The National Insurance Company Limited vs Smti Binita Bora And 3 Ors

Court
Gauhati High Court

Page 1 of 21

GAHC010203792017

2026:GAU-AS:16775

IN THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT

(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM & ARUNACHAL PRADESH)

MAC A PPEAL N O . 545 OF 2017

Smti Binita Bora
W/o-Late Raja Mohan Bora,
R/o-BeltolaTiniali, P.S. Basistha,
Guwahati-28, Dist. Kamrup(M), Assam.

…….. Appellant
- Versus -
1. National Insurance Company Ltd,
Tinsukia Branch,
Insurance Policy No. 200404/31/09/6300000279,
valid upto31.05.2010.

2. M/s S. N. Verma Enterprise,
S. R. Lohia Road, Tinsukia, Assam.
(Owner of the Vehicle Registration No. AS-23-C-9317 Truck)

3. United India Insurance Company Limited,
Jorhat Branch,
Insurance Policy No. 130400/31/08/01/00004685)
Valid Upto 31.12.2009

…….. Respondents

WITH

PPEAL O OF
MAC A N . 545 2017 Page 1
WITH
MAC A PPEAL N O . 177 OF 2015

Page 2 of 21

PPEAL O OF
MAC A N . 177 2015
The National Insurance Company Limited,
(Subsidiary of General Insurance Corporation of India)
Registered Head Office at 3 Middleton Street, Calcutta-700071
Represented by the Asstt. Manager,
Gauhati Regional Office,Bhangagarh,Guwahati-781005

- Versus -
1. Smti Binita Bora
W/o- Late Raja Mohan Bora,
R/o-BeltolaTiniali, P.S. Basistha,
Guwahati-781028, Dist. Kamrup(M), Assam.

2. M/s S. N. Verma Enterprise,
S. R. Lohia Road, Tinsukia, Assam.

3. United India Insurance Company Limited,
Jorhat Branch, Assam

…….. Respondents
::BEFORE ::
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE MRIDUL KUMAR KALITA
For the Appellants : Ms. R. D. Mazumdar, Advocate
(in MAC Appeal No. 177/2015)
: Mr. M. P. Sarma, Advocate
(in MAC Appeal No. 545/2017)
For the Respondents : Ms. R. D. Mazumdar, Advocate
(for the respondent No. 1 in MAC App. No. 177/2015)
: Mr. M. P. Sarma, Advocate
(for the respondent/claimant MAC App. No. 177/2015)
: Mr. K. K. Bhatta, Advocate

PPEAL O OF
MAC A N . 545 2017 Page 2
WITH
MAC A PPEAL N O . 177 OF 2015

Page 3 of 21

(for United India Ins. Com. Ltd., in both the appeals)




Date of Hearing : 27.08.2026
Date of Judgment : 13.11.2026

JUDGMENT & ORDER
1. Heard Ms. R. D. Mazumdar, the learned counsel for the appellant
in MAC Appeal No. 177/2015 as well as the counsel for the
respondent No. 1/Insurance Company in MAC Appeal No.
545/2017. Also heard Mr. M. P. Sarma, the learned counsel for
the appellant in MAC Appeal No. 545/2017 as well as counsel for
the respondent/claimant in MAC Appeal No. 177/2015 and Mr. K.
K. Bhatta, the learned counsel for the United India Insurance
Company Limited in both the appeals.
2. By this common judgment, this Court proposes to dispose ofthe
MAC Appeal No. 177/2015 as well as the MAC Appeal No.
545/2017 as both the appeals have arisen out of a common
judgment dated 16/6/2014passed in the MAC Case No. 531 of
2010 by the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal- cum- the Court of
the Additional District Judge No. 3, Kamrup(M).
3. One of the appeals, i.e.,MAC Appeal No. 177/2015 has been filed
by the National Insurance Company Limited, wherein the liability
to pay the entire compensation has been denied. The appellant in

