SRI. SIDLINGAPPA vs STATE OF KARNATAKA

Court
Karnataka High Court

- 1 -
WA No. 417 of 2023


Reserved on: 28.08.2026
Pronounced on: 13.11.2026

IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU



TH
DATED THIS THE 13 DAY OF NOVEMBER, 2026


PRESENT

THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE JAYANT BANERJI

AND

THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE T.M.NADAF

WRIT APPEAL NO.417 OF 2023 (LA-HS)

BETWEEN:



1.

SRI. SIDLINGAPPA,
S/O MAHADEVAPPA,
SINCE DECEASED BY LRS,

SMT. JAYAMMA,
D/O LATE SIDDLINGAPPA,
SINCE DECEASED BY HER LRS,

(a) SRI S. RUDRESH,
S/O LATE BASAPPA AND
SMT. JAYAMMA,
AGED ABOUT 61 YEARS,

(b) SMT. B. MANJULA
D/O LATE BASAPPA AND
SMT. JAYAMMA,
AGED ABOUT 54 YEARS,

(c) SRI. S. HANUMANTHU
S/O LATE BASAPPA AND
SMT. JAYAMMA,
AGED ABOUT 52 YEARS,

(d) SMT. S.REKHA
S/O LATE BASAPPA AND
SMT. JAYAMMA,
AGED ABOUT 50 YEARS,









Digitally
signed by
REKHA R
Location:
High Court
of Karnataka

- 2 -
WA No. 417 of 2023


ALL ARE RESIDING AT SHABANUR VILLAGE,
DAVANAGERE TALUK, AND DISTRICT - 577 002.

2 .




(a)
SMT. RATHNAMMA
W/O. NANJAPPA
D/O LATE SIDDALINGAPPA,
SINCE DECEASED BY HIS LRS,

SRI KALLESHI
S/O LATE NANJAPPA AND
SMT. RATHNAMMA,
AGED ABOUT 44 YEARS,
R/O. KUKUDAWADA,
DAVANGERE TALUK AND
DIST. 577002.

(b). SMT. SAVITHRI
D/O LATE NANJAPPA AND
SMT. RATHNAMMA,
AGED ABOUT 38 YEARS,
R/O. HOLESIRIGERE,
HARIHAR TALUK,
DAVANGERE DIST. 577002.

(c). SMT. SUSHEELA
D/O LATE NANJAPPA AND
SMT. RATNAMMA,
AGED ABOUT 37 YEARS,
R/O. MAKANUR,
RANNEBENNUR TALUK,
HAVERI DIST. 581110.

(d). SRI. JAGADEESH
D/O LATE NANJAPPA AND
SMT. RATNAMMA,
AGED ABOUT 36 YEARS,
R/O. MAKANUR,
RANEBBENUR TALUK,
HAVERI DIST. 581110.

3.



SMT. SHANTAMMA
W/O LATE BASAVANAGOUDA
D/O LATE SIDLINGAPPA
SINCE DECEASED BY HER LRS

- 3 -
WA No. 417 of 2023



(a)


SRI. DEVARAJ
S/O LATE BASAVANAGOUDA
AND SMT. SHANTAMMA,
AGED ABOUT 46 YEARS,
RESIDING AT YAKKANAHALLI VILLAGE,
HONNALI TALUK, DAVANAGERE DIST-577002.

(b) SMT. LEELAMMA @ NEELAMMA
D/O LATE BASAVANAGOUDA AND
SMT. SHANTAMMA,
AGED ABOUT 44 YEARS,
R/O MALEBENNUR HARIHAR TALUK
DAVANAGERE DIST-577002.

(c) SMT. SUNITHA
D/O LATE BASAVANAGOUDA AND
SMT. SHANTAMMA,
AGED ABOUT 42 YEARS
R/O RAMAGONDANAHALLI,
DAVANAGERE TALUK AND DIST-577002.

4. SRI B. SIDDAPPA
AGED ABOUT 68 YEARS,
S/O LATE SIDLINGAPPA,
RESIDING AT SHAMANUR VILLAGE,
DAVANGERE TALUK AND DISTRICT-577002.

5. SMT NANJAMMA @ LALITHAMMA
D/O SIDLINGAPPA,
AGED ABOUT 58 YEARS,
RESIDING AT ANEKONDA,
DAVANAGERE TALUK AND DIST-577002.

6. SMT. ANNAPURNAMMA @ LALITHAMMA
D/O LATE SIDDALINGAPPA,
AGED ABOUT 51 YEARS,
R/O KAKANOOR VILLAGE,
CHANNAGIRI TALUK,
DAVANAGERE DIST-577002.

7. SMT. DAKSHANYAMMA
D/O LATE SIDDALINGAPPA,
AGED ABOUT 49 YEARS,

- 4 -
WA No. 417 of 2023


R/O BELLODI, HARIHAR TALUK,
DAVANAGERE DIST-577002.

8.


SRI BASAVALINGAPPA
S/O LATE SRI MAHADEVAPPA,
BROTHER OF THE SIDDALINGAPPA
SINCE DECEASED BY HIS LRS

(a) SMT. SHIVALINGAMMA
W/O RUDRAPPA,
D/O LATE BASALINGAPPA,
AGED ABOUT 61 YEARS,
RESIDING AT AVARAGERE VILLAGE,
DAVANAGERE TALUK AND DIST-577002.

