Vinod Kumar Singh vs State Of U.P. And 3 Others

Court
Allahabad High Court

HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT ALLAHABAD
CRIMINAL MISC. WRIT PETITION No. - 1902 of 2026

Vinod Kumar Singh
.....Petitioner(s)
Versus
State Of U.P. And 3 Others
.....Respondent(s)
Counsel for Petitioner(s) : Sapana Singh, Vikas Mishra
Counsel for Respondent(s) : G.A.
A.F.R.
Court No. - 73
HON'BLE SANDEEP JAIN, J.
1. The present writ petition has been instituted praying for the following
reliefs:-
i. Issue an order or direction in the nature of certiorari quashing the judgment and
order dated 27.11.2025 (Annexure No.13 of the writ petition) passed by
Commissioner, Varanasi Division, Varanasi in Case NO.3662 of 2025 (Computerized
Case No. C202514000003662) and judgment and order dated 06.03.2025 (Annexure
No.8 to the writ petition) passed by learned District Magistrate, Chandauli in Case
No. 1093 of 2024 (State Versus Vinod Kumar Singh) (Computer Case No.
D202414180001093) under section 5(Ka) of Uttar Pradesh Cow Slaughter
(Prevention) Act, arising out of Case crime no.100 of 2024, under sections 3/5A/5B/8
of Cow Slaughter Act and section 11 of Animal Cruelty Act, Police Station
Shahabganj, District Chandauli;
ii. issue an order or direction in the nature of mandamus directing the courts below
not to give effect to the judgment and order dated 27.11.2025 passed by
Commissioner, Varanasi Division, Varanasi in Case No.3662 of 2025 (Computerized
Case No. C202514000003662) and judgment and order dated 06.03.2025 passed by
learned District Magistrate, Chandauli in Case No. 1093 of 2024 (State Versus Vinod
Kumar Singh) (Computer Case No. D202414180001093) under section 5(Ka) of Uttar
Pradesh Cow Slaughter (Prevention) Act, arising out of Case crime no. 100 of 2024
under sections 3/5A/5B/8 of Cow Slaughter Act and Section 11 of Animal Cruelty Act,
Police Station Shahabganj, District Chandauli .
iii. issue an order or direction in the nature of mandamus directing the concern police

CRLP No. 1902 of 2026
2
of Police Station Shahabganj to release the vehicle no.UP65 KT-4942 Tata ACE
GOLD in favour of petitioner which is standing in the campus of Police Station
Shahabganj, District Chandauli and deteriorated day by day."
2. Counter affidavit and rejoinder affidavit have been exchanged between
the parties.
Facts of the Case
3. The factual matrix, as borne out from the record, is that the petitioner is
the registered owner of a Tata Ace Gold Diesel transport vehicle bearing
Registration No. UP-65-KT-4942. According to the prosecution, on
19.09.2024, acting upon secret information received from an informer, the
police personnel of Police Station Sahabganj, District Chandauli
intercepted the aforesaid vehicle on suspicion that bovine animals were
being illegally transported from the State of Uttar Pradesh to the State of
Bihar for the purpose of slaughter. Consequently, Case Crime No.100 of
2024 was registered against the petitioner under Section 11 of the
Prevention of Cruelty to Animals Act, 1960 and Sections 5, 3/5-A/ 8 of
the Uttar Pradesh Prevention of Cow Slaughter Act, 1955 (hereinafter
referred to as "the Act of 1955").
4. The case of the State is that upon search of the vehicle, three bovine
animals (2 cows and 1 calf) were allegedly recovered, which were being
transported in contravention of the provisions of the Act of 1955 with the
intention of taking them to the State of Bihar for slaughter. On the basis
of the aforesaid allegations, proceedings for confiscation of the vehicle
were initiated by the District Magistrate, Chandauli under the provisions
of Section 5-A(7) of the Act of 1955.
5. A notice was accordingly issued to the petitioner, calling upon him to
show cause as to why the vehicle in question should not be confiscated in
favour of the State Government.
6. In response to the said notice, the petitioner filed his detailed objections
before the District Magistrate. It was specifically pleaded that the
allegations levelled by the police authorities were wholly false, fabricated
and contrary to the material available on record. The petitioner asserted