PPEAL O OF
MAC A N . 545 2017 Page 3
WITH
MAC A PPEAL N O . 177 OF 2015

Page 4 of 21

the said appeal has also impugned the quantum of the
compensation awarded to the claimant. Whereas, in the second
appeal, i.e.,MAC Appeal No. 545/2017, the claimant has impugned
the quantum of compensation awarded in the Claims case on the
ground that the Tribunal did not take into consideration the
income certificate issued by the Circle Officer, which was
exhibited as Exhibit-6 while assessing the income of the deceased
for the purpose of computation of the compensation paid to the
claimant.
4. The facts relevant for consideration of both the aforementioned
appeals, in brief, are that on 28.12.2009 at about 12:30 AM, the
husband of the claimant, namely, late Raja Mohan Bora was
driving a truck bearing Registration No. AS-06-B-7052. When the
said truck reached Sukan Pukhuriat Sibsagar while going from
Dergaonto Moran, he parked the said vehicle on the side of the
road to ease himself. At that time, another truck bearing
Registration No.AS-23-C-9317, which was coming from Dergaon
side and was driven in a rash and negligent manner, rammed the
truck of the deceased from behind. As a result of which the said
truck fell on the deceased causing serious injuries on his person
and resulting in his death at the spot. After the accident, the
deceased was taken to Sibsagar Civil Hospital, where his
postmortem examination was conducted and FIR was also lodged

PPEAL O OF
MAC A N . 545 2017 Page 4
WITH
MAC A PPEAL N O . 177 OF 2015

Page 5 of 21

in connection with the aforesaid accident, on the basis of which
Sivasagar Police Station Case No. 662/2009under
Sections279/338/304A/427 of the Indian Penal Code was
registered.
5. Thereafter, the widow of the deceased, Smt. Binita Bora, who is
the appellant in MAC Appeal No. 545/2017 approached the Motor
Accident Claims Tribunal-cum-the Court of learned Additional
District Judge (FTC) No. 3, Kamrup(M) by filing an application
under Section 166 of the MV Act seeking compensation for death
of her husband in the aforesaid motor vehicular accident. The said
claim case was registered as MAC Case No. 531/2010. The notices
were issued to the opposite parties in the said claim case.
However, only the National Insurance Company Limited filed a
written statement in the said claims case denying its liability to
pay any compensation. The owner and driver of the offending
vehicle as well as the insurer of the vehicle bearing Registration
No. AS-23-C-9317, i.e., United India Insurance Company Limited
did not file any written statement in the said claims case.
6. On the basis of the pleadings of the parties, the Motor Accident
Claims Tribunal framed following issues: -
“a. Whether the deceased Raja Mohan Bora died as a
result of an accident arising out of the use of the motor
vehicles bearing Registration No. AS-23/C-9317 (Truck)

PPEAL O OF
MAC A N . 545 2017 Page 5
WITH
MAC A PPEAL N O . 177 OF 2015

Page 6 of 21

and bearing registration No. AS-06/B-7052 (709 truck)
that took place on 28.12.2009 at 12:30 a.m. and whether
the said accident was caused due to rash and negligent
driving by the driver of the truck bearing registration No.
AS-23/C-9317?

b. Whether the claimant is entitled to receive
compensation in respect of the aforesaid death and if yes,
what has to be the quantum of compensation and by
whom the same has to be paid?”
7. In support of her claim, the claimant adduced evidence of three
witnesses including herself and exhibited as many as five
documentary evidence. Though, the United India Insurance
Company did not file any written statement, however, it did cross-
examine the witnesses of the claimant. Ultimately, by the
judgment and award, which has been impugned in both these
appeals, the Claims Tribunal awarded an amount of
Rs.13,47,500/- with an interest at the rate of 6% per annum from
the date of filing of claim petition to the claimant.
8. Ms. R.D. Mazumdar, the learned counsel for the appellant,
namely, National Insurance Company Limited, has submitted that
the Claims Tribunal has erred in attributing the entire negligence
resulting in the accident on the driver of the vehicle bearing
Registration No. AS-23-C-9317 in as much as it did not consider

