SMT. REKHA vs VIJAYA D SOUZA

Court
Karnataka High Court

- 1 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63562
MFA No. 5424 of 2025
C/W MFA No. 9744 of 2025


CNR: KAHC010478232025







IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU

TH
DATED THIS THE 17 DAY OF NOVEMBER, 2026

BEFORE

THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SHIVASHANKAR AMARANNAVAR

MISCELLANEOUS FIRST APPEAL No. 5424 OF 2025

(MV-D)

C/W

MISCELLANEOUS FIRST APPEAL No. 9744 OF 2025

(MV-D)



IN MFA No. 5424/2025

BETWEEN:

THE DIVISIONAL MANAGER
UNTIED INDIA INSURANCE CO. LTD.,
RAMBHA VAN COMPLEX
KODIALBAIL MANGALURU 03
REPRESENTED BY
THE REGIONAL MANAGER
UNITED INDIA INSURANCE CO LTD.,
6th FLOOR, KRISHI BHAVAN
HUDSON CIRCLE, NRUPATUNGA ROAD,
BENGLAURU – 560 027.

…APPELLANT
(BY SMT. MANJULA N TEJASWI, ADVOCATE)

AND:

1. SMT. REKHA
W/O LATE MANOJ KUMAR
AGED ABOUT 41 YEARS





Digitally Signed By:
SHIVASHANKAR BASAPPA
AMARANNAVAR
JUDGE, HIGH COURT OF KARNATKA

- 2 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63562
MFA No. 5424 of 2025
C/W MFA No. 9744 of 2025


CNR: KAHC010478232025


2. SMT. RAMANI (SINCE DEAD)
W/O LATE VISHWANATH DEVACADIGA
AGED ABOUT 69 YEARS.

RESPONDENTS No.1
RESIDENTS OF DOOR No.1-104(2)
MORALI THATHV, KULSHEKAR
MANGALORE – 05.

3. MR. VIJAYA D’SOUZA
S/O MOURICE D’SOUZA
AGED ABOUT 46 YEARS
R/AT ULLAL HOIGE HOUSE
NEAR NETHRAVATHI BRIDGE
PERMANNURU POST
MANGALURU - 575 017.

…RESPONDENTS

(BY SRI. G. RAVISHANKAR SHASTRY, ADVOCATE FOR R1
R2- SERVED)

THIS MFA IS FILED UNDER SECTION 173(1) OF MV ACT,
AGAINST THE JUDGMENT AND AWARD DATED:07.03.2025
PASSED IN MVC No.1744/2019 ON THE FILE OF THE I
ADDITIONAL SENIOR CIVIL JUDGE AND CJM, MANGALURU,
DAKSHINA KANNADA, AWARDING COMPENSATION OF
Rs.14,78,930/- WITH INTEREST AT 6 PERCENT P.A. FROM THE
DATE OF PETITION TILL REALIZATION.


IN MFA No. 9744/2025

BETWEEN:


1. SMT. REKHA
AGED ABOUT 41 YEARS
W/O LATE MANOJ KUMAR
R/AT D. No. 1-104(1), MAROLI
Digitally Signed By:
SHIVASHANKAR BASAPPA
AMARANNAVAR
JUDGE, HIGH COURT OF KARNATKA

- 3 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63562
MFA No. 5424 of 2025
C/W MFA No. 9744 of 2025


CNR: KAHC010478232025


THATHAV, KULSHEKAR, MANGALURU
PIN-575 005.
...APPELLANT

(BY SRI G. RAVISHANKAR SHASTRY, ADVOCATE)

AND:

1. VIJAYA D’SOUZA
AGED ABOUT 46 YEARS
S/O MOURICE D'SOUZA
R/AT ULLAL HOIGE HOUSE
NEAR NETHRAVATHI BRIDGE
PERMANNURU POST
MANGALURU- PIN-575 017.

