WORLD COLOPROCTOLOGY (OPC) PRIVATE LIMITED vs SMILES INTERNATIONAL INSTITUTE OF COLOPROCTOLOGY PRIVATE LIMITED

Court
Karnataka High Court

HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:61469
WP No. 35599 of 2024

CNR: KAHC010756212024




IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU

TH
DATED THIS THE 5 DAY OF NOVEMBER, 2026

R

BEFORE

THE HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE TARA VITASTA GANJU

WRIT PETITION NO. 35599 OF 2024 (GM-CPC)


BETWEEN:

1. WORLD COLOPROCTOLOGY (OPC) PRIVATE LIMITED,
A ONE PERSON COMPANY
INCORPORATED UNDER THE
COMPANIES ACT, 2013,
HAVING ITS REGISTERED
OFFICE AT NO.438,
TH TH
8 CROSS, 5 MAIN, HIG COLONY,
RMV II STAGE, DOLLARS COLONY,
BENGALURU-560 094.
REPRESENTED BY ITS DIRECTOR,
DR. YUVRAJ SINGH GHELOT.

2. DR. YUVRAJ SINGH GHELOT
S/O. PRAHLAD SINGH,
AGED ABOUT 43 YEARS,
R/AT NO. 1193, PHEONIX ONE,
BENGALURU WEST,
NO.1, RAJKUMAR ROAD,
BENGALURU-560 010.
…PETITIONERS
(BY SRI. DORE RAJ.B.H., ADVOCATE)

AND:

1. SMILES INTERNATIONAL INSTITUTE OF
COLOPROCTOLOGY PRIVATE LIMITED
A PRIVATE LIMITED
COMPANY INCORPORATED
UNDER COMPANIES ACT, 2013











Digitally signed by
SUMATHY KANNAN
Location: HIGH
COURT OF
KARNATAKA

1

HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:61469
WP No. 35599 of 2024

CNR: KAHC010756212024


HAVING ITS REGISTERED
OFFICE AT NO. 438,
TH TH
8 CROSS, 5 MAIN,
HIG COLONY,
BENGALURU-560 094,
REPRESENTED BY ITS DIRECTOR,
MRS. S.J.ANURADHA.

2. SUNAGAHALLI JAYARAM ANURADHA
W/O. DR. PARAMESHWAR.C.M.,
AGED ABOUT 45 YEARS,
TH
NO. 438, 8 CROSS,
TH
5 MAIN, HIG COLONY,
RMV II STAGE, DOLLARS COLONY,
BENGALURU-560 094.

3. DR. PARAMESHWAR C.M.
S/O. H.MUNIKRISHNA,
AGED ABOUT 45 YEARS,
TH
NO. 438, 8 CROSS,
TH
5 MAIN, HIG COLONY,
RMV II STAGE, DOLLARS COLONY,
BENGALURU-560 094.
…RESPONDENTS
*
THIS WRIT PETITION IS FILED UNDER ARTICLE 227 OF THE
CONSTITUTION OF INDIA, PRAYING TO CALL FOR THE
RECORDS OF THE CASE IN O.S.NO.8925/2018 ON THE FILE OF
THE 18TH ADDL.CITY CIVIL AND SESSIONS JUDGE,
BENGALURU, AND SET ASIDE THE ORDER DATED 13/06/2023
TH
PASSED BY THE 18 ADDL. CITY CIVIL AND SESSIONS JUDGE,
BENGALURU CITY (CCH 10), ON I.A.NO.3 IN THE SUIT IN O.S.
NO.8925/2018.

THIS WRIT PETITION, COMING ON FOR ORDERS, THIS DAY,
ORDER WAS MADE THEREIN AS UNDER:
2

HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:61469
WP No. 35599 of 2024

CNR: KAHC010756212024


CORAM: HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE TARA VITASTA GANJU

ORAL ORDER

1. The present petition seeks to challenge an order
dated 13.06.2023 passed by the learned XVIII Additional
City Civil Judge at Bangalore City in I.A.No.3 in
O.S.No.8925/2018 [hereinafter referred to as the
“Impugned Order”].By the Impugned Order, an application
[I.A.No.3] under Section 8 of the Arbitration and
Conciliation Act, 1996 [hereinafter referred to as the “A &
C Act”] filed by the respondents/defendants has been
allowed by the learned Commercial Court, referring the
matter for arbitration holding that the subject matter of
the suit is subject to arbitration in terms of the Asset
Transfer Agreement dated 20.11.2017 between the parties
[hereinafter referred to as the “ATA”].

