati including the aforesaid official
dealing with pension cases in AIR Ahmedabad has bothered to bring to
the notice of the applicant that the applicant on his retirement would be
released only provisional pension in view of the directives issued by the
Ministry of Information & Broadcasting in the month of August 2021.
In other words, the applicant was totally kept in dark about the aforesaid
decision of the Min. I&B to grant only provisional pension till the final
outcome of the pending litigation on the subject.
2026.10.01
PRATIK VYAS
15:52:15+05'30'

: 9: OA No.120/416/2023

4.10 Immediately a month thereafter, on his coming to know of the
aforesaid decisions of the Min I&B dated 18.08.2021 and 19.08.2021
from one of his colleagues serving in AIR, Ahmedabad, the applicant
has submitted a detailed representation dated 24.02.2022 ( Annexure-
A/21 refer) to the DDG, AIR, Ahmedabad, informing the said authority
of his forthwith withdrawal of his previous application dated 19.01.2022
and the same be treated as NULL, VOID & REVOKED.
4.11 Nevertheless, the Pay & Accounts Officer In AIR, Mumbai, vide his
communication dated 19.04.2022 ( Annexure-A/22 refer) has called
upon the AIR, Ahmedabad, to prepare and submit to PAO, Mumbai, the
provisional pension case of the applicant.
4.12 On 31.05.2022, the applicant has retired from the services of the Prasar
Bharati on his attaining the age of superannuation, vide Order dated
31.05.2022 ( Annexure-A/23 refer) issued by the AIR, Ahmedabad. On
31.05.2022, the applicant was issued Last Pay Certificate dated
31.05.2022 ( Annexure-A/24 refer) wherefrom it will be appreciated
that no recovery whatsoever was made from his salary in pursuance of
the aforesaid withdrawal of III MACP ordered on 17.11.2016.
4.13 Since the applicant was not being issued any P.P.O nor was being
released any retiral dues such as regular Pension, Commutation,
Gratuity, Leave Encashment, etc., even after his retirement, the
applicant had to submit a formal written representation dated
13.06.2022 ( Annexure-A/25 refer), addressed to the competent
authority in AIR, Ahmedabad, requesting for the forthwith release of all
his retiral dues. In his aforesaid representation dated 13.06.2022, the
applicant had undertaken to abide by the outcome of the pending
litigations and to refund the excess payment, if any, made to the
applicant.
4.14 For a couple of months, no response was forthcoming from any of the
respondent authorities. It was only on 04.08.2022 that the AIR,
Ahmedabad, vide its communication dated 04.08.2022 ( Annexure-A/26
2026.10.01
PRATIK VYAS
15:52:15+05'30'

: 10: OA No.120/416/2023

refer), addressed to the applicant that in terms of the provisions
contained in Rule 64 of CCS (Pension) Rules,1972, the competent
authority has accorded approval for the grant of Provisional Pension @
Rs.41,800/- p.m. w.e.f. 01.06.2022 and release of a sum of
Rs.16,63,556/- being 90% of the admissible gratuity. In the said
communication, the applicant was further informed that a sum of
Rs.7,74,490/- is to be recovered from the aforesaid gratuity of
Rs.16,63,556/-. Apart from issuance of the aforesaid communication, a
formal Order dated 04.08.2022 granting the aforesaid Provisional
Pension and 90% Gratuity was issued to the applicant. Immediately
upon his receipt of the aforesaid two documents, the applicant
has submitted a formal written representation dated 16.08.2022
( Annexure-A/27 refer) to AIR, Ahmedabad, raising serious objection to
the proposed recovery of the aforesaid sum of Rs.7,74,490/- from the
aforesaid 90% Gratuity amount. In response thereto, the authority in
AIR, Ahmedabad, vide its communication dated 16.08.2022
( Annexure-A/28 refer), has informed the applicant that its previous
communication dated 04.08.2022 with regard to the proposed recovery
of Rs.7,74,490/- stands amended in the manner as set out in the
aforesaid communication dated 04.08.2022. Again, on 29.08.2022, the
aforesaid Authority in AIR, Ahmedabad has issued a further
communication dated 29.08.2022 in supersession of its previous
communication dated 04.08.2022.
4.14 In the interregnum, in a joint OA being OA No.2691/2021 filed before
the Principal Bench of this Tribunal, by 15 retired/serving technicians in
AIR challenging the Circular/Letter dated 19.08.2021 issued by the
Office of the Controller of Accounts (CCA), Min. of I&B, New Delhi,
the Principal Bench of this Tribunal,
vide its Final Order dated 05.07.2022 ( Annexure-A/29 refer),was
pleased to quash and set aside the aforesaid Circular/Letter dated
19.08.2021 and directed the AIR authorities to release full pension
& gratuity to those already retired from Prasar Bharati. In this
2026.10.01
PRATIK VYAS
15:52:15+05'30'

: 11: OA No.120/416/2023

nature of the situation, the Ministry of Information & Broadcasting,
GoI, New Delhi, vide its communication dated 06.10.2022 ( Annexure
A/30 refer), addressed to the Chief Controller of Accounts, Ministry of
I&B, New Delhi, was pleased to advise the latter that in
supersession of the Ministry's Letter dated 18.08.2021, the CCA might
issue necessary instructions to all PAOs for release of final pension and
all pensionary benefits to reitiring/retired government employees of
AIRs/DDs, immediately. In consequence of the aforesaid development,
on the very next day, the Office of the aforesaid Chief Controller of
Accounts, Min of I&B, New Delhi was pleased to issue an Office
Memorandum dated 07.10.2022 ( Annexure-A/31 refer) addressed to
all concerned to forthwith strictly comply with the instructions issued by
the I&B Ministry in its aforesaid letter dated 06.10.2022. Immediately
on his coming to know of the aforesaid developments and the
instructions issued by the I&B Ministry and also the CCA of the said
Ministry, the applicant has submitted a formal written representation
dated 10.10.2022 ( Annexure-A/32 refer) to the competent authority
in AIR, Ahmedabad, drawing the kind attention of the said
competent authority to release to the applicant the full
pension and other retiral dues in terms of the instructions contained
in the aforesaid communications of the Ministry of I&B and the
CCS, MIB.
4.15 Nevertheless, the Pay & Accounts Officer at AIR, Mumbai, in
pursuance of his receipt of the Provisional Pension papers from AIR,
Ahmedabad, had the audacity to issue communication dated 10.10.2022,
addressed to DDG, AIR, Ahmedabad, informing the latter about the
grant of Provisional Pension of Rs.41,800/- plus DA to the applicant
and further informing the latter that the PPO would be issued after the
finalization of the case. This is not all. On the very day, the aforesaid
P&AO, AIR, Mumbai, has the further audacity to issue another
communication dated 10.10.2022, addressed to the DDG, AIR,
Ahmedabad, authorized the latter to draw a sum of Rs.16,63,556/- being
2026.10.01
PRATIK VYAS
15:52:15+05'30'

