Dhurlab Singh And Anr vs Sukhwinder Singh And Ors

Court
Punjab and Haryana High Court

IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA AT CHANDIGARH

RSA No.689 of 2013 (O&M)
Subedar Dhulab Singh and another . . . Appellants
vs.
Sukhvinder Singh and others . . . Respondents

Reserved on: November 17, 2026
Pronounced on: November 19, 2026
Pronounced fully/opera :ve part : Fully

CORAM: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE DEEPAK GUPTA
Argued By:- Mr. Pritam Singh Saini, Advocate for the appellants.
Mr. Parminder Singh, Advocate for the respondents.
DEEPAK GUPTA, J.
The plain ffs have preferred the present regular second appeal
under Secon 100 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908, assailing the judg-
ment & decree dated 17.09.2012 passed by the learned Addional District
Judge, Karnal, whereby their appeal against the judgment & decree dated
15.03.2010 passed by the learned Addional Civil Judge (Senior Division), As-
sandh, dismissing their suit for declaraon with consequenal relief of joint
possession, was dismissed.
2. Briefly stated, the plainffs instuted a suit seeking declaraon
that the Will dated 15.10.1986, allegedly executed by Surat Singh in favour of
defendant No.1-Nishan Singh, and mutaon No.3426 sanconed on its basis
were illegal, null and void and not binding upon their rights. They also sought
SARITA RANI
2026.11.19 16:43
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
Chandigarh

RSA No.689 of 2013 (O&M) 2026:PHHC: 203717

joint possession of the suit land measuring 20 kanal 6 marla, situated in
village Kheri Sharaf Ali, Tehsil Assandh, District Karnal.
3. The plain ffs pleaded that Surat Singh died on 10.01.1987 and
that they, along with the other legal heirs, had inherited his estate. According
to them, defendant No.1, a;er the death of Surat Singh, took forcible
possession of the suit property on the strength of the alleged Will. The Will
was challenged on the grounds that Surat Singh was not competent to
bequeath the property, the same being ancestral and joint Hindu family
property, and that the Will was the result of fraud, misrepresentaon and
undue influence.
4. Defendant No.1 contested the suit, asserng that Surat Singh
was the absolute owner of the property and had voluntarily executed the
Will in his favour while in a sound disposing state of mind. Preliminary
objecons regarding maintainability, locus standi and limitaon were also
raised.
5. The learned Trial Court, a;er appreciang the evidence, upheld
the Will dated 15.10.1986 and consequently held that the plainffs had no
right, tle or interest in the suit property. It further held that the suit was
barred by limitaon, having been instuted in the year 2002 despite the Will
having been executed in 1986 and mutaon having been sanconed in 1987.
Accordingly, the suit was dismissed.
6. In the first appeal, the learned Addional District Judge re-
appreciated the evidence and reversed the findings of the Trial Court on
Issues No.1 and 2. It was specifically held that defendant No.1 had failed to
prove the due execuon and a?estaon of the Will in accordance with law.
The First Appellate Court noced material discrepancies regarding the
identy and signatures of the a?esng witnesses and held that the statutory
requirements for proving the Will had not been sasfied.
7. Consequently, the First Appellate Court held that the property
would devolve upon the legal heirs of Surat Singh in accordance with Secon
SARITA RANI
2026.11.19 16:43
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
Chandigarh
Page 2 of 9