CRLP No. 1902 of 2026
3
that only one cow and one calf were being transported in the vehicle, both
of which belonged to one Radhey Shyam, who had sold the said animals
to one Kalluram for a consideration of Rs.2,000/-, and the petitioner was
merely transporting those animals to the residence of Mantosh. It was
further pleaded that the destination of the vehicle was entirely within the
State of Uttar Pradesh and there was no intention whatsoever of
transporting the animals to the State of Bihar or for the purpose of
slaughter.
7. The petitioner further alleged that while the vehicle was on its way, it
was intercepted by the police personnel, who demanded illegal
gratification from the driver. Upon refusal to accede to such unlawful
demand, the vehicle was falsely implicated and seized. It was also
specifically pleaded that, contrary to the allegations contained in the First
Information Report, only two bovine animals were present in the vehicle,
whereas the police had falsely shown recovery of three animals solely to
strengthen an otherwise unsustainable prosecution case.
8. The District Magistrate, however, did not accept the explanation
offered by the petitioner. While relying principally upon the report of the
Veterinary Officer dated 19.09.2024, the District Magistrate concluded
that the bovine animals had been transported in a cruel manner, thereby
attracting the provisions of Section 5-B of the Act of 1955. The District
Magistrate further held that in view of the statutory presumption
contained in Section 5-A(10) of the Act of 1955, the burden lay upon the
petitioner to establish that the transportation was not for the purpose of
slaughter, and according to the District Magistrate, the petitioner had
failed to discharge the said burden.
9. The District Magistrate further recorded a finding that in view of
Section 5-A(1) of the Act of 1955 read with Rule 16(1) of the Uttar
Pradesh Prevention of Cow Slaughter Rules, 1964, prior permission in the
form of permit, was mandatory for transportation of bovine animals,
which admittedly had not been produced by the driver at the time of
interception. Proceeding on the aforesaid reasoning, the District
Magistrate presumed that the bovine animals were being transported for
slaughter in violation of the statutory provisions and, accordingly, by

CRLP No. 1902 of 2026
4
order dated 06.03.2025, confiscated the petitioner's vehicle in favour of
the State Government.
10. Aggrieved thereby, the petitioner preferred Appeal No.3662 of 2025
(Vinod Kumar Singh v. State of U.P. and others) under Section 5-A(8) of
the Act of 1955 before the Commissioner, Varanasi Division, Varanasi. In
the memorandum of appeal, the petitioner reiterated all the submissions
which had been advanced before the District Magistrate and specifically
contended that the confiscation proceedings were founded merely upon
assumptions and conjectures without any legally admissible evidence
demonstrating that the animals were being transported either outside the
State or for the purpose of slaughter.
11. The appellate authority, however, concurred with the findings
recorded by the District Magistrate. It held that the petitioner had failed to
substantiate his defence through cogent evidence and, consequently,
dismissed the appeal by order dated 27.11.2025, affirming the order of
confiscation.
12. Being aggrieved by the orders dated 06.03.2025 passed by the District
Magistrate, Chandauli and 27.11.2025 passed by the Commissioner,
Varanasi Division, Varanasi, the petitioner has invoked the extraordinary
jurisdiction of this Court under Article 226 of the Constitution of India.
Submissions of learned counsel for the parties
13. Learned counsel appearing for the petitioner submits that both the
impugned orders suffer from manifest illegality, patent arbitrariness and
complete non-application of mind.
14. It is contended that there is not an iota of evidence on record to
establish that the cow and its progeny were being transported to the State
of Bihar or that the transportation was intended for the purpose of
slaughter. The authorities have proceeded merely on conjectures by
drawing an inference solely because the vehicle was intercepted in
District Chandauli, which shares its boundary with the State of Bihar.
Such an inference, according to the learned counsel, is wholly speculative
and unsupported by any admissible evidence.

CRLP No. 1902 of 2026
5
15. It is further submitted that neither any beef nor any remains of
slaughtered cow were recovered from the vehicle. Equally, no material
has been brought on record to indicate that any slaughterhouse was the
intended destination of the vehicle or that any overt act suggesting an
intention to slaughter the animals had been committed by the petitioner.
16. Learned counsel further submits that the confiscating authority has
completely misread the provisions of the Act of 1955 and the Rules
framed thereunder. It is argued that no permit or permission is required
for transportation of cow and its progeny within the territorial limits of the
State of Uttar Pradesh, and this legal position has consistently been
affirmed by this Court in a catena of decisions. Consequently, the entire
foundation of the confiscation proceedings is contrary to the statutory
scheme.
17. It is next submitted that the petitioner's vehicle constitutes his sole
source of livelihood. The vehicle had been purchased by availing
financial assistance from HDB Financial Services Limited, under a loan
agreement requiring repayment in 41 monthly installments (EMIs) of
Rs.12,599/- each. Learned counsel submits that even after seizure of the
vehicle, the petitioner, despite acute financial hardship, continued to repay
the loan installments up to November, 2025 solely to minimise the
mounting financial liability. Thereafter, owing to the continued
confiscation of the vehicle and consequent loss of income, the petitioner
became financially incapable of servicing the remaining loan liability,
resulting in default of the balance instalments.
18. It is, therefore, argued that the illegal confiscation of the vehicle has
not only deprived the petitioner of his principal means of livelihood but
has also subjected him to severe financial distress, mental agony and
economic hardship. Consequently, apart from quashing the impugned
confiscation orders, the petitioner also claims compensation towards the
loss of earnings suffered during the period of illegal confiscation, together
with damages for the mental harassment, humiliation and financial
hardship caused by the arbitrary action of the State authorities.
19. Per contra, learned A.G.A. has supported the impugned orders and
submitted that the confiscation proceedings have been conducted strictly