: 12: OA No.120/416/2023

the amount of Gratuity payable to the applicant. In the said
communication, it was further informed that a sum of Rs.l,84,840/- has
been withheld from Gratuity which will be paid on settlement of court
case. Thereafter, in the month of October, 2022, the applicant came to
be released the arrears arising out of the aforesaid provisional pension
w.e.f. June 2022 to September 2022 and 90% of gratuity amount.
Still the applicant is getting only provisional pension. The applicant is
not being released full pension, commutation of pension, remaining
amount of gratuity, leave encashment, etc. etc.,
4.16 Be that as it may, in pursuance of the applicant's representation dated
10.10.2022, referred to hereinabove, the authority in AIR, Ahmedabad,
had issued a communication dated 12.10.2022 ( Annexure-A/33 refer)
addressed to AIR, Hqrs., New Delhi, informing the latter about of the
pendency of pension case of the applicant in view of its non receipt of
case papers of the applicant from AIR, Mumbai.
4.17 It is stated that the Directorate General, AIR, New Delhi, vide its
communication dated 21.10.2022 ( Annexure A/34 refer) has called
upon all the Zones to take immediate and necessary action for
compliance with the instructions issued by the MIB and the CCA, MIB
on 07.10.2022 for the settlement of retiral dues of the retired employees
and directed that before releasing the full & final pension and all other
retiral dues the authorities concerned might take an undertaking from
the retired employees to the effect that if any excess payment is made to
an individual then the same shall be recovered from him or her after the
disposal of the W.P.No.9890/2019, pending before the Hon’ble High
Court of Delhi or any other similar litigations. Still the applicant
was not being released full & final pension and all other retiral
dues. In this nature of the situation, the applicant had to
submit a further representation dated 18.11.2022 ( Annexure A/35 refer)
addressed to AIR, Ahmedabad, pointing out therein that since
the applicant had already in his representation dated 13.06.2022
had given his undertaking to the aforesaid effect, his final
2026.10.01
PRATIK VYAS
15:52:15+05'30'

: 13: OA No.120/416/2023

pension and other retiral dues may kindly be released to him.
Nevertheless, there was no response from the said authority. In
the month of January 2023, the Prasar Bharati Hqrs., New Delhi,
vide its communication dated 07.0l.2023 ( Annexure A/36 refer),
addressed to all PAOs in the Zones including the respondent no.7 had
called upon the said PAOs to strictly adhere to the orders of the
Principal Bench of this Tribunal dated 05.07.2022 and avoid contempt
of Court. In so far as the case of the applicant, the authority in AIR,
Ahmedabad, had demanded from the PAO, AIR, Mumbai, the
applicant's Service Verification papers for further action in the matter,
vide its Communication dated 13.01.2023 ( Annexure-A/37 refer).
4.18 On 30.01.2023, in view of the instructions issued by the
Prasar Bharati Hqrs., vide Office Memorandum dated 30.01.2023
( Annexure-A/38 refer), the applicant immediately on his
coming to know of the OM, has submitted again a formal written
representation dated 30.01.2023 ( Annexure-A/39 refer) requesting
for the release of his final and full pension and other retiral dues.
Again there was no response from the said authority.
4.19 Since the applicant was not receiving any response from any of the
respondents’ authorities in AIR nor was being released the final pension
and other retiral dues, the applicant had to submit a formal Grievance
Letter Petition dated 10.03.2023 to the DG, AIR, New Delhi. In
response thereto, the GRC Section in DG, AIR, New Delhi has issued
reply communication dated 26.04.2023 informing the applicant that his
grievance will be governed by the final outcome of WP(C)
No.9890/2019 which is sub judice as on date and that action would be
taken once the said case attains finality.
4.20 In the month of April 2023, the respondent no.7, vide communication
dated 21.04.2023 ( Annexure-A/40 refer), returning the applicant's
service record to AIR, Ahmedabad, has advised that its observations
contained in the aforesaid communication dated 21.04.2023 may be
complied with. In pursuance of the aforesaid communication dated
2026.10.01
PRATIK VYAS
15:52:15+05'30'

: 14: OA No.120/416/2023

21.04.2023, the authority in AIR, Ahmedabad, vide communication
dated 27.04.2023 has since informed the applicant that the applicant is
required to deposit a sum of Rs.7,74,490/- towards recovery of
excess payment on or before 05.05.2023, for regularization of his
pension and that the applicant shall also file an undertaking in the
format attached, for recovery of excess payment. The aforesaid
communication dated 27.04.2023 was received by the applicant through
post after the aforesaid deadline of 05.05.2023. In response thereto, the
applicant has since submitted his detailed and elaborate reply dated
23.05.2023 ( Annexure-A/41 refer) pointing out to AIR, Ahmedabad,
that no recovery, much less the aforesaid amount of Rs.7,74,4901- can
be made from the applicant and he is entitled to be granted
forthwith regular pension and other retiral dues without any delay.
4.21 In the month of September 2023 in response to the applicant's aforesaid
representation dated 23.05.2023, the local authority in AIR,
Ahmedabad, has since issued to the applicant a communication dated
26.09.2023 ( Anneuxre-A/42 refer) calling upon the applicant
once again to deposit with the department the aforesaid amount of
Rs.7,74,490/- and also submit the requisite undertaking referred to in its
previous letter dated 27.04.2023. Hence, the applicant has filed the
present OA seeking the reliefs as quoted above.
CONTENTIONS OF THE APPLICANT
5. Learned counsel for the applicant contended that at the time of his
superannuation on 31.05.2022, he was neither under suspension nor
facing any departmental or criminal proceedings. Despite the same, the
respondents have withheld the release of his retiral dues for nearly four
years, on the pretext that he should either deposit a sum of Rs.7,74,490/-
towards alleged excess payment or furnish a fresh undertaking for
recovery of the said amount.
5.1 It is submitted that the applicant had joined the respondents’
department, All India Radio, on 16.01.1988 as Technician and was
2026.10.01
PRATIK VYAS
15:52:15+05'30'

: 15: OA No.120/416/2023

subsequently promoted as Senior Technician on 25.03.1992. He became
nd
eligible for grant of 2 MACP w.e.f. 01.09.2008, which was
retrospectively granted to him on 23.04.2010. Thereafter, he was
rd
granted 3 MACP w.e.f. 28.03.2012 by order dated 08.10.2012.
However, pursuant to the clarification issued by the DoP&T and the
subsequent communication dated 12.01.2015 issued by Prasar Bharati
directing its lower formations to rectify the alleged erroneous grant of
rd
3 MACP, the Association challenged the said action before the
Principal Bench of this Tribunal in OA No.3035/2015, wherein an
interim order dated 14.08.2015 was passed staying recovery of any
amount from the members of the Association. Nevertheless, Prasar
rd
Bharati, Mumbai, by order dated 17.11.2016, withdrew the 3 MACP
earlier granted to the applicant. However, the said order was not
received by AIR, Ahmedabad, and consequently was not implemented
by the local authorities. The applicant also remained unaware of the said
withdrawal order.
5.2 Learned counsel also submitted that the aforesaid OA No.3035/2015
was ultimately allowed by the Principal Bench of this Tribunal vide
Final Order dated 08.08.2018. Thereafter, when applicant’s pay was re-
fixed in the year 2020 pursuant to the decision dated 11.03.2014 of the
DG, AIR, extending the benefit of notional pay fixation to Technicians
and Senior Technicians, the local authorities at Ahmedabad did not
rd
disturb the 3 MACP already granted to him. However, in the
meantime, the Ministry of Information & Broadcasting issued
communication dated 16.08.2021 directing the grant of provisional
pension and provisional gratuity to retiring employees under Rule 64 of
the CCS (Pension) Rules till conclusion of the pending litigation,
followed by consequential directions issued by Prasar Bharati on
19.08.2021. According to the applicant, these developments were not
within his knowledge while he was serving at Ahmedabad.
5.3 Learned counsel also submitted that, as applicant’s retirement was
approaching, he was summoned by the local authorities on 19.01.2022
2026.10.01
PRATIK VYAS
15:52:15+05'30'