RSA No.689 of 2013 (O&M) 2026:PHHC: 203717

8 of the Hindu Succession Act, 1956, including the plain ffs. However,
notwithstanding these findings, the appeal was dismissed on the ground that
the suit was barred by limitaon, as the plainffs had failed to explain the
delay in challenging the Will and mutaon.
Rival Submissions of par es
8. Assailing the concurrent judgments of dismissal by the courts
below, Learned counsel for the appellants contends that once the First
Appellate Court had held that the Will was not proved and that the plain ffs
had inherited a share in the estate of Surat Singh, the suit could not have
been dismissed merely on the ground of limitaon. It is submi?ed that
inheritance opens immediately upon the death of the owner and that the
rights of an heir are not exnguished merely because mutaon has been
sanconed in favour of another person. Reliance is placed upon the Division
Bench judgment of this Court in Mohinder Singh (dead) by LRs and another
v. Kashmira Singh, 1985 AIR Punjab and Haryana 215 , and the judgment of
the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Hardev Singh v. Gurmail Singh (dead) by LRs,
2007 AIR SC 1058.
Per contra
9. , learned counsel appearing for the contes ng
respondents supports the judgments & decrees passed by the Courts below
insofar as the suit has been dismissed as barred by limitaon. It is contended
that the plainffs were fully aware of the Will dated 15.10.1986 and the
exclusive possession of defendant No.1 over the suit property. Surat Singh
admi?edly died on 10.01.1987, wherea;er mutaon No.3426 was sanconed
in favour of defendant No.1 on the basis of the Will. However, the suit was
instuted only in the year 2002, a;er an unexplained lapse of about fi;een
years.
10. It is further submi?ed that the plainffs themselves pleaded that
defendant No.1 had taken forcible possession of the property a;er the death
of Surat Singh. Plainff No.1 also admi?ed during cross-examinaon that
defendant No.1 remained in possession of the suit property a;er Surat
Singh's death. Thus, according to learned counsel, the plainffs cannot claim
SARITA RANI
2026.11.19 16:43
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
Chandigarh
Page 3 of 9

RSA No.689 of 2013 (O&M) 2026:PHHC: 203717

ignorance of the asser on of exclusive ownership by defendant No.1. Despite
such knowledge, they did not take any steps to challenge the Will or
mutaon within the prescribed period.
11. Learned counsel further contends that the plainffs have not
disclosed any specific date on which they acquired knowledge of the Will or
the mutaon. Reliance is placed upon Shyam Lal @ Kuldeep v. Sanjeev
Kumar and others, (2009) 12 SCC 454 , wherein the Hon'ble Supreme Court
upheld the dismissal of a suit on the ground of limita on, nocing the
absence of pleadings and evidence regarding the date of knowledge of the
disputed Will and mutaon. It is submi?ed that the facts of the present case
are substanally similar and, therefore, no interference is warranted in the
concurrent findings on limitaon.
12. It is also argued that even if the First Appellate Court has
reversed the finding regarding due execuon of the Will, such reversal does
not automacally render the suit within limitaon. The queson of limitaon
is independent of the validity of the Will. The plainffs, having remained out
of possession for a considerable period despite knowledge of the defendant's
exclusive claim, cannot seek to revive a stale cause of acon merely by
describing their suit as one based upon inheritance. Dismissal of the appeal
is, accordingly, prayed for.
Considera on by the Court
13. Having considered the rival submissions and examined the
judgments of both Courts below, this Court finds that the controversy
essen ally concerns the nature of the plainffs' claim and the applicability of
the relevant provision of the Limitaon Act, 1963.
14. The main queson arising for consideraon is whether the First
Appellate Court, having held that the Will dated 15.10.1986 propounded by
defendant No.1 was not duly proved and that the plainffs were entled to
inherit the estate of Surat Singh, was jusfied in dismissing their suit as
barred by limitaon. The answer necessarily depends upon the nature of the
SARITA RANI
2026.11.19 16:43
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
Chandigarh
Page 4 of 9