PPEAL O OF
MAC A N . 545 2017 Page 6
WITH
MAC A PPEAL N O . 177 OF 2015

Page 7 of 21

the admission by the sole eye-witness, i.e., the PW-3, who was
the handyman of the vehicle bearing Registration No. AS-06-B-
7052, wherein he has admitted during his cross-examination that
the parking lights of the vehicle bearing Registration No. AS-06-B-
7052 were not on when the said vehicle was parked on the road
when the accident occurred. She submits that as the accident
occurred in the month of December, past midnight and the truck
bearing Registration No. AS-06-B-7052 was parked in the middle
of the road with parking lights not on. Hence, mainly because of
the fact that the driver of the truck bearing Registration No. AS-
23-C-9317 hit the said truck bearing Registration No. AS-06-B-
7052 from behind in itself may not be sufficient to come to a
conclusion that the accident occurred entirely due to the
negligence of the driver of the truck, which was insured by the
appellant/Insurance Company. She submits that a stationary
vehicle occupying the road in the dead of night without any
warning indication poses an evident hazard to road users and this
aspect was not taken into consideration by the Tribunal. She
submits that under aforesaid facts and circumstances, it is evident
that the driver of the both trucks involved in the accident have
contributed to the accident and as such, she submits that the
appellant/Insurance Company, i.e., National Insurance Company
Limited may be liable to pay only 50% of the awarded amount as

PPEAL O OF
MAC A N . 545 2017 Page 7
WITH
MAC A PPEAL N O . 177 OF 2015

Page 8 of 21

there was apparently contributory negligence on the part of both
the drivers.
9. The learned counsel for the appellant, in MAC Appeal No.
177/2015,further submits that the Tribunal also erred in
computing the compensation payable to the claimant on a higher
side as it failed to take into consideration that even if the mother
and minor daughter of the deceased were taken to be his
dependent, there were only three dependents at the time of his
death as the father may not be regarded as a dependent in
absence of any evidence to the contrary. She, therefore, submits
that the deduction made by the Tribunal on account of living and
personal expenses of the deceased ought to have been to the
rd th
extent of 1/3 of the income of the deceased and not 1/4 as
done by the Tribunal.
10. She further submits that the Tribunal had also erred in adding
50% of the earnings of the deceased towards future prospect
inasmuch as, as per the judgment of the Apex Court in the case
of “ National Insurance Co. Ltd. Vs. Pranay Sethi” reported
“(2017) 16 SCC 680” ,
in if the deceased happens to be a self-
employed person or he used to get a fixed salary and if he
happens to be less than forty yearsin age, the addition towards
future prospect should be to the extent of 40% of his income and
not 50% as done by the Tribunal.

PPEAL O OF
MAC A N . 545 2017 Page 8
WITH
MAC A PPEAL N O . 177 OF 2015

Page 9 of 21

11. She further submits that the Tribunal also erred in awarding
Rs.25,000/- against funeral expenses, which is on a higher side
than that of what has been directed by the Apex Court in the case
of “ Pranay Sethi” ( supra). She submits that in the aforesaid case,
the Apex Court has standardized the compensation to be paid
against funeral expenses to the extent of Rs.15,000/- only.
Similarly, she submits that against the conventional head of loss
of estate, the compensation paid is on lower side by the Tribunal,
i.e.,Rs.10,000/- only. She fairly submits that this compensation
may be increased to Rs.15,000/- as per the guideline of the Apex
Court in the case of “ Pranay Sethi” ( supra).
12. She further submits that the Tribunal has also erred in awarding a
compensation amount of Rs.1,00,000/- to the claimant against
loss of consortium as well as Rs.1,00,000/-to the minor child of
the claimant against loss of affection and guidance as well as
awarding Rs.1,00,000/-against loss of care and affection to both
parents. She fairly submits that the wife as well as the minor child
and parents may be entitled to loss of consortium at the rate of
Rs.40,000/- each as was directed by the Apex Court in the case of
“ Pranay Sethi” ( supra) as well as “Magma General Insurance Co.
Ltd. Vs. Nanu Ram@ Chuhru Ram and Ors.” reported in “(2018) 18
SCC 130”
.