: 16: OA No.120/416/2023

and was asked to give written authorization for giving effect to the
rd
withdrawal of his 3 MACP while preparing his PPO. Acting in good
faith and without knowledge of the intervening developments, he gave
such authorization. It was, however, not disclosed to him that he would
consequently be issued only provisional pension. On subsequently
learning about the developments, he immediately withdrew the said
authorization vide representation dated 24.02.2022.
5.4 Learned counsel contended that the applicant retired from service on
attaining the age of superannuation on 31.05.2022. Thereafter, by
representation dated 13.06.2022, he requested the local authorities for
release of his PPO and other retiral dues and specifically undertook to
refund any excess payment, if ultimately found payable, subject to the
final outcome of the aforesaid writ petition pending before the Hon'ble
Delhi High Court.
5.5 Learned counsel argued that the Principal Bench of this Tribunal, in
OA No.2691/2021, vide Final Order dated 05.07.2022, quashed and set
aside the decision dated 19.08.2021 and directed the respondents to
issue appropriate orders sanctioning pension and gratuity admissible
under the pension rules. Despite the aforesaid judicial order, the local
authority issued an order dated 04.08.2022 granting him only
provisional pension of Rs.41,800/- and provisional gratuity of
Rs.16,63,566/-, while simultaneously communicating that an amount of
Rs.7,74,490/- was recoverable towards alleged overpayment of pay and
allowances. The applicant immediately objected to the proposed
recovery vide representation dated 16.08.2022, particularly in view of
the stay operating in the pending proceedings before the Hon'ble Delhi
High Court.
5.6 The applicant further points out that, significantly, on 16.08.2022, the
local authority itself issued a corrigendum prohibiting recovery of any
amount from the gratuity admissible to him. Despite the same, the local
authority reiterated its earlier stand vide communication dated
29.08.2022.
2026.10.01
PRATIK VYAS
15:52:15+05'30'

: 17: OA No.120/416/2023

5.7 It is the applicant's case that, following the Final Order dated
05.07.2022, the Ministry of Information & Broadcasting issued
communication dated 06.10.2022, directing that an undertaking could be
obtained from retiring/retired employees that any excess payment found
payable could be recovered after disposal of WP (C) No.9890/2019 or
any other pending litigation. A consequential Circular dated 07.10.2022
was also issued by the PAO for compliance. Upon learning of the
aforesaid developments, the applicant again represented on 10.10.2022
for immediate release of all his retiral benefits in view of the orders of
the Court and the consequential circulars issued by the Ministry.
However, despite the same, the Prasar Bharati authority at Mumbai
issued written authority dated 10.10.2022 directing release of
provisional pension while withholding Rs.1,84,840/- from the
provisional gratuity.
5.8 Learned counsel also contended that shortly thereafter, the DG, Prasar
Bharati, New Delhi, vide Circular dated 21.10.2022, directed all Zonal
Heads, including the Mumbai Zone, to release all pensionary benefits to
retired employees in terms of the Ministry's Circular dated 07.10.2022.
The applicant again represented on 18.10.2022, furnishing the
undertaking required by the Ministry and requesting release of his
pensionary dues, followed by a reminder dated 30.01.2023. Instead of
releasing his retiral dues, the respondents, vide communications dated
26.04.2023 and 27.04.2023, took the stand that his case would be
governed by the final outcome of WP (C) No.9890/2019 and that
appropriate action would be taken thereafter. The local authority further
insisted upon submission of a fresh undertaking, to which the applicant
objected vide representation dated 23.05.2023. Thus, left with no
effective alternative, he filed the present OA on 21.12.2023, seeking
release of his pensionary and other retiral benefits.
5.9 Learned counsel further submitted that during the pendency of the
present OA, the proceedings arising out of OA No.3035/2015, which
had been remanded by the Hon'ble Delhi High Court on 01.02.2023,
2026.10.01
PRATIK VYAS
15:52:15+05'30'

: 18: OA No.120/416/2023

were finally decided in favour of the Association by the Principal Bench
of this Tribunal vide Final Order dated 28.08.2025. In view of the said
subsequent development, the applicant’s learned counsel argued that the
very basis on which the respondents had withheld his retiral benefits no
longer survives and, consequently, the present OA deserves to be
allowed and all the reliefs prayed for by him deserve to be granted.
CONTENTIONS OF THE RESPONDENTS
6. Learned counsel for the respondents by referring to the contents of the
reply filed on behalf of the respondents submitted that the applicant was
rd
erroneously granted 3 MACP in the grade pay of Rs.4800/- w.e.f.
28.03.2012 which was later withdrawn vide ADG(E)(WZ), Mumbai's
order dated 17.11.2016. Further on perusal of Annexures A-10 &
rd
A-II produced by the applicant with this OA, it is clear that the 3
nd
MACP is to be granted on completion of 10 years from the 2 MACP
or 30 years of service, either of the condition being fulfilled. However,
the applicant did not fulfill any of the above conditions as
the applicant had joined his services w.e.f. 16.01.1988 and was granted
nd
2 MACP w.e.f. 01.09.2008. He completes 30 years of service on
nd
16.01.2018 and 10 years from the date of 2 MACP on 01.09.2018
which is evident from Annexures A/l0 &A/l1 produced by the applicant,
rd
he was eligible for the 3 MACP w.e.f. 16.01.2018. As such the
rd
applicant was due for his 3 MACP w.e.f. 16.01.2018, which was
erroneously given w.e.f. 28.03.2012 and hence, later correctly
withdrawn vide the ADG (E)(WZ) order dated 17.11.2016. (Annexure-
R/3).
6.1 Learned counsel by referring to the FAQs provided by the DoP&T
(Annex-I) point No. 06 (Annexure-R/1) wherein it has clearly been
stipulated that:
“The financial up-gradation under MACPs is in the immediate next
higher grade pay in the hierarchy of recommended pay bands and
grade pay as given in CCS (Revised Pay) Rules, 2008. However, if the
promotional hierarchy as per recruitment rules is such that
2026.10.01
PRATIK VYAS
15:52:15+05'30'

: 19: OA No.120/416/2023

promotions are earned in the same grade pay, then the same shall be
counted for the purpose of MACP”.
From the above, it is clear that the scale given in MACP should not be
greater than the promotion scale. The MACP of the promotion scales
are given below for ready reference:
Technician : Grade Pay Rs. 4200/-
Sr. Technician : Grade Pay Rs. 4200/-
Engr. Assistant : Grade Pay Rs. 4600/-
Sr. Engr. Assistant : Grade Pay Rs. 4600/-
rd
Thus, it is glaring that, the 3 MACP in case of the applicant will be in
the Grade Pay of Rs. 4600/- and not Rs. 4800/- and, therefore, has
rightly been withdrawn.
6.2 Learned counsel also submitted that the issue of recovery came into
light only qua the applicant when his book was sent to the Pay &
Accounts Office, Akashvnai Mumbai for service verification following
which the revised pay fixation was done by withdrawing wrongly given
rd
3 MACP.
6.3 Learned counsel also submitted that as stated by the applicant when he
was called orally on 19.01.2022, he was specifically told about his
recovery status as had been advised by PAO office, Mumbai.
6.4 Learned counsel further submitted that no recovery was made from the
applicant due to the applicant's 'objection and even had not submitted
any undertaking for recovery of the excess payment. Meaning thereby,
applicant though was aware about excess payment, contributed to
receive excess amount. When the applicant had still not given any
undertaking for recovery required for processing his pension case which
is the usual procedure, the provisional pension case being prepared by
the respondents, guidance was sought from higher offices and later on it
was known that the sanction for provisional pension to be sent to the
PAO office was to be prepared locally. In the sanction prepared locally
2026.10.01
PRATIK VYAS
15:52:15+05'30'

