Palaniyachi vs The Director General of Police

Court
Madras High Court

WP(MD) No. 6479 of 2024
BEFORE THE MADURAI BENCH OF MADRAS HIGH COURT
DATED: 13.11.2026
CORAM
THE HON'BLE MRS. JUSTICE K. GOVINDARAJAN THILAKAVADI
WP(MD) No. 6479 of 2024
CNR:{HCMD010299852024}
AND
WMP(MD) Nos. 6061 and 6063 of 2024
Palaniyachi ..Petitioner
Vs
1. The Director General of Police,
Chennai 600 005.
2. The Superintendent of Police,
Office of the Superintendent of Police,
Tirunelveli District,
Tirunelveli.
3. The Inspector of Police,
Veeravanallur Police Station,
Veeravanallur,
Tirunelveli District.
4. The Inspector of Police,
CBCID, Tirunelveli District,
Tirunelveli. ..Respondents
PRAYER: Writ Petition is filed under Article 226 of the Constitution of
rd
India, to issue a Writ of Mandamus 3 respondent to hand over the
investigation of the case in Crime No.100 of 2024 registered for offence
th
under Section 176 (1A) (i) of Cr.P.C., to the 4 respondent
herein/Inspector of Police, CBCID, Tirunelveli for further investigation
__________
Page  1  of  15
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 05:35:38 pm )

WP(MD) No. 6479 of 2024
and to file a report in accordance with law within the time stipulated by
this Court and pass such other orders as this Court may deem fit.
For Petitioner : M/s.V.Maharajan
For Respondents : M/s.K.Suyambulinga Bharathi
Additional Public Prosecutor

ORDER
The present Writ Petition has been filed seeking issuance of a Writ
rd
of Mandamus directing the 3 respondent to transfer the investigation in
Crime No.100 of 2024, registered under Section 176(1A)(i) of the Code
of Criminal Procedure, 1973, relating to the death of the petitioner's son
th
Pechidurai, to the 4 respondent, namely the Inspector of Police, CBCID,
Tirunelveli, for further investigation and to file a final report within the
time stipulated by this Court.
2. The petitioner has also filed WMP(MD) No.6061 of 2024
seeking directions to preserve the CCTV footages relating to
Veeravanallur Police Station, Mukkudal Government Hospital,
Tirunelveli Medical College Hospital and Palayamkottai mortuary for the
period from 07.03.2024 to 11.03.2024 besides preserving the clothes
worn by the deceased, the weapons allegedly used by the police
personnel and other relevant material objects. The petitioner has further
__________
Page  2  of  15
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 05:35:38 pm )

WP(MD) No. 6479 of 2024
sought copies of the post-mortem report, post-mortem videography,
inquest report, medical records and CCTV footage in WMP(MD)
No.6063 of 2024.
3. The case of the petitioner is that her son was apprehended by the
police on 07.03.2024 and was allegedly subjected to brutal physical
assault and fire arm injury while in police custody. He was initially taken
to Mukkudal Government Hospital and thereafter shifted to Tirunelveli
Medical College Hospital for further treatment, where he succumbed to
the injuries on 11.03.2024.
4. According to the petitioner, the death of her son was not a
natural death but was the consequence of excessive and unlawful police
action. It is her specific allegation that several persons witnessed the
assault and some of them had also recorded the incident through their
mobile phones. The petitioner therefore contends that the investigation
conducted by the local police cannot be considered independent and
impartial and seeks transfer of the same to CBCID.
rd
5. The 3 respondent has filed a detailed status report opposing the
prayer for transfer of investigation. The respondents have stated that the
__________
Page  3  of  15
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 05:35:38 pm )