PPEAL O OF
MAC A N . 545 2017 Page 9
WITH
MAC A PPEAL N O . 177 OF 2015

Page 10 of 21

13. The learned counsel for the appellant, namely, National Insurance
Company Limited, further submits that the Tribunal has correctly
discarded Exhibit-6, which is the income certificate issued by the
Circle Officer as the author of the said certificate was not
examined by the claimant side. She further submits that the said
certificate was also issued only after death of the husband of the
claimant No. 1. As such, the Tribunal has correctly discarded the
said certificate. She, however, submits that while assessing the
income of the deceased, the Tribunal erred by assessing the same
at Rs.5,000/- without there being any basis for the same.
14. She further submits that the accident had occurred in the year
2009 and the Tribunal ought to have taken into consideration of
the minimum wages payable to an unskilled worker at that time
while assessing the income of the deceased in absence of any
credible documentary evidence.
15. She further submits that in view of the submissions made by her
and grounds taken by the appellant in the memo of appeal, the
quantum of compensation payable to the claimant may be
reassessed and liability of the appellant, namely, National
Insurance Company Limited may be restricted to 50% of the
awarded amount. She further submits that the National Insurance
Company Limited has already deposited Rs.7,00,000/- out of the
awarded amount.She submits that no further liability should be

PPEAL O OF
MAC A N . 545 2017 Page 10
WITH
MAC A PPEAL N O . 177 OF 2015

Page 11 of 21

attributed to the present appellant. In support of her submission,
the learned counsel for the appellant has cited a ruling of the
Apex Court in the case of “ Oriental Insurance Company Limited Vs.
Kalu Ram and Others ”, reported in “ 2026 INSC 653 ”.
16. On the other hand, Mr. M. P. Sarma submits that the Tribunal has
correctly ascertained that it was the driver of the offending truck
bearing Registration No. AS-23-C-9317, which was at fault, which
caused the accident as the said truck hit the truck which was
parked on the road by the deceased. He submits that the criminal
case which was registered in connection with the accident was
against the driver of the truck bearing Registration No. AS-23-C-
9317. He further submits that during his cross-examination, the
PW-3 has only denied the suggestion given to him regarding using
of the parking light by truck bearing Registration No. AS-06-B-
7052 and the National Insurance Company did not adduce any
evidence to counter the evidence led by the claimant. As such, he
submits that there is no infirmity in the Tribunal reaching a
conclusion regarding negligence of the driver of the offending
truck bearing Registration No. AS-23-C-9317 which caused the
accident. He further submits that the Tribunal though correctly
assessed the liability to pay compensation on the part of the
owner and insurer of the offending truck bearing Registration No.
AS-23-C-9317,however, it erred in assessing the income of the

PPEAL O OF
MAC A N . 545 2017 Page 11
WITH
MAC A PPEAL N O . 177 OF 2015

Page 12 of 21

deceased and consequently computing the compensation payable
to the claimant on a lower side.
17. He further submits that though the claimant has adduced the
documentary evidence, i.e., Exhibit-6, which is a certificate of
income issued by the Circle Officer wherein it was reflected that
the deceased was earning an amount of Rs.15,000/- at the time
of his death. However, said certificate was discarded by the
Tribunal without showing any reasons for the same in the
impugned judgment. He submits that the said certificate being
issued by a public authority is a public document within the
meaning of Section 74 of the Evidence Act and as such same
ought to have been relied upon by the Tribunal while assessing
the income of the deceased. In support of his submission, he has
cited a ruling in the case of “ Prithi Singh Vs. Union of India”
reported in “ 1959 AIR (Manipur) 43 ”.
18. On the other hand, Mr. K. K.Bhatta, the learned counsel for the
United India Insurance Company Limited has submitted that the
Tribunal has correctly assessed the compensation to be payable
to the claimant on the basis of evidence on record and the same
needs no interference. He submits that the negligence on the part
of the driver of truck bearing Registration No. AS-23-C-9317 is
apparent from the evidence of the eyewitness as well as other
documentary evidence including the FIR and Accident Information