: 20: OA No.120/416/2023

on 04.08.2022, the amount of excess payment to be recovered was
shown. As per PAO's advice the same was rectified immediately and
forwarded to the PAO on 29.08.2022. Provisional Pension was released
along with Provisional Gratuity.
6.5 Learned counsel also submitted that the PPO is generated only when the
regular pension has been processed. However, in this case, applicant has
been given Provisional Pension, as his recovery of the excess payment
made to him is pending.
6.6 So far as W.P.(C) No 9890/2019 is concerned, the same is about the
rd
admissibility of 3 MACP to certain categories, who had been given
upgraded pay scales. Thus, issue in that case is not germane to the issue
involved in the present case. Further, the said W.P (C) No.9890/2019
has been filed by Association of Akashvani and Doordarshan
Engineering Employees (AADEE) while the OA 3035/2015 had been
filed by Association of Radio & Television Engineering Employees
(ARTEE). Prasar Bharati has long since discarded any sort of unions, so
the eligibility of the applicant being in both the unions which have been
discarded is questionable. Therefore, the respondents are correct in its
position of recovering the excess payment from the applicant.
6.7 Learned counsel also submitted that no undertaking for recovery of
excess payment has yet been received from the applicant for processing
his regular pension. Further, the applicant was supposedto deposit a sum
of Rs. 7,74,490/- towards recovery of excess payment which has
however reduced to Rs. 5,03,065/- as per revised pay fixation done as
per DG, Akashvani New Delhi's order dated 07.04.2023 ( Annexure-
R/2 refer). The applicant, however, still needs to submit an undertaking
for the same. The respondents are bound to prepare pension papers in
accordance with the guidelines received from the Pay & Accounts
Office, Akashvani Mumbai on the basis of service verification done for
each and every retiring employee. In applicant's case too, PAO office
pointed out the wrong fixation and thus the respondents have revised the
applicant’s pay accordingly. Also, the applicant is referring to the WP
2026.10.01
PRATIK VYAS
15:52:15+05'30'

: 21: OA No.120/416/2023

rd
(C) No.9890/2019 filed by AADEE, which is about as to whether the 3
MACP is admissible to the officials, who have been given upgraded pay
scales by Prasar Bharati. Clear directives have been received that the
upgraded pay scales need to be adjusted against one the MACPs. At the
same time, the applicant is also raising contentions in relation to the OA
No.3035/2015 filed by ARTEE. No employee can be a member of more
than one union simultaneously. Also, Prasar Bharati has disbanded all
the Unions since long back. Applicant as such is misguiding.
Nonetheless, the applicant may be directed to deposit the amount of
excess payment to the respondents for early process of his regular
pension.
6.8 Lastly, learned counsel prayed that the applicant is not entitled for the
final relief(s), he has prayed for and the O.A. is devoid of anymerits and
hence, is required to be dismissed.
7. We have heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the material
placed on record.
ANALYSIS
8. Having considered the rival submissions and the material placed on
record, we find that the controversy requires examination under three
interrelated aspects: first, the applicant's entitlement to release of final
pensionary benefits; second, the legality of withholding such benefits on
rd
account of the alleged excess payment arising from the 3 MACP; and
third, the effect of the judicial proceedings concerning the very basis of
the alleged excess payment.
9. It is an admitted position that the applicant superannuated on
31.05.2022. It is also not the respondents' case that on the date of his
retirement, he was under suspension or that any departmental or judicial
proceeding was pending against him in the conventional sense
contemplated by the pension rules. The respondents' justification for
withholding the final pensionary benefits is substantially founded upon
rd
the alleged excess payment consequent upon grant of the 3 MACP and
2026.10.01
PRATIK VYAS
15:52:15+05'30'

: 22: OA No.120/416/2023

the pendency of litigation concerning the admissibility of such financial
upgradation.
nd
10. The applicant's service record shows that he was granted the 2 MACP
rd
retrospectively w.e.f. 01.09.2008 and thereafter the 3 MACP w.e.f.
28.03.2012. The latter was subsequently withdrawn by order dated
17.11.2016. Significantly, however, the withdrawal was not acted upon
by the Ahmedabad authorities and the applicant continued to draw the
benefit until retirement.
11 . The respondents seek to justify the withdrawal by contending that the
rd
applicant was not eligible for the 3 MACP from 28.03.2012.
nd
According to them, having obtained the 2 MACP from 01.09.2008, he
rd
could become eligible for the 3 MACP only upon completion of the
prescribed period, and, on the respondents' own calculation, the relevant
date would be 16.01.2018. They further contend that, having regard to
rd
the hierarchy of grade pay, the applicant's 3 MACP could not have
been in Grade Pay ₹4800/- and that the grant was, therefore, erroneous.
There is, therefore, undoubtedly a substantive dispute regarding the
correctness of the original grant. But the existence of such a dispute
does not by itself answer the separate question as to whether all final
pensionary benefits could indefinitely be withheld from a retired
employee.
12. The above question assumes considerable importance because the
Principal Bench of this Tribunal, in OA No.2691/2021, vide its Final
Order dated 05.07.2022, had already quashed the communication dated
19.08.2021 under which provisional pension and provisional gratuity
were being contemplated for retiring/retired employees of AIR on
account of the pending MACP litigation. The applicant specifically
relies upon this Order and the consequential instructions issued by the
Ministry of Information & Broadcasting and the Chief Controller of
Accounts directing release of final pension and pensionary benefits.
2026.10.01
PRATIK VYAS
15:52:15+05'30'

: 23: OA No.120/416/2023

13. The respondents cannot effectively dispute the significance of the
subsequent administrative instructions issued pursuant to the said
decision. The record itself shows that after the Order dated 05.07.2022,
the Ministry of Information & Broadcasting issued communication
dated 06.10.2022 advising that final pension and pensionary benefits be
released, while the CCA issued consequential instructions dated
07.10.2022. The applicant thereafter approached the authorities on
10.10.2022 seeking implementation.
14. More importantly, the subsequent departmental communications
themselves demonstrate that the respondents were aware of the said
judicial mandate. The Directorate General, AIR, by communication
dated 21.10.2022, directed the Zones to take necessary action for
settlement of retiral dues and contemplated obtaining an undertaking
that any excess payment ultimately found payable could be recovered
after the outcome of WP(C) No.9890/2019 or other similar litigation.
15. Thus, the administrative mechanism adopted after the decision in OA
No.2691/2021 was not that a retired employee must first deposit the
disputed amount and only thereafter receive pension. Rather, the
departmental instructions themselves contemplated release of
pensionary benefits against an undertaking safeguarding the
Government's right to recovery depending upon the ultimate outcome of
the litigation.
16. The respondents nevertheless contended that the applicant never
furnished the undertaking required for processing his regular pension
and that he was required to deposit the amount of alleged excess
payment. They further contended that the amount was subsequently
revised from Rs.7,74,490/- to Rs.5,03,065/- after revised applicant’s pay
fixation. This contention, however, has to be considered in the factual
setting of the case. The applicant had already furnished an undertaking
in his representation dated 13.06.2022, undertaking to abide by the
result of the pending litigation and to refund any excess payment, if
ultimately found payable.
2026.10.01
PRATIK VYAS
15:52:15+05'30'

: 24: OA No.120/416/2023

17. Consequently, once the departmental authorities themselves
subsequently issued instructions contemplating release of final pension
upon obtaining an undertaking, the insistence upon a fresh undertaking,
without first explaining why the undertaking already furnished was
inadequate, cannot by itself constitute a legally sustainable ground for
indefinitely withholding the applicant's pensionary dues. The
respondents' own subsequent conduct is particularly relevant. The
applicant's grievance was not that the respondents had no right
whatsoever to protect the Government against a possible future
recovery. His case was that such protection had already been offered by
him and, therefore, the final pension could be released while preserving
the respondents' right to act in accordance with the ultimate judicial
determination.
18 . The next question is whether the alleged excess payment can lawfully be
recovered from the applicant. The respondents correctly contended that
a financial benefit wrongly granted under the MACP Scheme does not,
merely because it was sanctioned by an administrative authority,
become a substantive entitlement contrary to the governing scheme. An
administrative mistake cannot ordinarily create an indefeasible right to a
benefit which the statutory scheme does not permit. However, that
proposition is materially different from the proposition that every excess
payment is recoverable from an employee irrespective of the
circumstances in which the payment was made.
rd
19. Here in this case, the 3 MACP was granted pursuant to an official
order dated 08.10.2012 and pay fixation was thereafter undertaken by
the departmental authorities. There is no allegation that the applicant
secured the benefit by fraud, misrepresentation or concealment. On the
contrary, the respondents' own case is that the mistake was attributable
to the departmental interpretation/application of the MACP provisions.
The respondents discovered and sought to correct the matter through
their own administrative process. This factual distinction assumes
2026.10.01
PRATIK VYAS
15:52:15+05'30'