2. Given the order that the Court proposes to pass
today, this Court does not deem it apposite to issue notice
in this matter.
3

HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:61469
WP No. 35599 of 2024

CNR: KAHC010756212024


3. A suit was filed by the petitioners/plaintiffs against
the respondents/defendants seeking the following reliefs:
“a) RESTRAIN by an order of injunction, the Defendants
and its officers, employee, agents, representatives, from
directly or indirectly using the deceptively similar
Schedule ‘B’ mark or any other mark which is deceptively
similar to Schedule ‘A’ mark.

b) DECLARE that the Plaintiffs are the owners of the web
portal www.bengalurusmiles.com and consequently,
RESTRAIN by an order of injunction the Defendants and
its officers, employees, agents, representatives, from
directly or indirectly using the websites
ww.bengalurusmiles.com and www.siicp.com.

c) DIRECT the Defendants to render true and faithful
account of all the profits earned by them by using the
deceptively similar mark and future direct the Defendant
to pay to the Plaintiff such amount as may be found due,
on such account being taken, along with interest at 18%
from the date of the suit till the actual realization.

d) DIRECT the Defendants to pay costs of the suit.

e) GRANT any other appropriate relief as this Hon’ble
Court may deem fit and proper in the interest.

Schedule A
Trademark bearing Registration No.3326209 under Class

44:



Schedule B
The deceptively similar mark being used by the
Defendant:


4

HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:61469
WP No. 35599 of 2024

CNR: KAHC010756212024


3.1. The petitioners/plaintiffs, contended that, prima
facie, they have the ownership over a trademark and have
invested a lot of money in developing the brand. In
addition, it is stated in the plaint that the respondents/
defendants be restrained from using deceptively, a similar
trademark.

4. A Written Statement was filed by the respondents/
defendants. However, neither the Written Statement nor
the Asset Transfer Agreement has been placed on record
by the petitioners/plaintiffs before this Court. A photocopy
of the ATA, has, however, been handed across to the
Court today, with a memo.

5. An application being I.A.No.3 was filed by the
respondents/defendants, under Section 8 of the A & C Act,
seeking to refer the suit for arbitration, in view of the
existence of an Arbitration Clause [10.4] in an Asset
Transfer Agreement [hereinafter referred to as the “ATA”]
dated 20.11.2017. It is the case of the respondents/
5

HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:61469
WP No. 35599 of 2024

CNR: KAHC010756212024


defendants, that since Clause 10.4 of the ATA sets out an
Arbitration Clause, the disputes between the parties may

be referred to an Arbitrator.

5.1 It is the case of the respondents/defendants, as can
be seen from the affidavit filed in support of the
application filed under Section 8 of the A & C Act is that
the plaintiff No.2 and defendant No.2 incorporated the
defendant No.1/Company, to take over the business
activities undertaken by the plaintiff No.1/Company and
that plaintiff No.2 and defendant No.2 each held 50%
stake in the defendant No.1/Company. Thereafter, by the
ATA, the plaintiff No.1, represented by plaintiff No.2 and
defendant No.1, represented by the defendant No.2
entered into an agreement and the parties have
transferred all the business activities of plaintiff No.1 to
defendant No.1. It is further stated that since disputes
have arisen between the parties regarding the use of the
movable assets which were transferred under the ATA, the
disputes were required to be referred to the arbitration.
6

HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:61469
WP No. 35599 of 2024

