Manoj Kumar vs KVS
- Court
- Central Administrative Tribunal
1
Item No. 52/ C-III O.A. No. 370/2025
Central Administrative Tribunal
Principal Bench: New Delhi
O.A. No. 370/2025
th
This the 26 day of October, 2026
Hon’ble Mr. Manish Garg, Member (J)
Manoj Kumar, Aged- 42 Years
S/o Sh. Abhey Singh,
Working as PGT (Math) in KVS and
Presently posted in K.V. No. 1, AFS, Gurugram (Har),
R/o H. No. 290, Sector 4, Near Blue Bells, Senior Secondary
School, Gurugram (Har). …Applicant
(By Advocate: Mr. Yogesh Sharma)
Versus
1. Kendriya Vidyalaya Sangathan,
Through the Commissioner,
18, Institutional Area,
Shaheed Jeet Singh Marg,
New Delhi-110016
2. The Deputy Commissioner,
Kendriya Vidhyalaya Sangathan,
Gurugram Region, KV No. 1 Campus,
Old Delhi Road, Gurugram (Har).
3. The Deputy Commissioner,
Kendriya Vidyalaya Sangathan,
JNU Campus, Delhi Region,
New Delhi,
4. The Principal,
Kendriya Vidyalya Sector 5,
Dwarka, New Delhi-75. …Respondents
(By Advocate: Mr. Ashish Yadav, Mr. Shubhranshu Padhi,
Mr. Anuj Yadav)
Digitally signed
by NEETU
SHARMA
Date: 2026.11.05
11:50:36+05'30'
NEETU
SHARMA
2
Item No. 52/ C-III O.A. No. 370/2025
ORDER (ORAL)
In the present O.A. filed under Section 19 of the
Administrative Tribunals Act, 1985, the applicant seeks the
following reliefs:
“(i) That the Hon’ble Tribunal may further graciously be
pleased to pass an order of quashing the impugned Warning
dated 31.8.2021 declaring to the effect that the same is illegal,
arbitrary and against the rules and consequently, pass an
order directing the respondents to remove the same from the
service file of the applicant, and same may not be place before
any committee/DPC etc.
(ii) Any other relief which the Hon’ble Tribunal deem fit and
proper may also be granted to the applicant along with the
costs of litigation.”
2. Highlighting the facts of the case, learned counsel for the
applicant submits that the applicant was initially appointed
as Trained Graduate Teacher (Mathematics) in Kendriya
Vidyalaya Sangathan (KVS) on 15.11.2008 and was
subsequently promoted as PGT (Mathematics) in 2016. While
posted at Kendriya Vidyalaya, Sector-5, Dwarka, New Delhi,
he submitted a representation dated 27.02.2021 alleging
discriminatory treatment in the allocation of invigilation
duties. Pursuant thereto, an inquiry was conducted, and the
Principal issued an advisory dated 31.08.2021 regarding his
conduct and behaviour towards colleagues. The applicant
alleges that the inquiry report and advisory were not
communicated to him at the relevant time and were retained
Digitally signed
by NEETU
SHARMA
Date: 2026.11.05
11:50:36+05'30'
NEETU
SHARMA
3
Item No. 52/ C-III O.A. No. 370/2025
in his personal/service record without affording him an
adequate opportunity to represent against the observations
made therein.
3. The applicant states that he came to know about the said
documents after his transfer to Kendriya Vidyalaya No. 1,
Gurugram, and obtained copies through the respondents’
communication dated 24.04.2024, following his requests and
an RTI application. Thereafter, he submitted representations
dated 03.06.2024 and 03.07.2024 seeking expunction of the
advisory, but claims that no decision was communicated to
him. Aggrieved, the applicant has filed the present O.A. under
Section 19 of the Administrative Tribunals Act, 1985, seeking
quashing of the advisory dated 31.08.2021, its removal from
his service record, and a direction that it not be considered by
any committee or Departmental Promotion Committee
(DPC). Hence, the present O.A.
4. Impugned order dated 31.08.2021 (Annexure-A/1) reads
as under:-
“Mr. Manoj Kumar, PGT (Math) is instructed to control his
temper while dealing with his colleague and your behavior
towards ladies should be dignified. You are also required to be
considered and work with attitude of team spirit.”
5. The premises on which the Advisory, in the form of the
impugned order dated 31.08.2021 (Annexure-A/1) , has
Digitally signed
by NEETU
SHARMA
Date: 2026.11.05
11:50:36+05'30'
NEETU
SHARMA
4
Item No. 52/ C-III O.A. No. 370/2025
been issued are contained in the Office Memorandum dated
06.12.2026 (Annexure-A/8) , which reads as under::-
“Subject: CCS (CCA) Rules, 1965 — Clarification regarding
effect of warning, censure etc on promotion.