: 25: OA No.120/416/2023

importance in light of the Hon’ble Supreme Court's decision concerning
recovery of excess payments.
20 . In State of Punjab v. Rafiq Masih (White Washer) , reported in (2015)
4 SCC 334, the Hon'ble Supreme Court considered the circumstances in
which recovery of excess payment would be impermissible as being
harsh, inequitable and violative of Article 14 of the Constitution. The
Hon’ble Supreme Court identified, inter alia , cases involving retired
employees or employees on the verge of retirement, payments
continuing for more than five years, and other situations where recovery
would be so harsh or arbitrary that it would outweigh the employer's
right to recover. In para 18 laid down certain situations wherein
recoveries by the employee(s) would be impermissible in law, which
reads as under:-
“18. It is not possible to postulate all situations of hardship which would
govern employees on the issue of recovery, where payments have
mistakenly been made by the employer, in excess of their entitlement. Be
that as it may, based on the decisions referred to hereinabove, we may, as
a ready reference, summarise the following few situations, wherein
recoveries by the employers, would be impermissible in law:
( i ) Recovery from the employees belonging to Class III and Class IV
service (or Group C and Group D service).
( ii ) Recovery from the retired employees, or the employees who are
due to retire within one year, of the order of recovery.
( iii ) Recovery from the employees, when the excess payment has been
made for a period in excess of five years, before the order of
recovery is issued.
( iv ) Recovery in cases where an employee has wrongfully been
required to discharge duties of a higher post, and has been paid
accordingly, even though he should have rightfully been required to
work against an inferior post.
( v ) In any other case, where the court arrives at the conclusion, that
recovery if made from the employee, would be iniquitous or harsh
or arbitrary to such an extent, as would far outweigh the equitable
balance of the employer's right to recover.”
21. The principle emerging from Rafiq Masih (supra) is not that every
recovery of excess payment is automatically prohibited. Rather, the
Hon’ble Supreme Court balanced the employer's right to correct an
erroneous payment against the equitable consequences of recovery from
2026.10.01
PRATIK VYAS
15:52:15+05'30'

: 26: OA No.120/416/2023

an employee, who was not responsible for the error. The Hon’ble
Supreme Court's framework expressly includes retired employees and
those nearing retirement among the circumstances in which recovery
would ordinarily be impermissible, as quoted above.
22. The present case falls substantially within the equitable considerations
underlying that principle. The applicant had retired on 31.05.2022; the
alleged excess payment originated in a departmental order of 2012; the
benefit was sanctioned by the competent departmental authorities; and
the applicant continued to receive it for several years without any
allegation of fraud or misrepresentation.
23 . The respondents' reliance upon the fact that the applicant was allegedly
informed about the recovery position on 19.01.2022 also does not
materially alter the position. At that stage, the applicant was
approaching retirement and the departmental authorities themselves
were seeking to adjust the consequences of the earlier MACP order.
There is nothing in the pleadings to demonstrate that the applicant had
procured the benefit by misrepresentation or fraud. Indeed, the record
shows that when the applicant was eventually informed of the
withdrawal order, he sought clarification and thereafter, upon
retirement, offered to abide by the result of the litigation and refund any
amount ultimately found recoverable.
24 . The respondents' case regarding the alleged excess payment cannot be
examined in isolation from OA No.3035/2015. That proceeding arose
rd
from the very controversy concerning withdrawal of the 3 MACP
benefits granted to similarly situated employees of AIR. We deem it fit
to reproduce the relevant paras of the said Order
5.1 The present reconsideration culminates from the order dated
01.02.2023 passed by the Hon’ble High Court of Delhi in WP (C)
No.1272/2023.
5.2 For better appreciation of the contentions urged by the respective
parties, we had directed the learned counsel for the respondents to place
on record a copy of the writ petition filed on behalf of the respondents, so
as to examine the pleadings and the grounds taken therein. Upon a close
2026.10.01
PRATIK VYAS
15:52:15+05'30'

: 27: OA No.120/416/2023

examination of the said pleadings, it is observed that the respondents
have highlighted their position as under:
“X. That after consulting the DOP&T and the Expenditure, M/O
Finance, the Petitioner No. 3 herein issued a Clarification dated
31.01.2018 on the admissibility of MACP.
By the said Clarification, it is clarified that the Upgraded
Scales, which were granted to the 11 Categories of Employees vide
Order dated 25.02.1999 is to be treated as one Upgradation
against the Three Upgradations applicable in terms of MACP
Scheme.
The Copy of the same herein is enclosed as Annexure P 5.
Y. That the Clarification dated 31.01.2018 was assailed before the
the parties, the Hon'ble Tribunal vide its Order dated 01.08.2019
in Ο.Α. ΝΟ. 2449/2018 upheld the Clarification dated 31.01.2018,
however, the Hon'ble Tribunal directed that no recovery is to be
made from t applicants therein.
The Copy of the same herein is enclosed as Annexure P 6.
Z. That the said Order of the Hon’ble Tribunal dated 01.08.2019 in
O.A. No. 2449/2018 is assailed by the applicants therein before this
Hon’ble High Court by filing W.P(C). NO. 9890/2018, which is
now posted for hearing on 20.03.2023. After heareing the Counsel
for the parties, the Hon’ble High Court vide its Order dated
13.09.2019 stayed the operation of the Hon’ble Tribunal in OA.
NO. 2449/2018.
The Copy of the same herein is enclosed as Annexure P-
AA. That the issue rose in the matter of Smt. Manju Vashishta &
Ors. is quite different qua the Respondents herein. It is submitted
that once the Upgraded Scale granted to the Respondents herein
vide O.M. dated 25.02.99 is to be treated as One Upgradation
against the Three Upgradation available under the MACP Scheme,
therefore, the issue raised in the instant Writ Petition is to be
decided independently and not in terms of the Order passed in Smt.
Manju Vashishta's Case.
Even otherwise, it is once again reiterated herein that while
dismissing the SLP in Smt. Manju Vashistha's case, the Hon'ble
Apex Court kept the Question of law open.
BB. Feeling aggrieved by the impugned Order dated 08.08.2018 in
O.A. No. 3035/2015 passed by the Tribunal, the present Writ
Petition is being filed by the Petitioners herein on the following
amongst other grounds.”
5.3 The respondent have not disputed that the Order dated 25.02.1999
read with clarification dated 31.1.2018 is sub judice before the Hon’ble
High Court of Delhi in W.P. (C) No.9890/2019 and the Hon’ble High
Court has stayed the order dated 01.08.2019 passed in OA
No.2449/2018. One of the ground urged in Writ Petition was that
“From, administrative point of view, the respondents herein are already
recipient of 1 promotion, 1 Upgraded Scale and 1 MACP w.e.f.
01.09.2008. However, the fact of upgraded Scale will be decided in W.P.
2026.10.01
PRATIK VYAS
15:52:15+05'30'