(b) SMT. PREMA W/O BASAVARAPPA
D/O LATE BASALINGAPPA,
AGED ABOUT 57 YEARS,
R/O KABBUR VILLAGE,
DAVANAGERE TALUK AND DIST-577002.

(c) SRI SRIKANTAPPA
SON OF LATE BASALINGAPPA,
AGED ABOUT 57 YEARS,
R/O SHABANUR VILLAGE,
DAVANAGERE TALUK AND DIST-577002.

(d) KUMAR ALIAS SHIVAKUMAR
S/O LATE BASALINGAPPA,
AGED ABOUT 55 YEARS,
R/O SHABANUR VILLAGE,
DAVANAGERE TALUK AND DIST-577002.

(e) SRI. B. SIDDESHI
S/O LATE BASALINGAPPA,
AGED ABOUT 51 YEARS,
R/O SHAMANUR VILLAGE
DAVANGERE TALUK AND DIST-577002.

9.




SIDDARAMAPPA
S/O LATE MAHADEVAPPA,
BROTHER OF LATE SIDDLINGAPPA,
SINCE DECEASED BY LRS,

- 5 -
WA No. 417 of 2023


(a) SMT. KALLAMMA
W/O LATE SIDDRAMAPPA
AGED ABOUT 83 YEARS,
R/O SHAMANUR VILLAGE,
DAVANGERE TALUK AND DIST-577002.

(b) SMT. B. CHANDRAMMA
W/O T.H. KALLAPPA,
D/O LATE SIDDARAMAPPA,
AGED ABOUT 57 YEARS,
TURUCHAGHATTA VILLAGE,
DAVANGERE TALUK AND DIST-577002.

(c) SRI B. MANJUNATH
S/O LATE SIDDARAMAPPA
AGED ABOUT 56 YEARS,
NO.274, SHAMANUR VILLAGE,
DAVANGERE TALUK AND DIST-577002.

(d) SRI B. RAJAPPA @ RAJANNA
S/O LATE SIDDARAMAPPA,
AGED ABOUT 54 YEARS,
NO.274, SHAMANUR VILLAGE,
DAVANAGERE TALUK AND DIST-577002.

(e) SRI B.MAHADEVAPPA
S/O LATE SIDDARAMAPPA,
AGED ABOUT 52 YEARS,
NO.274, SHAMANUR VILLAGE,
DAVANAGERE TALUK AND DIST-577002.

(f) SRI B. SIDDESHI
S/O LATE SIDDARAMAPPA,
AGED ABOUT 50 YEARS,
NO.274, SHAMANUR VILLAGE,
DAVANAGERE TALUK AND DIST-577002.

(NOTE: SINCE PETIONER/APPELLANT NO.8(A), (B),
(G) ARE DEAD ARE NOT MADE PARTY.)
…APPELLANTS
(BY SRI. SHRIDHAR PRABHU, ADVOCATE FOR
SRI. MUDDURAJA N., ADVOCATE)

- 6 -
WA No. 417 of 2023


AND:

1. STATE OF KARNATAKA,
REPRESENTED BY ITS PRINCIPAL SECRETARY,
DEPARTMENT OF REVENUE,
VIDHANA SOUDHA, BANGALORE-560001.

2. THE DEPUTY COMMISSIONER,
DAVANAGERE DIST, DAVANAGERE-577002.

3. KUVEMPU UNIVERSITY,
GNANA SAHAYADRA,
SHANKARAGHATTA-577457,
REPRESENTED BY ITS REGISTRAR.

4. ASST. COMMISSIONER,
DAVANGERE SUB-DIVISION,
DAVANGERE TALUK AND DIST-577002.

5. BDT COLLEGE OF ENGINEERING,
REPRESENTED BY ITS PRINCIPAL,
DAVANGERE TALUK,
DAVANGERE DIST-577002.
…RESPONDENTS
(BY MS. PRAHIBA R.K., AGA FOR R1, R2 AND R4;
SRI.T.P.RAJENDRA KUMAR SUNGAY, ADVOCATE FOR R3;
SRI.C.K.NANDAKUMAR, SR. ADVOCATE FOR
SRI.SANTOSH S.NAGARALE, ADVOCATE FOR R5)

THIS WRIT APPEAL IS FILED UNDER SECTION 4 OF THE
KARNATAKA HIGH COURT ACT, PRAYING TO CALL FOR THE
RELEVANT RECORDS IN WP NO.51657/2017 AND SET-ASIDE
THE IMPUGNED ORDER DATED 23.03.2023 PASSED BY THE
LEARNED SINGLE JUDGE OF THIS HON’BLE COURT BY
ALLOWING THIS WRIT APPEAL AND GRANT SUCH OTHER
RELIEF OR RELIEFS AS THIS HON’BLE COURT DEEMS FIT
UNDER THE FACTS AND CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE, IN
THE INTEREST OF JUSTICE AND EQUITY.