CRLP No. 1902 of 2026
6
in accordance with the provisions of the Uttar Pradesh Prevention of Cow
Slaughter Act, 1955.
20. It is contended that the vehicle of the petitioner was intercepted while
carrying cow and its progeny without any valid permission as
contemplated under the provisions of the Act of 1955 and the Rules
framed thereunder. According to the learned AGA, the petitioner failed to
produce any authorization or permit permitting transportation of the cow
and its progeny, thereby attracting the statutory consequences envisaged
under the Act.
21. It is further submitted that the place of interception, namely District
Chandauli, is situated on the border of the State of Bihar. Considering the
route adopted by the vehicle and the surrounding circumstances, the
competent authorities rightly inferred that the cow and its progeny were
being transported outside the State of Uttar Pradesh for the purpose of
slaughter. Such a factual inference, according to the learned AGA, cannot
be interfered with by this Court in exercise of its writ jurisdiction.
22. Learned AGA has also argued that the Veterinary Officer's report
clearly demonstrates that the cow and its progeny were being transported
in a manner causing unnecessary pain and suffering, thereby attracting the
provisions of the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals Act, 1960 as well as
Section 5-B of the Act of 1955. It is, therefore, submitted that the
confiscation order cannot be faulted.
23. Lastly, it is submitted that once the confiscation has been validly
made under the statutory provisions, the petitioner is not entitled to claim
any compensation on account of alleged loss of livelihood or financial
hardship. The State cannot be saddled with monetary liability merely
because the petitioner remained deprived of the use of the vehicle during
the pendency of confiscation proceedings. It is thus prayed that the writ
petition, being devoid of merit, deserves to be dismissed.
Conclusion of this Court
24. I have heard learned counsel for the parties at length and have
carefully perused the pleadings exchanged between them, the impugned

CRLP No. 1902 of 2026
7
orders and the material available on record.
25. In order to appreciate the rival submissions advanced by the learned
counsel for the parties, it would be appropriate to first examine the
relevant statutory provisions governing the controversy.
26. Accordingly, Sections 5, 5-A and 5-B of the Uttar Pradesh Prevention
of Cow Slaughter Act, 1955 read with Rule 16 of the Uttar Pradesh
Prevention of Cow Slaughter Rules, 1964 are being reproduced
hereinafter:
" 5. Prohibition on sale of beef. - Except as herein excepted and notwithstanding
anything contained in any other law for the time being in force, no person shall sell or
transport or offer for sale or transport or cause to be sold or transported beef or beef
products in any form except for such medicinal purposes as may be prescribed.
Exception–A person may sell and serve or cause to be sold and served beef or beef-
products for consumption by a bonafide passenger in an air-craft or railway train.
" 5-A.Regulation on transport of cow, etc. -(1) No person shall transport or offer for
transport or cause to be transported any cow, or bull or bullock, the slaughter
whereof in any place in Uttar Pradesh is punishable under this Act from any place
within the State to any place outside the State, except under a permit issued by an
officer authorized by the State Government in this behalf by notified order and except
in accordance with the terms and conditions of such permit.
(2) Such officer shall issue the permit on payment of such fee not exceeding [five
hundred rupees ] for every cow, bull or bullock as may be prescribed :
Provided that no fee shall be chargeable where the permit is for transport of the cow,
bull or bullock for a limited period not exceeding six months as may be specified in
the permit.
(3) Where the person transporting a cow, bull or bullock on a permit for a limited
period does not bring back such cow, bull or bullock into the State within the period
specified in the permit, he shall be deemed to have contravened the provision of sub-
section (1).
(4) The form of permit, the form of application therefor and the procedure for disposal
of such application shall be such as may be prescribed.