: 28: OA No.120/416/2023

(C) No. 9890/2019 which will have the way for taking any action on the
impugned order dated 08.08.2018”.
5.4 We do not understand on what basis 1 upgraded Scale has been
treated at par with MACP Scheme which is an entirely different matter
altogether. The respondents are making an attempt to distinguish the
case of Manju Vashistha on the touchstone of their OM dated 25.02.1999
read with the clarification dated 31.01.2018. The issue is under
examination before the Hon’ble High Court in WP No. 2034/2017,
wherein record of proceeding dated 11.04.2017 reads as under:
“Issue notice to the respondents, returnable on 10th August, 2017.
Learned counsel for the petitioner submits that the respondent
became an employee of Prasar Bharti on 1st November, 1997 and
had also retired also from the same institution. With reference to
MACP Scheme, it is submitted that the respondent was initially
appointed as Engineering Assistant in the pay scale of Rs.5000-
8000, has earned more than three financial upgradations. As per
the MACP Scheme, the next higher grade pay is payable.
There will be stay of the operation of the impugned order till the
next date of hearing.
Relist on 10th August, 2017.”
Similar orders were passed by the Hon’ble High Cour of Delhi in
W.P. No. 9890/2019, dated 13.09.2019. Both the writ petitions, bearing
Nos. 2034/2017 and 9890/2019, along with Cont. Case (C) No.
276/2022, are being heard together.
5.5 The only difference in the present case is that Technician, whereas
the Writ Petitions mentioned above pertains to other posts with the same
department.
5.6 The record of proceedings dated 11.07.2018, reads as under:
“2. Learned counsel submits that the only question involved in the
OA is granting of 3rd MACP on completion of 20 years of regular
service from the date of first promotion of the employees. Learned
counsel for the applicant further submits that the said question is
squarely covered by the Full Bench decision of the Tribunal in OA-
1288/2014 passed on 23.05.2016 – Smt. Manju Vashishtha & Ors.
Vs. UOI & Ors., which was already upheld by the Hon’ble High
Court of Delhi in Writ Petition (C) No.11826/2016 dated
03.02.2017.”
5.7. Furthermore, as evident from the order of remand by the Hon’ble
High Court, the learned counsel for the respondents submitted as under:-
“1. Challenge in this Writ Petition is to the order dated August 08,
2018, whereby the Tribunal has allowed the O.A. in terms of its
order of the Full Bench in O.A. 1288/2014 dated March 25, 2016,
Smt. Manju Vashistha & Ors. vs. Union of India & Ors., which has
been upheld by this Court in W.P.(C No. 11826/2016 dated
February 03, 2017, Union of India & Ors. vs. Manju Vashistha &
Ors.
2026.10.01
PRATIK VYAS
15:52:15+05'30'

: 29: OA No.120/416/2023

2. We have been informed by Mr. Arif that the SLP filed against the
judgment dated February 03, 2017, has been dismissed, however,
the question of law has been open by the Supreme Court.”
5.8 Now, the respondents taking shelter in light of OM dated 25.02.1999
and clarification dated 31.1.2018 cannot be comprehended at all. While
dealing with the questions raised by both sides, this very Bench in OA
No.3522/2017 titled “Yogesh Kumar Gulati and ors VS Commissioner of
Police and ors” had observed as under :
“8. At the outset, we refer to the impugned order dated 13.06.2017.
It is astonishing to note that the 3rd MACP benefits of the
applicants were withdrawn for the reason that the applicants were
not a party in OA No. 1288/2014 titled Manju Vashishta & Ors.
Vs. UoI & Ors . While deciding the said case, this Tribunal had
passed an order dated 23.05.2016, paras 12 to 15 of which read as
under:
“12. It is noteworthy that the second MACP Scheme benefit
has been granted the applicant only wie.f. 01.09.2008 i.e.
after a gap of more than 16 years from the date of her first
regular promotion. The date 01.09.2008 is fortuitous as it
noppent to be a date from which MACP Scheme was
implemented. Otherwise. has no relevance to the service
record of the applicant since it is not the date on which the
applicant completed either 10 or 20 years of service nor it is
the octe on which she completed 10 years of service after
getting first promotion. Her second MACP Scheme benefit
got delayed only because MACP Scheme came into existence
late. Hypothetically if MACP Scheme had come into existence
from an earlier date, she would have got second MACP
Scheme benefit on any date after 11.11.2001 after completion
of 10 years of service from the date of her first regular
promotion. However, due to late implementation of MACP
Scheme, she has lost benefit of almost 07 years of service.
Even then the date of second MACP Scheme benefit cannot
be preponed since before 01.09.2008 there was no MACP
Scheme in existence.
13. In our opinion, the situation as it exists in the case at
hand has not been envisaged in the MACP Scheme. The
Scheme has left this area uncovered and i silent on this
aspect. No provision has been made for preventing loss of
service those employees, who have suffered only on account
of date of Clementation of the MACP Scheme. We have also
seen that determining Sole of granit of third MACP Scheme
benefit to the applicant No.1 based on her sol date of
recruitment or on 01.09.2008. the date on which she got the
benefit second MACP Scheme can lead to erroneous results,
which are contrary to very provisions of the MACP Scheme.
Under these circumstances, the only the which can be used as
reference for determining the date from which third MACP
Scheme benefit can be granted to the applicant is the date of
her regular promotion as ASi le. 11.11.1991. Therefore, third
MACP Scheme benefits should be rightfully given to her after
20 years of service counted from 11.11.1991.
14 On the basis of above analysis, we come to the conclusion
that the question drawn by a Division Bench of the Principal
2026.10.01
PRATIK VYAS
15:52:15+05'30'

: 30: OA No.120/416/2023

Bench of this Tribunal has to be answered in the negative.
We are inclined to agree with the judgment of Emakulam
Bench of this Tribunal in OA-905/2012(supra) albeit for
different reasons, in which benefit of third upgradation under
MACP Scheme has been granted to the applicant therein
after completion of 20 years counted from the date of his
pramotion.
15. Consequently, we allow this O.A. (No. 1288/2014) and
quash the Impugned orders at Annexures A/1. A/2, A/3 and
A/4 with all consequential benefits. No costs.”
9. We also draw attention to the decision of the Hon’ble High
Court of Delhi rendered in Staff Selection Commission & Ors. Vs.
Darpan Sharma in W.P.(C) No. 3761/2018 dated 18.11.2024. Para
16 of the judgment reads as under:
“16. We are conscious of the fact that, in its final order dated
30 July 2019, the Supreme Court left the question of law,
arising before it, open. That, however, according to us, only
means that the Supreme Court did not pronounce on the
question of law that arose before it. The implication of the
Supreme Court leaving the question of law open was only,
therefore, that the Supreme Court has not pronounced on the
question aldaw which arose in the SLP, one way or the other.
That, however, does not, in any way, lessen the precedential
value of the judgement of the High Court. When, in the case
of a candidate situated identically to the respondent in the
present case, relief was granted by the High Court, and the
grant of the said relief was performed by the Supreme Court,
there can be no two views on the fact that the respondent
would be entitled to the same relief. Else, it would result in a
situation in which two persons, identically situated, had been
accorded differential treatment by Courts, which is obviously
unthinkable in law.”
10. In view of the above, we find that the impugned order has been
passed without application of mind by the respondents. The same is
quashed and set aside. Accordingly, the respondents are directed to
restore the benefits of the applicants, if they have not already done
so.
11. During the course of hearing it has been pointed out that
Applicant Nos. 2 & 3 have retired. Therefore, no recovery is
ordered to be made by the respondents from them. Even if recovery
is made, it the same shall be paid to the applicant along with their
pay fixation and accordingly, appropriate pensionary benefits shall
be given to them. Since Applicant No. 1 is yet to retire, no such
orders are called qua him.
12. The above exercise shall be carried out within a period of five
months from the date of receipt of a certified copy of this Order.
13. The OA is disposed of in the aforesaid terms. Pending MAs, if
any, stand disposed of. No order as to costs.
5.9 We do not appreciate the stance taken by the respondents, as they
cannot be permitted to blow hot and cold at the same time. On one hand,
they contend that the decision in Manju Vashistha (supra) is not
2026.10.01
PRATIK VYAS
15:52:15+05'30'