- 7 -
WA No. 417 of 2023


THIS APPEAL HAVING BEEN HEARD AND RESERVED FOR
JUDGMENT, COMING ON FOR PRONOUNCEMENT THIS DAY,

JUDGMENT IS DELIVERED/ PRONOUNCED AS UNDER:

CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE JAYANT BANERJI
and
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE T.M.NADAF
CAV JUDGMENT
(PER: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE T.M.NADAF)
This intra-Court appeal by the unsuccessful
petitioners, laying a challenge to the well articulated order
of the Writ Court touching all the corners of the lis , dated
23.03.2023, in W.P.No.51657/2017.
2. The parties are referred to as per the rankings
before the Writ Court.
3. Facts germane to file the present petition are as
under:
3.1 The petitioners are the legal representatives of
deceased land owners. The petitioners were before
the Writ Court assailing the acquisition proceedings
of the year 1971-72, so also calling in question the
Government order dated 27.10.2014, where under

- 8 -
WA No. 417 of 2023


the request for sparing their land from acquisition
has been turned down. They also sought an
alternative prayer to declare that the entire
acquisition proceeding is nullified on account of un-
utilization of the land for the last 37 years since the
acquisition.
3.2 The petitioners were before the Writ Court on the
following grounds:
(i) Firstly, the acquisition has lapsed under Section
24(2) of the Right to Fair Compensation and
Transparency in Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation
1
and Resettlement Act, 2013 , for not taking
possession of the land coupled with non-
payment of compensation.
(ii) Secondly, the land under acquisition has been
left unutilized and the petitioners have been
continuing in possession for all these years and

1
Hereinafter referred to as, ‘the Act of 2013’

- 9 -
WA No. 417 of 2023


therefore, the acquisition should be deemed to
have been abandoned.
(iii) Thirdly, as the possession was not taken, the
petitioners request for dropping of the land
from the acquisition ought to have been
considered favorably by the Government, in
view of earlier order passed by this Court in the
Writ Petition filed by them.
(iv) Fourthly, the order impugned in the Writ
Petition that is, declining to accede to the
request of the petitioners to drop the land has
been authored by a different Authority from the
one who had heard the matter, after remand
vide order dated 25.01.2007 in
W.P.No.36918/1999.
3.3 Whereas the State as well as the University argued in
support of the order impugned declining to accede to
the request of dropping the land from the acquisition
proceedings and denying the contentions of the

- 10 -
WA No. 417 of 2023


petitioners in respect of possession continued with
them, non-passing of award, non-payment of
compensation amount, non-utilization of land and
abandonment of the acquisition proceedings.
3.4 The University filed statement of objection, whereas
the Government argued and supported the statement
of objection and the order impugned in the Writ
Petition on following grounds:
(i) Firstly, the acquisition was of the year 1971-72,
whereas the challenge is made to the same
after considerable lapse of time, without there
being any plausible explanation, explaining the
enormous delay caused, tainted with laches. As
such, the petitioners be non-suited on the said
ground alone. So also on the ground of
suppression of fact on the principle of
‘ suppressio veri & suggestio falsi ’ and perjury
and fraud on the Court.

- 11 -
WA No. 417 of 2023


(ii) Secondly, the acquisition proceeding which has
been initiated has been concluded with issuance
of Notification under Section 16(2) of the Land
2
Acquisition Act, 1894 and the same having
been handed over to the BDT College of
Engineering.
(iii) Thirdly, the erstwhile landowners, under whom
the present petitioners laying the challenge now
after considerable time, have acquiesce the
acquisition proceeding by receiving
compensation and acknowledging the same
(Annexure-R1). In these circumstances, the
legal representatives have left with no right to
lay a challenge to the acquisition proceeding at
the belated point of time. Added to this, when
the other land owners have not laid any
challenge to the acquisition.
(iv) Fourthly, the Government, being convinced with
taking of possession and payment of

2
Hereinafter referred to as, ‘the Act of 1894’

- 12 -
WA No. 417 of 2023


compensation, has rightly turned down the
request for de-notifying the land, that too,
keeping in mind the public interest for which
the land was acquired. The enormity of the
requirement is apparent regard being had to
multiple increase of student population and
consequent escalation of teacher and staff
strength.
(v) Fifthly and lastly, the owners have no right in
the discretion of the Government exercising
power under Section 48, negating their request
to de-notify the land, as such the Court has no
say in the discretion which is otherwise not
tainted with any arbitrariness.
3.5 The Writ Court having considered the rival
submissions, declined to entertain the Writ Petition
on the grounds urged by the petitioners and
answered each and every point raised, the
submissions on the basis of the documents produced
and the facts of the case.

- 13 -
WA No. 417 of 2023


3.6 The Writ Court, in categorical terms has stated that
the petitioners falsely averred in Paragraph No.8 of
the petition that, “ The Deputy Commissioner after
examining all aspect of the land submitted a
report to the Principal Secretary-Revenue inter
alia stating that even after 28 years the land is
not utilized and the same continues to be in
possession and enjoyment of the Petitioners. ”,
held that the petitioners suppressed the material
aspects of the matter and they have no vested right
once their ancestors in title have acquiesced with the
acquisition proceedings by receiving the
compensation.
( emphasis supplied )
3.7 The Writ Court further has given a finding that there
is taking of possession of land lawfully and in the
absence of any contra evidence placed by the
petitioners to support their contention of continued
possession and they carrying dairy business, has
categorically stated that taking possession has been