The undersigned is directed to refer to this Department's O.M.
No. 11012/6/2008- Estt.(A) dated 7th July, 2008 on the above
mentioned subject and to say that vide para 2(iii) of the said
OM, it was instructed that where a departmental proceeding
has been instituted, and it is considered that a Government
servant deserves to be penalized for the offence/misconduct,
one of the prescribed penalties may only be awarded and no
warning, recordable or otherwise, should be issued to the
Government servant. However, while considering cases for
empanelment, the ACC has observed that in many cases,
rather than exonerating the officer or imposing a penalty on
him, administrative warning is issued even when disciplinary
proceeding were drawn against him. Administrative warning
is not recognized as a penalty.
2. In view of the above, the following position as contained in
various instructions issued so far on warning/Censure etc. are
reiterated for strict compliance:-
(i) As clarified in the Ministry of Home Affairs O.M. No.
th
39/21/56-Estt.(A) dated 13 December, 1956, warning is
administrated by any authority superior to a Government
employee in the event of minor lapses like negligence,
carelessness, lack of thoroughness, delay etc. It is an
administrative device in the hands of superior authorities for
cautioning the Government employees with a view to toning
up efficiency and maintaining discipline. There is, therefore,
no objection to the continuance of this system. However, where
a copy of the warning is also kept in the Confidential Report
dossier, it will be taken to constitute an adverse entry and the
officer so warned will have the right to represent against the
same in accordance with the existing instructions relating to
communication of adverse remarks and consideration of
representations against them.
(ii) Where a departmental proceeding has been instituted
under the provisions of CCS(CC&A) Rules 1965, after the
conclusion of disciplinary proceedings, the officer is either
exonerated or where it is considered that some blame attaches
to the officer, he should be awarded one of the recognized
statutory penalties as given in Rule 11 of the CCS (CCA) Rules,
1965 i.e. at least 'Censure' should be imposed. In such a
Digitally signed
by NEETU
SHARMA
Date: 2026.11.05
11:50:36+05'30'
NEETU
SHARMA
5
Item No. 52/ C-III O.A. No. 370/2025
situation, a warning, recordable or otherwise, should not be
issued.
(iii) Warning, letter of caution, reprimands or advisories
administered to Government servants do not amount to a
penalty and, therefore, will not constitute a bar for
consideration of such Government servants for promotion.
3. All the disciplinary authorities in Ministries/Departments
are, therefore, requested to keep in view the above guidelines
while dealing with disciplinary case against the Government
servants.”
6. Learned counsel for the applicant submits that the said
advisory the applicant submitted his representation dated
03.07.2024 to the Deputy Commissioner, KVS Regional
Office, New Delhi and the same was forwarded through
proper channel to the Deputy Commissioner, Delhi Region
vide letter dated 22.07.2024 and till date no decision has
been taken by the Deputy Commissioner, Delhi Region.
7. Opposing the grant of relief, learned counsel for the
respondents relies upon the averments made in the counter
affidavit. He submits that the impugned administrative
advisory dated 31.08.2021 was issued by the then Principal,
Kendriya Vidyalaya, Sector-5, Dwarka, after due and
objective consideration of the Applicant's representation by a
duly constituted committee. The said advisory was issued
purely in the interest of maintaining institutional discipline,
professional decorum, appropriate staff conduct and smooth
functioning of academic activities in the Vidyalaya.
Digitally signed
by NEETU
SHARMA
Date: 2026.11.05
11:50:36+05'30'
NEETU
SHARMA
6
Item No. 52/ C-III O.A. No. 370/2025
7.1 It is further submitted that the impugned communication
is merely in the nature of administrative guidance and
caution and does not constitute any penalty, censure or
disciplinary warning within the meaning of Rule 11 of the CCS
(CCA) Rules, 1965. The same was neither issued pursuant to
any disciplinary proceedings nor intended to operate as a
punishment against the applicant. Learned counsel further
submits that the issuance of the aforesaid advisory has not
resulted in any civil or adverse service consequences against
the applicant. It has neither affected his seniority nor his
promotion, increments or any other service benefits.
Therefore, in the absence of any demonstrable prejudice or
infringement of the applicant's service rights, the impugned
advisory does not give rise to any legally enforceable cause of
action warranting interference by this Tribunal. With regard
to the allegation that the impugned advisory was
incorporated in the applicant's Service Book or permanent
service records, learned counsel categorically denies the
same. It is submitted that no adverse remark or entry
pursuant to the said advisory was ever recorded in the
applicant's Service Book, APAR or any other service-related
record. The apprehension expressed by the applicant in this
regard is, therefore, wholly unfounded and without any
factual basis.