RSA No.689 of 2013 (O&M) 2026:PHHC: 203717

rights asserted, the substan ve relief claimed and the applicable provision of
the Limitaon Act, 1963.
15. There can be no dispute with the contenon advanced on behalf
of the respondents that failure to prove a Will does not, by itself, render the
queson of limitaon inconsequenal. However, a disncon must be drawn
between a suit seeking declaraon simpliciter regarding the invalidity of an
instrument and a suit seeking possession on the basis of an exisng tle
acquired through inheritance. While Arcle 58 of the Limitaon Act may
govern the former, a suit substanally founded upon tle and seeking
possession of immovable property ordinarily a?racts Arcle 65. The
applicability of either provision must be determined from the substance of
the pleadings and relief claimed, rather than the form in which the suit has
been framed.
16. In the present case, the plainffs sought declaraon that the Will
dated 15.10.1986 and mutaon No.3426 sanconed on its basis were illegal
and not binding upon their rights, besides seeking joint possession of the suit
property as legal heirs of Surat Singh. The First Appellate Court, upon re-
appreciaon of the evidence, reversed the findings of the Trial Court on
Issues No.1 and 2, holding that defendant No.1 had failed to prove the due
execuon and a?estaon of the Will. It consequently held that the property
would devolve upon the legal heirs of Surat Singh in accordance with Secon
8 of the Hindu Succession Act, 1956, including the plainffs. Thus, the
plainffs' claim to their respecve shares was founded upon succession and
not upon any tle sought to be created by the declaratory decree. The
declaraon regarding the Will was incidental to the enforcement of their
inherited rights.
17. In Mohinder Singh and another v. Kashmira Singh (supra) , a
Division Bench of this Court held that inheritance does not remain in
abeyance and that the rights of an heir vest immediately upon the death of
the predecessor-in-interest. An heir is not required to ins tute a suit merely
to establish a tle which has already devolved upon him by operaon of law.
SARITA RANI
2026.11.19 16:43
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
Chandigarh
Page 5 of 9

RSA No.689 of 2013 (O&M) 2026:PHHC: 203717

Where such heir is out of possession, his suit for possession based upon
inherited tle is governed by Arcle 65 of the Limitaon Act and can be
defeated upon proof that the defendant has perfected tle by adverse
possession. Arcle 65 prescribes a period of twelve years commencing from
the date when the defendant's possession becomes adverse to the plainff.
Therefore, neither the death of the predecessor-in-interest nor the
sanconing of mutaon, by itself, furnishes the starng point of limitaon for
such a suit.
18. Reference may also be made to Hardev Singh v. Gurmail Singh
(dead) by LRs (supra) , relied upon by learned counsel for the appellants.
Although the said judgment primarily dealt with the applicability of Sec on
43 of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882, the queson of tle claimed through
a Will also arose therein. The se?led legal posion remains that a Will relied
upon as the source of tle must be proved in accordance with Secon 63 of
the Indian Succession Act, 1925, read with Secon 68 of the Indian Evidence
Act, 1872. Where the Will is not duly proved, it cannot displace succession
under the applicable law of inheritance.
19. In the present case, the First Appellate Court has already
returned a categorical finding against defendant No.1 regarding proof of the
Will. Consequently, his claim to exclusive ownership cannot be sustained
merely on the strength of that instrument.
20. The reliance placed by learned counsel for the respondents upon
Shyam Lal @ Kuldeep v. Sanjeev Kumar and others (supra) , also deserves
considera on. In that case, the Hon'ble Supreme Court upheld the finding on
limitaon having regard to the nature of the declaratory relief claimed, the
pleadings regarding accrual of the cause of acon and the absence of
parculars concerning knowledge of the disputed Will and mutaon. The said
judgment, however, cannot be construed as laying down an inflexible
proposion that every suit founded upon inheritance becomes barred merely
because it is instuted beyond three years from the death of the predecessor
SARITA RANI
2026.11.19 16:43
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
Chandigarh
Page 6 of 9

RSA No.689 of 2013 (O&M) 2026:PHHC: 203717

or sanc oning of mutaon. Its applicability must be examined with reference
to the substanve relief sought and the facts of the parcular case.
21. In the present suit, the plainffs have specifically claimed joint
possession on the strength of their inherited tle, and therefore, the
queson of limitaon requires examinaon in the context of Arcle 65 of the
Limitaon Act.
22. The contenon advanced on behalf of the respondents that
defendant No.1 had remained in exclusive possession of the suit property
ever since the death of Surat Singh on 10.01.1987 also deserves
consideraon. It is true that the plainffs pleaded that defendant No.1 had
taken forcible possession a;er the death of Surat Singh and that plainff
No.1 admi?ed his possession during the relevant period. However, the
nature of the defence raised by defendant No.1 is important. A perusal of his
wri?en statement reveals that he specifically claimed to be the owner in
possession of the suit property by virtue of the Will dated 15.10.1986. He
neither pleaded that his possession had become adverse to the rights of the
other legal heirs nor claimed to have perfected tle by adverse possession .
His defence was thus founded en rely upon the alleged testamentary
disposion in his favour.
23. It is well se?led that adverse possession is required to be
specifically pleaded and proved by the person claiming its benefit. Such a
plea must disclose the nature of possession, the point of me from which it
became hosle to the true owner, and its open, connuous and unequivocal
character for the prescribed statutory period. In Karnataka Board of Wakf v.
, the Hon'ble Supreme
Government of India and others, (2004) 10 SCC 779
Court emphasised the necessity of establishing these essen al ingredients.
Similar principles were reiterated in P.T. Munichikkanna Reddy and others v.
Revamma and others, (2007) 6 SCC 59 . Although alterna ve pleas may be
permissible in appropriate cases, the Court cannot construct a case of
adverse possession for a defendant, who has neither pleaded nor sought to
establish such a defence.
SARITA RANI
2026.11.19 16:43
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
Chandigarh
Page 7 of 9