CRLP No. 1902 of 2026
8
(5) The State Government or any officer authorized by it in this behalf by general or
special notified order, may, at any time for the purpose of satisfying itself or himself,
as to the legality or propriety of the action taken under this section, call for and
examine the record of any case and pass such orders thereon as it or he may deem
fit.]
[(6) Where the said conveyance has been confirmed to be related to beef by the
competent authority or authorised laboratary under this Act, the driver, operator and
owner related to transport, shall be charged with the offence under this Act, unless it
is not proved that transport medium used in crime, despite all its precautions and
without its knowledge, has been used by some other person for causing the offence.
(7) The vehicle by which the beef or cow and its progeny is transported in violation of
the provisions of this Act and the relevant rules, shall be confiscated and seized by the
law enforcement officers. The concerned District Magistrate/Commissioner of Police
will do all proceedings of confiscation and release, as the case may be.
(8) The cow and its progeny or the beef transported by the seized vehicle shall also be
confiscated and seized by the law enforcement officers. The concerned District
Magistrate/Commissioner will do all proceedings of the confiscation and release, as
the case may be.
(9) The expenditure on the maintenance of the seized cows and its progeny shall be
recovered from the accused for a period of one year or till the release of the cow and
it's progeny in favour of the owner thereof whichever is earlier.
(10) Where a person is prosecuted for committing abetting, or attempting to an
offence under section 3, 5 and 8 of this Act and the beef or cow-remains in the
possession of accused has been proved by the prosecution and transported things are
confirmed to be beef by the competent authority or authorized laboratory, then the
Court shall presume that such person has committed such offence or attempt or
abetment of such offence, as the case may be, unless the contrary is proved.
(11) Where the provision of this Act or the related rules in context of search,
acquisition, disposal and seizure are silent, the relevant provisions of the Code of
Criminal Procedure, 1973 shall be effective thereto.]
- Whoever causes any physically injury to any cow or its progeny so as to
5-B.

CRLP No. 1902 of 2026
9
endanger the life thereof such as to mutilate its body or to transport it in any situation
whereby endangering the life thereof or with the intention of endangering the life
thereof does not provide with food or water shall be punished with imprisonment for a
term which shall not be less than one year and which may extend to seven years and
with fine which shall not be less than one Lakh rupees and which may extend to three
Lakh rupees.
Rule 16. -(1) Any person intending to transport or the offer for transport or to cause to
transport any cow, bull or bullock, the slaughter whereof is punishable under this Act
in any place in Uttar Pradesh from any place within the State to any place outside the
State shall apply for a permit to the licensing authority on prescribed Form "G".
(2)The licensing authority may grant such permit on payment of fee of Rs. 5.00
(Rupees five) per cow, bull or bullock to be deposited through treasury Challan under
the receipt head '110 - Puashupalan - A - Other receipt (6) Misc.' In case the animal
so transported is brought back to the State within the period of six months from the
date of issue of the permit, the fee Rs. 5.00 shall be refunded to the permit-holder, if
the refund is claimed. All animal intended to be transported shall be tattooed in right
ear prior to the transportation from the State.
(3)Cow, bull or bullock transported without a valid permit shall be confiscated and
shall be auctioned and the sale proceeds will be deposited under the receipt head
given in sub-rule (2) above and such person, who causes unauthorised transport shall
be prosecuted under Section 8 of the Act.
(4)The permit referred in sub-rule (2) shall be in Form 'H'.
(5)In the event of death of the cow, bull or bullock being so transported prior to its
return, the permit-holder shall submit the death certificate from the local Veterinary
Surgeon to the licensing authority failing which he shall be liable for prosecution
under Section 8 of the Act.
(6)These rules shall also apply to the cow, bulls or bullocks transported to cattle fairs,
exhibitions and markets outside the State. The permit-holder shall have to submit a
certificate of sale from the manager of such fairs, exhibitions and market to the
licensing authority on Form I failing which he shall be liable to prosecution under
Section 8 of the Act.

CRLP No. 1902 of 2026
10
(7)In case cow, bulls or bullocks are needed by another State Government of
recognised institutions outside the State, such permit for transportation of animal will
be granted on deposit of requisite fees by the party concerned under sub-rule (2), but
the application shall have to be routed through the State Government concerned."
27. Further, this Court in the case of
Kaliya vs. State of UP And Others
2023 SCC OnLine All 1974 , held as under:-
"10. Having heard learned counsel for the petitioner, learned A.G.A. and going
through the record as well as provisions of the Act, I find that the moot question
involved in this case is whether the present petitioner has violated any provision of
law in transportation of cows and its progeny by the aforesaid vehicle and whether the
impugned orders have been passed confiscating the said vehicle in accordance with
law.
*11.
12.
A perusal of section 5-A(1) of the Act shows that the said provision shall come
into place when the cow or its progeny is transported from within the State of U.P.
to any other place outside the State and in that case, permit issued by the authorised
officer of the State government shall be required.
13. There is nothing on record to show that the alleged recovered animals, i.e. the
cows were being transported from within the State of U.P. to any other State.
Therefore, from the plain reading of section 5-A of the Act, the permit is not required
in the peculiar facts of this case.
14. The question involved in the case in hand has also come up for consideration
before this court in Kailash Yadav v. State of U.P. 2008 (10) ADJ 623 wherein it has
been held that no permit is required for transportation of cow or its progeny within
the State of U.P. Section 5-A(6 to 8) provides for confiscation and release of vehicle
by which beef or cow and its progeny is transported in violation of the provisions of
the Act and relevant rules.
15.
From perusal of sub sections (1 to 5) of section 5-A of the Act and the law laid
down by this court in Kailash Yadav's case (supra), it is evident that there is no need
of permit to transport cow(s) and its progeny within the State of U.P. Hence, such
transportation of cow and its progeny cannot be said to be in violation of the Act.

