K. Suman Chandra vs Union Of India
- Court
- Supreme Court
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
EXTRA-ORDINARY APPELLATE JURISDICTION
2026 INSC 893
SPECIAL LEAVE PETITION (CIVIL) NO. OF 2026
(@ DIARY NO.5679 OF 2024)
K. SUMAN CHANDRA PETITIONER
VERSUS
UNION OF INDIA AND OTHERS RESPONDENTS
J U D G M E N T
ATUL S. CHANDURKAR, J
1. Delay condoned.
2. The petitioner takes exception to the order dated 08.08.2023
1
passed by the Division Bench of the High Court of Telangana at
Hyderabad by which the challenge raised by the first and second
respondents to the order dated 15.07.2019 passed by the Central
2 3
Administrative Tribunal , Hyderabad in Original Application
No.45 of 2017 has been upheld and that order has been set aside.
Consequently, the O.A. has been dismissed.
Signature Not Verified
Digitally signed by
ABHINAV KUMAR
Date: 2026.08.20
15:41:55 IST
Reason:
1
For short, ‘the High Court’
2
For short, ‘the CAT’
3
For short, ‘O.A.’
Special Leave Petition (Civil) arising out of Diary No.5679 of 2024 Page 1 of 7
3. Briefly stated, the petitioner seeks a declaration that
pursuant to service rendered by him at the National Institute of
4
Rural Development and having retired from the post of Professor,
he is entitled to be covered under the General Provident Fund-
5
cum-Pension Scheme and not under the Central Pension Fund
6
Scheme so as to receive necessary benefits. The petitioner was
initially appointed as Research Associate with the NIRD on
contractual basis on 12.11.1984. As per the Office Order dated
13.11.1984, he was covered under the CPF Scheme. His services
were, thereafter, regularised with effect from 07.11.1985 pursuant
to Office Order dated 05.06.1985. Subsequently, he was appointed
as Assistant Director on 09.03.1992 on regular basis, as Deputy
Director on 10.08.1999 on contractual basis and as Professor on
01.05.2007 on contractual basis. His services were, thereafter,
regularised on the post of Professor by Office Order No.98 dated
04.05.2012. It may be noted that along with the petitioner, the
7
services of Mr. Shyam Sunder Prasad Sharma on the post of
Professor were also regularised. The petitioner retired from service
on 31.01.2017 and was paid all his retiral benefits on 14.02.2017,
4
For short, ‘NIRD’
5
For short, ‘GPF’
6
For short, ‘CPF’
7
For short, ‘Mr. S.S.P. Sharma’
Special Leave Petition (Civil) arising out of Diary No.5679 of 2024 Page 2 of 7
which included the contribution of NIRD to the CPF amount
besides his own contribution. Thereafter, the petitioner
approached the CAT seeking a declaration that the action on the
part of NIRD in continuing him under the CPF Scheme instead of
the GPF Scheme was illegal and also contrary to the NIRD Rules of
2011 as well as the NIRD Service Bye-laws, Chapter IX Para 52
Section 4. He, accordingly, sought necessary consequential
benefits pursuant to such declaration.
4. Mr. S.S.P. Sharma, whose services were also regularised on
04.05.2012 on the post of Professor, had approached the CAT in
O.A. No.109 of 2015 seeking similar reliefs. The CAT by its
judgment dated 27.08.2018 allowed his O.A. and granted relief to
Mr. S.S.P. Sharma. Writ Petition No.44613 of 2018 preferred by
the Union of India and others challenging the order of the CAT was
dismissed. In the O.A. preferred by the petitioner, the CAT was of
the view that issues raised by the petitioner were covered by its
earlier adjudication in the case of Mr. S.S.P. Sharma. Accordingly,
by its judgment dated 15.07.2019, the CAT allowed the petitioner’s
O.A. and directed NIRD to permit the petitioner to come under the
GPF Scheme from the date he was eligible.
Special Leave Petition (Civil) arising out of Diary No.5679 of 2024 Page 3 of 7
5. In the interregnum, NIRD raised a challenge to the
adjudication undertaken by the CAT in the case of Mr. S.S.P.