CNR: KAHC010756212024


The relevant extract of the affidavit filed in support of the
application [I.A.No.3] are set out below:
“3. I state that, admittedly the Plaintiff No.2 and
Defendant No.2 have incorporated Defendant No.1
company under the provisions of the Companies Act,
2013 in order to take over the business activities
undertaken by the Plaintiff No.1. I further submit
that, the Plaintiff No.2 and Defendant No.2 held
50% stakes each in the Defendant No.1 company.
Thereafter, vide Asset Transfer Agreement dated
20.11.2017, entered between Plaintiff No.1
represented by Plaintiff No.2 and Defendant No.1
represented by Defendant No.2, the parties to the
present suit have transferred all the business
activities under taken by the Plaintiff No.1 to
Defendant No.1. I respectfully submit that, under the
said Asset Transfer Agreement dated 20.11.2017,
the Plaintiffs have transferred Plaint Schedule A
Property and website viz., www.bengaluru
smiles.com to the Defendant No.1 company. A
Notarized copy of the Asset Transfer Agreement dated
20.11.2017 entered between the Parties to the present
suit is produced herewith and marked as ANNEXURE-‘A’.

4. I submit that, as can be seen from the memorandum of
plaint filed by the Plaintiffs, certain disputes have
arisen between the parties with regard to the using
of the movable assets transferred through the Asset
Transfer Agreement dated 20.11.2017 in favor of
the Defendant No.1 . The disputes that have arisen are
arbitrable.”

[Emphasis Supplied]


6. In their Objections filed to this application by the
petitioners/plaintiffs, various objections have been taken,
such as, non-franking of the ATA, subsequent
7

HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:61469
WP No. 35599 of 2024

CNR: KAHC010756212024


correspondence to the agreement and lack of specific
description in the ATA, etc. It is also the specific case of
the petitioners/plaintiffs that they have never executed
any agreement with the respondents/defendants.

7. The learned Commercial Court, after examining the
application and the pleadings before it, sought for the
production of the original ATA. The respondents/
defendants produced the original agreement on
07.02.2019. Subsequently, the learned Commercial Court
allowed the application [I.A.No.3], referring the matter to
arbitration.

8. This Court has examined the copy of the ATA placed
before it. The ATA is a duly stamped document dated
20.11.2017, which is executed between the petitioner
No.1/plaintiff No.1 and respondent No.1/defendant No.1.
The recitals in the ATA set out that the agreement has
been signed by its sole shareholder and Director - Dr.
Yuvraj Singh Ghelot and by the Director of the respondent
8

HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:61469
WP No. 35599 of 2024

CNR: KAHC010756212024


No.1/defendant No.1, Mrs. S.J. Anuradha. The recitals of
the ATA further set out that the petitioner is the seller and
the assets of the seller which includes their trademarks,
are being sold by the seller to the purchaser.

8.1 The ATA, also details that, in addition to sale and
purchase of the seller assets, the parties have agreed to
representations and warranties, along with conditions
precedent clauses and also sets out termination,
indemnification and survival of representations and
covenants clauses. In the agreement, a Clause setting
down the Governing Law and Arbitration is also present.
The relevant recitals of the ATA as well as the relevant
Clauses of the ATA are set out below:
“ ASSET TRANSFER AGREEMENT
This Asset Transfer Agreement (the "Agreement") is
made on this 20th day of November 2017, by and
between:
1. WORLD COLOPROCTOLOGY (OPC) PRIVATE
LIMITED, a one person company registered under
the provisions of the Indian Companies Act, 2013
having its registered office at No. 438, 8th Cross, 5th
Main, RMV Stage 2, Dollars Colony Bangalore, Karnataka
560 094 (hereinafter referred to as the "Seller"
which expression shall, unless repugnant or contrary to
9

HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:61469
WP No. 35599 of 2024

CNR: KAHC010756212024


the context or meaning thereof, be deemed to mean and
include its successors and permitted assigns)
represented herein by its sole shareholder and
Director, Dr. Yuvrajsingh Pralhadsingh Gehlot ;
AND
II. SMILES INTERNATIONAL INSTITUTE OF COLO
PROCTLOGY PRIVATE LIMITED, a company
incorporated in accordance with the provisions of the
Companies Act, 2013 and having its registered office at
No. 438, 8th Cross, 5th Main, RMV Stage 2, Dollars
Colony Bangalore, Karnataka 560 094 (hereinafter
referred to as the "Purchaser", which expression
shall, unless repugnant to the context or meaning
thereof, be deemed to mean and include its successors-
in-interest and permitted assigns), represented herein
by its authorized signatory Ms. SUNAGAHALLI
JAYRAM ANURADHA its Director .
The Seller and the Purchaser are hereinafter collectively
referred to as the "Parties" and individually as a "Party",
as the context may require.