2. THE DIVISIONAL MANAGER
UNITED INDIA INSURANCE CO. LTD.,
RAMBHAVAN COMPLEX, KODIALBAIL
MANGALURU PIN-575 003.
...RESPONDENTS

(BY SMT. MANJULA N TEJASWI, ADVOCATE FOR R2
R1- SERVED)

THIS MFA IS FILED UNDER SECTION 173(1) OF MV ACT,
AGAINST THE JUDGMENT AND AWARD DATED: 07.03.2025
PASSED IN MVC No.1744/2019 ON THE FILE OF THE I
ADDITIONAL SENIOR CIVIL JUDGE AND CJM, MANGALURU,
DAKSHINA KANNADA, PARTLY ALLOWING THE CLAIM
PETITION FOR COMPENSATION AND SEEKING ENHANCEMENT
OF COMPENSATION.


THESE APPEALS COMING ON FOR ORDERS THIS DAY,
JUDGMENT WAS DELIVERED THEREIN AS UNDER:


CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SHIVASHANKAR AMARANNAVAR

Digitally Signed By:
SHIVASHANKAR BASAPPA
AMARANNAVAR
JUDGE, HIGH COURT OF KARNATKA

- 4 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63562
MFA No. 5424 of 2025
C/W MFA No. 9744 of 2025


CNR: KAHC010478232025


ORAL JUDGMENT

1. MFA No. 5424/2025 is filed by the Insurer
challenging the accident and liability and MFA No.
9744/2025 is filed by the claimant seeking enhancement
of compensation awarded in the judgment and award
dated 07.03.2025 passed in MVC 1744/2019 by I
Additional Senior Civil Judge and Member MACT,
Mangaluru.

2. Even though the appeals are listed today for
`Admission’ they are taken up for disposal with the
consent of the learned counsel appearing for parties.

3. Claimants made a claim petition praying to
award compensation for the death of Manoj Kumar in a
road traffic accident occurred on 05.02.2019 contending
that the accident occurred due to the rash and negligent
driving by the rider of the motorcycle bearing registration
No. KA-19-Q-6253. The Tribunal after recording evidence,
appreciating the evidence on record, assessed the
Digitally Signed By:
SHIVASHANKAR BASAPPA
AMARANNAVAR
JUDGE, HIGH COURT OF KARNATKA

- 5 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63562
MFA No. 5424 of 2025
C/W MFA No. 9744 of 2025


CNR: KAHC010478232025


compensation and awarded compensation under different
heads as under:

1 Loss of dependency Rs.12,65,964/-
2 Spousal consortium Rs.48,400/-
3 Funeral expenses Rs.18,150/-
4 Medical expenses Rs.1,17,726/-
5 Conveyance/Traveling Rs.10,000/-
expenses
6 Loss of Estate Rs.18,500/-
Total Rs.14,78,390/-


4. The Tribunal has also awarded interest at the
rate of 6% p.a. from date of petition till the date of
realization and directed the Insurer to deposit the said
award amount with interest. Insurer has filed the appeal
challenging the accident and liability and claimant has filed
the appeal seeking enhancement of the compensation
awarded by the Tribunal.

5. Heard learned counsel for Insurer and learned
counsel for claimant.
Digitally Signed By:
SHIVASHANKAR BASAPPA
AMARANNAVAR
JUDGE, HIGH COURT OF KARNATKA

- 6 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63562
MFA No. 5424 of 2025
C/W MFA No. 9744 of 2025


CNR: KAHC010478232025



6. Learned counsel for Insurer contended that wife
of the deceased had filed a complaint as per Ex.P.2,
wherein time of accident was mentioned as 03.00 p.m.
She was not knowing who was the rider of the vehicle
which dashed to her husband. In Ex.P.6 - charge sheet
also, place of accident is mentioned as Kudupu, so also in
Ex.P.2 – complaint. In Accident Information Report, Ex.P.4
time of accident is mentioned as 03.00 p.m. on
05.02.2019. In MLC intimation – Ex.P.13 time of accident
is mentioned as 10.15 a.m. and history is mentioned as
fall from moving bike and place of accident is mentioned
as Vamanjoor. In wound certificate – Ex.P.14 and
discharge summary – Ex.P.15, in the history it is
mentioned as fall from bike on 05.02.2019 around 03.00
p.m. near Kudupu. She further submits that in Ex.P.16 -
death summary, place of accident is mentioned as Mudipu,
which is contrary to the place of accident mentioned in the
other documents. P.W.1 - wife of the deceased, in her
evidence has stated that the accident has occurred at
Digitally Signed By:
SHIVASHANKAR BASAPPA
AMARANNAVAR
JUDGE, HIGH COURT OF KARNATKA