PPEAL O OF
MAC A N . 545 2017 Page 12
WITH
MAC A PPEAL N O . 177 OF 2015

Page 13 of 21

Report and as such, the impugned judgment and award needs no
interference of this Court in this appeal.
19. I have considered the submissions made by learned counsel for
both sides and I have gone through the materials available on
record. I have also gone through the rulings cited by learned
counsel for both sides in support of their respective submissions.
20. Let us first discuss the grounds taken by the appellant/claimant in
MAC Appeal No. 545/2017 in assailing the impugned
judgment.The main ground taken by the claimant is that the
Motor Accident Claims Tribunal erred in discarding Exhibit-6,
which is the income certificate of the deceased, suggesting that
he was earning Rs. 15,000/- per month at the time of his death.
21. On perusal of the records, it appears that Exhibit-6, which is a
certificate purported to be issued by the Circle Officer of Dergaon
Revenue Circle, was exhibited by PW-3, who was the handyman
of the truck which was parked by the deceased on the side of the
road on the date of the fateful accident.Though it appears that
the Tribunal ought to have explained in the impugned judgment
as to why it did not rely upon Exhibit-6, however, it appears that
the author of Exhibit-6, or anyone from the office of the Circle
Officer, Dergaon, was not examined by the claimant's side to
prove the veracity of the said document.The settled mode to

PPEAL O OF
MAC A N . 545 2017 Page 13
WITH
MAC A PPEAL N O . 177 OF 2015

Page 14 of 21

prove the veracity or genuineness of a document is to examine
the author of the said document, and if there is any difficulty in
procuring the attendance of the author, the same has to be
explained.The claimant could have summoned anyone from the
office of the Circle Officer, Dergaon, who could have proved the
veracity of the said document. However, the same was not done.
As such, this Court does not find any defect or error in the Motor
Accident Claims Tribunal discarding the said document and
declining to rely on the same.
22. The Motor Accident Claims Tribunal also does not appear to be at
fault in taking the net income of the deceased at Rs. 5,000/- per
month, taking into account the fact that he was maintaining a
truck which was in the name of his wife at the time of his
death.In the absence of any evidence by the insurance company
to counter the evidence regarding the earning of the deceased,
the Tribunal cannot be faulted with in not assessing the income of
the deceased on the basis of minimum wages payable to an
unskilled worker in the year 2009, as no such plea appears to
have been taken by the insurance company during the course of
the inquiry before the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal.
23. As regards the contention of the insurance company taken in MAC
Appeal No. 177/2015, wherein it has questioned the Claims
Tribunal in attributing negligence on the part of the driver of the

PPEAL O OF
MAC A N . 545 2017 Page 14
WITH
MAC A PPEAL N O . 177 OF 2015

Page 15 of 21

offending vehicle, in view of the fact that the PW-3, who was the
handyman of the truck which was parked on the road by the
deceased, has deposedduring cross-examination that it is not a
fact that he saw the parking light of the truck parked on the road
on. It appears that during his examination-in-chief, he has
deposed that the parking lights of the truck parked on the road by
the deceased were on; however, during cross-examination, he
admitted the suggestion that the said fact is not true.
24. In view of the fact that PW-3 has taken a contrary stand as
regards the use of parking lights by the truck bearing Registration
No. AS-06-B-7052 in his examination-in-chief as well as in his
cross-examination, his testimony becomes unreliable. As such, on
the basis of his testimony, it may not be safe to either infer and
attribute negligence on the part of the deceased or come to a
contrary finding.
25. Even if we discard the testimony of PW-3, it appears that PW-2,
who is the Officer-in-Charge of Sivasagar Police Station, has
exhibited the charge-sheet which was laid against the driver of
the offending truck bearing Registration No. AS-23-C-9317. The
insurance company could not controvert the said charge-sheet
against the driver of the offending truck, and the same, in the
considered opinion of this Court, is sufficient, on the basis of the
principles of preponderance of probabilities, to attribute

