MAHENDRA KUMAR DUGAR vs RENTCONTROLLER AT CLCUTTA AND ANR

Court
Calcutta High Court

Form No. J(2)





In the High Court at Calcutta
Constitutional Writ Jurisdiction
Appellate Side


Present: The Hon’be Justice Sabyasachi Bhattacharyya
And
The Hon’ble Justice Md. Shabbar Rashidi


WPLRT 55 of 2026

Mahendra Kumar Dugar
Vs.
Rent Controller at Calcutta and another

With

WPLRT 56 of 2026

Bharat Auto Stores
Vs.
Rent Controller at Calcutta and another

With

WPLRT 57 of 2026

Noratanmal Jain
Vs.
Rent Controller at Calcutta and another

With

WPLRT 58 of 2026

M/s. Khaitan Trading Corporation, represented by its partner
Kishan Kumar Khaitan
Vs.
Rent Controller at Calcutta and another


2

With

WPLRT 59 of 2026

Hanuman Mal BalchandNahata alias
Balchand Nahata
Vs.
Rent Controller at Calcutta and another

With

WPLRT 60 of 2026

Hanuman Mal Noratan Jain
Vs.
Rent Controller at Calcutta and another





For the petitioner : Mr. Souryajit Sengupta,
Mr. Sachinda Nanada Pandey
Mr. K.P. Tiwari

For the State : Mr. Nilanjan Bhattacharjee, SSC
Mr. Bratin Kumar Dey

For the private respondent : Mr. Avishek Prasad
Ms. Riya Ballav
Ms. Shreyasi Manna

Heard on : 17.11.2026

Judgment on : 17.11.2026





Sabyasachi Bhattacharyya, J.:-


1. In view of the identity of the issues involved, all the matters are
taken up for hearing together.

3

2. The present writ petitioners have been preferred against orders
whereby the West Bengal Land Reforms and Tenancy Tribunal,
in challenges preferred by the tenant/petitioners against the
determination of fair rent by the Controller under the West
Bengal Premises Tenancy Act, 1997, refused to grant
stay/injunction.
3. Learned counsel for the petitioners submits that by dint of the
directions of the Tribunal passed in the self-same original
applications, the petitioners have already paid half of the
amount adjudicated as fair rent to the landlord/private
respondent.
4. Despite the same, it is submitted that the prayer for stay has
been refused in all the matters, thereby jeopardizing the
petitioners, particularly since the respondents/landlord have
already initiated suits for eviction against the petitioners on the
ground of non-payment of rent at the rate as decided by the
Controller as fair rent.

5. Learned counsel appearing for the respondents submits that the
learned Tribunal rightly observed that the petitioners have an
equally efficacious alternative remedy than injunction in the
form of monetary compensation.
6. As such, it is argued that the learned Tribunal rightly dismissed
the applications for stay.

4

7. Upon a perusal of the impugned orders, we find a confusion of
concepts on the part of the learned Tribunal, since the
yardsticks applicable to injunction have been applied, despite
the applications which were being heard were for stay.
8. Be that as it may, unless orders of stay are granted, the very
challenges to the adjudication of fair rent thrown by the
petitioners in the original applications would be rendered
infructuous.
9. However, at the same time, equities ought to be balanced,
inasmuch as the petitioners ought to go on paying occupation
charges to the private respondents as a condition for such stay
at the previous rates of rent which were being paid prior to
fixation of fair rent in each of the matters.
10. Accordingly, WPLRT 55 of 2026, WPLRT 56 of 2026, WPLRT 57
of 2026, WPLRT 58 of 2026, WPLRT 59 of 2026 and WPLRT 60 of
2026 are disposed of by setting aside the orders impugned
therein, disposing of the stay applications in connection with the
original applications by granting stay of operation of the orders
of the Rent Controller fixing fair rent, subject to the condition
that the petitioners shall go on paying monthly occupation
charges to the private respondent at the rates at which rent was
being previously paid by the petitioners prior to the adjudication
of fair rent.

5

11. The first of such monthly occupation charges shall be paid by
the petitioner in each of the matters on or before November 30,
2026, for the current month of November, 2026, and thereafter
by the last day of each succeeding month for the said current
month.

12. Such payments shall be without prejudice to the rights and
contentions of the parties in the original applications and shall
be subject to the final orders passed in the original applications.
13. It is made clear that the merits of the contentions of the parties
in the original applications have not been gone into by this
Court.
14. We further clarify that in default of any of the monthly payments
as directed above in each of the cases, the stay granted by us
shall stand automatically vacated without further reference to
the Court or the Tribunal.
15. In view of the long pendency of the original applications before
the Tribunal, we request the learned Tribunal to dispose of the
original applications as expeditiously as possible, preferably
within three months from the date of communication of this
order to the Tribunal.
16. There will be no order as to costs.

6

17. Urgent photostat certified copies of this judgment, if applied for,
be given to the parties upon compliance of all requisite
formalities.


(Sabyasachi Bhattacharyya, J.)
I agree.

(Md. Shabbar Rashidi , J.)

AD-40-45
AK