- 7 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63562
MFA No. 5424 of 2025
C/W MFA No. 9744 of 2025


CNR: KAHC010478232025


11.30 a.m. in Kudupu, which is contrary to her complaint
– Ex.P.2. P.W.2 - Dinesh Devadiga, has stated that the
accident has taken place at 11:30 a.m. and his statement
has been recorded by the Police which is at Ex.P.26.
Considering these documents, there is contradictory
statements regarding place and time of the accident and
the claimant failed to establish that the deceased
sustained injury and succumbed to the injuries as a result
of the accident caused by the driver of the insured
motorcycle. She further submits that she has not
challenged the quantum of compensation awarded by the
Tribunal. She placed reliance on the judgment of the
Hon’ble Apex Court in the case of Vanita and others Vs.
Shriram Insurance Company Ltd., and another,
reported in 2025 SCC OnLine SC 1980.

7. Learned counsel for claimant would contend
that the owner of the motorcycle, i.e., respondent No. 1 in
his written statement has not disputed the accident, but
he has contended that there is contributory negligence on
Digitally Signed By:
SHIVASHANKAR BASAPPA
AMARANNAVAR
JUDGE, HIGH COURT OF KARNATKA

- 8 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63562
MFA No. 5424 of 2025
C/W MFA No. 9744 of 2025


CNR: KAHC010478232025


the part of the deceased. The Insurer in the statement has
not taken defence of non-involvement of the insured
vehicle and therefore there is no pleading with regard to
the contention taken by the learned counsel for the
Insurer. Complainant who is the wife of the deceased in
her further statement Ex.P.7 has stated the correct timing
as 11.30 a.m. and the same is recorded on 06.02.2019 -
the very date of complaint. In the charge sheet Ex.P.6
filed against rider of offending motorcycle it is stated that
accident occurred at 11.30 a.m. in Kudupu and that has
not been challenged by the rider of the offending
motorcycle. Ex.P.13 and Ex.P.14 on which the learned
counsel for Insurer has placed reliance are not pertaining
to the deceased but they pertain to the rider of offending
motorcycle. The very fact that rider of the offending
motorcycle sustaining injury on 05.02.2019 and taking
treatment for the said injuries itself clearly indicate that
accident has occurred and rider of offending motorcycle
has also sustained injuries. Evidence of P.W.2 - eyewitness
Digitally Signed By:
SHIVASHANKAR BASAPPA
AMARANNAVAR
JUDGE, HIGH COURT OF KARNATKA

- 9 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63562
MFA No. 5424 of 2025
C/W MFA No. 9744 of 2025


CNR: KAHC010478232025


clearly establish the date, time and place of accident.
Considering the said evidence on record, the Tribunal has
rightly held that the claimants have proved the accident.
He further submits that the claim petition was filed by wife
and mother of the deceased. Mother of the deceased died
during pendency of the claim petition. Even though wife is
the only claimant after death of the mother of the
rd
deceased, deductions are to be taken at 1/3 and not 1/2
as held by the Hon'ble Apex Court in the case of Ved
Kanwar and others Vs. Babulal and others reported in
2026 ACJ 872 .

8. Ex.P.17 is the salary certificate and its author
has been examined as P.W.3 and he has given evidence
Rs.
regarding the deceased getting salary of 17,292/- per
month and the Tribunal has erred in taking lesser income
than the income mentioned in Ex.P.17. With this he
prayed to allow the appeal filed by the claimant.
Digitally Signed By:
SHIVASHANKAR BASAPPA
AMARANNAVAR
JUDGE, HIGH COURT OF KARNATKA

- 10 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63562
MFA No. 5424 of 2025
C/W MFA No. 9744 of 2025


CNR: KAHC010478232025



9. In reply learned counsel for Insurer would
contend that evidence of P.W.3 cannot be believed since
there is no corroboration regarding credit of the said
salary amount to the account of the deceased and the said
certificate has been issued in the year 2022. After death of
mother the deceased, only claimant is the wife of the
deceased and therefore considering the same the Tribunal
has rightly deducted 50% towards personal expenses of
the deceased.

