Sukhbir And Others vs State Of Haryana And Others

Court
Punjab and Haryana High Court

CWP CWP-37037 CWP CWP 37037 37037-2026 37037 2026 2026 2026 -1-



IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB & HARYANA AT CHANDIGARH IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB & HARYANA AT CHANDIGARH IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB & HARYANA AT CHANDIGARH IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB & HARYANA AT CHANDIGARH



CWP CWP CWP-37037 CWP 37037 37037-2026 37037 2026 2026 2026
Date of decision : 11.11.2026

Sukhbir and others

... Petitioners

Versus

State of Haryana and others

... Respondents

CORAM: CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTIC CORAM: CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTIC HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE VIKAS BAHL HON'BLE MR. JUSTIC E VIKAS BAHL E VIKAS BAHL E VIKAS BAHL
HON’BLE M HON’BLE MS. JUSTICE HON’BLE M HON’BLE M . JUSTICE . JUSTICE DIVYA SHARMA . JUSTICE DIVYA SHARMA DIVYA SHARMA DIVYA SHARMA

Present: Mr. Aalok Jagga, Advocate,
Ms.Richa Tayal, Advocate,
Ms.Khushi Bhatia, Advocate and
Mr.Sahil Lohan, Advocate
for the petitioners.

Mr. Deepak Bhardwaj, Addl. AG, Haryana.

VIKAS BAH VIKAS BAHL, J.(ORAL) VIKAS BAH VIKAS BAH L, J.(ORAL) L, J.(ORAL) L, J.(ORAL)

1. In the present writ petition, following prayers have been made:-

“Civil Writ Petition under Articles 226/227 of the Constitution of India,
with the prayer that this Hon'ble Court may be pleased to direct respondent
No. 2 to conduct the draw of lots for plots earmarked under the No Profit
No Loss category (NPNL) in the project, namely Flower Valley, Central
Park, situated in Sectors 29, 30, 32 and 33, Sohna, District Gurugram,
being developed by respondent No. 3, in a time bound schedule by
uploading in the public domain the list of applicants in NPNL category,
under its supervision, with a further prayer that such draw of lots be
videographed and petitioners may be permitted to witness through their
physical presence.
It is still further prayed that this Hon'ble Court may be pleased to issue an
appropriate writ, order or direction directing respondent No. 2 to inquire
DAVINDER KUMAR
2026.11.18 10:19
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this
order/judgment

CWP CWP-37037 CWP CWP 37037 37037-2026 37037 2026 2026 2026 -2-


into the illegal allotments being made by respondent No. 3 by diverting
plots earmarked for the NPNL category for its private use, and to take
necessary action, including cancellation of the licence in terms of Section
8 of the Haryana Development and Regulation of Urban Areas Act, 1975
and the Rules framed thereunder, as also in view of the violation of Clause
21 of the bilateral agreement dated 29.01.20, Annexure P-1, and to restore
the earmarked NPNL plots to the said category.
It is still further prayed that this Hon'ble Court may be pleased to direct
respondent No. 2 to follow its earlier decision dated 19.09.24 (Annexure
P-17) for conducting the draw of lots for the NPNL category in the project
being developed by respondent No. 3 as well, since the entire process lacks
transparency, to the prejudice of the applicants/petitioners.
It is still further prayed that this Hon'ble Court may be pleased to issue any
other appropriate writ, order or direction as this Hon'ble Court may deem
fit in the peculiar facts and circumstances of the present case.
It is still further prayed that, during the pendency of the present petition,
respondent Nos. 2 and 3 may be directed to ensure that no further
allotment of NPNL category plots is carried out by respondent No. 3, nor
the said plots diverted to any other category, until the draw of lots is
conducted in a transparent manner.”


2. Learned counsel for the petitioners has submitted that
respondent no.3 was granted four licences i.e., licence no.54 of 2014, 28 of
2016, 7 of 2020 and 104 of 2021. It is submitted that a bilateral agreement
was executed between respondents no.2 and 3 in terms of Rule 11 of the
Haryana Development and Regulation of Urban Areas Rules 1976
(hereinafter to be referred to as “1976 Rules”) which stipulated that there
would be reservation of residential plots under the No Profit No Loss
(NPNL) category and that the allotment of the said plots would be made
through a draw of lots where the number of applicants exceeded the number
of available plots. It is further submitted that the petitioners, who are 30 in
number, had applied to respondent no.3 for allotment of the plots under the
DAVINDER KUMAR
2026.11.18 10:19
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this
order/judgment