- 14 -
WA No. 417 of 2023


proved in terms of law with the Notification issued
under Section 16(2) of Act of 1894.
3.8 The Writ Court further observed that the petitioners
cannot be permitted to make unjust enrichment once
having received the compensation again staking a
right on the alleged continuous possession and
seeking dropping/ de-notifying the land from the
acquisition proceedings. The relevant paragraphs of
the judgment are more fully stated in Paragraph
Nos.III, IV, V and VI, which read as under:
“III. TAKING OF POSSESSION AND PAYMENT OF
COMPENSATION:
xxxx
xxxx
xxxx
xxxx
(e) What one cannot loose sight of is the
run of time and the propensity of disappearance of
evidentiary material in the ‘Kiln Of The Time’ that
keeps working relentlessly. The acquisition has
been accomplished a little less than half a century
ago; the foundational facts of the litigation began
only in April 1998. Once the compensation for the
acquired land is received without any demur, the

- 15 -
WA No. 417 of 2023


land owners or anyone claiming under them have
no right to complain against the acquisition, vide
Apex Court decision in INDORE DEVELOPMENT
AUTHOTIRY, supra. The version of Petitioners that
their predecessor-in-title had not received the
compensation being a blatant lie, cannot go with
impunity.
IV. AS TO CHECKERED HISTORY OF THE CASE:
(a) The Governments & their officials
nowadays being what they are, leave a lot of
scope for the assumption that at the official level,
things do not run in a way, they ought to. The
normal presumption that the public functions are
discharged in accordance with law, at times can
hardly be justified. The Under Secretary of the
government had assumed that the Petitioners
were continuing in the possession of the land and
no compensation was paid and further that the
land losers happened to belong to Backward Class.
There is not only no evidence in support of all this
but it is contrary to a wealth of material on record,
as already discussed above. Strangely enough, the
government issued the denotification vide order
dated June 1999 gazetted on 15.7.1999 u/s 48(1)
of the 1894 Act and thereby, had dropped only
this land from the accomplished acquisition, that
too without notice to the beneficiary college which
no longer belonged to the government as such but
rd
by that time land had gone into the hands of 3
Respondent University vide statutory notification
issued under the Karnataka State Universities Act,

- 16 -
WA No. 417 of 2023


1976. Such things can happen only in fictitious
novels as in ‘Alice in Wonderland’ (Lewis Carroll,
1832-1898). In 3rd University’s
W.P.No.36918/1999, the said judgment came to
be set at naught by a Coordinate Bench of this
court. In Petitioners W.P.No.5009/2002, another
Coordinate Bench recalled the said judgment vide
order dated 29.6.2004 on the ground that
Petitioners were not parties to University’s Writ
Petition.
xxxx
V. AS TO GOVERNMENT’S POWER TO
DENOTIFY ACQUISITION:
xxxx
xxxx
(c) The vehement submission of learned
counsel for the Petitioners that the remand was
heard by one authority and the impugned order
has been made by the other, has no substance. In
matters like this, the government takes
institutional decisions. Where it takes the opinion
of some High Level Committee, it cannot be said
that some other authority has taken the decision.
Obviously, the Committee is nothing but a limb of
the government only and not an independent
agency. Even otherwise, this contention would not
come to the aid of the petitioners since the land
already vested in the State and possession was
taken after paying the compensation. The principle
of administrative law that one who hears should
decide, cannot be ritualistically pressed into

- 17 -
WA No. 417 of 2023


service. Such a contention offends the doctrine of
unjust enrichment in the sense that the person will
get back the property and retain compensation, as
well.
(d) Once the compensation has been
received by the land owner, even de-notification of
the land cannot be sought, as a matter of
justiciable right. As already discussed above, no
such arguable right remains alive once the
possession of the acquired land has been taken
over. The premise on which the impugned order is
structured, is factually sustainable on the basis of
the material available on record. A Writ Court is
not a court of appeal and what it needs to see is
the decision making process and not the decision
on merits, as observed by the Apex Court in
H.B.GANDHI vs. GOPINATH 1992 SUPP.2 SCC
312.
VI. AS TO WAIVER OF ACQUISITION VS.
WAIVER OF RIGHT TO CHALLENGE ACQUISITION:
xxxx
(b) Far from the so called abandonment
of acquisition, there is a perfect case of waiver of
right to challenge the acquisition: The original land
owner had never sought for de-notification of the
land nor had he challenged the acquisition, during
his life time. In any of their pleadings, the
Petitioners have not offered any explanation as to
why he did not do this, either. The possession
having been taken over and the compensation
having been received by the land owner decades

- 18 -
WA No. 417 of 2023


ago, there is acquiescence in the acquisition
process that has been fructified, as vouched by
the records. If the land owner himself had no right
to challenge, it is un-understandable as to how
such a right would avail in favour of the Petitioners
who claim under him. Admittedly, land owners had
not filed any objections to the Preliminary
Notification. Other persons whose lands have also
been acquired under the very same Notification
have no grievance whatsoever. In the totality of
these circumstances, it can be safely assumed
that the original land owner has waived whatever
arguable right he had to challenge the acquisition
and as a consequence, the petitioners claiming
under him have no litigable interest to launch
challenge of the kind.
In the above circumstances, this Writ
Petition being devoid of merits, is dismissed with
costs quantified at Rs.1,00,000/- (Rupees One
Lakh) only, collectively payable by the Petitioners
to the Karnataka State Legal Services Authority,
Bengaluru, within eight weeks, failing which, an
additional levy of Rs.1,000/- per day would follow,
in addition to Petitioners risking contempt action.
The Respondent-College and the concerned
University shall take all necessary steps to
safeguard the possession of the subject land on a
war footing, if necessary with the aid of police and
other authorities.”