10. Having heard learned counsel for the parties the
Court has perused the judgment, award and trial Court
records.

11. The following points arises for consideration.

I. Whether the Tribunal is justified in holding that
Manoj Kumar died in a road traffic accident that
occurred on 05.02.2019 at 11.30 a.m. near
Kudupu Temple, Kudupu, Mangaluru due to the
rash and negligent riding of the motorcycle
Digitally Signed By:
SHIVASHANKAR BASAPPA
AMARANNAVAR
JUDGE, HIGH COURT OF KARNATKA

- 11 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63562
MFA No. 5424 of 2025
C/W MFA No. 9744 of 2025


CNR: KAHC010478232025


bearing registration No. KA-19-Q-6253 by its
rider?

II. Whether there are any grounds for enhancement
of compensation awarded by the Tribunal?

12. Reasons on Point No. I . It is the case of the
claimant that the accident occurred on 05.02.2019 at
11.30 a.m. near Kudupu temple, Kudupu and rider of
motorcycle KA-19-Q-6253 has caused the accident. Due to
the accident, Manoj Kumar sustained injuries and he
succumbed to the injuries. Ex.P.1 is the FIR and it is
registered based on the first information filed by the wife
of the deceased as per Ex.P.2. Wife of the deceased was
not an eyewitness to the incident and based on
somebody's statement she has given first information as
per Ex.P.2 wherein time of accident is stated as 03.00
p.m. Wife of the deceased has given her further statement
to the Police on the very same day of filing of complaint,
i.e., 06.02.2019 as per Ex.P.7 wherein she has stated that
in grief she has mentioned time of accident wrongly and
Digitally Signed By:
SHIVASHANKAR BASAPPA
AMARANNAVAR
JUDGE, HIGH COURT OF KARNATKA

- 12 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63562
MFA No. 5424 of 2025
C/W MFA No. 9744 of 2025


CNR: KAHC010478232025


the correct time of accident is 11.30 a.m. and in the said
statement she has mentioned the name of rider of the
offending motorcycle. Based on the said complaint and
further statement of the complainant the Police conducted
investigation and filed charge sheet as per Ex.P.6. In the
charge sheet time of accident is mentioned as 11.30 a.m.
on 05.02.2019 at Kudupu.

13. P.W.2 is eyewitness to the incident. P.W.2 has
stated in his evidence that accident has taken place near
his tailoring shop and he has witnessed the accident and
accident occurred at 11.30 a.m. on 05.02.2019 due to the
rash and negligent driving by the rider of motorcycle KA-
19-Q-6253. Even owner of the offending motorcycle, in his
pleading, has not disputed involvement of his vehicle in
the accident. Merely because there is discrepancy in the
Police documents, namely Ex.P.4, discharge summary –
Ex.P.15 and death summary – Ex.P.16 will not create
doubt in the case of the claimant since those documents
are issued based on the earlier statement of the
Digitally Signed By:
SHIVASHANKAR BASAPPA
AMARANNAVAR
JUDGE, HIGH COURT OF KARNATKA

- 13 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63562
MFA No. 5424 of 2025
C/W MFA No. 9744 of 2025


CNR: KAHC010478232025


complainant filed as per Ex.P.1. Considering these aspects,
the Tribunal has rightly held that the accident occurred
due to the rash and negligent riding by the rider of the
motorcycle KA- 19-Q-6253 on 05.02.2019 at 11.30 a.m. in
Kudupu and the deceased Manoj Kumar sustained injuries
and succumbed to the injuries. Accordingly, point No. I is
answered.

14. Reasons on point No. II . Deceased was
working in the Canara Workshop Ltd. Ex.P.17 is the salary
certificate of the deceased. P.W.3 is the author of the said
salary certificate. P.W.3 has stated that the deceased was
Rs.
getting salary of 17,292/- at the time of his death.
Bank passbook produced by the claimant does not pertain
to the year of accident and they pertain to the years 2011-
12. Nothing material has been elicited in the cross-
examination of P.W.3 to disbelieve his evidence. The said
evidence of P.W.3 and documents produced by him clearly
establish that deceased Manoj Kumar was employed with
Rs.
Canara Workshops Ltd., and getting salary of 17,292/-
Digitally Signed By:
SHIVASHANKAR BASAPPA
AMARANNAVAR
JUDGE, HIGH COURT OF KARNATKA

- 14 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63562
MFA No. 5424 of 2025
C/W MFA No. 9744 of 2025


CNR: KAHC010478232025


Rs.
per month. In the said salary, 200/- is to be deducted
towards professional tax and therefore net salary of the
Rs.
deceased is 17,092/- (Rs.17,292 - 200 - professional
tax).