CWP CWP-37037 CWP CWP 37037 37037-2026 37037 2026 2026 2026 -3-


NPNL category in the project known as Flower Valley, Central Park,
situated in Sectors 29, 30, 32 and 33, Sohna, District Gurugram and along
with the said application, the petitioners had submitted an amount of Rs.6
lacs as earnest money. It is submitted that the said application had been filed
on 22.07.2025 but no draw of lots had been held till today and as per the
information of the petitioners, respondent no.3 wants to divert the plots
which are meant for the NPNL category to some other category. It is
submitted that in the said circumstances, apart from other actions,
respondent no.3 should also be liable for proceedings under Section 8 of the
1976 Act.
3. Learned counsel for the petitioners has submitted that in similar
circumstances, where the colonizer was not adhering to Rule 11 of the 1976
Rules, a writ petition i.e., CWP-5472-2024 was filed which was disposed of
vide order dated 07.03.2024. The said order has been annexed as Annexure
P-15 along with the present writ petition. It is submitted that thereafter the
Director of Town & Country Planning, Haryana, had passed a speaking
order in pursuance of the said decision taken by the Co-ordinate Division
Bench and the relevant portion of the said order dated 19.09.2024, which
has been highlighted before this Court, is reproduced hereinbelow:-
“DTP (HQ) apprised that the provisions of the Haryana
Development and Regulation of Urban Areas Act, 1975 & Rules 1976,
does not provide mandatory requirement of monitoring the process of
allotment of NPNL category plots, however, only fixation of rates to be
done by the Department. The said requirement has already been made the
Department by fixing the rates of NPNL plots, which was duly conveyed
to the colonizer on dated 17.11.2023.
8. Matter is heard. Keeping in view of the aforesaid facts, report of
scrutiny committee and relevant provisions of the Act/Rules, I order
DAVINDER KUMAR
2026.11.18 10:19
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this
order/judgment

CWP CWP-37037 CWP CWP 37037 37037-2026 37037 2026 2026 2026 -4-


accordingly that:-
i. The developer i.e. EROS City Developers Pvt. Ltd. is directed to
conduct the draw of lot of 171 applications (excluding 12 no. of
applications received after cutoff date, which have already been
rejected/returned by the colonizer and one application withdrawn by the
applicant) received under NPNL category plots before cut of date i.e.
24.10.2019.
ii. The list of 171 applicants (along with their other details) participating
the draw of lot should be properly displayed at developers site office,
Senior Town Planner, Faridabad office and District Town Planner,
Faridabad office notice board.
iii. Deputy Commissioner, Faridabad is requested to convene the draw of
lot manually in transparent manner.
iv. The developer i.e. EROS City Developers Pvt. Ltd. is directed to
coordinate with the Deputy Commissioner, Faridabad to get the suitable
date, time and venue for draw and intimate regarding the draw of lot to all
the concerned applicants at least two weeks prior to the date of draw.
v. Senior Town Planner, Faridabad is directed to coordinate and provide
all necessary assistance required to Deputy Commissioner, Faridabad to
conduct the draw smoothly and transparent manner.
Dated: 19.09.2024 (Amit Khatri, IAS)
Director, Town & Country Planning
Haryana, Chandigarh”

4. It is further submitted that prior to the passing of the said
speaking order dated 19.09.2024, the colonizer who was aggrieved with the
action sought to be taken by the petitioner therein, had also filed CWP-
20710-2024 which was decided vide order dated 30.08.2024. The relevant
portion of the said order, which has been highlighted, is reproduced
hereinbelow:-
“3. When the present writ petition came up for hearing for the first
time on 27.08.2024, Mr. Ankur Mittal, Additional Advocate General,
Haryana, prayed for some time to seek instructions and /or submit an
affidavit as regards the hearing scheduled to be held on 04.09.2024.
Pursuant to that, affidavit dated 29.08.2024 of the Director Town &
DAVINDER KUMAR Country Planning Haryana was filed in the Court on 29.08.2024. In the
2026.11.18 10:19
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this
order/judgment

CWP CWP-37037 CWP CWP 37037 37037-2026 37037 2026 2026 2026 -5-


said affidavit while regretting the delay that has occurred in passing an
order in terms of our order dated 07.03.2024 and tendering an apology on
his request, it has been averred that a Committee has been constituted to
scrutinize the applications submitted by the applicants for allotment of
NPNL plots:
“That the delay occurred in passing the order is highly
regretted it was unintentional, the answering respondent tender
unconditional apology for the same. However, in order to ensure
timely compliance the answering respondent vide order dated
28.08.2024 has constituted a committee headed by the Senior Town
Planner, Faridabad with following representatives to scrutinize the
applications submitted by the applicants before the petitioners for
allotment of NPNL plots, considering all aspects raised by the
petitioners in the CWP No. 5472 of 2024 including the date of
receipts of applications vis-à-vis cutoff date etc.:-
i) Senior Town Planer, Faridabad - Chairman.
ii) District Town Planner, Faridabad - Member.
iii) Representative of developer/petitioner.
iv) Representative of petitioners of CWP No. 5472 of 2024.
Further, the petitioner (developer) and the petitioner of
CWP No. 5472 of 2024 has been directed to provide the following
information in the office of Senior Town Planner, Faridabad on or
before 03.09.2024:-
i) Name of representative who will be part of scrutiny by the
aforesaid committee.
ii) All the relevant original records pertaining to inviting
applications and applications received regarding NPNL
plots.
8. That the stakeholders including petitioner will be directed to
confirm on the next date of hearing i.e. 04.09.2024 that all relevant
record related to applications for NPNL plots has been submitted in
the office of Senior Town Planner, Faridabad. However, in case
any of the stakeholders required to submit some additional
documents then last opportunity will be provided to submit the
same before 3:00 PM on 06.09.2024 in the office of Senior Town
Planner, Faridabad.
Thereafter, the constituted committee shall scrutinize the
applications and submit the report regarding the eligible
DAVINDER KUMAR
2026.11.18 10:19
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this
order/judgment