Digitally signed
by NEETU
SHARMA
Date: 2026.11.05
11:50:36+05'30'
NEETU
SHARMA
7
Item No. 52/ C-III O.A. No. 370/2025
7.2 Learned counsel further submits that the present O.A. is
hopelessly barred by limitation, delay and laches. The
impugned advisory was issued on 31.08.2021, whereas the
present O.A. has been filed only in the year 2025, after an
inordinate delay of nearly four years. The applicant has failed
to establish any continuing cause of action or recurring
adverse consequence arising out of the said advisory. The
mere existence of an administrative communication issued in
the year 2021 cannot constitute a continuing cause of action,
particularly when no adverse service consequence has ever
ensued therefrom. The belated challenge to the advisory is,
therefore, an afterthought and the O.A. is liable to be
dismissed on this ground alone, in terms of Section 21 of the
Administrative Tribunals Act, 1985.
7.3 Learned counsel submits that the respondents have duly
adhered to the principles of natural justice and procedural
fairness. The applicant's initial grievance was examined by an
internal committee constituted for the said purpose. The
applicant was personally heard and was also afforded an
opportunity to submit his point-wise written representation.
His version and submissions were duly considered before the
matter was examined and the consequential administrative
advisory was issued. Thus, there has been no violation of the
Digitally signed
by NEETU
SHARMA
Date: 2026.11.05
11:50:36+05'30'
NEETU
SHARMA
8
Item No. 52/ C-III O.A. No. 370/2025
principles of natural justice or denial of reasonable
opportunity to the applicant.
7.4 It is further submitted that the respondents have
maintained complete transparency in the matter. Upon the
applicant seeking information under the Right to Information
Act, 2005, the relevant advisory document was duly
furnished to him. This clearly demonstrates that the
Respondents have acted fairly and transparently and have not
withheld any relevant information from the applicant.
7.5 Learned counsel further submits that the reliance placed
by the Applicant upon the DoPT Office Memorandum dated
06.12.2016 is wholly misplaced. The said Office
Memorandum, as applicable to the facts of the present case,
distinguishes administrative advisories and cautions from
formal disciplinary penalties and adverse remarks recorded
in service-related assessment records. In the present case, the
impugned advisory was neither treated as a penalty nor
incorporated in the Applicant's APAR, Confidential Report
dossier or Service Book. Consequently, the Applicant cannot
claim any adverse service consequence or violation of his
service rights on the basis of the said Office Memorandum.
7.6 Learned counsel also submits that Kendriya Vidyalaya,
Sector-5, Dwarka falls within the administrative jurisdiction
Digitally signed
by NEETU
SHARMA
Date: 2026.11.05
11:50:36+05'30'
NEETU
SHARMA
9
Item No. 52/ C-III O.A. No. 370/2025
of the Delhi Region of Kendriya Vidyalaya Sangathan.
Accordingly, the applicant was appropriately advised to route
his representations through the prescribed regional
administrative hierarchy. Such advice was consistent with the
established administrative procedure and cannot, by any
stretch of interpretation, be construed as arbitrary, illegal or
contrary to the applicant's rights.
7.7 Learned counsel, therefore, submits that the respondents
have acted in a bona fide manner and strictly within their
administrative authority. The impugned advisory is purely
administrative in nature, does not constitute a penalty under
the applicable service rules, and has not resulted in any
adverse service consequence to the applicant. Further, the
applicant was afforded an adequate opportunity of hearing,
his representation was duly considered, and no adverse entry
was ever made in his service records.
7.8 In view of the aforesaid submissions, learned counsel for
the respondents respectfully submits that the present O.A. is
misconceived, devoid of merit and barred by limitation, delay
and laches. The applicant has failed to establish any illegality,
arbitrariness or violation of statutory rules or principles of
natural justice warranting interference by this Tribunal.
Accordingly, learned counsel for the respondents prays that
the present O.A. may kindly be dismissed with costs, being
Digitally signed
by NEETU
SHARMA
Date: 2026.11.05
11:50:36+05'30'
NEETU
SHARMA
10
Item No. 52/ C-III O.A. No. 370/2025
devoid of merit and not disclosing any legally sustainable
cause of action.
8. I have heard learned counsels for the parties and perused
the pleadings available on record.
