Smt Sunita Devi & Anr. vs Tata Aig General Insurance Co. Ltd & Anr.

Court
Delhi High Court

$~12
* IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
rd
% Date of decision: 03 November 2026
# CNR No. DLHC010478932022
+ MAC.APP. 426/2022
SMT SUNITA DEVI & ANR. .....Appellants
Through: Mr. Umesh Kumar, Advocate.

versus

TATA AIG GENERAL INSURANCE CO. LTD & ANR.
.....Respondents
Through: Ms. Vandana Kahlon, Mr. Rudra
Kahlon, Advocates for Respondent
No.1
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE ANISH DAYAL
JUDGMENT

ANISH DAYAL, J (ORAL)
1. This appeal has been filed by the claimants’ seeking enhancement of
compensation, as well as, challenging the finding of 50% contributory
negligence fastened on Late Nishchint Rao (‘ deceased ’) in respect of an
th
accident which occurred on 12 October 2019 at around 09:30 a.m., by
th
impugned award dated 05 September 2022, Motor Accident Claims
Tribunal, South East, Saket Courts, New Delhi (‘ MACT/Tribunal ’)
awarding compensation of Rs.12,49,276/- along with 9% interest.
2. The deceased was driving his car, along with his friend Mayank
Dagar (‘ PW2 ’) and others, travelling from Surajkund Road towards Sector
Signature Not Verified
MAC.APP. 426/2022 Page 1 of 10

Digitally Signed By:RAHUL
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
Signing Date:18.11.2026
16:31:31

21-C, Faridabad, when vehicle bearing registration No. HR-51BJ-2103
(‘ offending vehicle ’), coming from the opposite side, hit the car of
deceased in the middle of the road.
3. As regards issue of contributory negligence, it was undisputed that
the road, where the accident occurred, did not have a divider. The site plan,
as extracted below, shows that the offending vehicle was coming from the
side of Sector 21-C, Faridabad towards Surajkund, whereas, the deceased’s
car is coming from the other side and the collision occurred at point ‘A’:

4. As per the site plan, the offending vehicle swerved from its lane
towards the middle of the road, whereas, the deceased’s car continued to
Signature Not Verified
MAC.APP. 426/2022 Page 2 of 10

Digitally Signed By:RAHUL
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
Signing Date:18.11.2026
16:31:31

remain approximately in the middle of the road. The reason for the
deceased’s car to be driven in the middle of the road, as adverted to by
PW2 / eye-witness and co-occupant of the car, seems to be due to a
depression on left side of the road. PW2 first stated that his friend
( deceased ) was driving the car in the middle of the road, but then
volunteered that he was driving the car in his own lane. Later, he also stated
in his testimony that there was a small depression on the left side of the
lane in which the deceased had been driving. He could not confirm whether
the deceased could have driven over the depression or not, since it was a
small car.
5. It does appear from the site plan, as well as, the testimony of PW2
that the offending vehicle had crossed over from its side of the road and
come to the other side of the road where the deceased was driving and hit
their vehicle.
6. MACT seems to have appreciated the situation in the reverse as is
evident from paragraph nos. 20 and 21 of the impugned award. In
paragraph no. 20 , the MACT does note PW2’s testimony that they were
travelling from Surajkund towards Sector 21-C, Faridabad and offending
vehicle was coming from the opposite side and that there was no divider on
the road. In paragraph no.21 , however, noting point ‘A’ as the place of
collision, MACT went on to state that the deceased’s car changed direction
towards the right side of the road instead of going straight. However, it
was, in fact the offending vehicle which is marked as having veered
towards the middle of the road i.e. the right side rather than the deceased’s
car.
Signature Not Verified
MAC.APP. 426/2022 Page 3 of 10

Digitally Signed By:RAHUL
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
Signing Date:18.11.2026
16:31:31

7. While, the driver of offending vehicle had stated in his written
statement that the deceased had moved towards the right side and collided
head with his vehicle, the site plan placed on record seems to suggest
otherwise. Moreover, driver of the offending vehicle did not enter the
witness box and no other proof of contributory negligence was provided.
Various judgments have consistently held that contributory
8.
negligence has to be proved by the person claiming that the
injured/deceased was contributorily negligent and it cannot just be simply
assessed. This has been clearly held by the Supreme Court in Yashwant
Krishna Kumbar v. Divisional Manager , United India Insurance Co. Ltd.
th
SLP (C) NO. 22599/2024 by order dated 25 November 2025, where the
Supreme Court was adjudicating an appeal filed by the pillion rider on the
ground that contributory negligence of 50% was attributed by the Tribunal
and High Court. Allowing the pillion rider’s appeal, the Supreme Court
held as under:
“16. In cases where contributory negligence is sought
to be attributed to a pillion rider in a motor vehicle
accident, the burden squarely lies on the party alleging
such negligence to establish, by cogent material, that
any act or omission on the part of the pillion rider
contributed to the occurrence of the accident. In the
absence of such proof, no finding of contributory
negligence can be sustained against a pillion rider.
17. This Court is therefore of the considered view that
the Tribunal committed a manifest error in reducing
the compensation by 50% on the ground of alleged
contributory negligence of the claimant. The insurer,
on whom the burden squarely rested, led no evidence
to establish even remote negligence attributable to the
claimant. Consequently, the finding of contributory
negligence cannot be sustained and is liable to be set
Signature Not Verified
MAC.APP. 426/2022 Page 4 of 10