CRLP No. 1902 of 2026
11
Consequently, it can also not be said that the seized vehicle has been used in
violation of Section 5-A or any other provision of the Act. Therefore, the police has
no power or jurisdiction to seize or confiscate the vehicle in question and the
District Magistrate also could not have issued notice under section 5-A of the Act
when there is nothing to substantiate that the animals were being transported from
within the State to some other State. In other words, in case the animals were being
transported within the State of U.P., no show cause notice under section 5-A of the
Act could have been given.
16. A coordinate Bench of this Court vide judgment and order dated 25.8.2022 passed
in Mohd. Shakib v. State of U.P. Application under section 482 CrPC No. 23143 of
2021 has held that no permit is required to transport cow and its progeny within the
State of U.P. and therefore, it cannot be said that the seized vehicle in question was
used in violation of section 5A(1) to (11) or any provisions of the Cow Slaughter
Act. Relevant paras 12 and 13 of the judgment in Mohd. Shakib's case (supra) is
reproduced as below:
“ 12. Now, it is to be considered whether permit is required for transportation of the
cow or its progeny within the State of Uttar Pradesh. This question came up for
consideration before this Court in Criminal Revision No. 131 of 2005 (Kailash Yadav
v. State of U.P., 2008 (10) ADJ 623), wherein it is held that no permit is required for
transportation of cow or its progeny within the State of Uttar Pradesh. Sub-section 5A
(6 to 8) provides for confiscation and release of vehicle by which beef or cow and its
progeny is transported in violation of the provision of this Act and the relevant rules.
Sub-section 5A (6 to 8) reads as follows:-
(6) Where the said conveyance has been confirmed to be related to beef by the
competent authority or authorised laboratory under this Act, the driver, operator and
owner related to transport, shall be charged with the offence under this Act, unless it
is not proved that the transport medium used in crime, despite all its precautions and
without its knowledge, has been used by some other person for causing the offence.
(7) The vehicle by which the beef or cow and its progeny is transported in violation of
the provisions of this Act and the relevant rules, shall be confiscated and seized by the
law enforcement officers. The concerned District Magistrate/Commissioner of Police
will do all proceedings of confiscation and release, as the case may be.
(8) The cow and its progeny or the beef transported by the seized vehicle shall also be

CRLP No. 1902 of 2026
12
confiscated and seized by the law enforcement officers. The concerned District
Magistrate/Commissioner will do all proceedings of the confiscation and release, as
the case may be.
13. From the perusal of sub-section (1 to 5) of Section 5A of this Act and the law
laid down by this Court in Kailash Yadav v. State of U.P. (supra), it is abundantly
clear that there is no need of permit to transport cow and its progeny within the state
of Uttar Pradesh. Therefore, transportation of a cow and its progeny within the state
of Uttar Pradesh is not a violation of any of the provisions of the Cow Slaughter
Act. Therefore, it cannot be said that the seized vehicle in question was used in
violation of Section 5A (1) to (11) or any provisions of the Cow Slaughter Act, and
therefore, police has no power or jurisdiction to seize or confiscate the vehicle in
The District Magistrate, Varanasi has passed the impugned confiscation
question.
order dated 18.08.2021 in contravention of the law, as no permit is required to
transport cow and its progeny within the state of Uttar Pradesh. In above
circumstances, the impugned order dated 18.08.2021 passed by District Magistrate,
Varanasi is without jurisdiction and the same is liable to be set-aside. Likewise, the
revisional court has not considered the relevant provisions of Section 5A of Cow
Slaughter Act while dismissing the criminal revision of the applicant, therefore, the
impugned order dated 13.10.2021 passed by Special Judge (SC/ST Act), Chandauli is
also against the provisions of law and is liable to be set-aside."
(emphasis supplied)
28. Similarly, this Court again in the case of Munib vs. State of UP and 2
others 2024 SCC OnLine All 9631 held as under:-
"12. Thus transportation of cow etc. is regulated by Section 5A and Section 5A(7)
confers power upon the District Magistrate/Commissioner of Police to confiscate the
vehicle by which the beef or cow and its progeny is transported in violation of the
provisions of this Act and the relevant Rules. A perusal of the F.I.R. indicates that
none of the cow were maimed nor physically injured. Further, the allegation that they
were being transported to West Bengal from Prayagraj for slaughtering requires no
consideration as the condition precedent for the application of the section is that the
cattle described in the Act should have been transported from any place in the State
of U.P. to any place outside the State. Even if the story of seizure of cattle is believed
then also 06 cattle are said to have been seized within the jurisdiction of Police