9. The controversy in the present case essentially revolves
around the nature and effect of the communication dated
31.08.2021. It is not disputed that the applicant was issued
the impugned communication following an examination of
his representation regarding allocation of invigilation duties.
The respondents themselves describe the communication as
an administrative advisory or caution and categorically deny
that it constitutes a formal disciplinary penalty.
10. It is well settled that every administrative communication
containing advice, caution or guidance to an employee cannot
automatically be treated as a penalty within the meaning of
the applicable disciplinary rules. An employer is entitled to
issue appropriate administrative instructions and guidance to
its employees for maintaining discipline and ensuring the
smooth functioning of an institution. However, the
nomenclature assigned to a communication is not conclusive
of its true nature. Its contents, purpose, manner of issuance
and the consequences flowing therefrom have to be
examined.
Digitally signed
by NEETU
SHARMA
Date: 2026.11.05
11:50:36+05'30'
NEETU
SHARMA
11
Item No. 52/ C-III O.A. No. 370/2025
11. In the present case, the respondents have specifically
asserted that the impugned advisory was not issued as a
disciplinary punishment, was not recorded in the applicant’s
APAR or Service Book and has not adversely affected his
seniority, promotion, increments or any other service
benefits. The applicant, on the other hand, has expressed
apprehension that the advisory may be used against him in
future service-related assessments, including consideration
by a DPC.
12. In our considered view, an administrative advisory which
is not in the nature of a penalty and is not directed to be
incorporated as an adverse entry in the APAR or other service
assessment record cannot, merely by its existence, be treated
as a disciplinary punishment. At the same time, the
respondents cannot be permitted to use such an advisory
indirectly to prejudice the applicant’s service prospects,
particularly when it has not been subjected to the safeguards
prescribed under the applicable disciplinary rules.
13. The position in this regard stands clarified by the
Department of Personnel and Training (DoP&T) vide Office
Memorandum No. 11012/12/2016-Estt.A-III dated
06.12.2016. The said Office Memorandum reiterates that
warnings, letters of caution, reprimands or advisories
administered to Government servants do not amount to a
Digitally signed
by NEETU
SHARMA
Date: 2026.11.05
11:50:36+05'30'
NEETU
SHARMA
12
Item No. 52/ C-III O.A. No. 370/2025
penalty and, therefore, do not constitute a bar to their
consideration for promotion. At the same time, it specifically
clarifies that where a copy of such warning is kept in the
Confidential Report dossier, it would constitute an adverse
entry, entitling the employee concerned to represent against
it in accordance with the applicable instructions.
14. Thus, the distinction between an administrative advisory
and an adverse service entry is of considerable significance.
While the competent administrative authority may issue an
advisory for maintaining discipline and professional
decorum, such advisory cannot be permitted to acquire the
character of an adverse service entry by being retained in the
confidential assessment records or by being relied upon to
assess the suitability of the employee for promotion, without
following the prescribed procedure.
15. In the present case, the respondents have categorically
stated in their counter affidavit that the impugned advisory
has not been incorporated in the applicant's Service Book,
APAR or any other permanent service-related record. They
have also undertaken the position that no adverse service
consequence has flowed from its issuance. In view of this
categorical stand, there is no occasion for this Tribunal to
presume that the advisory has been treated as an adverse
Digitally signed
by NEETU
SHARMA
Date: 2026.11.05
11:50:36+05'30'
NEETU
SHARMA
13
Item No. 52/ C-III O.A. No. 370/2025
entry or that it has adversely affected the applicant’s service
prospects.
16. However, we find substance in the limited apprehension
of the applicant that an administrative advisory, though not a
statutory penalty, should not be subsequently used to
prejudice his service career. The respondents, having
themselves asserted that the advisory is merely
administrative in nature and does not constitute a penalty,
are bound by the consequences flowing from such a stand.
They cannot subsequently adopt a contrary position and use
the said advisory as a ground to deny the applicant promotion
or to assess him adversely in any service-related
consideration.
17. We may also observe that the applicant’s grievance
regarding non-communication of the advisory and the
inquiry report at the relevant time has to be viewed in the
context of the fact that the respondents furnished the relevant
documents to him on 24.04.2024. The applicant thereafter
submitted representations dated 03.06.2024 and
03.07.2024. Although the respondents have asserted that the
applicant was heard by the committee and his written
submissions were considered, the fact remains that the
applicant approached the respondents after obtaining the
relevant documents and sought expunction of the advisory. In
Digitally signed
by NEETU
SHARMA
Date: 2026.11.05
11:50:36+05'30'
NEETU
SHARMA
14
Item No. 52/ C-III O.A. No. 370/2025
the circumstances, the respondents ought to have considered
and communicated a reasoned decision on his
representations.