WHEREAS:
A. The Seller is engaged in the Seller's business of
Running Specialty hospital for various colorectal
disorders like piles/hemorrhoids, fissures, fistula, colon
cancers, constipation, IBD, JBS, etc;
B. The Purchaser is desirous of purchasing all the
assets associated with the Seller's business (the
"Seller Assets") in order to use and apply them in the
Purchaser's own business;
xxx xxx xxx
E. This Agreement contains finally agreed terms
and conditions and supersedes all previous
agreements, arrangements, letters of intent, writings,
understandings etc., in respect of this transaction,
except to the extent expressly set out herein below.
10

HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:61469
WP No. 35599 of 2024

CNR: KAHC010756212024


NOW THEREFORE, in consideration of the promises and
covenants herein set forth and for other good and
valuable consideration, the receipt, adequacy and legal
sufficiency of which are hereby acknowledged, the
Parties mutually agree as follows:
xxx xxx xxx
2. Sale and Purchase of the Seller Assets
2.1. Sale of Seller Assets : Subject to the terms and
conditions of this Agreement, on the Closing Date and at
the Closing provided for in Clause 2.3, in consideration
for the issuance and allotment of the Purchase Shares
(as defined below), the Seller shall sell, assign, transfer
and convey to the Purchaser, and the Purchaser shall
acquire from the Seller, the Seller Assets, including all
goodwill, rights, entitlements and benefit related to the
Seller Assets, as set forth below.
2.1.1. The sale of the Seller Assets would, inter alia,
consist of the following components:
2.1.1.1. The trademarks that were originally used
and associated with the Purchaser's business and
used by the Purchaser for long periods of time
before the same was registered by the Seller and out
in Annexure I to this Agreement, along with all
proprietary and intellectual property rights vesting in the
same (the "Trademarks");
2.1.1.2. The ownership of and all rights to the
website www.bengalurusmiles.com including all
information, layout, designs, diagrams and content
thereof (the "Website");
2.1.1.3. Movable properties used and applied in the
Seller's business (the "Movable Property") which
has been detailed in Annexure II;
11

HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:61469
WP No. 35599 of 2024

CNR: KAHC010756212024


2.1.1.4. All documents, instruments, papers, books,
records, books of account, files and data (including
customer and supplier lists), catalogs, brochures, sales
literature, promotional materials, certificates, Tax books
and records and other documents to the extent solely
and specifically related to the Seller's business of the
Seller and copies of the Tax books and records relating
to the Seller's business not otherwise provided pursuant
to this Clause (the "Books and Records");
2.1.1.5. Any and all accounts receivable, arising
out of the Seller Assets and/or the Seller's business of
the Seller, and any and all notes, debts, trade
receivables (whether current or non-current), and other
receivables arising out of Seller Assets and/or the
Seller's business of the Seller (collectively,
"Receivables");
2.1.1.6. Any and all inventories, discoveries,
improvements, processes, methods, designs,
formulae (secret or otherwise), data, engineering,
technical and shop drawings, specifications, trade
secrets, confidential information, technology, know-how,
shop rights, and any and all drawings, records, books or
other indication, however evidenced, of the foregoing,
together with any and all rights to use any or all of the
foregoing, and any and all goodwill, if any,
associated with any of the foregoing (hereafter,
collectively "Know-How"), in each case to the
extent solely and specifically related to the Seller
Assets set forth in this Clause 2.1.1;
2.1.1.7. Any and all office, production or supplies, items,
materials, spare parts and other miscellaneous supplies
used solely and specifically for the Seller's business set
forth in Clause 2.1.1 (collectively, "Office Supplies");
2.1.1.8. Any and all prepaid expenses arising out of or
related to the Seller Assets set forth in Clause 2.1.1 and
reflected on the balance sheet as on 19th November
12

HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:61469
WP No. 35599 of 2024

CNR: KAHC010756212024


2017 (the "Balance Sheet Date") or arising in the
ordinary course of business since the Balance Sheet Date
and reasonably necessary for the conduct of the Seller's
business associated with the Seller's business set forth in
Clause 2.1.1;
2.1.1.9. Any and all goodwill, if any, of the Seller's
business relating to the Seller's Assets as set forth
Clause 2.1.1, as a going concern.
2.2. Consideration for the Purchase: In
consideration for the transfer by the Seller to the
Purchaser of the Seller Assets, at Closing, the
Purchaser shall issue and allot 5000 shares (i.e,
50% stake) in the Purchaser, free from any and all
kinds of Encumbrances to the Seller (the
"Purchase Shares").
2.3. It is agreed to between the Seller and the Purchaser
that besides the Seller Assets that have been detailed in
Clause 2.1.1, no other asset or liability of the Seller's
business is being acquired by the Purchaser.
4.Representations and Warranties of the Purchaser
The Purchaser represents and warrants, to and for the
benefit of the Seller, as follows:
4.1. Organisation: The Purchaser is a private limited
company duly incorporated and subsisting under the
laws of India, duly qualified to transact business and to
complete the transaction envisaged in this Agreement
upon fulfillment of the conditions precedent in
accordance with the provisions of this Agreement.
4.2. Authority; Binding Nature of Agreements: The
Purchaser has the absolute and unrestricted right,
power and authority to enter into and to perform
its obligations under this Agreement; and the
execution, delivery and performance by the
Purchaser of this Agreement has been duly
13

HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:61469
WP No. 35599 of 2024

CNR: KAHC010756212024


authorized by all necessary action on the part of
Purchaser and its respective board of directors and
officers. This Agreement constitutes the legal, valid and
binding obligation of the Purchaser, enforceable against
the Purchaser in accordance with its terms.
xxx xxx xxx
7. Termination
7.1. Termination Events: This Agreement may be
terminated prior to the Closing:
7.1.1. by the Purchaser if: (i) there is a material breach
of any covenant or obligation of the Seller and such
breach shall not have been cured within ten (10) days
after the delivery of notice thereof to the Seller; or (ii)
the Purchaser reasonably determines that the timely
satisfaction of any condition set forth in Clause 5 has
become impossible or impractical (other than as a result
of any failure on the part of the Purchaser to comply with
or perform its covenants and obligations set forth in this
Agreement);
7.1.2. by the Purchaser at or after the Scheduled Closing
Time if any condition set forth in Clause 5 has not been
satisfied by the Scheduled Closing Time;
7.1.3. by the Purchaser if the Closing has not taken
place on or before 20th November 2017 (other than as a
result of any failure on the part of the Purchaser to
comply with or perform its covenants and obligations
under this Agreement); or
7.1.4. by the mutual written consent of the Purchaser
and the Seller.
xxx xxx xxx
10.2. Notices: Any notice or other communication
required or permitted to be delivered to any Party
under this Agreement shall be in writing and shall
14

HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:61469
WP No. 35599 of 2024

CNR: KAHC010756212024


be deemed properly delivered, given and received when
delivered (by hand, by courier service or by e-mail) to
the address or email id set forth beneath the name of
such Party below (or to such other address or e-mail id
as such Party shall have specified in a written notice
given to the other Parties hereto):
If to the Seller:
st st
Address: #423/2, 60ft road, 1 stage, 1 phase, behind
SBI, Mathikere main road, Bengaluru,
Karnataka - 560054.
Email: [email protected]
Attn: Yuvrajsingh Pralhadsingh Gehlot, Director.

If to the Purchaser:
th th
Address: # 438, 8 Cross, 5 Main, RMV Stage 2,
Dollars Colony Bangalore, Karnataka - 560 094.
Email: [email protected]
Attn: SUNAGAHALLI JAYRAM ANURADHA, Director.