WP(MD) No. 6479 of 2024
occurrence dated 07.03.2024 involved several serious incidents, including
the alleged murder of one Karuppasamy Pandian, and attempt to murder
another person, criminal intimidation and damage to public property. It is
submitted that Veeravanallur Police Station registered Crime No.93 of
2024 on 07.03.2024 in connection with the alleged murder and other
offences. The final report was filed on 22.05.2024 for offences under
Sections 294(b), 302, 307, 506(ii), 427 and 34 IPC and Section 3 of the
Tamil Nadu Public Property (Prevention of Damage and Loss) Act, 1992.
The case is stated to be pending in S.C. No.298 of 2024 before the
learned IV Additional District and Sessions Court, Tirunelveli.
6. The status report further refers to Crime No.94 of 2024,
registered in connection with the alleged attack on police personnel, and
Crime No.95 of 2024, relating to the alleged damage to a government
bus. The final report in Crime No.95 of 2024 is stated to have been filed
and the case is pending in S.C. No.145 of 2025 before the competent
Court. The respondents have further stated that, according to the police
version, Head Constable Senthilkumar sustained an injury to his right
index finger when he was allegedly attacked with an aruval during the
attempt to apprehend the deceased and his associates. The records also
refer to the alleged attempts to attack the Sub Inspector and Inspector of
Police.
__________
Page  4  of  15
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 05:35:38 pm )

WP(MD) No. 6479 of 2024
7. With regards to the actual firing, the respondents have stated that
the deceased was traced while allegedly hiding in a banana plantation at
Sriparparanallur Village. When the police attempted to apprehend him, he
allegedly attempted to attack the Sub Inspector with an aruval despite
being directed to surrender. According to the police version, the Inspector
of Police fired two rounds aimed below the right knee of the deceased in
order to prevent an attack and apprehended him.
8. The respondents have specifically stated that the deceased was
immediately taken to Mukkudal Primary Health Centre and thereafter
referred to Tirunelveli Government Medical College Hospital. During the
course of treatment, his right leg was surgically amputated above the
knee. He ultimately died on 11.03.2024 at approximately 2.45 a.m. The
medical opinion referred to in the inquiry records attributes the death to
complications arising from the gun shot injury, including severe blood
loss.
9. The respondents have further stated that, after the death of the
deceased, Crime No.100 of 2024 was registered on 11.03.2024 under
Section 176(1A)(i) Cr.P.C. The Superintendent of Police, Tirunelveli
__________
Page  5  of  15
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 05:35:38 pm )

WP(MD) No. 6479 of 2024
District, by proceedings dated 11.03.2024, nominated the Deputy
Superintendent of Police, District Crime Records Bureau, Tirunelveli, as
the investigating officer. It is further submitted that the learned District
Munsif cum Judicial Magistrate, Cheranmahadevi, conducted a statutory
magisterial inquiry in Crl. M.P. No.1576 of 2024 and submitted a report
dated 15.07.2024. The inquiry is stated to have considered the statements
of police personnels, relatives of the deceased, medical personnel and
other witnesses. The inquiry materials also included CCTV footage from
Veeravanallur and Mukkudal Police Stations, general diary entries,
treatment records, X-rays, post-mortem materials, inquest photographs,
videographs and forensic ballistic materials.
10. The respondents would further submit that the learned Judicial
Magistrate, after considering the materials, recorded an opinion that the
firing was resorted to in the exercise of private defence and for the
purpose of apprehending the deceased, that the force used was reasonable
and that there was no police excess. It is further stated that the Deputy
Superintendent of Police, District Crime Records Bureau, Tirunelveli,
filed a final report classifying Crime No.100 of 2024 as a case in which
further action was dropped. The learned Judicial Magistrate by order
dated 09.12.2024 in R.C.S. No.842 of 2024, accepted the final report and
__________
Page  6  of  15
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 05:35:38 pm )

WP(MD) No. 6479 of 2024
closed the proceedings. The respondents also state that notice was issued
to the father of the deceased, who appeared before the Court on
03.12.2024 and submitted a letter expressing no objection to the
acceptance of the final report.
11. The respondents therefore contend that a statutory magisterial
inquiry was conducted, an investigating officer was independently
nominated by the Superintendent of Police, relevant materials were
collected and examined, and the final report was accepted by the
competent Judicial Magistrate. According to the respondents, there is no
specific material establishing bias, malafides, deliberate suppression of
evidence or any illegality warranting transfer of the investigation to
CBCID.
12. Heard the learned counsel appearing for the petitioner and the
learned Additional Public Prosecutor appearing for the respondents.
Perused the affidavit, the status report and the materials placed before this
Court.
13. The question arises for consideration is whether, in the facts
and circumstances of the present case, the petitioner has established
__________
Page  7  of  15
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 05:35:38 pm )