18. The respondents have raised an objection under Section
21 of the Administrative Tribunals Act, 1985, on the ground
that the impugned advisory was issued on 31.08.2021,
whereas the present O.A. was instituted in 2025.
19. We find that the applicant’s specific case is that the
impugned advisory was not communicated to him when it
was issued and that he obtained a copy only through the
respondents’ communication dated 24.04.2024. He
thereafter submitted representations in June and July 2024.
The respondents have not demonstrated, on the basis of any
material referred to before us, that the advisory was duly
served upon the applicant in 2021 or that he had knowledge
of its contents at that time.
20. Section 21 of the Administrative Tribunals Act, 1985,
prescribes the period of limitation for approaching this
Tribunal. However, in the peculiar facts of the present case,
the respondents cannot seek to calculate the period of
limitation mechanically from the date of issuance of a
communication which, according to the applicant, was never
communicated to him. The date of actual knowledge and the
Digitally signed
by NEETU
SHARMA
Date: 2026.11.05
11:50:36+05'30'
NEETU
SHARMA
15
Item No. 52/ C-III O.A. No. 370/2025
subsequent representations are relevant circumstances for
examining the objection.
22. Nevertheless, mere submission of repeated
representations does not automatically revive a cause of
action which has already become barred by limitation. The
question of limitation has to be determined with reference to
the date of communication or knowledge of the impugned
action and the statutory requirements of Section 21. In the
present case, since the applicant’s substantive prayer for
treating the advisory as a penalty or expunging it altogether is
not found sustainable on the grounds discussed above, we do
not consider it necessary to record a conclusive finding on the
limitation objection.
23. In view of the foregoing discussion, we are of the
considered opinion that the impugned administrative
advisory dated 31.08.2021 cannot be equated with a statutory
penalty or formal censure under Rule 11 of the CCS (CCA)
Rules, 1965. The respondents have categorically denied that
the same has been incorporated in the applicant's Service
Book or APAR. In the absence of any material establishing
that the advisory has been treated as an adverse service entry
or has resulted in any adverse service consequence, we are
not inclined to quash the advisory in its entirety.
Digitally signed
by NEETU
SHARMA
Date: 2026.11.05
11:50:36+05'30'
NEETU
SHARMA
16
Item No. 52/ C-III O.A. No. 370/2025
24. At the same time, we make it clear that the respondents
cannot be permitted to use the impugned advisory, either
directly or indirectly, to prejudice the applicant in his future
service prospects. In particular, the advisory shall not be
treated as a penalty, censure or adverse entry, nor shall it
constitute a ground for denying him promotion or adversely
assessing his suitability by any DPC or other
selection/assessment committee. Any consideration of the
applicant for promotion shall be undertaken strictly in
accordance with the applicable recruitment rules, service
regulations and other relevant instructions, without treating
the impugned advisory as a disqualification or adverse service
factor.
25. We further direct the respondents to ensure that the
impugned advisory dated 31.08.2021, along with the inquiry
report, is not placed or retained in the applicant's APAR
dossier, Confidential Report dossier or any other service
assessment record in a manner that may operate to his
prejudice. If any such entry or document has been placed in
the aforesaid records, the same shall be removed therefrom.
This direction, however, shall not require destruction of the
original administrative correspondence maintained in the
ordinary course of official record-keeping, provided that the
Digitally signed
by NEETU
SHARMA
Date: 2026.11.05
11:50:36+05'30'
NEETU
SHARMA
17
Item No. 52/ C-III O.A. No. 370/2025
same is not used for any adverse service assessment or
decision concerning the applicant.
26. As regards the representations dated 03.06.2024 and
03.07.2024 submitted by the applicant, the competent
authority shall consider the same and communicate a
reasoned decision to the applicant, keeping in view the
observations made hereinabove and the DoP&T Office
Memorandum dated 06.12.2016, within a period of eight
weeks from the date of receipt of a certified copy of this order.
27. It is clarified that we have not examined the correctness
or otherwise of the observations made by the committee
concerning the applicant’s conduct and behaviour, nor have
we expressed any opinion on the underlying allegations
between the applicant and his colleagues.
28. In view of the above, the O.A. stands partly allowed. The
prayer for quashing the administrative advisory in its entirety
is declined. There shall be no order as to costs.
29. Pending M.A., if any, shall also stand disposed of.
(Manish Garg)
Member (J)
/neetu/
Digitally signed
by NEETU
SHARMA
Date: 2026.11.05
11:50:36+05'30'
NEETU
SHARMA