Sharma. This Court by its judgment dated 28.02.2023 in National
Institute of Rural Development Vs. Shyam Sunder Prasad
8
Sharma and Others held, after considering Bye-law 52 as well as
the Rules of 2011, that the regularisation of services of
Mr. S.S.P. Sharma pursuant to the order of regularisation dated
04.05.2012 would operate from the date of that order and would
not relate back to the date of his initial appointment as was held
by the CAT and affirmed by the High Court. This was for the reason
that it was specifically stated in the order of regularisation dated
04.05.2012 that it would take effect from the date of issuance of
the order, which condition had not been challenged by Mr. S.S.P.
Sharma. Accordingly, the orders passed by the CAT and the High
Court were set aside and it was held that Mr. S.S.P. Sharma was
entitled to benefits under the CPF Scheme.
6. When the writ petition preferred by NIRD was taken up for
consideration by the High Court, the judgment of this Court in
S.S.P. Sharma (supra) was brought to its notice. The High Court
was of the view that the case of the petitioner was similar as that
8
Civil Appeal No.542 of 2023 decided on 28.02.2023
Special Leave Petition (Civil) arising out of Diary No.5679 of 2024 Page 4 of 7
of Mr. S.S.P. Sharma. The effect of regularisation would, therefore,
be from 04.05.2012 and not from the date of his initial
appointment. Moreover, it was found that the petitioner had
approached the CAT only after his retirement that too after
receiving benefits under the CPF Scheme. It, therefore, allowed the
writ petition filed by NIRD and set aside the order passed by the
Tribunal dated 15.07.2019. Being aggrieved, the petitioner has
challenged the order of the High Court.
7. We have heard Mr. Manish Kumar Saran, learned counsel for
the petitioner, Ms. Ruchi Kohli, learned Senior Advocate for the
first respondent and Ms. Vishakha, learned counsel for the second
respondent. While the endeavour on behalf of the learned counsel
for the petitioner was to distinguish the decision of this Court in
S.S.P. Sharma (supra) , the learned counsel for the respondents
submitted that the petitioner was similarly situated as Mr. S.S.P.
Sharma and, hence, the adjudication by this Court in S.S.P.
Sharma (supra) was applicable on all fours to the case of petitioner.
Having given due consideration to the respective submissions
and having gone through the relevant material on record, we are
of the considered view that the adjudication undertaken in S.S.P.
Sharma (supra) by this Court would also apply to the case of
Special Leave Petition (Civil) arising out of Diary No.5679 of 2024 Page 5 of 7
petitioner. We do not intend to reproduce all the contentions raised
by the learned counsel for the parties as the petitioner’s case is
based on Office Order No.98 dated 04.05.2012 by which the
services of Academic Staff working on contractual basis were
regularised. By the said Office Order, the services of the petitioner
as Professor on contractual basis were regularised subject to
various terms and conditions, which included the order of
regularisation taking effect from the date of the said order as well
as services being continued to be governed by the existing CPF
Scheme. As found by this Court in S.S.P. Sharma (supra) , the terms
and conditions of regularisation stipulated in the Office Order
dated 04.05.2012 were not challenged by the petitioner at any
point of time, as also in the case of Mr. S.S.P. Sharma. Having
accepted the terms and conditions for regularisation of services on
the post of Professor and the grievance in this regard having been
raised post-retirement after accepting benefits under the CPF
Scheme, the petitioner was rightly non-suited by the High Court.
This Court in S.S.P. Sharma (supra) considered in detail the effect
of the Rules of 2011, especially Rule 6 thereof as well as Bye-law
52 Clause(a) along with Bye-laws 48 and 49 thereof. We are in
complete agreement with what has been held by this Court in
Special Leave Petition (Civil) arising out of Diary No.5679 of 2024 Page 6 of 7
S.S.P. Sharma (supra) and we do not find any reason, whatsoever,
to re-open the aforesaid issue at the instance of the petitioner.
8. In our view, as the petitioner is similarly situated as
Mr. S.S.P. Sharma, especially in the backdrop of the fact that the
services of Mr. S.S.P. Sharma and the petitioner were regularised
by the Office Order dated 04.05.2012 on identical conditions, we
do not find any reason, whatsoever, to exercise jurisdiction under
Article 136 of the Constitution of India.
9. The Special Leave Petition is, thus, dismissed.
……..………………………..J.
[ UJJAL BHUYAN ]
...…..………………………..J.
[ ATUL S. CHANDURKAR ]
NEW DELHI,
AUGUST 20, 2026.
Special Leave Petition (Civil) arising out of Diary No.5679 of 2024 Page 7 of 7