Digitally Signed By:RAHUL
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
Signing Date:18.11.2026
16:31:31

aside, restoring the claimant’s entitlement to the full
measure of compensation determined in accordance
with law.”
(emphasis added)

9. In any event, even as per the assessment of site plan and the
testimony of PW2 , the MACT ought not to have deducted 50% towards
contributory negligence on this account.
10. In light of the above, 50% deduction towards contributory
negligence is set aside.
11. Mr. Umesh Kumar , counsel for the claimants raised another issue for
enhancement of compensation on the ground that notional income should
not have been assessed on the basis of minimum wages of a skilled person
of Haryana. The deceased was pursuing Bachelors of Technology (‘ B.
nd
Tech. ’) from Manav Rachana University, Faridabad and was in his 2 year
at the time of the accident. He was also stated to have been giving tuitions
and earning Rs.15,000/- per month. Since no proof had been placed
regarding the tuitions, MACT considered his income on the basis of
minimum wages of a skilled person.
12. Mr. Umesh Kumar , relies upon the additional evidence placed before
th
this Court, was allowed by order dated 10 February 2026 in CM APPL.
9260/2026 , being the placement record of the year 2022. It was stated that
the placement record was uploaded after the conclusion of evidence before
the MACT in 2021 and, therefore, could not be produced before the
MACT.
13. However, this is objected to by Mr. Rudra Kahlon , counsel for
Insurance Company, on the basis that this placement record has been placed
Signature Not Verified
MAC.APP. 426/2022 Page 5 of 10

Digitally Signed By:RAHUL
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
Signing Date:18.11.2026
16:31:31

after seven years of the accident and after four years of the conclusion of
proceedings before the MACT. Moreover, no witness from the said college
has been produced to support the evidence.
14. Mr. Umesh Kumar , seeks to rely upon the placement record to state
that the deceased would have received placement offers, which have been
stated to be in the average range of Rs. 3,00,000/- to Rs. 6,00,000/- per
annum.
15. However, at this stage, and taking into account the objection made
by Mr. Kahlon , reliance cannot be placed on an unproven document,
considering that there was no witness to support the evidence.
16. In order to buttress his submission in support of potentiality of
income of deceased, Mr. Umesh Kumar relies upon the decision of this
Court in Uttar Pradesh State Road Transport Corporation v. Seema
Rustagi 2026:DHC:4289 to argue that the potentiality of income ought to
be taken for a student who was about to graduate, as also the decision of
Supreme Court in Navjot Singh v. Harpreet Singh & Ors. 2020 SCC
OnLine SC 1562.
17. As regards the decision in Seema Rustagi ( supra ), this Court had
considered evidence of colleagues of the deceased, who were her
batchmates and had provided pay slips of what they had received in their
eventual employment, which was placed on record. On the other hand, in
Navjot Singh ( supra ), the Supreme Court has considered notional income
at Rs.10,000/- per month by exercising powers under Article 142 of the
Constitution of India, 1950, in case of a student pursuing a degree course in
engineering, rather than minimum wages admissible to an unskilled worker.
Signature Not Verified
MAC.APP. 426/2022 Page 6 of 10

Digitally Signed By:RAHUL
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
Signing Date:18.11.2026
16:31:31