- 19 -
WA No. 417 of 2023


3.9 Calling in question the order passed by the Writ
Court, the unsuccessful petitioners are before us in
this intra-Court appeal.
4. Heard, Sri.Shridhar Prabhu, learned counsel
appearing for the petitioners, Ms.Prathiba.R.K, learned
Addl. Government Advocate appearing for respondents 1,
2 and 4, Sri.T.P.Rajendra Kumar Sungay, learned counsel
appearing for respondent No.3 and Sri.C.K.Nandakumar,
learned Senior counsel assisted by Sri.Santosh S.Nagarale,
learned counsel for respondent No.5.
5. Sri.Shridhar Prabhu, reiterating the
submissions, submitted that, as per Annexure-E, the
Deputy Commissioner has categorically stated in the
report that the Government has to take possession of the
land, presupposes that the possession still continues with
the petitioners. The amount stated in the impugned Order
is against the amount stated in Annexure-R1. As such, the
said document has no relevance in the case on hand. The
Writ Court has failed to consider this aspect of the matter

- 20 -
WA No. 417 of 2023


and weighed much on Annexure-R2 than the one required
under law. As such, the order required to be set aside.
5.1 Learned counsel submits that the Writ Court passed
an erroneous adverse inference regarding de-
notification dated 15.07.1999 on the date of the
Gazzette Notification, when the document itself is
gazetted. He further submits that in the absence of
any documentary proof, such as Mahazar, etc. only
Notification under Section 16(2) cannot be read as a
conclusive proof of possession. The language used in
the Act of 1894 with respect to Section 16(2) is not
absolute. In terms of the language used, Section
16(2) has to be considered as a presumption rather
an absolute declaration. Any presumption in law as
read in so many other enactments is rebuttable,
unless the contrary is proved. Though Section 16(2)
Karnataka Amendment states regarding notification
and taking possession and vesting of the land, the
same is not absolute but it is a rebuttable
presumption. In the absence of supporting

- 21 -
WA No. 417 of 2023


documents, the Writ Court has overweighed the said
presumption and notification to come to a conclusion
that possession of the land has been taken.
5.2 Learned counsel further submits that the Writ Court
has failed to consider that there is no application of
mind by the Government while passing the order
under Section 48 of the Act of 1894, while de-
notifying the land on the request of the petitioners.
He further submits that the Authority which has
passed the order is different from the Authority which
has heard the matter conclusively. In that an
eventuality, the order gets vitiated.
5.3 Sri.Shridhar Prabhu, further submits that the
compensation amount has neither been paid nor
deposited. The reason being there is no document
with respect to Section 12(2) notice produced by the
Government. He further submits that the
Government participated in the Writ Petition as a
silent spectator, except supporting the contention of
the University. The Government neither filed

- 22 -
WA No. 417 of 2023


statement of objection nor produced any document
in support of the contention with respect to the
impugned order.
5.4 Learned counsel emphasizes more on the Inspection
Report of the Deputy Commissioner to contend that
once there is a categorical observation by the Deputy
Commissioner that the Government is required to
take possession of the land, presupposes that the
land is continued with the landowners. The payment
of compensation cannot be a circumstance to decline
the request of the petitioners. The reason being, to
exercise power contained under Section 48, the main
ingredient is not taking of possession. In the case on
hand, in the teeth of the Report of the Commissioner
categorically holding that the Government is yet to
take possession of the land, the State ought to have
considered the request of the petitioners to de-notify,
taking into consideration the submission and the
documents produced on their behalf. The Writ Court
has failed to consider the power to de-notify. In that

- 23 -
WA No. 417 of 2023


an eventuality, the order suffers from perversity and
required to be set aside. To buttress his argument,
learned counsel placed reliance on the following
Judgments:

(1) THE BANGALORE DEVELOPMENT
AUTHORITY VS. A.M.LAKSHMINARAYANA
@ LAKSHMINARAYANAPPA AND
3
ANOTHER .
(2) BALWANT NARAYAN BHAGDE VS.
4
M.D. BHAGWAT AND OTHERS .
(3) BALMOKAND KHATRI EDUCATIONAL
AND INDUSTRIAL TRUST, AMRITSAR
VS. STATE OF PUNJAB AND
5
OTHERS .
(4) BANDA DEVELOPMENT AUTHORITY,
BANDA VS. MOTI LAL AGARWAL
6
AND OTHERS .

(5) GOVERNMENT OF NCT OF DELHI
AND ANOTHER VS. BSK REALTORS
7
LLP AND ANOTHER .

