Vighnaharta C.H.S.Ltd. Thr Its Secretary Mr. Nitin Palve vs Suncity Nanik Infrastructures
- Court
- Bombay High Court
CNR No : HCBM010354632026
2026:BHC-AS:45230
3(ii)-ARA-51-2026+(Operative Order).doc
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
ARBITRATION APPEAL NO.51 OF 2026
Digitally signed
by SATISH
RAMCHANDRA
SANGAR
Date:
2026.11.05
16:49:43
+0530
SATISH
RAMCHANDRA
SANGAR
Vighnaharta C.H.S. Ltd. }
A Co–operative Housing Society, }
Through its Secretary Mr.Nitin Palve, }
Age : 44 Years, Occupation : Business, }
Having address at :- NL–2 Type Apartment }
Owners Association, Plot No.3, Sector 1A, }
Nerul, Navi Mumbai – 400 703. } ...Appellant
Versus
Suncity Nanik Infrastructures, }
A Partnership Firm, Having address at:- }
Office No. 2404–2406, Fairmount C.H.S., }
Palm Beach Road, Plot No.4, Sector 17, }
Sanpada, Navi Mumbai – 400 706. } ...Respondent
===================================================
ALONG WITH
INTERIM APPLICATION NO.8201 OF 2026
IN
ARBITRATION APPEAL NO.51 OF 2026
Sandesh Gopinath Kanade, }
Age : 53 Years, Occupation : Business, }
Residing at : Flat NL/2/5/B–2 and Others } ...Applicants
In the matter between :-
Vighnaharta C.H.S. Ltd. }
A Co–operative Housing Society, }
Through its Secretary Mr.Nitin Palve, }
1/4
Satish Sangar
Uploaded on - 05/11/2026 Downloaded on - 16/11/2026 15:38:03
3(ii)-ARA-51-2026+(Operative Order).doc
Age : 44 Years, Occupation : Business, }
Having address at :- NL–2 Type Apartment }
Owners Association, Plot No.3, Sector 1A, }
Nerul, Navi Mumbai – 400 703. } ...Appellant
Versus
Suncity Nanik Infrastructures, }
A Partnership Firm, Having address at:- }
Office No. 2404–2406, Fairmount C.H.S., }
Palm Beach Road, Plot No.4, Sector 17, }
Sanpada, Navi Mumbai – 400 706. } ...Respondent
===================================================
ALONG WITH
INTERIM APPLICATION NO.7456 OF 2026
IN
ARBITRATION APPEAL NO.51 OF 2026
Vighnaharta C.H.S. Ltd. }
A Co–operative Housing Society, }
Through its Secretary Mr.Nitin Palve, }
Age : 44 Years, Occupation : Business, }
Having address at :- NL–2 Type Apartment }
Owners Association, Plot No.3, Sector 1A, }
Nerul, Navi Mumbai – 400 703. } ...Applicant
In the matter between :-
Vighnaharta C.H.S. Ltd. }
A Co–operative Housing Society, }
Through its Secretary Mr.Nitin Palve, }
Age : 44 Years, Occupation : Business, }
Having address at :- NL–2 Type Apartment }
Owners Association, Plot No.3, Sector 1A, }
Nerul, Navi Mumbai – 400 703. } ...Appellant
2/4
Satish Sangar
Uploaded on - 05/11/2026 Downloaded on - 16/11/2026 15:38:03
3(ii)-ARA-51-2026+(Operative Order).doc
Versus
Suncity Nanik Infrastructures, }
A Partnership Firm, Having address at:- }
Office No. 2404–2406, Fairmount C.H.S., }
Palm Beach Road, Plot No.4, Sector 17, }
Sanpada, Navi Mumbai – 400 706. } ...Respondent
===================================================
Mr.Atul Damle (Senior Advocate) a/w
Mr.Akhilesh Dubey, Mr.Amit Dubey,
Mr.Uttam Dubey, Ms.Payal Vardhan,
Mr.Abhishek Karnik and Mr.Aryan
Yadav i/b. Mr.Rajuram Kuleriya:-
Advocates for Appellant and
for Applicant in Interim
Application No.7456 of 2026.
Mr.R.D.Soni a/w Mr.Girish Agrawal,
Mr.Vinod Gupta and Ms.Chitra
Darekar:-
Advocates for Respondent.
Mr.Suresh Sabrad a/w Mr.Pratik
Sabrad, Ms.Neha Parte, Mr.Amey
Sawant & Ms.Eshwaree Kudalkar:-
Advocates for Applicants in
Interim Application No.8201
of 2026.
===================================================
CORAM : S. M. MODAK, J.
th
DATE : 4 NOVEMBER 2026
P. C. :-
1. For the reasons recorded separately, which are under typing, the
following operative order is passed:-
-: OPERATIVE ORDER :-
(i) The Appeal is allowed.
nd
(ii) The order dated 22 June 2026 passed by the District Judge
in Civil Misc. Application No.38 of 2026 is set aside.
3/4
Satish Sangar
Uploaded on - 05/11/2026 Downloaded on - 16/11/2026 15:38:03
3(ii)-ARA-51-2026+(Operative Order).doc
(iii) The Interim Applications filed by few of the Society
members are rejected in view of the above order.
(iv) Above observations are made while dealing with an Appeal
challenging the order passed under Section 9 of 1996 Act. If
any of the parties decide to take recourse to the provisions of
Section 17, they are at liberty and the Authorities are at
liberty to decide such Application without being influenced
by the observations and such Application to be decided as
per the merits.
(v) All contentions of the parties are kept open.
2. With these observations, the Appeal is disposed of.
3. Interim Applications are also disposed of.
[S. M. MODAK, J.]
4/4
Satish Sangar
Uploaded on - 05/11/2026 Downloaded on - 16/11/2026 15:38:03
Powered by TCPDF (www.tcpdf.org)