15. Claim petition was filed by the wife and mother
of the deceased. Mother of the deceased died during
pendency of the claim petition before the Tribunal. The
claim petition has been continued by the wife of the
deceased.

16. In cases of bachelors deduction towards
personal expenses is to be taken at 50% and not in cases
of married person having wife. In the case Ved Kanwar
(supra) the Hon'ble Apex Court has held that if wife is the
rd
only claimant then also deduction is to be taken at 1/3 .

17. Since the deceased was aged 45 years and was
employed with Canara Workshop Ltd., future prospects are
to be added at 25%. The Tribunal has rightly applied
Digitally Signed By:
SHIVASHANKAR BASAPPA
AMARANNAVAR
JUDGE, HIGH COURT OF KARNATKA

- 15 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63562
MFA No. 5424 of 2025
C/W MFA No. 9744 of 2025


CNR: KAHC010478232025


multiplier 14 considering the age of the deceased. In view
of the same the loss of dependency is calculated as under:
17,092 x 12 = Rs.2,05,104/-
2,05,104 + 25% = Rs.2,56,380/-
2,56,380 – 1/3 = Rs.1,70,920/-
1,70,920 X 14 = Rs.23,92,880/-

18. The Tribunal has rightly awarded funeral
Rs.
expenses of 18,150/-, loss of estate in a sum of
Rs.
Rs.18,150/- and medical expenses of 1,17,726/-. As
compensation awarded towards funeral expenses includes
transportation of dead body, claimant is not separately
entitled to conveyance and traveling expenses of
Rs.1
0,000/- awarded by the Tribunal.

19. In view of the above claimant is entitled to
total compensation under various heads as under:

1 Towards loss of dependency Rs.23,92,880/-
2 Towards loss of consortium Rs.48,400/-
3 Towards loss of estate Rs.18,150/-
4 Towards funeral & obsequies Rs.18,150/-
Digitally Signed By:
SHIVASHANKAR BASAPPA
AMARANNAVAR
JUDGE, HIGH COURT OF KARNATKA

- 16 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63562
MFA No. 5424 of 2025
C/W MFA No. 9744 of 2025


CNR: KAHC010478232025


ceremony expenses
5 Towards medical expenses Rs.1,17,726/-
Total Rs.25,95,306/-


20. Claimant is entitled to total compensation of
Rs.
Rs.25,95,306/- as against 14,78,390/- awarded by the
Tribunal with interest. Consequently claimant is entitled to
Rs.
enhanced compensation of 11,16,916/- with interest at
the rate of 6% per annum from the date of petition till the
date of realization. Claimant is not entitled to interest for
the delay period of 170 days in filing the appeal as per
order dated 08.01.2026 passed on I.A. No. 1/2025.
Insurer - appellant in MFA No. 5424/2025 is liable to pay
the said enhanced compensation with interest.

21. In view of the above, the following;
O R D E R

a. Both the appeals are allowed in part.

b. Claimant is entitled to enhanced compensation
of Rs.11,16,916/- with interest at the rate of 6%
Digitally Signed By:
SHIVASHANKAR BASAPPA
AMARANNAVAR
JUDGE, HIGH COURT OF KARNATKA

- 17 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63562
MFA No. 5424 of 2025
C/W MFA No. 9744 of 2025


CNR: KAHC010478232025


p.a. from the date of petition till the date of
realization.

c. Claimant is not entitled to interest on delay
period of 170 days in filing the appeal.

d. Insurer shall deposit the enhanced compensation
with interest before the Tribunal within six weeks
from this day.

e. Amount in deposit is ordered to be transmitted
to the Tribunal.

f. Out of the enhanced compensation 50% shall be
kept in Fixed Deposit in the name of claimant in
any nationalized/scheduled Bank for a period of
5 years and remaining 50% shall be released to
Digitally Signed By:
SHIVASHANKAR BASAPPA
her.
AMARANNAVAR
JUDGE, HIGH COURT OF KARNATKA

(SHIVASHANKAR AMARANNAVAR)
JUDGE

LRS
List No.: 1 Sl No.: 16