3
WA No. 4718 of 2016
4
(1976) 1 SCC 700
5
(1996) 4 SCC 212
6
(2011) 5 SCC 394
7
(2024) 7 SCC 370

- 24 -
WA No. 417 of 2023


(6) HARYANA URBAN DEVELOPMENT
AUTHORITY VS. ABHISHEK GUPTA
8
ETC .
6. In contrast, Sri.C.K.Nandakumar, learned
Senior counsel, assisted by Sri.Santosh S.Nagarale,
learned counsel appearing for BDT College of Engineering
– respondent No.5, argued in support of the Order passed
by the Writ Court and submitted that the relief sought is
liable to be dismissed on delay and laches, which has
properly been considered by the Writ Court, while
dismissing the Writ Petition on that ground.
6.1 Learned Senior counsel further submits that the
possession of the land has been taken vide 16(2)
Notification, subsequent to passing of the award and
payment of compensation and in view of the
Notification issued, possession of the land gets
vested with the Government as on 12.07.1973 and in
the absence of any challenge, the land having been
handed over to the possession of the BTD College for

8
2024 SCC OnLine 2991

- 25 -
WA No. 417 of 2023


construction of staff quarters, and subsequently in
the year 1992, the said College was entrusted to
Kuvempu University along with its assets as per
Annexure-R3. In these circumstances, in view of the
law laid down by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in
INDORE DEVELOPMENT AUTHORITY VS.
9
MANOHARLAL AND OTHERS , that “once an
award is made, and possession is taken by
virtue of Section 16, the lands vests absolutely
in the State free from all encumbrances.
Vesting of land is automatic on the happening
of the two exigencies of passing award and
taking possession as provided under Section
16. Once possession is taken under Section 16
of the 1894 Act, the owner of the land loses
title to it and the Government becomes the
absolute owner of the land.”
6.2 Learned Senior counsel submits that the Writ Court,
referring to the Judgment of the Hon'ble Supreme

9
(2020) 8 SCC 129

- 26 -
WA No. 417 of 2023


Court in INDORE DEVELOPMENT AUTHORITY
(supra) in Paragraph No.III(c) under the heading
Possession and Payment of compensation, rightly
held that retaining or regaining possession of
acquired land after receiving the compensation
virtually amounts to an act of rank trespass of public
property. The relevant paragraph reads as under:
“III. TAKING OF POSSESSION AND PAYMENT OF
COMPENSATION:
xxxx
xxxx
(c) The submission of learned counsel for the
Petitioners that their clients have power supply
connection in the very same property and
therefore, the presumption as to possession
should be drawn in their favour, cannot be agreed
to. When, how and for what purposes, the alleged
installation of power supply has been made, is not
explained. In the absence of such material
particulars in the pleadings and in the absence of
any evidentiary material to vouch the same,
nothing turns out as to assume their possession.
Even if, a plea was taken and the electricity bills
were produced, that too would not have
buttressed an argument of the kind, especially
when a wealth of contra material produced by the
Respondents that would fully rebut whatever little

- 27 -
WA No. 417 of 2023


presumption that could have been raised in favour
of the petitioners. It hardly needs to be stated that
to secure power supply, the extant rules of
KEB/KPTCL do not prescribe a strict proof of
possession or ownership of the premises.
Similarly, not even an iota of material is produced
as to the cultivation of the land & its agricultural
produce. It hardly needs to be stated that
retaining or regaining possession of acquired land
after receiving the compensation virtually amount
to an act of rank trespass of public property vide
INDORE DEVELOPMENT AUTHOTIRY, supra
wherein it is observed as under:
“...When the State has acquired the
land and award has been passed, land
vests in the State Government free from
all encumbrances. The act of vesting of
the land in the State is with possession,
any person retaining the possession,
thereafter, has to be treated as
trespasser and has no right to possess
the land which vests in the State free
from all encumbrances...”
6.3 Learned Senior counsel further submits that in the
instant case, the award is passed and paid to
Smt.Siddamma, Sri.Siddaramappa and
Sri.Basalingappa on 06.09.1972 and the amount has
been received by the said landowners and further

- 28 -
WA No. 417 of 2023


under Section 30 of the Act, balance amount is
deposited before the concerned Civil Court. He
submits that, in the teeth of relevant material
documents, the case has been made out with respect
to taking possession, payment of compensation and
issuance of notice under Section 16(2). In that view
of the matter, the contention of the petitioners after
considerable lapse of time, only on the basis of
misinterpreting the report filed by the Deputy
Commissioner to the Government, cannot be
permitted to reopen the acquisition proceeding which
has been given quietus, by passage of time while
satisfying all the legal requirements.
6.4 Learned Senior counsel further submits that a
perusal of Report clearly indicates that the report not
at all states that the petitioners are continuing in
possession. What is stated in the report is that, the
respondent University despite the land acquired and
possession given, not utilized the same for
construction of staff quarters for which it was

- 29 -
WA No. 417 of 2023


acquired and in the event of establishment of new
district head quarter in the year 1997 for the purpose
of construction of district headquarters and staff
quarters for the district administration, possession of
the land be handed over to the Revenue Department
for the purpose of construction of District Head
quarters and staff quarters. With no stretch of
imagination the observation by Deputy Commissioner
in the report can be considered as the land still in the
possession of the petitioners. In that an eventuality,
the submission made by the petitioners and their
contention in the Writ Petition amounts to
misrepresentation and misleading the Court. In that
regard, the same amounts to playing fraud on the
Court. With this, learned Senior counsel sought to
dismiss the appeal.
6.5 To substantiate his contention, learned Senior
counsel placed reliance on the following Judgments:

- 30 -
WA No. 417 of 2023


(1) SATENDRA PRASAD JAIN AND
OTHERS VS. STATE OF U.P. AND
10
OTHERS
(2) MUNICIPAL COUNCIL,
AHMEDNAGAR AND ANOTHER VS.
11
SHAH HYDER BEIG AND OTHERS
(3) RAM CHAND AND OTHERS VS.
12
UNION OF INDIA AND OTHERS
(4) AWADH BIHARI YADAV AND
OTHERS VS. STATE OF BIHAR AND
13
OTHERS
(5) INDORE DEVELOPMENT AUTHORITY
14
VS. MANOHARLAL AND OTHERS
7. Ms.Prabthiba.R.K, learned Addl. Government
Advocate appearing for respondents 1, 2 and 4 - State and
Sri.T.P.Rajendra Kumar Sungay, learned counsel
appearing on behalf of respondent No.3 – University,
argued in line with learned Senior counsel appearing for
respondent No.5, supporting the order of the Writ Court
and sought to dismiss the appeal.

10
(1993) 4 SCC 369
11
(2000) 2 SCC 48
12
(1994) 1 SCC 44
13
(1995) 6 SCC 31
14
(2020) 8 SCC 129

- 31 -
WA No. 417 of 2023


8. We having heard the learned counsel appearing
for the respective parties, perused the entire Writ Appeal
paper, so also the Judgments relied on by both the
parties.
9. Before dealing with the rival submissions, it is
relevant to state certain facts which were contended by
the Writ Petitioners in the earlier petition and petition now
filed.
9.1 In W.P.No.5009/2001, filed by the petitioners on the
earlier occasion, at paragraph No.2, they have stated
as under:
“2. On 05.01.1970, the preliminary
notification was issued under Section 4(1) of
the Act stating that the lands in Sy.No.100/1
and 142 formed in Shabanur Village are
required for public purpose to wit for
construction of staff quarters of BDT College
of Engineering, Davanagere. “The petitioner’s
predecessors who were illiterates and being
unaware of issuance of notifications failed to
file any objections”. Thereafter, the Final
notification was issued under Sec.6(1) of the
Act on 11.05.1971. The same was gazette on
27.05.1971. As per the said notification, it

- 32 -
WA No. 417 of 2023


was declared that the lands afore-mentioned
were required for a public purpose. A copy of
the final notification is herewith produced and
marked as Annexure-A.”
9.2 In the present Writ Petition, the petitioners at

Paragraph Nos.3 and 4, state as under:
“3. “The Petitioners being the land
owners of the Schedule Property filed objections
to proposed acquisition inter alia stating that
the land is fertile agricultural land and the
Petitioners have no other source of income
except the Schedule Property and accordingly
requested to drop the Schedule Property from
the acquisition proceedings”. Further, the
Petitioner brought to the Notice of the State
Government, the Government has vast extent
of land for staff quarter of BDT college of
Engineer and therefore acquisition of the
Schedule Property was illegal.
4. That the Petitioners submit that the
State Government without considering the
objections filed by the Petitioners objecting the
acquisition and without considering the fact that
there is already land available adjacent to the
Schedule Property for the construction of Staff
Quarters issued Final Declaration under Section
6(1) of the L.A Act on 11.05.1971 acquiring the
Schedule Property for construction of Staff
Quarters. The copy of the Final Declaration

- 33 -
WA No. 417 of 2023


issued under Section 6(1) of L.A. Act dated
11.05.1971 is produced herewith as
ANNEXURE-B. That the Land Acquisition Officer
has passed an award on 29.04.1972 awarding
compensation to the land Owners.”
(emphasis by us)
9.3 The petitioners, so far as their contention regarding

continued possession, at paragraph No.8 of the
petition has stated as under:
“8. That the Petitioners submit that the
Petitioners have been utilizing the Schedule
Property for carrying on agricultural activities
and continued to be in possession of the
Schedule Property and therefore the Petitioners
made request to the Deputy Commissioner to
cancel the acquisition proceedings for
construction of staff quarters earlier for BDT
College of Engineering. The Deputy
Commissioner after examining all aspect of the
land submitted a report to the Principal
Secretary – Revenue inter alia stating that even
after 28 years the land is not utilized and the
same continues to be in possession and
enjoyment of the Petitioners. The copy of the
communication dated 29.08.1998 of the Deputy
Commissioner is produced herewith as
ANNEXURE-E .”