CRLP No. 1902 of 2026
13
Station Lalganj District Mirzapur namely within the State of Uttar Pradesh and
admittedly, the border is far away. The fact remains that cattle were apprehended
from within the State of U.P. and, therefore, it cannot be said that they were
transported to a place outside the State of U.P.
13....Commission of offence is one of the requisite ingredients for passing an order of
confiscation and an order of confiscation should not be passed automatically. Thus,
there is no material, as exist on record, to justify the exercise of powers under Sub
Section 7 of Section 5A. The same is clearly contrary to the mandates and powers
conferred upon the District Magistrate.
14. The confiscation by its very connotation implies depriving a person of his property
to which he is entitled to retain. Article 300A of the Constitution of India provides that
no person shall be deprived of his property save by authority of law. Arbitrary
confiscation of the property which he might be using for his trade, profession or
occupation is a serious encroachment on the fundamental right of a citizen under
Article 19(1)(g) of the Constitution of India to carry on his trade, occupation or
business. The procedure prescribed by law for confiscating the property as contained
in Section 5A(7) of the Cow Slaughter Act, empowers the District
Magistrate/Commissioner of Police to confiscate/seize the vehicle only if the
conditions so prescribed under Sub Section 7 of Section 5A are fulfilled."
(emphasis supplied)
29. Upon a careful examination of the statutory provisions and the
material brought on record, this Court finds that the principal question
requiring determination is whether there existed any legal material before
the confiscating authority to conclude that the cow and its progeny were
being transported outside the State of Uttar Pradesh for the purpose of
slaughter.
30. This Court finds that the answer must necessarily be in the negative. It
is not in dispute that the petitioner's vehicle was intercepted within the
territorial limits of District Chandauli. The entire reasoning adopted by
the confiscating authority proceeds on the assumption that since
Chandauli shares its border with the neighbouring State of Bihar, the cow
and its progeny must necessarily have been intended to be transported
into the State of Bihar for slaughter. Such a conclusion is founded merely

CRLP No. 1902 of 2026
14
upon conjectures and surmises and is wholly unsupported by any
independent evidence. The existence of an international or inter-State
boundary by itself cannot constitute proof of illegal transportation. Unless
there exists positive and cogent evidence indicating that the destination of
the vehicle was outside the State of Uttar Pradesh or that the
transportation was intended for slaughter, no such presumption can
legally be drawn merely because the vehicle happened to be intercepted in
a border district.
31. The authorities have failed to produce any material whatsoever
indicating the intended destination of the vehicle. Neither any statement
of the driver nor any documentary evidence nor any independent witness
has been relied upon to establish that the animals were being transported
to the State of Bihar.
32. The findings recorded by both the authorities, therefore, are based
entirely upon assumptions rather than legally admissible evidence.
Equally significant is the fact that no beef, or remains of any slaughtered
cow and its progeny were recovered from the vehicle. The Veterinary
Officer conducted medical examination of the recovered animals on
19.09.2024. A perusal of the veterinary report, which has been placed on
record by the petitioner himself, clearly reveals that one cow and one calf
were medically examined and both were found to be healthy. The report
nowhere records that the animals had sustained any injury or were being
transported in such a condition so as to indicate cruelty within the
meaning of law.
33. Therefore, the submission advanced by the learned A.G.A. that the
Veterinary Officer found the animals in an unsafe, injured or mutilated
condition is factually incorrect and stands completely belied by the
medical report itself. The confiscating authority has further relied upon
Rule 16 of the Uttar Pradesh Prevention of Cow Slaughter Rules, 1964 to
hold that transportation without permit was impermissible. This finding
also cannot be sustained.
34. A plain reading of Rule 16 leaves no room for ambiguity that the
requirement of obtaining permit is attracted only where cow and its
progeny are proposed to be transported from any place within the State of