10.3. Counterparts: This Agreement may be executed in
several counterparts, each of which shall be an original
and all of which, when taken together, shall constitute
one agreement.
10.4. Governing Law; Arbitration:

This Agreement shall be governed by the laws of India.

The Parties agree that all disputes arising under or
in connection with this Agreement shall be referred
to arbitration under the provisions of the Indian
Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996.”

[Emphasis Supplied]

8.2 Annexure I and Annexure II of the agreement set out
a ‘list of trademarks’ and a ‘list of movable properties’
which are being sold. The agreement is signed by the
15

HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:61469
WP No. 35599 of 2024

CNR: KAHC010756212024


parties named above, and it is witnessed by two parties
who have set out their names and mobile numbers. The
ATA also has been notarized on 20.11.2017, the date of
the agreement.

9. Sub-Section (1) of Section 8 of the A & C Act provides
that where an arbitration agreement is brought before a
judicial authority before whom proceedings are pending
not later than the date of submitting its first of defense,
such judicial authority shall refer the parties to the dispute
to Arbitration in terms of this provision, unless it finds, on
a prima facie view, that no valid arbitration agreement
exists. Sub-Section (2) of Section 8 provides that every
application referred to Sub-Section (1) must be
accompanied by an original agreement or a duly certified
copy thereof. Section 8 of the A & C Act is set out below:
8. Power to refer parties to arbitration where there
“
is an arbitration agreement.
(1) A judicial authority, before which an action is brought
in a matter which is the subject of an arbitration
agreement shall, if a party to the arbitration
agreement or any person claiming through or under
him, so applies not later than the date of submitting
16

HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:61469
WP No. 35599 of 2024

CNR: KAHC010756212024


his first statement on the substance of the dispute,
then, notwithstanding any judgment, decree or
order of the Supreme Court or any Court, refer the
parties to arbitration unless it finds that prima facie
no valid arbitration agreement exists.
(2) The application referred to in sub-section (1) shall not
be entertained unless it is accompanied by the
original arbitration agreement or a duly certified
copy thereof:
Provided that where the original arbitration agreement
or a certified copy thereof is not available with the party
applying for reference to arbitration under sub-section
(1), and the said agreement or certified copy is retained
by the other party to that agreement, then, the party so
applying shall file such application along with a
copy of the arbitration agreement and a petition
praying the Court to call upon the other party to
produce the original arbitration agreement or its
duly certified copy before that Court .
(3) Notwithstanding that an application has been made
under sub-section (1) and that the issue is pending before
the judicial authority, an arbitration may be commenced
or continued and an arbitral award made.”

[Emphasis Supplied]

10. The Supreme Court in its judgment in the case of In
Re-Interplay Between Arbitration Agreements under
the Arbitration Act, 1996 and the Indian Stamp Act,
1
1899 , has while interpreting this provision, held that
when an application under Section 8 of the A & C Act is
filed, the Court will examine if an original agreement is

1

(2024) 6 SCC 1
17

HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:61469
WP No. 35599 of 2024

CNR: KAHC010756212024


produced and the Court would prima facie examine the
existence of an arbitration agreement and an arbitral
clause. It was further held that all that a referral Court is
required to prima facie examine, is the existence of an
Arbitration Agreement and unless it finds the agreement is
incapable of performance or void, the matter shall be
referred to an Arbitration. The relevant extract is below:


“147. In the Indian context, Section 8 provides that
when an action is brought before a judicial authority
in a matter which is the subject of an arbitration
agreement, such judicial authority shall refer the
parties to arbitration on an application made by a
party to the arbitration agreement or any person
claiming through or under him not later than the
date of submitting their first statement on the
substance of the dispute . Section 8 mandates the
judicial authority to refer the parties to arbitration “unless
it finds that prima facie no valid arbitration agreement
exists”. Section 8 is based on Article 8 of the Model
Law which provides that a “court” before which an
action is brought in a matter which is the subject of
an arbitration agreement shall refer the parties to
arbitration “unless it finds that the agreement is
null and void, inoperative or incapable of being
performed ”. It is evident that Section 8 has made a
departure from Article 8 by using the expansive term
“judicial authority” rather than “court”. The intention of
the legislature to provide an expansive application can
also be gauged from the fact that the expression “unless it
finds that the agreement is null and void, inoperative or
incapable of being performed” does not find place in
Section 8.