- 34 -
WA No. 417 of 2023


9.4 However, the petitioners have not produced any Iota
of document in support of their contention regarding
their possession and running dairy business. The
averments made are just opposite to the earlier
contention amounts to misrepresentation and playing
fraud on the Court.
10. Reverting to the contentions urged and
considered by the Writ Court, so far as possession, the
issue now has been settled with the Judgment of the
Hon'ble Supreme Court in INDORE DEVELOPMENT
AUTHORITY (supra), wherein the Hon'ble Supreme Court
has categorically held as under:
“… When the State has acquired the land
and award has been passed, land vests in the
State Government free from all encumbrances.
The act of vesting of the land in the State is
with possession, any person retaining the
possession, thereafter, has to be treated as
trespasser and has no right to possess the land
which vests in the State free from all
encumbrances…”
11. In the very same Judgment, the Hon’ble
Supreme Court at Paragraph No.359 has held as under:

- 35 -
WA No. 417 of 2023


“359. The entire gamut of submissions of
the landowners is based on the
misinterpretation of the provisions contained in
Section 24. It does not intend to divest the
State of possession (of the land), title to which
has been vested in the State. It only intends to
give higher compensation in case the obligation
of depositing of compensation has not been
fulfilled with regard to the majority of holdings.
A fresh cause of action in Section 24 has been
given if for five years or more possession has
not been taken nor compensation has been
paid. In case possession has been taken and
compensation has not been deposited with
respect to the majority of landholdings, higher
compensation to all incumbents follows, as
mentioned above. Section 24 does not confer a
new cause of action to challenge the acquisition
proceedings or the methodology adopted for the
deposit of compensation in the treasury instead
of reference court, in that case, interest or
higher compensation, as the case may be, can
follow. In our considered opinion, Section 24 is
applicable to pending proceedings, not to the
concluded proceedings and the legality of the
concluded proceedings, cannot be questioned.
Such a challenge does not lie within the ambit
of the deemed lapse under Section 24. The
lapse under Section 24(2) is due to inaction or
lethargy of authorities in taking requisite steps
as provided therein.”

- 36 -
WA No. 417 of 2023


12. The entire bedrock of the argument is their
continued possession and non-payment of compensation.
Both have been Negatived by the respondents with the
statement of objection and documents at Annexures-R1,
R2 and R3.
13. The Writ Court while answering the contentions
on taking possession and payment of compensation, in
categorical terms, referring to Annexures-R1 and R2 has
clearly stated that the compensation has been paid and
possession has been taken. Further, has held that the
predecessors in title have not taken any action on the
acquisition proceedings and once they having acquiesced
the same, now it is not available to the legal
representatives claiming under them, to contend that the
possession continued with them and they having not been
paid with the compensation, entitled for de-notification.
14. The Writ Court, while answering the
Government power to de-notify, at paragraph (C) and (D)
under the heading ‘Governments power to Denotify
Acquisition’, held that, the power is a discretionary power,

- 37 -
WA No. 417 of 2023


but the same has been exercised legally by the
Government in the case on hand after considering the
wealth of documents produced. By referring to
K.T.PLANTATIONS PRIVATE LIMITED VS. STATE OF
15
KARNATAKA by the Supreme Court, the Writ Court has
properly held that the power to drop the land from
acquisition under Section 48(1) avails only when
possession has not been assumed. The Writ Court also
observed that this Section does not cast an obligation on
the Government to drop the acquisition proceedings even
when the possession of the notified land is not taken. In
other words, the Government has abundant discretion not
to give up acquisition if the land is genuinely needed for a
public purpose. Of course, every discretion has to be
exercised in accordance with the Rules of reason and
Justice.
15. We are in full agreement with the finding of the
Writ Court on the power of the Government to de-notify,
as we find that the discretion exercised by the

15
(2011) 9 SCC 1

- 38 -
WA No. 417 of 2023


Government under Section 48 is not tainted with any
arbitrariness. The same is exercised in the presence of
documents which were the bedrock for exercising the
discretion under Section 48(1) as per the order impugned.
The land owners cannot claim it as a matter of right for
two reasons; (i) they failed to establish their contention
that the land continued in their possession and (ii) the
power under Section 48(1) is available to the Government
only when possession has not been assumed. In the
absence of any cogent materials produced by the
petitioners, except the self-serving statement, it becomes
very hard for us to consider the case of the petitioners
that they continued in possession of the property.
16. The Writ Court, having considered the wealth of
the documents produced and, reading in between lines
each of the documents, with a well-articulated Judgment
and reasons, declined to accept the contentions of the
petitioners.
17. So far as payment of compensation is
concerned, the same in terms of Annexure-R1 gets

- 39 -
WA No. 417 of 2023


proved. It is for this reason, the ancestors in title have
acquiesced the acquisition proceedings.
18. So far as 12(2) Notice is concerned, as per the
language used in the said Section, the petitioners have
failed to produce any document to contend that their
ancestor in title were not present while passing of the
award. In that an eventuality, the contention of the
petitioners cannot be countenanced on Section 12(2).
19. Further, we find valid reason in the order
passed by the Writ Court to hold that when lands having
been acquired, and possession having been taken in
respect of other lands, there is no reason for the
Government not to take possession of the petitioners'
land. Once the possession note has been issued after
payment of compensation and followed by Section 16(2)
notification, same puts quietus to taking possession as
evidence, conclusively holding that the possession has
been taken, in the absence of any contra evidence to that
effect. The Judgments relied on by the petitioners are
factually not applicable to the case on hand. In that view

- 40 -
WA No. 417 of 2023


of the matter, we are in full agreement with the well-
reasoned order passed by the Writ Court.
20. For the foregoing reasons, we proceed to pass
the following:
ORDER
(i) The Writ Appeal is dismissed .
(ii) In view of dismissal of the Writ Appeal,
pending interlocutory applications, if any,
stand disposed of.



Sd/-
(JAYANT BANERJI)
JUDGE



Sd/-
(T.M.NADAF)
JUDGE
TKN