WP(MD) No. 6479 of 2024
exceptional circumstances warranting transfer of the investigation in
Crime No.100 of 2024 to CBCID. There can be no dispute with regard to
the legal position that every death occurring during police action or
following an alleged police encounter requires an independent, fair and
effective investigation. The police version cannot be accepted as the final
word merely because the police personnel claim that the firing was
resorted to in self defence. The Hon'ble Supreme Court has laid down
safeguards to be followed in cases of deaths resulting from police
encounters. The investigation must be independent, impartial and
transparent. (Ref.: People's Union for Civil Liberties vs. State of
Maharashtra, (2014) 10 SCC 635).
14. The involvement of police personnel in the incident requires
careful scrutiny, and the investigation must examine the circumstances in
which force was used, the nature of the injuries sustained, the medical
evidence and the available independent eye witnesses accounts. At the
same time, the transfer of investigation to an independent agency is not to
be ordered as a matter of routine. Such a direction is warranted in
exceptional circumstances where the facts demonstrate that the
investigation has not been conducted fairly or where transfer is necessary
to instil confidence in the investigation.
__________
Page  8  of  15
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 05:35:38 pm )

WP(MD) No. 6479 of 2024
15. In the present case, it is not disputed that the deceased sustained
a fire arm injury on 07.03.2024 and subsequently died on 11.03.2024.
The fact that the death followed the gun shot injury is also reflected in the
medical and inquiry materials referred to in the status report. However,
the mere fact that the death occurred following police firing would not,
by itself, establish that the investigation conducted by the police was
biased or that the police personnel had committed an offence. Equally,
the police version that the firing was resorted to in self defence cannot be
accepted without proper scrutiny of the materials collected during the
investigation.
16. This Court finds that the respondents have placed before this
Court materials indicating that the matter was not left entirely to the local
police station. The Superintendent of Police had nominated the Deputy
Superintendent of Police, District Crime Records Bureau, Tirunelveli, to
conduct the investigation. A statutory magisterial inquiry was also
conducted by the competent Judicial Magistrate, who examined the
relevant witnesses and considered the medical, electronic, forensic and
other documentary materials. The magisterial inquiry report dated
15.07.2024 is stated to have considered CCTV footage, general diary
__________
Page  9  of  15
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 05:35:38 pm )

WP(MD) No. 6479 of 2024
entries, medical records, post-mortem materials, ballistic evidence and
the statements of witnesses, including the statement of one Chandru dated
18.03.2024. The conclusion recorded in the inquiry report is that the
firing was resorted to in the exercise of private defence and that there was
no police excess.
17. This Court is conscious of the fact that the conclusion recorded
in the magisterial inquiry cannot, by itself, be treated as a conclusive
determination of criminal liability or as an absolute bar against further
investigation if any fresh or material evidence subsequently emerges.
Nevertheless, the fact that a detailed judicial inquiry was conducted and
that the materials were considered by the competent Judicial Magistrate is
a relevant circumstance while examining the petitioner's request for
transfer of investigation.
18. Another relevant circumstance is that the final report in Crime
No.100 of 2024 was placed before the competent Judicial Magistrate and
was accepted by order dated 09.12.2024 in R.C.S. No.842 of 2024. The
father of the deceased was also stated to have appeared before the Court
and expressed no objection to the acceptance of the final report.
However, this Court makes it clear that the statement of no objection
__________
Page  10  of  15
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 05:35:38 pm )