: 31: OA No.120/416/2023

applicable; on the other hand, they assert that the issue has been left
open by the Apex Court, and therefore, the said decision cannot be
applied in the present case.
5.10. The present case has to be decided in the context of the relief(s)
sought, and we draw reliance on the observations made by us in Yogesh
Kumar Gulati (supra). In the present case as well, the withdrawal has
been effected without proper application of mind and without issuance of
a show –cause notice, despite the fact that the benefits was granted by
the respondents after due consultation and following the prescribed
procedure, based on the recommendations of the Screening Committee
since the year 2010 onwards. It is also pertinent to note that the OM
dated 25.02.1999 was very much in existence at the time of granting the
benefits under the MACP Scheme. Such a withdrawal, even otherwise,
could not have been made without first referring the matter to the
Screening Committee and without adhering to the principles of natural
justice. Moreover, the withdrawal of benefits cannot be justified solely on
the basis of the clarification dated 31.01.2018, which was issued at a
much later date.
6. CONCLUSION :
6.1 In view of the above discussions, the impugned orders dated
18.03.2018 and 20.07.2015 are set aside, without prejudice to the rigfhts
and contentions of the parties in W.P. (C) No.2034/2017 and W.P. (C)
No.9890/2019, and Cont. Case (C) Bi, 276/2022, which are independent
of the present Original Application.
6.2. Consequential relief(s), if any, shall follow on a case to-case basis in
terms of the MACP Scheme. The respondents are directed to restore the
applicant’s pay/pension and refund any amount recovered, if applicable,
within a period of two months from the date of receipt of a certified copy
of this order, failing which interest at GPF rates shall be payable for the
period of default until the date of actual payment.
6.3. The O.A. is allowed in the aforesaid terms. M.A.s, if any, shall stand
disposed of. No Costs.”
25. The respondents attempt to distinguish that case by pointing out that the
applicant was not necessarily a member of the said Association, which
instituted the proceedings and that WP (C) No.9890/2019 arose from a
different Association. They also contended that the MACP controversy
in the writ proceedings concerned employees who had received
upgraded pay scales and that the issue was therefore not identical to the
applicant's individual case. The objection has some relevance for
determining the direct binding effect of a judgment inter parties.
However, it does not resolve the present controversy. The applicant
does not merely rely upon the earlier decision to assert that he
rd
automatically became entitled to the 3 MACP from 28.03.2012. His
more immediate contention is that the very foundation on which his
2026.10.01
PRATIK VYAS
15:52:15+05'30'

: 32: OA No.120/416/2023

pensionary benefits were withheld was subsequently removed by the
adjudication of the MACP dispute as quoted above.
26. We note that the applicants therein also had been granted financial
upgradations by the respondents themselves and that the withdrawal was
subsequently founded upon departmental clarification. It also examined
the relationship between the MACP scheme, the earlier departmental
orders and the pending writ proceedings. Significantly, the Principal
Bench of this Tribunal found fault with the withdrawal because it had
been effected without proper application of mind and without issuance
of show-cause notice, despite the benefits having earlier been granted by
the respondents after following the prescribed procedure. The Principal
Bench of this Tribunal further held that withdrawal could not be
justified merely on the basis of a later clarification, particularly where
the original grant had been made after following the departmental
procedure. Ultimately Principal Bench of this Tribunal set aside the
impugned orders dated 18.03.2015 and 20.07.2015, while expressly
preserving the rights and contentions of the parties in the pending writ
proceedings.
27. The significance of the aforesaid decision for the present case is
therefore twofold. First, it demonstrates that the issue regarding
rd
withdrawal of the 3 MACP was not a case of an employee having
obtained a benefit by fraud or misrepresentation. It was a dispute
concerning the interpretation and application of the MACP Scheme by
the departmental authorities. Second, the subsequent adjudication
substantially weakens the respondents' attempt to treat the alleged
excess payment as an undisputed and crystallized debt immediately
recoverable from the applicant. At the very least, so long as the legal
foundation of the recovery remained subject to adjudication, the
respondents could not reasonably insist that the applicant must first
surrender the disputed amount as a condition precedent to release of his
pensionary entitlements.
2026.10.01
PRATIK VYAS
15:52:15+05'30'

: 33: OA No.120/416/2023

28. The respondents have placed considerable reliance upon the pendency
of WP(C) No.9890/2019, contending that the said proceedings concern
rd
the admissibility of 3 MACP to employees who had been granted
upgraded pay scales and that the applicant's pension should therefore
remain provisional until final adjudication. This submission cannot be
accepted in its broad form. The pendency of litigation may justify
protection of the Government's financial interest, but it does not
automatically justify indefinite deprivation of an employee's pensionary
benefits, particularly where the departmental authorities themselves had
been directed to release final pension upon obtaining an undertaking.
There is a fundamental distinction between: (i) withholding pension
because pension itself is lawfully liable to be withheld under the pension
rules, and (ii) releasing pension subject to an undertaking preserving the
Government's right to recover an amount if ultimately found payable.
29. The administrative instructions issued after the order in OA
No.2691/2021 clearly contemplated the latter course. The respondents
therefore could not continue indefinitely with the former course merely
by invoking the pendency of the writ proceedings.
30. It is also necessary to keep separate two questions which appear to have
been conflated by the respondents. The first is what pension is legally
admissible to the applicant. The second is whether the Government can
recover a particular amount which was allegedly paid in excess. Even
assuming, for the sake of argument, that the respondents ultimately
rd
establish that the applicant's 3 MACP was wrongly granted from
28.03.2012, it does not necessarily follow that the entire pensionary
entitlement could be withheld until the applicant deposits the alleged
excess amount. Pension is not in the nature of a discretionary ex gratia
payment. Once an employee has rendered qualifying service and
superannuated, pensionary benefits become governed by the applicable
pension rules. Any withholding must, therefore, have a clear foundation
in those rules or in a legally sustainable order.
2026.10.01
PRATIK VYAS
15:52:15+05'30'

: 34: OA No.120/416/2023

31. The respondents' own conduct in granting provisional pension and 90%
gratuity confirms that the applicant's basic entitlement to pension and
gratuity was not in dispute.
32. What remained disputed was the adjustment/recovery arising from the
MACP issue. The respondents' contention regarding the grade pay of
Rs.4800/-. The respondents have also sought to justify the withdrawal
on the ground that, even apart from the date of entitlement, the applicant
could not have received Grade Pay Rs.4800/- because the relevant
promotional hierarchy carried Grade Pays of Rs.4200/- and Rs.4600/-.
rd
They, therefore, submitted that the 3 MACP in the applicant's case
ought to have been in Grade Pay Rs.4600/- and not Rs.4800/-. This
contention may have relevance for determination of the applicant's
correct pay fixation, but it cannot justify the manner in which his
pension was withheld. The proper course, if the respondents were of the
view that the applicant's pay had been wrongly fixed, was to undertake a
lawful re-fixation in accordance with the applicable MACP provisions
and thereafter determine the consequential pensionary entitlement. The
existence of a dispute as to the correct grade pay does not authorize the
administration to indefinitely withhold undisputed retiral benefits.
33. Moreover, the decision dated 28.08.2025 in OA No.3035/2015
demonstrates that the underlying MACP controversy involved questions
of interpretation and application of the scheme and could not be reduced
to a simple case of an employee having received money through fraud
or misrepresentation.
34 . Another circumstance which cannot be overlooked is the extraordinary
period for which the applicant has remained deprived of final
rd
settlement. The 3 MACP was granted in 2012. The departmental
authorities purportedly withdrew it in 2016, yet admittedly the
withdrawal was not implemented by the applicant's local office and the
applicant continued to be treated as drawing the benefit even when his
pay was subsequently re-fixed in 2020. The applicant retired in May
2022. Even thereafter, instead of finalizing the pensionary benefits, the
2026.10.01
PRATIK VYAS
15:52:15+05'30'