RSA No.689 of 2013 (O&M) 2026:PHHC: 203717

24. In the present case, defendant No.1 claimed exclusive ownership
under the Will, which has been held by the First Appellate Court to be not
duly proved. Once the very founda on of his asserted testamentary tle
failed, he could not be held to have acquired ownership merely because he
had remained in possession of the property for a considerable period. The
admission of the plainffs regarding his possession a;er the death of Surat
Singh cannot substute the essenal pleadings and proof of adverse
possession. Moreover, where the contest is between persons claiming
succession to the estate of a common predecessor, mere exclusive
possession of one heir does not necessarily constute ouster of the others. In
the absence of a specific plea and proof of hosle possession for the
statutory period, the plainffs' inherited rights could not be defeated on that
ground.
25. The First Appellate Court, while reversing the findings on Issues
No.1 and 2 and holding that the Will was not duly proved and that the
plainffs were entled to inherit the estate of Surat Singh, nevertheless
dismissed the suit as barred by limitaon by reckoning me from the
execuon of the Will, sanconing of mutaon and instuon of the suit. Such
an approach overlooks the disncon between a suit for declaraon
simpliciter and one seeking joint possession on the basis of inherited tle. As
held by the Division Bench of this Court in Mohinder Singh and another v.
Kashmira Singh (supra), inheritance does not remain in abeyance, and a suit
for possession founded upon such tle is governed by Arcle 65 of the
Limitaon Act.
26. In the absence of any plea or proof of adverse possession by
defendant No.1, the mere lapse of me from the death of Surat Singh or
sanconing of mutaon could not render the plainffs' claim for joint
possession me-barred. The finding recorded on Issue No.5 is, therefore,
legally unsustainable.
27. Accordingly, the substanal queson of law is answered in
favour of the appellants and against the contesng respondents.
SARITA RANI
2026.11.19 16:43
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
Chandigarh
Page 8 of 9

RSA No.689 of 2013 (O&M) 2026:PHHC: 203717

28. Consequently, the present regular second appeal is allowed. The
judgment and decree dated 17.09.2012 passed by the learned Addi onal
District Judge, Karnal, and the judgment and decree dated 15.03.2010 passed
by the learned Addional Civil Judge (Senior Division), Assandh, insofar as
they dismissed the plainffs' suit, are set aside.
29. The suit filed by the plainffs is decreed to the extent that the
Will dated 15.10.1986, propounded by defendant No.1, having not been duly
proved, shall not affect their lawful inheritance rights. Mutaon No.3426
sanconed on the basis of the said Will shall likewise not defeat those rights.
The plainffs shall be entled to joint possession of the suit property to the
extent of their respecve shares in the estate of Surat Singh, as determined
in accordance with the applicable law of succession, without prejudice to the
lawful rights of the other legal heirs.
30. The appeal stands allowed in the aforesaid terms. There shall be
no order as to costs.

(DEEPAK GUPTA)
JUDGE
November 19, 2026
Sarita
Whether speaking/reasoned? : Yes/No
Whether reportable? : Yes/No
Uploaded on: November 19, 2026
SARITA RANI
2026.11.19 16:43
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
Chandigarh
Page 9 of 9