xxx xxx xxx
18

HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:61469
WP No. 35599 of 2024

CNR: KAHC010756212024


164. The 2015 Amendment Act has laid down different
parameters for judicial review under Sectio 8 and Section
11. Where Section 8 requires the Referral Court to
look into the prima facie existence of a valid
arbitration agreement, Section 11 confines the
Court’s jurisdiction to the examination of the
existence of an arbitration agreement. Although the
object and purpose behind both Sections 8 and 11 is to
compel parties to abide by their contractual
understanding, the scope of power of the Referral Courts
under the said provisions is intended to be different. The
same is also evident from the fact that Section 37 of the
Arbitration Act allows an appeal from the order of an
Arbitral Tribunal refusing to refer the parties to arbitration
under Section 8, but not from Section 11. Thus, the 2015
Amendment Act has legislatively overruled the dictum of
Patel Engg. where it was held that Section 8 and Section
11 are complementary in nature. Accordingly, the two
provisions cannot be read as laying down a similar
standard.

165. The legislature confined the scope of reference under
Section 11(6-A) to the examination of the existence
of an arbitration agreement. The use of the term
“examination” in itself connotes that the scope of
the power is limited to a prima facie determination.
Since the Arbitration Act is a self-contained code,
the requirement of “existence” of an arbitration
agreement draws effect from Section 7 of the
Arbitration Act. In Duro Felguera, this Court held that
the Referral Courts only need to consider one aspect to
determine the existence of an arbitration agreement –
whether the underlying contract contains an arbitration
agreement which provides for arbitration pertaining
to disputes which have arisen between the parties
to the agreement. Therefore, the scope of
examination under Section 11(6-A) should be
confined to the existence of an arbitration
agreement, in view of Section 7 . Similarly, the validity
of an arbitration agreement, in view of Section 7, should
be restricted to the requirement of formal validity such as
the requirement that the agreement be in writing. This
interpretation also gives true effect to the doctrine of
competence-competence by leaving the issue of
19

HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:61469
WP No. 35599 of 2024

CNR: KAHC010756212024


substantive existence and validity of an arbitration
agreement to be decided by Arbitral Tribunal under
Section 16. We accordingly clarify the position of law laid
down in Vidya Drolia in the context of Section 8 and
Section 11 of the Arbitration Act.

xxx xxx xxx

229. The discussion in preceding segments indicates
that the Referral Court at Section 11 stage should not
examine or impound an unstamped or insufficiently
stamped instrument, but rather leave it for the
determination by the Arbitral Tribunal. When a party
produces an arbitration agreement or its certified
copy, the Referral Court only has to examine
whether an arbitration agreement exists in terms of
Section 7 of the Arbitration Act. The Referral Court
under Section 11 is not required to examine
whether a certified copy of the agreement/
instrument/contract discloses the fact of payment
of stamp duty on the original. Accordingly, we hold
that the holding of this Court in SMS Tea Estates, as
reiterated in N.N.Global, is no longer valid in law.”

[Emphasis Supplied]

11. The learned Commercial Court has done exactly that.
The Impugned Order clearly sets out that the original
agreement has been produced and that the original
agreement contains an arbitral clause, thus, all disputes
need to be referred to arbitration.

12. Given what is stated above, this Court finds no
ground to interfere with the Impugned Order, in exercise
20

HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:61469
WP No. 35599 of 2024

CNR: KAHC010756212024


of the jurisdiction under Article 227 of the Constitution of
India.

13. The petition is accordingly, dismissed . All pending
applications stand closed.
Digitally signed by TARA
VITASTA GANJU
Location: HIGH COURT OF
KARNATAKA


(TARA VITASTA GANJU)
JUDGE

BMV*
List No.: 2 Sl No.: 1
21