: 35: OA No.120/416/2023

matter continued to be kept pending. The applicant repeatedly
represented to the authorities, including on 13.06.2022, 10.10.2022,
18.11.2022, 30.01.2023 and 23.05.2023. Such prolonged withholding
cannot be sustained merely by repeatedly referring to a pending dispute,
particularly when the employee has already offered to abide by the final
result. The applicant's undertaking dated 13.06.2022 is also of
considerable significance. The applicant had expressly undertaken to
abide by the outcome of the pending litigation and to refund any excess
payment, if ultimately found payable. Therefore, the Government's
legitimate concern regarding possible financial loss stood substantially
protected. The subsequent departmental instruction dated 06.10.2022
itself contemplated precisely such a mechanism for release of final
pensionary benefits upon obtaining an undertaking that excess payment,
if found payable after the litigation, could be recovered. In these
circumstances, insisting that the applicant should first deposit the very
amount whose legal recoverability remains disputed amounts, in
substance, to converting a disputed future liability into a condition
precedent for receiving pension. That approach cannot be countenanced.
35. The position has become even clearer because, during the pendency of
the present OA, the Principal Bench of this Tribunal has rendered its
final decision dated 28.08.2025 in OA No.3035/2015, the relevant
portion of which has already quoted above. The applicant has
specifically brought this subsequent development to the notice of this
Bench of the Tribunal and contended that the very basis on which the
respondents withheld his retiral benefits no longer survives. The
respondents' defence, on the other hand, was principally constructed
around the proposition that the MACP issue remained sub judice . Once
the proceedings in OA No.3035/2015 were finally adjudicated, that
factual premise could no longer remain unqualified.
36. At the very least, the respondents were required to reconsider the
applicant's case in the light of the subsequent decision of this Tribunal
in OA No.3035 of 2015 (Principal Bench) instead of mechanically
2026.10.01
PRATIK VYAS
15:52:15+05'30'

: 36: OA No.120/416/2023

continuing the withholding. The respondents cannot derive advantage
from their own administrative lapse.
37. It is also material that the respondents themselves failed to implement
their order dated 17.11.2016 for several years. The applicant's case is
that the order did not reach the Ahmedabad office and, therefore,
continued to be ignored even when his pay was re-fixed in 2020. The
respondents cannot, therefore, simultaneously rely upon the 2016
withdrawal order to contend that the applicant's receipt of the benefit
was unauthorized from that date, while their own establishment
continued to treat him as entitled to the benefit for purposes of pay
fixation and service records. An employee cannot reasonably be
expected to discover and act upon an internal departmental order which
was neither communicated to him nor implemented by the competent
local establishment. This aspect becomes especially important when the
respondents seek recovery from a retired employee on the footing that
the excess payment continued because of his knowledge and consent.
38 . The decision in OA No.3035/2015 also assumes significance on the
question of natural justice. The Principal Bench of this Tribunal, while
examining the withdrawal of the MACP benefits, found fault with
withdrawal effected without proper application of mind and without
issuance of a show-cause notice, particularly where the benefit had
earlier been granted after following the prescribed procedure. Although
the applicant before us was not necessarily a party to that proceeding,
the principle is relevant. Where an employee has been granted a
recurring financial benefit under a formal departmental order, and the
administration subsequently seeks to retrospectively alter the financial
consequences and recover substantial amounts, the action cannot be
treated as a mere clerical correction if it adversely affects vested
financial consequences. The administration must establish the legal
authority for the correction as well as compliance with the procedural
safeguards applicable to such adverse action.
2026.10.01
PRATIK VYAS
15:52:15+05'30'

: 37: OA No.120/416/2023

39 . The respondents undoubtedly have a legitimate right to ensure that no
employee ultimately retains a financial benefit which, upon final
adjudication, is found to have been wrongly paid. But that right must be
balanced against the equally important right of a retired employee to
receive his lawful pension and other retiral benefits without avoidable
delay. The appropriate balance, in our considered view, lies in releasing
the applicant's admissible final pensionary benefits without requiring
him to deposit the disputed amount as a precondition, while preserving
the respondents' right, subject to law and the final outcome of the
aforesaid Writ Petition, to undertake lawful recovery of any amount
which may ultimately be found recoverable. This approach also accords
with the departmental mechanism contemplated after the decision in OA
No.2691/2021, namely, release of final pensionary benefits upon an
undertaking securing the Government's right to recovery in accordance
with the ultimate outcome.
40 . As regards the applicant's claim for interest at 18% per annum, the same
cannot be granted mechanically merely because there has been delay.
The question of interest has to be determined having regard to the nature
of the delay, the applicable pension rules, and the conduct of the parties.
However, where the Tribunal finds that the respondents had no lawful
justification for continuing to withhold the final pensionary benefits
after the judicial and administrative directions for release, an award of
reasonable interest on the delayed amounts would be justified. The
applicant's prayer for 18% per annum may, therefore, be considered in
accordance with the settled approach of the courts, rather than being
granted automatically at the contractual/commercial rate claimed by
him.
41. On an overall consideration of the matter, we find that the respondents
have proceeded on an erroneous premise that the pendency of the said
Writ Petition entitled them to keep the applicant's pension provisional
indefinitely and to make payment of the alleged excess amount a
condition precedent for release of his final retiral dues. The respondents
2026.10.01
PRATIK VYAS
15:52:15+05'30'

: 38: OA No.120/416/2023

rd
may be correct to the limited extent that the original grant of 3 MACP
cannot be treated as conclusively valid merely because it was granted by
an administrative order. However, that proposition does not confer upon
them an unrestricted power to withhold the applicant's pensionary
benefits for an indefinite period. The facts are materially distinguishable
from a case involving fraud, misrepresentation or deliberate suppression
rd
by an employee. The 3 MACP was granted by the departmental
authorities themselves; the applicant continued to receive the benefit for
years; the departmental authorities themselves failed to implement the
withdrawal order for a considerable period; and the controversy
subsequently became the subject matter of judicial proceedings. The
applicant, moreover, offered to abide by the final outcome and refund
any amount lawfully found recoverable.
42 . In the result, for the foregoing discussions, we ultimately observe that
the applicant is entitled to release of his regular/final pension and all
other admissible retiral benefits, including commutation, balance
gratuity and leave encashment, subject to lawful determination of his
pension after taking into account the final judicial position concerning
the MACP issue. The respondents shall not insist upon prior deposit of
the disputed amount of ₹7,74,490/- (or the subsequently revised
amount) as a condition precedent for release of the applicant's
pensionary dues. Equally, the applicant's undertaking already furnished
may be treated as sufficient protection of the respondents' interest,
subject to any further undertaking only if strictly required by the
applicable rules and not as a device to postpone payment indefinitely.
The claim for recovery of the alleged excess payment shall, however,
remain subject to the governing MACP provisions, the final outcome of
the pending aforesaid Writ Petition (Civil) No.9890/2019, and the
principles laid down by the Hon'ble Supreme Court governing recovery
from employees, particularly the equitable limitations recognized in
Rafiq Masih (supra). The fact that the applicant has already retired is a
particularly important circumstance against coercive recovery. The
2026.10.01
PRATIK VYAS
15:52:15+05'30'

: 39: OA No.120/416/2023

respondents shall accordingly undertake a fresh exercise for finalization
of the applicant's pensionary benefits in the light of OA No.2691/2021,
the consequential departmental instructions, and the subsequent decision
dated 28.08.2025 in OA No.3035/2015, and release the admissible dues
within a stipulated period.
43. In view of the above, the present OA is allowed in terms of the
following directions:-
(i) The respondents are directed to release of the applicant's final
pensionary benefits;
(ii) The respondents shall be at liberty to take such action for recovery,
if any, as may ultimately become legally permissible, but only in
accordance with the applicable rules and the binding decisions of
the Hon’ble Courts, and not by withholding the applicant's
pensionary benefits indefinitely; and
(iii) The above exercise shall be complied with within a period of two
months from the date of receipt of a certified copy of this Order.
44. There shall be no order as to costs.
45. Pending MA(s), if any, shall stand disposed of accordingly.



(Sanjiv Kumar) (Jayesh V. Bhairavia)
Member (A) Member (J)



/pv/nk/
2026.10.01
PRATIK VYAS
15:52:15+05'30'