CWP CWP-37037 CWP CWP 37037 37037-2026 37037 2026 2026 2026 -6-


applications to the answering respondent by 16.09.2024. After
receipt of report of the committee, the answering respondent shall
grant opportunity of hearing to all stakeholders including Senior
Town Planner, Faridabad on 19.09.2024 and will pass the speaking
order by 20.09.2024."
4. We have heard learned counsel for the parties.
5. Learned Senior counsel representing the petitioner submits that the
petitioner is agreeable to the course suggested by respondent No.1 as also
the time-line given in the affidavit. He, however, submits that instead of a
representative of the petitioner and the private respondent being made a
part of the Committee, they can be associated with the Committee during
the scrutiny of applications.
6. Learned Additional Advocate General, Haryana, on instructions,
submits that respondent No.1 would have no objection in not making the
representative of the petitioner and the private respondent as Members of
the Committee and instead simply associating them in the process of
scrutiny of applications etc.
7. Learned counsel for the parties are therefore, ad idem that with the
aforesaid modification in the structure of the Committee, let the necessary
exercise be carried out by respondent No.1 in terms of the schedule given
in the affidavit. It has also been undertaken that parties shall abide by the
said scheduled and shall duly co-operate during the proceedings.
8. The writ petition is accordingly disposed of in the above terms.
We are sanguine that the authorities shall arrive at a decision in
accordance with law within the time period laid down in the affidavit and
extracted in the preceding paragraphs. However, nothing observed herein
above shall be construed to be an opinion on the merits of the case.”

5. Learned counsel for the petitioners has submitted that a perusal
of the order dated 30.08.2024 passed by the Co-ordinate Bench as well as
the order dated 19.09.2024 passed by the Director, Town & Country
Planning, Haryana in the case of Eros City Developers Pvt. Ltd would show
that in order to resolve the issue with respect to the allotment of NPNL
plots, a committee was constituted which included the Senior Town
Planner, District Town Planner and other persons and the said Committee
DAVINDER KUMAR
2026.11.18 10:19
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this
order/judgment

CWP CWP-37037 CWP CWP 37037 37037-2026 37037 2026 2026 2026 -7-


had carried out the process in accordance with law under the supervision of
the Deputy Commissioner. Learned counsel for the petitioners has
submitted that, at this stage, the petitioners would be satisfied, in case
respondent no.2 is directed to look into the legal notice dated 18.08.2025
(Annexure P-10) and take appropriate action in accordance with law.
6. Learned counsel for the respondents-State has submitted that
respondent no.2 would look into the legal notice dated 18.08.2025 and
would take action in accordance with law after taking into consideration the
speaking order and the orders passed in the abovesaid writ petitions.
7. Keeping in view the above said facts and circumstances, the
present writ petition is disposed of with the following observations /
directions:-
i) Respondent no.2 would look into the averments made in
the legal notice dated 18.08.2025 (Annexure P-10) within a
period of two months from today and would also give an
opportunity of hearing to the petitioners / their authorized
representative and in case respondent no.2 is of the opinion that
the averments made in the legal notice as well as the facts put
forth by the petitioners / their authorized representative are
meritorious, then, respondent no.2 would initiate appropriate
action in accordance with law and resolve the entire issue, as
expeditiously as possible.
ii) While considering the action to be taken, respondent no.2
would also take into consideration the orders passed by the Co-
ordinate Division Bench of this Court in CWP-5472-2024,
DAVINDER KUMAR
2026.11.18 10:19
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this
order/judgment

CWP CWP-37037 CWP CWP 37037 37037-2026 37037 2026 2026 2026 -8-


CWP-20710-2024 as well as the speaking order dated
19.09.2024.
8. It is made clear that this Court has not opined on the merits of
the case and respondent no.2 would proceed in the matter independently, in
accordance with law.
9. In case respondent no.3 is aggrieved of the present order, it
would be open to respondent no.3 to seek recall of the present order.


(VIKAS BAHL) (VIKAS BAHL) (VIKAS BAHL) (VIKAS BAHL)
JUDGE JUDGE JUDGE JUDGE


(DIVYA SHARMA DIVYA SHARMA DIVYA SHARMA) DIVYA SHARMA

JUDGE JUDGE JUDGE JUDGE

November 11 November 11, 2026. November 11 November 11 , 2026. , 2026. , 2026.
Davinder Kumar

Whether speaking / reasoned Yes/No
Whether reportable Yes/No
DAVINDER KUMAR
2026.11.18 10:19
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this
order/judgment