Committee Of Management, Standard Intermediate College And 3 Others vs State Of U.P. And 4 Others

Court
Allahabad High Court

HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT ALLAHABAD
WRIT - C No. - 46804 of 2026
Committee of Management, Standard Intermediate College and 3 others
…..Petitioner(s)
Versus
State of U.P. and 4 others
…..Respondent(s)
Counsel for Petitioner(s) : Pradeep Kumar Upadhyay
Counsel for Respondent(s) : C.S.C., Dhananjay Kumar
Court No. - 38 A.F.R.
HON'BLE SIDDHARTH NANDAN, J.
1. Heard Shri Pradeep Kumar Upadhyay, learned counsel for the
petitioners, Shri K.R. Singh, learned Senior Counsel, assisted by Shri
Dhananjay Singh, learned counsel for respondent No. 5, and the learned
Standing Counsel for the respondents-State.
2. The present petition has been filed assailing the order dated
27.10.2026, which is stated to have been passed by the Regional Level
Committee in pursuance of the direction issued by this Court on
09.04.2026, whereby the matter was relegated to the District Inspector of
Schools, Prayagraj, with a direction to decide the dispute relating to the
appointment of the Manager in terms of the Government Order dated
19.12.2000, while setting aside the recognition order dated 18.03.2026
passed in favour of Shri Jubaid Ahmed.
3. It is an admitted fact that the last undisputed election took place on
17.07.2022. However, the Manager of the Committee of Management
died on 20.02.2025, and thereafter, two separate elections were set up. In
the first election, Shri Jubaid Ahmed was stated to have been elected by

2
WRIC No. - 46804 of 2026
the petitioners and was subsequently recognised vide order dated
18.03.2026, which has already been set aside by this Court. In the
second election, the Deputy Manager, namely, Shri Aiyaz Ahmed, was
elected as the Manager, and his signatures were also attested on
10.07.2025.
4. It is also admitted that the petitioners had preferred a petition
challenging the order dated 10.07.2025, which was subsequently
withdrawn.In view of the aforesaid, order dated 10.07.2025 remain
intact.
5. However, the sole ground raised by learned counsel for the petitioners
before this Court in assailing the order dated 27.10.2026 is that Dr.
Brijesh Mishra participated in the meeting of the Regional Level
Committee in a dual capacity, i.e., as Joint Director of Education,
Prayagraj Region, Prayagraj, and Deputy Director of Education
(Madhyamik), Prayagraj Mandal, Prayagraj. Placing reliance on a
decision of this Court in the case of Committee of Management Janta
Janardan Shiksha Sadan Inter College Tilaon and Another vs. State of
U.P. and Others, reported in 2026 (5) ADJ 155, it has been contended
that since the Government Order dated 19.12.2000 provides for a three-
member Regional Level Committee to assist in the implementation of
Section 16-A(7) of the Intermediate Education Act, 1921, the absence of
any one member would render the decision taken by the Regional Level
Committee vitiated. The said decision has also been affirmed in an intra-
court appeal, being Special Appeal No. 1046 of 2026 (Dinesh Gupta vs.
Committee of Management, Adarsh Inter College and 7 Others), and, as
such, it is contended that the order passed by the Regional Level
Committee is liable to be set aside. For ready reference para 60 of this
judgement is reproduced below:-
"60. In view of the aforesaid, I find that the impugned order dated
08.08.2025 cannot be sustained and is accordingly set aside, with
the following directions:-
(i) The Joint Director of Education, Vindhyachal Mandal,
Mirzapur, is directed to seek a nomination from the government
within a period of two weeks from the date of receipt of the