CRLP No. 1902 of 2026
15
Uttar Pradesh to any place situated outside the State. The Rule does not
require any permit for transportation of bovine animals from one place to
another within the territorial limits of Uttar Pradesh. This Court has
consistently interpreted the said Rule to hold that no permit or permission
is required for transportation of cow and its progeny within the State of
Uttar Pradesh, and the confiscating authority has completely overlooked
the settled legal position.
35. Consequently, the very foundation upon which the confiscation order
has been passed is contrary to the statutory scheme. The reliance placed
upon the presumption contained in Section 5-A(10) of the Act of 1955 is
equally misconceived. The statutory presumption contemplated therein is
not automatic. Such presumption arises only in circumstances specifically
provided under the statute, particularly where beef or cow remains are
recovered and laboratory examination confirms the prohibited substance.
36. Admittedly, in the present case, neither any beef nor any remains of
slaughtered cow and its progeny were recovered from the petitioner's
vehicle. The foundational facts necessary for drawing the statutory
presumption are, therefore, completely absent. In absence of those
foundational facts, the burden never shifted upon the petitioner.
Consequently, both the authorities have committed a manifest error of law
in invoking the statutory presumption against the petitioner.
37. Viewed from any angle, this Court finds that the confiscation
proceedings suffer from patent illegality, complete non-application of
mind and misinterpretation of the statutory provisions. The impugned
orders are based on assumptions unsupported by evidence and cannot
withstand judicial scrutiny.
38. Accordingly, the order dated 06.03.2025 passed by the District
Magistrate, Chandauli and the appellate order dated 27.11.2025 passed by
the Commissioner, Varanasi Division, Varanasi deserve to be quashed.
39. The matter, however, does not end with setting aside the confiscation
orders. The petitioner has specifically pleaded that the vehicle in question
constituted his sole source of livelihood. The said assertion has not been
specifically denied by the respondents. The materials placed on record

CRLP No. 1902 of 2026
16
further demonstrate that the vehicle had been purchased by availing
financial assistance from HDB Financial Services Limited and that the
petitioner was under a contractual obligation to repay monthly instalments
of Rs.12,599/-. The loan statement brought on record along with the
rejoinder affidavit clearly indicates that despite confiscation of the
vehicle, the petitioner somehow managed to continue repayment of the
loan till November, 2025.
40. Thereafter, owing to complete deprivation of income resulting from
the illegal confiscation, he became incapable of servicing the remaining
loan liability. The inevitable consequence of the illegal action of the State
has been that the petitioner remained deprived of his only source of
income for a substantial period without any legal justification. Article 21
of the Constitution protects not merely life but also the right to livelihood.
41. The Apex Court in the case of Nilabati Behera (Smt.) Alias Lalita
Behera(Through The Supreme Court Legal Aid Committee) vs. State of
Orissa and Others (1993) 2 SCC 746 , held as under:-
34. The public law proceedings serve a different purpose than the private law
“
proceedings. The relief of monetary compensation, as exemplary damages, in
proceedings under Article 32 by this Court or under Article 226 by the High Courts,
for established infringement of the indefeasible right guaranteed under Article 21 of
the Constitution is a remedy available in public law and is based on the strict liability
for contravention of the guaranteed basic and indefeasible rights of the citizen. The
purpose of public law is not only to civilize public power but also to assure the citizen
that they live under a legal system which aims to protect their interests and preserve
their rights. Therefore, when the court moulds the relief by granting “compensation”
in proceedings under Article 32 or 226 of the Constitution seeking enforcement or
protection of fundamental rights, it does so under the public law by way of penalising
the wrongdoer and fixing the liability for the public wrong on the State which has
failed in its public duty to protect the fundamental rights of the citizen. The payment of
compensation in such cases is not to be understood, as it is generally understood in a
civil action for damages under the private law but in the broader sense of providing
relief by an order of making ‘monetary amends’ under the public law for the wrong
done due to breach of public duty, of not protecting the fundamental rights of the
citizen. The compensation is in the nature of ‘exemplary damages’ awarded against
the wrongdoer for the breach of its public law duty and is independent of the rights