18. The Court has traversed the law relating to potentiality of income in
cases where the deceased person was a student about to graduate in ICICI
Lombard General Insurance Company Limited v. Dharmender Khurana
& Ors. 2026:DHC:5199 which were connected cross appeals involving two
deceased persons namely, Vinay Khurana and Prabhleen Kaur .
Deceased/ Vinay Khurana was in his final year of B.E. Computer
Engineering from Netaji Subhash Institute of Technology (‘ NSIT ’). While
assessing his notional income, the Court relied upon the offer letter of one
of the offers secured by him, which stated that the letter was provisional
and subjection to the completion of his degree. Moreover, the testimony of
PW-6 from the said Company had also testified that the deceased would
have approximately earned Rs. 80,000/- per month and was therefore, taken
to be his notional income after deduction of income tax.
19. Deceased/ Prabhleen Kaur on the other hand, was in her third-year
pursuing B.E. (Instrumentation and Control Engineering) from NSIT.
While she had not secured a placement, she had been earning Rs. 20,000/-
from an internship at Sun Pharmaceutical Industries Ltd . Considering her
educational background, this Court deemed it appropriate to assess her
notional income at Rs. 60,000/-.
20. After taking into account the above decisions, as well as, testimony
of the mother of deceased/ Sunita Devi (‘ PW1 ’) into consideration, who
stated that her son was teaching 5-6 students on a daily basis and was
charging Rs. 1,000/- per student, this Court is inclined to consider an
estimate of the notional income. While taking minimum wages of a non-
graduate skilled person, the MACT had noted that the deceased was taking
tuitions and earning Rs. 15,000/-, however, no proof had been placed on
Signature Not Verified
MAC.APP. 426/2022 Page 7 of 10

Digitally Signed By:RAHUL
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
Signing Date:18.11.2026
16:31:31

record. It was observed in paragraph 35 of the impugned award that but for
the accident, the deceased would have become an engineer/technical expert
and would be working in a permanent job. Therefore, in the opinion of this
Court, potential notional income of deceased can be considered at Rs.
15,000/-.
21. Future prospects have been awarded at 50% by the MACT, however,
considering that there was no proof of permanent employment of the
deceased, future prospects will be awarded at 40% as per the principles
enunciated in National Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Pranay Sethi, (2017) 16 SCC
680.
22. Therefore, the revised compensation is as under:
Heads Awarded by the
Tribunal
Awarded by this
Court
S.
No.
1 Income of deceased (A) Rs. 10,447/-

Rs. 15,000/-
2 Add: Future Prospects (B) Rs. 5,223.5/- Rs. 6,000/-
3 Less: Personal expenses of
deceased (C)
Rs. 5,223.5/- Rs. 7,000/-
4 Loss of dependency (A+B)-C=
(D)
Rs. 10,447/- Rs. 14,000/-
5 Annual loss of dependency (D x
12) = (E)
Rs. 1,25,364/- Rs. 1,68,000/-
6 Multiplier (F) 18 18
7 Total loss of dependency (E x F)
= (G)
Rs. 22,56,552/- Rs. 30,24,000/-
8 Compensation for loss of
consortium (H)
Rs. 88,000/- Rs. 88,000/-
9 Compensation for loss of estate
(I)
Rs. 16,500/- Rs. 16,500/-
10 Compensation towards funeral
expenses (J)
Rs. 16,500/- Rs. 16,500/-
Signature Not Verified
MAC.APP. 426/2022 Page 8 of 10

Digitally Signed By:RAHUL
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
Signing Date:18.11.2026
16:31:31

11 Less: Contributory Negligence
(K)
Rs. 11,28,276/-* Nil
12 Total compensation
(G+H+I+J - K) = (L)
Rs. 12,49,276/- Rs. 31,45,000/-
13 Rate of Interest Awarded 9% 9%
14 Enhanced Compensation Rs. 18,95,724/-

*MACT has deducted contributory negligence from the total loss of dependency
Directions
23. For the aforesaid reasons, compensation has been enhanced by
Rs.18,95,724/- [“ enhanced amount ”].
24. Enhanced amount along with 9% interest per annum from the date of
filing the petition shall be deposited before MACT within a period of six
weeks. It is directed that a lump sum amount of Rs. 10,00,000/- shall be
released to the claimants from the deposit of enhanced amount within a
period of two weeks thereafter in terms of the apportionment directed by
the MACT. Remaining enhanced amount, along with accrued interest, shall
be kept in Fixed Deposit Receipts (FDRs) of Rs. 25,000/- each for periods
of 3 month, 6 months, 9 months and so on, in succession as maybe
calculated. Interest accruing on said FDRs shall be credited to the
designated Savings Bank Account of claimants. The amount of FDRs on
maturity would be released to the Savings Bank Account of claimant upon
due verification in terms of the apportionment directed by the MACT.

25. Appeal is disposed of in the above terms.
26. Pending applications, if any, are rendered infructuous.
27. Copy of this judgment be sent to the concerned MACT/bank for
information and necessary compliance.
Signature Not Verified
MAC.APP. 426/2022 Page 9 of 10

Digitally Signed By:RAHUL
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
Signing Date:18.11.2026
16:31:31

28. Judgment be uploaded on the website of this Court.


(ANISH DAYAL)
JUDGE
NOVEMBER 3, 2026/ ak/ sp

Signature Not Verified
MAC.APP. 426/2022 Page 10 of 10

Digitally Signed By:RAHUL
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
Signing Date:18.11.2026
16:31:31