PPEAL O OF
MAC A N . 545 2017 Page 15
WITH
MAC A PPEAL N O . 177 OF 2015

Page 16 of 21

negligence on the part of the driver of the offending truck bearing
Registration No. AS-23-C-9317.As such, the contention of the
learned counsel for the insurance company that there was
contributory negligence on the part of the deceased in resulting in
the accident involved in this case cannot be accepted.
26. As regards the computation of the compensation to be awarded
to the claimants, it appears that the Tribunal has erred in
computing the same in view of the guidelines laid down by the
Apex Court.
27. The Apex Court, in the case of National Insurance Company
Limited Vs. Pranay Sethi (Supra), has observed regarding addition
of future prospects as follows:
“59.4. In case the deceased was self-employed or on
a fixed salary, an addition of 40% of the established
income should be the warrant where the deceased
was below the age of 40 years. An addition of 25%
where the deceased was between the age of 40 to
50 years and 10% where the deceased was between
the age of 50 to 60 years should be regarded as the
necessary method of computation. The established
income means the income minus the tax
component.”

28. In the instant case, the deceased was a self-employed person and
was below the age of 40 years. As such, an addition of 40% of
the established income ought to have been made towards future

PPEAL O OF
MAC A N . 545 2017 Page 16
WITH
MAC A PPEAL N O . 177 OF 2015

Page 17 of 21

prospect. However, the Tribunal has erred in adding 50% of his
established income towards future prospect.
29. Similarly, the father of the deceased, in the absence of proof to
the contrary, may not be regarded as a dependent of the
deceased. However, though the claimant has not adduced any
evidence to show that the father of the deceased was also
dependent on the deceased, he was regarded as a dependent and
one-fourth (1/4th) of the income was deducted from the monthly
income towards personal expenses of the deceased, instead of
one-third (1/3rd) of his income, which ought to have been done
taking the wife, mother, and minor daughter of the deceased as
his dependents.
30. Further, the Tribunal also seems to have erred in awarding Rs.
1,00,000/- each to the wife, minor children, and parents towards
loss of consortium, loss of affection and guidance, and loss of
care and affection, which is contrary to the guidelines laid down
by the Apex Court in the case of Pranay Sethi (supra). For the sake
of convenience, the observations made by the Apex Court in the
National Insurance Company Limited Vs. Pranay Sethi
case of
(supra) , are reproduced hereinbelow:
“52. As far as the conventional heads are
concerned, we find it difficult to agree with the
view expressed in Rajesh [Rajesh v. Rajbir Singh,
(2013) 9 SCC 54 : (2013) 4 SCC (Civ) 179 : (2013)

PPEAL O OF
MAC A N . 545 2017 Page 17
WITH
MAC A PPEAL N O . 177 OF 2015

Page 18 of 21

3 SCC (Cri) 817 : (2014) 1 SCC (L&S) 149] . It has
granted Rs 25,000 towards funeral expenses, Rs
1,00,000 towards loss of consortium and Rs
1,00,000 towards loss of care and guidance for
minor children. The head relating to loss of care
and minor children does not exist.
Though Rajesh [Rajesh v. Rajbir Singh, (2013) 9
SCC 54 : (2013) 4 SCC (Civ) 179 : (2013) 3 SCC
(Cri) 817 : (2014) 1 SCC (L&S) 149] refers
to Santosh Devi [Santosh Devi v. National
Insurance Co. Ltd., (2012) 6 SCC 421 : (2012) 3
SCC (Civ) 726 : (2012) 3 SCC (Cri) 160 : (2012) 2
SCC (L&S) 167] , it does not seem to follow the
same. The conventional and traditional heads,
needless to say, cannot be determined on
percentage basis because that would not be an
acceptable criterion. Unlike determination of
income, the said heads have to be quantified. Any
quantification must have a reasonable foundation.
There can be no dispute over the fact that price
index, fall in bank interest, escalation of rates in
many a field have to be noticed. The court cannot
remain oblivious to the same. There has been a
thumb rule in this aspect. Otherwise, there will be
extreme difficulty in determination of the same and
unless the thumb rule is applied, there will be
immense variation lacking any kind of consistency
as a consequence of which, the orders passed by
the tribunals and courts are likely to be unguided.
Therefore, we think it seemly to fix reasonable
sums. It seems to us that reasonable figures on
conventional heads, namely, loss of estate, loss of
consortium and funeral expenses should be Rs