CRLP No. 1902 of 2026
17
available to the aggrieved party to claim compensation under the private law in an
action based on tort, through a suit instituted in a court of competent jurisdiction
or/and prosecute the offender under the penal law.
35. This Court and the High Courts, being the protectors of the civil liberties of the
citizen, have not only the power and jurisdiction but also an obligation to grant relief
in exercise of its jurisdiction under Articles 32 and 226 of the Constitution to the
victim or the heir of the victim whose fundamental rights under Article 21 of the
Constitution of India are established to have been flagrantly infringed by calling upon
the State to repair the damage done by its officers to the fundamental rights of the
citizen, notwithstanding the right of the citizen to the remedy by way of a civil suit or
criminal proceedings. The State, of course has the right to be indemnified by and take
such action as may be available to it against the wrongdoer in accordance with law —
through appropriate proceedings. Of course, relief in exercise of the power under
Article 32 or 226 would be granted only once it is established that there has been an
infringement of the fundamental rights of the citizen and no other form of appropriate
redressal by the court in the facts and circumstances of the case, is possible….”
42. The Apex Court again in the case of
Sube Singh vs. State of Haryana
and Others (2006) 3 SCC 178 (By three Judges) , held as under:-
"38. It is thus now well settled that the award of compensation against the State is an
appropriate and effective remedy for redress of an established infringement of a
fundamental right under Article 21, by a public servant. The quantum of compensation
will, however, depend upon the facts and circumstances of each case. Award of such
compensation (by way of public law remedy) will not come in the way of the aggrieved
person claiming additional compensation in a civil court, in the enforcement of the
private law remedy in tort, nor come in the way of the criminal court ordering
compensation under Section 357 of the Code of Criminal Procedure."
43. Similarly, the Apex Court again in the case of
Indibily Creative
Private Ltd. And Others vs. Government of West Bengal And Others
, has granted compensation for consequential financial
(2020) 12 SCC 436
losses caused by State authorities. In this case the petitioner has suffered
violation of fundamental rights under Articles 19(1)(a) & (g), 14 and 21.
The respondent State authorities were directed to pay compensation of Rs
20 lakhs, which was a huge amount. The relevant para is extracted
hereinbelow:-
“ 52. As a consequence of the pulling off of the film from the theatres where it was

CRLP No. 1902 of 2026
18
screened on 16-2-2019, the petitioners have suffered a violation of their fundamental
right to free speech and expression and of their right to pursue a lawful business. This
has been occasioned by the acts of commission and, in any event, of omission on the
part of the State in failing to affirm, fulfil and respect the fundamental freedoms of the
petitioners. We are clearly of the view that a remedy in public law for the grant of
remedial compensation is required in the present case. We order and direct the
respondents to pay to the petitioners compensation which we quantify at Rs 20 lakhs
within a period of one month from the date of the present judgment.”
44. It is apparent that whenever the instrumentalities of the State, by
arbitrary and illegal exercise of statutory powers, deprive a citizen of his
legitimate means of earning his livelihood, the constitutional courts are
fully empowered to award compensation in exercise of their public law
jurisdiction. Compensation in such cases is not merely restitutive but also
serves as a constitutional remedy against arbitrary exercise of State
power.
45. Having regard to the facts of the present case, the nature of the
vehicle, the admitted repayment of substantial monthly loan installments
and the ordinary earning capacity of a commercial transport vehicle, this
Court is of the considered opinion that the petitioner's monthly loss of
income can reasonably be assessed at Rs.20,000/- per month.
46. Accordingly, the petitioner shall be entitled to compensation at the
rate of Rs.20,000/- per month from 19.09.2024, i.e., the date of seizure of
the vehicle, till the actual date on which possession of the vehicle is
restored to him.
47. Apart from the financial loss, the petitioner has also suffered
avoidable litigation, mental harassment, financial distress and
unnecessary hardship solely because of the arbitrary and illegal action of
the authorities. This Court, therefore, considers it appropriate to award an
additional sum of Rs.25,000/- towards compensation for mental agony,
harassment and avoidable litigation suffered by the petitioner.
48. Accordingly, the writ petition succeeds and is allowed with the
following directions:

CRLP No. 1902 of 2026
19
(i) The order dated 06.03.2025 passed by the District Magistrate,
Chandauli confiscating the petitioner's vehicle and the appellate order
dated 27.11.2025 passed by the Commissioner, Varanasi Division,
Varanasi are hereby quashed.
(ii) The respondents are directed to release the petitioner's vehicle bearing
Registration No. UP-65-KT-4942 forthwith, if not required in connection
with any other case, preferably within one week from the date of
production of a certified copy of this judgment.
(iii) The respondents shall pay to the petitioner compensation calculated
at the rate of Rs.20,000/- per month from 19.09.2024 till the date of actual
release of the vehicle.
(iv) The respondents shall further pay a consolidated amount of
Rs.25,000/- to the petitioner towards compensation for the mental agony,
financial hardship and unnecessary harassment suffered by him on
account of the illegal confiscation.
(v) The aforesaid amount shall be paid within one month from the date a
certified copy of this judgment is produced before the competent
authority.
(vi) In the event of failure to comply with the aforesaid directions within
the stipulated period, it shall be open to the petitioner to seek appropriate
legal remedies available in law for enforcement of this order.
(vii) Since the confiscation has been found to be wholly illegal and
arbitrary, it shall be open to the State Government to hold an appropriate
departmental inquiry and, if responsibility is fixed upon any officer for
the illegal exercise of statutory power, to recover the amount of
compensation paid to the petitioner from the officer(s) found responsible,
strictly in accordance with law and after complying with the principles of
natural justice.
(Sandeep Jain,J.)
August 5, 2026
Himanshu
Digitally signed by :-
HIMANSHU YADAV
High Court of Judicature at Allahabad