WP(MD) No. 6479 of 2024
given by the father of the deceased cannot, by itself, operate as a waiver
of the independent legal remedies available to the petitioner, who is the
mother of the deceased. The acceptance of the final report is relevant to
the present consideration, but it does not extinguish any statutory remedy
available to an aggrieved person in accordance with law.
19. The status report also refers to the criminal antecedents of the
deceased, including the existence of a history sheet and registration of
several criminal cases against him. This Court is of the considered view
that such antecedents cannot be treated as proof that the deceased was a
habitual offender who could lawfully be subjected to excessive force or
that the police firing was necessarily justified. The legality of the police
action has to be determined exclusively on the basis of the circumstances
prevailing at the time of the occurrence and the relevant evidence. At the
same time, the respondents have placed materials relating to the alleged
attack on police personnel, the injury sustained by the Head Constable,
the alleged possession and use of an aruval by the deceased, the nature of
the police response and the medical treatment provided immediately after
the incident. These materials were also stated to have been considered
during the statutory inquiry.
__________
Page  11  of  15
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 05:35:38 pm )

WP(MD) No. 6479 of 2024
20. On a careful consideration of the entire materials placed before
this Court, this Court is unable to find any specific material
demonstrating that the investigating officer deliberately suppressed
material evidence, fabricated records, failed to examine material
witnesses or conducted the investigation with an ulterior motive. No
specific circumstance has been established, at this stage, to demonstrate
that the statutory inquiry was conducted without considering the relevant
medical, electronic and forensic materials. In the absence of any specific
material demonstrating bias, malafides or a fundamental failure in the
investigation, this Court is not inclined to exercise its extraordinary
jurisdiction under Article 226 of the Constitution of India to transfer the
investigation to CBCID merely on the basis of the petitioner's
apprehension.
21. It is also relevant to point out that the final report in Crime
No.100 of 2024 has already been accepted by the competent Judicial
Magistrate. If the petitioner is aggrieved by the order dated 09.12.2024
accepting the final report, it is open to her to work out the remedies
available under the criminal procedural law, including an appropriate
challenge before the competent Court, in accordance with law. The
__________
Page  12  of  15
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 05:35:38 pm )

WP(MD) No. 6479 of 2024
petitioner cannot seek to bypass the remedies available against the
acceptance of the final report merely by seeking a direction for transfer of
investigation. If any specific document or material is required for
pursuing the appropriate legal remedy, it is open to the petitioner to make
an application before the competent authority or Court.
22. It is made clear that this Court has not adjudicated upon the
correctness of the police version, the proportionality of the force used or
the criminal liability of any police personnel. The observations made
herein are confined to examining whether the materials placed before this
Court justify the extraordinary relief of transferring the investigation to
CBCID.
23. In the light of the foregoing discussion, this Court is of the
considered view that the petitioner has not made out a case warranting
transfer of the investigation in Crime No.100 of 2024 to CBCID.
Accordingly, the prayer seeking transfer of investigation to CBCID is
rejected and the Writ Petition stands dismissed. However, liberty is
granted to the petitioner to work out her remedies against the order dated
09.12.2024 accepting the final report, in accordance with law. It is also
open to the petitioner to place any fresh or additional material, if
__________
Page  13  of  15
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 05:35:38 pm )

WP(MD) No. 6479 of 2024
available, before the competent Court and seek appropriate relief in
accordance with law. Consequently, WMP(MD) Nos.6061 and 6063 of
2024 are closed.
13.11.2026
Index: Yes/No
Speaking/Non-speaking order
Neutral Citation: Yes/No
mar/skn
To
1. The Director General of Police,
Chennai 600 005.
2. The Superintendent of Police,
Office of the Superintendent of Police,
Tirunelveli District,
Tirunelveli.
3. The Inspector of Police,
Veeravanallur Police Station,
Veeravanallur,
Tirunelveli District.
4. The Inspector of Police,
CBCID, Tirunelveli District,
Tirunelveli.
__________
Page  14  of  15
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 05:35:38 pm )

WP(MD) No. 6479 of 2024
K.GOVINDARAJAN THILAKAVADI J.
mar/skn
WP(MD) No. 6479 of 2024
AND
WMP(MD) Nos. 6061 and 6063 of 2024
13.11.2026.
__________
Page  15  of  15
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 05:35:38 pm )