PPEAL O OF
MAC A N . 545 2017 Page 18
WITH
MAC A PPEAL N O . 177 OF 2015

Page 19 of 21

15,000, Rs 40,000 and Rs 15,000 respectively. The
principle of revisiting the said heads is an
acceptable principle. But the revisit should not be
fact-centric or quantum-centric. We think that it
would be condign that the amount that we have
quantified should be enhanced on percentage basis
in every three years and the enhancement should
be at the rate of 10% in a span of three years. We
are disposed to hold so because that will bring in
consistency in respect of those heads.”
31. In view of the aforesaid guidelines issued by the Apex Court, the
compensation to which the claimants (the present claimant, her
mother-in-law, and her minor daughter) are entitled to is
computed as follows:

Sl. No. Head of Compensation Amount (in Rs.)
1. Annual Income of the deceased (Rs. 5,000 × 12) 60,000/-
2. Less: 1/3rd deduction towards personal expenses (Rs.
40,000/-
60,000 - Rs. 20,000)
3. Add: 40% towards future prospects (Rs. 40,000 + Rs.
56,000/-
16,000 [40% of Rs. 40,000])
4. Loss of Dependency (Rs. 56,000 × 15) 8,40,000/-
4. Funeral Expenses 19,500/-
5. Loss of Estate 19,500/-
6. Loss of Spousal Consortium (to the claimant/wife) 52,000/-
7. Loss of Parental Consortium (to the minor daughter) 52,000/-
8. Loss of Filial Consortium (to the parents of the 52,000/-

PPEAL O OF
MAC A N . 545 2017 Page 19
WITH
MAC A PPEAL N O . 177 OF 2015

Page 20 of 21

deceased)
Total Awarded Compensation Rs. 10,35,000/-

32. The National Insurance Company Limited is liable to pay the
aforesaid amount along with interest at the rate of 9% per annum
from the date of filing of the claim petition till payment to the
claimant. The amount which has already been paid by the
insurance company has to be deducted therefrom. The mother of
the deceased is entitled to get an amount of Rs. 3,32,000/- from
the awarded compensation along with interest accrued thereon.
The remaining amount may be disbursed to the claimant and her
daughter, out of which the daughter is entitled to get Rs.
3,32,000/- along with interest.
33. In view of the discussions made and reasons stated in the
foregoing paragraphs, MAC Appeal No. 545/2017 is hereby
dismissed, whereas MAC Appeal No. 177/2015 is partly allowed as
indicated hereinbefore.
34. The Insurance Company is directed to deposit the remaining
outstanding dues against the awarded compensation within a
period of 4 (four) weeks from the date of this judgment.
35. Let the records of MAC Case No. 531/2010 be sent back to the
concerned Tribunal along with a copy of this judgment.

PPEAL O OF
MAC A N . 545 2017 Page 20
WITH
MAC A PPEAL N O . 177 OF 2015

Page 21 of 21



JUDGE
Comparing Assistant

Munmun
Boruah
Digitally signed by
Munmun Boruah
Date: 2026.11.17
11:38:15 +05'30'

PPEAL O OF
MAC A N . 545 2017 Page 21
WITH
MAC A PPEAL N O . 177 OF 2015