3
WRIC No. - 46804 of 2026
certified copy of this order, in case, till date no “Deputy Director
of Education” has taken charge.
(ii) Respondent no.1 on receipt of such a request, shall proceed to
nominate Regional Deputy Director of Education, from a
neighbouring region as an adhoc Member of the Regional Level
Committee, Vindhyachal Mandal, Mirzapur.
(iii) On the constitution of the Regional Level Committee,
Vindhyachal Mandal, Mirzapur as per the Government Order
dated 19.12.2000, the Committee shall proceed to decide the issue
within a period of three weeks from the date of aforementioned
nomination, after adhering to the principles of natural justice and
notice to all the parties concerned.
(iv) Respondent no.1 is directed to issue a circular to all the
Regional Level Committees, constituted under the Government
Order dated 19.12.2000, prescribing a procedure or a standard
operating procedure (SOP), indicating the procedure to be
followed by all the Regional Level Committees in the State of
Uttar Pradesh, in case any one of the Members as contemplated
under the Government Order dated 19.12.2000, is not available
and ensure strict compliance of the same, keeping in mind, the
observations and law discussed, herein above."
6. Learned counsel appearing on behalf of respondent No. 5 as well as
the learned Standing Counsel does not dispute the aforesaid proposition.
It has further been pointed out by the learned Standing Counsel that in
pursuance of the decision of this Court, a Government Order dated
17.06.2026 has also been issued, wherein a complete mechanism has
been provided to meet out the contingency in case one of the members of
the Regional Level Committee is not available. For ready reference,
Government Order dated 17.06.2026 is reproduced herein below:-
" ,
प्रेषक
संदीप परमार
,
सयुक्त सचिव
उत्तर प्रदेश शासन।
सेवा मे
(1) ( ) (2) ( )
शिक्षा निदेशक मा० शिक्षा निदेशक बेसिक

उ०प्र० लखनऊ। उ०प्र० लखनऊ।
-6 17 , 2026
माध्यमिक शिक्षा अनुभाग लखनऊः दिनाक जून

4
WRIC No. - 46804 of 2026
,
विषयः प्रबन्धकीय विवाद शिक्षकों के वरिष्ठता एवं वेतन अनुमन्यता से सम्बन्धि त समरूप प्रकरण
( )
न्यायालयी प्रकरण को छोड़कर के निस्तारण हेतु मण्डलीय संयुक्त शिक्षा निदेशक की अध्यक्षता में
गठित समिति के सम्बन्ध में।
,
महोदय
-3446/15-13-2000-
उपर्युक्त विषय के सम्बन्ध में अवगत कराना है कि शासनादेश संख्या
9(11)/94 19 , 2000 , 1921
दिनांक दिसम्बर द्वारा इण्टरमीडिएट शिक्षा अधिनियम एवं वेतन वितरण
, 1971 ,
अधिनियम द्वारा प्राप्त अधिकारों के अन्तर्गत प्रबन्धकों के हस्ताक्षर प्रमाणित करना वेतन
, ,
वितरण अधिनियम के अन्तर्गत साधिकार नियंत्रक की नियुक्ति समस्त प्रकार के प्रबन्धकीय विवाद
(
शिक्षको के वरिष्ठता सम्बन्धी विवाद एवं वेतन अनुमन्यता से सम्बन्धि त समरूप प्रकरण न्यायालयी
)
प्रकरण को छोड़कर के निस्तारण हेतु मण्डलीय संयुक्त शिक्षा निदेशक की अध्यक्षता में एक समिति
, ( )
गठित की गयी जिसमें मण्डलीय उप शिक्षा निदेशक मा० एवं सम्बन्धि त जिला विद्यालय निरीक्षक
सदस्य नामित किये गये है।
2-
यह तथ्य प्रकाश में आया है कि कई बार एक अधिकारी के पास मूल पद के अतिरिक्त अन्य
02
पद का भी प्रभार होता है और ऐसी स्थि ति में एक ही व्यक्ति द्वारा उक्त समिति के पदाधिकारियो
के रूप में हस्ताक्षर कर दिये जाते हैं। मा० उच्च न्यायालय में योजित रिट याचिका
-1656/2026 10.04.2026 0
संख्या में पारित आदेश दिनांक में मा न्यायालय द्वारा उक्त विसंगति के
निराकरण करने के निर्देश दिये गये हैं।
3- -3446/15-
अतएव इस सम्बन्ध में मुझे यह कहने का निदेश हुआ है कि शासनादेश संख्या
13-2000-9 (11)/94 19 , 2000
दिनांक दिसम्बर द्वारा गठित उक्त समिति में एक अधिकारी यदि
/
एक से अधिक पद धारित करते हैं तो ऐसी स्थि ति में समिति के अध्यक्ष सदस्य के रूप में वह मूल
,
पद के अनुसार ही हस्ताक्षर करेंगे प्रभारी पद के सापेक्ष हस्ताक्षर नहीं करेंगे। प्रभारी पद के सापेक्ष
लिंक मण्डल के समकक्ष अधिकारी द्वारा हस्ताक्षर किये जायेगे। समरूपता के दृष्टिगत निम्नांकित
:-
विवरणानुसार लिंक मण्डल रहेंगे
क्र० मूल मण्डल लिंक मण्डल
1
मेरठ सहारनपुर
2
सहारनपुर मेरठ
3
आगरा अलीगढ
4
अलीगढ आगरा
5
कानपुर लखनऊ
6
लखनऊ कानपुर
7
बरेली मुरादाबाद
8
मुरादाबाद बरेली
9
वाराणसी आजमगढ
10
आजमगढ़ वाराणसी
11
अयोध्या देवीपाटन
12
देवीपाटन अयोध्या
13
झांसी चित्रकूट
14
चित्रकूट झांसी
15
गोरखपुर बस्ती

5
WRIC No. - 46804 of 2026
16
बस्ती गोरखपुर
17
प्रयागराज मीरजापुर
18
मीरजापुर प्रयागराज
यदि लिंक मण्डल में भी अधिकारी उपलब्ध न हो अथवा मण्डलीय समिति पूर्ण न हो रही हो
तो सम्बन्धि त मण्डल के मण्डलीय संयुक्त शिक्षा निदेशक किसी अन्य मण्डल के समकक्षीय
( )
अधिकारी को नामित किए जाने हेतु शिक्षा निदेशक माध्यमिक से अनुरोध करेंगे और शिक्षा
( ), , /
निदेशक माध्यमिक जिसे वह उचित समझे सदस्य पदाधिकारी नामित करेंगे। किसी भी स्थि ति में
/
एक अधिकारी द्वारा समिति के अध्यक्ष सदस्य के रूप में दो पदों के सापेक्ष हस्ताक्षर नहीं किये
जायेगे।
,
भवदीय
( )
सदीप परमार
"
संयुक्त सचिव।
5. In view of the aforesaid, the admitted factual position is that the order
dated 18.03.2026, whereby Shri Jubaid Ahmad was recognised as the
Manager, has already been set aside by this Court vide order dated
09.04.2026, and the same has attained finality. On the other hand, the
order dated 10.07.2025, whereby the then Deputy Manager was elected
as the Manager of the institution, has also attained finality, since the writ
petition challenging the order dated 10.07.2025 was withdrawn. As such,
subject to the decision of the Regional Level Committee, as required by
the order of this Court dated 09.04.2026 passed in Writ-C No. 13149 of
2026, Shri Aiyaz Ahmad shall continue as the Manager of the
Committee of Management.
6. Since no fruitful purpose would be served by keeping the present
petition pending, with the consent of the parties, the present writ petition
is decided at the admission stage itself.
7. In view of the fact that learned counsel for respondent No. 5 and the
learned Standing Counsel do not dispute the settled legal proposition that
a member of the Regional Level Committee constituted under the
Government Order dated 19.12.2000, as amended from time to time,
cannot participate in a dual capacity, the impugned order dated
27.10.2026 is liable to be vitiated on the said ground alone. Needless to

6
WRIC No. - 46804 of 2026
state that the Government Order dated 17.06.2026, as referred to
hereinabove, also provides a mechanism to deal with the contingency
where one of the members of the Regional Level Committee is
unavailable.
8. In view of the above, the order dated 27.10.2026 is hereby set aside,
with a direction to the Regional Level Committee to decide afresh the
dispute referred to it vide order dated 19.04.2026 passed in Writ-C No.
13149 of 2026. In case one of the members of the Regional Level
Committee, namely, the Deputy Director of Education (Madhyamik),
Prayagraj Mandal, Prayagraj, is unavailable for whatsoever reason,
recourse shall be taken to the Government Order dated 17.06.2026, and a
fresh decision shall be taken as directed hereinabove, expeditiously,
preferably within a period of two months from the date of service of the
certified copy of this order.
9. It is made clear that this Court has not made any observations with
regard to the merits of the determination to be made by the Regional
Level Committee.
10. Accordingly, the petition is allowed. 
(Siddharth Nandan,J.)
November 19, 2026
piyush
Digitally signed by :-
PIYUSH KUMAR
High Court of Judicature at Allahabad